Delhi Pollution Control Committee v. Lodhi Property Co. Ltd. Etc.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 923; [2025] 8 S.C.R. 362
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, Justice Manoj Misra
- Decided
- 3 Aug 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 757/2013
- Sections
- 33A, 31A, 17, 5, 25, 4, 21, 20, 23, 24, 26, 33B
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 362 : 2025 INSC 923 Delhi Pollution Control Committee v.
Lodhi Property Co. Ltd. Etc.
(Civil Appeal No(s). 757-760 of 2013)
04 August 2025 [Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Manoj Misra, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the regulatory boards can, in exercise of powers u/s.33A of the Water Act and s.31A of the Air Act, impose and collect as restitutionary and compensatory damages fixed sums of monies or require furnishing bank guarantees as an ex-ante measure towards potential environmental damage.
Headnotes† Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 – s.33A – Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 – s.31A – The Division Bench of the High Court held that DPCC (regulatory body/Board) is not empowered to levy compensatory damages in exercise of powers u/s.33A of the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 and s.31A of the Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 on the ground that such an action amounts to imposition of penalty provided for in Chapters VII and VI of the respective Acts, and as such, procedure contemplated thereunder will be the only method for imposing and collecting compensatory damage – Correctness:
Held: 1. Having considered the principles that governing environmental laws and on interpretation of ss.33A and 31A of the Water and Air Acts, this Court is of the opinion that the Division Bench of the High Court was not correct in restrictively reading powers of the Boards – The environmental regulators, the Pollution Control Boards exercising powers under the Water and Air Acts, can impose and collect restitutionary or compensatory damages in the form of fixed sum of monies or require furnishing of bank guarantees as an ex-ante measure to prevent potential environmental damage – These powers are incidental and ancillary to the empowerment u/ss.33A and 31A of the Water and Air Acts – The powers must be exercised as per procedure laid down by [2025] 8 S.C.R. 363Delhi Pollution Control Committee v. Lodhi Property Co. Ltd. Etc. subordinate legislation incorporating necessary principles of natural justice, transparency and certainty. [Paras 2, 28]
2. The Board’s powers u/s.33A of the Water Act and s.31A of the Air Act have to be read in light of the legal position on the application of Polluter Pays principle as formulated and explained – This means that State Board cannot impose environmental damages in case of every contravention or offence under the Water Act and Air Act – It is only when the State Board has made a determination that some form of environmental damage or harm has been caused by the erring entity, or the same is so imminent, that the State Board must initiate action u/s.33A of the Water Act and s.31A of the Air Act. [Para 30] Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 – s.33A – Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 – s.31A – Board’s responsibility to choose appropriate course of action: Held: Given their broad statutory mandate and the significant duty towards public health and environmental protection the Boards must have the power and distinction to decide the appropriate action against a polluting entity – It is essential that the Boards function effectively and efficiently by adopting such measures as is necessary in a given situation – The Boards can decide whether a polluting entity needs to be punished by imposition of penalty or if the situation demands immediate restoration of the environmental damage by the polluter or both. [Para 32] Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 – Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 – 2024 amendments – Decriminalisation and Adjudicatory Officer: Held: There is no conflict between the powers of the State Boards to direct payment of environmental damages u/ss.33A and 31A of the Water and Air Acts and the powers of the Adjudicating Officer to impose penalties under Chapter VII of the Water Act and Chapter VI of the Air Act – The decriminalization of offences under these Chapters has not removed the punitive nature of actions that can be taken under them – There remains a clear distinction between the nature of directions that the State Boards can issue u/ss.33A and 31A of the Water and Air Acts for payment of environmental damage and the determination by Adjudicating Officers – The former is compensatory in nature and will be resorted to when remedial measures are being undertaken to restore the 364 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports degraded environment or pollution caused – The latter is a penalty for an offence under the law and is imposed with the objective of punishing the offender. [Para 31] Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 – s.33A – Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 – s.31A – Power of Boards to direct the payment of environmental damages – Powers must be guided by transparency and non-arbitrariness:
