The State of Himachal Pradesh & Anr. v. Jsw Hydro Energy Limited & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 857; [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1104
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, Justice Joymalya Bagchi
- Decided
- 16 Jul 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 12883/2024
- Sections
- 14, 10(2), 61, 2(71), 185, 7, 8, 10, 42(2), 42, 73, 62(1)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1104 : 2025 INSC 857 The State of Himachal Pradesh & Anr.
v.
JSW Hydro Energy Limited & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 12883 of 2024)
16 July 2025 [Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha* and Joymalya Bagchi, JJ.] Issue for Consideration The primary issues arising for consideration are: first, whether the CERC Regulations, 2019 bar respondent no. 1 from supplying free power to the appellant-State beyond 13%; and second, whether respondent no. 1 could have invoked the High Court’s writ jurisdiction for aligning the Implementation Agreement with the CERC Regulations, 2019.
Headnotes† Electricity Act, 2003 – CERC (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2019 – Regulations 44 and 55 – Note 3 of Regulation 55 – Respondent no.1, a generating company, installed and commissioned a hydroelectric power project pursuant to a grant followed by an Implementation Agreement with the appellant-State of Himachal Pradesh – Under this agreement, respondent no. 1 undertook to supply as consideration 18% of net generation free of cost (free power supply of 12% of net generation for 12 years and 18% thereafter for next 28 years) to the appellant-State – At the commencement of the obligation to supply 18% free power, respondent no. 1 approached the High Court by way of a writ petition to align the Implementation Agreement with the CERC (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2019, which provide for a maximum of 13% free power to the State Government, on the ground that contractual agreements, to the extent that they are inconsistent with the applicable regulations, shall stand overridden by their operation – The High Court directed for modification of the Implementation Agreement – Correctness: Held: 1. The purpose and intendment of Note 3 of Regulation 55 is for the State Commission to determine tariff by assuming that * Author [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1105The State of Himachal Pradesh & Anr. v. JSW Hydro Energy Limited & Ors.
FEHS is 13%, whenever it is higher in actuality, while calculating the energy and capacity charges – Neither the language of Note 3 nor the context in which it appears in the CERC Regulations, 2019 supports respondent no. 1’s contention that the legal effect of this cap is to override its contractual obligations with the appellant- State – On the other hand, use of the term “shall be taken as 13% or actual, whichever is less” shows that the Regulations cover a situation where the obligation to supply free power is higher than 13%, and in such an eventuality, allow only a certain portion of free supply to be considered for tariff determination and payments by beneficiaries for the saleable capacity – Once the Regulation does not prohibit the supply of free power beyond 13%, respondent no. 1 cannot rely on it to wriggle out of its contractual obligations – The Regulatory Commissions, APTEL, and the Courts must enforce these contractual obligations and ensure that their interpretation of regulations does not allow the party to circumvent and breach its contractual undertakings when the same is not intended by the regulation itself. [Paras 19, 20]
2. This Court holds that CERC Regulations, 2019 do not prohibit respondent no. 1 from supplying free power beyond 13% to the appellant-State, and the Implementation Agreement does not stand overridden by the operation of these Regulations – Further, a writ petition before the High Court for aligning the Implementation Agreement with the CERC Regulations, 2019 and the CERC’s order dated 17.03.2022 is not maintainable – Once respondent no.1’s prayer for relief was rejected by the CERC and it specifically held only the PPA and PSAs to stand overridden, which finding was not further appealed, it would not be open for respondent no. 1 to seek modification of the Implementation Agreement by way of a writ petition before the High Court. [Para 40] Electricity Act, 2003 – Writ Jurisdiction of High Court – Whether the writ petition before the High Court for aligning the Implementation Agreement with the CERC Regulations, 2019 and the CERC’s order dated 17.03.2022 is maintainable: Held: Under the Electricity Act, the statutory regulator has been entrusted with discharging the function of tariff determination, including making regulations for the purpose and interpreting the same – Constitutional courts must enable the regulator to comprehensively regulate all aspects of the sector such that remedies are not fragmented and certain issues are not left 1106 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports outside the regulator’s domain – The regulator has the expertise, specialisation, and institutional memory to conduct such an interpretative exercise to further the objective of the regulatory regime and systematically lay down legal principles – In this light, the High Court should not have entered into the domain of interpreting these Regulations which deal with tariff determination, as the same falls within the exclusive domain of the CERC – The Electricity Act itself provides the appellate mechanisms by establishing a specialised and permanent tribunal, namely the APTEL, and an appeal before this Court, against the CERC’s orders – In view of the existence of a statutory regulatory forum, the High Court should not have entertained the writ petition by interpreting the CERC Regulations, 2019 – Therefore, a writ petition before the High Court for aligning the Implementation Agreement with the CERC Regulations, 2019 and the CERC’s order dated 17.03.2022 is not maintainable. [Paras 38, 40] Electricity Act, 2003 – A complete and comprehensive code: Held: The Electricity Act, 2003 is a complete and comprehensive code for regulating the generation, transmission, distribution, trading and use of electricity – One of the core features of the Act is that it unbundles the functions of electricity generation, transmission, and distribution that were erstwhile performed by State Electricity Boards into separate utilities, and provides for their regulation through independent Regulatory Commissions. [Para 7] Electricity Act, 2003 – Electricity Regulatory Commissions Act, 1998 – Need for an independent and transparent regulatory mechanism:
Held: The need for an independent and transparent regulatory mechanism was felt due to the regulatory failures under the erstwhile legal regime, wherein SEBs constituted by the State Governments were entrusted with regulation – It was experienced that various problems plagued the power sector, including lack of rational retail tariffs, high level of cross-subsidies, poor planning and operation, inadequate capacity, neglect of consumer interest, and limited involvement of the private sector’s skills and resources – It is in this context that the Electricity Regulatory Commissions Act, 1998 was enacted to reform the governance of the sector by establishing an independent and transparent regulatory mechanism – Thereafter, the Electricity Act, 2003 was enacted as a comprehensive legislation [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1107The State of Himachal Pradesh & Anr. v. JSW Hydro Energy Limited & Ors.
