The Hp Power Transmission Corporation Ltd. v. M/S Brua Hydrowatt Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 680; [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1360
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Augustine George Masih
- Decided
- 14 May 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 3919/2023
- Sections
- 02, 86(1), 158, 111
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 1360 : 2025 INSC 680 The HP Power Transmission Corporation Ltd.
v.
M/s Brua Hydrowatt Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 3919 of 2023)
14 May 2025 [Abhay S. Oka and Augustine George Masih,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity was correct in reversing the Order passed by Himachal Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission thereby exonerating respondent from bearing the entire construction cost for the Bay.
Headnotes† Doctrine of Privity – Whether the appellant can recover dues and other charges despite being a stranger to the internal tripartite agreement (ITA) dated 27.12.2019 among the respondents: Held: The respondents executed an ITA wherein they agreed to pool in the power to be generated from their respective generative stations at Bay and the entire cost of the terminal, including metering arrangements, were to be shared between them in proportion to their individual generating capacities – Separately, the appellant executed a Connection Agreement with only respondent no. 1, wherein respondent no. 1 acted as lead partner of the consortium of the respondents, had the liability to pay for cost of construction, additional charges, and O&M Charges to the appellant in relation to the Bay – Respondent no. 1 was to ensure the payment to be made to the appellant and thereafter seek reimbursement in case of nonpayment of the amount by the other generating companies within the time stipulated – Respondent no. 3 defaulted in its payment, the appellant raised a demand from the respondent no. 1 citing sole liability of the said respondent as per Connection Agreement dated 02.07.2021 – Since the appellant was not a party to the ITA which was executed by and between the respondent no. 1, 2 and 3, thus appellant could not have and cannot claim proportionate shares as per the installed capacity of the project from Respondent No. 02 and Respondent No. 03 – The right, to claim and seek recovery of the liability from Respondent No. 02 and Respondent No. 03 would be * Author [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1361The HP Power Transmission Corporation Ltd. v. M/s Brua Hydrowatt Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.
only with respondent no. 1 as per the ITA – Appellant is not privy to the ITA executed among the respondents, therefore does not have any right to claim for dues or liabilities from respondent no. 2 & 3 – As ITA does form part and parcel of the Connection Agreement executed between appellant and respondent no. 1, the exact wording only binds respondent no. 1 for the payment of concerned cost and charges – APTEL’s judgment is based upon wrong assumptions and misreading of the terms of agreement thereby ignoring the basic principle that a party not privity to the agreement or contract cannot be, unless the context otherwise makes it apparent, made liable for any term(s) and condition(s) unrelated to it.
Case Law Cited Essar Oil Limited v. Hindustan Shipyard Limited and Others [2015] 6 SCR 924 : (2015) 10 SCC 642 – relied on.
Jamna Das v. Pandit Ram Autar Pande and Others, 1911 SCC OnLine PC 35 – relied on.
Tweddle v. Atkinson (1861) 121 ER 762 – relied on.
List of Acts Electricity Act, 2003; The Himachal Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission (Conduct of Business) Regulations, 2005.
List of Keywords Doctrine of Privity; Connection Agreement; Transmission Licence; Hydro Electric Process; Stranger to an agreement cannot enforce. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 3919 of 2023 From the Judgment and Order dated 17.03.2023 of the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity at New Delhi at AN No. 30 of 2023 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Anand K. Ganesan, Nikunj Dayal, Pramod Dayal, Amal Nair, Ms. Shivani Verma.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Tarun Johri, Ankur Gupta, Vishwajeet Tyagi.
1362 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Augustine George Masih, J.
1. This Civil Appeal assails the Judgment dated 17.03.2023 in Appeal No. 30 of 2023 (“Impugned Judgment”) by the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity at New Delhi (“APTEL”) which reversed the findings returned vide Order dated 27.12.2022, by Himachal Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission at Shimla (State Commission) in Petition No. 35 of 2022, holding M/s Brua Hydrowatt Pvt. Ltd., Respondent No.01 herein (“BHP Ltd”) liable to bear the entire cost for Bay at the 66kV Switching Station at Urni (“Bay”), which was constructed by the HP Power Transmission Corporation Limited, Appellant herein (“HPPTC Ltd”) as per the Connection Agreement (Revised) dated 02.07.2021 “(CA dated 02.07.2021”).
2. The details of the parties before us are that the HPPTC Ltd is a transmission licensee responsible for executing transmission networks, including transmission lines and sub-stations of 66kV and above in the State of Himachal Pradesh. The BHP Ltd, formerly known as M/s Contransys Pvt Ltd, is a company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956, and classified as a generating company under Section 02 (28) of the Electricity Act, 2003. Respondent No. 02 and Respondent No. 03, being M/s Darjeeling Power Pvt Ltd and M/s Roura Non-Conventional Energy Pvt Ltd respectively, are the other generating companies engaged in hydroelectric projects within the State of Himachal Pradesh. Respondent No. 04 and 05 are proforma respondents, being the State Commission and State of Himachal Pradesh respectively.