Held: The Boards have the power to direct the payment of environmental damages, this Court makes it clear that this power must always be guided by two overarching principles – First, that the power cannot be exercised in an arbitrary manner; and second, the process of exercising this power must be infused with transparency. [Para 33] Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 – s.17 – Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 – s.17 – Existing Legal Regime for Pollution Control in India – discussed. [Paras 9 and 10] Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 – s.33A – Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 – s.31A – Insertion of ss.33A & 31A in Water and Air Acts – Discussed. [Paras 11 to 15 ] Constitution of India – Part IV A and Arts. 48A, 51A – Interpretation of and for Environmental Institutions – Discussed. [Paras 16-17] Environment – Pollution control – Duty to Restitute v. Power to Punish and Penalise – Discussed. [Paras 18 to 26] Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 – Chapters VII – Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 – Chapters VI – Environmental damage – Distinction between restitution and punitive action:
Held: There is a distinction between a direction for payment of restitutionary and compensatory damages as a remedial measure for environmental damage or as an ex-ante measure towards potential environmental damage on the one hand; and a punitive action of fine or imprisonment for violations under Chapters VII of the Water Act and VI of the Air Act on the other hand – If directions [2025] 8 S.C.R. 365Delhi Pollution Control Committee v. Lodhi Property Co. Ltd. Etc. in furtherance of restitutionary and compensatory measures are issued, these are not to be considered as punitive in nature – Punitive action can only be taken through the procedure prescribed in the statute for example under chapters VII and VI of the Water and Air Acts respectively. [Paras 27(I)(II)] Environmental Law – Indian environmental law assimilation of Principle of Polluter Pays:
Held: Indian environmental law has assimilated the principle of Polluter Pays and there is also a statutory incorporation of this principle in our laws – The invocation of this principle is triggered in the situations – i) when an established threshold or prescribed requirement is exceeded or breached, and it does result in environmental damage, ii) when an established threshold or prescribed requirement is not exceeded or breached, nevertheless the act in question results in environmental damage and also iii) when a potential risk or a likely adverse impact to the environment is anticipated, irrespective of whether or not prescribed thresholds or requirements are exceeded or breached. [Para 27(III)] Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 – s.33A – Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 – s.31A – Duty of Environmental regulators:
Held: Environmental regulators have a compelling duty to adopt and apply preventive measures irrespective of actual environmental damage – Ex-ante action shall be taken by these regulators and for this purpose a certain measure in exercise of powers u/ss.33A and 31A of the Water and Air Acts is necessary. [Para 27(IV)] Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 – s.33A – Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 – s.31A – Environment Protection Act – s.5 – Powers of Board under Environment Protection Act and Water and Air Acts:
Held: The powers of the Boards u/ss.33A and 31A of the Water and Air Acts are identical to that of s.5 of the Environment Protection Act – Under Section 5, the Central Government or its delegate has the power to issue directions to the polluting industry to pay certain amounts and utilise the said fund for carrying out remedial measures – The Boards are empowered to take similar actions u/ss.33A and 31A of the Acts. [Para 27(V)] 366 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 – s.33A – Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 – s.31A – Directions issued by the Supreme Court:
Held: (a) The judgement and order dated 23.01.2012, passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Delhi is set aside to the extent of declaration of law but direct that the show cause notices that have been set aside by the High Court shall not be revived;
(b) This Court directs that the Pollution Control Boards can impose and collect as restitutionary and compensatory damages fixed sums of monies or require furnishing bank guarantees as an exante measure towards potential environmental damage in exercise of powers u/ss. 33A and 31A of the Water and Air Acts; (c) It is further directed that the power to impose or collect restitutionary or compensatory damages or the requirement to furnish bank guarantees as an ex-ante measure u/ss. 33A and 31A of the Water and Air Acts shall be enforced only after detailing the principle and procedure incorporating basic principles of natural justice in the subordinate legislation. [Para 39] Case Law Cited MC Mehta v. Kamal Nath [2000] Supp. 1 SCR 389 : (2000) 6 SCC 213; Vellore Citizens’ Welfare Forum v. Union of India [1996] Supp. 5 SCR 241 : (1996) 5 SCC 647; Research Foundation for Science (18) v. Union of India [2005] 1 SCR 115 : (2005) 13 SCC 186; Deepak Nitrite Ltd. v. State of Gujarat [2004] Supp. 2 SCR 49 : (2004) 6 SCC 402; T.N. Godavarman Thirumulpad, In Re v. Union of India [2024] 3 SCR 187 : (2025) 2 SCC 641; Bengaluru Development Authority v. Sudhakar Hegde [2020] 5 SCR 755 : (2020) 15 SCC 63 – relied on.
