Cmj Foundation and Others v. State of Meghalaya and Others
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 211; [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1020
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 13 Feb 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 9694/2024
- Sections
- 48, 14(1), 48(2), 13(1), 14, 22, 13(3), 13(2), 45(3), 46(4), 41(1), 52
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1020 : 2025 INSC 211 CMJ Foundation and Others v.
State of Meghalaya and Others (Civil Appeal No. 9694 of 2024)
13 February 2025 [Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the appointment of the Chancellor of the CMJ University was made with due adherence to the procedure, as mandated by law; whether the dissolution order dated 31st March, 2014 was passed with due adherence to the procedure provided under Section 48 of the CMJ University Act, 2009 and in compliance of the directions issued by this Court vide order dated 13th September, 2013 in SLP(C) No. 19617 of 2013 titled as “CMJ Foundation & Ors. v. State of Meghalaya and Ors.”; whether the Division Bench of the High Court of Meghalaya was justified in remanding the matter to the learned Single Judge for reconsideration on merit, while allowing the Writ Appeal No. 14 of 2017.
Headnotes† Chandra Mohan Jha University Act, 2009 – s.14(1) – Non-compliance with – Appointment of the Chancellor of the CMJ University, if was non-est and void ab initio:
Held: Yes – Under s.14(1), the Sponsor must appoint a person suitable to be appointed as the Chancellor of the University, however, such appointment is ‘subject to the approval’ of the Visitor – Thus, the appointment of the Chancellor, made by the University, shall require mandatory approval by the Visitor failing which, such appointment would be non est in the eyes of law – The phrase ‘subject to’ means ‘conditional upon’ in law – Therefore, the appointment of Chancellor was conditional upon the approval of the Visitor – The Visitor is not merely a titular head and the appointment of any person as Chancellor by the Sponsor would attain validity only upon the approval of the Visitor – However, in the present case, the Visitor’s approval was never granted for the appointment of the Chancellor of the University – Thus, the procedure prescribed u/s.14(1) for the appointment of the * Author [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1021CMJ Foundation and Others v. State of Meghalaya and Others Chancellor was not duly followed by the CMJ University – Division Bench of the High Court rightly declared the appointment of the Chancellor of the CMJ University as invalid and non-est in the eyes of law – To this extent, the impugned judgment does not suffer from any infirmity. [Paras 36, 39, 44, 46] Chandra Mohan Jha University Act, 2009 – s.48(2) – State Government dissolved the CMJ University vide order dated 31.03.2014 – Aforesaid dissolution order, if was passed adhering to the procedure provided u/s.48 and in compliance of the directions issued by this Court vide order dated 13.09.2013 in SLP(C) No.19617 of 2013 wherein it took cognizance of the recommendations issued by the Visitor indicating the irregularities committed by the CMJ University and directed the State Government to take appropriate action and pass a speaking order u/s.48, after giving due notice and opportunity of hearing to the appellants:
Held: Yes – On facts, proper opportunity to show cause and take necessary measures for rectification was extended to the appellants against the proposed action of dissolution – State Government examined the replies to the show cause notices and passed the well-reasoned order dated 31.03.2014, by taking recourse to the powers conferred by s.48(2), dissolving the CMJ University with immediate effect on the grounds that the appellants neither satisfactorily explained the allegations set out in the show cause notices, nor could they provide adequate justification for the evident anomalies and irregularities – Also, the reminder letter dated 03.06.2013 issued by the State Government was in compliance with s.48(2) – Decision of the State Government dated 31.03.2014 dissolving the CMJ University, affirmed – Educational Institution – Dissolution. [Paras 55, 56, 58, 59] Practice and Procedure – Remand of the matter, when not proper – Whether the Division Bench of the High Court was justified in remanding the matter