3. The facts leading to the case are that Government of Himachal Pradesh entered into an Implementation Agreement with the HPPTC Ltd on 25.07.2006 to establish the Brua Hydro Electric Project (“BHEP”), initially with a capacity of 05 MW. The interconnection was originally planned at a 33kV single circuit transmission line at Karcham in Kinnaur district of Himachal Pradesh. However, the Power Purchase Agreement dated 06.04.2009 was revised through a Supplementary Power Purchase Agreement on 09.07.2018 to increase the capacity to 09 MW at a fixed tariff of INR 2.93 per unit. [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1363The HP Power Transmission Corporation Ltd. v. M/s Brua Hydrowatt Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.
The connection at Karcham was approved on 03.12.2010 by the Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board Ltd (HPSEBL), but stood modified to be connected at Urni instead of Karcham, allowing for the Bay in joint mode for the three generating companies i.e. BHEP, Shaung and Roura-II Hydro Power Project.
4. To this effect, an application for connectivity had been submitted by the BHP Ltd on 04.07.2012 and stood approved by the HPPTC Ltd on 18.03.2013 and 23.04.2013 leading to the Connection Agreement dated 04.06.2014, designating Urni as the connection point. Admittedly, the HPPTC Ltd informed the BHP Ltd on 04.12.2015 that Bay would only be operational after completion of the Urni-Wangtoo 66kV line and the Wangtoo sub-station. In the interregnum, it allowed BHP Ltd to utilize the 220kV Kahshang Bhaba line circuit at 66kV. Further, in pursuance of direction of the HPSEBL, the HPPTC Ltd completed a 66kV feeder Bay at Nathpa sub-station for interim power evacuation, leading to signing of Interim Power Transmission Agreement dated 23.01.2016, requiring the BHP Ltd to pay INR 0.14 per unit to the HPPTC Ltd for providing interim arrangements.
5. All three generating companies i.e., BHP Ltd, Respondent No.02 and Respondent No.03 entered into an Internal Tripartite Agreement dated 27.12.2019 (ITA dated 27.12.2019) to allow for proportionate sharing of transmission charges, including the cost of Bay installed by the HPPTC Ltd at Urni. As per the agreement, while the BHP Ltd would handle claims for deemed generation and Operation and Maintenance Charges (O&M Charges), the other parties to the ITA dated 27.12.2019 i.e., Respondent No.02 and Respondent No.03 would reimburse BHP Ltd.
6. The HPPTC Ltd and BHP Ltd then entered the CA dated 02.07.2021 wherein, while the HPPTC Lt d was to manage the interconnection to the State’s Transmission Utility System, BHP Ltd was made liable for all the payments concerned, including the construction cost for the Bay. Subsequently, request was made by BHP Ltd for connection to Bay, and the HPPTC Ltd raised a demand for INR 3,42,85,447 (Rupees Three Crore Forty-Two Lakh Eighty-Five Thousand Four Hundred Forty-Seven only) as construction cost for the Bay vide Letter dated 24.01.2022.
7. Against this demand, BHP Ltd wrote to Respondent No.02 and Respondent No.03 for the payment of their proportionate shares. 1364 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports While Respondent No. 02 agreed for transfer of payment, Respondent No. 03 responded with their inability to do so at that point in time. Consequently, the BHP Ltd wrote Letter dated 10.05.2022 to HPPTC Ltd stating that it is willing to deposit the proportionate share for itself and that of Respondent No.02, however, Respondent No.03 shall pay its proportionate share along with interest subsequently. This demand was rejected by the HPPTC Ltd vide Letter dated 30.05.2022, citing the sole liability of BHP Ltd under the CA dated 02.07.2021.
8. This prompted the BHP Ltd to move the State Commission through Petition No. 35 of 2022 under Section 86(1)(f) read with Section 158 and other enabling provisions of the Electricity Act, 2003 and Regulations 53, 68, and 70 of the Himachal Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission (Conduct of Business) Regulations, 2005. 8A. While dismissing the petition of the BHP Ltd vide Order dated 27.12.2022, the State Commission observed that BHP Ltd was acting as the lead partner of the consortium, while it applied for the connection for all three projects and agreed to pay the cost of construction, additional charges, and O&M Charges to the HPPTC Ltd, with the expectation that the amount would be reimbursed by the Respondent No.02 and Respondent No.03 in their proportionate shares, which aspect of liability had been acknowledged by them. The HPPTC Ltd, therefore, rightfully issued the invoice(s) to the BHP Ltd, which is responsible and liable for payment as per the agreement. Recovery, if any, from Respondent No.02 and Respondent No.03 was an internal matter between them, and the HPPTC Ltd had no concern. While rejecting the contention that the HPPTC Ltd should issue separate bills or that HPPTC Ltd must enter into separate O&M agreements with the parties concerned, the State Commission observed that the BHP Ltd must fulfil its obligations under the agreements dated 27.12.2019 and 02.07.2021.
