Baljinder Kumar @ Kala v. State of Punjab
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 856; [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1070
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sanjay Karol, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 16 Jul 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 2688/2024
- Sections
- 106, 34, 27, 308, 325, 293, 302
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1070 : 2025 INSC 856 Baljinder Kumar @ Kala v.
State of Punjab (Criminal Appeal No(s). 2688-2689 of 2024)
16 July 2025 [Vikram Nath,* Sanjay Karol and Sandeep Mehta, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the courts below erred in convicting the appellant for offences u/ss.302, 308 and 325, Penal Code, 1860 and imposing death sentence on him, when the prosecution had failed to prove his guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
Headnotes† Evidence – Charges not proved beyond reasonable doubt – Courts below strongly relying upon the testimonies of three witnesses PW1 (the complainant), PW2 (alleged eyewitness) and PW17 (injured child witness), convicted the appellant for the murder of his wife, two children and sister-in-law and imposed death sentence – Sustainability:
Held: Impugned judgment as well as the judgment of the Trial Court are quashed and set aside – In order to record conviction based on ocular evidence, the testimonies have to be completely credible and trustworthy – However, in the present case, there are major contradictions and embellishments in the testimonies of key prosecution witnesses accompanied by glaring investigative defects/ lapses leading to gaps in the evidentiary chain – Nothing to link the appellant to the scene of the crime – Prosecution failed to establish the charges beyond reasonable doubt – Appellant acquitted – Penal Code, 1860 – ss.302, 308 and 325. [Paras 38, 41, 43, 44] Evidence Act, 1872 – s.106 – Adverse inference, when cannot be drawn – Penal Code, 1860 – ss.302, 308 and 325 – Appellant-accused was convicted for the murder of his wife, two children and sister-in-law – High Court drew adverse inference against the accused as regards his silence and absence of any alternative explanation about the injuries sustained by him on the day of the incident which led him to * Author [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1071Baljinder Kumar @ Kala v. State of Punjab getting admitted in the hospital later on the same day causing consequent amputation of his left arm, and presumed that the said injuries were a result of the resistance that he must have faced during the commission of the crime earlier in the day – Sustainability:
Held: Prosecution has not been able to establish the presence of accused at the site of crime through direct, circumstantial, oral or forensic evidence thus, taking recourse to s.106 and employing it against the accused in a detrimental manner in the absence of any foundational facts, is unwarranted – Neither PW1 nor PW2, in their statement stated anything about the accused of having suffered an arm injury while he was allegedly spotted at the crime scene – Therefore, no opportunity arises to shift the burden of proof on the appellant so as to reasonably explain his injury and thereby, no adverse inference can be drawn. [Para 39] Evidence – Contradictions in testimonies, material discrepancies – Testimonies not to be relied upon – Appellantaccused was convicted for the murder of his wife, two children and sister-in-law, relying upon the testimonies of three witnesses PW1 (the complainant), PW2 (alleged eyewitness) and PW17 (injured child witness):
Held: Only such omissions which amount to contradiction in material particulars can be used to discredit the testimony of the witness – Material discrepancies are those which are not normal and not expected of a normal person – When witness testimonies exhibit significant contradictions between their initial statements and trial depositions, they cannot be relied upon unless independently corroborated – In the present case, the contradictions in prosecution witnesses’ testimonies are major ones and carve a gaping hole in the prosecution story altogether – The internal inconsistencies and lack of corroboration cast serious doubts and snatch away the degree of accuracy that is to be attained while determining the culpability of an accused in cases of murder – There are obvious inconsistencies in the depositions of the main witnesses indicating deliberate embellishment and coaching, rendering these testimonies unreliable – Therefore, no credence can be lent to the testimonies of PW1 and PW2 and their account of being “eyewitness” to the incident or having seen the accused is discarded – Statements of PW1 and PW2 inspire no confidence and their presence at the scene of occurrence is disbelieved – Further, the testimony of 1072 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports PW17 (child witness) also cannot be considered as incriminating against the appellant for the lack of having witnessed the actual incident. [Paras 30-34] Evidence – Motive – Absence of – Appellant-accused was convicted for the murder of his wife, two children and sisterin-law due to an alleged monetary dispute:
