State of U.P. & Another v. Miss Bhavna Tiwari & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 747; [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2687
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 29 Apr 2025
- Case number
- SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) No. 9298/2018
- Sections
- 33, 25, 57, 24
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 2687 : 2025 INSC 747 State of U.P. & Another v.
Miss Bhavna Tiwari & Ors.
(Special Leave Petition (C) No. 9298 of 2018)
29 April 2025 [J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Streamlining of the counselling process in NEET-PG; curbing the malpractice of seat blocking to ensure transparency and fairness in the admission process; compensation of Rs.10,00,000/- awarded by the High Court to the respondents for seat blocking in NEET- PG counselling, if was justified.
Headnotes† Education/Educational Courses – Post Graduate Medical Courses – Admission process – NEET PG counselling – Malpractice of seat blocking – Prevention of – Need for transparency and fairness – Directions issued to the concerned authorities to ensure effective implementation of the revised counselling framework:
Held: Implementation of a Nationally synchronized counselling calendar to align All India Quota (AIQ ) and State rounds and prevent seat blocking across systems – Pre-Counselling Fee Disclosure by all private/deemed universities, detailing tuition, hostel, caution deposit, and miscellaneous charges to be mandatory – Establishment of a Centralized Fee Regulation Framework under the National Medical Commission (NMC) – Permitting upgrade windows post-round 2 for admitted candidates to shift to better seats without reopening counselling to new entrants – Publication of raw scores, answer keys and normalization formulae for transparency in multi-shift NEET-PG exams – Enforcement of strict penalties for seat blocking including forfeiture of security deposit, disqualification from future NEET-PG exams (for repeat offenders), blacklisting of complicit colleges – Implementation of Aadhaar-based seat tracking to prevent multiple seat holdings and misrepresentation – State authorities and institutional DMEs to be held accountable under contempt or disciplinary action for rule or schedule violations – Uniform Counselling Conduct Code to be 2688 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports adopted across all States for standard rules on eligibility, mop-up rounds, seat withdrawal, and grievance timelines – A third-party oversight mechanism to be set up under NMC for annual audits of counselling data, compliance, and admission fairness. [Para 16] Education/Educational Courses – Post Graduate medical courses – Admission process – NEET PG counselling – Respondent Nos.1, 2 (aspirants in the first NEET-PG) filed writ petitions alleging large-scale seat blocking, stating that nearly 80% of the seats were filled during the mop-up round resulting in the seats of their first preference being eventually allotted to less meritorious candidates – High Court issued specific directions to the Government authorities and also directed payment of compensation to the Respondents for seat blocking – Challenge to:
Held: Various reforms introduced by the authorities address the concerns raised by the High Court in the impugned order ensuring that meritorious students are not deprived of their rightful opportunities, impugned order not interfered with in entirety – Directions issued by this Court to ensure the effective implementation of the revised counselling framework upholding the principles of merit, fairness and transparency – However, on facts, no valuable right was denied to the respondents regarding participation in the mop-up round and once admission was granted, the process concluded unless specific exceptions applied as per the admission guidelines – Award of Rs.10,00,000/- each as compensation is arbitrary and excessive – Rs.1,00,000/- awarded each to Respondent Nos.1 and 2 – Impugned order modified. [Paras 14.4, 15.3, 15.4] Education/Educational Courses – Post Graduate Medical Courses – Admission process – NEET PG counselling – Malpractice of seat blocking – Discussed. [Paras 7, 8] Case Law Cited Sharwan Kumar v. DGHS and Others (1993) 3 SCC 332; Ashish Ranjan v. Union of India (2016) 11 SCC 225; Modern Dental College and Research Centre v. State of Madhya Pradesh [2016] 3 SCR 579 : (2016) 7 SCC 353; Christian Medical College Vellore Association v. Medical Council of India, Order of Supreme Court dated 03.05.2017 in WP(C) No. 261 of 2017; Education Promotion [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2689State of U.P. & Another v. Miss Bhavna Tiwari & Ors. Society of India v. Union of India, Order of Supreme Court dated 04.05.2017 in WP(C) No. 244 of 2017; Nihila P.P. v. the Medical Counselling Committee and Others, 2021 SCC OnLine SC 3283; Dar-us-Slam Educational Trust v. MCI, Order of Supreme Court dated 09.05.2017 – referred to.
