United Bank of India (Now Punjab National Bank) v. Swapan Kumar Mullick & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 881; [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1642
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Dipankar Datta, Justice Ujjal Bhuyan
- Decided
- 22 Jul 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 9679/2025
- Sections
- 5(1), 5
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1642 : 2025 INSC 881 United Bank of India (Now Punjab National Bank)
v.
Swapan Kumar Mullick & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 9679 of 2025)
22 July 2025 [Dipankar Datta* and Ujjal Bhuyan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose to determine whether an employee resigning from service citing mental depression, after having served his employer much in excess of the period stipulated to qualify for being entitled to pension, forfeits his right to opt for pension in terms of a specific provision in the Pension Regulations for all times to come, or, in view of pension being a social welfare measure for employees in the winter years of their life, adopting a beneficial approach is permissible.
Headnotes† Service Law – United Bank of India (Employees’) Pension Regulations, 1955 – Regn 22 – Resignation of an employee, who is not a pension optee – Benefit of pension on basis of the circular – Entitlement – Resignation tendered by the respondent no.1-employee citing mental depression, after 36 years of service – Bank accepted the same and the employee relieved from service – Few years later, based on bipartite settlement, Bank issued a Circular extending ‘another option for pension’ for the employees who had not opted for the pension scheme under the 1955 Regn – On basis thereof, the employee claimed pension, however, the Bank returned the application stating that employees who had left the service by opting for voluntary retirement/compulsory retirement/ resignation not eligible to opt for pension – Single Judge held that the employee was entitled to opt for pension – Division Bench set aside the order and issued certain directions to the Bank, directing the Board of Directors of the Bank to consider amending Regn 22 – Correctness:
* Author [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1643United Bank of India (Now Punjab National Bank) v. Swapan Kumar Mullick & Ors.
Held: Employee must be held to have resigned from service and not retired voluntarily so as to enable him secure the benefit of a further opportunity to opt for pension in terms of the circular – Employee while in service had the opportunity to opt for pension in terms of the 1995 Regulations, however, he opted for provident fund – Having served the Bank for over 35 years and in service for more than a decade after introduction of the 1995 Regulations, he is presumed to have been aware of the same together with the consequences of tendering resignation instead of seeking voluntary retirement – Presumption can also be legitimately drawn that respondent no.1 was satisfied with whatever he received on account of provident fund dues while demitting office – Respondent no.1 was suffering from mental depression but that did not prevent him from being coherent while writing the resignation letter – Not the case of employee that he signed without being aware of its contents – Terms of the bipartite settlement are binding on all the employees of the public sector banks, which were parties thereto, and such terms cannot be read in a manner to extend its coverage dehors the statutory regulations – Reg 22 not found to be so manifestly arbitrary, so as to call for interference – Reg 22 could have been held to violate Art.14, if employee, upon resigning from service, were denied dues on account of provident fund – Since by 2006, when he resigned, respondent no.1 had not shown any inclination to opt for pension instead of provident fund, Reg 22 did not affect him at all – To have an entitlement to pension, futuristically speaking, employee was required to adhere to the 1995 Regulations, which he did not – Although the Division Bench required the Board of Directors of the Bank to ‘consider’ an amendment to Regn 22, in the light of stipulation of a timeline and the other directions for determining whether resignation tendered by respondent no.1 could be treated as voluntary retirement and to process his claim for pension upon such determination, user of the word ‘consider’ is really a mandate on the Bank to amend Regn 22, which could not have been issued – Division Bench overstepped its bounds by directing the Board of Directors to consider amending Regn 22 even when the vires of such a regulation was not under challenge – Order passed by the Division Bench upheld and the directions to ‘consider’ an amendment to Regn 22 set aside – In exercise of power u/Art.142, some relief extended to the employee to assist him survive in the winter years of his life with a fair measure of dignity. [Paras 64, 65, 72, 73] 1644 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Service Law – Expression ‘voluntary retirement’ and ‘resignation’ – Distinction between:
