Harinagar Sugar Mills Ltd. (Biscuit Division) & Anr. v. State of Maharashtra & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 801; [2025] 7 S.C.R. 427
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Sanjay Karol, Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra
- Decided
- 4 Jun 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 7372/2025
- Sections
- 25, 25N, 39, 1
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 427 : 2025 INSC 801 Harinagar Sugar Mills Ltd. (Biscuit Division) & Anr.
v.
State of Maharashtra & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 7372 of 2025)
04 June 2025 [Sanjay Karol* and Prashant Kumar Mishra, JJ.] Issue for Consideration
(i) Whether letter dated 25.09.2019 sent by the Deputy Secretary of State Government can be construed to be an order - Connectedly, whether the appellants would be entitled to the relief of deemed closure, as on 27.10.2019 by virtue of the deeming fiction present in s. 25-O(3) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947; (ii) What would be the meaning of the phrase ‘appropriate Government’ and whether in the facts of this case, it was the appropriate Government acting in the matter of the closure - if not what is the effect in law, thereof. Headnotes† Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 – s.25-O(1), 25-O(3) – Industrial Dispute (Maharashtra) Rules, 1957 – r.82-B(1) – Appellant-HSML was engaged in biscuit manufacturing exclusively for BIL under Job Work Agreements (JWA) – JWA was terminated by BIL – Resultantly, applications for closure of business were made to the competent authorities on 26.08.2019 – By a letter dated 25.09.2019 sent by Dy. Secretary, State Government informed HSML that they failed to disclose their efforts to prevent closure, nor had they given cogent reasons for closure and were, therefore, asked to resubmit their application – By way of reply dated 10.10.2019, HSML furnished the particulars as asked for – It is to be noted that the 60-day period provided for u/s. 25-O(3) of the Act ran out on 27.10.2019 – On 04.11.2019, HSML was once again asked to resubmit their application as authorities found response of HSML lacking – HSML in their response contended that by virtue of s.25-O(3), the permission of closure is deemed to have been granted – The Deputy Commissioner sent to HSML two letters, dated 20.11.2019 and 22.11.2019 asking them to be present for a meeting on 26.11.2019, and conveying to them that the State Government was yet to grant permission for closure – Letters * Author 428 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports dated 04.11.2019, 20.11.2019 and 22.11.2019 were challenged before High Court – High Court, by the impugned judgment, dismissed the writ petitions – Correctness:
Held: There is nothing on record to show that the Dy. Secretary was duly authorised to conduct communication and/or accept or reject applications for closure made by industrial units – The concerned authority in that regard is only the Minister – There is no express authority resting with the Deputy Secretary – Reliance cannot be placed on internal noting to establish compliance with procedure – s.25-O specifically provides “by order and for reasons to be recorded in writing,” and so, reasons are a statutory necessity – When the minister is the sole authority, endorsement of a view taken by an undisclosed officer of the Ministry cannot be said to be an ‘application of mind’ by the competent authority – The decision had to be top down and not otherwise – The necessary conclusion is that the letter dated 25.09.2019 addressed by the Deputy Secretary to HSML cannot be constituted to be an order since such order to resubmit the application was without any authority since it was not the appropriate Government acting in that regard and not an order rejecting or accepting the application – The appropriate Government failed to make and communicate any order on the application for closure – The deemed closure would, therefore, come into effect – In that view of the matter, application dated 28.08.2019 was complete in all respects, and the 60-day period for the deemed closure to take effect would be calculable from said date – Also, the Deputy Secretary was not the appropriate Government who could have asked HSML to revise and resubmit the application for closure – That authority is only vested with the Minister concerned. [Paras 15, 16, 17, 18, 22] Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 – s.25-O – Scope of:
Held: i) The right to close the business is subject to the interest of the general public; ii) any application seeking permission for closure must disclose adequate and genuine reasons which the authority has to have regard for; iii) in certain cases, however, even if the reasons are genuine and adequate, it does not mean that permission to close ought to be granted; iv) if it is found that the reasons are generally adequate, and despite that the appropriate Government decides for refusal of permission of foreclosure, then the interest of the general public involved in that particular case must be “compelling” and “overriding”; v) financial difficulty on its own cannot constitute the reason for shutting down the business – [2025] 7 S.C.R. 429Harinagar Sugar Mills Ltd. (Biscuit Division) & Anr. v. State of Maharashtra & Ors.
