S.C. Garg v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 493; [2025] 5 S.C.R. 627
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Pankaj Mithal, Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra
- Decided
- 15 Apr 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 438/2018
- Sections
- 482, 420, 138, 156, 141(1), 11, 10, 3, 141, 17, 156(3), 200
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 627 : 2025 INSC 493 S.C. Garg v.
State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr.
(Criminal Appeal No. 438 of 2018)
16 April 2025 [Pankaj Mithal and Prashant Kumar Mishra,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration The appellant’s petition u/s.482 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 seeking quashment of Criminal Case No. 7489 of 2002 pending on the file of Chief Judicial Magistrate for offences u/s.420 of the Penal Code, 1860 was dismissed by the High Court. Headnotes† Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.482 – Negotiable Instrument Act, 1881 – s.138 – Penal Code, 1860 – s.420 – The appellant’s company filed a complaint u/s.138 of the NI Act against ID Packaging and respondent no.2 in relation to the 07 dishonored cheques – The trial Court convicted respondent no.2 – Respondent no.2 preferred criminal revision – The High Court disposed of criminal revision as well as two other proceedings between the parties basis compromise between them – When 138 NI Act proceedings were pending between the parties, respondent no.2 had moved an application u/s.156 (3) CrPC seeking registration of an FIR against appellant and company inter alia alleging that despite payment of amount involved in 07 dishonoured cheques, by way of separate demand drafts, appellant again presented 11 cheques and fraudulently realised the amount from 04 out of 11 cheques thereby cheating respondent no.2 – FIR was registered against the appellant and not his company – Cognizance was taken – Appellant preferred a petition u/s.482 CrPC for quashing of the chargesheet and the summoning order, which was dismissed by the High Court – Correctness:
* Author 628 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Held: Respondent no.2 cannot maintain a prosecution on the basis of allegations which were precisely his defence in the earlier proceedings wherein he was an accused – Thus, the present criminal proceedings deserve to be quashed on this ground alone – It is also to be seen that the business relation was between the two companies – The cheques and the demand drafts, as the case may be, were issued by one company to the other company and no payment was made by respondent no.2 to appellant individually – It is settled that s.141(1) of the Negotiable Instruments Act, extends vicarious criminal liability to the officers of a company by deeming fiction, which arises only when the offence is committed by the company itself and not otherwise – It is also settled that a person cannot be vicariously prosecuted, especially for offences under the IPC, merely on account of the fact that he holds a managerial position in a company without there being specific allegations regarding his involvement in the offence – Besides that, it will not be just enough for the court to look into the averments made in the FIR/complaint alone for the purpose of ascertaining whether the necessary ingredients to constitute the alleged offence are disclosed or not – In frivolous or vexatious proceedings, the court owes a duty to look into many other attending circumstances emerging from the record of the case over and above the averments and, if need be, with due care and circumspection try to read in between the lines – The Court while exercising its jurisdiction u/s.482 CrPC or Article 226 of the Constitution need not restrict itself only to the stage of a case but is empowered to take into account the overall circumstances leading to the initiation/registration of the case as well as the materials collected in the course of investigation – The present is a fit case for allowing the appeal to quash the impugned criminal proceedings instituted against the appellant for offences u/s.420 of the IPC. [Paras 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25] Principle of res judicata – Applicability of principle of res judicata in a criminal proceeding – Discussed. [Paras 13-19] Case Law Cited Pritam Singh & Anr. v. The State of Punjab, AIR 1956 SC 415; Bhagat Ram v. State of Rajasthan [1972] 3 SCR 303 : (1972) 2 SCC 466; The State of Rajasthan v. Tarachand Jain [2025] 5 S.C.R. 629S.C. Garg v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. [1974] 1 SCR 146 : (1974) 3 SCC 72; Sharad Kumar Sanghi v. Sangita Rane [2015] 2 SCR 145 : (2015) 12 SCC 781; Dayle De’ Souza v. Government of India [2021] 11 SCR 511 : (2021) 20 SCC 135; Delhi Race Club (1940) Ltd. & Ors. v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. [2024] 8 SCR 670 : (2024) SCC OnLine SC 2248 – relied on.