Held: “Resignation” and “voluntary retirement” are two distinct concepts with varying consequences on severance of relationship and that substitution of the two for each other based solely on the duration of an employee’s service would run counter to the intendment of statutory regulations and, thus, is improper – Employees resigning from service and employees retiring from service voluntarily constitute two different classes – Treating the two classes differently may not offend Art.14 – Resignation, being a voluntary relinquishment of employment, is an implied term of employer-employee relationship – Resignation can be exercised anytime while the employee is in service – But unless specified otherwise, resignation is unilateral, majorly, resignation is bilateral which, to be effective, requires acceptance by the employer – On the other hand, an employee may seek voluntary retirement if an option is provided by the employer as a condition of service to such employee to retire from service on fulfilment of the specified terms and conditions – Any employee may, thus, offer to retire voluntarily upon completion of the requisite period of service and upon fulfilling other requirements – An offer to retire voluntarily, made by an employee, is normally accepted by the employer unless, of course, there is any debilitating factor – Importantly, when a provision for voluntary retirement does exist, yet, an employee elects to resign, such resignation (irrespective of the length of service) cannot be treated as voluntary retirement unless, in a given case, the employee also satisfies the conditions for voluntary retirement – What is applicable in a case of voluntary retirement ex proprio vigore may not apply to resignation in all cases. [Paras 47, 52, 53] Judicial Review – Legislative policies – Scope of interference: Held: Judicial review courts should refrain from assessing the merits of policies formulated by legislative or regulatory authorities which are codified in statutes/regulations – Any shortcomings in the policy do not render the regulation ultra vires – Courts cannot invalidate a regulation merely because in its opinion the policy is unwise or ineffective – Scrutiny has normally to be restricted to the process of policy making – As long as the policy is not beyond [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1645United Bank of India (Now Punjab National Bank) v. Swapan Kumar Mullick & Ors.
the scope of the regulation-making power or does not transgress the bounds of the parent enactment or is in violation of any of the limitations imposed by the Constitution, there is little or no scope for interference by the Courts – Power u/Art.226 cannot be exercised by a High Court to direct the legislature/executive to enact a law (primary or subordinate) or frame a regulation/bye-law – These are executive functions which are to be performed based on policy decisions taken at the appropriate level – Constitution of India – Art.226. [Paras 57, 58, 67] Case Law Cited LIC v. Shree Lal Meena [2019] 5 SCR 391 : (2019) 4 SCC 479; State of West Bengal v. Anwar Ali Sarkar [1952] 1 SCR 284 : (1952) 1 SCC 1 – distinguished.
Bank of Baroda v. S.K. Kool (dead) Through Legal Representatives [2013] 12 SCR 783 : (2014) 2 SCC 715; Shashikala Devi v. Central Bank of India [2014] 13 SCR 868 : (2014) 16 SCC 260; M.R. Prabhakar v. Canara Bank [2012] 8 SCR 1072 : (2012) 9 SCC 671; BSES Yamuna Power Ltd. v. Ghanshyam Chand Sharma [2019] 14 SCR 546 : (2020) 3 SCC 346; UCO Bank & Ors. v. Sanwar Mal [2004] 2 SCR 1125 : (2004) 4 SCC 412; Delhi Transport Corporation v. D.T.C. Mazdoor Congress [1990] Supp. 1 SCR 142 : (1991) Supp. 1 SCC 600; D.S. Nakara v. Union of India [1983] 2 SCR 165 : (1983) 1 SCC 305; Reserve Bank of India v. Cecil Dennis Solomon [2003] Supp. 6 SCR 465 : (2004) 9 SCC 461; Sheelkumar Jain v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd. [2011] 9 SCR 574 : (2011) 12 SCC 197; Sudhir Chandra Sarkar v. TISCO [1984] 3 SCR 325 : (1984) 3 SCC 369; S. Appukuttan v. Thundiyil Janaki Amma [1988] 2 SCR 661 : (1988) 2 SCC 372; Asger Ibrahim Amin v. LIC [2015] 9 SCR 865 : (2016) 13 SCC 797; Mallikarjuna Rao v. State of Andhra Pradesh [1990] 2 SCR 418 : (1990) 2 SCC 707; V.K. Sood v. Department of Civil Aviation [1993] 3 SCR 772 : (1993) Supp. 3 SCC 9; State of Himachal Pradesh v. Satpal Saini [2017] 1 SCR 658 : (2017) 11 SCC 42 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited Administrative Law, H.W.R. Wade, 6th Edition – referred to. 1646 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports List of Acts United Bank of India (Employees’) Pension Regulations, 1955; Constitution of India; Contract Act, 1872.