Held: When there is nothing to link the appellant to the scene of the crime, an alleged monetary dispute between the parties shall not by itself aid the prosecution case enough to frame the accused for a charge of murder on multiple counts – Trial Court held that dacoity or commission of offence by a stranger party has to be ruled out due to the gruesome nature of the crime – However, merely lack of an alternative plausible explanation to the incident is not enough evidence in itself to send a man to the gallows, whose guilt otherwise remains unestablished. [Para 38] Evidence – Alleged recoveries – Evidentiary value, questionable – Failure to conclusively link material objects to the crime:
Held: Neither the arrest of the accused nor the alleged recovery of the blood-stained clothes and the weapon (purportedly based on the disclosure statement of the accused) is supported by any independent witness – Though the recovery may not be wholly discarded due to the lack of a supporting witness, however, it becomes highly questionable, especially with the factum of long delay of two months in the discovery being effected – Furthermore, the investigating agency took minimum pains to link the discovered articles to the incident or the deceased persons through forensic evidence or otherwise. [Paras 36, 37] Judicial Deprecation – Shoddy investigation; poorly conducted trial – Appellant-accused was convicted for the murder of his wife, two children and sister-in-law and was sentenced to death by the Trial Court holding the case to be rarest of rare – High Court upheld the conviction and confirmed the death sentence – Appellant has undergone incarceration for more than eleven years – Acquitted by Supreme Court holding that the prosecution has failed to establish the charges beyond reasonable doubt – Approach of investigating agencies and courts below, deprecated – Penal Code, 1860 – ss.302, 308 and 325. [Para 1] [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1073Baljinder Kumar @ Kala v. State of Punjab Case Law Cited Narayan Chetanram Chaudhary & Anr. v. State of Maharashtra [2000] Supp. 3 SCR 104 : (2000) 8 SCC 457; State of Himachal Pradesh v. Lekh Raj [1999] Supp. 4 SCR 286 : (2000) 1 SCC 247; State of Rajasthan v. Kalki & Anr. [1981] 3 SCR 504 : (1981) 2 SCC 752; Vadivelu Thevar v. State of Madras [1957] 1 SCR 981 : AIR 1957 SC 614 – referred to.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860.
List of Keywords Murder; Murder of four members of a family; Wife; Two children; Sister-in-law; Guilt of accused not proved beyond a reasonable doubt; Charges not proved beyond reasonable doubt; Presence of accused at the site of crime not established; Gaps in the evidentiary chain; Major contradictions and embellishments in the testimonies of key prosecution witnesses; Glaring investigative defects/lapses; Material discrepancies in testimonies; Testimonies not to be relied upon; Omissions; Contradiction in material particulars; Different versions of the same set of events; Accused not linked to the scene of the crime; Silence surrounding the injuries sustained by accused; On the day of the incident; Amputation of left arm; No alternative explanation about the injuries sustained; No adverse inference can be drawn; Burden of proof not shifted on the accused; Absence of motive; Alleged motive; Alleged monetary dispute; Conviction based on ocular evidence; Alleged eyewitness; Child witness; Death sentence; Inconsistencies and lack of corroboration; Lack of an alternative plausible explanation; Alleged recoveries; Evidentiary value questionable; Alleged recovery of the blood-stained clothes and the weapon not supported by independent witness; Alleged weapon of offence; Shoddy investigation; Poorly conducted trial; Judicial deprecation; Accused acquitted; Headline in the local papers; Sensation; Pressure on the investigating agencies to find the culprit. Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No(s). 2688-2689 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 04.03.2024 by the High Court of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh in MRC No. 1 of 2020 in CRAD No. 323 of 2020 1074 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Dama Seshadri Naidu, Sr. Adv., Ms. Sakshi Jain, Yash S. Vijay, Deepak Sharma, Ms. Kms Sivani, Shikhar Aggarwal.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Siddhant Sharma, Bhuvnesh, Prafull Bhardwaj.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Vikram Nath, J.