An employer must demonstrate exceptional circumstances or an impossibility of running the business. [Para 13] Constitution of India – Art.19(1)(g) – Freedom of trade, profession, occupation and business – Right to shut down business – Elucidated:
Held: If there exists the freedom to set up and run a trade/business as one sees fit, necessarily, there has to be a set of rights vesting with the proprietor/owner to take decisions as may be in his best interest – At the same time, law does not permit such owner or proprietor to take any and all decisions without having considered and accounted for the impact that it shall have on the employees or workers that are part of this establishment – This is evidenced by the s. 25-O of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 providing for a detailed procedure to be followed when a person wishes to ‘shut shop’, but concomitant providing that if the concerned Government does not take action with reasonable expediency, the business owner should not be saddled with the costs and responsibilities of running the business indefinitely, till such time the authority arrives at a proper and just decision – The sum and substance are that Art. 19(1)(g) includes the right to shut down a business but is, of course, subject to reasonable restrictions. [Para 10] Case Law Cited Cooverjee B. Bharucha v. Excise Commr. [1954] SCR 873 : (1954) 1 SCC 18; Hindustan Antibiotics Ltd. v. Workmen [1967] 1 SCR 652 : 1966 SCC OnLine SC 106; Excel Wear v. Union of India [1979] 1 SCR 1009 : (1978) 4 SCC 224; Orissa Textile and Steel v. State of Orissa [2002] 1 SCR 309 : (2002) 2 SCC 578 – followed.
Ajaib Singh v. Sirhind Coop. Marketing-cum-Processing Service Society Ltd. [1999] 2 SCR 505 : (1999) 6 SCC 82; Star Enterprises v. City and Industrial Development Corpn. of Maharashtra Ltd. [1990] 2 SCR 826 : (1990) 3 SCC 280 – relied on.
Bachhittar Singh v. State of Punjab [1962] Supp. 3 SCR 713 : AIR 1963 SC 395; Sethi Auto Services Station v. DDA [2008] 14 SCR 598 : (2009) 1 SCC 180; Shanti Sports Club v. Union of India [2009] 13 SCR 710 : (2009) 15 SCC 705; State of Haryana v. Hitkari Potteries (2001) 10 SCC 74; Sree Meenakshi Textile Mills Ltd. v. Madurai Textile Workers Union (CITU) & Ors., 1979 (38) FLR 213; Pimpri Chinchwad New Township Development Authority v. 430 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Vishnudev Coop. Housing Society [2018] 11 SCR 310 : (2018) 8 SCC 215; Mahabir Jute Mills Ltd. v. Shibban Lal Saxena [1976] 1 SCR 168 : (1975) 2 SCC 818 – referred to.
List of Acts Constitution of India; Industrial Dispute (Maharashtra) Rules, 1957; Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.
List of Keywords Closure of business; Closing down an undertaking; Permission of closure; Closure application; Job work agreement; Efforts to prevent closure; Not given cogent reasons for closure; Functus officio; Workers’ unions; Form XXIV-C prescribed u/r.82-B(1) of the Industrial Dispute (Maharashtra) Rules, 1957; Form XXIV-B prescribed u/r.82-B(1) of the Industrial Dispute (Maharashtra) Rules, 1957; Relief of deemed closure; Deeming fiction in s.25-O(3) of Industrial Disputes Act, 1947; Freedom of trade, profession, occupation and business; Appropriate government; Right to shut down a business; Minister of Labour; Internal noting; Non-application of mind; Minister is the sole authority; Top Down decision; Order without authority; Communication without legal sanction; Sub-delegation to officer.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 7372 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 17.02.2023 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in WP No. 3447 of 2019 With Civil Appeal No. 7373 of 2025 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Mukul Rohatgi, Sr. Adv., Ms. Nina Nariman, Abhay Jadeja, Praveen Kumar, Arun Unikrishnan, Ms. Pragya Baghel, Ms. Sunaina Kumar. Advs. for the Respondents:
Shailesh S. Pathak, Nitin S. Tambwekar, Seshatalpa Sai Bandaru, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Shrirang B. Varma, Sourav Singh, Jitendra Kumar Tripathi, Aditya Mishra, Ratish Kumar Sharma.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 431Harinagar Sugar Mills Ltd. (Biscuit Division) & Anr. v. State of Maharashtra & Ors.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Sanjay Karol, J.