List of Keywords Pension; Resignation; Voluntary retirement; Enactment of law by legislature/executive; Policy decisions; Circular (No.SP/OPTION/2/ OM-0293/10-11) dated 16th August, 2010, clauses 2, 3; Mental depression; Social welfare measure for employees; Resignation of an employee, who is not pension optee; Bipartite settlement; Voluntary retirement/compulsory retirement/resignation; Provident fund; Employer-employee relationship; Ex proprio vigore; Judicial Review; Legislative policies; Executive functions.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 9679 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 17.06.2020 of the High Court at Calcutta in FMA No. 4412 of 2016 With:
Civil Appeal No. 9675 of 2025 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Tripurari Ray, Laxmi Narayan Sharma, Atul Wadera, Rajinder Singh, Ms. Shilpa Singh, Rajesh Kumar Gautam, Anant Gautam, Deepanjal Choudhary, Ms. Likivi Jakhalu, Kushagra Nilesh Sahay. Advs. for the Respondents:
Puneet Jain, Shekhar G. Devasa, Sr. Advs., Rajesh Kumar Gautam, Anant Gautam, Deepanjal Choudhary, Ms. Likivi Jakhalu, Kushagra Nilesh Sahay, Tripurari Ray, Balwant Singh Billowria, Vivek Gupta, Anirudh Ray, Ms. Payal Rani, Manu Shanker Mishra, Ms. Christi Jain, Mann Arora, Mrs. Akriti Sharma, Harsh Jain, Om Sudhir Vidyarthi, Subhasish Mohanty, Mata Prasad Singh, Bikash Chandra, Ms. Priyanka Thakur, Ankit Bhatnagar, Ms. Madhusmita Bora, Manish Tiwari, Pawan Shyam, Ms. Thashmitha Muthanna, Shashi Bhushan Nagar, Vishwanath Chaturvedi, M/s. Devasa & Co.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1647United Bank of India (Now Punjab National Bank) v. Swapan Kumar Mullick & Ors.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Dipankar Datta J.
The A ppeAls
1. Leave granted. These appeals, arise out of a common judgment and order dated 17 th June, 2020 1 of a Division Bench of the High Court at Calcutta 2 . The operative part of the impugned order reads thus: A) The judgment and order under appeal dated 1 st April, 2016 is set aside.
B) The Board of Directors of the United Bank of India shall consider amendment of Regulation 22 of the United Bank of India (Employees’) Pension Regulations, 1995 according to the circular of the Indian Banks Association dated 30 th June, 2015 with or without retrospective effect within 3 months of physical communication of this order.
C) The appellant bank by constituting an authority shall determine by 21st October, 2020 upon giving an opportunity to Mullick to place facts and adduce evidence before it whether he could be treated as having voluntarily retired from service, strictly following the judgment of the Supreme Court in Shashikala case reported in (2014) 16 SCC 260 read with UCO Bank & Ors. Vs. Sanwar Mal reported in (2004) 4 SCC 412 and Senior Divisional Manager, Life Insurance Corporation of India & Ors. Vs. Shree Lal Meena reported in (2019) 4 SCC 479, BSES Yamuna Power Ltd. Vs. Sh. Ghanshyam Chand Sharma & Anr. reported in AIR 2020 SC 76 and the observation made in this judgment and order.
