State of Rajasthan v. Chatra
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 360; [2025] 4 S.C.R. 95
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sanjay Karol
- Decided
- 17 Mar 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 586/2017
- Sections
- 376, 375, 118
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 95 : 2025 INSC 360 State of Rajasthan v.
Chatra (Criminal Appeal No. 586 of 2017)
18 March 2025 [Vikram Nath and Sanjay Karol,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the High Court erred in reversing the conviction of the respondent-accused under Section 376, Penal Code, 1860 for the rape of a minor girl and acquitting him.
Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – s.376 – Evidence of a child witness-victim – Appreciation of – Rape of minor girl – High Court reversed the conviction of the respondent-accused inter alia holding that the victim-child witness was indifferent/silent about the incident which was unlikely if the incident would have been true, and acquitted him – Challenge to:
Held: There is no hard and fast rule qua testing the competency of a child witness to testify at trial – In the present case, though the child witness-victim (‘V’) did not depose anything about the commission of the offence against her however, her silence cannot accrue to the benefit of the respondent – Her silence cannot be equated with the silence of a fully realised adult prosecutrix – There is no hard and fast rule that in the absence of the testimony of the prosecutrix, a conviction cannot stand, particularly when other evidence, medical and circumstantial, is available pointing to such a conclusion – The absence of evidence of the prosecutrix is, not in all cases, a negative to be accounted for in the prosecution case – PW-14, the Doctor stated that the cause of injury to ‘V’ can be through sexual intercourse – This along with the finding of injury on the genital organ of the accused being possible only due to forceful intercourse with a minor female, leads to a circumstance pointing to the respondent having committed the offense against ‘V’ – Acquittal of the respondent is set aside, conviction restored – Circumstantial evidence. [Paras 14, 17, 20-22] Evidence – Testimony of a child witness – Principles – Discussed. [Para 14] * Author 96 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Case Law Cited Hemudan Nanbha Gadhvi v. State of Gujarat [2018] 12 SCR 672 : (2019) 17 SCC 523 – relied on.
Atley v. State of U.P., AIR 1955 SC 807; Geeta Devi v. State of U.P [2022] 1 SCR 428; Bhupinder Sharma v. State of H.P. [2003] Supp. 4 SCR 792 : (2003) 8 SCC 551; State of Karnataka v. Puttaraja [2003] Supp. 6 SCR 274: (2004) 1 SCC 475; Dinesh v. State of Rajasthan [2006] 2 SCR 793 : (2006) 3 SCC 771; Nipun Saxena v. Union of India [2018] 14 SCR 755 : (2019) 2 SCC 703; State of Rajasthan v. Om Prakash [2002] 3 SCR 753 : (2002) 5 SCC 745; Dattu Ramrao Sakhare v. State of Maharashtra (1997) 5 SCC 341; Hari Om v. State of U.P. [2021] 13 SCR 49 : (2021) 4 SCC 345; Suryanarayana v. State of Karnataka [2001] 1 SCR 1: (2001) 9 SCC 129; State of H.P. v. Sanjay Kumar [2016] 9 SCR 237 : (2017) 2 SCC 51; Pradeep v. State of Haryana, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 777; State of Madhya Pradesh v. Balveer Singh, 2025 INSC 261: 2025 SCC OnLine 390; State of M.P v. Ramesh [2011] 5 SCR 1 : (2011) 4 SCC 786; Panchhi v. State of U.P. [1998] Supp. 1 SCR 40 : (1998) 7 SCC 177; State of U.P. v. Ashok Dixit [2000] 1 SCR 855 : (2000) 3 SCC 70; Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra [1985] SCR 88: (1984) 4 SCC 116; Ramakant Rai v. Madan Rai [2003] Supp. 4 SCR 17 : (2003) 12 SCC 395; K. Gopal Reddy v. State of A.P. [1979] 2 SCR 363 : (1979) 1 SCC 355; State of Maharashtra v. Bandu alias Daulat (2018) 11 SCC 163; Patan Jamal Vali v. State of A.P [2021] 3 SCR 470 : (2021) 16 SCC 225; Mange v. State of Haryana (1979) 4 SCC 349; State of Punjab v. Kartar Singh [1994] 2 SCR 375 : (1994) 3 SCC 569; Sanjeev Kumar Gupta v. State of U.P [2015] 5 SCR 122 : (2015) 11 SCC 69 – referred to.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860.