for regulating the sector and it replaced the Electricity Act, 1910, Electricity Supply Act, 1948 and the 1998 Act [Para 8] Electricity Act, 2003 – Regulation of Electricity Generation Under the Electricity Act – Discussed. [Paras 11 to 14] Electricity Act, 2003 – CERC Regulations, 2019 – Interpretation of – Discussed. [Para 15] Case Law Cited PTC India Ltd. v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission [2010] 3 SCR 609 : (2010) 4 SCC 603; Transmission Corporation of A.P. Ltd. v. Rain Calcining Ltd. [2019] 17 SCR 474 : (2021) 13 SCC 674; Ganga Retreat and Towers Ltd. v. State of Rajasthan [2003] Supp. 6 SCR 1134 : (2003) 12 SCC 91; K.C. Ninan v. Kerala State Electricity Board [2023] 9 SCR 637 : (2023) 14 SCC 431; W.B. Electricity Regulatory Commission v. CESC Ltd. (2002) 8 SCC 715; Sesa Sterlite Ltd. v. Orissa Electricity Regulatory Commission [2014] 13 SCR 426 : (2014) 8 SCC 444; Dilip v. Satish, 2022 SCC OnLine SC 810; Chameli Singh v. State of U.P. [1995] Supp. 6 SCR 827 : (1996) 2 SCC 549; Tata Power Co. Ltd. v. Reliance Energy Ltd. [2009] 9 SCR 625 : (2009) 16 SCC 659; Indsil Hydro Power & Manganese Ltd. v. State of Kerala [2021] 13 SCR 136 : (2021) 10 SCC 165; Reliance Infrastructure Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra [2019] 1 SCR 886 : (2019) 3 SCC 352; Cellular Operators Assn. of India v. Union of India [2002] Supp. 5 SCR 222 : (2003) 3 SCC 186; U.P. Power Corpn. Ltd. v. NTPC Ltd. [2009] 3 SCR 1060 : (2009) 6 SCC 235; BSES Ltd. v. Tata Power Co. Ltd. [2003] Supp. 4 SCR 932 : (2004) 1 SCC 195; Maharashtra State Electricity Distribution Co. Ltd. v. Adani Power Maharashtra Ltd. [2023] 7 SCR 648 : (2023) 7 SCC 401; Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Ltd. v. MB Power (M.P.) Ltd. [2024] 1 SCR 909 : (2024) 8 SCC 513 – referred to. Books and Periodicals Cited H.W.R. Wade and C.F. Forsyth, Administrative Law (11th edn, Oxford University Press 2014), 116-117 – referred to.
List of Acts Electricity Act, 2003; Electricity Regulatory Commissions Act, 1998; Electricity Act, 1910; Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948; CERC Regulations, 2019; CERC (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2014.
1108 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports List of Keywords Contractual obligation; Statutory regulator; Implementation Agreement; Consideration; Free energy for home State; Writ Jurisdiction of High Court; Aligning the Implementation Agreement; Supplying free power beyond 13%; Interpreting cap under Note 3 of Regulation 55; Calculation and fixation of tariff; CERC as statutory regulator.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 12883 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 28.05.2024 of the High Court of Himachal Pradesh at Shimla in CWP No. 7667 of 2023 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Vaibhav Srivastava, A.A.G., Kapil Sibal, Parag Tripathi, Anup Rattan, Sr. Advs., Ms. Sugandha Anand, Bhargava Ravikumar, Puneet Rajta, Ms. Mishika Bajpai.
