Shahed Kamal & Ors. v. M/S A. Surti Developers Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 502; [2025] 4 S.C.R. 1275
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice K.V. Viswanathan, Justice N Kotiswar Singh
- Decided
- 17 Apr 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 2033/2025
- Sections
- 500, 34, 499, 415, 482, 204, 200, 202, 11
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 1275 : 2025 INSC 502 Shahed Kamal & Ors.
v.
M/s A. Surti Developers Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
(Criminal Appeal No. 2033 of 2025)
17 April 2025 [K.V. Viswanathan* and N. Kotiswar Singh, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the complaint filed by the respondent makes out a case for offences punishable under Section 500 read with Section 34, IPC against the appellants.
Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – ss.499 Exception 9, 500 r/w 34 – Defamation – When not – Principle of qualified privilege – Scope of Exception 9 to s.499 – Constitution of India – Articles 19(1)(a), (b) and (c) – Appellants-home buyers, not satisfied with the services provided by the respondent-developer, protested against the developer by erecting a banner visible to public at large – Complaint filed by the respondent u/s.500 r/w s.34 – Summons issued against the appellants – Appellants’ case, if falls within the exception 9 to s.499:
Held: Yes – Under the 9th Exception to s.499 if the imputation is made in good faith for the protection of the person making it or for another person or for the public good it is not defamation – In a business relationship like that of a builder and home-buyer, certain allowances in the use of phraseology in communication should be provided as long as the deployment of the phraseology in question is based on good faith – The language employed could be a clear pointer to decide whether the accused in the case has exceeded his privilege – One of the tests to decide whether the case falls within the 9th exception is the choice of words employed in the impugned publication – In the instant case, all that the banner depicts is what the appellants thought were their grievances against the respondent with whom they had a business relationship – Careful choice of the words, the conscious avoidance of intemperate, rude, offensive or abusive language and the peaceful manner of protest, * Author 1276 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports all point to the fact that to protect their legitimate interests and the interest of the other homeowners and without any malice and in good faith the erection of the banner was done – Appellants did not transgress into the offending zone – Their case falls within the sweep, scope and ambit of exception 9 to s.499 – Their peaceful protest is protected by Article 19(1)(a), (b) and (c) of the Constitution of India – Impugned judgment of High Court, set aside – Complaint alongwith order issuing summons quashed and set aside. [Paras 17, 22, 24, 30, 35] Constitution of India – Articles 19(1)(a), (b) and (c); 19(2) – Dissent and Disagreement within permissible limits – Right to protest peacefully – Peaceful pamphleteering – Discussed. [Paras 27-29, 31-34] Penal Code, 1860 – 9th Exception to s.499 vis-a-vis 1st Exception – Discussed. [Paras 19, 20] Case Law Cited Iveco Magirus Brandschutztechnik GMBH v. Nirmal Kishore Bhartiya and Anr. [2023] 13 SCR 220 : (2024) 2 SCC 86 – relied on. Chaman Lal v. State of Punjab [1970] 3 SCR 913 : (1970) 1 SCC 590; Harbhajan Singh v. State of Punjab and Another [1965] 3 SCR 235 : 1965 SCC OnLine SC 118; Denman v. Bigg; S. Khushboo v. Kanniammal and Another [2010] 5 SCR 322 : (2010) 5 SCC 600; Subramanian Swamy v. Union of India, Ministry of Law and Others [2016] 3 SCR 865 : (2016) 7 SCC 221; Javed Ahmad Hajam v. State of Maharashtra and Another [2024] 3 SCR 317 : (2024) 4 SCC 156; Anita Thakur and Others v. Government of Jammu and Kashmir and Others [2016] 4 SCR 50 : (2016) 15 SCC 525; Tata Press Ltd. v. Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Ltd. [1995] Supp. 2 SCR 467 : (1995) 5 SCC 139 – referred to.
Kuruppanna Goundan v. Kuppuswami Mudaliar, 1935 MWN 365; Valmiki Faleiro v. Mrs. Lauriana Fernandes and Others, etc., 2005 SCC OnLine Bom 1584; Ramachandra Venkataramanan v. Shapoorji Pallonji & Company Ltd. and Another, 2019 SCC OnLine Bom 524; Municipal Board Konch v. Ganesh Prasad Chaturvedi, 1951 SCC OnLine All 117; Queen-Empress v. E.M. Slater (1891) ILR 15 Bom 351 – referred to.