D) Depending on such determination the option form/application submitted by Mullick dated 23rd August, 2010 in the terms of the circular dated 16 th August, 2010 for availing of the pension scheme shall be processed by the bank by 20th November, 1 impugned order 2 High Court 1648 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 2020. The appeal (FMA 4412 of 2016) is disposed of by this judgment and order.
(bold in original)
2. The appellant - United Bank of India (now Punjab National Bank) 3 is aggrieved by the directions contained in (B) to (D) supra; hence, it has preferred the lead appeal.
3. Upon service of notice, the 1 st respondent - Shri Swapan Kumar Mullick 4 - has preferred the connected appeal.
FAcTs
4. The uncontroverted facts giving rise to the present appeals are as under:
4.1. Mullick joined the services of the Bank as a typist on 23 rd November, 1970. Subsequently, he was promoted to the post of machine operator in the year 1978, and later to the post of head cashier.
4.2. After rendering 36 years of service with the Bank, Mullick tendered his resignation on 21 st August, 2006, citing mental depression. The Bank accepted Mullick’s resignation on 19 th October, 2006, and relieved him from its service.
4.3. On 27 th April, 2010, a bipartite settlement was signed between the Indian Banks Association5 and various unions of workmen. Based on this bipartite settlement, the Bank issued a circular (No.SP/OPTION/2/OM-0293/10-11) dated 16th August, 2010 6 extending ‘another option for pension’ for the employees who had not opted for the pension scheme under the United Bank of India (Employees’) Pension Regulations, 1995 7 .
4.4. The circular assumes primacy since it defined retired employees who would be entitled to pensionary benefits. It is this circular 3 Bank 4 Mullick
5 IBA
6 circular 7 1995 Regulations [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1649United Bank of India (Now Punjab National Bank) v. Swapan Kumar Mullick & Ors.
upon which Mullick based his claim for pension. Clause 2 of the circular defines retired employees and reads thus:
2. Retired employees means those who were in service of the Bank on or after 29th September, 1995 and ceased to be in service of the Bank on account of retirement on Superannuation, Voluntary retirement or on account of VRS under special scheme prior to 27 th April, 2010.
4.5. Clause 3 of the circular lays down the eligibility and terms and conditions, and reads thus:
3. Eligibility and terms and conditions:
A) This ‘another option for pension’ will be available to those hitherto non optee retired employees.
i) Retired from the Bank’s service on superannuation or on Voluntary retirement on or after 29th September, 1995.
ii) Retired from the Bank’s service on account of VRS under special scheme on or after 29 th September, 1995 after rendering a minimum of 15 years service.
iii) Died while in service of the Bank on or after 29th September, 1995 (families of the deceased employees may opt for getting family pension).
All of the above retired employees/families of the deceased employees who want to opt for pension now will have to pay 156% of what they received on retirement/death on account of the Bank’s contribution to SPF and interest accrued thereon being his/her share of 30% initial funding gap.
4.6. Mullick, on 23 rd August, 2010, sought to exercise the option under the circular and filled the form. On 5th October, 2010, the General Manager (Staff Pension) of the Bank returned the application stating that employees who had left the service by opting for voluntary retirement/compulsory retirement/resignation are not eligible to opt for pension.
1650 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
4.7. On 24th September, 2012, through his advocate, Mullick made a representation to the Bank requesting for reconsideration of his case to opt for pension.
4.8. Having received no response, Mullick filed a writ petition before the High Court inter alia praying for a writ of mandamus against the Bank and its officers [respondents 2 to 4 in the connected appeal] to extend the benefit of pension to him.
