M/S Techno Prints v. Chhattisgarh Textbook Corporation & Anr.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 236; [2025] 3 S.C.R. 208
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 11 Feb 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2362/2025
- Sections
- 16
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 208 : 2025 INSC 236 M/s Techno Prints v.
Chhattisgarh Textbook Corporation & Anr.
(Civil Appeal No. 2362 of 2025)
12 February 2025 [J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the respondents-Corporation justified in calling upon the appellant-contractor to show cause as to why they should not be blacklisted for a period of three years on alleged violation of the clauses of the tender; and whether the appeal should be entertained arising from a challenge to the show cause notice.
Headnotes† Tender – Tender agreement – Breach of contract – Blacklisting – Power of the Authority to blacklist – Scope – Show cause notice – Issuance of – Appellant was assigned a contract by the respondent no.1 – Issuance of show cause notice by respondent no.1 to the appellant to show cause as to why it should not be blacklisted for a period of three years and the security deposit/EMD be forfeited for violation of the clauses of the tender agreement – Writ petition by the appellant – Rejected by the Single Judge of the High Court – Appeal thereagainst, also dismissed – Correctness:
Held: Ordinarily, a writ court should not entertain any petition, seeking to challenge a show cause notice unless the Court is convinced that the same has been issued by an authority having no jurisdiction, or the same is tainted with mala fides – Sum and substance of the clauses of the tender is that if the appellant is unable to complete the work of printing within the stipulated time then the consequences will be blacklisting – Guiding principles as to when and in what circumstances a blacklisting order can be passed then, should be borne in mind by the Authority at the time of issuing a show cause notice – On facts, no good reason for the Authority to issue show cause notice calling upon the contractor why he should not be blacklisted – There is always an inherent power in the Authority to blacklist a contractor but there should [2025] 3 S.C.R. 209M/s T echno Prints v.
Chhattisgarh T extbook Corporation & Anr.
be reasonable ground to exercise such power – Final order in any case cannot travel beyond the show cause notice – Whether show cause notice makes out a case for blacklisting, should be the test to determine whether it is a genuine case to blacklist a contractor or visit him with any other penalty, like forfeiture of EMD, recovery of damages – Once an order of blacklisting is passed the same would put an end to the business of the person concerned, it is a drastic step – While the debarment itself may not be permanent and may only remain effective for a limited, pre-determined period, its negative effect continues to plague the business of the debarred entity for a long period of time – If a contractor is to be visited with the punitive measure of blacklisting on account of an allegation that he has committed a breach of a contract, the nature of his conduct must be so deviant or aberrant so as to warrant such a punitive measure – Mere allegation of breach of contractual obligations without anything more, per se, does not invite any such punitive action – Respondent no.1 to forfeit the EMD, however notice calling upon the appellant as to why it should not be blacklisted is quashed and set aside. [Paras 16, 24, 29, 30, 32-37] Case Law Cited Kulja Industries Limited v. Chief General Manager Western Telecom Project BSNL & Ors. [2013] 14 SCR 430 : AIR 2014 SC 9; The Blue Dreamz Advertising Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. v. Kolkata Municipal Corp. & Ors. [2024] 8 SCR 189 : 2024 INSC 589; Erusian Equipment & Chemicals Ltd. v. State of W.B. [1975] 2 SCR 674 : (1975) 1 SCC 70 – referred to.
List of Acts Constitution of India.
List of Keywords Tender; Tender agreement; Breach of contract; Blacklisting; Power of the Authority to blacklist; Show cause notice; Security deposit/ EMD; Inherent power in the Authority to blacklist a contractor; Forfeiture of EMD; Recovery of damages; Legal redress; Violation of tender terms; COVID-19 pandemic; Textbook printing tender; Stigma of blacklisting; Punitive measure of blacklisting. 210 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 2362 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 11.04.2023 of the High Court of Chhattisgarh at Bilaspur in WA No. 72 of 2023 Appearances for Parties Gaurav Agarwal, Sr. Adv., Chandrashekhar A Chakdabbi, Vaibhav Shukla, Himanshu Sinha, Anshul Rai, Advs. for the Appellant. Ankit Mishra, Archit Mandhyan, Ms. Kanupriya Mishra, Shantanu Krishna, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Order
1. Leave granted.
2. This appeal arises from the judgment and order passed by the High court of Chhattisgarh at Bilaspur in Writ Appeal No.72 of 2023, by which the writ appeal filed by the appellant herein, came to be dismissed and thereby the judgment and order passed by the Learned Single Judge, rejecting the writ petition of the appellant came to be affirmed.