Organization for A Better Austin v. Jerome M. Keefe (1971) 402 U.S. 415; Concerned Consumers League v. O’Neill, 371 F Supp. 644 (E.D. Wis. 1974) – referred to.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 1277Shahed Kamal & Ors. v. M/s A. Surti Developers Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. Books and Periodicals Cited P. Ramanatha Aiyar’s Advanced Law Lexicon 3rd Edition – referred to.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Constitution of India; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Maharashtra Ownership of Flats Act, 1963; Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority Act.
List of Keywords Defamation; 9th Exception to Section 499, Penal Code, 1860; Principle of qualified privilege; Peaceful protest; Protest by erecting banner; Right to protest peacefully; Defame complainant’s image and reputation; Defamatory; No foul or intemperate language; Impugned publication; Article 19(1)(a), (b), (c) of the Constitution of India; Business relationship; Builder and homebuyer; Public good; Imputation with intent to harm; Peaceful pamphleteering; Imputation on character of another; Imputation made in good faith; Without any malice; Good-faith; Ignoring grievances; Abusive language; Freedom of speech and expression; Exception 1 and 3 to Section 499; Protect legitimate interest; Exceeded privilege; Choice of words in the publication/language; Voices of dissent or disagreement; Article 19(2); Reasonable restriction; Article 19(1)(c); Abuse of process.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
2033 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 10.06.2024 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in CRWP No. 2099 of 2021 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Sureshan P., Ajay Panicker, Shivam Yadav, Ms. Lavnya Panicker. Advs. for the Respondents:
Siddharth Luthra, Sr. Adv., Prasenjit Keswani, Sr. Adv., Nitin Sangra, Upmanyu Tewari, Syed Kamran Ali, Arjun Varma, Abhishek Sagar, Mrs. V. D. Khanna, Shashibhushan P. Adgaonkar, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande.
1278 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment K.V. Viswanathan, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. Homebuyers and developers have not always been the best of friends. Instances are innumerable where the two have been at daggers drawn. This case presents one such instance. Not satisfied with the services provided by the respondent-developer and when, according to them, repeated entreaties did not elicit a response, the appellant-home buyers decided to resort to a unique form of protest. They erected a board/banner visible to the public at large setting out in English and Hindi languages the following statements. The English version is as follows:- “WE PROTEST AGAINST THE BUILDER “A SURTI DEVELOPERS PVT. LTD.”
FOR
• NOT FORMING THE SOCIETY EVEN AFTER
18 MONTHS
BROKEN PODIUM
• NOT GIVING SOCIETY ACCOUNTS • NOT CO-OPERATING WITH THE RESIDENTS SHABBY GARDEN • NOT ATTENDING TO BUILDERS’ DEFECTS • NOT SORTING WATER ISSUE IGNORING
GRIEVANCES
• POOR LIFT MAINTENANCE • LEAKAGE PROBLEM NON-CO-OPERATION • PLUMBING ISSUES • DIRTY/BOUNCY APPROACH ROAD WE PROTEST FOR OUR RIGHTS”
3. The respondent-developer hit back and threatened to sue them for defamation unless an apology was tendered. When the appellants refused, a criminal complaint was filed for offences punishable under Section 500 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for [2025] 4 S.C.R. 1279Shahed Kamal & Ors. v. M/s A. Surti Developers Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. short ‘IPC’). The Metropolitan Magistrate Court, Borivali, Mumbai, on 04.10.2016, after perusal of the complaint and the verification statement of the complainant, issued summons against the appellants for offences punishable under Section 500 read with Section 34 of the IPC. A challenge in revision having failed, the appellants approached the High Court by way of a Writ Petition under Article 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India read with Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 seeking to quash the complaint as well as the summons issued. The High Court having turned down their plea, the appellants are before us.
4. The short question before us is whether the complaint filed by the respondent makes out a case for offences punishable under Section 500 read with Section 34 of the IPC against the appellants?