4.9. Before the writ court, Mullick advanced two-fold submissions: first, he submitted that the “resignation letter” submitted by an employee who has qualified the criteria enabling him to pensionary benefits is liable to be treated as “retirement from service”, thereby enabling him to get the said benefit. In support of the same, reliance was placed on the decisions of this Court in Bank of Baroda v. S.K. Kool (dead) Through Legal Representatives8 and Shashikala Devi v. Central Bank of India 9; and secondly, he relied upon Regulation 14 of the 1995 Regulations and asserted that he was entitled to pension as he had put in qualifying length of service in terms thereof. For facility of reference, Regulation 14 is reproduced below:
14. Qualifying Service - Subject to the other conditions contained in these regulations, an employee who has rendered a minimum of ten years of service in the Bank on the date of his retirement or the date on which he is deemed to have retired shall qualify for pension.
4.10. In contrast, the Bank asserted that Mullick was ineligible for the claimed benefits in view of Regulation 22 of the 1995 Regulations which disqualified an employee resigning from service to grant of pension. Regulation 22 reads as follows:
22. Forfeiture of service - (1) Resignation or dismissal or removal or termination of an employee from the service of the Bank shall entail forfeiture of his entire past service and consequently shall not qualify for pensionary benefits;
8 (2014) 2 SCC 715
9 (2014) 16 SCC 260
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1651United Bank of India (Now Punjab National Bank) v. Swapan Kumar Mullick & Ors.
4.11. The Single Judge, upon considering the rival contentions, formulated the following issue:
Whether the petitioner’s claim for pension becomes barred simply because he had submitted his “resignation” from service instead of seeking “retirement”?
4.12. Several decisions were cited before the Single Judge who, after analysing the same, held that Mullick’s case was squarely covered by the decision in Shashikala Devi (supra). The Court noted that Mullick had served the Bank for 36 years (which was far in excess of the qualifying service of 10 years for grant of pension), had no pending disciplinary proceedings, and had resigned due to mental depression. In such state of mind, the use of the term ‘resignation’ by Mullick instead of ‘retirement’ should not deprive him of pensionary benefits to which he was otherwise entitled.
4.13. Consequent upon such findings, the Single Judge of the High Court, on 1st April, 2016, held that Mullick was entitled to opt for pension. The writ petition was allowed with direction to the Bank to extend the benefit of pension to Mullick and pay him his admissible dues within 6 months of the order.
4.14. Against the judgment of the Single Judge, the Bank filed an intra-court appeal 10 before a Division Bench of the High Court. Impugned Order
5. The Division Bench also referred to Shashikala Devi (supra) and summarised the legal principle propounded therein: if an employee resigns shortly before superannuation, with an unblemished service record, and does not expressly waive the right to pension, a presumption arises that the employee did not intend to forfeit pension. Furthermore, such resignation should be treated as voluntary retirement if the employee has rendered the qualifying years of service.
6. Thereafter, the Division Bench noted that if circumstances surrounding Mullick’s case were covered by those referred to in Shashikala Devi (supra), then he should be given the benefit thereunder. Acknowledging the absence of any factual finding by the Single 10 F.M.A. 4412 of 2016 1652 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Judge on this aspect, as no arguments in this regard were made, the Division Bench set aside the order of the Single Judge and ordered for a decision on Mullick’s case by an appropriate authority in view of the circular dated 30th June, 2015 of the IBA suggesting that the banks, who were parties to the bipartite settlement dated 10 th April, 2002/27th May, 2002, might consider amendments to Regulation 22 of the Bank Employees (Pension) Regulations, 1995 as far as workmen employees are concerned. According to the Division Bench, the main thrust of the circular dated 30 th June, 2015 was that the operation of Regulation 22 may not divest the employees who had rendered qualifying service of past service and their entitlement to pension. The resultant directions given by the Division Bench, premised on such reasoning, have been noted above.
prOceedIngs beFOre ThIs cOurT
7. After notice was issued in the lead appeal, interim applications for intervention/impleadment were filed by several parties, which were allowed. The connected appeal, which is in the nature of a cross-appeal, was also filed by Mullick. Accordingly, we have heard the submissions advanced on behalf of the Bank, Mullick and the intervenors. submIssIOns On behAlF OF The bAnk /AppellAnT In The leAd AppeAl
8. The Division Bench has given a direction to ‘consider’ an amendment to Regulation 22 of the 1995 Regulations. Though it might seem to be innocuous, such a direction in effect is in the nature of a mandate, and such a mandate is in the teeth of several decisions of this Court.