to the Single Judge for reconsideration on merit, while allowing the Writ Appeal: Held: By way of the impugned judgment, the Division Bench had quashed and set aside the judgment dated 16.07.2015 passed by the Single Judge and upheld the procedure followed by the State Government in ordering the dissolution of the University u/s.48 – Division Bench was fully justified in quashing and setting aside the 1022 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports order dated 16.07.2015 passed by the Single Judge which had set aside the dissolution order dated 31.03.2014 and the show cause notices issued to the University by the State Government – However, it remanded the matter to the Single Judge for taking appropriate decision regarding the validity of order dissolving the University on merit, observing that the Single Judge only examined the dissolution order on procedural framework and did not enter into the merits of the said decision – The remand to the Single Judge was entirely unjustified and unwarranted as the controversy in the present case was exhaustively examined and conclusively determined on merits by the Division Bench, leaving no substantive questions or unresolved issues for re-determination on merits by the Single Judge – Thus, once the Division Bench had approved the procedure adopted by the State, in passing the dissolution order, the exercise of remand was an empty formality – Order of remand legally flawed and untenable – Wednesbury Principle. [Paras 60-65] Interpretation of Statutes – Chandra Mohan Jha University Act, 2009 – Absence of a deeming provision creating a legal fiction – Legal fiction can only be created by a statute and not by judicial interpretation – Plea of the appellants that repeated requests were made to the Visitor of the CMJ University seeking approval for the appointment of the Chancellor and a letter was also sent stating that if the Visitor did not provide approval within the specified date, it would be deemed as approval – However, there was no response – Thus, the appellants acting in a bona fide manner assumed that such inaction/omission on part of the Visitor amounted to a ‘deemed approval’ for the appointment of the Chancellor:
Held: Such contention is misplaced and unsubstantiated by law – There is no deeming provision in the Act creating such legal fiction as was assumed by the appellants – In the absence of any statutory flavour, a provision cannot be interpreted to create a legal fiction – Creating a fiction through judicial interpretation will amount to legislation, which is exclusively the domain of legislature. [Paras 42, 43] Case Law Cited V. Balasubramaniam & Others v. Tamilnadu Housing Board & Others [1988] 1 SCR 228 : (1987) 4 SCC 738; Trilochan Mishra etc. v. [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1023CMJ Foundation and Others v. State of Meghalaya and Others State of Orissa & Ors., AIR 1971 SC 733; Union of India & Ors. v. M/s Bhimsen Walaiti Ram [1970] 2 SCR 594 : AIR 1971 SC 2295; State of Orissa & Ors. v. Harinarayan Jaiswal & Ors. [1972] 3 SCR 784 : AIR 1972 SC 1816; State of U.P. & Ors. v. Vijay Bahadur Singh & Ors., AIR 1982 SC 1234; Laxmikant & Ors. v. Satyawan & Ors. [1996] 3 SCR 532 : AIR 1996 SC 2052; K.R.C.S. Balakrishna Chetty & Sons & Co. v. State of Madras [1961] 2 SCR 736 : 1960 SCC OnLine SC 179; Vijay S. Sathaye v. Indian Airlines Ltd. [2013] 10 SCR 73 : (2013) 10 SCC 253; Sant Lal Gupta & Ors. v. Modern Cooperative Group Housing Society Ltd. and Ors. [2010] 13 SCR 621 : 2010 SCC OnLine SC 1169; Union of India v. G. Ganayutham [1997] Supp. 3 SCR 549 : 1997 SCC OnLine SC 135; Gohil Vishvaraj Hanubhai and Ors. v. State of Gujarat and Ors. [2017] 3 SCR 401 : (2017) 13 SCC 621; Nadekerappa since Deceased by LRs. and Ors. v. Pillamma since Deceased by LRs. and Ors. [2022] 14 SCR 1046 : 2022 SCC OnLine SC 387 – relied on.
U.P. Avas Evam Vikas Parishad & Anr. v. Friends Coop. Housing Society Ltd. & Anr. [1995] 3 SCR 729 : (1995) Supp. 3 SCC 456; High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan v. P.P. Singh & Anr. [2003] 1 SCR 593 : (2003) 4 SCC 239; Ashok Kumar Das & Ors. v. University of Burdwan & Ors. [2010] 3 SCR 429 : (2010) 3 SCC 616; Chet Ram Vashist v. MCD and Another [1981] 1 SCR 1073 : (1980) 4 SCC 647; CMJ Foundation & Ors. v. State of Meghalaya and Ors., Order dated 13.09.2013 of Supreme Court in SLP(C) No. 19617 of 2013 – referred to.
