Manohar and Others v. The State of Maharashtra & Others
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 900; [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1675
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice * Cji and Augustine George Masih, Justice J.]
- Decided
- 28 Jul 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 9870/2025
- Sections
- 4, 51A, 32, 18, 32(2), 23
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1675 : 2025 INSC 900 Manohar and Others v.
The State of Maharashtra & Others (Civil Appeal No. 9870 of 2025)
28 July 2025 [B.R. Gavai,* CJI and Augustine George Masih, J.] Issue for Consideration Whether the impugned judgment passed by the High Court dismissing the First Appeals filed by the Appellants-farmers is sustainable or not.
Headnotes† Maharashtra Industrial Development Act, 1961 – Land Acquisition Act, 1894 – Grant of compensation – Highest exemplar sale deed – Benefit of, ought to be given to the Appellants – Appellants’ land and other adjoining lands were acquired under the 1961 Act for the establishment of Jintur Industrial Area – LAO awarded compensation to the tune of Rs. 10,800/- per Acre – Appellants sought enhancement of compensation – Reference Court enhanced the compensation to Rs. 32,000/- per Acre however, ignored the highest exemplar sale deed showing market value of Rs. 72,900/- per Acre relied upon by the Appellants – First Appeal filed by Appellants, dismissed by High Court – Interference with:
Held: When there are several exemplars with reference to similar land, usually the highest of the exemplars, which is a bona-fide transaction, will be considered – The highest exemplar sale deed showing market value of Rs. 72,900/- per Acre, available at Sr. No.4 and relied upon by the Appellants as a bona-fide sale instance was completely overlooked by the Reference Court – Though, the High Court recorded that the Reference Court considered in all ten exemplars and that it did not consider the sale instance at Sr. No.4 which is from Jintur, however, it took a diametrically opposite view that the Reference Court had considered the sale instance at Sr. No.4 since they are found nearby to the notification under the 1961 Act – Such finding recorded by the * Author 1676 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports High Court is erroneous – Impugned judgment not sustainable – Sale exemplar at Sr. No.4 is the most proximate to the date of transaction – Land of the Appellants was situated in a prime location and they deserve the benefit of the highest sale exemplar – However, on facts, the Reference Court rightly applied a deduction of 20% in the price determined – Thus, while accepting the sale exemplar at Sr. No.4, having market value of Rs. 72,900/- per Acre, a deduction of 20% i.e., Rs. 14,580/- per Acre is applied – Compensation granted to the Appellants enhanced from Rs. 32,000/- per Acre to Rs. 58,320/- per Acre with all other consequential benefits, as directed. [Paras 22, 25, 26, 28, 33, 50, 51] Land Acquisition Act, 1894 – Maharashtra Industrial Development Act, 1961 – Potential value of the land to be considered – Appellants’ land and other adjoining lands were acquired under the 1961 Act for the establishment of Jintur Industrial Area – Respondent No.3-Maharashtra Industrial Development Corporation contended that the Courts below rightly excluded the sale exemplar at Serial No. 4 on account of it being of an abnormally high value:
Held: Contention rejected – The compensation payable to the owner of the land is determined by reference to the price which a seller might reasonably expect to obtain from a willing purchaser– Also, the land acquired has to be valued not only with reference to its condition at the time of notification u/s.4, LA Act but its potential value must be taken into account – Thus, the sale deeds of lands situated in the vicinity and the comparable benefits and advantages which they have, provide a ready method of computing the market value – In the present case, the sale exemplar at Sr. No.4 i.e., the sale instance dated 31st March 1990, is the most proximate to the date of transaction – Further, the sale instances at Sr. Nos.9 and 10, from Jintur, show that after the notice under the 1961 Act, there has been a very high rise in the prices of the land in the nearby areas – Land of the Appellants was situated in a prime location and they deserve the benefit of the highest sale exemplar. [Para 41] Land Acquisition – Compensation – Method of computation – Plea of the Respondent No.3-Corporation that the Reference Court rightly used the principle of averaging of sale price of sale exemplars at Sr. Nos.1, 2, 3 and 5 for determination of market value of acquired land:
