K. Subramaniam (Died) Through LRs K.S. Balakrishnan & Ors. v. M/S Krishna Mills Pvt. Ltd.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1309; [2025] 12 S.C.R. 167
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Dipankar Datta, Justice Manmohan
- Decided
- 11 Nov 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2561/2025
- Sections
- 10(2), 10, 4, 11(4), 23(2), 25, 23(4)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 167 : 2025 INSC 1309 K. Subramaniam (Died) Through LRs K.S. Balakrishnan & Ors.
v.
M/s Krishna Mills Pvt. Ltd.
(Civil Appeal No. 2561 of 2025)
11 November 2025 [Dipankar Datta* and Manmohan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose whether the High Court was right in declining to reverse the appellate order of eviction obtained by the respondent-owner against the appellants-lessee on the ground of wilful default in payment of rent.
Headnotes Tamil Nadu Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1960 – s.10(2)(i) – Eviction on the ground of wilful default – Respondent-owner leased out properties to lessee for a monthly rent of Rs. 48,000/-, however, the lessee paid Rs.33,000/- – Rent Controller fixed a fair rent which was upheld by the appellate authority however, the High Court modified the same – SLP thereagainst by lessee dismissed by this Court – Lessee persisted in paying only a fraction thereof – In an appeal against the order of Rent Controller fixing fair rent, appellate authority did not grant stay of the order of Rent Controller – Thereafter, eviction petition by the respondents on the ground of wilful default – Rent Controller dismissed the eviction petition, however appellate court passed order of eviction against the appellants-legal heirs of deceased lessee, on the ground of wilful default in payment of rent – High Court affirmed the said order – Correctness:
Held: High Court in exercise of its revisional jurisdiction rightly refrained from re-examining factual determinations and such an approach being reasonable and unexceptionable, it committed no error in affirming the appellate order of eviction passed against the appellants on the ground of wilful default – Plea that pendency of proceedings created uncertainty as to the quantum payable is of * Author 168 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports no avail to the appellants – Lessee challenged the fixation of fair rent but did not seek a stay of its operation before the appellate or revisional fora – Mere filing of an appeal does not operate as a stay of the decree/order under appeal – Payments were made belatedly and only after protracted litigation – Such conduct cannot be reconciled with bona fide doubt as to liability – Appellants defaulted in payment of rent and such default is undoubtedly a wilful default – Concurrent finding of the appellate authority, affirmed by the High Court, that the lessee and thereafter the appellants had been in wilful default, rests on sound appreciation of the legal position and the appellants’ own admissions – It cannot be said that the absence of a two months’ notice under the Explanation to s.10(2)(i) would ipso facto disentitle the landlord from maintaining the proceedings for eviction on the ground of wilful default – Statute, when read as a whole, does not render such notice an indispensable condition precedent to the assumption of jurisdiction by the Rent Controller – Nature of default committed by the lessee satisfies the attributes of a wilful default and leaves little room to hold that no wilful default had been committed – Implication of “without prejudice” used in the order of dismissal of the SLP filed by the lessee would mean, that notwithstanding the liberty granted to the lessee to make payment, as per liberty granted, such payments were not to be seen as a waiver of respondent’s rights to realise unpaid rent and even to proceed for the lessee’s ejectment owing to wilful default committed by him – No advantage can be derived by the appellants by contending that payments having been made in terms of this Court’s order, the issue stood closed – Lessee, and subsequently the appellants, taking shelter of the pending appeal against the order fixing fair rent without, however, seeking a stay thereof and also in light of the parting observation made by this Court while disposing of SLP had no protective umbrella over him/them so as to remain absolved from tendering payment to the respondent. [Paras 31-34, 21-22, 24, 27-29] Judgment/order – Principle of finality of a judicial decision – Applicability, when appeal filed without seeking stay:
Held: Judicial proceedings attain finality upon a decision being rendered by the apex court in the hierarchy of courts – Nonetheless, proceedings do attain finality even at the level of the High Courts, or the district courts or the trial courts if the immediate next superior forum is not approached by the party suffering the decree/order of the court seized of the lis – However, the principle of finality of a [2025] 12 S.C.R. 169K. Subramaniam (Died) Through LRs K.S. Balakrishnan & Ors. v. M/s Krishna Mills Pvt. Ltd.
