Vaibhav v. The State of Maharashtra
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 800; [2025] 7 S.C.R. 407
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice B.V. Nagarathna, Justice Satish Chandra Sharma
- Decided
- 4 Jun 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1643/2012
- Sections
- 34, 5, 25(1), 302, 201, 8, 27, 25
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 407 : 2025 INSC 800 Vaibhav v.
The State of Maharashtra (Criminal Appeal No. 1643 of 2012)
04 June 2025 [B.V. Nagarathna and Satish Chandra Sharma,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration In a case based on circumstantial evidence where there were missing links in the chain of circumstances, whether the finding of the High Court regarding the conviction of the appellant for offences u/ss.302, 201 r/w s.34, Penal Code, 1860 and s.5 r/w s.25(1)(a), Arms Act, 1959 was sustainable in light of the evidence on record. Headnotes† Circumstantial evidence – Missing links in the chain of circumstances – Accidental gunshot injury – Appellant was convicted u/ss.302, 201 r/w s.34, Penal Code, 1860 and s.5 r/w 25(1)(a), Arms Act, 1959 for the murder of his friend – Defence of the appellant that the deceased had accidentally shot himself with the pistol belonging to the appellant’s father: Held: The present is a case of an accidental gunshot injury and the possibility of a homicidal death is very weak in the present case – Imprints on the pistol had not been matched with the appellant and therefore, it cannot be concluded that the trigger was pulled by the appellant – Courts below failed to examine whether the defence of the appellant that the deceased on finding the service pistol of the appellant’s father, got curious, picked it up, started looking into it with one eye from a close distance and accidentally pressed the trigger, was a probable defence or not – The theory put across by the appellant is fairly probable and is supported by medical evidence including the examination of the bullet injury and trajectory – Contrarily, the conclusion drawn by the Courts below is not supported by medical evidence and is not consistent with the bullet injury and trajectory – The subsequent conduct of the appellant of removing the dead body and concealment of articles was a natural result of fear of his father and was consistent with the * Author 408 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports theory of accidental death – A young boy in first year of college, with no criminal background and with no motive in sight, would certainly have become scared on seeing that his friend has accidentally shot himself in the living room of his house with the pistol belonging to his father – In a case purely based on circumstantial evidence, the chain of circumstances must be complete and consistent with the conclusion of guilt only and must not support a contrary finding – Circumstantial evidence on record is not consistent and leaves a reasonable possibility of an alternate outcome of innocence of the appellant – High Court erred in arriving at the finding of guilt and upholding the judgment of Trial Court – Appellant acquitted for offences u/s.302, IPC and s.5 r/w s.25(1)(a), Arms Act – However, conviction u/s.201, IPC is sustained and he is sentenced for the period already undergone. [Paras 18, 20, 22, 26, 27, 29] Evidence Act, 1872 – s.8 – Subsequent conduct – Case based on circumstantial Evidence – Evidentiary burden – To be discharged by the prosecution vis-à-vis the accused – Appellant was convicted for the murder of his friend – Defence of the appellant that the deceased had accidentally shot himself in the living room of the appellant’s house with the pistol belonging to appellant’s father – Courts below relied on subsequent conduct of the appellant like removal of the dead body, concealment of articles and drew adverse inference: Held: Primary burden is on the prosecution and it is only if the prosecution succeeds in discharging its burden beyond reasonable doubt that the burden shifts upon the accused to explain the evidence against him or to present a defence – Prosecution’s version suffered from inherent inconsistencies and doubts, and thus, the inability of the appellant to explain certain circumstances could not be made the basis to relieve the prosecution from discharging its primary burden – Undoubtedly, in a case based on circumstantial evidence, facts indicating subsequent conduct are relevant facts u/s.8, Evidence Act – Equally, the inconsistencies in the version of the appellant are also relevant however, the occasion to examine the version/defence of the appellant could have arisen only if the prosecution had succeeded in discharging its primary burden beyond reasonable doubt – The inability of an accused to offer plausible explanation on certain aspects would not automatically absolve the prosecution of its evidentiary burden, which must be discharged first and beyond doubt – Evidence Act, 1872 – s.8. [Para 21] [2025] 7 S.C.R. 409Vaibhav v. The State of Maharashtra Gunshot cases – Nature of death whether suicidal, accidental or homicidal not ascertainable from direct evidence – Factors to be examined by the Court, stated. [Para 19] Circumstantial evidence – Motive, relevance of – Accidental gunshot injury – Absence of motive – Appellant was convicted for the murder of his friend – Defence of the appellant that the deceased had accidentally shot himself in the living room of the appellant’s house with the pistol belonging to appellant’s father:
