M/S Oswal Petrochemicals Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Mumbai - II
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 578; [2025] 4 S.C.R. 1792
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Ujjal Bhuyan
- Decided
- 28 Apr 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 129/2011
- Sections
- 35L, 35E, 4, 11
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 1792 : 2025 INSC 578 M/s Oswal Petrochemicals Ltd.
v.
Commissioner of Central Excise, Mumbai - II (Civil Appeal No(s). 129-130 of 2011)
28 April 2025 [Abhay S. Oka and Ujjal Bhuyan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration
(i) Whether a duty demand based on reclassification of the products Benzene and Toluene from chapter 29 to chapter 27 is sustainable when such re-classification is based on test reports of which only a gist was provided to the appellant by the respondent; (ii) whether CESTAT was justified in treating the assessments provisional for the two products Benzene and Toluene for the months of January and February, 1993 in the absence of any order passed under Rule 9B of the Central Excise Rules, 1944 and without executing any B-13 bond.
Headnotes† Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 – Central Excise Act, 1944 – s.35L(b) – Central Excise Rules, 1944 – rr.9B, 56, 173B – Appellant filed the classification list, including two products of Benzene and Toluene which was approved by the Assistant Collector – Products of Benzene and Toluene were classified under chapter sub-heading 2902.00 – Approval was challenged on the basis of the subsequent test reports which revealed that purity of the two products were less than 96 percent, thus warranting re-classification under chapter sub-heading 2707.10 and 2707.20 respectively – Copies of test reports were not furnished to the appellant – The test reports formed the sub-stratum of higher duty demand – Later, Assistant Collector passed an order directing provisional assessment of certain products, including products of the appellant – CESTAT in appeal upheld the demand of duty and treated the assessments provisional for the two products Benzene and Toluene for the months of January and February, 1993 – Challenge to:
Held: Principles of natural justice required that copies of such test reports ought to have been furnished to the appellant – Informing * Author [2025] 4 S.C.R. 1793M/s Oswal Petrochemicals Ltd. v.
Commissioner of Central Excise, Mumbai - II the appellant only the gist of the test reports cannot be said to be in compliance with the principles of natural justice as the test reports formed the sub-stratum of higher duty demand raised by the department thus entailing adverse civil consequences on the appellant – With respect to R.56 of the Central Excise Rules, use of the word shall in sub-rule (2) is indicative of the mandatory nature of the provision – Officer who has taken the samples for testing has to communicate the result of such test to the manufacturer – On the other hand, sub-rule (4) contemplates that upon receipt of the test result if a manufacturer is aggrieved by the same, he may within 90 days of the date on which the result of the test is received by him, request the Assistant Commissioner that the samples be re-tested – Unless a copy of the test report is furnished to the manufacturer, he would not be in a position to seek re-test within the specified period – Therefore, a copy of the test report has to be furnished to the manufacturer – In such circumstances, extracting the gist of the test reports, that too in the show-cause notices, would clearly be in breach of r.56(2) and r.56(4) of the Central Excise Rules – Belated sampling and test reports casts shadow of doubt on the entire procedure adopted by the respondent – Therefore, orders re-classifying the products Benzene and Toluene under chapter sub-heading 2707.10 and 2707.20 respectively and levying consequential differential duty demand cannot be sustained in law – With respect to order of provisional assessment, r.9B is the relevant provision – In the instance case, essential requirements of r.9B were not complied with – There is no order of the proper officer u/r.9B directing that assessments for the months of January and February, 1993 for the two products Benzene and Toluene were provisional – Neither any bond in proper format was directed nor executed by the appellant – Thus, the order of CESTAT is set-aside. [Paras 37, 39, 40, 44.1, 48, 50] Central Excise Rules, 1944 – r.9B – Essential requirements: Held: First and foremost, requirement of r.9B is that it is the assessee who has to request in writing the proper officer for provisional assessment in the event the assessee is unable to determine the value of excisable goods or the correct classification of goods – The second requirement is that the proper officer competent to make provisional assessment may direct after making necessary inquiry that duty leviable on such goods shall be assessed provisionally – Such directions the proper officer can 1794 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports issue only by passing a written order and not otherwise – Thirdly, the assessee must execute a bond in the proper form binding the assessee to pay the differential amount of duty as provisionally assessed and as may be finally assessed – However, r.9B also provides for an exception – If the proper officer is satisfied that the self-assessment made by the assessee is not in order, he may direct the assessee to resort to provisional assessment – In any event, for an assessment to be provisional in terms of r.9B, an order is required to be passed. [Para 45] Central Excise Rules, 1944 – r.173B – Approval of classification list is not an empty formality – Discussed. [Para 40] Case Law Cited Coastal Gases and Chemicals Pvt. Ltd v. Assistant Collector of Central Excise, Visakhapatnam (1997) 7 SCC 223; Metal Forgings v. Union of India (2003) 2 SCC 36; Commissioner of Central Excise, Calcutta v. Hindustan National Glass & Industries Ltd [2005] 2 SCR 744 : (2005) 3 SCC 489 – referred to.