List of Acts Chandra Mohan Jha University Act, 2009; University Grants Act, 1956; Meghalaya Private Universities (Regulation of Establishment and Maintenance of Standards) Act, 2012.
List of Keywords Sections 14 (1), 48 of the Chandra Mohan Jha University Act, 2009; Chandra Mohan Jha Foundation; Chandra Mohan Jha University; CMJ University; Chancellor of the University; Appointment of Chancellor; Due adherence to the procedure; Visitor; Ex-Officio; Governor ex-officio Visitor; Visitor’s approval; Mandatory approval; Sponsor; ‘subject to’; Subject to the Approval; ‘Conditional upon’; Deeming provision; Deemed Approval; Legal fiction; Dissolution; Dissolution Order; Irregularities; Anomalies; Deficiencies; Management 1024 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports of the CMJ University; Reconsideration on merit; Remand Order; Non Est; Void ab inito; Wednesbury Principles; Compliance; Directions; Adjudication on Merits.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 9694 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 06.05.2021 of the High Court of Meghalaya at Shillong in WA No. 14 of 2017 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Anupam Lal Das, Suryanarayana Singh, Sr. Advs., Philemon Nongbri, Ahanthem Henry, A. Rohen Singh, Ms. Anne Mathew, Ms. Pragati Neekhra, Aditya Bhanu Neekhra, Atul Dong, Aniket Patel. Advs. for the Respondents:
Anupam Lal Das, Sr. Adv., Philemon Nongbri, Ahanthem Henry, A. Rohen Singh, Ms. Anne Mathew, Ms. Pragati Neekhra, Dr. Vinod Kumar Tewari.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
For the convenience of exposition, this judgment is divided into the following parts: - INDEX* A. FACTUAL MATRIX ............................................................... 3
B. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANTS ...... 17
C. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT-
STATE ..................................................................................... 22 D. ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION .......................................... 26 E. ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION ............................................ 27 * Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1025CMJ Foundation and Others v. State of Meghalaya and Others ISSUE No. I: “Whether the appointment of the Chancellor of the CMJ University was made with due adherence to the procedure, as mandated by law”? ......................................... 27 ISSUE No. II: “Whether the dissolution order dated 31st March, 2014 was passed with due adherence to the procedure provided under Section 48 of the CMJ University Act, 2009 and in compliance of the directions issued by this Court vide order dated 13th September, 2013 in SLP(C) No. 19617 of 2013 titled as “CMJ Foundation & Ors. v. State of Meghalaya and Ors.”? ................................................. 35 ISSUE No. III: “Whether the Division Bench of the High Court of Meghalaya was justified in remanding the matter to the learned Single Judge for reconsideration on merit, while allowing the Writ Appeal No. 14 of 2017”? ................ 44 F. CONCLUSION .................................................................... 47
1. Application for impleadment is allowed.
2. These appeals are filed challenging the judgment and order dated 6th May, 2021 passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Meghalaya at Shillong 1 in Writ Appeal No. 14 of 2017, whereby the judgment and order dated 16 th July, 2015 passed by the learned Single Judge of the High Court in Writ Petition(C) No. 177 of 2014 was quashed and set aside and the matter was remanded to the learned Single Judge to take appropriate decision regarding the validity of the order, dissolving the Chander Mohan Jha University, 2 on merit preferably within a period of six months.
3. Vide judgment and order dated 16 th July, 2015, the learned Single Judge of the High Court quashed and set aside the order dated 31 st 1 Hereinafter, being referred to as ‘High Court’.
2 Hereinafter, being referred to as the ‘CMJ University’. 1026 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports March, 2014, passed by the Government of Meghalaya 3 dissolving the University and also quashed the show cause notices dated 12 th November, 2013 and 24 th January, 2014, issued to the University by the State Government.
4. This case has a chequered history. To properly appreciate the controversy involved in this case, it would be essential to set out the detailed facts, giving rise to these appeals.
