Sheikh Javeed Ahmad & Anr. v. State of J&k & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 624; [2025] 3 S.C.R. 1503
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sanjay Karol, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 27 Mar 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 4426/2025
- Sections
- 103, 13(3)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 1503 : 2025 INSC 624 Sheikh Javeed Ahmad & Anr.
v.
State of J&K & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No(s). 4426-4427 of 2025)
27 March 2025 [Vikram Nath, Sanjay Karol and Sandeep Mehta, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the High Court erred in setting aside the appointments of the appellants as Assistant Professors as being incompatible with the rules and regulations.
Headnotes† Service Law – High Court canceled the appointment of the appellants as Assistant Professors in the Department of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation (PMR), Sher-I-Kashmir Institute of Medical Sciences, Soura, Srinagar (SKIMS) holding that they did not have the prescribed qualification of diploma course in PMR – It was held that they did not make any effort for admission into the institutions that ran the aforesaid course and that there was nothing on record to show that obtaining a diploma in PMR was impossible – Challenge to:
Held: High Court erred in setting aside the appointment of the appellants – Notification issued by the competent authority, blocking two positions of Assistant Professor for the appellants shows that the two candidates were to be sponsored for twoyear diploma in their specialty whereafter, they would serve the institution for seven years in accordance with the necessary bond – Therefore, it was SKIMS that had to make arrangements to secure admission for the appellants however, it could not arrange for the appellants to undertake the course – Further, it was also found that various colleges had shut down the diploma course – Moreover, the appellants did undertake such training and the first appellant, even secured a letter of recommendation by the Head of Department, AIIMS Delhi – Appellants to be 1504 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports reinstated in service as Assistant Professors with continuity in service. [Paras 8, 9, 11, 12, 15] Service matters – Public Interest Litigation – Maintainability – Discussed.
Case Law Cited Dr. Duryodhan Sahu v. Jitendra Kumar Misha & Ors. [1998] Supp. 1 SCR 77 : (1998) 7 SCC 273; Gurpal Singh v. State of Punjab [2005] Supp. 1 SCR 215 : (2005) 5 SCC 136; Hari Bansh Lal v. Sahodar Prasad Mahto [2010] 10 SCR 561: (2010) 9 SCC 655; High Court of Gujarat v. Gujarat Kishan Mazdoor Panchayat & Ors. [2003] 2 SCR 799 : (2003) 4 SCC 712 – referred to.
List of Acts J&K Constitution.
List of Keywords Appointments as Assistant Professors; Sher-I-Kashmir Institute of Medical Sciences (SKIMS); Apical Selection Committee; Senior Residents in Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation (PMR); Diploma courses in PMR; Two-year diploma; ‘Impossibility’ of obtaining the prescribed qualifications; All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi (AIIMS); Requirement of a diploma relaxed; Public interest litigation; PIL in service matters; Reinstatement; Continuity in service; Impossibility in law.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No(s). 4426-4427 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 30.03.2018 and 11.07.2014 of the High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh at Srinagar in PIL No. 43 of 2014 and PIL No. 861 of 2010 respectively Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Gaurav Pachnanda, A.M.Magrey, Sr. Advs., Nitish Gupta, Farman Ali, Ms. Nikita Jaitely, Dhruv Arora, Chandra Prakash. Advs. for the Respondents:
G.M. Kawoosa, Pashupathi Nath Razdan.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 1505Sheikh Javeed Ahmad & Anr. v. State of J&K & O rs. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Order Leave Granted.
2. These appeals question the correctness of a judgment and order dated 11 th July 2014 passed in OWP (PIL) No.861 of 2010 and the order dated 30 th March 2018 in RPIL No.43 of 2014 as well as the order dated 30 th March, 2018 in RPPIL No.43/2014, by the High Court of Jammu and Kashmir at Srinagar, whereby appointments as Assistant Professors, granted to the appellants herein, namely, Dr. Sheikh Javeed Ahmad & Dr. Abdul Hamid Rather, were set aside as being incompatible with the rules and regulations, and the reviews sought thereagainst being dismissed as well.
At the outset, we note an order of this Court passed on 3rd November 2023- “When the matters are called on for hearing, learned counsel for the petitioners submitted before us that out of the three petitioners of the Public Interest Litigation (‘PIL’) out of which the present proceeding arises, two are not traceable and one of the three persons in whose names that action has been brought has filed an affidavit before the High Court stating therein that he had not filed the said petition.
