M/S Chithra Woods Manors Welfare Association v. Shaji Augustine
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 567; [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2707
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Augustine George Masih
- Decided
- 24 Apr 2025
- Case number
- CONTEMPT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 712/2023
- Sections
- 2, 17, 37
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 2707 : 2025 INSC 567 M/s Chithra Woods Manors Welfare Association v.
Shaji Augustine (Contempt Petition (Civil) No. 712 of 2023 In SLP (Civil) No. 17433 of 2021)
24 April 2025 [Abhay S. Oka and Augustine George Masih,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the Respondent-alleged contemnor is guilty of civil contempt for non-compliance of the directions issued by this Court vide Order dated 07.11.2022.
Headnotes† Contempt of Court Act, 1971 – s.2(b) – Civil contempt – When – Agreement entered between the Petitioner-Association and Respondent permitted the latter to occupy and use the Property of the Petitioner for 10 years on payment of licence fees – Persistent defaults in the payment of licence fees by the Respondent – Litigation between parties across forums; settlement Agreement arrived at however, Respondent again defaulted in making payment thereunder – Eventually, matter reached this court; vide order dtd. 07.11.2022 as an interim measure, Respondent was directed to pay arrears of use and occupation charges in six monthly instalments – Non-compliance by the Respondent alleging financial incapabilities – Contempt Petition filed by the Association: Held: Civil contempt means wilful disobedience of judgment, decree, or direction, order, writ or other process of the Court or wilful breach of an undertaking given to the Court – All throughout, the Respondent had been in possession of the property and utilising the income generated from running of the said resort – Non-fulfilment of the mandate and direction of this Court which were at the request of the Respondent himself reflects his intent to not comply with the order rather to violate the same with impunity – The conduct clearly reflects that the intention of the Respondent was to gain the benefit by running the resort in the subject property without paying the current liability, what to say of the arrears – A party, * Author 2708 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports misguiding the Court to pass an order which was never intended to be complied with, would constitute an act of overawing the due process of law and, thus, commit contempt of Court – From the very beginning till the very end the Respondent took the Court for a ride – There has been intentional and deliberate non-compliance on the part of the Respondent of the order passed by this Court, contempt of which stands committed, but on getting an interim order of continuing in possession usurped the earnings instead of paying off the dues – Therefore, the malafide is writ large – Respondent guilty of Civil Contempt – 3 months simple imprisonment imposed with fine of INR 20,000/- – However, 30 days granted as one more opportunity to purge the contempt and comply with the Order dtd. 07.11.2022. [Paras 28, 31, 36, 41, 42] Case Law Cited In re Hira Lal Dixit and Two Others [1955] 1 SCR 677 : (1954) 2 SCC 325; Bank of India v. Vijay Transport and Others [2000] Supp. 3 SCR 685 : (2000) 8 SCC 512; Sitaram Enterprises v. Prithviraj Vardichand Jain [2024] 9 SCR 414 : 2024 SCC OnLine SC 2493 – referred to.
List of Acts Contempt of Court Act, 1971.
List of Keywords Contempt of Court; Civil contempt; Wilful disobedience; Nonpayment of arrears of use and occupation charges; Malafide intention; Misguiding the Court; Misuse of the process of court; Intentional and deliberate non-compliance of the order of court; Wilful breach of an undertaking given to the Court; Not approaching the Court with clean hands; Tarnish the image of judiciary. Case Arising From INHERENT JURISDICTION: Contempt Petition (Civil) No. 712 of 2023 In SLP (Civil) No. 17433 of 2021 From the Judgment and Order dated 01.12.2023 of Supreme Court of India at New Delhi in SLP (C) No. 17433 of 2021 [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2709M/s Chithra Woods Manors Welfare Association v. Shaji Augustine Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Petitioner:
Nishe Rajen Shonker, Babu Karukapadath, Mrs. Anu K Joy, Alim Anvar.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Lakshmeesh S. Kamath, Mrs. Samriti Ahuja, Ms. Aditi Prakash, Karan Singh Dalal, Aditya Shenoy.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Augustine George Masih, J.
1. The instant Contempt Petition (Civil) No. 712 of 2023 (hereinafter referred to as “instant Petition”) in SLP (C) No. 17433 of 2021 (hereinafter referred to as “main Petition”) was filed during its pendency by M/s Chithra Woods Manors Welfare Association, being the Respondent No. 01 therein (hereinafter referred to as “Petitioner Association”), alleging non-payment of arrears of use and occupation charges for period between 20.09.2021 and 31.11.2022 in six monthly instalments beginning 31.12.2022, as directed by this Court vide Order dated 07.11.2022 in the main Petition.