Devendra & Ors. v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. [2009] 7 SCR 872 : (2009) 7 SCC 495; Muskan Enterprises & Anr. v. The State of Punjab & Anr., 2024 INSC 1046; Sambasivam v. Public Prosecutor, Federal of Malaya, (1950) AC 458; Iqbal @ Bala & Ors. v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors. (2023) 8 SCC 734 – referred to. List of Acts Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881; Penal Code, 1860; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 List of Keywords Dishonor of cheque; Quashment of Criminal Proceeding; Applicability of principle of res judicata in criminal matters; Vicariously prosecuted; Vicarious criminal liability; Frivolous proceedings; Vexatious proceedings; Section 482 of CrPC. Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No. 438 of 2018 From the Judgment and Order dated 28.04.2017 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in Crl. Misc. Application No. 10531 of 2002 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Siddharth Aggarwal, Sr. Adv., Ms. Garima Bajaj, Vishwajeet Singh Bhatti, Ms. Vismita Diwan, Sajal Awasthi, S. S. Nehra, Chetan Sharma.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Vikas Bansal, Dr. Vijendra Singh, Deepak Goel, Shailesh Sharma, M/S. Gaur & Nehra Law Firm, Prafulla Kumar Behera, S S Nehra, Dr. K S Bhati, Sanjay Singh, Vikrant Nehra, H L Nimba. 630 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Prashant Kumar Mishra, J.
1. Challenge in this Criminal Appeal is to the final judgment and order dated 28.04.2017 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad whereby the appellant’s petition under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 19731 seeking quashment of Criminal Case No. 7489 of 2002 pending on the file of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ghaziabad for offences under Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code, 18602 , has been dismissed.
2. Brief facts necessary for disposal of the criminal appeal are that the appellant/S.C. Garg 3 was the Managing Director of the Company Ruchira Papers Ltd. 4 which was engaged in manufacturing craft papers. The Company had business dealings with ID Packaging, a partnership concern of respondent no. 2/R.N. Tyagi 5 . In conduct of business between two entities, the parties used to maintain a running account and Tyagi used to issue cheques from time to time in favour of ID Packaging. Between 22.12.1997 to 30.01.1998, Tyagi issued 11 cheques which were initially dishonoured due to insufficiency of funds in the account. To maintain business relations, both the parties agreed to present the 11 cheques again at a later stage upon instructions from Tyagi. In relation to the liabilities other than the amount involved in the 11 cheques, Tyagi made payment by issuing 03 demand drafts in the name of the appellant’s company. On 08.06.1998, 11 cheques were again presented for encashment upon which only four cheques were cleared leaving the remaining 07 cheques to be dishonoured again. The appellant’s company filed a complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 6 against ID Packaging and Tyagi in relation to the 07 dishonoured cheques.
1 ‘Cr.P.C.’ 2 ‘IPC’ 3 ‘Garg’ 4 ‘Company’ 5 ‘Tyagi’ 6 ‘NI Act’ [2025] 5 S.C.R. 631S.C. Garg v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr.
3. On 25.10.2002, the learned Magistrate convicted Tyagi for offence under Section 138 of the NI Act. His defence, that there is no enforceable debt as the amount involved in 07 cheques has already been paid through the demand drafts, was rejected with a specific finding that the demand drafts pertained to other liabilities of Tyagi to the company and were not towards liquidating the liability arising under the cheques in question. Tyagi was sentenced to imprisonment till rising of Court and pay fine of Rs. 3,20,385/- (i.e. cumulative amount of the 7 dishonoured cheques). The appeal preferred by Tyagi challenging his conviction under Section 138 of the NI Act was dismissed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge on 17.03.2005 by affirming the finding, conviction and sentence awarded to him.
4. Tyagi and his Company/ID Packaging challenged the appellate order by preferring criminal revision and vide order dated 10.10.2012 the High Court disposed of criminal revision as well as two other proceedings between the parties basis compromise between them. When the criminal revision challenging his conviction was pending, the sentence was suspended upon deposit of R. 3,20,385/-. The High Court disposed of three different proceedings between the parties by observing thus in paragraph nos. 5 & 6 of the order: “5. When these petition/appeal/ revision were taken up today, Sh. R.N. Tyagi, who is present in Court along with his counsel Sh. Rampal Tyagi and Ashok Tyagi expressed his desire to put an end to the entire controversy on the condition that the amount deposited by him in this Court by demand draft pursuant to the orders passed in the Criminal Revision (supra) along with interest be paid to M/s Ruchira Papers in full satisfaction of all their claims, subject matter of criminal appeal No. 752 of 2002, CMPMO No. 305 of 2012 and in Civil Suit No. 47/1 of 2005/01, titled as M/s Ruchira Papers versus M/s I.D. Packings, decreed on 23.09.2005. Statement of Sh. R.N. Tyagi, who is present in Court, to this effect has been recorded separately, which statement has been accepted by Sh. Sanjeev Sood, learned counsel on behalf of M/s Ruchira Papers.