The State shall file a report as regards whereabouts of the three petitioners who had brought the PIL. The State shall also apprise this Court about the position of vacancy in the Sher-I- Kashmir Institute of Medical Sciences, Srinagar…” (Emphasis supplied)
On 12th December 2023, it was informed that the Director General, Crime Investigation Department 1 was inquiring into the identities of the PIL petitioners. Vide affidavit dated 12 th February 2024 filed by the Secretary to the Government of Jammu Kashmir, enclosed the report of the CID, which is extracted below for reference : 1 Hereafter, CID 1506 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports i. The petitioner namely Mohd Syed Shah S/O Mohd Sadiq Shah figuring at S.No.01 in the ibid reference found to be resident of Konan, Bandipora. He is approximately 70 years of age. He was running a medical shop at Chuntimullah, Bandipora, currently his two sons are running a medical shop in main market Bandipora. The purported petitioner Mohammad Syed Shah has denied to have filed the PIL before the Hon’ble Court. Reportedly 02 years back, he had given an undertaking to SKIMS authorities wherein he denied filing of any such PIL before the Hon’ble Court. The contact number of Mohammad Syed Shah is 9596325628.
ii. The petitioner namely Mohammad Ishaq Khanday S/O Abdul Khaliq Khanday R/O Batpora, Sopore figuring at S.No.02 in the ibid reference is currently residing at Hamza Colony Bemina Srinagar since 1986 and retired as Research Assistant from Agriculture Department in 2020. His phone number is 7889505126. He admitted the filing of the PIL.
iii. The whereabouts in respect of the petitioner namely Mohammad Amin Sheikh S/O Ghulam Ahmad Sheikh R/O Bohari, Sopore figuring at S.No.3 in the above quoted reference could not be traced out due to incomplete address.
3. The field report further revealed that the petition was reportedly filed by one Dr. Ali Mohammad Buhroo S/O Ghulam Mohammad Buhroo R/O Gundiqasier, Bandipora, the then HOD Physics SKIMS Srinagar (Now retired)
10years ago before the Hon’ble High Court of J & K on behalf of the petitioners including Mohammad Syed Shah with whom the purported petitioner Mohammad Syed Shah was working as an attendant.”
(Emphasis supplied)
We may here itself record our surprise that the High Court, after being in receipt of such an affidavit of the alleged petitioner, did not take steps to look into its order and the propriety thereof. Be that [2025] 3 S.C.R. 1507Sheikh Javeed Ahmad & Anr. v. State of J&K & O rs. as it may, we now proceed to the facts and merits of the matters before us.
3. Shorn of unnecessary details, the factual backdrop of these appeals is as under :
3.1 The authorities of the State issued advertisement notice No. 1 on 31 st December 2004 to fill up positions of Professors, Associate Professors and Assistant Professors at the Sher-I- Kashmir Institute of Medical Sciences, Soura, Srinagar2. The Appellants herein applied for the position of Assistant Professors, however, were adjudged ineligible.
3.2 Subsequently, the Apical Selection Committee, in its XXIX th meeting held from 25 th to 29 th August 2005, recommended the appointment of the two Appellants as Senior Residents in Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation 3 as also their sponsorship for a two-year diploma in the specialty. It was also stated in the resolution that they shall be appointed as Assistant Professors in Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation after completing the two years’ training course and as such, two positions of Assistant Professors were blocked for such purpose.
3.3 The appellants were appointed to such positions (Senior Residents) on 12 th December 2005. Due to certain difficulties, it appears that the two-year diploma could not fructify. This led to certain correspondence between the Head of Department, SKIMS and the Head of Department, PMR, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi 4 , asking for clarity in this regard. The Head of the Department of the latter institution recommended in his letter dated 10 th March 2006 that according to the practice that has been followed, on-the-job training is imparted in PMR, AIIMS, under a learned teacher and that he would be more than willing to fill in this gap. It is also stated in the letter that this training is for either 6 months or any other time period as is deemed necessary. Though, this would not amount to a degree but is sufficient for the person having received the 2 Abbreviated as ‘SKIMS’ 3 Abbreviated as ‘PMR’ 4 Abbreviated as ‘AIIMS’ 1508 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports same to work as a faculty in the subject. The correspondence dated 10th March 2006 by Dr. U. Singh, the Head of Department, PMR, AIIMS, is extracted as below :
“…Dear Sir Buhroo, Kindly refer to your letter No. SIMS/PMR/170/24/06 dated 07.03.2006 regarding training of Sr. Residents of your Department to undergo Diploma in PMR, and extending Academic Assistance to your Institution.