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1677Manohar and O thers v. The State of Maharashtra & O thers Held: Not accepted – In the event, the values of the sale instances taken into consideration by the Reference Court had a “marginal variation”, averaging thereof would have been permissible – But, the sale exemplars taken into consideration by the Reference Court, were the ones from Sr. Nos.1 to 6 and they ranged from Rs. 25,000/- per Acre to Rs. 72,900/- per Acre – In such a case, the averaging thereof was clearly not permissible – Further, only because the Reference Court, without recording any reason, decided to completely overlook/omit the sale instance at Sr. No.4 and only took into consideration the sale instances at Sr. Nos.1, 2, 3 and 5, which are having value of Rs. 40,000/- per Acre, Rs. 41,000/- per Acre, Rs. 40,000/- per Acre and Rs. 40,000/per Acre respectively; the averaging of these sale instances, having a marginal variation, could have been envisaged by the Reference Court – However, such an approach taken by the Reference Court was completely impermissible. [Paras 48, 49] Land Acquisition Act, 1894 – s.51A – Respondent No.3- Corporation contended that the Reference Court did not enter any finding that the sale instance at Sr. No.4 is a bona-fide transaction and it was justified in not considering the same as it reflected an unusually high rate:
Held: The contention of the Respondent No.3 qua sale instance at Sr. No. 4 not being a bona-fide transaction is rejected on the basis of s.51A as per which the certified copy of a document can be accepted as evidence of transaction recorded in the said document – Further, though the Respondent State denied the correctness of the said documents, it did not lead any rebuttal evidence – Maharashtra Industrial Development Act, 1961. [Para 44] Case Law Cited State of Punjab and Another v. Hans Raj (Dead) by LRs. Sohan Singh and Others [1994] 1 SCR 1008 : (1994) 5 SCC 734; Mehrawal Khewaji Trust (Registered), Faridkot and Others v. State of Punjab and Others [2012] 4 SCR 24 : (2012) 5 SCC 432; Mohammad Yusuf and Others v. State of Haryana and Others [2018] 3 SCR 1075 : (2018) 16 SCC 105; Anjani Molu Dessai v. State of Goa and Another [2010] 14 SCR 997 : (2010) 13 SCC 710; Major General Kapil Mehra and Others v. Union of India and Another [2014] 10 SCR 1153 : (2015) 2 SCC 262; Shawal Singh (Dead) Through Legal Representatives v. Land Acquisition Collector, 1678 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Himachal Pradesh and Another (2016) 12 SCC 619 ; Nirmal Singh and Others v. State of Haryana Through Collector (2015) 2 SCC 160 – referred to.
List of Acts Land Acquisition Act, 1894; Maharashtra Industrial Development Act, 1961.
List of Keywords Highest exemplar sale deed; Benefit of highest sale exemplar; Bona-fide transaction; Bona-fide sale instance; Highest sale exemplar most proximate to the date of transaction; Enhancement of compensation; Jintur Industrial Area; Jintur town; Land situated in a prime location; Nashik-Nirmal State Highway; Maharashtra Industrial Development Corporation; Farmers owners of land; Sale deeds of lands situated in the vicinity; High rise in prices of land in nearby areas; Method of computation of the compensation; Principle of averaging of sale price of sale exemplars; Marginal variation; Determination of market value of acquired land; Sale instances.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 9870 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 21.04.2022 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay at Aurangabad in FA No. 1179 of 2008 With Civil Appeal No(s). 9871 and 9872 of 2025 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Deshmukh Adith Satish, Bharat Thakorlal Manubarwala.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Ms. Rukhmini Bobde, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Ms. Soumya Priyadarshinee, Vinayak Aren, Amlaan Kumar, Naveen Kumar Bhardwaj, Ms. Shyamali Gadre, Soumik Ghosal, G Pal, Ashutosh Chaturvedi.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1679Manohar and O thers v. The State of Maharashtra & O thers Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment B.R. Gavai, CJI
1. Delay condoned.
2. Leave granted.
3. The present batch of appeals challenge the common judgment and final order dated 21 st April, 2022, passed by a learned Single Judge of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay, Bench at Aurangabad (hereinafter, “High Court”), whereby the First Appeals filed by the claimants/Appellants came to be dismissed.
FACTS
4. The facts, in brief, giving rise to the present appeals are as given below:
4.1. The Appellants, in the lead matter, are farmers and were owners of land bearing Survey No. 103 and 104, admeasuring 16 Hectare 79 Are situated at Village Pungala, Taluq and District Parbhani, Maharashtra.