Advs. for the Respondents:
P. Chidambaram, Dr. A.M. Singhvi, Gurminder Singh, Nikhil Nayyar, Sr. Advs., Mahesh Agarawal, Aman Anand, Shashwat Singh, Ms. Madhavi Agarwal, Chirag Nayak, Ms. Natasha Debroy, Shidharth Seem, E. C. Agrawala, Anand K Ganesan, Amal Nair, Shivani Verma, Nitin Saluja, Ms. Preetika Dwivedi, Abhisek Mohanty, Nikunj Dayal, Jatinder Singh Gill, T. V. S. Raghavendra Sreyas, Siddharth Vasudev, Brahma Prakash Soni, Kshitij Maheshwari.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, J.
Table of Contents* I. Introduction ............................................................................ 2 II. Facts ....................................................................................... 4 * Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1109The State of Himachal Pradesh & Anr. v. JSW Hydro Energy Limited & Ors.
III. Impugned Order ..................................................................... 14 IV. Submissions ........................................................................... 16 V. Issue ....................................................................................... 29 VI. Analysis .................................................................................. 29 VII. Regulation of Electricity Generation Under the Electricity Act ... 33 VIII. Legal Effect of Note 3 of Regulation ...................................... 36 i) Interpretation of the CERC Regulations, 2019 ................ 36 ii) CERC’s Order dated 17.03.2022 ..................................... 41 IX. Maintainability of the Writ Petition .......................................... 44 i) CERC as an Expert and Specialised Regulator, and Extent of Judicial Interference ..................................................... ii) Grant of Relief by the High Court ................................... 50 X. Conclusion .............................................................................. 53 I. Introduction:
1. Respondent no. 1, a generating company, installed and commissioned a 1045MW hydroelectric power project pursuant to a grant followed by an Implementation Agreement with the appellant-State of Himachal Pradesh. Under this Agreement, respondent no. 1 undertook to supply as consideration 18% of net generation free of cost 1 to the appellant-State. At the commencement of the obligation to supply 18% free power, respondent no. 1 approached the High Court by way of a writ petition to align the Implementation Agreement with the CERC (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2019 2 , which provide for a maximum of 13% free power to the State Government, on the ground that contractual agreements, to the extent that they are inconsistent with the applicable regulations, shall stand overridden by their operation. Accepting the argument, the High Court entertained 1 The obligation to supply free power is 12% of net generation from 12.09.2011 to 12.09.2023, and 18% thereafter till 12.09.2051.
2 Hereinafter “CERC Regulations, 2019”.
1110 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the writ petition and directed that the Implementation Agreement stood modified.
2. We have allowed the appeal by the State of Himachal Pradesh by interpreting the provisions of the Electricity Act, 2003 3 and the CERC Regulations, 2019 in the context of the subsisting and continuing contractual relationship between the parties. We have held that the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission 4 shall give effect to the Regulations and provide a pass-through to the extent of 13% free power but the remaining part of the obligation is contractual in nature and will be governed by the provisions of the Implementation Agreement. On interpreting the cap under Note 3 of Regulation 55 of the CERC Regulations, 2019, we have held that it does not restrain or prohibit respondent no. 1 from supplying free power beyond 13% but it is only meant for the calculation and fixation of tariff. Further, considering the expertise and specialisation of the CERC as a statutory regulator and the wide-ranging jurisdiction it exercises under the Electricity Act, as well as respondent no. 1’s conduct in not seeking relief against the appellant before the CERC, we have held that the present writ petition was not maintainable before the High Court as the interpretation of the Regulations falls within the exclusive domain of the regulator.
II. Facts:
3. The facts, to the extent necessary are as follows. By a Memorandum of Understanding 5 dated 28.08.1993, the appellant-State allotted the Karcham Wangtoo Hydroelectric Project for an installed capacity of 900 MW to one Jaiprakash Industries Limited6 , which is a power generating company and the predecessor of respondent no. 1. Under Clause 6 of the MoU, JIL agreed to supply 12% of the power generated to the appellant-State free of cost.
3.1 Pursuant to the MoU, the appellant entered into an Implementation Agreement with JIL for an enhanced capacity of 1000 MW. The relevant clauses of the Implementation Agreement are as follows: 3 Hereinafter “Electricity Act”.
