Gangubai Raghunath Ayare v. Gangaram Sakharam Dhuri (D) Thr. LRs and Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 355; [2025] 4 S.C.R. 184
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia
- Decided
- 16 Mar 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 3183/2009
- Sections
- 44
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 184 : 2025 INSC 355 Gangubai Raghunath Ayare v.
Gangaram Sakharam Dhuri (D) Thr. LRs and Ors.
Gangaram Sakharam Dhuri (D) Thr. LRs (R1 to R8)
R1: Anandi Gangaram Dhuri (D) Thr. LRs (R2 to R8)
R2: Sunanda Gangaram Dhuri R3: Vaishali Vilas Majalkar R4: Kavita Kashiram Ugave R5: Vithal Gangaram Dhuri R6: Mangesh Gangaram Dhuri R7: Babaji Gangaram Dhuri R8: Geeta Subhash Baraskar R9: Laxmibai Vishnu Shelar Ladubai Mahadev Rane (D) Thr. LRs (R10 to R13)
R10: Hemlata Arjun Tawde R11: Pratibha Sawant R12: Supriya Pawar R13: Sunanda Rane R14: Shantabai Mahadev Ayare (D)
R15: Pushpa Prabhakar Gudekar (LR of R14)
R16: Tai Shankar Pawar (Civil Appeal No. 3183 of 2009)
17 March 2025 [Sudhanshu Dhulia and Ahsanuddin Amanullah,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the High Court was right in holding that when the principal prayer for administration of the estate was rejected by the Trial Court, any other prayer indirectly seeking partition could not have been granted, until the proper parties were impleaded in the suit; whether the sale deed in favour of the 2nd defendant by ‘V’ was valid to the extent of his undivided share in the suit property.
* Author [2025] 4 S.C.R. 185Gangubai Raghunath Ayare v.
Gangaram Sakharam Dhuri (D) Thr. LRs and Ors.
Headnotes † Suit – Proper parties/necessary party – Non-joinder – ‘V’ (brother of the plaintiff and the third to fifth defendants) sold ½ portion of the suit property belonging to their deceased father, to the 2nd defendant – Plaintiff inter alia sought administration of the deceased’s estate and declaration that the sale deed in favour of the 2nd defendant was null and void – Trial Court rejected the prayer for administration of the estate however, declared the sale void in toto and directed the 2nd defendant to handover possession of ½ portion of the suit property – Appeal filed by 2nd defendant, allowed by High Court – Challenged:
Held: High Court was right in holding that when the principal prayer for administration of the estate was rejected by the Trial Court, that too as non-maintainable, any other prayer indirectly seeking partition could not have been granted, until the proper parties were impleaded in the suit – The decree of possession against the 2nd defendant was also rightly set aside by the High Court, as the said relief could not have been granted as the third to fifth defendants had not filed any suit seeking their share in the suit property, whilst the Plaintiff herself was entitled only to a 1/5th share in the suit property – On the passing away of ‘V’, during the pendency of the suit, only his wife was brought on record, whereas his sons and daughters were not impleaded in the suit by the Plaintiff – Further, ‘V’ had 1/5th undivided share in the suit property, belonging to the deceased – Thus, the sale deed in favour of the 2nd defendant by ‘V’ is valid only to such extent – Furthermore, the Plaintiff cannot be disturbed with her possession until the suit property is partitioned in accordance with law. [Paras 23, 24, 26] Case Law Cited Chief Conservator of Forests, Government of Andhra Pradesh v. Collector [2003] 2 SCR 180 : (2003) 3 SCC 472; Bachhaj Nahar v. Nilima Mandal [2008] 14 SCR 621 : (2008) 17 SCC 491 – relied on. List of Acts Code of Civil Procedure, 1908; Transfer of Property Act, 1882. List of Keywords Proper parties; Necessary party; Administration of estate; Principal prayer; Ancillary prayer; Suit property; Exclusive owner; Proper 186 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports parties; Impleadment; Possession; Sale Deed valid to the extent of undivided share; Co-owners; Undivided share; Partition suit; Legal representatives; Hindu Undivided Family property; Misjoinder of parties; Non-joinder of necessary parties; Relinquishment deed; Legal heirs.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 3183 of 2009 From the Judgment and Order dated 20.02.2007 of the High Court of Bombay in FA No. 116 of 1988 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Prasenjit Keswani, Debmalya Banerjee, Kartik Bhatnagar, Rohan Sharma, Anmol, Nicholas Choudhury, Upmanyu Tewari, Mrs. Manik Karanjawala.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Ajit Bhasme, Sr. Adv., Parth Sarathi, Gyanendra Vikram Singh, Ms. Soumya Gulati, Raja Kumar Ojha, Sanjay Kumar Visen, Mrs. Bina Gupta.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Ahsanuddin Amanullah, J.