judicial decision would have no applicability in a situation where a party, despite owing money (unpaid rent, here) to his adversary in terms of a judicial determination, approaches the superior forum but prefers not to seek a stay of such determination pending the proceedings leaving the other party deprived of the benefits flowing from the said judicial determination – Bogey of judicial finality cannot, thus, be pressed into service to unfairly deny a party the benefits of a judicial decision, operation of which does not suffer from any interdiction by the superior court. [Para 30] Case Law Cited Chordia Automobiles v. S Moosa [2000] 2 SCR 13 : (2000) 3 SCC 282; PM Punnoose v. KM Munneruddin [2003] Supp. 1 SCR 698 : (2003) 10 SCC 610; N. Velmurugan v. K.N. Govindarajan (2002) 2 SCC 500; Rupa Ashok Hurra v. Ashok Hurra [2002] 2 SCR 1006 : (2002) 4 SCC 388; Sundaram Pillai & Ors. v. V.R. Pattabiraman [1985] 2 SCR 643 : (1985) 1 SCC 591; Trimurthi Fragrances (P) Ltd. v. Government of N.C.T. of Delhi, 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1247 – referred to.
Visalakshi Ammal v. T.B. Sathyanarayana (1997) 2 MLJ 453; J. Vishalakshmi Ammal v. T.B. Sathyanarayana, 1996-2-L.W. 849; Giridharilal Chandak & Bros. v. Mehdi Ispahani, 2011 (5) CTC 252 – referred to.
List of Acts Tamil Nadu Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1960; Tamil Nadu Regulation of Rights and Responsibilities of Landlords and Tenants Act, 2017; Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
List of Keywords Revisional jurisdiction; Eviction on the ground of wilful default; Lessee; Fixation of fair rent; Eviction petition; Wilful default; Accumulation of arrears; Principle of finality of a judicial decision; Judicial finality.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 2561 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 22.06.2021 of the High Court of Judicature at Madras in CRP No. 2053 of 2020 170 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Jaideep Gupta, Senthil Jagadeesan, Sr. Adv., Sajal Jain, Punit Manoj Agarwwal, Ms. Racheeta Chawla, Riddhi Bose, Ms. Rishi Agarwal, Ms. Sampriti Baksi.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Mrs. V Mohana, Sr. Adv., Pr Ramakrishnan, B Ragunath, Mrs. Nc Kavitha, Sriram P., Ms. Sreepriya K, S Padmanaban.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Dipankar Datta, J.
The A ppeAl
1. This is an appeal by the heirs of a lessee seeking reversal of a revisional judgment and order dated 22.06.20211 of the High Court of Judicature at Madras 2 . The impugned order affirmed an appellate order of eviction dated 25.02.2020 which, in turn, had reversed the original order of dismissal of the eviction petition dated 06.02.2019. FAcTuAl MATrix
2. The basic facts giving rise to the impugned order are not in dispute. To the extent germane for disposal of the present appeal, the same are adverted to in brief hereunder:
a. The sole respondent, M/s. Krishna Mills Pvt. Ltd. 3 , is the owner of a godown bearing D. No. 1084, Avinashi Road, Pappanaickenpalayam, Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu, and the adjacent building 4 .
b. The three appellants are the sons and heirs of K. Subramanian (since deceased), (proprietor of M/s. Royal Agencies). 5 The 1 impugned order 2 High Court 3 M/s. Krishna, hereafter 4 petition property 5 Lessee, hereafter [2025] 12 S.C.R. 171K. Subramaniam (Died) Through LRs K.S. Balakrishnan & Ors. v. M/s Krishna Mills Pvt. Ltd.
petition property consists of three portions of buildings measuring 5000 sq. ft. each, totalling to 15000. sq. ft., and a separate shed on the western side measuring 500 sq. ft.
c. A lease agreement, dated 11.10.1999, was executed by and between M/s. Krishna and the lessee, whereby a portion of the petition property, measuring 5000 sq. ft. was leased out at a monthly rent of Rs. 15,000/- for a period of 15 years. In October 2000, another 5000 sq. ft. of land and building was taken on lease for a monthly rent of Rs. 15,000. From 01.05.2000, the separate shed of 500 sq. ft. was taken on lease for a monthly rent of Rs. 3000. Subsequently, in October 2001, another 5000 sq. ft. was taken on lease for a monthly rent of Rs. 15,000. Thus, the total extent of 15,500 sq. ft. of land and building was leased for an aggregate monthly rent of Rs. 48,000/-. However, the lessee contended that the rent payable was Rs. 33,000/- p.m. d. In 2004, M/s. Krishna filed an application for fixation of fair rent6 before the Rent Controller, Coimbatore, alleging that the original rent was Rs. 48,000/- p.m. and not Rs. 33,000/- as claimed by the lessee; and consequently, fixation of Rs. 3,76,800/- p.m. as fair rent was sought. The Rent Controller allowed the application in part on 10.01.2007, and fixed the fair rent at Rs. 2,43,600/p.m., payable from 01.02.2005.