4 Hereinafter “CERC”.
5 Hereinafter “MoU”.
6 Hereinafter “JIL”.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1111The State of Himachal Pradesh & Anr. v. JSW Hydro Energy Limited & Ors.
i. Article 1.2 is the definitions clause that defines “Law” as any Act, rule, regulation, notification, order, or instruction having the force of Law enacted or issued by any competent legislature, government, or statutory authority in India. ii. Further, the Effective Date of the Agreement is defined as the date of signing, and the Scheduled Commercial Operation Date 7 is defined as 120 months from the Effective Date.
iii. Article 3.2 stipulates that the Implementation Agreement shall remain in force for a period of 40 years from the Commercial Operation Date8 of the Project (Agreement Period), unless terminated earlier as per its provisions. It reads:
“3.2 Agreement Period a) This Agreement shall remain in force up to a period of forty (40) years from the Commercial Operation Date of the Project (Agreement Period), unless terminated earlier in accordance with the provisions of the Agreement.”
iv. Article 4 delineates the obligations of the appellant-State under the Agreement, which include the grant of various consents and permissions to JIL to establish, operate, and maintain the Project; to acquire land and prepare a rehabilitation and resettlement plan for local residents; to enter into leases for government land required for the works; to upgrade roads and bridges for the Project; and to provide necessary assistance to JIL as per the Agreement. v. Article 5 deals with the obligations of JIL, of which the most relevant is the supply of power to the appellant-State without any cost or charges under Article 5.1. Sub-clause
(a) stipulates the quantum of such supply as 12% of the net generation for the first 12 years from the COD, and 18% of the net generation for the next 28 years. Further, 7 Hereinafter “SCOD”.
8 Hereinafter “COD”.
1112 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports sub-clause (b) stipulates that JIL shall ensure that any Power Purchase Agreement9 entered into by it shall not be detrimental to the rights of the appellant-State envisaged in this clause. It reads:
“5.1 Government Supply
(a) The Company shall supply to the Government or its Agent, during the Agreement Period, at the Interconnection Point without any cost or charges to the Government, the quantum of electrical energy generated as specified below (Government Supply):
i) Commencing from the date of synchronisation of the first Unit and for the first twelve
(12) years from Commercial Operation Date (COD)
Twelve (12)
percent of Net Generation ii) For the next twenty eight (28)
years after expiry of the period specified in (i) above.
Eighteen (18)
percent of Net Generation This quantum of Government Supply is applicable in case the Project achieves Commercial operation on Scheduled Commercial Operation Date. In the event of early or delayed commissioning of the Project, the same shall be as per provision specified in Clause 5.19 and 5.20 respectively.
In case the Government levies any duty/tax on generation and supply of power, the same shall be borne by the Government in respect of Government Supply. Further modalities for providing the Government Supply shall be mutually agreed between the Company and the Board.
9 Hereinafter “PPA”.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1113The State of Himachal Pradesh & Anr. v. JSW Hydro Energy Limited & Ors.
(b) The Company shall ensure that any Power Purchase Agreement entered into by it shall not be detrimental to the rights of the Government envisaged in this Clause.”
vi. Article 9 provides that the rights and obligations under or pursuant to the Agreement shall be governed by and construed according to Law.
vii. Article 10 provides for dispute resolution through mutual discussions, and in case of failure of the same, arbitration. 3.2 By an addendum to the Implementation Agreement dated 24.05.2001, the time-period for commencing construction was extended from 36 to 48 months from the Effective Date, but the COD was unamended.
3.3 Subsequently, by a tripartite agreement dated 30.12.2002 between the appellant, JIL, and one Jaypee Karcham Hydro Corporation Limited 10 that was incorporated by JIL as per Clause 8 of the MoU, the rights and liabilities of the Project were transferred from JIL to JKHCL.
3.4 JKHCL entered into a PPA dated 21.03.2006 with respondent no. 4, i.e., PTC India Limited, which is an inter-state trading licensee, for sale of 704 MW of power. PTC then entered into Power Sale Agreements11 with respondent nos. 5 to 10, which are distribution companies in the States of Punjab, Haryana, Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan, to sell the power which it purchased from JKHCL. In the PPA as well as the PSAs, “free power” is defined in the same manner as Article 5.1 of the Implementation Agreement.
3.5 The appellant and JKHCL entered into a Second Supplementary Implementation Agreement on 20.12.2007 to extend the SCOD to 144 months from the Effective Date, i.e. 18.11.2011. 3.6 The Project achieved commercial operation on 12.09.2011, i.e., within the extended SCOD. It is relevant to note that this is the date from which JKHCL’s obligation to supply free 10 Hereinafter “JKHCL”.
11 Hereinafter “PSAs”.
1114 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports power to the appellant-State commenced as per Article 5.1 of the Implementation Agreement. For the first 12 years from 12.09.2011, the quantum of free power to be supplied is 12%, and 18% thereafter for the next 28 years.
3.7 By a tripartite agreement dated 29.08.2015, the rights and liabilities in the Project were transferred from JKHCL to Himachal Baspa Power Company Limited 12 , which is the predecessor of respondent no. 1, with effect from 01.09.2015. As per clause 3 of this agreement, HBPCL agreed to be bound by and liable for the contractual undertakings as specified in the Implementation Agreement, Addendum, tripartite agreement dated 30.12.2002, and the Second Supplementary Implementation Agreement.