Heard learned counsel and senior counsel appearing for the respective parties.
2. The present appeal is directed against the Final Judgment and Order dated 20/21.02.2007 1 in First Appeal No.116 of 1988 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Impugned Judgment’) passed by a learned Single Judge (as he then was) of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay, reversing Judgment and Decree dated 18/19.09.1987 passed by the City Civil Court, Bombay (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Trial Court’) in Suit No.2060 of 1970.
1 2007 SCC OnLine Bom 144 | (2007) 5 Mah LJ 136 | (2007) 5 Bom CR 306. [2025] 4 S.C.R. 187Gangubai Raghunath Ayare v.
Gangaram Sakharam Dhuri (D) Thr. LRs and Ors.
3. At the outset, it is gainful to take note of the position of the contesting parties before the respective Courts, as under:
Name Trial Court High Court This Court Gangubai Raghunath Ayare Plaintiff Respondent No.1 Appellant Gangaram Sakharam Dhuri Defendant No.2 Appellants No.1-8 (Died - Represented by LRs 2 )
Respondents No.1-8 Vishnu Shelar Defendant No.1 (Died during pendency of the suit - Represented by his widow Laxmibai Vishnu Shelar)
Respondent No.2 Respondent No.9 Ladubai Mahadev Rana Defendant No.3 Respondent No.3 [Died - Represented by LRs 3(A) to 3(D)] Respondents No.10-13 Shantabai Mahadev Ayare Defendant No.4 Respondent No.4 [Died - Represented by LR 4(a)] Respondents No.14 and 15 Tai Shankar Pawar Defendant No.5 Respondent No.5 Respondent No.16 1 Defendant No.1 is the real brother of the Plaintiff and Defendants No.3-5.
2 Defendant No.2 is the purchaser as per the Sale Deed executed by Defendant No.1.
2 The abbreviation expands to Legal Representatives.
188 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
FACTUAL SCENARIO:
4. For the sake of convenience, the parties are referred to as per their original status before the Trial Court.
5. The dispute in the suit pertains to property bearing C.T.S. No.1048 admeasuring 398.5 square yards altogether, with a building thereon by the name ‘Sai Niwas’ situated at Bandra, Bombay – 50 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘suit property’).
6. One Gangaram Thakoji Shelar (hereinafter referred to as the ‘deceased’) was the exclusive owner of the suit property. The deceased passed away on 13.05.1967. At the time of his death, the deceased was survived by his widow Sunderbai, his son Vishnu and four daughters namely, the Plaintiff and the third to fifth defendants, who were his only legal heirs and representatives.
7. The Plaintiff stated that the deceased was the absolute owner of the suit property. It is stated that one of the rooms i.e., Room No.1 in the suit property was let out to Raghunath Narayan Ayare, the Plaintiff’s husband on a monthly rent of Rs.20/-. The Plaintiff, with her husband and her family members, have been occupying Room No.1, as tenant(s) thereof, during the lifetime of the deceased. It is stated that after the death of the deceased, Vishnu, being the only male member in the family and also the Plaintiff’s and the third to fifth defendants’ brother, started managing the affairs of and looking after the suit property.
8. The Plaintiff contends that her brother, Vishnu, had, in the course of management of the suit property, obtained her as well as her sisters’ signatures, on some blank papers, including for the purpose of effecting transfer thereof in the public record in the names of all the legal heirs.