A. FACTUAL MATRIX
5. A trust namely Chandra Mohan Jha Foundation4 was registered at Shillong, Meghalaya in the year 2004. The Meghalaya Legislative Assembly enacted the Chandra Mohan Jha University Act, 2009 5 on 20 th July, 2009 to establish and incorporate the CMJ University in the State with an emphasis on providing high-quality and industryrelevant education in various subjects. 6
6. The Board of Trustees of the CMJ Foundation appointed Shri Chander Mohan Jha as the Chancellor of the CMJ University on 29th July, 2009, in terms of Section 14(1) of the Act. 7 Thereafter, on 3rd August, 2009, the appellants sent a letter to the Commissioner and Secretary, Education Department, Government of Meghalaya, seeking approval of the Visitor for the appointment of Chancellor. It is pertinent to note that as per Section 13(1) of the Act, the Governor of Meghalaya was holding the ex-officio position of Visitor of the CMJ University.8
7. A reminder was sent to the Visitor vide letter dated 17 th November, 2009 and a second reminder dated 09 th December, 2009 was sent to the Officer on Special Duty, Education Department, Government of Meghalaya, seeking approval of the appointment of the Chancellor. 3 Hereinafter, being referred to as ‘State Government’. 4 Hereinafter, being referred to as ‘CMJ Foundation’.
5 The Chandra Mohan Jha University Act, 2009 (Act No. 4 of 2009). For short ‘the Act’. 6 The subjects inter alia include, Physical Sciences, Life Sciences, Technology, Medical Science and Paramedical, Management, Finance & Accounting, Commerce, Humanities, Language & Communication, Applied and Performing Arts, Education, Law, Social Sciences and related areas and to provide matters connected therewith or incidental thereto.
7 S. 14: The Chancellor: (1) The Sponsor shall appoint a person suitable to be appointed as the Chancellor of the University subject to the approval of the Visitor. 8 The ‘Governor of Meghalaya’, hereinafter referred to as ‘Visitor.’ [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1027CMJ Foundation and Others v. State of Meghalaya and Others
8. Since approval for the appointment of the Chancellor was not forthcoming despite several reminders, a letter dated 1 st April, 2010 was sent by the appellants to the State Government asserting that “In case the approval is not granted by the Visitor by 25 th April, 2010, it would be deemed that the approval of Chancellor has been granted by the Visitor”. However, no response was received to the letter dated 1st April, 2010 from the Visitor, either approving or refusing the appointment of Chancellor.
9. Notwithstanding all this, the State Government accorded sanction for the establishment of the CMJ University in accordance with the guidelines issued by the University Grants Commission 9 vide notification dated 17 th June, 2010. The UGC vide its letter dated 25 th November, 2010, intimated that the CMJ University had been established by an Act of the State Legislature as a ‘State Private University’ and was empowered to award degrees under Section 22 of the University Grants Act, 1956 10 through its main campus, after approval is accorded by Statutory Bodies and Councils, if so required.
10. The Visitor sent letters dated 4 th April, 2013 and 11 th April, 2013, to the appellants, seeking some information and highlighting that the appointment of the Chancellor of the CMJ University was irregular since the same was never approved by the Visitor. In response thereto, the appellants submitted their reply, providing the requested information to the Visitor vide letters dated 9 th April, 2013 and 29 th April, 2013.
11. On perusal of the records/information submitted by the appellants, the Visitor noticed certain serious anomalies and non-conformity with the State Act, Regulations and Rules. Upon noticing these anomalies, the Visitor through the Principal Secretary issued a letter dated 30th April, 2013 under Section 13(3)(b) 11 of the Act and issued the following directions to the CMJ University: - 9 Hereinafter, being referred to as “UGC”.
10 For short, ‘UGC Act’.
11 13. The Visitor: (3)
(a) …….
b) On the basis of the information received by the Visitor, if he is satisfied that any order, proceeding or decision taken by any authority of the University is not in conformity with the Act, Regulations or Rules, he may issue such directions as he may deem fit in the interest of the University which will be binding to all concerned.
1028 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports “1. The CMJ University shall recall/withdraw all the degrees awarded so far and publish this fact in national and local newspapers at their own cost.
2. The CMJ Foundation shall submit a fresh proposal for the appointment of the Chancellor along with the correct Biodata of the candidate recommended and supporting documents.