State of MP v. Centre for Environment Protection Research & Development [2020] 12 SCR 1139 : (2020) 9 SCC 781; Chandra Kishore Jha v. Mahavir Prasad & Ors. [1999] Supp. 2 SCR 754 : (1999) 8 SCC 266; Indian Council for Enviro-Legal Action v. Union of India [1996] 2 SCR 503 : (1996) 3 SCC 212; Bengaluru Development Authority v. Sudhakar Hegde [2020] 5 SCR 755 : (2020) 15 SCC 63 – referred to.
Splendor Landbase Ltd. v. DPCC, 2012 (195) DLT 177; State Pollution Control Board, Odisha v. M/s Swastik Ispat Pvt Ltd and Others, 2014 SCC OnLine NGT 13 – referred to.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 367Delhi Pollution Control Committee v. Lodhi Property Co. Ltd. Etc. List of Acts Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974; Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981; Constitution of India; Environment (Protection) Act 1986.
List of Keywords Restitutionary and compensatory damages; Bank guarantees as an ex-ante measure; Potential environmental damage; Violation of the environmental norms; Power of Boards; Principle of Natural Justice in the subordinate legislation; Polluter Pays principle; Broad statutory mandate; Appropriate action against a polluting entity; Payment of environmental damages; Pollution control; Section 33A of Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974; Section 31A of Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981; Environmental regulators; Punitive action; Remedial measure; Power to issue directions to the polluting industry; Decriminalization of offences; Powers of the Adjudicating Officer to impose penalties; Remedial jurisprudence; Injunctory, mandatory and compensatory remedies; Restitutionary directives; Fundamental rights of citizens; Environmental wrongs; Institutional foresight; Institutional memory; Institutional integrity; Institutional transparency and accountability; Independent and objective decisions.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No(s). 757-760 of 2013 From the Judgment and Order dated 23.01.2012 of the HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI in LPA No(s). 709, 710, 866 and 867 of 2011 With Civil Appeal No(s). 1977-2011 of 2013 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Ninad Laud, Saurabh Kulkarni, Ms. Rashika Narain, Ms. Ishani Shekhar, Dcosta Ivo Manuel Simon, Pradeep Misra, Daleep Dhyani, Suraj Singh.
368 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Advs. for the Respondents:
S. D. Sanjay, Satya Darshi Sanjay, A.S.Gs., Pinaki Mishra, B.b.gupta, Ms. Swarupma Chaturvedi, Kailash Vashudev, Pravin Bahadur, Kishan Rawat, Ms. Rubi Singh Ahuja, Ms. Kanika Gomber, Rajan Narain, Umesh Kumar Khaitan, Ajit Warrier, Angad Kochhar, S. S. Shroff, Gurmeet Singh Makker, Ms. Ruchi Kohli, Chinmayee Chandra, Chitvan Singhal, Mohit D. Ram, Ms. Nayan Gupta, Mrs. Priya Puri, Navin Prakash, Ms. Srishti Prakash, Ms. Swarupama Chaturvedi, Ms. Ruchi Kohli, Ms. Chinmayee Chandra, Chitvan Singhal, Amit Sharma V, Dr. N. Visakamurthy, Avijit Roy. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Contents*
1. Introduction .................................................................................. 2
2. Facts ............................................................................................ 3
3. Single Judge’s Judgement and Orders ....................................... 4
4. Impugned Order of the Division Bench ....................................... 6
5. Submissions ................................................................................. 8
6. Issue ............................................................................................. 11
7. Existing Legal Regime for Pollution Control in India ................... 12
8. Insertion of Sections 33A & 31A in Water and Air Acts ............... 14
9. Interpretation of and for Environmental Institutions ..................... 18
10. Duty to Restitute v. Power to Punish and Penalise ..................... 20
11. Principles ...................................................................................... 26 A. Board’s Responsibility to Choose Appropriate Course of Action .................................................................................... B. Powers Must Be Guided by Transparency and Non-Arbitrariness .................................................................. * Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 369Delhi Pollution Control Committee v. Lodhi Property Co. Ltd. Etc.
1. Introduction.
1. The Delhi Pollution Control Committee (DPCC) 1 is in appeal against the judgment of the Division Bench of the High Court holding that it is not empowered to levy compensatory damages in exercise of powers under Section 33A of the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 and Section 31A of the Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 2 on the ground that such an action amounts to imposition of penalty provided for in Chapters VII and VI of the respective Acts, and as such, procedure contemplated thereunder will be the only method for imposing and collecting compensatory damage.