5. Principally, the grievance in the complaint of the respondent was that the appellants individually and in connivance with each other to spread disharmony erected/fixed two banners/boards in Hindi and English visible to the general public at large on 10.08.2015. The contents of the banner have been set out hereinabove. According to the complaint, the appellants have started a calculated campaign to defame the complainant’s image and reputation, and the appellants are making false propaganda and spreading rumours. The complaint alleges that the banners have adversely affected and damaged the reputation of the complainant and have been put up with full knowledge that they are false and frivolous. The complaint alleges that the banners have been put up in the manner as to be visible to the public with the deliberate intention to defame the complainant. The complainant further alleges that it informed the Mumbai Municipal Corporation about the erection of the two banners and that ultimately the banners were removed on 29.02.2016 under the supervision of the appellants 1, 2 & 7 and other residents. The complaint alleges that the motive of the appellants was to lower the reputation of the complainant in the eye of the public at large and caused mental agony and injury to the reputation of the complainant.
6. The High Court has refused to interfere with the summons issued by holding that prima facie the imputation has propensity to cause a dent in the reputation of the complainant. The High Court, even after correctly noticing the legal position that the Court at the stage of issue of summon is not in any manner precluded from considering 1280 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports whether any of the exceptions to Section 499 were attracted, on facts, held without any reasons that in the present case they were questions of fact. Holding so, the High Court rejected the plea of the appellants and relegated them to face trial.
7. We have heard learned Counsel for the parties and perused the records. Learned Counsel for the appellants submits that the complaint has been filed to exert pressure on the appellants in order not to object to the illegal construction of the second building on the same plot by utilizing the additional FSI; that the additional FSI became available after the completion of the building in which the appellants are occupying and as such the additional building could not have been constructed; that the civil dispute is being given a criminal colour; that the defective and unfulfilled works listed out in the banner were breach of contractual obligations and the same are pending adjudication in suit no. 610 of 2019 pending before the High Court.
8. Learned Counsel for the appellants contends that the banner only highlights the factual grievances of defective and unfulfilled works left unattended by the respondent and the hardships being suffered by all the 128 flat owners collectively; that there is not a single word or statement in the banner, which can be termed as defamatory; that the appellants have the fundamental right of freedom of speech and expression and the contents of the banner do not constitute defamation as defined in Section 499 IPC read with the exceptions; that the complainant has suppressed the material facts; that several letters have been written by the ad-hoc committee of flat purchasers regarding the grievances and some of the letters have been admittedly received by the respondent and that these letters have been suppressed by the complainant while approaching the Criminal Court.
9. The learned Senior Counsel for the respondent has reiterated the averments in the complaint set out hereinabove. The learned Senior Counsel contended that no civil or consumer proceedings have ever been initiated by the appellants or any other flat purchasers as regards the alleged deficiencies and that suit no. 610 of 2019 has been instituted much later and that too primarily with regard to the alleged claim over the FSI as increased by the notification dated 18.11.2015; that in the suit the learned Single Judge, by order dated 25.11.2020, and the Division Bench, by order dated [2025] 4 S.C.R. 1281Shahed Kamal & Ors. v. M/s A. Surti Developers Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. 17.03.2022, have found that the appellants and the flat purchasers do not have the right over the increased FSI and that the provisions of the Maharashtra Ownership of Flats Act, 1963 (MOFA) are not applicable to the land in question; that the land is owned by the Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA) and covered by the MMRDA Act and that the complainant was under no obligation to register a society or convey title under the provisions of the MOFA. It is further contended that in the revision application, the appellants did not raise any contention about their case being covered under any of the exceptions to Section 499 IPC and it was only in the writ petition that Exception 1 and 3 to Section 499 were invoked, which has been rightly rebuffed by the High Court. According to the learned Senior Counsel for the respondent, the ingredients of Section 499 are clearly attracted and the appellants have been rightly summoned to answer the charge for offences under Section 500 read with Section 34.
ANALYSIS AND REASONS:-
10. Section 499 of the IPC along with the 9 th Exception is extracted hereinbelow:- “499. Defamation.- Whoever, by words either spoken or intended to be read, or by signs or by visible representations, makes or publishes any imputation concerning any person intending to harm, or knowing or having reason to believe that such imputation will harm, the reputation of such person, is said, except in the cases hereinafter expected, to defame that person.