List of Keywords Rape; Child victim; Child witness; Evidence of a child witness; Sexual assault; Injury to private parts; Sexual intercourse; Absence of evidence of the prosecutrix; Injury on genital organ; Minor female; Forceful intercourse; Silence; Circumstantial evidence; Chain of circumstances; Absence of the testimony of the prosecutrix. [2025] 4 S.C.R. 97State of Rajasthan v. Chatra Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
586 of 2017 From the Judgment and Order dated 12.07.2013 of the High Court of Rajasthan at Jaipur in SBCRA No. 503 of 1987 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Ms. Sansriti Pathak, A.A.G., Milind Kumar.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Ranbir Singh Yadav, Prateek Yadav, Puran Mal Saini, Ms. Anzu K. Varkey.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Sanjay Karol, J.
1. Nearly forty years ago, on 3 rd March 1986 happened an incident, that forever altered the trajectory of a minor girl’s life, who for the purposes of this judgment, shall be referred to as ‘V’ 1 . She was discovered unconscious and bleeding from her private parts, by one Gulab Chand, after the respondent-accused had allegedly subjected her to sexual assault. The said Gulab Chand filed a report with the concerned police station on 4 th March, 1986 2 - and now by way of this judgment, the matter shall be finally laid to rest. It is a matter of great sadness that this minor girl and her family have to go through nearly four decades of life, waiting to close this horrific chapter of her/their lives.
2. The State is before us, being aggrieved by the finding of acquittal recorded by the learned Single Judge of the High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan at Jaipur Bench, Jaipur 3 , vide judgment dated 12 th July 1 Identity concealed 2 Crime No. 31/86 3 In S.B Criminal Appeal No. 503/1987 98 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 2013 which set aside the finding of conviction entered by learned Sessions Judge, Tonk 4 vide judgment dated 19 th November 1987.
3. The FIR recorded the occurrence of incident in the following terms:- “To, The S.H.O.
Uniyara.
Sir, Subject : With regard to the rape with ‘V’ D/o ‘X’5 . It is respectfully submitted that it is incident of about 1:30 hours that I had gone to handle well on hut of Khadda in village Sureli, and as soon as I reached near the house of Chhatra S/o Sukhdeva Jat then I heard sound of cry of a little girl, where upon I entered into the house then the dhoti of accused was in open condition and he ran outside seeing me. I saw that ‘V’ who is daughter of ‘X’ was lying unconscious and blood was oozing from her private part, at that time Prabhu Kumhar came there on camel Lattha from the side of Banatha, as such I sit with girl over the Lattha of camel and brought her to house because neither Mother of her was present in house and nor ‘X’. After some time Savitri mother of ‘V’ came to our village but since any means of conveyance was not available for going to police station therefore report was not lodged. Primary treatment was provided by calling nurse of Sureli and Private Sindhi Doctor Siwad and thereafter today after coming from there I had lodged report in police station.
Applicant – Gulab Chand S/o Sunder Lal Caste Mahajan R/o Sureli Sd/- Gulab Chand Gupta Date 4.3.86”
4 Sessions Trial 26/86 5 Name of the father of the victim is also redacted for the purpose of protection of identity [2025] 4 S.C.R. 99State of Rajasthan v. Chatra
4. After completion of the investigation, the challan was presented to the Court for trial. To prove its version of events, the prosecution examined 15 witnesses and exhibited 19 documents. The respondent-accused termed it to be a false case that Gulab Chand had concocted since he wanted the father of ‘V’ to vacate the house of the respondentaccused. He put forth 2 witnesses and four documents in his defence.