2. Having considered the principles that govern Indian environmental laws, we have held that the environmental regulators, the Pollution Control Boards exercising powers under the Water and Air Acts, can impose and collect restitutionary or compensatory damages in the form of fixed sum of monies or require furnishing of bank guarantees as an ex-ante measure to prevent potential environmental damage. These powers are incidental and ancillary to the empowerment under Sections 33A and 31A of the Water and Air Acts. At the same time, we have directed that the powers must be exercised as per procedure laid down by subordinate legislation incorporating necessary principles of natural justice, transparency and certainty.
2. Facts.
3. It is the case of the Delhi Pollution Control Committee that pursuant to the directions of the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC) to take appropriate action against certain entities operating in violation of the environmental norms, show cause notices were issued for violation of Section 25 of the Water Act and Sections 21 and 22 of the Air Act. These entities were either residential complexes, commercial complexes or shopping malls. The show cause notices were issued on the ground that they proceeded with construction and in fact, were operating without obtaining the mandatory “consent to 1 DPCC is a regulatory body in the National Capital Territory of Delhi, established as a ‘State Board’. These Boards are constituted under section 4 of the Water Act and under section 4 or section 5 of the Air Act, and exercise powers granted under section 33A of the Water Act and section 31A of the Air Act. Our interpretation of section 33A and 31A herein will apply to any such body established under said Acts. 2 Hereinafter referred to as the Water Act and Air Act respectively. 370 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports establish” and “consent to operate” under Section 25 of the Water Act and Section 21 of the Air Act. The show cause notices were challenged by way of 38 writ petitions before the Delhi High Court. The challenge culminated in the judgement of a single judge dated 30.09.2010 in the case of Splendor Landbase Ltd. v. DPCC 3. The learned single judge considered the question as to whether a State Board can levy environmental damages in the form of fixed sums of money or require an entity to furnish a bank guarantee as a condition for grant of consent under Section 33A of Water Act and/or Section 31A of Air Act. Similar writ petitions were considered and decided by another single judge bench in Bharti Realty Ltd. v. DPCC and Anush Finlease and Construction v. DPCC on 20.07.2011 and 15.09.2011 and were disposed of in terms of the decision in Splendor Landbase Ltd. v. DPCC. The reasoning adopted in the judgement and orders passed by the Single Judges are as follows.
3. Single Judge’s Judgement and Orders.
4. In Splendor Landbase Ltd. v. DPCC 4, the ld. single judge by his judgement dated 30.09.2010 dealt with two major issues – firstly, whether proprietors of properties over 20,000 square meters are required to obtain consent to establish and consent to operate under Water Act and Air Act independently, despite obtaining EIA Clearance from the Ministry; and secondly, whether Boards can levy penalties, fines, environmental damages in form of fixed sums of monies or call for bank guaranties as a condition to grant consent under Water and Air Acts? While the first question was answered in the affirmative, the second was answered in the negative.
4.1 It was held that the power to levy penalty is in the nature of a penal power and as such a penalty cannot be imposed without there being an enabling statutory power. For this reason, the single judge held that Board has no power to levy penalty or damage, even on the basis of the general powers under Sections 31A or 33A of the Acts. The learned Judge criticized the monetary demand as a pre-condition for grant of consent under the Acts on the ground that it has no statutory backing.
3 2012 (195) DLT 177.
4 Hereinafter referred to as Splendor.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 371Delhi Pollution Control Committee v. Lodhi Property Co. Ltd. Etc. 4.2 In the other batch of cases i.e. in Bharti Realty Ltd. v. DPCC and Anush Finlease and Construction Ltd. v. DPCC, decided on 12.07.2011 and 15.09.2011, the learned Single Judge was constrained to enquire into the matter in detail as writ appeals against the judgement in Splendor were already pending before a Division Bench. Therefore, the Single Judge allowed the writ petitions following the decision in Splendor and holding that the Board has no power to impose and collect compensatory damages. In these cases, the learned Judge also directed refund of the amounts collected. However, no interest was granted to the respondents as they chose to comply with the demand instead of challenging the same at the relevant point in time.