6. In these circumstance, all three cases are being disposed of the following directions:
632 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports a) Criminal Appeal No.752 of 2002, titled M/s Ruchira Papers Ltd., versus M/s I.D. Packings and another is disposed of as not pressed.
b) Criminal Revision No. 52 of 2005, titled M/s I.D. Packings and another versus M/s Ruchira Papers and another is disposed of with the directions that the amount lying deposited in FDR A/c No. 042704PR00001211 dated 11.09.2012 along with interest satisfies the entire claim of the respondents M/s Ruchira Papers subject matter of the revision.
c) CMPMO No. 305 of 2012, titled R.N. Tyagi and another versus M/s Ruchira Papers ltd., is also disposed of with this direction that the decree passed in Civil Suit No.47/1 of 2005/01, titled M/s Ruchira Papers versus M/s I.D. packing shall stand fully satisfied on the FDR along with interest having been paid to respondents M/s Ruchira Papers Limited.
d) The registry is directed to remit the amount of aforesaid FDR account along with interest accrued thereon to the bank account of M/s Ruchira Papers Limited for which purpose they shall submit the photocopy of their current account to the Registry.”
5. From the above extracted order of the High Court, it appears that Garg had instituted a suit for recovery of the amount involved under the 07 dishonoured cheques in which ex-parte decree was passed and that too has been compromised upon payment of Rs. 3,20,385/by Tyagi to Garg.
6. When 138 NI Act proceedings were pending between the parties, Tyagi moved an application under Section 156 (3) Cr.P.C. seeking registration of an FIR against Garg and company inter alia alleging that despite payment of amount involved in 07 dishonoured cheques, by way of separate demand drafts, Garg again presented 11 cheques and fraudulently realised the amount from 04 out of 11 cheques thereby cheating Tyagi. FIR No. 549 of 1998 (present [2025] 5 S.C.R. 633S.C. Garg v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. FIR) came to be registered against Garg based upon the above allegations. However, the company was not made an accused in this FIR. The chargesheet filed against Garg on account of being the Managing Director of the Company and Mukesh Kumar Behal, director of M/s. M.V. Agency is again without joining the company. The learned Magistrate took cognizance of the alleged offence and summoned the accused persons including the appellant vide order dated 19.06.2002. Garg preferred a petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. for quashing of the chargesheet and the summoning order dated 19.06.2002 which has been dismissed by the High Court under the impugned judgment and order.
7. Mr. Siddharth Aggarwal, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant would vehemently urge that the appellant cannot be prosecuted for an offence allegedly committed by the company without arraying it as an accused that too without making any specific allegation against Garg. He would submit that the impugned prosecution has been instituted as a counterblast to the concluded proceedings under Section 138 of the NI Act in which Tyagi was convicted and it eventually concluded by way of compromise before the High Court. It is also argued that the summoning order is without any reasoning showing complete non-application of mind.
8. Per contra, Mr. Vikas Bansal, learned counsel appearing for the respondent would submit that it is a subject matter of trial as to whether Garg encashed the amount involved in 04 cheques despite having received the amount by way of demand drafts separately given to him by Tyagi after all the cheques were dishonoured on the first occasion. According to him, it is a clear case of receiving double payment for the same dues, thus, committing cheating.
9. Having heard learned senior counsel for the parties and upon perusal of the material on record we are satisfied that the appeal deserves to be allowed, and the impugned chargesheet/criminal proceedings deserve to be quashed on the reasoning hereafter stated.