4.2. It appears that the land of the Appellants and other adjoining lands were sought to be acquired in the 1990s under the provisions of the Maharashtra Industrial Development Act, 1961 (hereinafter, “Act of 1961”) for setting up an Industrial Area near Jintur town in Parbhani District.
4.3. On 16th January, 1992, the Land Acquisition Officer & Deputy Collector, Hingoli (hereinafter, “Land Acquisition Officer”) issued a notice under sub-section (2) of Section 32 of the Act of 1961.
4.4. On 6th December, 1994, the Respondent-State took possession of the Appellants’ land and an Award came to be passed by the Land Acquisition Officer. In terms of the said Award, the total area subject matter of the acquisition was 89 Hectares and 44 Are and the total compensation awarded was Rs. 45,70, 508/-.
4.5. Being aggrieved by the quantum of compensation awarded, the Appellants accepted the compensation under protest and 1680 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports simultaneously filed a Reference under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter, “LA Act”) in the year 1997.
4.6. Vide judgment and award dated 7th June 2007, in L.A.R. No. 61 of 1997, the Court of Principal District Judge, Parbhani (hereinafter, “Reference Court”), partly allowed the reference with proportionate costs and directed the Respondent-State to pay the Appellants an amount of Rs. 46,26,013/- along with future interest @ 15% per annum from the date of award until the payment is made on the additional market value of Rs. 16,43,224/-.
4.7. Aggrieved still, the Appellants filed a First Appeal bearing No. 1179 of 2008 before the High Court.
4.8. Vide impugned judgment and final order, the learned Single Judge of the High Court dismissed the First Appeal.
4.9. Being aggrieved thereby, the present appeals came to be filed by way of special leave.
4.10. Vide order dated 22nd September, 2023, this Court issued notice on the application for condonation of delay in filing Special Leave Petition as well as on the Special Leave Petition.
SUBMISSIONS
5. We have heard Mr. Adith Satish Deshmukh and Mr. Bharat Thakorlal Manubarwala, learned counsel for the Appellants, Ms. Rukhmini Bobde, learned counsel for Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 and Ms. Shyamali Gadre, learned counsel for Respondent No. 3.
6. Mr. Deshmukh and Mr. Manubarwala submitted that the Appellants are farmers, who lost their only source of sustenance and ever since are prosecuting their claim for fair, just and reasonable compensation based on the highest exemplar dated 31 st March 1990. He further submitted that the Reference Court having found the highest exemplar sale to be a bona-fide transaction erred in ignoring the same without any reasoning. He, therefore, submitted that the finding of the High Court, that the Reference Court considered the highest exemplar sale deed, is contrary to the record.
7. Mr. Deshmukh and Mr. Manubarwala submitted that Reference Court and High Court ought to have given benefit of the highest exemplar [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1681Manohar and O thers v. The State of Maharashtra & O thers sale deed to the Appellants. He further submitted that the Courts having found that, the lands acquired in the acquisition are situated near T-point of Nashik-Nirmal State Highway adjacent to Jintur town which is a prime location with percolation tank just opposite to the lands with sufficient water, ought to have enhanced the compensation based on the highest exemplar sale deed dated 31st March, 1990.
8. To buttress his submissions, the learned counsel for the Appellants placed reliance on the judgments of this Court in the cases of State of Punjab and Another v. Hans Raj (Dead) by LRs. Sohan Singh and Others, 1 Mehrawal Khewaji Trust (Registered), Faridkot and Others v. State of Punjab and Others,2 Mohammad Yusuf and Others v. State of Haryana and Others, 3 and Anjani Molu Dessai v. State of Goa and Another.4
9. Per contra, Ms. Bobde appearing on behalf of the Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 submitted that the Land Acquisition Officer had considered the sale instances of similar lands in the vicinity of the acquired lands and arrived at a proper valuation. She, accordingly, submitted that the compensation of acquired lands is fair and reasonable.