9. Aggrieved by the said Order, the BHP Ltd moved the APTEL vide Appeal No. 30 of 2023 under Section 111 of the Electricity Act, 2003, which effected the pronouncement of the Impugned Judgment dated 17.03.2023. APTEL, while considering the CA dated 02.07.2021, observed that the BHP Ltd was liable for construction cost and O&M Charges of the Bay on “mutually agreed terms”. A reference was also made to the ITA dated 27.12.2019 stipulating that the costs would [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1365The HP Power Transmission Corporation Ltd. v. M/s Brua Hydrowatt Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.
be shared by the parties in proportion to their individual capacities. Furthermore, the Supplementary Power Purchase Agreement dated 09.07.2018 indicates that the interconnection facilities required for the project, including switching equipment, protection, control, and metering devices, shall be installed and maintained by the HPPTC Ltd at the Bay, with the costs to be shared proportionately by the parties. The BHP Ltd had submitted that no specific agreement for the payment of charges to the Appellant under Clause 2.4 of the CA dated 02.07.2021 was executed, holding that, in the absence of such an agreement, the demand for payment of the entire Bay charges could not be imposed on it. However, the State Commission concluded that the BHP Ltd, acting as the lead partner, had agreed to pay these charges, contrary to the assertion.
9A. Inclined with the assertions of the BHP Ltd, APTEL further observed that the Clauses 2.4 and 2.5 of the CA dated 02.07.2021 do not indicate that the BHP Ltd agreed to pay the entire Bay charges and O&M Charges on behalf of Respondent No.02 and Respondent No.03, in addition to its own liabilities. Furthermore, it does not address the scenario where one of the generating companies fails to pay the Bay charges or does not commission its project, leaving the lead member responsible for the costs and charges of such defaulting generating Company. Therefore, the unilateral demand for payment of Bay charges by the HPPTC Ltd for liability of other generating companies is contrary to the terms of the CA dated 02.07.2021.
9B. Thereafter, APTEL examined the ITA dated 27.12.2019 and while rejecting the contentions of the HPPTC Ltd, observed that it cannot place reliance on the said ITA for its benefit without being a party therein as it does not form part and parcel of the CA dated 02.07.2021, nor does it govern the payment of Bay charges. While concluding on the liability of the BHP Ltd, APTEL observed that before the State Commission, the other generating companies, i.e. Respondent No.02 and Respondent No.03, had accepted their liability of the proportionate Bay charges and an undertaking to that effect being given by Respondent No. 03 should similarly apply to the BHP Ltd, so as to not hold it liable for share of other generating companies. The interim arrangement for power evacuation should cease once the BHP Ltd is connected through the Bay. Respondent No. 03’s 1366 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports failure to commission its project has led to complications, but the BHP Ltd cannot be burdened with additional costs without explicit contractual provisions. The Bay charges attributable to Respondent No. 03 may be recovered by the HPPTC Ltd after its project is commissioned or through other legal remedies. 9C. Appeal No. 30 of 2023 preferred by BHP Ltd was allowed vide Judgment dated 17.03.2023 passed by APTEL; setting aside the Order dated 27.12.2022 passed by the State Commission. Further directions were issued to HPPTC Ltd to provide connection to the BHP Ltd and Respondent No.02 on payment of their respective share of charges for the Bay.
10. This resulted in the HPPTC Ltd moving this Court through instant Civil Appeal No. 3919 of 2023 assailing the Impugned Judgment passed by APTEL. To press their claim, the counsels on behalf of the HPPTC Ltd have asserted that even by virtue of the ITA dated 27.12.2019 it was the BHP Ltd who was liable to act on behalf of other two generating companies and the mandate was limited to recovery of the proportionate charges by BHP Ltd from the other generating companies. It was solely BHP Ltd who was designated as the sole applicant in CA dated 02.07.2021 for payment of charges and to settle claims of deemed generation for the Bay to the HPPTC Ltd. Furthermore, as a stranger to the ITA dated 27.12.2019, HPPTC Ltd cannot seek or enforce to recover the other part of charges from Respondent No.02 and Respondent No.03 which APTEL failed to appreciate while directing HPPTC Ltd to do so.
11. Contesting the assertions by the HPPTC Ltd, the counsels for the BHP Ltd submitted that in pursuance of the Impugned Judgment, the parties entered into an agreement for the O&M of interconnection facilities as stipulated in Clause 2.5 of the CA dated 02.07.2021 which included provisions for a separate arrangement for the execution, operation and maintenance (O&M) of the Bay. Moreover, proportionate share of liability arising as against the BHP Ltd has been deposited and acknowledged by the HPPTC Ltd vide Letter dated 01.04.2023 and the connection has been provided at the Bay. Having complied with the Impugned Judgment, the HPPTC Ltd is now precluded from challenging it, rendering this Civil Appeal infructuous. Moreover, separate bills have been raised by the HPPTC Ltd for the three generating companies vis-à-vis payment of provisional O&M Charges for April 2023 to March 2024. Therefore, it is asserted that the new [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1367The HP Power Transmission Corporation Ltd. v. M/s Brua Hydrowatt Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.