This judgment, for clarity and ease of reference, is divided as follows: TABLE OF CONTENTS* THE APPEALS ........................................................................... 2
BACKGROUND TO THE WRIT PETITIONS .............................. 3
THE IMPUGNED JUDGMENT ................................................... 13 SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES ............................................. 17 A. Appellants ......................................................................... 17 B. Respondents .................................................................... 21 QUESTIONS TO BE CONSIDERED ......................................... 23 ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION .................................................. 24 CONCLUSION ............................................................................ 42 Leave Granted.
THE APPEALS
2. These appeals by special leave, question the correctness of a judgment and order passed by the High Court of Judicature at Bombay, dated 17 th February 2023 1 , in Writ Petition No.3447 of 2019 and Writ Petition No.3397 of 2019, preferred by the appellants herein in Civil Appeal arising out of SLP(C)No.4268 of 2019 and by the appellant in Civil Appeal arising out of SLP(C)No.4565 of 2023, respectively. 1 Hereinafter ‘impugned judgment’ * Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
432 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
BACKGROUND TO THE WRIT PETITIONS
3. The factual backdrop in which the writ petitions came to be filed is indisputably identical. As such we refer to the facts of the first appeal, which are as below :
3.1 Harinagar Sugar Mills Limited (Biscuit Division) 2 is a company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956 and was engaged in biscuit manufacturing for Britannia Industries Limited 3 . 3.2 Such manufacturing by HSML had been exclusively for BIL, and had been ongoing for more than three decades, under Job Work Agreements 4 , granted by the latter to the former and extended from time to time.
3.3 JWA was terminated by BIL with effect from 20 th November 2019, vide letter dated 24 th May 2019, stating that the 180-day notice period, as mandated by clause 20.3.1 of the JWA signed on 22 nd May 2007, would begin from 1 st June 2019. The letter is extracted as under :- “ANNEXURE P/1
BRITANNIA INDUSTRIES LIMITED
Prestige Shantiniketan, White Field Main Road Mahadevpura Post, Bengaluru-560048 Without prejudice By Speed Post/Courier/Email Date: 24th May 2019 To, M/s Harinagar Sugar Mills Limited 207, Kalbaddevi Road, Mumbai-400002, Maharashtra, India CC: World Trade Centre, Centre-1, 10 th Floor, Caffe Parade, Mumbai-400 005 2 Abbreviated as ‘HSML’ 3 Abbreviated as ‘BIL’ 4 Abbreviated as ‘JWA’ [2025] 7 S.C.R. 433Harinagar Sugar Mills Ltd. (Biscuit Division) & Anr. v. State of Maharashtra & Ors.
Kind Attention : Mr. Ashok Kumar Jasrpuria Sub : Termination of the job work Agreement Ref: a. Job work Agreement dated 22 nd May, 2007.
b. Job Work Agreement Renewal dated 23rd Oct, 2013 (effective from 18 th Feb 2013 till 17 th Feb 2023)
Dear Sir, We refer to job work agreement dated 22 nd May, 2007 entered for period of 10 years effective from 21 st February, 2003 and renewed on same terms and conditions for another period of 10 years effective from 18 th February, 2013 whereby based on your representations, we have appointed you as our Contract Manufacturer on the terms and conditions contained therein.