e. M/s. Krishna then filed an application 7 on 17.07.2007 seeking eviction of the lessee on the ground of wilful default. While it was alleged that an extent of 15,500 sq. ft. had been given on lease at a monthly rent of Rs.48,000/- p.m., the lessee contended that the rent was only Rs.33,000/- p.m. Earlier, as noted above, on M/s. Krishna’s application, the Rent Controller by its order dated 10.01.2007 had fixed the fair rent at Rs.2,43,600/- p.m. and subsequently, a demand of Rs.68,87,400/- was claimed towards arrears.
f. The lessee challenged the fixation of fair rent by carrying it in an appeal8 before the Rent Control Appellate Authority, Coimbatore, 6 RCOP No. 44 of 2005 7 RCOP No.134 of 2007 8 RCA No.21 of 2007 172 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports which came to be dismissed on 20.02.2008, thereby confirming the fair rent.
g. Against such dismissal, the lessee filed a revisional application 9 before the High Court. By an interim order, the High Court directed deposit of Rs.25,00,000/- before the Rent Controller and further payment of Rs.75,000/- p.m. without prejudice to the parties’ contentions. Complying with the said order, the lessee deposited the sum, as directed, and commenced paying Rs.75,000/- p.m.
h. On 09.09.2011, the High Court partly allowed the revisional application and reduced the rent to Rs.2,37,500/- p.m.
i. A legal notice dated 01.10.2011 followed, whereby M/s. Krishna demanded arrears of Rs.1,22,22,000/- after giving credit for Rs.25,00,000/-. The lessee, under protest, remitted Rs.2,13,750/- (after TDS) on 21.10.2011 towards rent for September, 2011 and thereafter preferred special leave petitions 10 before this Court. During the pendency of these petitions, M/s. Krishna filed a revised memo of calculation on 23.12.2011.
j. By an order dated 23.03.2012, this Court dismissed the special leave petitions but directed the lessee to pay arrears in instalments of Rs.15,00,000/- by the 15 th of each month, along with regular rent of Rs.2,37,500/- p.m., clarifying that such arrangement was without prejudice to the rights of the parties in the pending proceedings.
k. In compliance therewith, the lessee remitted Rs.13,50,000/- (after TDS) on 05.05.2012 and tendered two further cheques of Rs. 2,13,750/- (after TDS) and Rs. 13,50,000/- (after TDS) on 09.06.2012 towards arrears and rent.
l. The lessee sought a statement of accounts for audit purposes on 02.01.2013, and on 11.01.2013 sent a cheque of Rs.2,22,000/- (after TDS) in full settlement of arrears, asserting that all dues stood discharged. M/s. Krishna, by reply dated 05.02.2013, confirmed receipt of the arrears but stated that the same was 9 CRP (NPD) No.2511 of 2008 10 SLP (C) Nos.6500-6501 of 2012 [2025] 12 S.C.R. 173K. Subramaniam (Died) Through LRs K.S. Balakrishnan & Ors. v. M/s Krishna Mills Pvt. Ltd.
received without prejudice to their rights in RCOP No. 134 of 2007.
m. On 06.02.2013, M/s. Krishna raised invoices claiming service tax and interest from 01.06.2007 to 31.12.2012. By letter dated 17.04.2013, the lessee reiterated that all dues had been cleared and denied wilful default, further contending that service tax liability did not fall upon him under the lease.
n. Following the demise of the lessee, M/s. Krishna filed an amended application on 23.10.2017 under Section 10(2)(i) of the Tamil Nadu Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1960 11 , impleading the appellants (i.e., the heirs of the deceased lessee). Appellants filed their additional counter in February 2018, contending that no arrears were outstanding.
o. By an order dated 06.02.2019, the Rent Controller, Coimbatore, dismissed RCOP No.134 of 2007, holding that M/s. Krishna had failed to establish that original rent was Rs.48,000/- p.m. and further that since the lessee had paid fair rent in terms of the orders of this Court, no wilful default was made out.
p. Aggrieved thereby, M/s. Krishna preferred an appeal 12 . By a judgment and order dated 25.02.2020, the Principal Subordinate Judge, Coimbatore, reversed the Rent Controller’s finding, observing that despite fair rent proceedings attaining finality, the lessee had failed to tender arrears promptly and that clearance in instalments, even after dismissal of the special leave petitions, amounted to wilful default. The Principal Subordinate Judge finally held that the appellants were liable to be evicted on the ground of wilful default.