Held: In a case based on circumstantial evidence, motive is relevant – However, it is not conclusive of the matter – But a complete absence of motive may weigh in favour of the accused – Testimonies of prosecution witnesses revealed that the appellant and the deceased were friends and there was no ill-will between them – Even the father of the deceased testified to that effect – In cases purely based on circumstantial evidence, the absence of motive could raise serious questions and might even render the chain of evidence as doubtful because the presence of motive explains the circumstantial evidence – For instance, in the facts of the present case, any evidence of enmity between the appellant and the deceased would have made suspicious the act of the appellant of taking the deceased to his home prior to his death – However, since the evidence suggests that they were friends, the fact that the appellant brought him home could not be termed as per-se incriminating – Therefore, motive explains the circumstances on record and enables the Court to draw better inference in a case based on circumstantial evidence. [Paras 23, 25] Case Law Cited Anwar Ali & Anr. v. State of Himachal Pradesh [2020] 9 SCR 878 : (2020) 10 SCC 166; Shivaji Chintappa Patil v. State of Maharashtra [2021] 2 SCR 617 : (2021) 5 SCC 626; Nandu Singh v. State of Madhya Pradesh (now Chhattisgarh), Criminal Appeal No. 285 of 2022 – referred to.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Arms Act, 1959; Evidence Act, 1872.
410 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports List of Keywords Accidental gunshot injury; Accidental death; Circumstantial evidence; Bullet injury and trajectory; Service pistol; Homicidal death; Removal of the dead body; Concealment of articles; Burden beyond reasonable doubt; Preponderance of probabilities; Absence of motive; Subsequent conduct; Chain of evidence; Inconsistencies in the chain of circumstances; Cleaning up the crime scene; Disappearance of evidence; Mere suspicion, no matter how grave, cannot take the place of proof; No direct evidence; Alternate outcome; Innocence.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
1643 of 2012 From the Judgment and Order dated 13.06.2012 of the High Court of Bombay at Nagpur in CRLA No. 57 of 2012 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Vipin Sanghi, Sr. Adv., Satyajit A. Desai, Siddharth Gautam, Ananya Thapliyal, Abhinav K. Mutyalwar, Sachin Singh, Ms. Anagha S. Desai.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Bharat Bagla, Sourav Singh, Aditya Krishna, Adarsh Dubey.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Satish Chandra Sharma, J.
1. This is a tale of two friends, Vaibhav and Mangesh, who were studying at Bagla Homeopathy Medical College, Arvat Chandrapur, Maharashtra. They were students of first year and often used to commute together on their two-wheelers. On the fateful day of 16.09.2010, both friends left the college together on the scooter belonging to Mangesh, had tea at the tea stall of PW-3 and arrived at Vaibhav’s house in the afternoon. When Mangesh’s father/PW-1 [2025] 7 S.C.R. 411Vaibhav v. The State of Maharashtra discovered late in the evening that his son had not reached home, he tried to find out and eventually lodged a missing report. The next day, on 17.09.2010, the dead body of Mangesh was found and accordingly, the present criminal case came to be registered against unknown persons.
2. Investigation commenced and a supplementary statement of PW-1 was recorded wherein he raised suspicion against Vaibhav, Mangesh’s friend, classmate, scooter partner and appellant before us in the present appeal. Upon investigation, the police prepared the chargesheet wherein the appellant was alleged to have caused death of deceased Mangesh by shooting him by the gun belonging to the appellant’s father/PW-12.
3. Upon trial, the Trial Court found that the appellant had killed Mangesh using the service gun belonging to his father when he came to drop him after college. Thereafter, the appellant called his friends Vishal and Akash (juvenile at the time of incident) for helping him in the disposal of the dead body. The appellant was found guilty for the commission of the offences under Sections 302, 201 read with Section 34 of Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter referred as “IPC” for brevity) and Section 5 read with 25(1)(a) of Arms Act, 1959. His friend Vishal was also found guilty for the commission of the offence under Section 201 read with Section 34 of IPC. Both the convicts had preferred separate appeals before the Bombay High Court and both the appeals came to be disposed of by the impugned judgment, wherein the conviction of the appellant was upheld and Vishal was acquitted for want of evidence. The present appeal assails the said impugned judgment dated 13.06.2012 passed in Criminal Appeal No. 57/2012.