10. It is to be noted that in 138 NI Act proceedings against Tyagi, he raised a specific defence that there is no outstanding debt qua 07 cheques as the amount involved therein has already been paid by separate demand drafts. Learned Magistrate in its order dated 25.10.2002 rejected the said defence by recording a finding that no 634 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports request was made by Tyagi to the complainant company to return the bounded cheques to the accused company when the demand drafts were allegedly sent by the accused persons to the complainant company. The Trial Magistrate specifically recorded a finding in paragraph No. 16 in the following manner:
“16. Moreover, it may be stated that the accused company was having business dealing with the complainant company. The complainant company has also placed on record the copy of statement of account Ex. P-16 pertaining to the transaction of the accused firm with the complainant company. In the said statement of account, the impugned demand draft No. 859562 for Rs. 55,000/- D.D. No. 859879 for Rs. 50,000/- D.D. No. 859797 for Rs. 50,000/-, D.D. No. 4123761 for Rs. 1,50,000/- and D.D. No. 860060 for Rs. 1,11,357/- have been accounted for against liability of accused person and ultimately, liability of the accused firm to the tune of Rs. 3,31,151/- is shown outstanding in favour of the complainant company. From this statement of account Ex.P-16, to can be safety presumed that these demand drafts pertaining to some other liability of the accused persons and these demand drafts were not issued to liquidate the liability of impugned cheques Ex.P-2 to Ex.P-8.”
11. The above finding of the Trial Magistrate was affirmed by the Sessions Court in its order dated 17.03.2005 by observing thus in paragraph No. 16 “16. …… I have closely scrutinised the evidence of DW1 and DW2, the statement of the aforesaid witnesses does not inspire confidence particularly in view of the facts that the accused himself did not appear in the witness box to state so. From the statement of account Ext.P16 placed on record by the complainant company, it can be gathered that the demand drafts No. 859562 for Rs. 55,000/- 859797 for Rs.50,000/-, 4123761 for Rs. 1,50,000/- and 860060 for Rs.1,11,356/- have been accounted for against liability of the accused persons and ultimately, liability of the accused firm to the tune of Rs. 3,31,151/- which is [2025] 5 S.C.R. 635S.C. Garg v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. shown outstanding in favour of the complainant company. Therefore, from the statement of account Ext.P16 it can be presumed that these demand drafts were pertaining to some other liability of the appellants and were not issued to liquidate the liability of the impugned cheques Ext.P2 to Ext. P8”
12. It is thus apparent that the finding recorded by the jurisdictional criminal court in 138 NI Act proceedings between the parties would be binding to both the parties in any subsequent proceedings involving the same issue.
13. The question as to the applicability of principle of res judicata in criminal matters have been considered by this Court in several decisions. In the matters of Pritam Singh & Anr. vs. The State of Punjab,7 Bhagat Ram vs. State of Rajasthan 8 & The State of Rajasthan vs. Tarachand Jain,9 this Court has consistently laid down the principle that the principle of res judicata is equally applicable in criminal matters. However, in two later decisions, namely, Devendra & Ors. vs. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr.10 and Muskan Enterprises & Anr. Vs. The State of Punjab & Anr.11 in which one of us was a member (Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra), this Court observed in the context of maintainability of second petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. that principle of res judicata has no application in a criminal matter. Considering divergence of opinion, it would be appropriate for us to have deeper examination and reading of the law laid down by this Court in the earlier decisions.
14. In Pritam Singh (supra), a three Judge Bench of this Court speaking through Natwarlal Harilal Bhagwati, J. placing reliance on Sambasivam vs. Public Prosecutor, Federal of Malaya, 12 decided by a Bench of Five Judges of the Judicial Committee, opined that maxim res judicata is no less appliable to criminal than
7 AIR 1956 SC 415
8 (1972) 2 SCC 466
9 (1974) 3 SCC 72
10 (2009) 7 SCC 495
11 (2024) INSC 1046
12 (1950) AC 458 636 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports to civil proceedings. In the said matter, accused Pritam Singh was earlier tried for an offence under the Arms Act basing recovery of a weapon from him. In the said case Pritam Singh was acquitted. In a subsequent trial, the same recovery was again sought to be used by the prosecution as one of the circumstances in an offence of murder. In these set of facts, this Court recorded the following findings as to the applicability of principle of res judicata in criminal matters:
“15. In regard to the recovery of Ex. P-14 the learned Additional Sessions Judge had not put any reliance on the acquittal of the accused by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Faridkot, of the offence under the Arms Act, observing that any expression of opinion contained in the judgment was not only not binding on him but was irrelevant under the Indian Evidence Act.