Pursuant to clause 20.3.1 of the Job Work Agreement, we hereby serve you One Hundred Eight (180) days written notice commencing from 1 st June 2019 (“Effective date”). The business relationship between the parties under the Agreement shall stand terminated on the close of business hours of 27 th November, 2019.
You are requested to discontinue the operations under the agreement accordingly upon termination and cease to the know-how-return, all copies of the Know-how without retaining any part thereof, and deliver entre quantity of goods manufactured, ingredients, packing material and Raw Material etc. which are in your possession or custody as per the terms of the agreement.
Further, you are requested to return all the documents containing information relating to products and Intellectual Property Rights of the Company and refrain from sharing, exchanging or selling or making any copies, summaries or transcripts of confidential information of the Company. Sd/- Britannia Industries Ltd.”
(Emphasis supplied)
434 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 3.4 Resultantly, applications for closure of business were made to the competent authorities on 26 th August 2019, as per Form XXIV-C prescribed under Rule 82-B(1) of the Industrial Dispute (Maharashtra) Rules, 1957 read with Section 25-O(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 5 . The workers of HSML were informed vide closure notices dated 28 th August 2019. The letter is extracted below:
“HARINAGAR SUGAR MILLS LIMITED
(BISCUIT DIVISION)
Conductors of the Factory & Business of Shangrilla Food Products Limited Regd. Office : 207 Katbadevi Road, Mumbai-400002 Pl. Correspondence to:
L.B.S. Marg. Bhandup (W), Mumbai-400078.
Ref No.
Dated : 28.08.2019 From-XXIV-C (To be submitted in triplicate)
[See Rule 82-B(1)] From of application for permission of closure to be made by an employer under sub-Section (1) of Section 25-O of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (14 of 1947)
To, The Secretary to the Government of Maharashtra Industries, Energy and Labour Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai-32.
Sir, Under Section 25-O of the Industrial disputes Act, 1947 (14 of 1947), I hereby inform you that I propose to close down the undertaking specified below.
5 Hereinafter, ‘the Act’ [2025] 7 S.C.R. 435Harinagar Sugar Mills Ltd. (Biscuit Division) & Anr. v. State of Maharashtra & Ors.
M/s Harinagar Sugar Mills Ltd. (Biscuit Division), (herein after referred to as Biscuit Division), L.B.S. Marg, Bhandup (W), Mumbai-400078 w.e.f. 28/11/2019.
The Biscuit Division had entered into, a job, work agreement with M/s Britannia Industries Ltd. (BIL) to manufacture biscuits of Britannia brand. BIL used to forward to the Biscuit Division its weekly plan as per the market demand of various varieties of Britannia Brand. The Biscuit Division then used to manufacture the biscuits as per the plan forwarded by BIL in the factory premises A written termination notice was received by the Biscuit Division on 31-05-2019 from BIL stating that the business relationship between the parties shall stand terminated on the close of business hours, of 27/11/2019. Thus BIL has terminated the job work agreement with the Biscuit Division and the said Division has no other manufacturing avenue, since the said Division was manufacturing biscuits only for BIL. In view of the above, the Biscuit Division has no other alternative but to close down, the manufacturing activities.
2. The number of workmen whose service will be terminated on account of the closure of the undertaking is 178 permanent workmen.
3. Permission is solicited for the proposed closure.
4. I hereby declared that in the event of approval for the closure being granted every workmen in the undertaking to whom sub-section (9) of the said section 25-O applies will be given notice and paid compensation as specified in section 25N of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (14 of 1947), as if the workman had been retrenched under that section.
Yours faithfully For Harinagar Sugar Mills Ltd. (Biscuit Division)
Sd/- Illegible (Authorised Signatory)
436 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports CC: 1) The Commissioner of Labour, Maharashtra, Mumbai 2) The Industries Commissioner, Maharashtra, Mumbai 3) The Joint Director of Industries, Mumbai”
(Emphasis supplied)
3.5 Letter dated 25 th September 2019 sent by the Deputy Secretary, Government of Maharashtra, informed HSML that they failed to disclose their efforts to prevent closure, nor had they given cogent reasons for closure. They were, therefore, asked to resubmit their application. This letter forms an important aspect of the respondents’ case before the High Court and, therefore, it would be appropriate for it to be extracted. It reads :
“ANNEXURE P/5 Government of Maharashtra No. Closure-82019/C.No.3/L-2 Industry, Energy & Labour Dept.