TRIAL COURT JUDGMENT
5. The sole issue before the Trial Court was whether the respondentaccused had sexually assaulted ‘V’ or not. A perusal of the judgments reveals that the complainant, Gulab Chand who was examined as PW-2 has been greatly relied on, supported by the deposition of PW-14, Dr. Vasudev. Regarding the commission of sexual assault against ‘V’, the finding is as under :
“39. In such situation when we again believe on deposition of PW-2 Gulabchand then his such evidence that accused committed forcible rape with PW-1 ‘V’ becomes believable and in this regard deposition of PW-2 Gulabchand stands corroborated from deposition of PW-14 Vasudev that what injury in vagina of PW-1 ‘V’ was caused, that was caused by forcible sexual intercourse and that sexual intercourse was forcibly committed by accused with PW-1. PW-14 Dr. Vasudev has stated even to the extent that the hymen of PW-1 ‘V’ was completely fresh ruptured and her forshite and posterior commissions ruptured and doctor has also stated that if there was slight more penetration then the penis would have reached in stomach of girl after rupturing uterus and by which death of girl might have caused.
Thus from the evidence of this doctor it is clear that what penetration was done by accused in vagina of PW-1 that was grievous and from doing such whatever ingredients in section 375 IPC are told are fulfilled.”
There was an issue of motive raised by the counsel for the accused. However, neither that nor the possibility that the injury sustained by ‘V’ was as a result of injury by a nail found favour with the Court. There was also the aspect of the FIR being lodged on the next day. On this issue, the Trial Court held that given P.S. Uniyara, was situated 14 kms. away from the village where the incident took 100 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports place, i.e., Sureli, and that the injuries sustained by ‘V’ were quite severe, the delay was held to be justified. It was finally held that the respondent-accused had indeed committed the offence punishable under Section 376 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 6 , and he was, vide order of sentencing dated 19 th November 1987 sentenced to 7 years rigorous imprisonment instead of 10 years given that he was a first-time offender and at the relevant time of the offence he was aged only 21 years. He was further sentenced to pay a fine of Rs.500/- in default and one month of simple imprisonment.
IMPUGNED JUDGMENT
6. The respondent-accused aggrieved by the sentence awarded to him, carried the matter in appeal to the High Court. By way of a judgment running into all of 6 pages, the findings of guilt returned by the Trial Court were upturned and the respondent-accused was acquitted of the charges against him. Suffice it to say that we are surprised with the manner in which this matter was dealt with by the High Court. As the First Appellate Court, the High Court is expected to independently assess the evidence before it before confirming or disturbing the findings of the Court below. This is the settled position of law. [See: Atley v. State of U.P.; 7 and Geeta Devi v. State of U.P. etc. 8 ]. Clearly, the same has not been followed. The discussion on merits of the matter by the High Court is reproduced herein below :
“The statement of PW-2 Gulab Chand, the central witness of the prosecution, as recorded in Ex.D-1, assumes importance. A bare perusal of that document reveals that he is stated to have witnessed the appellant to be engaged in the act of forcible sexual intercourse with the victim, when he entered the room. This runs counter to the narration made in his written report on which the investigation was initiated as well as his deposition at the trial. PW-10 Prabhu also has not supported him in full. His statement that his attention was drawn by the cries of the victim is 6 Hereafter ‘IPC’
7 AIR 1955 SC 807
8 Criminal Appeal No.78 of 2022 [2025] 4 S.C.R. 101State of Rajasthan v. Chatra belied by her statement that she was found unconscious and unable to speak.
Though the victim, ‘V’ 9 was a child at the time of her examination in Court, it is unlikely that if the incident would have been true she would have been so indifferent and inert as she happened to be when asked about the same. It seems that no attempt as well had been made to brief her in this regard. Though keeping her age in mind, the incident even if had occurred in the manner as projected by the prosecution, could have been forgotten by her, it is not acceptable that if true, the parents or her relations would have made no attempt to have at least the skeletal facts narrated in court through her. This assumes importance in view of the consistent stand taken on behalf of the defence that the appellant had been framed due to subsisting dispute between him and the father of the victim. Though the medical evidence proves injury on her private parts, the Forensic Science Laboratory report does not show the presence of semen in the frock of the victim, the lungi on which she was laid by Gulab Chand (PW-2) and also the blood smeared soil by the police. The varying versions of Gulab Chand is also a factor which strikes at the trustworthiness of the prosecution case.
On a cumulative consideration of all the above, I am thus of the view that the prosecution has not been able to prove the charge beyond all reasonable doubt, and that, the appellant is entitled to the benefit thereof. The impugned judgment and order is set aside. The appeal is allowed. The appellant stands discharged from his bail bonds.