1. One can fairly imagine the amplitude of havoc that would wreak loose in a quiet village which on one fine morning wakes up to the news of four members of a family dead, including two lives yet to even reach the incipient age of five years, and with two other family members grievously injured. To add to the horror, the primary suspect in the entire incident is the father of the deceased children. At least, that is what the alleged eyewitnesses’ account points towards. It is but natural that the case garners enough sensation in no time to become a headline in the local papers and the pressure on the investigating agencies is enormous to find the culprit. The breakdown of the legal system becomes apparent when such haste to lay a finger of blame on somebody leads to a shoddy investigation and a poorly conducted trial. The result is a loosely tied prosecution case with glaring loopholes all across and yet the Courts’ enthusiasm to deliver justice in such a heinous crime ensures that the accused person ends up on the death row, albeit without sufficient evidence. This is precisely the misery which the instant case entails.
2. The present appeals have been preferred by the accused-appellant assailing the judgment and order dated 04.03.2024 passed by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana in MRC No. 1 of 2020 and CRA-D No. 323 of 2020. The High Court, vide the impugned order, has upheld the conviction and confirmed the sentence of death imposed on the appellant by the Additional Sessions Judge, Kapurthala, on 29.02.2020 in Case No. SC/64/2014, under Sections 302, 308 and 325 of the Indian Penal Code, 18601 .
1 IPC, hereinafter.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1075Baljinder Kumar @ Kala v. State of Punjab Factual Background –
3. The case of the prosecution is that in the early morning of 29.11.2013, PW1–Vijay Kumar (“the complainant”) saw the appellant outside his mother’s (PW2–Manjit Kaur) house armed with a datar, wherein the appellant told the complainant that “he has finished what he had started”, and fled away with 3-4 unidentified persons who were armed with a gandasi and rods. On entering PW2’s house, the complainant found his following relatives in injured condition – (i) Seema Rani aged 26 years (sister of PW1; wife of the appellant), (ii) Reena Rani aged 28 years (sister of PW1; sister-in-law of the appellant),
(iii) Harry aged 5 years (son of Seema Rani from her first marriage; adopted son of Reena Rani; step-son of the appellant), (iv) Sumani Kumari aged 3-4 years (daughter born out of the wedlock between Seema Rani and the appellant), (v) Harsh aged 1.5-2 years (son born out of the wedlock between Seema Rani and the appellant), and (vi) Om Prakash @ Tari aged 18 years (brother of PW1). PW1 called an ambulance, and all the six injured persons were taken to the hospital where Seema Rani, Reena Rani, Sumani Kumari and Harsh were declared brought dead while Harry and Om Prakash @ Tari were admitted at the hospital.
4. The FIR was registered at 11.15 a.m. on 29.11.2013 itself under Sections 302, 323 and 34 of the IPC at Police Station Satnampura, Kapurthala by S.I. Karnail Singh (‘Investigating Officer/IO’) on receiving a telephonic message from the Civil Hospital, Phagwara. On 15.02.2014, on receipt of opinion from the doctor regarding nature of injuries on the person of injured Om Prakash and Harry, the offence was enhanced under Sections 308 and 325 IPC, while offence under Section 34 of IPC was reduced. The appellant was arrested subsequently on 30.01.2014 post his discharge from the hospital since he was also undergoing treatment of his arm since the date of incident.