List of Acts Central Excise Act, 1944; Central Excise Rules, 1944; Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985.
List of Keywords Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT); Differential duty demand; Benzene and Toluene; Test reports; Tariff classification; Provisional assessments; Sub-heading 2902.00; Heading 2707.10 and 2707.20; Re- classification of the products; Remand order; Principles of natural justice.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No(s). 129-130 of 2011 From the Judgment and Order dated 21.05.2010 of the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, West Zonal Bench at Mumbai in Appeal Nos. E/2380/06-MUM and E/3816/03-MUM With Civil Appeal No. 131 of 2011 [2025] 4 S.C.R. 1795M/s Oswal Petrochemicals Ltd. v.
Commissioner of Central Excise, Mumbai - II Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
A.K. Prasad, Ms. Surabhi Sinha, Ms. Pankhuri Shrivastava, Ms. Neelam Sharma.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Arijit Prasad, Sr. Adv., Mukesh Kumar Maroria, Ms. B. Sunita Rao, Udai Khanna, Sarthak Karol, Ms. Neelakshi Bhaduria, Gunmaya S. Mann.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Ujjal Bhuyan, J.
The above three appeals have been filed by the appellant under Section 35L(b) of the Central Excise Act, 1944.
2. Since the three appeals arise out of the common order dated 21.05.2010 passed by the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, West Zonal Bench at Mumbai and are inter-related with parties being the same, those were heard together and are being disposed of by this common judgment and order.
3. Be it stated that by the judgment and order dated 21.05.2010 (impugned order), Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, West Zonal Bench at Mumbai (‘CESTAT’ hereinafter) disposed of appeal Nos. E/2380/06-MUM, E/3816/03-MUM and E/40/02-NB-C. It may be mentioned that appeal No. E/2380/06-MUM was filed by the respondent whereas the other two appeals were filed by the appellant.
4. By the impugned order dated 21.05.2010, CESTAT dismissed the appeals filed by the appellant and partly allowed the appeal filed by the respondent. The differential duty demand in respect of the two products Benzene and Toluene for the period September, 1990 to December, 1992 amounting to Rs. 1,97,17,015.00 and for the period January and February, 1993 of Rs. 18,16,304.00 have been upheld. In respect of the aforesaid two products, CESTAT has also held that contents of the test reports on the basis of which tariff classification of the above two products were changed leading to 1796 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports higher duty and hence differential duty were duly communicated to the appellant. CESTAT has also held that the assessments covering the said period were not provisional except for the months of January and February, 1993.
5. This Court vide the order dated 03.01.2011 had condoned the delay in filing of the appeals and had issued notice.
6. Relevant facts may be briefly noted.
7. Appellant is a manufacturer of excisable goods falling under Chapters 27, 28, 29, 32, 38 and 39 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 (briefly ‘the Tariff Act’ hereinafter)
8. Appellant had filed classification list bearing No. 1/89-90 effective from 03.11.1989 for various excisable products manufactured by it in terms of Rule 173B of the Central Excise Rules, 1944 (referred to hereinafter as ‘the Central Excise Rules’)
8.1. In the said classification list, appellant had classified the various products manufactured by it as under:
(i) Dripolene ‘C’ - chapter sub-heading 2713.90 and claimed concessional rate of duty under Notification No. 75/84.
(ii) Cyclo Hydro Carbons viz. (a) BTX and (b) BVR chapter sub-heading 2902.00
(iii) Benzene and Toluene - chapter sub-heading 2902.00 claiming exemption under various notifications
(iv) Ethylene and Propylene - chapter sub-heading 2901.90 claiming exemption under various notifications.