Madam Cama Road Hutama Rajguru Chowk Mantralaya, Mumbai-400032 Dated : 25 TH September, 2019 To, Authorised Signatory, M/s. Hari Nagar Sugar Mills Limited, L.B.S. Marg, Bhandup (W)
Mumbai-400 078.
Subject:- Application for obtaining permission U/s. 25(O)(1) for closing down establishment of M/s Hari Nagar Sugar Mills Ltd. at L.B.S.
Marg, Bhandup (W), Mumbai-78 Reference: Your application dated 28/8.2019.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 437Harinagar Sugar Mills Ltd. (Biscuit Division) & Anr. v. State of Maharashtra & Ors.
Sir, With reference to the above referred application, you as authorised signatory of M/s. Hari Nagar Sugar Mills Ltd. have submitted an application to the Government on 28/8/2019 u/s 25(O)(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 for closing down the unit at L.B.S. Marg, Bhandup (W) Mumbai-78.
2. On reviewing the said application it is observed that the job contract agreement signed by M/s. Hari Nagar Sugar Mills Ltd. with M/s. Britania Industries Ltd. for production of biscuits will be cancelled with effect from 27.11.2019 and therefore the management of the Company has given the reason that the said Biscuit Division will not be able to provide any work in the said Division, and therefore the application to obtain permission to close down said Biscuit Division was submitted to the Government on 28.08.2019.
3. However, no pros and cons about the efforts for not closing down the said Unit were discussed/ enlisted in the said application. Also, any justifiable and consummate reasons were also not provided for closing down the said Division. Therefore, it will be possible to take action only if you can submit the application again by providing explanation regarding other efforts initiated by you for not closing down the Division, providing justifiable as well as consummate rationale for this action.
Yours faithfully, Signed Dy. Secretary, Govt. of Maharashtra Copy :
1. Hon. Labour Commission, Kamgar Bhavan, C-20, E-Block, Bandra-Kurla Complex, Bandra (E), Mumbai-400 051.
2. Private Secretary to Hon. Minister (Labour)”
(Emphasis supplied)
438 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 3.6 By way of reply dated 10 th October 2019, HSML furnished the particulars as asked for. It is to be noted here that the 60-day period provided for under Section 25-O(3) of the Act ran out on 27 th October 2019. The said letter reads as under :
“Annexure P/6
HARINAGAR SUAR MILLS LIMITED
(BISCUIT DIVISION)
Conductors of the Factory & Business of Shangrilla Food Products Limited Regd. Office : 207 Katbadevi Road, Mumbai-400002 Pl. Correspondence to :
L.B.S. Marg. Bhandup (W), Mumbai-400 078.
Ref. No.76/19-20 Date: 10.10.2019 To Shri S.M. Sathe, The Dy. Secretary, State of Maharashtra Mantralaya Mumbai Sub: Permission sought under Section 25-(O)(I) of Ld. Act for closure of M/s. Harinagar Sugar Mills Ltd.
(Biscuit Division)
Ref: Your letter dated 25.09.2019.
On 01.10.2019 we have received your letter dated 25.09.2019 with regard to the aforesaid subject.
It is a fact that for last 32 years, the Company used to do job work of manufacturing biscuits only for Britannia Industries Ltd. For manufacturing biscuits for Britannia Industries Ltd., the raw material as well as necessary plant and machinery used to be provided and installed by Britannia Industries Ltd. After receiving termination of Job work agreement from BIL, the Company Immediately persuaded the management of BIL to continue agreement and the job work with the Company. However, said persuasion did not work or yield [2025] 7 S.C.R. 439Harinagar Sugar Mills Ltd. (Biscuit Division) & Anr. v. State of Maharashtra & Ors.
any result. The Company had then approached other biscuit manufacturers such as M/s. Mondelez India Limited and Us. ITC Ltd. On 15.07.2019, the top management of the Company had meeting with Mr. T. Arunkumar, CMO, Manager of M/s. Mondelez India Limited and then as per his requirement had forwarded e-mail on 24.07.2109.