3.8 In 2018, HBPCL changed its name to JSW Hydro Energy Limited, which is the present respondent no. 1 company. The parties signed the Third Supplementary Implementation Agreement dated 21.10.2019 for effecting the change in name while also agreeing that the other contractual undertakings would remain unamended.
3.9 During this time, the CERC (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2014 governed the field with respect to tariff determination of generating stations, including the specific provision with respect to free power supply under Note 3 of Regulation 42. This provided that “FEHS = Free energy for home State, in percent and shall be taken as 13% or actual whichever is less.” Respondent no. 1 sought for relaxation of this cap in its tariff petition for the 2014-2019 period. This was decided by the CERC’s order dated 30.03.2017, wherein it did not consider this issue as the free power supply obligation during this period was only 12%, which is below the 13% cap prescribed in the CERC Regulations, 2014. However, respondent no. 1 was given liberty to claim this relief at an appropriate time.
3.10 In 2019, the CERC framed the CERC Regulations, 2019 determining tariffs for generating stations and transmission 12 Hereinafter “HBPCL”.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1115The State of Himachal Pradesh & Anr. v. JSW Hydro Energy Limited & Ors.
units from 01.04.2019 to 31.03.2024. At this stage, it is relevant to refer to Note 3 of Regulation 55 that provides that free energy to home State (FEHS) shall be taken as 13% or actual, whichever is lesser. Further, Regulation 44 deals with the computation and payment of capacity and energy charges for generating station, and Regulation 55(2) provides for billing and payments. The relevant portions of these provisions are extracted hereinbelow:
Regulation 44:
“44. Computation and Payment of Capacity Charge and Energy Charge for Hydro Generating Stations:
(1) The fixed cost of a hydro generating station shall be computed on annual basis, based on norms specified under these regulations, and shall be recovered on monthly basis under capacity charge (inclusive of incentive) and energy charge, which shall be payable by the beneficiaries in proportion to their respective allocation in the saleable capacity of the generating station, i.e., in the capacity excluding the free power to the home State:… ***
(4) The energy charge shall be payable by every beneficiary for the total energy scheduled to be supplied to the beneficiary, excluding free energy, if any, during the calendar month, on ex-bus basis, at the computed energy charge rate. Total energy charge payable to the generating company for a month shall be:
Energy Charges = (Energy charge rate in Rs. / kWh) x {Scheduled energy (ex-bus) for the month in kWh} x (100 – FEHS) / 100
(5) Energy charge rate (ECR) in Rupees per kWh on ex-power plant basis, for a hydro generating station, shall be determined up to three decimal places based on the following formula, subject to the provisions of clause (7) of this Regulation:
1116 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports ECR = AFC X 0.5 x 10 / {DE x (100 – AUX) x (100 – FEHS)} Where, DE = Annual design energy specified for the hydro generating station, in MWh, subject to the provision in clause (6) below.
FEHS = Free energy for home State, in per cent, as mentioned in Note 3 under Regulation 55 of these regulations…”
Regulation 55:
“55. Billing and Payment of charges:
***
(2) … Payment of capacity charge and energy charge for a hydro generating station shall be shared by the beneficiaries of the generating station in proportion to their shares (inclusive of any allocation out of the unallocated capacity) in the saleable capacity (to be determined after deducting the capacity corresponding to free energy to home State as per Note 3 herein.
*** Note 3 FEHS= Free energy for home State, in percent and shall be taken as 13% or actual whichever is less…”
3.11 In 2019, respondent no. 1 filed a petition before the CERC for approval of its tariff between 2019-2024, as well as truing up the tariff for 2014-2019 period. In the tariff petition, respondent no. 1 inter alia prayed for relaxation of the 13% cap on free power under Note 3 of Regulation 55 of the 2019 Regulations, since its free power obligation under the Implementation Agreement is 18% of net generation after the completion of 12 years from COD.
3.12 This was decided by the CERC’s order dated 17.03.2022 wherein it rejected the prayer for relaxation of the 13% cap on free power supply. The CERC held that it was bound by the [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1117The State of Himachal Pradesh & Anr. v. JSW Hydro Energy Limited & Ors.
CERC Regulations, 2019 while determining the tariff and that the regulations will override inconsistent contractual provisions in the PPA and PSAs executed by respondent no. 1 in respect of free power to the appellant-State. We will be dealing with the findings of the CERC in more detail in our analysis. 3.13 In the meanwhile, the Central Electricity Authority approved an increase in the Project capacity from 1000MW to 1091MW in two stages by a letter dated 29.04.2021. Pursuant to this, the capacity of the Project was enhanced to 1045 MW by the Fourth Supplementary Implementation Agreement dated 08.07.2021. It was further agreed that respondent no. 1 would be required to supply an additional 3% free power to the appellant-State on the enhanced 45MW capacity.