5. After completion of the investigation, challan was presented against the appellant above to face trial under Sections 302, 308, 325 and 323 of the IPC. The case was committed to the Sessions Court, vide order dated 21.05.2014, wherein the accused pleaded not guilty and claimed trial. During the course of prosecution evidence, the case was transferred to the Court of Additional Sessions Judge, Kapurthala, wherein it was heard and decided as Case No. SC/64/2014. 1076 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
6. The motive attributed by the prosecution to the appellant is that the appellant’s sister, one Rekha Rani was married to one Haria – however, due to matrimonial dispute between the parties, the marriage was dissolved by divorce in presence of the panchayat wherein Haria returned all the dowry articles and also undertook to pay Rs. 35,000/- as maintenance to Rekha Rani. PW2–Manjit Kaur (mother-in-law of the appellant) stood as guarantor for Haria for returning the amount, and when such amount was not paid, it led to constant fights between the appellant and his wife Seema Rani. The fight had escalated to such an extent where the appellant had threatened to kill his wife and children if the money was not paid, and it also led to Seema Rani along with her children coming to her maternal home on 17.11.2013 after she was beaten by the accused.
7. While this was the motive ascribed, the primary evidence considered against the appellant by the Courts below was the testimonies of PW1/ complainant, PW2 who claims to be an eyewitness and PW17 who is an injured child witness. Besides the testimonies, there were also alleged discoveries of blood-stained clothes, a gandasi and a bicycle at the behest of the appellant based on his disclosure statement dated 01.02.2014, which led to the prosecution establishing its case against the accused-appellant.
Trial Court’s findings –
8. The prosecution, in order to substantiate its case before the Trial Court, examined 22 prosecution witnesses while the accused examined no witness in defence in spite of availing sufficient opportunities. The lead witnesses presented by the prosecution other than the medical officers and members of the investigation team included –
(i) PW1–Vijay Kumar (complainant); (ii) PW2–Manjit Kaur (claims to be eyewitness); and, (iii) PW17–Harry (injured child witness). Other than this, PW23–Om Prakash, who was an injured witness, was presented before the Court but was not examined as a witness on oath on account of being found mentally unfit and thereby, not a competent witness.
9. In order to draw a verdict about the conviction of the accused, the Trial Court, after hearing the rival contentions raised by the respective counsels, considered the following arguments and formed its reasoning on the varied grounds which are summarized as below – [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1077Baljinder Kumar @ Kala v. State of Punjab A. Delay in lodging FIR: The incident is alleged to have taken place at about 6 a.m. on 29.11.2013 and the FIR was lodged on the same day at around 11 a.m. The Trial Court held that naturally, the first effort of the complainant was to save the life of his six injured family members. As such, arranging the ambulance and taking them to the hospital consumed a lot of time and FIR cannot be said to be delayed in such circumstances. B. No independent witness: The defence counsel had argued that PW1–Vijay Kumar, PW2–Manjit Kaur and PW17–Harry are close relatives of the deceased persons and interested witnesses, and since no independent witness of the locality has been examined, thus their testimony cannot be relied upon. The Trial Court held that since the incident had taken place in the house of PW2–Manjit Kaur and that too in the early hours of the morning, therefore, she is the most natural and best witness. Further, PW17–Harry is a witness who sustained injuries during the occurrence and his presence at the place cannot be denied, therefore, his evidence cannot be discarded solely on the ground of being a close relative.
C. Presence of PW2–Manjit Kaur at the spot: Manjit Kaur, who claims to be an eyewitness to the incident, stated that after witnessing the occurrence, she managed to slip away outside the house and concealed herself behind the bushes out of fear and came back half an hour later. The defence counsel had contended that such a conduct was highly improbable and unnatural for a mother to leave her children at the mercy of the killer while slipping away from the place of occurrence and makes her presence at the spot extremely doubtful. The Trial Court observed that the reflex of every human being in a dangerous situation varies and it is quite natural that, in order to save herself from the attack, Manjit Kaur managed to escape from the house. Further, it was held that her account that she was about to leave for Gurudwara, in accordance with her daily ritual, was corroborated by PW17–Harry who had the same impression that his grandmother had left for Gurudwara by that hour.