However, thereafter there was no response. Similarly the top management of the Company had discussed with Mr. Divi of M/s. ITC, Foods. However, on 17.07.2019 Mr. Div replied that there is no requirement of contract manufacturing unit to them at present. Once again on 24.07.2019 mail was forwarded to Mr. Divi of M/s. ITC Foods but there was no response to the said mail. We enclose copies of e-mails forwarded to M/s. Mondelez India Ltd. and Ms. ITC Foods The management of the Company had also talked and discussed with Mr. Ajay Chauhan of Parle Biscuits to provide job work to the Company. However, there was no positive response even from Parle Biscuits.
The reason for closing down the manufacturing activities is there is no job work which can be done in the said factory. As stated in the closure application the company for last 32 years was doing only the job work for Britannia Industries Ltd. And the efforts mentioned hereinabove will support the contention of the company that there is no other way out but to close its manufacturing operation.
For Harinagar Sugar Mills Ltd.
(Biscuit Division)
Sd/- Authorised Signatory)”
(Emphasis supplied)
3.7 The authorities once again found the response lacking. Vide letter dated 4 th November 2019 said that their earlier response did not, once again, cover all aspects, i.e., the possibility of the employees’ absorption into other manufacturing divisions and also the possibility of HSML moving to the production of other goods, apart from biscuits. They were once again asked to resubmit their application.
440 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 3.8 On 22 nd November 2019 HSML, in their response, contented that by virtue of Section 25-O(3) of the Act, the permission of closure is deemed to have been granted, and the authorities have now become functus officio. The workers’ unions also opposed the closure, registering the same vide letter dated 4 th November 2019. They cited ‘ulterior motives’ and lack of bona fide reasons.
3.9 The Deputy Commissioner, Labour, sent to HSML two letters, dated 20th and 22nd of November 2019 asking them to be present for a meeting on 26 th November 2019, and conveying to them that the State Government was yet to grant permission for closure and as such, they should not close down the business on 27 th November 2019, respectively.
3.10 Workers’ unions on the same day as their letter also approached the Industrial Tribunal seeking to restrain HSML from going forward with the closure. An ad-interim order came to be passed by the Tribunal, granting said relief.
3.11 These letters dated 4 th November 2019, 20 th November 2019 and 22 nd November 2019 were the subject matter of challenge before the High Court.
THE IMPUGNED JUDGMENT
4. The proceedings before the High Court, the culmination of which was the judgment impugned in these appeals, were as follows: - 4.1 Order dated 28 th November 2019 records the statement of Mr. Ravi Kadam, Senior Counsel appearing for HSML that the salaries for the month of November shall be paid without insisting that the employees attend work. It is also recorded therein that the employees shall maintain peace and harmony. 4.2 On the next date, i.e., 12th December 2019 it was directed that the salaries for December be paid on or before 6 th January 2020. 4.3 Arguments were heard and concluded on 7 th February 2023. 4.4 The findings in the impugned judgment can be summarised thus : Firstly, the Court discussed the scheme of Section 25-O of the Act and found that an application for closure has to be made to a competent [2025] 7 S.C.R. 441Harinagar Sugar Mills Ltd. (Biscuit Division) & Anr. v. State of Maharashtra & Ors.