8.2. The said classification list filed by the appellant was approved by the Assistant Collector of Central Excise, Division-I, Mumbai II Collectorate (‘Assistant Collector’ hereinafter) on 26.04.1990.
9. On 04.10.1990, department drew samples of Benzene and Toluene from the appellant for chemical testing. The chemical analysis as indicated vide the Deputy Chief Chemist’s letter dated 29.01.1991 reportedly revealed that purity of the two products was less than 96 percent, thus, warranting classification under heading 2707.10 and 2707.20 respectively.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 1797M/s Oswal Petrochemicals Ltd. v.
Commissioner of Central Excise, Mumbai - II
10. Collector of Central Excise, Mumbai II then directed the Assistant Collector to file an appeal before the Collector of Central Excise (Appeals), Mumbai (for short ‘Collector (Appeals)’ hereinafter) against the approval granted on 26.04.1990. Accordingly, department challenged the approval of the classification list by filing an appeal before the Collector (Appeals), Mumbai on the ground that appellant had wrongly classified its products.
11. Collector (Appeals) vide the order dated 28.10.1991 allowed the appeal filed by the department and remanded the matter back to the Assistant Collector for re-determination of the classification of the subject goods after obtaining necessary material evidence to establish the essential chemical characteristics of the said goods.
12. In the meanwhile, despite the fact that appellant had cleared the two products Benzene and Toluene under the tariff heading which was approved by the Assistant Collector, a show-cause notice dated 26.03.1991 was issued to the appellant by the Superintendent of Central Excise in respect of Benzene and Toluene cleared during the period September, 1990 to January, 1991 seeking to re-classify the two products under chapter sub-heading 2707.10 and 2707.20 respectively and proposing to recover differential excise duty alongwith penalty and interest. It was acknowledged in the show-cause notice that if the purity of Benzene and Toluene was 96 percent or more, those two products would be classifiable under chapter 29 as declared by the appellant but if the two products had purity of less than 96 percent, those would be classifiable under the heading 2707 resulting in higher excise duty leading to demand of differential excise duty i.e. actual duty leviable less the duty paid. Thereafter, similarly worded show-cause notices were issued covering the period from February, 1991 to December, 1992 proposing a total excise duty of Rs. 1,75,30,861.00 alongwith penalty and interest for wrong classification of the two products Benzene and Toluene.
13. Appellant filed replies to the show-cause notices. Contention of the appellant was that the issue of classification was already decided in its favour by the Assistant Collector on 26.04.1990 while accepting the classification of Benzene and Toluene under chapter sub-heading 2902.00. Further contention of the appellant was that it was not supplied with copies of the test reports relied upon in the show-cause notices to re-classify the two products.
1798 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
14. Reverting back to the remand order dated 28.10.1991 passed by the Collector (Appeals), it appears that the Assistant Collector had passed an order dated 18.10.1993 directing provisional assessments of certain products mentioned in Annexure-A to the said order for the years 1990-91, 1991-92, 1992-93 and 1993-94. This included the products of the appellant. The aforesaid order directed the appellant to execute a bond and to furnish a bank guarantee equivalent to 25 percent of the differential duty.
15. Aggrieved by the remand order dated 28.10.1991, appellant filed an appeal before the then Customs and Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal. Primary contention of the appellant was that the appeal was heard and decided by the Collector of Central Excise (Judicial) who was not the competent authority under Section 35E of the Central Excise Act, 1944 (briefly ‘the Central Excise Act’ hereinafter). That apart, it was also contended that the appellate proceedings were barred by time as the time limit of one year provided under Section 35E of the Central Excise Act had expired.
16. The Customs, Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal vide order dated 04.08.1997 allowed the appeal of the appellant and remanded the matter back to the Commissioner of Central Excise (Appeals) as in the meanwhile, the Office of Collector (Appeals) was renamed as Commissioner of Central Excise (Appeals) (for short, ‘Commissioner (Appeals), hereinafter) to decide afresh the issue of limitation.