3. The CMJ University shall frame rules and procedures for admission into the M. Phil and Ph. D degree programmes, allocation of supervisors, course work, evaluation, assessment and other related matters. in accordance with the UGC (Minimum Standards and Procedure for Awards of M.Phil/Ph. D degree) Regulation, 2009.
4. No fresh admission of students shall be undertaken by the CMJ University till compliance of the above instructions and till the appointment of the Chancellor in accordance with Section 14(1) of the CMJ University Act 2009. ”
12. The CMJ University was mandated to comply with the aforesaid directions and submit a compliance report to the Visitor by 21 st May, 2013. Being aggrieved by the letter dated 30th April, 2013, the appellants filed Writ Petition(C) No. 106 of 2013 before the learned Single Judge of the High Court.
13. Learned Single Judge disposed of the Writ Petition(C) No. 106 of 2013 vide order dated 16 th May, 2013, holding the letter dated 30 th April, 2013 to be legally sound and directing that until the controversy is resolved, new students shall not be granted admission in the CMJ University. The learned Single Judge observed that in admitting students for the year commencing from 2010-2011 and onwards, the CMJ University had acted on its own volition without getting approval for the appointment of the ‘Chancellor’. The relevant observations from the order dated 16th May, 2013 are reproduced hereinbelow: - “Section 14(1) of the CMJ University Act, 2009 makes it obligatory on the part of the University to appoint Chancellor subject to approval of the Visitor for a period of five years, which may be extended with prior approval of the Visitor. The Chancellor will be the head of the University. By the letter dated 01.04.2010 under Annexure [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1029CMJ Foundation and Others v. State of Meghalaya and Others 9, issued by the Secretary, CMJ Foundation addressed to the Under Secretary to the Govt. of Meghalaya, Education Department, Shillong seeking for approval of the appointment of the Chancellor which may be communicated to them on or before 25th February, 2010 otherwise it may be assumed that the governor has accorded his approval for functioning of the University and also the appointment of the first Chancellor of the university. The provisions of the CMJ University Act, 2009, does not support the contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner that there would be a “deemed approval” for appointment of the Chancellor if the Governor fails to communicate before 25th February 2010. The said provision also does not support such action of the University in complying (sic) with the principle “deemed approval” for the functioning of the University and also the appointment of the first Chancellor of the CMJ University. The correspondence would go to show that there is no approval accorded for the appointment of the Chancellor by the authority concerned. Moreover, there are no materials placed before this Court by the petitioner according to the approval of the appointment of the “Chancellor” by the “Governor” under the Statute. In absence of which, it may be assumed that there was no approval of the appointment of the “Chancellor” by the “Governor”.”
(emphasis supplied)
14. Aggrieved by the order dated 16th May, 2013 passed by the learned Single Judge, the appellants preferred a Writ Appeal (SH) No. 16 of 2013 before the Division Bench, which was dismissed vide order dated 31st May, 2013, while making pertinent observations reproduced below: - “7. On plain perusal of Section 13(2) of the CMJ Act of 2009, It is clear that the Governor of Meghalaya (Visitor) shall have the power to call any paper or information relating to the affairs of the University and also on the basis of information received by the Visitor, he may issue such directions as he may deem fit in the interest of the 1030 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports University which will be binding to all concerned. Therefore, it is very clear that the Visitor of the CMJ University (Governor of Meghalaya) can call informations from the University and after receiving the information, he can issue directions as he may deem fit.
8. Section 14(1) of the CMJ Act of 2009, clearly provided that the sponsor shall appoint a person suitable to be appointed as the Chancellor of the University subject to the approval of the Visitor, It is the submission of the learned counsel for the appellants/writ petitioners that prior approval of the Visitor is not required for appointing the appellant/writ petitioner No. 3 as the Chancellor of the CMJ University. However, it is also clear under Section 14(1) of the CMJ Act of 2009 that the approval of the Visitor will be required for the appointment of Chancellor.