List of Acts Medical Council Act, 1956; National Medical Commission Act, 2019; MCI Postgraduate Medical Education Regulations and Regulations on Graduate Medical Education, 1997.
List of Keywords Post Graduate Medical Courses; NEET PG Counselling; Medical education; Admission process; Seat blocking; Counselling process; Mop-up round; Seat allotted to less meritorious candidates; Safeguarding interests of meritorious candidates; Medical Council of India (MCI); National Medical Commission (NMC); Merit-based admission system; Transparency and fairness; Compensation for seat blocking; Arbitrary and excessive; Nationally synchronized counselling calendar; Pre-Counselling Fee Disclosure; Centralized Fee Regulation Framework; Aadhaar-based seat tracking; Uniform Counselling Conduct Code across all States; Third-party oversight mechanism under NMC.
Case Arising From CIVIL EXTRAORDINARY JURISDICTION: Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 9298 of 2018 From the Judgment and Order dated 19.01.2018 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in WP No. 28550 of 2017 Appearances for Parties Adv. for the Pettioners:
Ankit Goel.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Gaurav Sharma, Sr. Adv., Mohan Kumar, Ms. Neetu Singh, Ms. Ishika, Ms. Asia Beg, Ms. Rashmi Pandey, Ms. Bobby Anand, Dr. Ritu Bhardwaj, Dr. Tribhuwan Bhandari, Sandeep Bansal, Narender Singh, Ms. Mikshita, Ms. Amrita Sarkar, Awnish Maithani, Prateek Bhatia, Dhawal Mohan, Paranjay Tripathi, Rajesh Raj. 2690 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Order
1. We have heard the learned counsel appearing for all the parties and perused the materials placed before us.
2. This Special Leave Petition arises from the final judgment and order dated 19.01.2018 1 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad 2 in Civil Miscellaneous Writ Petition No. 28550 of 2017, whereby the High Court disposed of the writ petition with the following observations and directions:
“In view of the decisions of the Supreme Court no admission can be granted after the cut of date. A time schedule is required to be strictly adhered to. However, in the given circumstances the petitioners are entitled to compensation, which the Court computes at Rs.Ten lakhs each payable to the petitioners. The said amount shall be paid by the Director General of Medical Education and Training, … within four weeks from the date of presentation of a certified copy of the order.
Before we part with the case, we are of the opinion that there is a need to issue further directions as we have found that there has been a large-scale blocking of seats. 80% of the seats were filled up in the mop up round. Obviously, there is a flaw in the admission procedure.
We, accordingly, direct the Principal Secretary, Medical Education, Government of U.P., Lucknow … to take this fact into consideration of large-scale blocking of seats and come out with a foolproof admission procedure, which would eliminate such blockage of seats and ensure that maximum number of seats are filled up in the first and second round of counseling. We also direct the Principal Secretary to hold an inquiry into the circumstances of diluting the admission procedure and allowing the 1 For short, “the impugned order”
2 Hereinafter referred to as “the High Court”
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 2691State of U.P. & Another v. Miss Bhavna Tiwari & Ors. candidates who had appeared in the first and second round of counseling to be considered again in the mop up round in the garb of misinterpreting the orders of the Supreme Court. Such inquiry shall be made within two months and action be taken against the erring officials. For future admissions in subsequent academic sessions, we direct that after the first and second round of counseling, a window should be opened for the candidates who had taken admission to upgrade their stream and thereafter allow the remaining seats to be filled up in the mop up round. By this procedure allowing the candidates to upgrade their seats would not amount to third round of counseling. Further, the upgradation of seats of the preferred choice of the candidate would ensure fairness in the admission process and allow the meritorious candidates to take admission not only in the preferred choice of seats but also in better streams and, thus, by doing so, discipline would be maintained.
The writ petitions are disposed of.”
3. Aggrieved by the aforesaid order, the petitioners viz., State of U.P., and the Director General of Medical Education & Training, Lucknow, U.P. – who were Respondent Nos.2 and 3 in the writ petition – have approached this Court by way of the present petition.