IMPUGNED JUDGMENT
4. While upholding the conviction of the appellant, the High Court appreciated the testimonies of the prosecution witnesses and acknowledged that the case is based on circumstantial evidence as no direct evidence of the alleged act could be found. After examining the testimonies of the prosecution witnesses, the High Court observed that the material against the accused could be summed up as follows: “17. The material evidence adduced by the prosecution an admitted by the defence which are necessary for the decision of this appeal are enumerated thus:- 412 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(a) PW12 Khushal Tijare, father of the deceased, is a Police Officer to whom the 9mm pistol was entrusted along with 30 rounds.
(b) The accused and the deceased were known to each other.
(c) On 16.9.2010, PW12 Khushalrao had kept the pistol under the mattress in his bedroom.
(d) A1 and the deceased had been to the house of A1.
On 16.9.2010 after 3 p.m. nobody was at home.
(e) A1 called upon his father telephonically and demanded the keys of the rear door which leads to the abandoned quarter.
(f) PW12 informed A1 that the keys were behind the wall.
(g) On 16.9.2010, the deceased was lastly seen in the company of the accused as admitted by him.
(h) On 16.9.2010 after 8 p.m., PW1 was searching for his son and in the course of searching visited the house of A1 to inquire about Mangesh and that A1 informed PW1 that he had lastly seen Mangesh at 4 p.m.
(i) A1 visited the house of PW1 at 10 p.m. on 16.9.2010 and inquired about Mangesh. He returned home. His parents were at home. However, he did not disclose anything.
(j) On 17.9.2010, A1 visited the house of PW1 i.e. father of Mangesh at 9 a.m. Thereafter he revisited the house of PW1 with four friends and assured PW1 that they would search for Mangesh and made PW1 believe that Mangesh was alive.
(k) After the dead body was noticed in the courtyard behind the residential house of A1 and was being removed from the spot, A1 accompanied the Police still pretending ignorance about cause of death of Mangesh.
(l) The admission of A1 that his acquaintance with the deceased was just one month prior to the incident.
(m) The admission of A1 as a defence witness that when he went to change his clothes in his room, Mangesh was [2025] 7 S.C.R. 413Vaibhav v. The State of Maharashtra sitting on the bed in the living room, A1 heard the noise of firearm and came in the living room and found Mangesh lying on the ground with the pistol in his hand and that pistol was of his father.
(n) The admission of defence witness A1 that as soon as he saw Mangesh lying on the ground with the pistol, his first reaction was that he took the pistol and kept under the mattress of the bed i.e. the place where it was left by his father. Yet he has stated that he had no knowledge as to where his father had left the pistol. This contention cannot be believed.
(o) The admission of A1 that out of fear he removed the dead body from the living room and took it to the courtyard on the rear side of his house, that he cleaned the floor due to fear.
(p) The admission of A1 that when he had gone to change his clothes, Mangesh had not left the living room. Therefore, Mangesh had no access to the bed room and location of the pistol from beneath the mattress within a span of few minutes.
(q) The fact that although there was memorandum of recovery of clothes and it was not followed by a seizure, coupled with the statement of A1 that he had given it to the Police but they said that it was not required. The act of the accused disposing the cartridge at a particular place, showing the place to the Police, attempting to search the bullet at that place and yet not finding it.
(r) The explanation of PW12 below Exh.83 which is denied in the cross-examination of PW12.
(s) The sanction order issued by the District Magistrate for prosecuting the accused showing that the weapon of assault was used in the offence.”
5. The High Court laid great emphasis on the fact that after the death of Mangesh, the appellant had tried to stifle the investigation by removing evidence. It observed thus:
414 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports “20. The fact that the accused attempted to stifle the investigation is relevant under Section 8 of the Indian Evidence Act. The fact of fear as deposed by A1, accepted by the accused is relevant.”