17. Reverting back to the show-cause notices issued by the respondent to the appellant for the products Benzene and Toluene, it appears that there was a personal hearing in which a specific contention was raised on behalf of the appellant that copies of the test reports relied upon in the show-cause notices were not provided to the appellant, thus violating provisions of Rule 56(2) of the Central Excise Rules as well as the principles of natural justice. It was also contended that no samples were drawn by the department for any of the periods covered by the show-cause notices and that appellant had upgraded its manufacturing process in the meanwhile. Appellant also placed on record copies of test reports of the two products for the period from September, 1990 to November, 1990 which indicated that purity of the two products was above 96 percent.
18. All the show-cause notices were adjudicated by the Assistant Commissioner. Vide the order dated 27.02.2001, Assistant [2025] 4 S.C.R. 1799M/s Oswal Petrochemicals Ltd. v.
Commissioner of Central Excise, Mumbai - II Commissioner held that the two products Benzene and Toluene manufactured by the appellant were indeed classifiable under chapter sub-heading 2707.10 and 2707.20 respectively and consequently levied duty demand of Rs. 1,97,17,015.00 alongwith equivalent amount of penalty. While so adjudicating, Assistant Commissioner relied upon the test reports in respect of the samples drawn on 04.10.1990 and report of the Deputy Chief Chemist dated 17.01.1991 but declined to rely upon the test reports of the sample test done in the laboratory of the appellant.
19. Aggrieved by the aforesaid order, appellant filed an appeal before the Commissioner (Appeals) which was dismissed by order dated 28.09.2001. Thereafter, appellant filed further appeal before the CESTAT which was registered as appeal No. E/40/02-NB-C.
20. In the meanwhile, pursuant to the remand order dated 04.08.1997 passed by the Customs, Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal, Commissioner (Appeals) passed an order dated 29.08.2003 holding that its earlier order was passed within the stipulated period of one year from the date of approval of the classification list as the appellant could not place on record any material evidence to the contrary. Commissioner (Appeals) also decided the issue of classification in favour of the department.
21. Aggrieved by the aforesaid order dated 29.08.2003, appellant preferred appeal before the CESTAT, which was registered as appeal No. E/3816/03-MUM.
22. In the meanwhile, the Deputy Commissioner took up the matter regarding finalization of the provisional assessments. It is contended that before adjudication, no show-cause notice was issued. Deputy Commissioner vide his order-in-original dated 03.03.2004 decided the issue of classification in favour of the department further holding that the assessments for the period subsequent to filing of classification list bearing No. 1/89-90 with effect from 03.11.1989 upto 1998-99 were provisional. Vide the aforesaid order-in-original dated 03.03.2004, Deputy Commissioner calculated the differential duty as under i.e. (i) Benzene, Toluene, Ethylene and Propylene – Rs. 5,40,50,427.00 and (ii) Dripolene ‘C’ – Rs. 8,92,86,214.00, thus, totalling Rs. 14,33,36,641.00 under Rule 9B of the Central Excise Rules as it then existed 1800 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
23. Aggrieved by the said order-in-original dated 03.03.2004, appellant challenged the same before the Commissioner (Appeals). Contention of the appellant was that the order-in-original was passed without issuance of any show-cause notice; the said order covered even prior periods; and that there was double demand of duty to the extent of Rs. 2,72,56,175.63. Commissioner (Appeals) vide the order-in-appeal dated 31.01.2005 partially allowed the appeal by reducing the demand of duty to Rs. 11,60,80,465.37 on the ground of duplication of demand.
24. Appellant filed further appeal against the aforesaid order in appeal dated 31.01.2005 before the CESTAT. By order dated 31.05.2005, CESTAT allowed the appeal and remanded the matter back to the Commissioner (Appeals) for considering afresh the issue of provisionality of assessments after furnishing to the appellant, copies of re-classification and RT-12 returns for the disputed period.
25. On remand, Commissioner (Appeals) allowed the appeal filed by the appellant vide the order-in-appeal dated 31.03.2006 holding that the disputed products were not under provisional assessment during the period of dispute i.e. 1989-90 to1998-99.
26. This order in appeal dated 31.03.2006 came to be challenged by the department before the CESTAT by filing an appeal which was registered as appeal No. E/2380/06-MUM.