9. Mullick had resigned, and not retired, from service in 2006. He had not opted for pension under the 1995 Regulations but opted for provident fund. Further, all terminal benefits payable to Mullick were paid to him soon after his resignation, in 2006 itself. Mullick, not having opted for pension and not having retired from the Bank’s service cannot, as a matter of any legal or statutory right, claim pensionary benefits under the 1995 Regulations.
10. In its decision in LIC v. Shree Lal Meena11, this Court considered the difference between ‘resignation’ and ‘retirement’. Paragraph 26 of
11 (2019) 4 SCC 479
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1653United Bank of India (Now Punjab National Bank) v. Swapan Kumar Mullick & Ors.
the decision was referred for the proposition that when the legislature extends the application of beneficial legislation to a certain class, its application cannot be extended to classes which are not included.
11. Further, the impugned order is also contrary to the law laid down in M.R. Prabhakar v. Canara Bank12 and BSES Yamuna Power Ltd. v. Ghanshyam Chand Sharma13, which followed the dictum in Shree Lal Meena (supra).
12. Next, the decision of this Court in S.K. Kool (supra) was erroneously relied upon by the High Court, since the issue there did not concern resignation of an employee, who is not a pension optee. The issue was related to interplay of punishment of removal from service with superannuation benefit, i.e., pension and/or provident fund and gratuity, as would be due otherwise and without disqualification from future employment. Thus, such decision is clearly distinguishable on facts.
13. Further, in S.K. Kool (supra), this Court held that an employee, upon whom the punishment of removal with superannuation benefit is imposed, would also be entitled to pension. Hence, the letter/circular of the IBA dated 30th June, 2015 - which made a suggestion to the banks to amend regulation 22 in terms of the decision in S.K. Kool (supra) – did not relate to a case where an employee has tendered resignation and particularly when he is not a pension optee.
14. Even otherwise, Mullick did not challenge any of the provisions of the regulations or the settlement. Significantly, a challenge to regulation 22 of the UCO Bank (Employees’) Pension Regulations, 1995, which is a pari materia provision followed by all nationalized banks, has been rejected by this Court in UCO Bank & Ors. v. Sanwar Mal14.
15. During the pendency of these appeals, a 12 th bipartite settlement dated 3rd March, 2024 has been signed between the management of various banks represented through the IBA and various Workmen Unions at the industry level. In terms of clause 37 thereof, employees who resigned from service have been given an option to opt for pension under the 1995 Regulations on the terms and conditions
12 (2012) 9 SCC 671
13 (2020) 3 SCC 346
14 (2004) 4 SCC 412
1654 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports mentioned therein; however, Mullick did not exercise an option in terms thereof.
16. Resting on the aforesaid submissions, it has been prayed that the lead appeal be allowed by setting aside the impugned order and the connected appeal dismissed.
submIssIOns On behAlF OF mullIck/AppellAnT In The cOnnecTed AppeAl
17. Regulation 22 of the 1995 Regulations is violative of Articles 14 to 16 of the Constitution of India. Although a challenge to the relevant regulation was not made before the High Court, the same is now sought to be challenged in the connected appeal.
18. Regulation 22 classifies employees together for the purpose of denial of pension in violation of Article 14. The classification of employees who have resigned with delinquent employees who have been punished/terminated/removed would be improper. An employee who has resigned would resemble an employee who has availed voluntary retirement under Regulation 29; and, thus, for the purpose of pension, he must be classified with an employee who has availed voluntary retirement, especially when the former has completed 20 years of qualifying service.
19. The decision in Sanwar Mal (supra) is in ignorance of the Constitution Bench decision of this Court in State of West Bengal v. Anwar Ali Sarkar 15. Further, Shree Lal Meena (supra) only referred to Sanwar Mal (supra) and did not consider Regulation 22 independently.