9. In the present case, it is an admitted fact that as of today, there is no approval of the Visitor to the appointment of appellant/writ petitioner No. 3 as Chancellor of CMJ University. As stated above it is the case of the appellants/ writ petitioners in the writ petition that as there was a considerable delay on the part of the Visitor in conveying the approval of the appointment of appellant/writ petitioners No. 3 as Chancellor of CMJ University, there should be a deemed approval for considering the submission of Mr. Amit Kumar Learned counsel appearing for the appellants/ writ petitioners, We have given our anxious considerable to the provisions of CMJ Act of 2009, however, we find that there is no provision under which if there is a considerable delay in conveying the approval of the Visitor to the appointment of Chancellor by the Visitor, there should be a deemed approval.”
(emphasis supplied)
15. In the meantime, on 3 rd June, 2013, the State Government issued a letter to the appellants, seeking compliance with the directions issued by the Visitor vide letter dated 30 th April, 2013, by 10 th June, 2013.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1031CMJ Foundation and Others v. State of Meghalaya and Others
16. The appellants assailed the order dismissing the writ appeal by filing a Special Leave Petition 12 before this Court. During the pendency of the said special leave petition, the Visitor (Governor of Meghalaya) issued comprehensive recommendations to the State Government vide letter dated 12 th June, 2013, to consider dissolution of the CMJ University on the grounds of mismanagement, maladministration, indiscipline and failure in enforcement of the objectives of the University, apart from criminal liability. The Visitor indicated in the aforesaid letter that the CMJ University had committed the following irregularities of grave nature: - “(i) The University functioned from 17/10/2010 with the self-appointed Chancellor without the approval of the Visitor in terms of Section 14 (1) of the CMJ University Act, 2009 on the presumption of “deemed approval” of the Visitor. This is not legally valid, and the position has been affirmed by the order dated 16th May, 2013 of the Hon’ble High Court of Meghalaya which has further been upheld by the Division Bench of the Hon’ble High Court of Meghalaya in their order dated 31st May, 2013.
(ii) It awarded B. Ed degree through Distance Mode without the requisite approval of the regulatory bodies and without affiliation. The B. Ed degrees awarded by the CMJ University were held to be invalid in the eye of Law by the order dated 24th May, 2013 of the Hon’ble High Court of Gauhati.
(iii) The Shillong Engineering and Management College was de-affiliated by NEHU from academic session 2011- 2012. This College, which was in existence prior to the sanction for establishment of the CMJ University, cannot be affiliated with the CMJ University. While the fate of the students of this College was already uncertain in view of the said de-affiliation, the College continued to make admissions by misleading the students that the degrees will be issued by the CMJ University.
(iv) The University had reported that during 2012-2013 it had awarded PhD degrees to 434 students and enrolled another 12 SLP (C) No. 19617 of 2013.
1032 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 490 students. These figures, though extraordinarily high, do not reflect the correct position. Information is available with us that another 29 students have also received PhD degrees from the University and more information is coming on a daily basis. So it is obvious that the actual number of award of and enrolment for, PhD and other programs will be much higher than was reported. The University awarded PhD even in subjects like the, Bodo and Punjabi languages where the guides/faculty are not easily available. These constitute gross abuse of the university’s power and violation of the UGC (Minimum Standards and Procedure for Awards of M. Phil/ Ph. D Degree) Regulation, 2009.
(v) The University furnished a list of 10 faculty members with PhD which is inaccurate. One of the faculty members is only a research scholar at NEHU. The list includes the Vice-Chancellor, Registrar and other functionaries of the University as faculty which is quite misleading. In fact, the University does not have adequate teachers to introduce courses which it had been doing.
(vi) The University is running several off-campus centres outside Meghalaya which is not permissible under the UGC (Establishment of and Maintenance of Standards of Private University) Regulations, 2003 and the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court (2005) in the case of Prof. Yashpal & Anr. Versus State of Chhattisgarh & Ors.
(vii) It is offering a distance education programme outside the boundaries of Meghalaya and outside India. These actions are in gross violation of UGC Regulations and guidelines.
(viii) Total students enrolled by CMJ University as per information submitted by the University in 2010-11:176, 2011-12:469, 2012-13: 2734. All these admissions are illegal as all its actions are ab initio(sic) void in absence of a legally appointed Chancellor.