While acknowledging the assistance rendered by Mr. Raunak Singhvi, learned amicus curiae, this Court directs payment of his professional fee of Rs.5000/- to be borne by the State Government.”
7. We note with some surprise that the High Court has referred to the victim by name throughout. This Court in judgments, going at least 9 Name redacted 102 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports a decade further back from the date of the impugned judgment, has highlighted the importance of abiding by such a restriction, preserving the privacy of the unfortunate victim, even though the restriction does not expressly apply to the High Court or this Court. [See: Bhupinder Sharma v. State of H.P.;10 State of Karnataka v. Puttaraja;11 and Dinesh v. State of Rajasthan12] We have redacted the name of the child victim. The record as it is before us, does not conceal the name of the prosecutrix, however, considering the fact that the directions in Nipun Saxena v. Union of India13 were issued in the pendency of this appeal, her name stands redacted even in the portion quoted from the record.
8. In ordinary circumstances, given the fleeting consideration bestowed on the merits of the matter, an order of remand to the High Court for consideration afresh, could have been a permissible view, however as already noted supra the genesis of this case is 40 years old, and, therefore, justice would not be served by adopting this approach, especially taking note of the fact that an appeal of the year 1987 was disposed of by the impugned judgment in the year 2013. In other words, it took twenty-six years for the criminal appeal to be disposed of. As such, we now proceed to examine the evidence on record.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
9. The mainstay of the reasoning of the High Court are the statements of PW-1, ‘V’, PW-2, and PW-10.
The relevant extract of the statement of the victim (PW -1) is as follows :
“Question : Are you studying.
Ans : Yes I am studying.
Question : In which standard are you studying.
Ans : I am studying in 1st standard.
10 (2003) 8 SCC 551
11 (2004) 1 SCC 475
12 (2006) 3 SCC 771
13 (2019) 2 SCC 703
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 103State of Rajasthan v. Chatra Question : Do you know meaning of smell.
Ans : Yes.
Question : Should speak lie or should speak truth?
Ans : Should speak truth.
Note :- The witness knows meaning of truth, although has small age. The mother of witness is present in the court with the witness. The learned counsel for the accused has objection that mother of witness will have to go outside the court as she is also witness in the matter. As the mother of the witness is not eye-witness of the occurrence and is a witness of facts after the occurrence and witness has small age and not capable in standing in the court room in absence of mother, therefore, on the prayer of P.P., the permission of presence of mother in the court room granted and instructed not to suggest any answer to the witness to the questions asked to the witness.
Question : Do you know the accused?
Ans: Said yes by nodding neck Question: Do you know the name of the accused?
Ans: Witness is not giving answers on aking repeatedly and keeps silent.
Question: What happens with you and when?
Ans: The learned P.P., her mother and Court repeatedly explained to give answer, but witness keeps mum and not speak a single word. Tears were flowing from eyes on much pressure, but not speak from mouth”
PW-2 Gulab Chand :
“…when I open the door I have seen that accused Chatra, he was present in the court was seating upon her on that time. When accused saw me he ran away from the room accused dhoti was open and lying on there. When I sent to support her at that time she was in a unconscious 104 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports condition and the blood was oozing from her private part, on back side of her body one white cloth was lying down on which blood stain was there … ... On Exhibit B-1 there is no mentioing about the accused seating upon the girl ‘V’, How they cannot remember to write about this on their report I don’t know. On Exhibit D-1 about this nothing is mentioned, I told to the police about this. On Exhibit B-1, they did not wrote on a report about the piece of cloth choke inside the mouth of ‘V’, so that she cannot shout at that time, when I opened the door accused saw me and ran away at that time.
Therefore, I cannot say that at that time when accused was above [‘V’] at that time accused arms was open or not.”
PW-10 Prabhu 14 :
“… I came near the hut of Khadda to find that X’s daughter was unconscious at the ‘Bayana Chabootri’. I then went to drop off the load I was carrying on the cart, and then proceeded towards Sureli, and then stopped of at the house of PW-2 Gulabchand. There was no other male with me, in the cart at that time. The child was in a bad state and her clothes were soiled with blood. There was blood oozing out from her private parts. I did not see the accused at the spot of the crime.