3. The facts giving rise to this appeal may be summarized as under:-
(a) The appellant herein, is in the business of printing past many years.
(b) The appellant company is one of the 30 firms, registered with the Chhattisgarh Text Book Corporation (respondent no.1 herein).
(c) The subject matter of this litigation is the show cause notice that came to be issued by the respondent no.1 to the appellant firm, calling upon the firm to show cause as to why it should not be blacklisted for a period of three years and the EMD of Rs.5,00,000/- (Rupees Five Lakh only), be forfeited. The appellant firm was also called upon to show cause as to why the loss incurred by the corporation, due to its default in fulfilling its terms of contract, be recovered.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 211M/s T echno Prints v.
Chhattisgarh T extbook Corporation & Anr.
4. Prima facie, it appears that the petitioner firm was declared as L-1 in one of the tenders issued by the corporation i.e. the respondent no.1. According to the respondent no.1, the appellant firm violated few clauses of the tender agreement.
5. The relevant clauses of the tender document/agreement which according to the respondent no.1, have been breached, read thus:- “16.1 Period of supply of books maximum 90 days as per mentioned in the work order from the date of printing order. It will be imperative upon the bidder to complete the allotted printing & binding work within stipulated time period i.e. maximum 90 days as per mentioned in the work order. In emergency the CGPPN will reduce period for supply of books as per requirements. The 22/52 decision of the Managing Director in this regard will be final and binding on concerned bidder.
xxx xxx xxx 16.3 If the progress of work at any stage is found slower than expected and if the Nigam is convinced that the printer will not be able to complete the work in time, the Nigam shall cancel the contract in full or in part and give it to other printer at the cost and risk of defaulting printer. In the event of such cancellation, the security deposit/EMD of the printer shall be forfeited and the printer will not be entitled to any compensation.
xxx xxx xxx 16.9 If the tenderer is awarded to the lowest rate printer on the basis of L-1 rate of group/groups and Nigam allots the printing works to the tenderer on the basis of his L1 rate (Lowest Tenderer) of group/groups then also if tenderer refuses to do the printing work or work not completed, in this condition Nigam has right to put the tenderer in BLACK LIST for 3 (Three) years and security deposit and EMD will be forfeited.”
6. The show cause notice issued by the respondent no.1 was made a subject matter of challenge, by filing writ petition before the High Court.
212 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
7. The Learned Single Judge rejected the writ petition holding as under:- “8. Having heard the contention put forth on either side and on perusal of records what is required to be taken note of at this juncture is the opening paragraph of the order of the High Court in WPC No. 1297/2021 (Sharda Offset Printers Pvt. Ltd. v. Chhattisgarh Textbook Corporation & another) and the operative part of the judgment of the said writ petition is reproduced hereinunder for ready reference:
“1. The challenge in this writ petition is to the order dated 02.01.2021 passed by respondent No.1 whereby the petitioner has been blacklisted for a period of 3 years. 23. Therefore, when the order of blacklisting is compared with the show cause notice, in the instant case, it clearly spells out that the order of blacklisting exceeded the grounds which were given in show cause.
The main emphasis was that the petitioner has received paper material in excess of bank guarantee for which the agreement contains measures under Clause 6.1.4. The black-listing was made under Clauses 13.3 & 13.6 of the agreement with respect to furnishing of bank guarantee. Even Clause 3 was not part of the show cause. The show cause notice was only confined to Clause 13.3 & 13.6. Reading of clause 13.3 & 13.6 would show that they are in general terms as Clause 13.3 purports that any failure to fulfill contractual obligations or breach of any provisions of agreement, may render the bidder to be black-listed. Clause 13.6 further purports that if the printer is found to influence any staff of the Nigam in any unauthorised manner will also be blacklisted. In the Statement of Chinta Ram Sahu and in police enquiry against him, nothing was found against the petitioner and omnibus inference cannot be drawn that the petitioner had influenced the staff of the Corporation and had influenced [2025] 3 S.C.R. 213M/s T echno Prints v.