4. Impugned Order of the Division Bench.
5. The decisions of the single judges were challenged by the appellant before the Division Bench of the High Court. By the judgement impugned before us, the Division Bench upheld the findings of the Single Judge in Splendor that the power to issue directions under Sections 33A and 31A under the two Acts does not confer the power to levy ‘penalty’. The High Court further observed that under Chapter VII and Chapter VI of the Water and Air Acts penalties can be levied only by courts and that too after taking cognizance of offences specified under the two Acts. Provided that the procedure so prescribed under the statute has to be followed mandatorily, the Division Bench held that the appellant would not be entitled to impose compensation or direct deposit of bank guarantees. The relevant portion of the Division Bench of the High Court is as follows – “37. We concur with the reasoning of the learned Single Judge in paras 58 to 64 of the impugned decision and thus do not elaborate any further, but would additionally highlight that, the power to issue directions under Section 33A of the Water Act and the power to issue directions under Section 31A of the Air Act, on their plain language, does not confer the power to levy any penalty. We would further highlight that under Chapter VII of the Water Act and under Chapter VI of the Air Act penalties and procedure to levy the same have been set out. A perusal of the provisions under the Water Act would reveal that penalties can be levied as per procedure prescribed and only Courts can take 372 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports cognizance of offences under the Act and levy penalties, whether by way of imprisonment or fine. Similar is the position under the Air Act. The legislature having enacted specific provisions for levy of penalties and procedures to be followed has specifically made the offences cognizable by Courts and the power to levy penalties under both Acts has been vested in the Courts. The role of the Pollution Control Boards is to initiate proceedings before the Court of Competent jurisdiction and no more.
40. The language of Sub-Section 5 of Section 25 of the Water Act makes it plain clear that the only solution to a situation of a building being constructed to establish an industry, operation or process without obtaining prior consent of the State Pollution Control Board is the power of the Board to serve upon the person concerned a notice imposing such conditions as might have been imposed on an application, seeking prior consent and we find that the learned Single Judge has correctly so opined and has rightly issued the direction that the only way out, pertaining to the Water Act is to permit DPCC to inspect the shopping malls and the shopping commercial complexes and if it is found that pertaining to discharge of sewage from these buildings any steps are required to prevent water pollution DPCC would be authorized to issue notices requiring the owner of the building to take steps in terms of the notice issued. Pertaining to the Air Act notwithstanding there being no similar provision, but the concept of a post decisional hearing may be made applicable with the modification that no hearing would be required inasmuch as there is no decision, but DPCC should be empowered to inspect the shopping malls and the shopping, commercial complexes and pertaining to air pollution, if the owners of the buildings do not take corrective action, DPCC would always have the power to file criminal complaints before the Courts of Competent Jurisdiction, which Courts would alone have the power to impose fine and additionally impose sentence of imprisonment upon the offending persons.
42. In a few cases, we find that since DPCC was not permitting the buildings to be occupied, under protest, the [2025] 8 S.C.R. 373Delhi Pollution Control Committee v. Lodhi Property Co. Ltd. Etc. owners paid the penalty to DPCC and have immediately approached the Court seeking refund and the same has been ordered for the reason neither under the Water Act nor under the Air Act there exists any power in DPCC to levy penalty or impose conditions of furnishing bank guarantee. The decision of the learned Single Judge is correct in directing the bank guarantees to be discharged and penalties levied to be refunded for the reason the said act of DPCC is ultra-vires its power under the two statutes and the levy of penalty is without any authority of law. In the decision reported as 1997 [5] SCC 535 Mafatlal Industries Ltd. & Ors. Vs UOI & Ors., under writ jurisdiction refund can be directed where the levy is without jurisdiction and the same would include a penalty levied without any jurisdiction. In the instant case the penalty levied is unconstitutional being not sanctioned by any power vested in DPCC either under the Water Act or the Air Act. The impugned decisions where penalty levied has been directed to be refunded are upheld.”
5. Submissions.
6. Mr. Pradeep Mishra appearing on behalf of the appellant DPCC submitted that the High Court erred in holding that the State Boards are not empowered to impose environmental damages under Sections 33A and 31A of Water and Air Acts. He has argued that the application of the principle of Polluter Pays is distinct from the requirement of authority of law to impose tax or penalty.