9. According to the Plaintiff, her husband received Letter dated 10.01.1969 sent to him by the second defendant alleging that the Plaintiff was in possession of Room No.1 in the suit property as a licensee of Vishnu. According to the Plaintiff, she learnt, for the first time, from the said Letter that Vishnu had sold ½ portion of the suit property to the second defendant based on the Relinquishment Deed dated 11.12.1967, purportedly executed by the Plaintiff and the third to fifth defendants in favour of Vishnu. The plaintiff’s husband replied to the said Letter by pointing out that he was a tenant in respect of Room No.1, and [2025] 4 S.C.R. 189Gangubai Raghunath Ayare v.
Gangaram Sakharam Dhuri (D) Thr. LRs and Ors.
not a Licensee. It was contended in the reply that the Plaintiff, being one of the co-owners of the suit property, the transaction in favour of the second defendant by Vishnu was not binding on her.
10. The Plaintiff filed Suit No.2060 of 1970 for administration of the estate of the deceased seeking the following reliefs (sic):
'a) estate and life of the deceased be ascertained and thereafter the same be administered by and under the directions of this Hon’ble Court;
b that the share of the plaintiff and the Original defendant Nos. 1 and 3 to 5 in the state of the said deceased be ascertained and declared.
c that it be declared that the said sale deed 10th January 1969 executed by Original 1 st defendant in favour of the 2 nd defendant is null and void and not binding on the estate of the said deceased and/or plaintiff’s share therein and that the 2nd defendant be decreed and ordered to deliver possession of ½ portion of the said property comprised in the said sale deed of the estate of the said deceased.
d That for the purpose aforesaid enquiries be made, orders be passed and action be taken as may appear necessary of this Hon’ble Court in that behalf;
e That the original and present 1 st defend and their heirs be decreed and ordered to disclose of the estate of the said deceased and to account for his dealings with the said estate.
f That pending the hearing and final disposal of the suit, Court Receiver, High Court, Bombay, be a pointed as Receiver of the said property viz. Sai Niwas, Bandra, Bombay 50, with all powers under order 40 and Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Code.
g This pending the hearing and final disposal of the suit present 1st defendant and 2nd defendant be restrained by an order of injunction of this Hon’ble Court in any manner to deal with, dispose of and/or alienating, transferring, encumbering the said property or any portion thereof.
190 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports h That an interim orders in terms of prayers above.
i That costs of and incidental to the suit be provided for. j That for such further and other reliefs as the nature and circumstances of the case may require be granted.’
11. The Trial Court framed issues and found as below:
S.
No.
Issues Finding 1 Is the suit bad for misjoinder of parties and causes of action?
[Considered unnecessary] 2 Does the Plaintiff prove that the property sold under the Sale Deed dated 10.01.1969 by the original 1st defendant to the 2nd defendant form part of the estate of the deceased Gangaram Thakoji Shelar?
Yes 3 Does the Plaintiff prove that the Sale Deed dated 10.01.1969 is not binding upon the Plaintiff?
4 Does the Plaintiff prove that the Sale Deed dated 10.01.1969 is null and void and illegal?
5 Costs? As per order 6 What Order?
12. The Trial Court held that the suit for administration of property is not maintainable as the children of Vishnu, who died during the pendency of the suit, were not brought on record, and for ascertainment and administration of the estate and determination of the share and income etc., no issues were raised and no data was available. The Trial Court held that the Relinquishment Deed dated 11.12.1967 was not proved in accordance with law and the transfer in favour of the second defendant was null and void and was not binding on the Plaintiff. The suit was decreed declaring that the Sale Deed dated 10.01.1969 executed by Vishnu in favour of the second defendant was null and void and directing the second defendant to handover possession of ½ portion of the suit property, which was subjectmatter of the Sale Deed in question. Further, the Trial Court also granted liberty to the Plaintiff to claim the other reliefs prayed for in the suit separately.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 191Gangubai Raghunath Ayare v.
Gangaram Sakharam Dhuri (D) Thr. LRs and Ors.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.