27. As noted above, all the three appeals were heard together by the CESTAT and were disposed of vide the common order dated 21.05.2010. While the CESTAT dismissed the two appeals filed by the appellant, it partially allowed the appeal filed by the department. The demand of duty for the period September, 1990 to December, 1992 (Rs. 1,97,17,015.00) and January and February, 1993 (Rs. 18,16,304.00) were upheld. CESTAT further held that the contents of the test reports relating to the two products Benzene and Toluene were intimated to the appellant. That apart, the assessments carried out were not provisional during the disputed period except for the months of January and February, 1993.
27.1. Regarding classification of Cyclo Hydro Carbons viz. (a) BTX and (b) BVR, CESTAT confirmed the order of Commissioner (Appeals). Contention of the appellant that confirmation of demand of differential duty of the two products on the ground [2025] 4 S.C.R. 1801M/s Oswal Petrochemicals Ltd. v.
Commissioner of Central Excise, Mumbai - II that the classification was wrong, was held not sustainable. As regards Ethylene and Propylene, CESTAT declined to consider the classification issue as there was no revenue implication.
28. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that CESTAT has committed a manifest error in upholding the order of Commissioner (Appeals) whereby the latter had confirmed the re-classification of Benzene and Toluene on the basis of test reports, the samples of which were drawn subsequent to the approval of the classification list bearing No.1/89-90. He submits that the said classification list was made effective from 03.11.1989 and was approved by the Assistant Collector on 26.04.1990. It was much thereafter that the purported samples were drawn in October, 1990. The test reports are dated 29.01.1991 which allegedly revealed that purity of the two products was less than 96 percent. It was on the basis of such test reports that Benzene and Toluene were re-classified under the heading 2707.10 and 2707.20 as against the approved classification of 2902.00, thus warranting higher levy of duty resulting in differential duty demand.
28.1. Learned counsel submits that once the classification of the above two products under chapter sub-heading 2902 was approved, the same could not have been erroneously and arbitrarily unsettled by the Collector (Appeals).
28.2. It is submitted that the test reports of the samples of the two products drawn in October, 1990 were never communicated to the appellant. Thus appellant was deprived of challenging the same and invoking its right for a re-test.
28.3. Referring to the impugned order, learned counsel submits that even CESTAT admitted that copies of the test reports were not communicated. But ironically, CESTAT placed the burden on the appellant by holding that no claim was made in any of the letters written by the appellant that the results of the chemical tests which were intimated to the appellant were incorrect. CESTAT endorsed the view of the department that by intimating the results of the chemical tests, department had fulfilled the obligation cast on it to communicate the results of the tests. This approach of the CESTAT is wholly incorrect. Learned counsel further submits that CESTAT was not at all justified to brush aside the contention of the appellant that because of non-communication of the test 1802 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports reports, appellant was denied the right to demand re-test. On the contrary, CESTAT put the burden on the appellant by posing the question as to why appellant did not ask for a re-test. Thereafter, CESTAT erroneously held that appellant was not deprived of its right to re-test as per Rule 56 of the Central Excise Rules as no such request was made. Further, CESTAT wondered as to why appellant did not seek re-test when it claimed that it had upgraded the facilities and its own test reports indicated that the two products had purity of more than 96 percent.
28.4. Learned counsel vehemently submits that non-communication of the test reports dated 29.01.1991 to the appellant is clearly in violation of the principles of natural justice. The same has vitiated the impugned order.
28.5. Learned counsel submits that the aforesaid test reports are part of the proceedings as those were relied upon in the show-cause notices. Therefore, non-furnishing of the same to the appellant was in clear violation of Rule 56 of the Central Excise Rules as well as of the principles of natural justice.
28.6. Learned counsel also submits that CESTAT failed to consider the contention of the appellant that appellant had upgraded its manufacturing process and thereby had achieved more than 96 percent purity.
28.7. On the question of preliminary assessments, learned counsel submits that merely because some RT-12 returns were marked as provisional, it cannot be said that the assessments were provisional. CESTAT erroneously held that there were provisional assessments only in respect of two products, i.e. Benzene and Toluene for the months of January and February, 1993. Assessments cannot be provisional for one or two products when the manufacturer is manufacturing a number of other products.
28.8. Learned counsel after referring to the materials on record submits that it was the department’s own case that assessments of various products manufactured by the appellant were not provisional at all. No order under Rule 9B of the Central Excise Rules was passed; that apart, [2025] 4 S.C.R. 1803M/s Oswal Petrochemicals Ltd. v.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.