D. Disclosure statement recorded and recovery effected without any independent witness: The defence counsel had 1078 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports submitted that there was no independent witness present at the time of recording of disclosure statement of the accused, nor at the time of effecting recovery of weapon. The Trial Court held that Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 2 does not lay down that the statement made to police official should always be in presence of independent witnesses. Thus, in such matters, Court seeks corroboration from independent witnesses as a matter of caution and not as a matter of rule. It was held that the recovery of blood-stained clothes of the accused finds corroboration from the testimony of PW2–Manjit Kaur, who had categorically stated that the accused, at the time of occurrence, was wearing black shirt and blue pajama and the same were recovered.
E. Discrepancies in the statement of other PWs about presence of PW2 at the spot and presence of private persons other than the accused: The Trial Court held that the contradictions pointed out by the defence counsel are minor in nature, and the two eyewitnesses and one injured child witness have stood the test of scrutiny despite the lengthy cross-examination. It was observed that such minor contradictions do not go to the root of the prosecution case.
F. Defence of accused’s arm being amputated: The defence counsel had argued that the left arm of the accused has been amputated and, in such a condition, it would have been impossible for the accused to carry out murder of four persons and cause injuries to two others with one hand using gandasi. However, PW1, during his cross-examination, had stated that the accused’s arm had been amputated after the alleged occurrence. This was also supplemented by the statement of PW15–Dr. Ramesh Chander who had attended to the accused at Civil Hospital, Phagwara. Further, no suggestion whatsoever, nor any evidence has been adduced by the accused to submit that his arm was amputated prior to the occurrence. Therefore, this argument of the defence also fell flat.
G. Motive: The Trial Court held that the motive has been established amply in shape of testimony of PW18–Satnam Singh (Sarpanch) 2 Evidence Act [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1079Baljinder Kumar @ Kala v. State of Punjab who had stated about the panchayati divorce between the sister of the accused and Haria and also the fact that PW2–Manjit Kaur stood as a guarantor towards the promise of payment of Rs. 35,000/-. Thus, it was clear that the appellant was nourishing a grudge against Manjit Kaur and her family members.
H. Plea of alibi: It was observed by the Trial Court that the accused was admitted to Civil Hospital, Phagwara at about 7 p.m. on 29.11.2013, i.e. the day of the incident due to some accidental injuries, whereas the occurrence had taken place at about 6 a.m. on the same day, i.e. more than twelve hours prior to him being admitted in the hospital. Therefore, the plea of alibi merely on this ground is nothing but a bald assertion and shall not succeed as the accused has failed to adduce any oral or documentary evidence to support his plea.
I. Injuries/medical evidence reflect the intention to kill: The Trial Court analysed the post-mortem reports and the medical opinion of the members of Board of doctors who conducted post-mortem which led it to conclude that the injuries were caused by the accused on the vital body parts of the deceased and such injuries were sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature. Therefore, it was established that the accused caused the injuries only with the intention to brutally kill them, leaving no chance of their survival.
J. Conviction under Sections 308 and 325 of the IPC: The Trial Court considered the medical reports and the statement of Medical Officer opining that “injury no. 3, possibility of dangerous to life, could not be ruled out”, and held that from the intention of accused, while causing injuries to minor Harry, ingredients of offence under Section 308 of IPC stand proven. Additionally, with regard to the injuries meted out to Om Prakash, the Medical Officer opined that the “possibility of injury nos. 1 and 3 to be grievous in nature cannot be ruled out”. Even though the final opinion regarding the injury was not placed on record by the prosecution, the Trial Court went ahead and held that the guilt of accused for the offence punishable under Section 325 of IPC stands proved.
K. Recovery of weapon and blood-stained clothes: A gandasi, i.e. the weapon used for the commission of the crime along with 1080 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports blood-stained clothes of the accused and a cycle were allegedly recovered on the basis of the accused’s disclosure statement. The clothes and gandasi were sent for chemical analysis, and the said report stated that “The exhibits contained in the parcel A and B are stained with human blood”. The said report was not exhibited before the Trial Court, but the Court, nevertheless, took judicial notice of the same and held that the report of chemical examiner is admissible in evidence as per Section 293 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 3 . The Court went ahead to the extent of holding that the blood-stained clothes and weapon of offence leave no room for doubt to connect the accused with the commission of crime.