10. Ms. Gadre appearing on behalf of the Respondent No. 3 submitted that the Appellants owned dry crop land which was subject matter of acquisition by Maharashtra Industrial Development Corporation (hereinafter, “MIDC”). She submitted that before the Reference Court, the Appellants relied on ten sale exemplars and the sale exemplars at Serial Nos. 1 to 4 are pre-notification sale exemplars from Jintur town. She further submitted that considering the total area under acquisition by MIDC, the sale exemplars relied upon, being of an area less than 1 Hectare, are of small plots in Jintur town.
11. Ms. Gadre submitted that the Reference Court has not entered any finding that the highest exemplar sale deed dated 31st March, 1990, is a bona-fide transaction. She further submitted that the Reference Court was justified in not considering the highest exemplar sale deed dated 31st March, 1990, showing market value of Rs. 72,900/- per Acre, as it reflected an unusually high rate. She further submitted that the sale
1 (1994) 5 SCC 734
2 (2012) 5 SCC 432
3 (2018) 16 SCC 105
4 (2010) 13 SCC 710
1682 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports exemplars at Serial Nos. 8 to 10 show that even after the acquisition, the market value of land had not increased in the same proportion.
12. In support of her submissions, Ms. Gadre placed reliance on the judgments of this Court in the cases of Major General Kapil Mehra and Others v. Union of India and Another,5 Shawal Singh (Dead) Through Legal Representatives v. Land Acquisition Collector, Himachal Pradesh and Another,6 Anjani Molu Dessai (supra), and Nirmal Singh and Others v. State of Haryana Through Collector.7
ISSUE FOR CONSIDERATION
13. On a perusal of the material placed on record, in light of the submissions advanced by the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the parties, the only issue that falls for our consideration is whether the impugned judgment and final order dated 21 st April, 2022, passed by the High Court is sustainable or not?
ANALYSIS
14. The land of the Appellants and other adjoining lands were acquired in the 1990s under the provisions of the Act of 1961 for setting up an Industrial Area near Jintur town in Parbhani District of Maharashtra. The Land Acquisition Officer, on 6 th December, 1994, awarded compensation to the tune of Rs. 10,800/- per Acre (or Rs. 27,000/per Hectare). However, not being satisfied with the compensation awarded, the Appellants preferred a petition under Section 18 of the LA Act before the Reference Court, claiming enhancement of compensation determined by the Land Acquisition Officer.
15. On a perusal of the judgment and award passed by the Reference Court dated 7th June, 2007, it appears that the case of the Appellants was that the Land Acquisition Officer has not considered that the land in question is touching the outskirts of municipal limits of Jintur city and having non-agricultural potential. It was further their case that Village Pungala is only one kilometre away from Jintur city so the Appellants, being farmers, had a good market for selling their agricultural produce.
5 (2015) 2 SCC 262
6 (2016) 12 SCC 619
7 (2015) 2 SCC 160
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1683Manohar and O thers v. The State of Maharashtra & O thers
16. It is pertinent to note that to substantiate their claim, the Appellants led evidence by way of affidavit. They placed on record the following sale instances:
S. No. Date of Sale Deed Name of Village Area Sold Price per Acre
1. 28/04/1989 Jintoor 20 R Rs. 40,000/-
2. 22/05/1989 Jintoor 39 R Rs. 41,000/-
3. 22/05/1989 Jintoor 80 R Rs. 40,000/-
4. 31/03/1990 Jintoor 96 R Rs. 72,900/-
5. 28/05/1990 Wazur 20 R Rs. 40,000/-
6. 05/10/1990 Bhogaon 40 R Rs. 25,000/-
7. 11/02/1992 Panghari 11 R Rs. 54,500/-
8. 16/04/1992 Panghari 47 R Rs. 18,000/-
9. 31/12/1992 Jintoor 26 R Rs. 61,500/-
10. 06/03/1993 Jintoor 12 R Rs. 60,000/-
17. It is further to be noted that though the Respondent-State denied the correctness of the above documents (sale instances), but no rebuttal evidence was placed on record by them.
18. After deciding the issue of limitation in the favour of the Appellants, the Reference Court found that the lands under acquisition are located at a short distance from Jintur town, which is a district headquarter; the purpose for which the lands were acquired was for development of Industrial Area and that the lands which were acquired were having non-agricultural potential. Further, the Reference Court found that the location of the lands is suitable for industrial units and that a water facility is available just adjacent to the lands.