2. This petition was then tagged along with the main Petition vide Order dated 24.02.2023 and eventually, owing to the said non-payment of arrears, the main Petition was disposed of as this Court observed to not entertain the prayer of Mr Shaji Augustine, the Petitioner therein (hereinafter referred to as “Respondent-Contemnor”) but the proceedings in instant Petition sustained.
3. Facts forming the backdrop of the instant Petition are that the Petitioner Association is owner of the decree scheduled building, consisting of 96 furnished studio apartments, at Munnar, Kerala (hereinafter referred to as the “said Property”). An agreement was entered between the Petitioner Association and Respondent- Contemnor on 26.01.2014, permitting the latter to occupy and use the said Property for a period of 10 years as against payment of licence fees of INR 12 Lakhs per month (hereinafter referred to as the “said Agreement).
2710 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
4. Within a short period of entering into the said Agreement, Respondent- Contemnor defaulted in payment of the license fees. On persistent default, Petitioner Association was constrained to institute OS No.30 of 2015 before the Sub Court at Thodupuzha, Kerala for realization of the arrears and other reliefs. As there was an arbitration clause in the said Agreement and on consent of the parties herein, the dispute was referred to a Sole Arbitrator.
5. Before the Sole Arbitrator, the Petitioner Association moved I.A. No. 01 of 2016 under Section 17 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as “A&C Act”), seeking direction to the Respondent-Contemnor to deposit INR 1,65,73,459/- (Rupees One crore Sixty-Five Lakhs Seventy-Three Thousand Four Hundred Fifty-Nine only) during pendency of the proceedings. The same was partially allowed vide Order dated 23.06.2016 with direction to deposit INR 1,36,49,439/- (Rupees One crore Thirty-Six Lakhs Forty-Nine Thousand Four Hundred Thirty-Nine only) and per undertaking of the Respondent-Contemnor, payment of INR 12 lakhs per mensem for month of June 2016 onwards, on or before the 10 th of the succeeding month, pending disposal of the proceedings.
6. Both Respondent-Contemnor and Petitioner Association moved in appeal under Section 37 of the A&C Act before the District Court at Ernakulam, Kerala. A Common Order dated 21.01.2017 was passed, staying the proceedings before the Sole Arbitrator with reiteration of direction to Respondent-Contemnor to pay arrears at the rate of INR 12 Lakhs per month with effect from 08.09.2016 with a further order to continue to pay INR 12 Lakhs per month towards monthly license fee.
7. This common order was challenged by the Respondent-Contemnor before the High Court of Kerala in O.P. (C) No 552 of 2017. The matter was referred for mediation at the request of the parties. The said mediation proceedings, lead to a Compromise dated 03.04.2017 (hereinafter referred to as the “Settlement Agreement”), Petitioner Association agreed to reduce the monthly license fees to INR 8 Lakhs per month. Arrears, as claimed before the Sole Arbitrator, were also reduced from INR 1,65,73,439/- to INR 75 Lakhs. Moreover, it was specifically recorded that the settlement entered between the parties would form part of the judgment. There was a specific clause that in case of default by any of the parties to any of the terms of the agreement the other would be entitled to proceed against the other party. The parties resolved their disputes, and the terms of settlement [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2711M/s Chithra Woods Manors Welfare Association v. Shaji Augustine arrived at between them were accepted by the High Court of Kerala and were incorporated in the Order dated 11.04.2017.
8. On default on the part of the Respondent-Contemnor in making payment through a promissory note, as per the Settlement Agreement, Petitioner Association preferred Execution Petition No. 58 of 2020 on 11.03.2020, no money was paid by the Respondent-Contemnor with effect from the month of July 2018. The Respondent-Contemnor was unsuccessful before the District Court in EA No. 14 of 2021 in its challenge to the maintainability of the execution petition. The Execution Court passed an Order dated 23.03.2021, giving an instalment facility to the Respondent-Contemnor for payments of its arrears, with the first being due on 01.06.2021 and the last being 01.09.2021. Furthermore, the amount of arrears being undisputed, and nothing having been paid, the Execution Court ordered delivery of the said Property. The Respondent-Contemnor challenged the order of the Execution Court before the High Court of Kerala, which was dismissed vide Judgment dated 20.09.2021.
9. It is at this stage that the respondent preferred the main Petition before this Court challenging the Judgment dated 20.09.2021. Notice was issued vide Order dated 12.11.2021 and subsequently, status quo was ordered vide Order dated 04.02.2022 vis-à-vis the said Property. The matter ultimately came for consideration on 07.11.2022 when following Order was passed:- “List on a non-miscellaneous day in the month of March, 2023.