3.14 In 2022, the present dispute arose between the parties as respondent no. 1 issued various letters to the appellant that Note 3 of Regulation 55 of the CERC Regulations, 2019 caps the free power supplied to the State at 13%. Further, that the CERC’s order dated 17.03.2022 requires inconsistent contractual provisions to be aligned with the Regulations. Relying on these, respondent no. 1 requested the appellant to align the Implementation Agreement with the CERC Regulations, 2019 and the order dated 17.03.2022 such that its free power supply obligation is confined to 13%. On the other hand, the appellant-State replied that the quantum of free power must be determined as per the Implementation Agreement and the Supplementary Implementation Agreements, which comes to 18.46% commencing from 13.09.2023. The appellant also issued a notice to respondent no. 1 dated 13.09.2023 to adhere to the contractual terms, failing which consequential action would be initiated against it. It also issued a notice dated 16.09.2023 to the Northern Regional Load Dispatch Centre to schedule 18.46% free power to the appellant.
3.15 This led respondent no. 1 to file the present writ petition before the High Court to direct the appellant to align the provisions of the Implementation Agreement and Supplementary Implementation Agreements on free power with the CERC Regulations, 2019 and the CERC’s order dated 17.03.2022, as well as to quash the notices issued by the appellant. 1118 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports III. Impugned Order:
4. By the order 28.05.2024, which is impugned before us, the High Court allowed the writ petition and directed the appellant to align the Implementation Agreement and Supplementary Implementation Agreements in respect of the quantum of free power with the provisions of the CERC Regulations, 2019 till they remain in force. Further, it directed that if respondent no. 1 supplied any free power above the maximum ceiling limit under the Regulations, the same shall be adjusted. For arriving at this conclusion, the High Court adopted the following reasoning:
4.1 First, it held that the writ petition is maintainable inspite of the arbitration clause in Article 10.1 of the Implementation Agreement as the issues of whether the CERC Regulations, 2019 will override the Implementation Agreement and whether the contractual provisions need to be aligned pertain to enforcement of statutory regulations. Hence, the arbitration clause does not stand in the way of invoking writ jurisdiction.
4.2 The High Court then took note of various provisions of the Electricity Act, the CERC Regulations, 2019, and the CERC’s order dated 17.03.2022 and rejected the appellant’s argument that these do not affect the obligations under the Implementation Agreement and held that the CERC’s order has a direct bearing on the supply of free power by respondent no. 1 to the appellant. Noting that the appellant-State was a party before the CERC and did not contest respondent no. 1’s prayer for relaxing the cap on free power, the Court held that such cap is not only to determine the tariff but is relevant for every other incidental and connected purpose.
4.3 While the CERC in its order dated 17.03.2022 held that inconsistent provisions in the PPA and PSAs stand overridden by the Regulations, the High Court observed that these provisions are the same as in the Implementation Agreement and Supplementary Implementation Agreements. In a composite scheme for generation and sale of electricity, it held that there cannot be any mismatch in respect of the quantum of supply of free electricity. Hence, the corollary of the CERC’s order that the PPA and PSAs stand overridden is that the Implementation Agreement becomes unworkable and must be aligned with the CERC Regulations, 2019.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1119The State of Himachal Pradesh & Anr. v. JSW Hydro Energy Limited & Ors.
4.4 Further, since the appellant-State accepted the CERC’s order, respondent no. 1 was within its right to seek alignment of the Implementation Agreement with the CERC Regulations, 2019 and the CERC’s order.
4.5 The High Court also relied on this Court’s decision in PTC India Ltd. v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission13 where it was held that statutory regulations under the Electricity Act will override existing contracts between regulated entities. On this basis, the High Court concluded that the CERC Regulations, 2019 will have supremacy over contractual undertakings and the provisions of the Implementation Agreement must be aligned accordingly.
IV. Submissions:
5. We have heard Mr. Kapil Sibal and Mr. Parag Tripathi, learned senior counsel for the appellant, and Mr. P. Chidambaram and Dr. A.M. Singhvi, learned senior counsel for respondent nos. 1 and 2. We also heard Mr. Nikhil Nayyar, learned senior counsel for respondent no. 11 (CERC), Ms. Preetika Dwivedi, learned counsel for respondent nos. 7-9 (distribution companies operating in the State of Rajasthan), and Mr. Gurminder Singh, learned senior counsel for respondent no. 10 (distribution company operating in the State of Punjab). Their submissions can be recapitulated as follows: 5.1 Mr. Tripathi and Mr. Sibal appearing for the appellant-State have broadly submitted that the quantum of free power to be supplied under the Implementation Agreement is not regulated or curtailed by the CERC Regulations, 2019 or the CERC’s order dated 17.03.2022. While taking us through the sequence of events, the following submissions have been made:
i. Regulation 2 provides the scope and extent of application of the CERC Regulations, 2019, which is to determine the tariff for generating and transmission companies.
ii. The purport of Note 3 of Regulation 55, which stipulates the 13% cap on free power, is for calculating the bill amount that the generating company can recover from
13 (2010) 4 SCC 603.