q. Appellants then mounted a challenge to the judgment and order of reversal dated 25.02.2020 in a revisional application 13 . Upon hearing the parties, vide the impugned order, the High Court on 22.06.2021 dismissed such application holding that the interim direction to deposit Rs.25,00,000/- and to pay Rs.75,000/- p.m. was only for the purpose of admission of the civil revision petition and that the Court had not granted any stay of the order. 11 Rent Control Act, 1960 12 RCA No.32 of 2019 13 CRP No.2053 of 2020 174 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports r. Although the appellants commenced paying rent as fixed by the High Court from 21.10.2011, belated payment of accumulated arrears nonetheless constituted wilful default.
A rguMenTs on B ehAlF oF The A ppellAnTs
3. Mr. Jaideep Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellants, contended that the eviction petition as originally filed was untenable. According to him, no notice had been issued by M/s. Krishna prior to the filing of RCOP No.44 of 2005, wherein wilful default in payment of rent was alleged on the ground that the monthly rent was Rs.48,000/- p.m., whereas the lessee consistently asserted that the rent was Rs.33,000/- p.m. He further contended that until disposal of CRP (NPD) No.2511 of 2008, no notice was ever served calling upon the lessee to pay arrears based on fixation of Rs.2,43,600/- p.m. as the fair rent by the Rent Controller with effect from 01.02.2005, covering the period up to 30.06.2007. He invited our attention to the letter dated 05.02.2013 of M/s. Krishna, wherein it acknowledged that the arrears had been received at the rate of Rs.2,37,500/- p.m., i.e., the fair rent as modified by the High Court on 09.09.2011. In such circumstances, it was urged that the belated amendment in RCOP No.134 of 2007, filed in the year 2017 after the demise of the lessee, impleading the present appellants and resurrecting the ground of wilful default for the very same arrears, was nothing but an afterthought and liable to be rejected.
4. Mr. Gupta maintained that the conduct of the lessee or the appellants was not that of a defaulter or an irregular payer of rent, since they continued to pay the originally agreed rent in compliance with the orders of various fora. Reliance was placed on the decision in Chordia Automobiles v. S Moosa14 to contend that when the arrear amount was in dispute and the proceedings were pending, it was reasonable for the lessee to follow the interim arrangements, and the same could not be held to be a case of wilful default.
5. It was next contended by Mr. Gupta that pursuant to the interim order dated 30.07.2008 in CRP (NPD) No.2511 of 2008, the lessee had, without delay, started remitting the rent in consonance with the directions of the High Court. While arrears were not cleared
14 (2000) 3 SCC 282
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 175K. Subramaniam (Died) Through LRs K.S. Balakrishnan & Ors. v. M/s Krishna Mills Pvt. Ltd.
in a lump sum immediately, this was on account of the pendency of SLP (C) Nos.6500-6501 of 2012 preferred against the order of the High Court dated 09.09.2011. The matter attained finality only upon the dismissal of the said special leave petitions by this Court on 23.03.2012 and, thereafter, the appellants’ father scrupulously adhered to the directions of this Court by paying instalments of Rs.15,00,000/- towards arrears along with the monthly rent of Rs.2,37,500/-. To address the issue of finality in the fixation of fair rent, he placed reliance on the decision in Visalakshi Ammal v. T.B. Sathyanarayana15, wherein it was held that the liability to pay fair rent would arise only upon the passing of the fair rent order by the Rent Controller, and that such liability would not attain finality so long as the order remained under challenge in appeal or revision. It was, therefore, submitted that the appellants cannot be branded wilful defaulters when the arrears were paid strictly in terms of the orders of this Court.
6. Mr. Gupta contended, by placing reliance on PM Punnoose v. KM Munneruddin16, that whenever there is a bona fide dispute on the quantum of arrears, the Controller should exercise his power under the proviso to sub-section (2) of Section 10 of the Rent Control Act, 1960 by passing an order thereunder and giving the tenant a reasonable time, not exceeding 15 days, to pay or tender the amount due to the landlord up to the date of such payment of rent. He also contended that the tenant had cleared the entire arrears and is willing to repay the outstanding arrears if any in two months, arguing against the order of eviction.
7. Reliance was further placed on N. Velmurugan v. K.N. Govindarajan17 to contend that once the execution petition was filed and the High Court had, by an interim order, permitted deposit and extended time for payment, there was no scope to allege wilful default. The expression “without prejudice” occurring in the order of this Court dated 23.03.2012 in SLP (C) Nos.6500-6501 of 2012, it was argued, could not be interpreted to enable M/s. Krishna, after having accepted arrears and rent pursuant to this Court’s
15 (1997) 2 MLJ 453
16 (2003) 10 SCC 610
17 (2002) 2 SCC 500
176 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports directions, to revive proceedings for wilful default in respect of the very same arrears.