10. Thereby, it was held by the Trial Court that the prosecution has been able to prove guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt. As such, the accused, vide judgment dated 29.02.2020, was convicted under Section 302 of IPC on four counts (i.e. Seema Rani, Reena Rani, Harsh and Sumani Kumari) along with Sections 308 and 325 of the IPC.
11. The order of sentence against the accused was passed by the Trial Court on the same day after lunch, wherein the Court held it to be one of the rarest of rare cases and sentenced the accused to death under Section 302 IPC for committing four murders. The accused was also sentenced to pay a fine of Rs. 2,00,000/- (Rupees Two lakhs only), in default of which to undergo rigorous imprisonment for one year under Section 302 IPC, in case his death sentence is not confirmed by the High Court. Further, the accused was sentenced to undergo seven years rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 50,000/- (Rupees Fifty thousand only) under Section 308 of IPC, in default of payment of fine to further undergo ten months’ rigorous imprisonment. Similarly, under Section 325 of IPC, the accused was sentenced to undergo seven years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 50,000/- (Rupees Fifty thousand only), and in default of payment of fine, to further undergo rigorous imprisonment for ten months. All the sentences were to run consecutively in case death sentence is not confirmed. Out of the amount of fine imposed, 2/3rd of the amount was to be paid as compensation to the victim 3 Cr.P.C.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1081Baljinder Kumar @ Kala v. State of Punjab PW2–Manjit Kaur as well as injured persons namely Harry and Om Prakash, in equal proportions.
12. The elemental factors considered by the Trial Court while categorizing the instant case in the “rarest of rare” category and awarding death sentence to the accused included that the crime was not committed in the heat of passion but was pre-meditated as the convict was nourishing grudge against his own family members and led to committing murder of his own wife, two children and sister-in-law. The Court also observed that if the accused could go on to take such an extreme step, he could very well be a danger to the life of complainant and PW2. It was held that the balance tilted towards the aggravating circumstances as the crime shook the society’s conscience and the convict deserves to meet the gallows. High Court’s findings –
13. The High Court, vide the impugned judgment, notes the findings of the Trial Court, details the arguments of the opposing counsels and proceeds to record its reasons for upholding the conviction. However, the High Court notes certain fallacies committed by the Trial Court, especially with regard to its analysis of the deposition of PW1–Vijay Kumar.
14. The High Court firstly noted that the site plan (Ex PW22/J) does not show that the PW1/complainant’s house is adjacent to that of his mother/PW2. Further, it was noted that the cycle repair shop of the complainant, which is where the complainant lived as per PW2’s statement, is situated 10 kilometers away from the house where the occurrence took place. Thus, it was held to be apparent that PW1–Vijay Kumar was not residing near the house in question and, therefore, it was highly improbable for him to be at the spot when the accused was coming out by holding gandasi after committing the offence. Therefore, PW1’s statement as to him having witnessed the accused while exiting the house after the incident was completely discarded by the High Court.
15. Subsequently, the High Court also observed that the manner in which the recovery of gandasi along with blood-stained clothes and the cycle had been effected after a considerable period of two months from the house of the accused does not inspire any confidence in the investigation and rather brings out glaring lapse on the part of the investigating agency.
1082 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
16. However, the High Court granted unblemished acceptance to PW2– Manjit Kaur’s statement as to her being present in the house at the relevant hour and that she was an eyewitness to the entire incident who fled away the scene out of fear of her own safety.
17. Further, with regard to the injuries sustained by the accused on the day of the incident and how the accused offered no explanation as to the cause of injuries, the High Court employed Section 106 of the Evidence Act to place reverse onus on the appellant. Failure to provide any explanation by the accused pertaining to his injuries led the Court to treat it as another reason to confirm the conviction by presuming that the said injuries were received by the accused during the assault on account of defence put up by the deceased and injured victims other than the minor children.