1120 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports beneficiaries. It does not prohibit respondent no. 1 from supplying free power beyond this cap. The effect of the cap is that the CERC Regulations, 2019 provide a passthrough to the extent of 13% free power while determining the tariff. Any further supply of free power must be borne by the generating companies from their resources.
iii. Further, that the Regulations govern agreements between the generation and distribution companies but do not extend to the Implementation Agreement, which was executed even prior to the commencement of generation.
In the written submissions, it is further submitted that the Implementation Agreement is a contract for natural resources, and not a tariff agreement. It hence falls outside the ambit of the CERC Regulations, 2019.
iv. In this vein, the learned senior counsel have also referred us to the relevant portions of the CERC’s order dated 17.03.2022 wherein respondent no. 1 prayed for relaxation of the 13% cap while calculating tariff in view of its contractual obligations under the Implementation Agreement. This was rejected by the CERC and it held that the PPA and PSAs executed by respondent no. 1 are overridden by the Regulations. The learned senior counsel submit that respondent no. 1 did not appeal this order before the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity 14 and instead filed a writ petition in 2023 seeking amendment of the Implementation Agreement.
v. Coming to the impugned order of the High Court, they submit that the High Court has proceeded on the basis that the appellant-State is a regulated entity under the Electricity Act, and thereby relied on PTC (supra) where this Court held that contracts between regulated entities stand overridden by statutory regulations under the Electricity Act. They submitted that this is incorrect as the State Government is not a deemed licensee under the third proviso of Section 14 as it is not engaging in transmission, distribution, or trading of electricity.
14 Hereinafter “APTEL”.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1121The State of Himachal Pradesh & Anr. v. JSW Hydro Energy Limited & Ors.
vi. They also submitted that contractual terms could not have been amended in exercise of writ jurisdiction, and the only remedy available to respondent no. 1 was to challenge the validity of the Regulation itself, which it had not done. Regarding the exercise of writ jurisdiction to align the contractual terms with the Regulations, it is further contended in the written submissions that the High Court has rewritten the Implementation Agreement by relying on the PPA and PSAs being overridden as per the CERC’s order dated 17.03.2022. However, the High Court ignored that these agreements are not on the same footing and Article 5.1(b) of the Implementation Agreement provides that it shall not be affected by the PPA.
vii. In the written submissions, the appellant submitted that the quantum of free power was arrived after a series of negotiations with JIL, which was awarded the Project through the MoU route rather than through competitive bidding. In order to avoid competitive bidding, JIL agreed to supply 18% free power during a certain portion of the Agreement period.
viii. The learned senior counsel further submitted that despite a similar cap on free power in the Hydroelectric Policy, 1998 @ 12%, respondent no. 1 knowingly agreed to supply 18% free power in the Implementation Agreement that was executed in 1999. Further, this obligation has been reiterated in all the Supplementary Agreements.
Moreover, the Fourth Supplementary Implementation Agreement was executed in 2021 for additional free power on the enhanced capacity, which was executed after the CERC Regulations, 2019 came into force.
Hence, once respondent no. 1 consented to supplying free power @ 18% despite a similar cap existing all through, the same cannot be avoided by filing a writ petition.
5.2 Mr. Chidambaram, learned senior counsel for respondent no. 1 submitted that the Implementation Agreement, which was negotiated prior to the CERC Regulations, 2019 stands overridden by the Regulations.
1122 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports i. Referring to Article 9 of the Implementation Agreement, he submitted that the rights and obligations under the Agreement are subject to “Law”, which has been widely defined as including regulations. The regulations in this case are framed under the Electricity Act, which was enacted in 2003, after the Implementation Agreement was executed. Prior to this, there was no law restricting the quantum of free power at the time of execution of the Implementation Agreement.
ii. The State Government is a regulated entity under the Electricity Act as it is a deemed licensee as per the third proviso of Section 14. He referred us to certain portions of the writ petition before the High Court, where respondent no. 1 contended that the appellant-State is a deemed licensee and the same was not denied by the appellant in its reply. He also referred to Section 10(2) of the Electricity Act to submit that generating companies can supply electricity to licensees only. On this basis, he submitted that respondent no. 1 is supplying electricity to the appellant-State as a licensee, albeit free of cost. iii. Relying on the decisions of this Court in PTC (supra) as well as Transmission Corporation of A.P. Ltd. v. Rain Calcining Ltd.15 , he submitted that even concluded contracts between regulated entities are overridden by regulations. Since the State Government is a licensee, the Implementation Agreement stands overridden by the Regulations. Further, he submitted that performance of a contract must be in conformity with the law in force at the time.16 iv. He then referred us to Regulation 30 of the CERC Regulations, 2019 that provides for Return on Equity17 to hydro-electric generating companies @ 16.5%, which the generating company earns through tariff on saleable power. The tariff is calculated by considering the free power cap @ 13% as per Note 3 of Regulation 55. However, if the
15 (2021) 13 SCC 674.