8. Mr. Gupta next placed reliance on the decision of this Court in Rupa Ashok Hurra v. Ashok Hurra18 to urge that the principle of finality attaches only to the judgment of the Court of last resort, namely, this Court. It was argued that until the dismissal of SLP (C) Nos. 6500–6501 of 2012 on 23.03.2012, the issue of fixation of fair rent remained sub judice and, consequently, any alleged default prior thereto could not, in law, be characterised as “wilful”. According to him, it was only after the dismissal of the said special leave petitions that the determination of fair rent at Rs.2,37,500/- p.m. attained finality, and from that stage onwards the lessee continued to make regular payments without fail. He further contended that reliance placed on the Tamil Nadu Regulation of Rights and Responsibilities of Landlords and Tenants Act, 2017 19 was wholly misplaced, inasmuch as Section 4 of the said enactment expressly exempts tenancies governed by written agreements, which was the case here. It was also argued by him that a unilateral termination letter issued by the landlord could not by itself oust the jurisdiction of the civil court to entertain a tenant’s defence under the governing rent control legislation.
9. Furthermore, on the issue of precedents concerning Order XLI Rule 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, Mr. Gupta submitted that such authorities were of no relevance in the present context. He contended that those decisions merely recognise the appellate court’s discretion to grant conditional stay of execution pending appeal, whereas the question before the Court in the present case was whether the lessee could be held guilty of “wilful default” within the meaning of Section 10(2)(i) of the Rent Control Act, 1960. According to him, the principle governing determination of wilful default is distinct: liability of the lessee is to be assessed with reference to whether he neglected to pay rent from the date it became due despite the opportunity to do so, and not with reference to interlocutory directions issued by appellate courts while entertaining appeals.
10. Mr. Gupta then referred to the own pleadings of M/s. Krishna in RCOP No.134 of 2007, where the period of alleged default was stated to be from 01.10.2000 to 31.01.2005, quantified at Rs.7,80,000/-,
18 (2002) 4 SCC 388
19 2017 Act [2025] 12 S.C.R. 177K. Subramaniam (Died) Through LRs K.S. Balakrishnan & Ors. v. M/s Krishna Mills Pvt. Ltd.
computed at a monthly rent of Rs.15,000/-. He pointed out that such a claim was never substantiated by M/s. Krishna at any stage of the proceedings. In this regard, reliance was placed upon the findings recorded in the order dated 06.02.2019 in RCOP No.134 of 2007, wherein the Rent Controller itself noted the absence of evidence establishing Rs.15,000/- p.m. as the rent for the relevant period.
11. Finally, as regards the quantum of arrears claimed in the eviction petition, Mr. Gupta submitted that the figure of Rs.61,07,400/- as averred by M/s. Krishna was untenable. His submission was twofold: first, that the amount was computed on the basis of the fair rent of Rs.2,43,600/- p.m. fixed by the Rent Controller on 10.01.2007, whereas the revisional court, by its order dated 09.09.2011, had reduced the fair rent to Rs.2,37,500/- p.m.; and secondly, that the said fair rent determination reached finality only upon dismissal of the special leave petitions by this Court on 23.03.2012. Thus, it was contended that any claim predicated upon the figure of Rs.2,43,600/- p.m. or upon a demand raised prior to the finality of the proceedings was legally unsustainable.
12. Resting on the aforesaid arguments, Mr. Gupta prayed that the civil appeal be allowed by setting aside the impugned order passed by the High Court in CRP No. 2053 of 2020.
A rguMenTs oF The respondenT (M/s. K rishnA)
13. Per contra, Ms. V. Mohana, learned senior counsel appearing for M/s. Krishna, contended that the dispute was initially governed by the Rent Control Act, 1960, but with the enactment of the 2017 Act the jurisdiction of the civil courts stood excluded and landlord-tenant disputes could thereafter be adjudicated only by Rent Courts and Rent Tribunals. She urged that the appellants had wilfully defaulted in payment of fair rent, a finding concurrently recorded by the Appellate Authority and the High Court, since fair rent was determined on 10.01.2007, yet, the lessee cleared the arrears only on 11.01.2013. Relying on J. Vishalakshmi Ammal v. T.B. Sathyanarayana20, Ms. Mohana contended that the expression “rent” in Section 10(2)
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.