Chhattisgarh T extbook Corporation & Anr.
the Police, thereby the petitioner was liable to be blacklisted. 24. Applying the principles laid down by the Supreme Court, I am of the view that the blacklisting order in this case travelled beyond the scope of show cause notice, as such, is liable to be quashed. Accordingly the order dated 02.01.2021 is quashed. With the above observations, this writ petition is allowed.”
9. The plain reading of the aforesaid order would clearly give an indication that the challenge in the earlier round of litigation was confined to the order of blacklisting. Further that the High Court had only tested the order of blacklisting qua the show cause notice that was earlier issued on 13.04.2020 while deciding the writ petition. The High Court at no point of time had precluded the respondents from conducting an inquiry and proceeding in accordance with law. It had only found the order of blacklisting earlier passed on 02.01.2021 to be bad in law and contrary to the contents of the show cause notice dated 13.04.2020.
10. The plain reading of the averments of the show cause notice would by itself show that the respondents have made certain serious allegations against the petitioner in respect of the lifting of the papers from the respondent- Corporation by material suppression of facts so far as furnishing of the Bank Guarantee is concerned.
11. Only because the earlier order of blacklisting having been quashed by the High Court would not preclude the respondent-Corporation from initiating appropriate proceedings for the irregularity committed by the petitioner, if any, in accordance with law. That it is for this reason that the petitioner has been issued with a fresh show cause notice spelling out the allegations that has been made against him. The petitioner can very well provide all the explanations to the allegations made to the respondents supported with all relevant documents in their support. Upon such explanation being submitted the respondent authorities are duty bound to duly consider the same and 214 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports after due consideration alone, can they take an appropriate decision to proceed further, if required.
12. Further, what is also reflected from the proceedings is that, subsequent to allowing of the earlier writ petition, the respondents have now issued with a detailed show cause notice to the petitioner on 14.12.2022, which is under challenge in the present writ petition. The notice would clearly give an indication of the details of the papers that the petitioner had collected for the printing and publication purpose at the different point of time from the respondent-Corporation. The core question that needs to be consider is that since there was no challenge to the show cause notice earlier and that it was order of blacklisting alone which was under challenge, would not preclude the respondents from conducting an inquiry in respect of an allegation as is reflected in the show cause notice against the petitioner.
13. The further question to be considered also is the fact that if at all if the earlier writ petition stands allowed which was exclusively challenging the order of blacklisting would it not amount to the respondents being precluded for all time to come from initiating any action in respect of any illegality which was detected by the respondents in respect of the contract entered into between the petitioner and the respondents. All the contentions and the allegations that the petitioner raises is only trying to establish the fact that the allegations leveled against the petitioner does not stand the test of law as it has already been subjected to test in the earlier round of litigation i.e. in WPC No. 1325/2021. Whereas on the perusal of the order of the earlier writ petition would clearly give an indication that the challenge in the said writ petition was only to the order of blacklisting. That it was only the order of blacklisting which was subjected to scrutiny by the writ Court and it was only the order of blacklisting which has been set aside/ quashed. The writ Court in the earlier judgment in WPC No. 1325/2021 has not held that the allegations leveled against the petitioner is not made out. All that it has been held by the writ Court was that the grounds raised for [2025] 3 S.C.R. 215M/s T echno Prints v.
Chhattisgarh T extbook Corporation & Anr.
blacklisting, was not reflected in the show cause notice and the order of blacklisting was traveling beyond the scope of the show cause notice.
14. Under the circumstances, the subsequent show cause notice in respect of the same contract would be sustainable and the same cannot be held to be either arbitrary or bad in law at this stage. The petitioner would have all the rights and liberty to put up their explanation so far as the allegations are concerned in their response which they are required to submit to the show cause notice. That upon such reply being furnished the authorities concerned are duty bound to duly consider the same and then take an appropriate decision whether to proceed further on the show cause notice proceedings in the light of the explanation so submitted by the petitioner or not?