20. This Court’s decision in Shashikala Devi (supra), which differentiated between resignation simplicitor and resignation on health grounds, was not at all considered in Shree Lal Meena (supra).
21. The relevant paragraph from Shashikala Devi (supra), which was cited, reads thus:
9. The High Court, as seen earlier, has taken the view that the letter was one of resignation that resulted in the forfeiture of past service under Regulation 22 of the Regulations. The High Court appears to have been impressed by the use of the word ‘resignation’
15 (1952) 1 SCC 1
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1655United Bank of India (Now Punjab National Bank) v. Swapan Kumar Mullick & Ors.
in the employee’s letter dated 8-10-2007. The use of the expression ‘resignation’, however, is not, in our opinion, conclusive. That is, in our opinion, so even when this Court has always maintained a clear distinction between ‘resignation’ and ‘voluntary retirement’. Whether or not a given communication is a letter of resignation simpliciter or can as well be treated to be a request for voluntary retirement will always depend upon the facts and circumstances of each case and the provisions of the rules applicable.
22. Accordingly, based on the aforesaid submissions and referring to the reasons assigned by the Single Judge to allow Mullick’s writ petition, it was prayed that the judgment of the Single Judge be restored upon reversal of the impugned order.
submIssIOns On behAlF OF The InTervenOrs
23. The intervenors, while supporting the claim of Mullick, contended that the benefit of pension must be extended to employees who have resigned.
24. There is no provision for workmen to retire from banks before attaining the age of superannuation. Most banks stipulate a minimum of 25 to 30 years in the Officers’ Service Regulations, 1979, to retire. Thus, the officers were compelled to resign and not retire.
25. The Bipartite Settlement dated 29 th October 1993 triggered the pension scheme by notification of the 1995 Regulations. While the settlement does not provide for forfeiture of service in case of resignation, Regulation 22 provided for forfeiture of service even for resignation. Regulation 22 cannot be used to take away the benefit of pension when an employee is otherwise entitled to it.
26. There exists no difference between payment of bank’s contribution of provident fund to those retired on superannuation/voluntary retirement and resignation.
27. Reliance was placed on a letter dated 1st October, 2001 issued by the IBA to show that voluntary retirement was not available to staff under the bipartite settlement, prior to introduction of the pension scheme. Even after the introduction of pension scheme, only those who had opted for pension could retire voluntarily. Thus, the workmen and 1656 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports officers were compelled to resign, instead of retire. Imposition of such conditions are unconscionable and in the teeth of the decision of this Court in Delhi Transport Corporation v. D.T.C. Mazdoor Congress16.
28. Denial of pension to a particular group of employees who resigned is discriminatory and violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. Any employee who has rendered the qualifying period of service must be held entitled to opt for pension.
29. The bipartite settlement grants the benefit of pension to those employees who sought voluntary retirement but does not consider the employees who have resigned and, in that regard, it would be violative of this Court’s decision in D.S. Nakara v. Union of India17.
30. The bipartite settlement scheme dated 8 th March, 2024, enjoins employees who resigned between 1 st January, 1980 and 27 th April, 2010. However, it does not stipulate minimum years of service. Despite that, banks have refused pension to employees who have served less than 20 years of service, as stipulated under regulation 29.
31. In terms of this Court’s decision in S.K. Kool (supra), the benefit of pension was extended even to delinquent employees, whose services were terminated on account of disciplinary action. It would be discriminatory to allow pension benefits to employees who committed fraud on the employer-bank but to disallow employees who resigned. This would result in an anomalous situation and would be arbitrary and violative of Articles 12, 14, 16 and 21.
32. Lastly, since the terms of employment of these employees are contractual in nature, the conditions imposed which are contrary to the provisions of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 are unsustainable in law. The settlement does not specifically disentitle those who resigned from its application and thus the banks cannot disallow the benefit to such employees who have resigned.