18. Another factor that weighed with the High Court was that the manner in which the assault was committed clearly showed that it was by a person who was keenly nursing a grudge and was not a case of robbery by unknown persons who could have easily over-powered the minor children and deceased women without inflicting injuries of such severe nature.
19. As such, the High Court held that, on co-relating the statement of PW2 and the child witness, the motive aspect and the fact that the appellant himself was admitted in the hospital later on the day of incident itself as he had suffered serious injuries, to which he has not given any plausible explanation, would go on to show that the prosecution is able to prove its case beyond any shadow of doubt regarding the involvement of the appellant.
20. The High Court also observed that the brutality of the incident is that of a diabolic act, whereby conscience of the society as a whole has been shocked. The deceased, including two children and wife of the accused-appellant himself, were done to death in the safety of their own house and, therefore, the Court held the case to fall in the rarest of rare category while confirming the death penalty. Submissions –
21. It is in the above background that the impugned judgment is being assailed before us by the accused-appellant.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1083Baljinder Kumar @ Kala v. State of Punjab
22. We have heard Mr. Dama Seshadri Naidu, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant and Mr. Siddhant Sharma, learned counsel appearing for the respondent–State of Punjab.
23. The counsel for the appellant, Mr. Naidu, has argued in length before us while adequately dealing with the evidence presented by the prosecution before the Courts below, and their submissions can be classified into five main contentions which are as follows – a) Failure of the prosecution to establish a clear motive: It has been contended that the purported financial dispute between the appellant and PW2’s family which has been attributed as the root cause of animosity and gave birth to the crime remains uncorroborated since the prosecution failed to examine Haria or the appellant’s sister, who were the principal parties to the alleged transaction.
b) Contradictions and embellishments in Prosecution Witness testimonies: It has been exhaustively argued that the testimonies of the key witnesses, i.e. PW1 and PW2 are riddled with contradictions ranging from the presence of the said witnesses to the weapon used and the existence of any accompanying accused persons. Even though, the appellant’s counsel has made pinpointed attacks and brought forth specific discrepancies, we are deliberately not elaborating the said submission at the instant juncture, as it shall be dealt with appropriately in the latter part of the judgment, while analysing the testimonies of the prosecution witnesses.
c) Deficiencies in the investigation and questionable evidentiary value of the alleged recoveries: It was submitted that the arrest as well as the recovery of weapon and clothes was not supported by any independent witness. Further, the disclosure statement being made two months after the incident and the lack of DNA or forensic evidence with regard to the recovered articles point towards investigative loopholes and inconclusive evidence on record.
d) Failure to meet the standard of proof beyond reasonable doubt: The above-mentioned deficiencies highlight the failure of the prosecution case in being able to meet the required standard of proof and legal threshold for conviction in cases of such nature.
1084 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports e) Non-applicability of the “rarest of rare” doctrine: Without prejudice to the above grounds, it was submitted that even as such, the instant case does not qualify as “rarest of rare” and, therefore, even if in arguendo, the accused is convicted, the sentence of death penalty shall be too grave and wholly unwarranted.
24. On the other hand, the counsel for the respondent–State has unequivocally supported the findings of the Courts below and submitted that the impugned judgment should not be interfered with. It was submitted that there was an eyewitness account of the complainant PW1, PW2–Manjit Kaur and the child witness Harry, and minor discrepancies in the statements of the witnesses can be overlooked, especially in view of the fact that there was a motive and the presence of injured eyewitness is irrefutable. It was submitted that the consequential recoveries of the weapon and the blood-stained clothes further strengthen the prosecution’s case, and there is no plausible reason to disbelieve the same.