16 Relied on Ganga Retreat and Towers Ltd. v. State of Rajasthan, (2003) 12 SCC 91. 17 Hereinafter “RoE”.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1123The State of Himachal Pradesh & Anr. v. JSW Hydro Energy Limited & Ors.
actual free power supply is 18% as per the Agreement, this will negatively impact the RoE. Further, to ensure that RoE is maintained, respondent no. 1 will be required to sell the remaining 82% of power at a higher rate to PTC and the distribution companies, which will ultimately be passed on to the consumers thereby affecting consumer interest. In the written submissions, respondent no. 1 also contended that the cost of generation and supply of electricity must be recovered through tariff as per Section 61 of the Electricity Act. However, if it is required to supply 18% free power despite the 13% cap in the Regulations, it will not recover revenue for 5% of the power it generates and supplies, and this will negatively impact its RoE.
5.3 Dr. Singhvi supplemented these submissions with the following arguments:
i. The consequence of a change in law (i.e., the cap on free power supply) must be borne by both parties, and cannot be unilaterally imposed on the generating company.
ii. The State Government is a regulated entity as per the third proviso to Section 14 as well as under Section 10(2) of the Electricity Act. Hence, the CERC Regulations, 2019 govern and override the contractual obligations under the Implementation Agreement.
iii. Since this is a composite scheme for generation and distribution of electricity, there can be no mismatch on the quantum of free power stipulated in the Implementation Agreement, which is an upstream agreement with the State Government, and the PPA and PSAs, which are downstream agreements with distribution companies.
5.4 We also heard Mr. Nikhil Nayyar for the CERC, who submitted the following:
i. The CERC Regulations, 2019 are only concerned with tariff fixation and neither deal with the Implementation Agreement nor impose restrictions on the quantum of free power supply to the appellant-State. The purport of the Regulations is to cap the free power that will be considered while fixing tariff and whose costs can be passed onto 1124 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the distribution companies and consumers. Since the actual quantum of free power supply is determined by contract, respondent no. 1 must use contractual remedies to challenge the same.
ii. Relying on PTC (supra), he submitted that the CERC is bound by its Regulations, including the cap on free power supply, while determining the tariff. Any further supply is to be met by the generating company from its own resources, which is also stipulated in the Hydro Power Policy, 2008 that forms the basis of the CERC Regulations, 2019.
iii. RoE for respondent no. 1 is stipulated as 16.5% under Regulation 30(2), which is arrived at after considering commercial principles and consumer interest, as per Section 61(b) and (d) of the Electricity Act. Referring to Regulations 14(4), 15, and 18 of the CERC Regulations, 2019, he submitted that the RoE is part of the Annual Fixed Cost, which is used to derive capacity charges that is in turn used to determine the tariff. Hence, RoE forms a part of the tariff itself and the tariff is structured on this basis. RoE is not the same as the net profit of respondent no. 1. In its written submissions, the CERC further submitted that RoE is calculated on the equity component of the Project, which has been granted in full to respondent no. 1 for the 2014-19 and 2019-24 periods.
iv. The CERC’s order dated 17.03.2022 only directs that the PPA and PSAs must be aligned with the Regulations.
It does not deal with or decide on the Implementation Agreement. This order was not challenged by respondent no. 1 before the APTEL, and they instead relied on the same to file a writ petition before the High Court to seek the relief of aligning the Implementation Agreement. The filing of the writ petition is a way to avoid the CERC order dated 17.03.2022 and an attempt to achieve the same result through a different prayer.
5.5 Mr. Gurminder Singh, learned senior counsel submits that the State Government cannot be treated as a deemed licensee in the present case. Further, he submits that the CERC’s role of tariff determination does not extend to allocating or apportioning [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1125The State of Himachal Pradesh & Anr. v. JSW Hydro Energy Limited & Ors.
the power supplied by the generating company to various entities. It only relates to fixation of tariff for such supply, after the generating company has decided the allocation.
5.6 Ms. Preetika Dwivedi submitted that PTC (supra) does not apply as tariff regulation is not concerned with a contract between the State Government and a generating company.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.