4. By order dated 16.04.2018, this Court has granted an order of interim stay of the operation of the impugned order.
5. According to the learned counsel for Respondent Nos.1 and 2 herein, the writ petitioners were aspirants in the first NEET-PG conducted for the academic year 2017-18. The ranks secured by them as well as the seats allotted to them in the first and second rounds of counselling are detailed below:
Particulars Respondent No.1 (Bhavna Tiwari)
Respondent No.2 (Sonal Sharma)
All India Rank 13979 11280 State Rank 1247 1011 2692 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Preferences Choice 1: MD Radiodiagnosis Choice 2: MD Pathology Choice 1: MD Radiodiagnosis Choice 2: MD Skin & VD Choice 3: MD Paediatrics First Round allotment MD Pathology at Subharti Medical College, Meerut MD Paediatrics at Rohilkhand Medical College, Bareilly Second Round allotment MD Pathology at Subharti Medical College, Meerut MD Paediatrics at Rohilkhand Medical College, Bareilly
5.1. The grievance of the writ petitioners was that there had been a deviation in the admission process. Candidates, who had already been allotted seats in the first and second rounds of counselling were again permitted to appear in the mop-up round. It was alleged that a number of seats in the Radiology course were available in the mop-up round and were allotted to candidates, who were less meritorious than the writ petitioners, including those who had already participated in the earlier rounds of counselling. Alleging large-scale seat blocking and asserting that nearly 80% of the seats were filled during the mop-up round – resulting in the seats of their first preference being eventually allotted to less meritorious candidates – Respondent Nos.1 and 2 / writ petitioners filed the aforesaid writ petition seeking the following reliefs:
(i) A declaration that paragraphs 5 and 6 of the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET) PG 2017 Brochure, published by the King George’s Medical University, Lucknow – inasmuch as they deprived Respondent Nos.1 and 2 of an opportunity to appear in the mop-up round – are ultra vires Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution of India.
(ii) A direction to the authorities to grant permission to Respondent Nos.1 and 2 to attend classes in the institutions of their first choice, where they have already been admitted in a different discipline.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 2693State of U.P. & Another v. Miss Bhavna Tiwari & Ors.
(iii) A direction to the authorities to pass consequential orders with respect to the admission of Respondent Nos.1 and 2 as per their first choice and merit.
(iv) A direction to the authorities to undertake necessary reshuffling of admissions in medical colleges based on merit and candidate preferences, by maintaining a common selection list for admission to PG courses.
(v) Any other order or direction as the Court may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case.
(vi) An award of costs of the petition in favour of Respondent Nos.1 and 2.
It is submitted by the learned counsel for the writ petitioners that the High Court, after hearing all parties, rightly disposed of the writ petition with appropriate observations and directions. Therefore, no interference is warranted by this court.
6. On a perusal of the impugned order, it is evident that apart from directing the payment of compensation to Respondent Nos.1 and 2 / writ petitioners, the High Court was categorical in addressing the issue of seat blocking and in safeguarding the interests of meritorious candidates. Accordingly, it issued specific directions to the Government authorities, viz.,
(i) To ensure that no seat blocking takes place in the future in medical courses and that the majority of the seats are filled during the first and second rounds of medical counselling.
(ii) To ensure that less meritorious students do not secure admission to relatively more prestigious Post Graduate medical courses over candidates who are higher in merit.
7. At the outset, it is to be noted that the NEET-PG counselling process was conceived as a transparent, merit-based national mechanism for allocating postgraduate medical seats. However, over time, it has come under increasing scrutiny for facilitating widespread seat blocking. This malpractice distorts the actual availability of seats, fosters inequity among aspirants, and often reduces the process to one governed more by chance than merit. Seat blocking is not merely an isolated wrongdoing – it reflects deeper systemic flaws 2694 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports rooted in fragmented governance, lack of transparency, and weak policy enforcement. Although regulatory bodies have introduced disincentives and technical controls, the core challenges of synchronization, real-time visibility, and uniform enforcement remain largely unaddressed. Achieving a truly fair and efficient system will require more than policy tweaks; it demands structural coordination, technological modernization, and robust regulatory accountability at both State and Central levels.