7. We have requested Mr. Ninad Laud, learned counsel to assist us in the matter. He has gracefully accepted and has eminently assisted the Court. He has submitted# that as per broad scheme of the Acts and also the statement of objects and reasons, State Boards are empowered to act on their own while enforcing Sections 25 and 26 and also while issuing directions under Sections 33A and 31A. However, when faced with non-compliances, recourse to judicial process is contemplated under Sections 49 and 43 of Water and Air Acts respectively. Further, neither Rule 34 of Water (Prevention # Ed. Note: “We have requested Mr. Ninad Laud, learned counsel to assist us in the matter. He has gracefully accepted and has eminently assisted the Court. He has submitted” instead of “On behalf of the respondents, Mr. Ninad Laud has submitted” in terms of subsequent corrigendum. 374 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports & Control of Pollution) Rules 1975 nor Rule 20A of Air (Prevention & Control of Pollution) Rules 1983, while providing a mechanism to administer Section 33A and Section 31A, contemplate monetary penalties. Countering the submission of Mr. Pradeep Misra on the principle of Polluter Pays to encourage reading the power to impose and collect environmental damages under Sections 33A and 31A of the respective Acts, he would submit such an approach is impermissible as the said power is specifically and separately provided under Chapters VII and VI therein. Relying on the decision of this Court in MC Mehta v. Kamal Nath5 , he would submit, after considering the scheme of penal provisions under Water Act, Air Act and Environment (Protection) Act 1986, the Supreme Court held that penalties under the Acts befall a person only after finding of guilt upon trial by a court of law. Referring to the legitimacy of State Board’s action demanding bank guarantees to secure compliance with conditions, he would submit that no penalty, other than that contemplated in the statute or statutory scheme can be imposed.6 We have also heard Mr. Pinaki Misra, Senior Advocate and other learned counsel and they have strongly supported the decision of the Division Bench.
7.1 Counsel for M/s Laxmi Buildtech Pvt Ltd 7 has submitted that they have neither violated nor acted in breach of any provision of environmental laws and therefore they cannot be subjected to any penalty or criminal prosecution. Counsel for other respondents further submitted that they have deemed consent as well as EIA clearance from the Ministry. They have also submitted that imposition and collection of damages by the State Boards is outside the powers vested in them under the Water and Air Acts.
7.2 Counsel for M/s Bharti Realty Ltd has submitted that it is a settled principle of law that if a statute provides for a thing to be done in a particular manner, then it has to be done in that manner and no other.8 This principle, according to the learned counsel, squarely applies to the present case as Chapter VII and Chapter VI of the Water and Air Acts have a prescribed 5 (2000) 6 SCC 213, para 13-17.
6 State of MP v. Centre for Environment Protection Research & Development, (2020) 9 SCC 781. 7 Civil Appeal No. 2001 of 2013.
8 Chandra Kishore Jha v. Mahavir Prasad & Ors, (1999) 8 SCC 266. [2025] 8 S.C.R. 375Delhi Pollution Control Committee v. Lodhi Property Co. Ltd. Etc. procedure to be followed before imposing penalties. It is further argued that the role of any State Board is in the nature of a complainant and not that of an adjudicatory authority. In this vein, it is submitted that any other interpretation would render the chapter on ‘Penalties and Procedures’ nugatory and otiose. It is also submitted that the power to give directions under Sections 33A and 31A of the Water and Air Acts is “subject to provisions of this Act”. Written submissions also refer to the recent amendments to the Water and Air Acts, empowering an Adjudicating Officer, not below the rank of Joint Secretary of Government of India or Secretary to State Government, for imposing penalties for contravention of provisions of the Acts.
6. Issue.
8. The core question in these appeals is - whether the regulatory boards can, in exercise of powers under Section 33A of the Water Act and Section 31A of the Air Act, impose and collect as restitutionary and compensatory damages fixed sums of monies or require furnishing bank guarantees as an ex-ante measure towards potential environmental damage?