… The police did not question me. It is wrong to say that when I reached Khadda’s hut, at that time the accused Vatar/Chatra was running away from the scene catching a hold of his dhoti, towards the riverbank.”
10. At this stage, let us consider the other witnesses relevant to the prosecution case. PW-14, the doctor, testified as follows: “....I medically examine the accused Chatra on 13.03.86, On his penis top, scratch spot was found and on his penis 14 Translated from the original record [2025] 4 S.C.R. 105State of Rajasthan v. Chatra swelling was found, and scratch was also found. These type of wound can only be found by forcefully inter-course with minor girl.....
.....
“....At the time of examination there was no blood oozing from the private part of ‘V’ but the blood spot was found all round the private part. In ‘V’ private inside by seeing from microscope I did not find spermatozoa. In 3 years old child the distance between the private part inside inner kennel and uterus, are very less the if the penetration will be more, then the pennies will torn the uterus and penetrate till the stomach of the girl due to which the girl can die. There was injury in inner kennel but there is no injury in uterus….”
11. PW-3, Savitri, the mother of ‘V’ testified that she had to go to a neighbouring village since someone there had passed away. When she left her village, she had entrusted the care of ‘V’ to the respondent accused. When she returned from having attended the funeral procession in the neighbouring village, she was informed by the women of her village that ‘V’ had been injured and taken to Sureli. She also went there subsequently and found that ‘V’ was unconscious. She has positively identified the clothes worn by the victim. The nurse at the hospital informed her that ‘V’ had been raped.
DW-1 is the brother of the respondent-accused. He testified that ‘X’ was a tenant of theirs and had been asked to vacate said dwelling, but he refused to do so. He further testified that PW-2 Gulab Chand had bribed the doctor with Rs.4,000/-, for him to say in the report that ‘V’ had been sexually assaulted. Further, it was said that the doctor asked him to pay Rs.7,000/- and if paid, so the report was to say that ‘V’ was not raped. He did not pay the money and instead lodged complaints which fell on deaf ears. He denies that Savitri, PW-3 had left ‘V’ in the care of the accused and that he had committed sexual assault against her.
12. Let us now consider pronouncements of this Court in cases involving a child victim of sexual assault.
106 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports In State of Rajasthan v. Om Prakash 15 this Court sounded a warning against offences of sexual nature against children, in the following terms:
“19. Child rape cases are cases of perverse lust for sex where even innocent children are not spared in pursuit of sexual pleasure. There cannot be anything more obscene than this. It is a crime against humanity. Many such cases are not even brought to light because of the social stigma attached thereto. According to some surveys, there has been a steep rise in child rape cases. Children need special care and protection. In such cases, responsibility on the shoulders of the courts is more onerous so as to provide proper legal protection to these children. Their physical and mental immobility call for such protection. Children are the natural resource of our country. They are the country›s future. Hope of tomorrow rests on them. In our country, a girl child is in a very vulnerable position and one of the modes of her exploitation is rape besides other modes of sexual abuse. These factors point towards a different approach required to be adopted…”
In numerous cases, this Court as well as others, have discussed the applicability of the statement of a child witness to a case. We may notice a few of them:
In Dattu Ramrao Sakhare v. State of Maharashtra 16 this Court held : “5….A child witness if found competent to depose to the facts and reliable one such evidence could be the basis of conviction. In other words even in the absence of oath the evidence of a child witness can be considered under Section 118 of the Evidence Act provided that such witness is able to understand the questions and able to give rational answers thereof. The evidence of a child witness and credibility thereof would depend upon the circumstances of each case. The only precaution which the court should bear in mind while assessing the evidence of a child
15 (2002) 7 SCC 745
16 (1997) 5 SCC 341
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 107State of Rajasthan v. Chatra witness is that the witness must be a reliable one and his/ her demeanour must be like any other competent witness and there is no likelihood of being tutored…”
In Hari Om v. State of U.P.,17 a three-Judge Bench reiterated the caution observed by this Court in Suryanarayana v. State of Karnataka,18 that “corroboration of the testimony of a child witness is not a rule but a measure of caution and prudence”. It was further observed therein :
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.