In the meanwhile, as an interim measure, we are inclined to direct that the petitioner will pay Rs. 12 lakhs per month to the respondent as use and occupation charges w.e.f.
20.09.2021 (the date of the impugned judgment). As prayed on behalf of the petitioner, the arrears @ Rs. 12 lakhs per month from 20.09.2021 till 31.11.2022, would be paid in six monthly instalments beginning 31.12.2022. The petitioner would also continue to make payment of Rs. 12 lakhs per month in the future by the 10th day of each succeeding calendar month.
The payment would be subject to the outcome of the present Special Leave Petition.”
2712 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
10. A perusal of the above would show that a direction was issued to the Respondent-Contemnor to pay arrears for the period specified therein in six monthly instalments beginning from 31.12.2022, totalling to INR 172 Lakhs, at the rate of INR 12 Lakhs per month, and being INR 28.60 Lakhs per instalment.
11. Pursuant to the Order dated 07.11.2022, the Respondent-Contemnor sent an e-mail to the Petitioner Association containing a letter dated 17.11.2022 seeking the concerned account details of the Petitioner Association for the Respondent-Contemnor to transfer the arrears enabling him to affect compliance with Order dated 07.11.2022 passed by this Court. The said details were provided by the Petitioner Association on 14.12.2022 in response to the aforesaid e-mail. Despite getting the required information, no amount was paid to the Petitioner Association and yet, the Respondent-Contemnor continued to enjoy and occupy the said Property. It is apparent that the intention on the part of the Respondent-Contemnor was not to do away with the possession of the said Property and to hold on to it owing to his act of moving the main Petition for challenging the handing over of the possession of the said Property.
12. Petitioner Association asserts that deliberate action on behalf of the respondent in not complying with the direction issued by this Court on 17.11.2022 with continuous default on his part amounts to civil contempt which is deliberate and intentional disobedience of the order of this Court.
13. Subsequently, on 01.12.2023, when both the main Petition and instant Petition were taken up for hearing following order was passed:- “The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner states that the petitioner has already vacated the premises subject matter of this Special Leave Petition.
We find that the order dated 7 th November, 2022 directing the petitioner to deposit money has not been complied with. The petitioner has expressed inability to pay the money. The jurisdiction of this Court under Article 136 of the Constitution of India is always discretionary.
Considering the conduct of the petitioner of not paying a single farthing after 7 th November, 2022, we decline [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2713M/s Chithra Woods Manors Welfare Association v. Shaji Augustine to entertain this Special Leave Petition and the same is accordingly dismissed.
However, the question of law is kept open to be considered in an appropriate case.
Pending application also stand disposed of.
CONMT. PET. (C) No. 712/2023 in SLP(C) No. 17433/2021.
List on 22nd January, 2024.”
14. With the main Petition having been dismissed, the instant Petition continued to survive and was taken up for hearing on various dates. Respondent-Contemnor was called upon by this Court on 15.03.2024 to file an affidavit giving details of all his movable and immovable assets as also that of his immediate family members along with the necessary documents. This was in light of the statement of the counsel of the Respondent-Contemnor that he is not in a position to deposit any amount.
15. After filing of the affidavit by the Respondent-Contemnor and on perusal thereof this Court on 12.09.2024 found the Respondent- Contemnor, who was appearing through video conferencing, of having committed wilful breach of the directions contained in the Order dated 07.11.2022. The Respondent-Contemnor was ordered to be heard on the said charge as no amount had been paid by him and was directed to be personally present in Court. The Respondent- Contemnor subsequently appeared and an opportunity was given to comply with the Order while being heard on charge. Owing to his non-intention to comply, the case was kept reserved for orders.
16. Stand of the Respondent-Contemnor in the affidavit which has been filed is that the compliance of the Order dated 07.11.2022 passed by this Court is beyond his financial and physical capabilities. It is thus, neither deliberate nor an intentional non-compliance of the order and is only on account of his penury. He has, thus, prayed for dropping of the current contempt proceedings.
17. Counsel for the Petitioner Association, on the other hand, has asserted that the conduct of the Respondent-Contemnor from the very beginning was clearly indicative of an attempt on the part of the Respondent-Contemnor to hold on to the possession of the said Property. Despite the Settlement Agreement, which has attained 2714 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports finality by virtue of not being challenged, to retain the possession of the said Property, Respondent-Contemnor has constantly litigated across forums. Such an act on part of the Respondent-Contemnor clearly showed that without making payment of the amount due to the petitioners, he was reaping the fruits of the scheduled property in violation of the terms of settlement.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.