Explanation 1.- It may amount to defamation to impute anything to a deceased person, if the imputation would harm the reputation of that person if living, and is intended to be hurtful to the feelings of his family or other near relatives.
Explanation 2.- It may amount to defamation to make an imputation concerning a company or an association or collection of persons as such.
Explanation 3.- An imputation in the form of an alternative or expressed ironically, may amount to defamation.
1282 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Explanation 4.- No imputation is said to harm a person’s reputation, unless that imputation directly or indirectly, in the estimation of others, lowers the moral or intellectual character of that person, or lowers the character of that person in respect of his caste or of his calling, or lowers the credit of that person, or causes it to be believed that the body of that person is in a loathsome state, or in a state generally considered as disgraceful.
Ninth Exception.- Imputation made in good faith by person for protection of his or other’s interests.- It is not defamation to make an imputation on the character of another provided that the imputation be made in good faith for the protection of the interests of the person making it, or of any other person, or for the public good.”
11. As the Section indicates to constitute the offence of defamation there should be imputation concerning any person with intent to harm or knowing or having reason to believe that such imputation will harm, the reputation of such person. This is subject to exceptions and the 9th exception which has been considered by the High Court provides that it will not be defamation to make an imputation on the character of another provided that the imputation is made in good faith for the protection of the interests of the person making it, or of any other person, or for the public good.
12. P. Ramanatha Aiyar’s Advanced Law Lexicon 3rd Edition defines “imputation” to mean “the act or an instance of imputing something, especially fault or crime, to a person: an accusation or charge (an imputation of negligence)”.
SCOPE OF THE ENQUIRY: -
13. Before we proceed further, it is appropriate to notice the recent pronouncement of this Court in Iveco Magirus Brandschutztechnik GMBH v. Nirmal Kishore Bhartiya and Anr., (2024) 2 SCC 86 wherein this Court, while examining the question whether the exceptions to Section 499 could be considered at the stage of issue of process under Section 204 CrPC and equally for the High Court examining a petition to quash under Section 482, had the following to say:- “60. What the law imposes on the Magistrate as a requirement is that he is bound to consider only such [2025] 4 S.C.R. 1283Shahed Kamal & Ors. v. M/s A. Surti Developers Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. of the materials that are brought before him in terms of Sections 200 and 202 as well as any applicable provision of a statute, and what is imposed as a restriction by law on him is that he is precluded from considering any material not brought on the record in a manner permitted by the legal process. As a logical corollary to the above proposition, what follows is that the Magistrate while deciding whether to issue process is entitled to form a view looking into the materials before him. If, however, such materials themselves disclose a complete defence under any of the Exceptions, nothing prevents the Magistrate upon application of judicial mind to accord the benefit of such Exception to prevent a frivolous complaint from triggering an unnecessary trial.
62. In the context of a complaint of defamation, at the stage the Magistrate proceeds to issue process, he has to form his opinion based on the allegations in the complaint and other material (obtained through the process referred to in Section 200/Section 202) as to whether “sufficient ground for proceeding” exists as distinguished from “sufficient ground for conviction”, which has to be left for determination at the trial and not at the stage when process is issued. Although there is nothing in the law which in express terms mandates the Magistrate to consider whether any of the Exceptions to Section 499 IPC is attracted, there is no bar either. After all, what is “excepted” cannot amount to defamation on the very terms of the provision. We do realise that more often than not, it would be difficult to form an opinion that an Exception is attracted at that juncture because neither a complaint for defamation (which is not a regular phenomenon in the criminal courts) is likely to be drafted with contents, nor are statements likely to be made on oath and evidence adduced, giving an escape route to the accused at the threshold. However, we hasten to reiterate that it is not the law that the Magistrate is in any manner precluded from considering if at all any of the Exceptions is attracted in a given case; the Magistrate is under no fetter from so considering, more so because being 1284 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports someone who is legally trained, it is expected that while issuing process he would have a clear idea of what constitutes defamation. If, in the unlikely event, the contents of the complaint and the supporting statements on oath as well as reports of investigation/inquiry reveal a complete defence under any of the Exceptions to Section 499 IPC, the Magistrate, upon due application of judicial mind, would be justified to dismiss the complaint on such ground and it would not amount to an act in excess of jurisdiction if such dismissal has the support of reasons.