Analysis –
25. Having heard the in-detail submissions and perused the material on record, we find it of utmost importance to primarily delve into the depositions of key witnesses. It is apparent that the Courts below have strongly relied upon the testimonies of three witnesses to bring home the conclusion of guilt against the accused. These three witnesses are – (i) PW1–Vijay Kumar (the complainant),
(ii) PW2–Manjit Kaur (alleged eyewitness), and (iii) PW17–Harry (injured child witness). Before we proceed ahead with verifying the inter-se corroboration amongst these testimonies, it would be relevant to reproduce the contents of FIR (which was registered at the instance of PW1) as well as the above-mentioned depositions.
Ex. PW22/B FIR No. 54/2013 at P.S. Satnampura, Phagwara registered on 29.11.2013 Statement of Vijay Kumar son of Late Daulat Ram, caste Adharmi, R/o Kot Rani, PS Satnampura, Phagwara, aged 28 years.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1085Baljinder Kumar @ Kala v. State of Punjab Stated that I am resident of above stated address. I am running a cycle repair shop at my residence. We are two brothers. My younger brother is Om Parkash @ Tari. We have two houses and have a joint family. Yesterday dated 28.11.2013 in our house situated in Dashmesh Puri my mother Manjit Kaur, my brother Om Parkash @ Tari, my sister Seema Rani and her children Harry aged 6 years, Sumani Kumari aged 3 years, Harsh 2 years and sister Reena Rani aged 28 years were sleeping in the house at night. My mother used to visit Shri Gurudwara Sahib at Dashmesh Puri daily in the morning. Sunehri Lai husband of my sister Reena Rani is living abroad since two years due to this reason she is living with us. My sister Seema Rani wife of Baljinder Kumar @ Kala R/o village Gurray, PS Guraya whose marriage was solemnized since six years ago, also living with us from 15 to 20 days alongwith her children due to disputes with her husband. On dated 14.11.2013 Baljinder Kumar @ Kala came our house and threatened all of us that if we did not paid Rs.35,000/- to him he would kill his children and his wife. Today at about 6.00 a.m. I alongwith my wife went to our another house to drink tea from my mother and when we reached at our house near the gate in a gali we saw that Baljinder Singh @ Kala armed with Datar came out from our house and asked us upon seeing that he would told us to face consequences for not giving Rs.35,000/- to him and he did the same what he had said and he fleed away from the spot. We had seen three/ four unidentified persons armed with Gandasis and Rods ran away alongwith him towards cremation ground and when we entered our house and saw that both of my sisters Seema Rani and Reena Rani, my brother Om Parkash @ Tari and three children Harry, Sumani Kumari and Harsh smeared with blood. The blood was scattered in the room here and there. Then I called Ambulance No. 108 for help and we went all of them to Civil Hospital Phagwara, there doctor Sahib declared my sister Seema Rani, Reena Rani, Children Sumani Kumari and Harsh dead. My brother Om Parkash @ Tari and Harry being injured was admitted to the hospital for treatment. All the 1086 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports offence occurred by Baljinder Kumar @ Kala son of Kaila Ram residence of village Gurray PS Guraya alongwith unidentified persons armed with weapons with my family. Action be taken against them. Statement was recorded, heard being correct.
Sd/- Vijay Kumar, Attested by Sd/- Karnail Singh SHO PS Satnampura dated 29.11.2013.
[Emphasis is mine] Examination-in-chief and cross-examination of PW1 – Vijay Kumar PW-1 on SA: Vijay Kumar son of Late Daulat Ram son of Ram Kishan, aged 28 years, Cycle repair shop, resident of village Kot Rani, P.S. Satnampura, Phagwara District Kapurthala.
I am running a cycle repair shop at Kot Rani. We are two brothers. The name of my younger brother is Om Parkash @ Tari. We are having two houses with joint family. One of our house is in village Kot Rani and the second house is situated in Mohalla Deshmesh Puri adjoining to Kot Rani. We have two sisters namely Reena Rani and Seema Rani.
My sister Reena Rani has been residing with us for the last two years and her husband is residing abroad. My sister Seema Rani was married with accused present in the Court since the last about six years. She was having three children namely Sumani Kumari, Harsh and Harry.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.