8. Seat blocking in NEET-PG counselling occurs when candidates temporarily accept seats, only to abandon them later after securing more preferred options. This leads to those seats remaining unavailable in earlier rounds and opening up only in later stages, disadvantaging higher-ranked aspirants, who may have already committed to less preferred choices. Delays in state counselling, last-minute seat additions or deletions, and lack of coordination between quotas worsen the issue. As a result, lower-ranked candidates can secure better seats by taking risks, while merit-based selection is undermined.
9. During the course of hearing, the learned counsel for the Petitioners submitted that except for the payment of compensation to Respondent Nos.1 and 2, the other directions issued by the High Court have been duly complied with.
9.1. It is further submitted that to streamline the counselling process and to curb the issue of seat blocking, the State of U.P. has taken substantial steps by introducing the following measures:
(i) By Government Order No.12/71-4-2018-18/18 dated 08.03.2018, a security deposit was stipulated under Clause 5, with a view to deter candidates from the practice of not joining the seats allotted to them in the first two rounds of counselling. This measure has proven effective, as failure to join the allotted seat results in forfeiture of the security deposit. For better appreciation, Clause 5 is extracted below:
“(5) Security Money For participating in the NEET PG 2018 counselling process in respect of Government medical colleges, security money is fixed as Rs.30,000/- [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2695State of U.P. & Another v. Miss Bhavna Tiwari & Ors. (thirty thousand rupees) and in respect of private medical and dental colleges, the same is fixed as Rs.2,00,000/- (two lakh rupees). In the event of candidates taking admission to the seat allotted to them in the Govt./private medical/ dental college, security money deposited by candidates shall be returned in the bank account provided by them. Such candidates who do not take admission inspite of allotment of seat, their security money shall be forfeited.
Security money be got deposited by online mode from the candidates participating in the online counselling process of NEET PG 2018, prior to choice filling.”
(ii) Earlier, the counselling for the stray vacancy round was conducted manually (by offline mode) whereby the private medical colleges were provided with a list of candidates amounting to ten times the number of vacant seats. This process often led to an arbitrary ‘pick and choose’ method being adopted by certain private institutions. To prevent such practices, the National Medical Commission, vide communication dated 24.07.2023, directed that counselling for all stray vacancy round seats be conducted through an online process. It is pertinent to note that even prior to this directive, the State had already implemented online counselling for the mop-up and stray vacancy rounds through the issuance of Government Order No.1/348793/2023 dated 13.07.2023.
(iii) A one-year debarment has been envisaged for candidates who fail to join the seats allotted to them in the stray vacancy round. Accordingly, a stipulation to this effect was incorporated in the Counselling Brochure for NEET-PG 2024, which reads as follows:
“If a candidate is allotted a seat in Stray round, candidate has to report & join the allotted seat / college else he / she shall be debarred from UPNEET PG / MDS Counselling -2025 along with forfeiture of security deposit”.
2696 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
10. Further, the learned counsel for the petitioners has drawn our attention to the status of seat allotment and admissions after each round of counselling in NEET - PG 2024, in the context of the measures implemented to curb seat blocking. The details are tabulated below: Particulars First Counselling Second Counselling Third Counselling Stray Vacancy round Special Stray Vacancy round Number of allotted students 1640 1695 672 148 102 Number of admitted students 965 1510 540 121 93 Number of students not admitted 675 185 132 27 9 Number of students who had resigned 59 49 15 2 0 Note: - In the first round of counselling, there were 2026 seats in all, and after receiving recognition for 74 new seats from N.M.C., total 2100 seats were placed in the second round of counselling process. Thus, according to the learned counsel for the petitioners, the counselling process has been significantly refined, and the issue of seat blocking has been effectively addressed to a large extent.
11. Additionally, the learned senior counsel for the NMC / MCI explained how the scheme for admission to medical colleges evolved through a series of judicial interventions.
11.1. In Sharwan Kumar v. DGHS and others3 , this Court framed a scheme for admission to medical courses. As per this scheme, only two rounds of counselling were conducted for All India Quota (AIQ) seats – the 1 st and 2 nd rounds of counselling. This scheme was adopted by State Governments for admission to
3 (1993) 3 SCC 332
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.