7. Existing Legal Regime for Pollution Control in India.
9. Under the Water Act and the Air Act, the State Boards have a broad statutory mandate to prevent, control and abate water pollution and air pollution. Under Section 17 of the Water Act, the State Boards are to shoulder enormous responsibilities and their functions are reproduced herein for ready reference - “Section 17. Functions of State Board – (1) Subject to the provisions of this Act, the functions of a State Board shall be— (a) to plan a comprehensive programme for the prevention, control or abatement of pollution of streams and wells in the State and to secure the execution thereof;
(b) to advise the State Government on any matter concerning the prevention, control or abatement of water pollution;
(c) to collect and disseminate information relating to water pollution and the prevention, control or abatement thereof; 376 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(d) to encourage, conduct and participate in investigations and research relating to problems of water pollution and prevention, control or abatement of water pollution;
(e) to collaborate with the Central Board in organising the training of persons engaged or to be engaged in programmes relating to prevention, control or abatement of water pollution and to organise mass education programmes relating thereto;
(f) to inspect sewage or trade effluents, works and plants for the treatment of sewage and trade effluents and to review plans, specifications or other data relating to plants set up for the treatment of water, works for the purification thereof and the system for the disposal of sewage or trade effluents or in connection with the grant of any consent as required by this Act;
(g) to lay down, modify or annul effluent standards for the sewage and trade effluents and for the quality of receiving waters (not being water in an inter-State stream) resulting from the discharge of effluents and to classify waters of the State;
(h) to evolve economical and reliable methods of treatment of sewage and trade effluents, having regard to the peculiar conditions of soils, climate and water resources of different regions and more especially the prevailing flow characteristics of water in streams and wells which render it impossible to attain even the minimum degree of dilution;
(i) to evolve methods of utilisation of sewage and suitable trade effluents in agriculture;
(j) to evolve efficient methods of disposal of sewage and trade effluents on land, as are necessary on account of the predominant conditions of scant stream flows that do not provide for major part of the year the minimum degree of dilution;
(k) to lay down standards of treatment of sewage and trade effluents to be discharged into any particular stream taking into account the minimum fair weather dilution [2025] 8 S.C.R. 377Delhi Pollution Control Committee v. Lodhi Property Co. Ltd. Etc. available in that stream and the tolerance limits of pollution permissible in the water of the stream, after the discharge of such effluents;
(l) to make, vary or revoke any order—
(i) for the prevention, control or abatement of discharges of waste into streams or wells;
(ii) requiring any person concerned to construct new systems for the disposal of sewage and trade effluents or to modify, alter or extend any such existing system or adopt such remedial measures as are necessary to prevent, control or abate water pollution;
(m) to lay down effluent standards to be complied with by persons while causing discharge of sewage or sullage or both and to lay down, modify or annul effluent standards for the sewage and trade effluents;
(n) to advise the State Government with respect to the location of any industry the carrying on of which is likely to pollute a stream or well;
(o) to perform such other functions as may be prescribed or as may, from time to time, be entrusted to it by the Central Board or the State Government.
(2) The Board may establish or recognize a laboratory or laboratories to enable the Board to perform its functions under this section efficiently, including the analysis of samples of water from any stream or well or of samples of any sewage or trade effluents.”
10. Section 17 of the Air Act 9 , substantially similar to its equivalent 9 Section 17 of Air Act states –
17. Functions of State Boards.— (1) Subject to the provisions of this Act, and without prejudice to the performance of its functions, if any, under the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974, the functions of a State Board shall be—
(a) to plan a comprehensive programme for the prevention, control or abatement of air pollution and to secure the execution thereof;
(b) to advise the State Government on any matter concerning the prevention, control or abatement relating to air pollution;
(c) to collect and disseminate information relating to air pollution;
(d) to collaborate with the Central Board in organising the training of persons engaged or to be engaged in programmes relating to prevention, control or abatement of air pollution and to organise a mass-education programme relating thereto;
378 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports under the Water Act, also indicates the crucial responsibilities of the State Boards in discharge of their mandate. Chapter V of the Water Act and Chapter IV of the Air Act include provisions that prescribe the regulatory powers of the State Boards. These powers include the power to issue, modify or withdraw consent 10 , power to obtain information 11 , power of entry and inspection 12 and power to take samples 13 .
8. Insertion of Sections 33A & 31A in Water and Air Acts.
11. In 1988, both Acts were amended. Notably, through amendments the State Boards were further empowered to give directions under Section 33A of the Water Act and Section 31A14 of the Air Act. These
(e) to inspect, at all reasonable times, any control equipment, industrial plant or manufacturing process and to give, by order, such directions to such persons as it may consider necessary to take steps for the prevention, control or abatement of air pollution;
(f) to inspect air pollution control areas at such intervals as it may think necessary, assess the quality of air therein and take steps for the prevention, control or abatement of air pollution in such areas;
(g) to lay down, in consultation with the Central Board and having regard to the standards for the quality of air laid down by the Central Board, standards for emission of air pollutants into the atmosphere from industrial plants and automobiles or for the discharge of any air pollutant into the atmosphere from any other source whatsoever not being a ship or an aircraft: Provided that different standards for emission may be laid down under this clause for different industrial plants having regard to the quantity and composition of emission of air pollutants into the atmosphere from such industrial plants;
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.