63. Adverting to the aspect of exercise of jurisdiction by the High Courts under Section 482 CrPC, in a case where the offence of defamation is claimed by the accused to have not been committed based on any of the Exceptions and a prayer for quashing is made, law seems to be well settled that the High Courts can go no further and enlarge the scope of inquiry if the accused seeks to rely on materials which were not there before the Magistrate. This is based on the simple proposition that what the Magistrate could not do, the High Courts may not do. We may not be understood to undermine the High Courts’ powers saved by Section 482 CrPC;
such powers are always available to be exercised ex debito justitiae i.e. to do real and substantial justice for administration of which alone the High Courts exist.
However, the tests laid down for quashing an FIR or criminal proceedings arising from a police report by the High Courts in exercise of jurisdiction under Section 482 CrPC not being substantially different from the tests laid down for quashing of a process issued under Section 204 read with Section 200, the High Courts on recording due satisfaction are empowered to interfere if on a reading of the complaint, the substance of statements on oath of the complainant and the witness, if any, and documentary evidence as produced, no offence is made out and that proceedings, if allowed to continue, would amount to an abuse of the legal process. This too, would be impermissible, if the justice of a given case does not overwhelmingly so demand.”
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 1285Shahed Kamal & Ors. v. M/s A. Surti Developers Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. The High Court has also noticed this judgment which holds that if the materials disclosed in the complaint and the documents annexed disclose a complete defence under any of the Exceptions, nothing prevents the Magistrate upon application of judicial mind to accord the benefit of such Exception to prevent a frivolous complaint from triggering an unnecessary trial. It has been further held that what is “excepted” cannot amount to defamation on the very terms of the provision and that the Magistrate is not in any manner precluded from considering if at all any of the Exceptions is attracted in a given case. It has been further held that if the Magistrate on examination notices that there is a complete defence made out under any one of the Exceptions, the Magistrate would be justified in dismissing the complaint. Equally, the High Court examining the case under Section 482, if it finds on a reading of the complaint, the substance of the statements on oath of the complainant and the witness and the documents produced by the complainant that no offence is made out and if the High Court is of the opinion that proceedings if allowed to continue would be an abuse of legal process, the High Court is empowered to interfere.
14. It is in this background that we have set out to examine the case at hand after keeping in mind the main part of the definition and the exceptions to Section 499. Before we take a closer look at the contents of the banner carrying the imputation, certain peculiar facts obtaining in the case at hand needs to be noticed.
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE PARTIES:-
15. The appellants and the respondent have a business relationship in the sense that the appellants are allottees of residential flats in the building developed by the respondent under a registered builderbuyer agreement with reciprocal obligations provided therein. It is not disputed that in the building there are about 128 allottees and the building itself has ground + stilt+ podium + 22 floors. The banner was put on 10th of August, 2015 i.e. approximately a year and six months after the flat purchasers were put in possession. The grievance raised in the banner is with regard to A) not forming the society even after 18 months B) not giving society accounts C) not co-operating with the residents D) not attending to builders’ defects E) not sorting water issue F) poor lift maintenance G) leakage problem H) plumbing issues I) dirty/bouncy approach road, there is also a grievance with 1286 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports regard to broken podium, shabby garden, ignoring grievances and non-cooperation. There is a caption “we protest for our rights”.
LANGUAGE EMPLOYED IN THE PUBLICATION: -
16. At the very outset, what strikes us is that there is no foul or intemperate language employed against the respondent. There is no reference to any expression like “fraud, cheating, misappropriation etc.” In mild and temperate language, certain issues, which the appellants perceived as their grievances have been aired. It is the appellants’ case that these issues have been raised in the form of letters before though the respondent has denied receipt of all of the letters attributed. Be that as it may, we are not deciding the issue based on the letters. Equally, the appellants have a case that the respondent itself has written letters promising to address grievances and it is only when it failed to do so that they resorted to the protest by erecting the banner. The appellants have a case that these letters have been suppressed. We are, for the moment, keeping these letters aside and deciding the issue based on the averments in the complaint. Further admittedly, there is a civil suit though filed much later in 2018 raising the issue of accounts, nonformation of society and highlighting the deficiencies and seeking reimbursement.
SCOPE OF THE EXCEPTION: -
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.