15. This view of this Court stands fortified from the order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of “STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH V. BRAHM DATT SHARMA & ANR.”
(1987) 2 SCC 179 and “SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF DEFENCE & ORS. V. PRABHASH CHANDRA MIRDHA”
(2012) 11 SCC 565. This Court in the recent past in WPC No. 4431/2019 (Kavita Sharma v. State of Chhattisgarh and others) while deciding the matter on an inquiry report that was furnished to the petitioner therein had while deciding the writ petition on 05.12.2019 in paragraphs No. 11 to 14 has held as under:
“11. The High Court in exercise of its powers under Article 226 of the Constitution of India would not substitute itself as a fact finding body to ascertain the correctness in respect of the allegations made neither can this Court in exercise of writ jurisdiction conduct a roving enquiry against the allegations which have been levelled against the petitioner.
12. The Supreme Court in the case of State of Uttar Pradesh v. Brahm Datt Sharma & Anr. [1987 2 SCC 179] dealing with the scope of judicial interference in disciplinary 216 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports matters was of the opinion that, “the purpose of issuing show cause notice is to afford an opportunity of hearing to the Government servant and once cause is shown and is open to the Government to consider the matter in the light of the facts and submissions placed by the Government servant, only thereafter a final decision in the matter could be taken.
Interference by the Court before that stage would be premature and the Hon’ble Supreme Court went on holding that, the High Court in our opinion ought not have interfered with the show cause notice.
13. Again, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Secretary, Ministry of Defence & Ors. v.
Prabhash Chandra Mirdha [2012 11 SCC 565] in paragraph 8, 10 & 12 has held as under:- “8. The law does not permit quashing of chargesheet in a routine manner. In case the delinquent employee has any grievance in respect of the charge-sheet he must raise the issue by filing a representation and wait for the decision of the disciplinary authority thereon. 10. Ordinarily a writ application does not lie against a chargesheet or show-cause notice for the reason that it does not give rise to any cause of action. It does not amount to an adverse order which affects the right of any party unless the same has been issued by a person having no jurisdiction/ competence to do so. A writ lies when some right of a party is infringed. In fact, chargesheet does not infringe the right of a party. It is only when a final order imposing the punishment or otherwise adversely affecting a party is passed, it may have a grievance and cause of action.
Thus, a charge-sheet or show-cause notice in disciplinary proceedings should not ordinarily be quashed by the court. 12. Thus, the law on the issue can be summarised to the effect that [2025] 3 S.C.R. 217M/s T echno Prints v.
Chhattisgarh T extbook Corporation & Anr.
the charge-sheet cannot generally be a subject matter of challenge as it does not adversely affect the rights of the delinquent unless it is established that the same has been issued by an authority not competent to initiate the disciplinary proceedings. Neither the disciplinary proceedings nor the charge-sheet be quashed at an initial stage as it would be a premature stage to deal with the issues.
14. Keeping in view the aforesaid legal pronouncements as is laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court and also taking into consideration the fact that the petitioner has also submitted a detailed reply to the show-cause notice, the authorities are yet to take a decision on the show-cause notice. The present writ petition in its present form would not be sustainable.
The authorities concerned are expected to take a decision objectively, considering all the submissions that the petitioner has made in the reply to the Show-Cause Notice.”
16. Given the said facts, reserving the right of the petitioner to submit a detailed reply to the show cause notice, the writ petition at this juncture stands rejected.”
8. The appellant being dissatisfied with the order passed by the Learned Single Judge, rejecting his writ petition went in appeal.
9. The Appellate Court dismissed the appeal, holding as under:- “4. A careful perusal of the aforesaid part of the notice would show that it is only a show cause notice and appellant’s response has been sought to decide the issue and nothing has been adjudicated to say that the respondent has already taken final decision in the matter. The learned Single Judge after detailed hearing has clearly held in paragraphs No.9 to 14 as under:- “9. The plain reading of the aforesaid order would clearly give an indication that the challenge in the earlier round 218 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports of litigation was confined to the order of blacklisting. Further that the High Court had only tested the order of blacklisting qua the show cause notice that was earlier issued on 13.04.2020 while deciding the writ petition. The High Court at no point of time had precluded the respondents from conducting an inquiry and proceeding in accordance with law. It had only found the order of blacklisting earlier passed on 02.01.2021 to be bad in law and contrary to the contents of the show cause notice dated 13.04.2020.