As desired in your letter, the AIIMS does not run any Diploma Course. It runs only three years Degree course leading to MD (PMR). If you wish to train your Senior Residents in PMR. It will not be very logical to train a person already having an MD (medicine)
degree to do any Degree course in PMR. As was done in the past, persons with MD (Medicines) or M.S. (Orthopaedics) used to get on the job training in PMR under a learned teacher, while working in Department of PMR itself. This has been the practice how our Senior illegible trained and imparted training to others.
I would like to suggest you that you should work the possibility of training your own Senior Residents, under your own care in the Department of PMR at SKIMS, Srinagar, rather than sending them away … … … I understand that for sharpening certain skills, some exposure would be required in other institutions as well for a short period of time. Our Department, at AIIMs, would be very happy to fill this gap. If you deem it necessary. The short term training may be of a few months, or the period you feel necessary … … … But, I would like to clarify once again that such short term trainings will not amount to any degree or diploma but it should be sufficient for the person to work as a Faculty of this subject.”
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 1509Sheikh Javeed Ahmad & Anr. v. State of J&K & O rs. 3.4 Consequently, the appellants undertook the short-term training program at AIIMS Delhi. On 6th October 2007, a fresh advertisement for recruitment was issued for the vacancies which remained unfilled. The record reveals that, vide letter dated 26th October 2007, SKIMS acknowledged that the efforts made to secure positions in a two-year diploma course for the appellants had not yielded results. It was further stated that since they had successfully completed the training offered in Delhi, they could be considered for the position of Assistant Professor. The letter is extracted, as under :
“ANNEXURE P-9
SHER-I KASHMIR INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL
SCIENCES,
(DEEMED UNIVERSITY) SOURA, SRINAGAR
Subject : Short term training Course in Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation at AIIMS, New Delhi.
Reference: Letter No.SIMS 302 07 (XXIX) 2005- 1955-56 dated: 11.10.2007 Refer your above communication regarding Dr.
Sheikh Javeed Ahmad and Dr. Abdul Hamid Rather for undergoing Diploma in PMR as per the decision of the Apical Selection Committee held from August 25 th to 29 th 2005.
In this connection you are hereby informed that the possibility of undergoing Diploma in PMR was tried and it was found that Diploma in PMR was not available in AIIMS and PGI. However, HOD, Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, AIIMS was contacted in this regard by HOD, PMR, SKIMS who had send his reply as enclosed.
Accordingly the concerned doctors were send for six months training in the department of Phy. Medicine & Rehabilitation at AIIMS and now they have returned after completing the training course.
1510 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Thus their case may be taken up for consideration to the post of Assistant Professor as decided in the Apical Selection Committee.
Registrar (Academic)
AAO (Policy)
SKIMS
Sims, ACAD/SR-995 2007 Dated: 26.10.2007 Copy for information to
1. PS to Dean for information of the Dean.”
3.5 On 12th February 2008, the requirement of a diploma was relaxed by the Directorate General of Health Services, Government of India, qua contractual employees 5 , which is annexed as Annexure P-10. However, yet again, a fresh advertisement dated 25th June 2009 was issued by SKIMS. Record is silent as to what became of this process.
3.6 On 20th October 2010, a Notification was issued appointing the instant appellants as Assistant Professors in the said department. The order of appointment, which runs into five pages, annexed as Annexure P-14 6 , elaborately discusses the background of the appointments of the appellants as Assistant Professors. Pursuant to SKIMS’ communication with AIIMS, Delhi, they undertook training at the latter institution. This was with the approval of the Apical Selection Committee, since despite best efforts by the former, admission into a two-year diploma could not be secured for the appellants on the ground of non-availability across the number of institutions in the country. It is in the aforesaid backdrop that the Apical Selection Committee recommended the relaxation of this condition qua the appellants which was so done by the competent authority, viz., Hon’ble Chief Minister, Chairman of the SKIMS Governing Body.
5 Page 100 of the paperbook.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.