authority at least 90 days prior to the date from which the closure is sought to be made effective; the reasons for such closure must be clearly stated; on receipt of such application, the ‘appropriate Government’ is to make an enquiry; provide an opportunity for hearing all concerned - workmen, employer and persons interested in closure, and then pass a reasoned order, also keeping in view interests of the general public. Section 25-O(3) provides that if such an appropriate authority fails to communicate an order made thereby, granting or denying permission within 90 days of the application being preferred, it shall be deemed that the permission was granted at the expiry of 60 days. Other parts of Section 25 of the Act were also taken note of such as the power of review, the remaining in force of the order of the competent authority for a period of one year etc. Secondly, it was observed that the case of the petitioners (appellants before us) was that orders had not been passed by the competent authority within the statutorily prescribed time frame, and consequently, the deeming fiction provided for in the Act would come into force and permission of closure would be deemed granted upon the expiry of 60 days from the application, since more than 90 days had passed since such making of application. The stand of the State was also taken into account - which was that the communication dated 25th September 2019 constituted an order refusing the grant of requisite permission. It would be appropriate to extract the consideration made by the High Court, of these contrasting submissions. It is as follows : “24. The first objection of Mr. Naidu is that even if communications dated 25 September 2019 were to be assumed as decisions, the decisions are not taken by the authority, viz. Hon’ble Minister for Labour but the same is taken by the Depute Secretary. To counter the contention, the State Government has placed on record the file noting on the basis of which the communications dated 25 September 2019 were issued. The file noting would indicate that note was prepared by Desk Officer on 30 August 2019 stating that as per notification dated 25 June 2013, the powers under Section 25-O (2) are conferred upon the Hon’ble Minister for Labour. It is further stated that the petitioners’ applications were required to be forwarded to the Hon’ble Minister for further action. However, there appears to be an endorsement in hand 442 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports writing towards the end of the noting to the effect that petitioners failed to furnish complete and cogent reasons in their applications. The noting was approved by various officers in the hierarchy and finally came to be approved by Hon’ble Minister with a remark accepting hand written endorsement with further direction that the establishment should be intimated to file application with cogent reasons. In accordance with the above decision of the Hon’ble Minister, the letters dated 25 September 2019 were addressed to petitioners. We therefore repel the objection of the petitioners that the decision in communication was not taken by the Hon’ble Minister.”
Thirdly, the contention of HSML that the application dated 28th August 2019 was complete in all respects and it ought to have been treated as such was considered. It was submitted that the letter dated 10th October 2019 (reproduced supra) was in response to the authorities asking them to resubmit. They supplied thereby, additional reasons for closure and the steps taken to prevent that eventuality. It was held that since the undisputed position is that vide letter dated 10th October 2019 HSML sought to furnish additional reasons, that ipso facto would amount to an acceptance that the application was not complete in all respects. That being the case, the deeming fiction would not come into play. Since the application was deficient, the State Government need not pass orders thereon. It was thereafter held as under:
“30.…The fact that authority was not convinced with the application of the petitioner and had communicated that cogent reasons are not spelt out in the application would be sufficient to conclude that the authority did not grant the application for closure. What was contemplated by letter dated 25 September 2019 was “re-submission”
of the application. Petitioners however chose to add reasons to the pending applications on 10 October 2019. Petitioners failed to submit fresh applications by providing statement of reasons as directed by State Government vide letters dated 25 September 2019. This is the reason why the State Government was once again required to convey to petitioners that they were required to resubmit the applications by subsequent communications dated 4 [2025] 7 S.C.R. 443Harinagar Sugar Mills Ltd. (Biscuit Division) & Anr. v. State of Maharashtra & Ors.
November 2019. It is only after receipt of letters dated 4 November 2019 petitioners took a stand of deemed permission under Section 25-O(3) of the ID Act in their letters dated 22 November 2019.
31. We are therefore unable to accept the contention raised on behalf of the petitioners that the closure applications filed by them on 28 August 2019 were complete in all respects so as to trigger deemed permission under provisions of Section 25 O(3) on expiration of period of 60 days. Petitioners themselves accepted the position that the closure applications were incomplete by seeking to adduce reasons for closure by letters dated 10 October 2019. It therefore cannot be held that the establishments of the petitioners are deemed to have been closed on expiration of period of 60 days from the date of submission of closure applications dated 28 August 2019.”
The Writ petitions were dismissed.
SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES
5. We have heard Mr. Mukul Rohatgi, learned Senior Counsel for the appellant - HSML as also the learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
A. Appellants i. The impugned judgment is based on an erroneous reliance on the ‘wrong form’, which originated out of a submission of learned Counsel for the State. Reliance was placed by the learned Division Bench on Form XXIV and instead, it should have considered Form XXIV-C.
ii. The finding that the applications were incomplete is based on a misunderstanding/misapplication of the forms.
iii. Noting in the internal office file cannot be used to construe what constitutes an order. Reference is made to Bachhittar Singh v. State of Punjab6 ; Sethi Auto Services Station v.
6 AIR 1963 SC 395
444 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
DDA7
; and Shanti Sports Club v. Union of India8 to submit that the internal file noting does not constitute an order. Furthermore, even such a contention that the letter dated 25th September 2019 is based on such noting is belied, for it does not say so. Instead, it only asks for details of the efforts made to avoid closure.
iv. An application for closure can only be disposed of by an order in accordance with Section 25-O(2). If it is not so done, what has been provided for in Section 25-O(3) will kick in.
v. The previous iteration of Section 25-O was struck down by this Court vide its judgment in Excel Wear v. Union of India9 on the ground that it did not prescribe a time limit for deciding the applications for closure. It was found that the restrictions were not in accordance with Article 19(6) of the Constitution of India. The amended iteration was upheld vide judgment in Orissa Textile and Steel v. State of Orissa10 , wherein it was held that the requirement to conduct an enquiry, give a hearing, pass a reasoned order, and also the time limit was the curing of defects present in the previous version of the section. It has been so submitted by the appellants to show that the 60-day requirement is mandatory. If not so observed, it would violate Article 19(1)(g).
vi. It has not been shown by the respondents, how the applications made by the appellants are defective/ incomplete. Providing of further information cannot mean that the original application was defective. The decision in State of Haryana v. Hitkari Potteries11 was relied upon to show that even when the application was belatedly rejected on the ground that it was incomplete in certain respects, this Court held the deemed permission to be granted.
7 (2009) 1 SCC 180
8 (2009) 15 SCC 705
9 (1978) 4 SCC 224
10 (2002) 2 SCC 578
11 (2001) 10 SCC 74
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 445Harinagar Sugar Mills Ltd. (Biscuit Division) & Anr. v. State of Maharashtra & Ors.
vii. The 60-day time period provided for in the Act cannot be extended, including on the pretext of resubmission of the application for closure. There were two letters issued by the State authority, one on 25 th September 2019 and the other on 4 th November 2019, with the latter one being beyond the said time period. Thereafter were two further letters dated 20 th and 22 nd November 2019 directing their presence for a meeting, both clearly beyond the time limit. Further, it is said that there is no provision for resubmission. Permitting the same would unsettle the scheme of the law.
viii. The Labour Minister is the “appropriate Government” within the meaning of the Act, hence all actions contemplated under Section 25-O could have been undertaken by him only. No further delegation thereof is provided for or permissible without notification to such effect under Section 39 of the Act. Be that as it may, it has been held in Orissa Textile and Steel (supra) that sub-delegation of quasi judicial function is impermissible. No communication has been addressed by the ‘appropriate Government’ within the time frame.
ix. The letter dated 25 th September 2019 is by no means an order. Had it been so, there was no basis for the State’s further letters. In fact, letter dated 4 th November 2019 makes reference to the application for closure dated 28 th August 2019. Said letter was also not marked to the workmen/their representatives which is a requirement under Section 25-O(2).
B. Respondents The Workers Union, namely the Maharashtra Rajya Rashtriya Kamgar Sangh (INTUC) has filed written submissions. Their stand is that the impugned judgment is justified and takes the correct interpretation of facts and law. It has been argued therein, inter alia, that : i. The first response of the State to the closure application, i.e., letter dated 25 th September 2019 is not within the sphere of challenge.
446 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports ii. The communication which took place regarding the alleged closure of HSML and Shangrila 12 total approximately 300 workers, and non-inclusion of their recognised union in such discussions is absolutely detrimental to the interests of these workers.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.