10. The plain reading of the averments of the show cause notice would by itself show that the respondents have made certain serious allegations against the petitioner in respect of the lifting of the papers from the respondent- Corporation by material suppression of facts so far as furnishing of the Bank Guarantee is concerned.
11. Only because the earlier order of blacklisting having been quashed by the High Court would not preclude the respondent-Corporation from initiating appropriate proceedings for the irregularity committed by the petitioner, if any, in accordance with law. That it is for this reason that the petitioner has been issued with a fresh show cause notice spelling out the allegations that has been made against him. The petitioner can very well provide all the explanations to the allegations made to the respondents supported with all relevant documents in their support. Upon such explanation being submitted the respondent authorities are duty bound to duly consider the same and after due consideration alone, can they take an appropriate decision to proceed further, if required.
12. Further, what is also reflected from the proceedings is that, subsequent to allowing of the earlier writ petition, the respondents have now issued with a detailed show cause notice to the petitioner on 14.12.2022, which is under challenge in the present writ petition. The notice would clearly give an indication of the details of the papers that the petitioner had collected for the printing and publication purpose at the different point of time [2025] 3 S.C.R. 219M/s T echno Prints v.
Chhattisgarh T extbook Corporation & Anr.
from the respondent-Corporation. The core question that needs to be consider is that since there was no challenge to the show cause notice earlier and that it was order of blacklisting alone which was under challenge, would not preclude the respondents from conducting an inquiry in respect of an allegation as is reflected in the show cause notice against the petitioner.
13. The further question to be considered also is the fact that if at all if the earlier writ petition stands allowed which was exclusively challenging the order of blacklisting would it not amount to the respondents being precluded for all time to come from initiating any action in respect of any illegality which was detected by the respondents in respect of the contract entered into between the petitioner and the respondents. All the contentions and the allegations that the petitioner raises is only trying to establish the fact that the allegations leveled against the petitioner does not stand the test of law as it has already been subjected to test in the earlier round of litigation i.e. in WPC No. 1325/2021. Whereas on the perusal of the order of the earlier writ petition would clearly give an indication that the challenge in the said writ petition was only to the order of blacklisting. That it was only the order of blacklisting which was subjected to scrutiny by the writ Court and it was only the order of blacklisting which has been setaside/quashed. The writ Court in the earlier judgment in WPC No. 1325/2021 has not held that the allegations leveled against the petitioner is not made out. All that it has been held by the writ Court was that the grounds raised for blacklisting, was not reflected in the show cause notice and the order of blacklisting was traveling beyond the scope of the show cause notice.
14. Under the circumstances, the subsequent show cause notice in respect of the same contract would be sustainable and the same cannot be held to be either arbitrary or bad in law at this stage. The petitioner would have all the rights and liberty to put up their explanation so far as the allegations are concerned 220 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports in their response which they are required to submit to the show cause notice. That upon such reply being furnished the authorities concerned are duty bound to duly consider the same and then take an appropriate decision whether to proceed further on the show cause notice proceedings in the light of the explanation so submitted by the petitioner or not?””
10. In such circumstances record to above, the appellant is here before this Court with the present appeal.
11. We have heard Mr. Gaurav Agarwal, the learned senior counsel, appearing for the appellant and Mr. Ankit Mishra, the learned counsel appearing for the respondent nos.1 and 2, respectively.
12. We take notice of the order passed by this Court dated 17.05.2023, the same reads thus:- “Mr. Priyank Upadhyay, learned Advocate on Record accepts notice on behalf of the respondents. Hence, issue of formal notice to the respondents is dispensed with. Objections to the petition, if any, be filed.
In the meanwhile, there shall be stay of further proceedings pursuant to the notice dated 14.12.2022.”
13. Thus, it appears that by way of interim order, the further proceedings of the show cause notice were stayed.
14. The short point that falls for our consideration in this appeal is whether we should entertain this appeal arising from a challenge to the show cause notice.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.