19. From paragraph 28 onwards, the Reference Court has dealt with the most material piece of evidence placed on record by the Appellants viz., the sale instances as specified above in tabular form. The Reference Court observed that the material date on which the market value of land is to be determined will be 19 th July, 1990, when firstly the notification under sub-section (2) of Section 32 of the Act of 1961 was issued. The Court, accordingly, came to the finding that the sale instances prior to the aforesaid date of notification will be of relevance to the matter. Thereafter, the Reference Court observed 1684 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports that the sale instances at Sr. Nos. 1 to 3 and 4 to 6 are prior to or nearby to the notification under the Act of 1961 and that the lands which are covered under the sale deeds are from Jintur town. The Court, therefore, came to the finding that the sale instances relied on by the claimants can be relied on and acted upon and that the sale deeds of lesser area of land can also be considered for determining the market value.
20. Pertinently, the Reference Court found that the claimants have placed on record certified copies of the sale deeds and that the same has got presumptive value under Section 51A of the LA Act. The Court further found that no rebuttal evidence has been led by the Respondent-State. Accordingly, the Reference Court came to the conclusion that the sale instances covered under the sale deeds came to be effected in due course of business in routine manner between willing purchaser and seller and, therefore, the transaction covered therein can be relied upon and acted upon to determine the market value of the land.
21. Surprisingly, after reaching till this point, the Reference Court in paragraph 31, while determining the price of the claimants’ land, came to the finding that since the price of land sold under the sale deeds at Sr. Nos. 1, 2, 3 and 5, was around Rs. 40,000/- per Acre i.e., Rs. 1,00,000/- per Hectare so by applying the deduction of 20% in the price, the market value of dry crop land, at the time of acquisition, was ascertained as Rs. 32,000/- per Acre (or Rs. 80,000/per Hectare) and the price of irrigated land, at the time of acquisition, was ascertained as Rs. 40,000/- per Acre (or Rs. 1,00,000/- per Hectare). In the result, compensation to be awarded for the land of the Appellants was enhanced to Rs. 32,000/- per Acre.
22. It can, therefore, be seen that the highest exemplar sale deed dated 31 st March, 1990, showing market value of Rs. 72,900/- per Acre, available at Sr. No. 4 and relied upon by the claimants as a bona-fide sale instance was completely overlooked by the Reference Court. It would, however, have been a different matter if the Reference Court, for reasons to be recorded by it, came to a finding that the sale instance at Sr. No. 4 was not a bona-fide one or a sham/bogus one which could not be relied upon.
23. Being aggrieved by the judgment and award of the Reference Court, the claimants/Appellants filed a First Appeal before the High Court. [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1685Manohar and O thers v. The State of Maharashtra & O thers The learned Single Judge of the High Court, however, finding no error in the approach and/or outcome of the judgment and award passed by the Reference Court dismissed the batch of appeals filed by the claimants. Aggrieved thereby, the Appellants filed the present appeals by way of special leave.
24. To ascertain whether the impugned judgment and final order passed by the learned Single Judge of the High Court is sustainable or not, it would be apposite to refer to paragraphs 45-46 and 49-50 thereof, which read thus:
“45. Now coming to the determination of the market value of the acquired lands and sale instances produced by the claimants. It is not in dispute that the acquired lands are situated at village Pungala. The compulsory land acquisition is made according to the Act of 1961 for the public purpose for establishment of Jintur industrial area. According to the evidence of claimants, village Pungala is at a distance of 2 k.m. away from Jintur, which is a taluka place, where the market committee, Wakhar Mahamandal, dairy business and other basic facilities are available. The oral evidence of claimants regarding distance in between the acquired land and Jintur town is not at all challenged by way of cross-examination initiated by the learned A.G.P. As such, there is no difficulty to accept the oral evidence produced by the claimants that the acquired lands are at a distance of 2 k.m. away from the Jintur town. Jintur is a town. There is a municipality and all the facilities are available. It is a taluka headquarter.
46. It is material to note that the acquired lands are selected for acquisition. It is evident from the testimony of the claimants that the acquired lands are more convenient for the establishment of M.I.D.C. Jintur. Water facility is also available at a short distance from the acquired lands. The stock of evidence produced by the claimants regarding the proximity of the acquired lands with Jintur town coupled with facilities available and advantages is not any way challenged by way of cross-examination.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.