The Issue
33. The issue that arises for determination is: whether an employee resigning from service citing mental depression, after having served 16 (1991) Supp. 1 SCC 600
17 (1983) 1 SCC 305
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1657United Bank of India (Now Punjab National Bank) v. Swapan Kumar Mullick & Ors.
his employer much in excess of the period stipulated to qualify for being entitled to pension, forfeits his right to opt for pension in terms of a specific provision in the Pension Regulations for all times to come, or, in view of pension being a social welfare measure for employees in the winter years of their life, adopting a beneficial approach is permissible and/or called for?
AnAlysIs And reAsOns
34. Multiple authorities have been cited on either side to persuade us to answer the question in their favour. A close look at each of the relevant decisions has to be taken to ascertain whether the issue we are concerned with is res integra.
35. In Reserve Bank of India v. Cecil Dennis Solomon18, the employees of the Reserve Bank of India 19 had tendered their resignations in 1988 and were getting superannuation benefits under the provident fund contributory provisions and gratuity schemes. Subsequently, the RBI Pension Regulations, 1990 were framed. The employees, who had tendered resignation in 1988, claimed that they were entitled to pension under these new Pension Regulations and moved the concerned high court for relief whereupon it was held that RBI was legally bound to grant pension to such employees. RBI then challenged the decision of the high court and this Court held that as the employees had tendered resignation, which was different from voluntary retirement, they were not entitled to pension under the Pension Regulations.
36. While allowing the appeal of RBI, a coordinate Bench in Cecil Dennis Solomon (supra) proceeded to make the following pertinent observations:
1 0 . I n s e r v i c e j u r i s p r u d e n c e , t h e e x p r e s s i o n s “superannuation”, “voluntary retirement”, “compulsory retirement” and “resignation” convey different connotations. Voluntary retirement and resignation involve voluntary acts on the part of the employee to leave service. Though both involve voluntary acts, they operate differently. One of the
18 (2004) 9 SCC 461
19 RBI
1658 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports basic distinctions is that in case of resignation it can be tendered at any time, but in the case of voluntary retirement, it can only be sought for after rendering prescribed period of qualifying service. Other fundamental distinction is that in case of the former, normally retiral benefits are denied but in case of the latter, the same is not denied. In case of the former, permission or notice is not mandated, while in case of the latter, permission of the employer concerned is a requisite condition. Though resignation is a bilateral concept, and becomes effective on acceptance by the competent authority, yet the general rule can be displaced by express provisions to the contrary. ...
37. In Sanwar Mal (supra), Sanwar Mal - who was initially appointed in UCO Bank on 29th December, 1959 and was thereafter promoted to Class III post in 1980 - resigned from the service of UCO Bank after giving one month’s notice on 25 th February, 1988. Thereafter, the UCO Bank (Employees’) Pension Regulations, 1995 were framed and Sanwar Mal opted for the pension scheme under such regulations. UCO Bank declined to accept his option to admit him into the pension scheme. Sanwar Mal filed a suit for a declaration that he was entitled to pension under the Pension Regulations and for a mandatory injunction directing UCO Bank to make payment of arrears of pension along with interest. The suit was decreed and the decree was affirmed in first appeal and, thereafter, by the relevant high court in second appeal. UCO Bank carried an appeal to this Court, which was allowed and the judgment of the high court set aside. This Court differentiated the expressions “resignation” from “voluntary retirement” by ruling as follows:
9. ... The words “resignation” and “retirement” carry different meanings in common parlance. An employee can resign at any point of time, even on the second day of his appointment but in the case of retirement he retires only after attaining the age of superannuation or in the case of voluntary retirement on completion of qualifying service. The effect of resignation and retirement to the extent that there is severance of employment (sic is the same) but in service jurisprudence both the expressions are understood differently. Under the Regulations, the expressions “resignation” and “retirement” have been employed for [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1659United Bank of India (Now Punjab National Bank) v. Swapan Kumar Mullick & Ors.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.