On a perusal of the evidence led by the prosecution in this behalf he had held that the recovery of Ex. P-14 was proved against the accused and considered that as connecting Pritam Singh Lohara with the incident. The High Court, on the other hand, relied upon the observations of Lord MacDermott at p.479 in Sambasivam v. Public Prosecutor, Federal of Malaya, 1950 A.C. 458(A):- “The effect of a verdict of acquittal pronounced by a competent Court on a lawful charge and after a lawful trial is not completely stated by saying that the person acquitted cannot be tried again for the same offence. To that it must be added that the verdict is binding and conclusive in all subsequent proceedings between the parties to the adjudication.
The maxim ‘res judicata pro veritate accipitur’ is no less applicable to criminal than to civil proceedings. Here, the appellant having been acquitted at the first trial on the charge of having ammunition in his possession, the prosecution was bound to accept the correctness of that verdict and was precluded from taking any steps to challenge it at the second trial.”
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 637S.C. Garg v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr.
15. In Bhagat Ram (supra), a two Judge Bench of this Court speaking through H.R. Khanna, J. again applied and approved Sambasivam (supra) and Pritam Singh (supra).
16. Thereafter in Tarachand Jain (supra), this Court referred to Bhagat Ram (supra) and Sambasivam (supra) to hold thus:
“13. ……….The question as to what is the binding effect of a decision in subsequent proceedings of the same original matter was considered by this Court in the case of Bhagat Ram v. State of Rajasthan, [(1972) 2 SCC 466 : 1972 SCC (Cri) 751] and it was held that the principle of res judicata is also applicable to criminal proceedings and it is not permissible in the subsequent stage of the same proceedings to convict a person for an offence in respect of which an order for his acquittal has already been recorded. Reliance in this context was placed upon the observations of the Judicial Committee in the case of Samba Sivam v. Public Prosecutor, Federation of Malaya. [1950 AC 458] In Bhagat Ram case [(1972) 2 SCC 466 : 1972 SCC (Cri) 751] a Single Judge of the High Court to whom a limited question had been referred because of a difference of opinion between two Judges of the Division Bench, not only decided the question referred to him, he also interfered with the acquittal of the accused regarding certain offences in respect of which an order for acquittal had already been made earlier by the Division Bench. It was held that it was not within the competence of the Single Judge to reopen the matter and pass the above order of conviction in the face of the earlier order of the Division Bench for acquittal. Although Bhagat Ram case [(1972) 2 SCC 466 : 1972 SCC (Cri) 751] related to acquittal, the principle laid down in that case, in our opinion, holds good in a case like the present wherein the question is about the binding effect of the earlier Division Bench judgment regarding the validity of the sanction for the prosecution of the accused-respondent.”
17. We shall now have a look at the subsequent matters Devendra (supra) and Muskan Enterprises (Supra) wherein it is held that 638 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports principle of res judicata is not applicable in criminal proceedings. In Devendra (supra) was a case where after dismissal of first petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. seeking quashing of the FIR, the appellants therein preferred another application under Section 482 Cr.P.C., after the Magistrate took cognizance of the matter, which was dismissed by the High Court. In this Court, it was argued by the opposite party that the first order of the High Court dismissing the petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. would operate as res judicata. Negating the said argument, a two Judge Bench of this Court held in para 25 as under: “25. Mr. Das, furthermore, would contend that the order of the High Court dated 17-10-2005 would operate as res judicata. With respect, we cannot subscribe to the said view. The principle of res judicata has no application in a criminal proceeding. The principles of res judicata as adumbrated in Section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure or the general principles thereof will have no application in a case of this nature.”
18. In Muskan Enterprises (supra), similar was the position. The first petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. was dismissed as withdrawn without liberty obtained to apply afresh, the High Court dismissed the second petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. as not maintainable. Referring to Devendra (supra), a two Judge Bench of this Court of which one of us was a member (Prashant Kumar Mishra, J.) observed thus in para 17:
“17. That the principle of res judicata has no application in a criminal proceeding was reiterated by this Court in Devendra vs. State of U.P.”
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.