6. On a careful perusal of the impugned judgment, it could be seen that the High Court has heavily relied upon Section 8 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (hereinafter referred as “Evidence Act”) to draw inferences from the subsequent conduct of the appellant, especially removal of the dead body, concealment of clothes, visits by the accused to the residence of PW-1 pretending to enquire about the deceased etc. As regards the causal link between the appellant and the alleged act, the High Court observed that the link was established as the 9 mm pistol belonging to the father of the appellant had caused the death of the appellant. The following para is indicative of the same: “23. …In the present case, the accused has himself admitted the weapon to be the service pistol of his father and that it was in the hand of deceased when he first saw him. The prosecution has led cogent and convincing evidence to prove that Mangesh had sustained the bullet injury with the same 9mm pistol. There is no ambiguity of the identity or description of weapon. The link evidence between the crime and the accused is established beyond reasonable doubt and by the admission of the accused himself and his father.”
7. The appellant had taken two primary defenses before the High Court – impossibility of homicidal death in light of the trajectory of the bullet and report of PW-9 which pointed towards accidental death. Both the contentions were turned down in the impugned judgment assigning different reasons. While rejecting the former contention, the High Court again adverted to the subsequent conduct of the appellant and observed thus:
“22. The learned counsel for the accused also pleaded that it appears from the evidence that the bullet was fired from a close range of 15cm would show that it is accidental. He has argued that there was no blackening around the eye. The direction in which the bullet had travelled through the eye to the occipital region would show that it is a case [2025] 7 S.C.R. 415Vaibhav v. The State of Maharashtra of accidental firing. The counsel has further argued that falsity of defence or giving a false explanation does not provide an additional link and cannot be made a ground for conviction. In the present case, it is not the falsity of defence which is being considered and, therefore, we have referred to Section 8 of the Indian Evidence Act.
The accused had prepared a good ground and given false explanation or rather made up a new story at the threshold i.e. even prior to investigation, at the time of investigation and, therefore, his conduct indicates the act of guilty mind.”
8. On the second aspect, the High Court observed that it was not obligatory for PW-9 to have given her opinion regarding the cause of death, as the cause of death was well known and was “admitted by the accused on oath”. The relevant part of the impugned judgment reads thus:
“28. The learned counsel has heavily relied upon the deposition of PW9 wherein it is stated that she cannot say as to whether the death is accidental or homicidal. We have already discussed that it is not obligatory on the part of the Doctor to give the cause of death when the cause is known and is established by the cogent and convincing evidence and moreover admitted by the accused on oath.”
THE CHALLENGE
9. Taking exception to the impugned judgment, Ld. Counsel on behalf of the appellant submits that the High Court did not examine the grounds taken by the appellant. It is submitted that as per the evidence of PW-9, the trajectory of the bullet was such that it had exited from the downward portion of the skull of the deceased and then hit the ventilator above the door. It is submitted that such a trajectory was only possible in case of a suicidal death and not homicidal. It is further submitted that the courts below have erred in not appreciating the testimony of PW-9, who had clearly deposed that she could not ascertain the cause of death and could not tell with certainty whether the death was suicidal or homicidal.
10. Relying upon medical jurisprudence, it is further submitted that in cases of accidental injuries by fire arm, bullet is hit from a close 416 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports distance. Further, in such cases, the injury is often singular. It is submitted that in the present case, both the elements of accidental death are present and the Courts below erred in not appreciating so.
11. As regards the conduct of the appellant after the incident, it is submitted that the appellant has categorically deposed that the death of Mangesh was caused by his father’s pistol at his residence. He has also deposed that as he heard the gunshot, he came out and saw the dead body of Mangesh lying in pool of blood. He got scared of his father and tried to clean up the scene and in doing so, he removed the dead body of the deceased and cleaned the blood by using phenyl. It is further submitted that there was no motive for the appellant to have caused the death of Mangesh and the relationship between the appellant and the deceased was friendly. To buttress this submission, it is submitted that in a case based on circumstantial evidence, absence of motive is a crucial fact which renders the prosecution case doubtful.
12. It is further submitted that the Courts below had placed undue burden upon the appellant to offer explanation for certain circumstances and his subsequent conduct. It is contended that it was for the prosecution to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt and mere inability of the appellant to explain certain aspects could not be read against him to arrive at a finding of guilt. Lastly, it is submitted that in a case based on circumstantial evidence, if two views are possible, the Court must lean in favour of the view favourable to the accused.
DISCUSSION
13. We have carefully considered the grounds of appeal, respective submissions advanced at Bar and have heard both sides at length. We may now consider the principal issue whether the finding of the High Court regarding the conviction of the appellant is sustainable in light of the evidence on record.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.