(ix) The University has violated Section 45(3) and Section 46(4) of the CMJ University Act, 2009 by not submitting the Annual Report and the Annual Accounts/Balance Sheet and the Audit Report to Visitor.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1033CMJ Foundation and Others v. State of Meghalaya and Others
(x) Even after the initiation of actions by the Visitor the University continued to mislead the students and the public by press statements. It issued a newspaper advertisement in the Shillong Times on 22nd April, 2013 claiming it has not yet awarded any PhD degree to any of the students enrolled from the State of Assam which is false. Again, it issued advertisements in newspapers on 2nd May and 16th May, 2013 in matters of holding Convocation and Award of PhD Degree knowing full well that there can be no Convocation without the legally appointed Chancellor and that the admissions of the courses and award of the degrees were illegal.
(xi) The University has violated Section 41(1) of the CMJ University Act relating to establishment of Endowment Fund and indulged in cheating by withdrawing the deposit of Rs.210 lakhs within days of making the deposit.
(xii) The University repeatedly acted in contravention of Section 52 of the CMJ University Act 2009 in respect of maintenance. of standards and other related matters applicable to private universities.”
17. This Court took cognizance of these comprehensive recommendations issued by the Visitor and disposed of the Special Leave Petition 13 vide order dated 13 th September, 2013, thereby, directing the State Government to take appropriate action and pass a speaking order under Section 48 of the Act, after giving due notice and opportunity of hearing to the appellants, within a period of three months from the date of the order.
18. In compliance with the order dated 13th September, 2013 passed by this Court, the State Government issued a show cause notice dated 12 th November, 2013 and another supplementary show cause notice dated 24th January, 2014 to the appellants, who submitted their detailed replies to the aforesaid show cause notices on 25th November, 2013 and 4th February, 2014 respectively.
19. The State Government found the replies submitted by the appellants to be untenable with the conclusion that the allegations levelled in 13 Ibid.
1034 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the show cause notices were not satisfactorily explained by the appellants and that there existed insurmountable evidence as to mismanagement, maladministration, indiscipline, fraudulent intent and failure in the accomplishment of the objectives of the University which was too overwhelming. Consequently, by exercising powers under Section 48(2) of the Act, the State Government issued an order on 31st March 2014, dissolving the CMJ University with immediate effect.
20. Being aggrieved with the dissolution of the CMJ University, the appellants herein filed a Writ Petition(C) No. 177 of 2014 before the High Court, which was allowed by the learned Single Judge vide order dated 16th July, 2015, and the order of dissolution dated 31st March, 2014 along with the show cause notices dated 12 th November, 2013 and 24 th January, 2014 were quashed and set aside. The learned Single Judge observed that the State failed to comply with the fundamental procedural requirements as provided under Section 48 of the Act, i.e., the principles of natural justice and the obligation of the administrative authorities to act fairly.
21. The learned Single Judge, further, directed the State Government to take steps strictly compliant with the provisions of the CMJ University Act, 2009, the Meghalaya Private Universities (Regulation of Establishment and Maintenance of Standards) Act, 2012, principles of natural justice and the obligation of the administrative authorities to act fairly in the interest of justice in compliance of the judgment and order dated 13 th September, 2013, vide which this Court directed the State authorities to pass a speaking order under Section 48 of the Act.
22. Aggrieved, the State Government filed intra-court Writ Appeal No. 14 of 2017 before the Division Bench of the High Court assailing the order dated 16 th July, 2015. The Division Bench vide an interim order dated 12 th June, 2017, stayed the operation of the order dated 16th July, 2015 passed by the Single Bench and directed that the admission and award of degrees by the CMJ University shall remain subject to the final judgment to be passed in appeal.
23. Being aggrieved of this interim order dated 12 th June, 2017, the CMJ University approached this Court by filing Special Leave Petition, 14 14 SLP (C) No. 21890 of 2017.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1035CMJ Foundation and Others v. State of Meghalaya and Others wherein this Court vide order dated 4 th September, 2017 granted interim stay on the effect and operation of the interim order passed by the Division Bench of the High Court. This Court vide another order dated 13 th August, 2018 passed in the aforesaid special leave petition, extended the stay, and the writ appeal pending before the High Court of Meghalaya was transferred to the Gauhati High Court with the consent of both the parties for the reason that Meghalaya High Court had only two Judges at that time, one of whom had recused from hearing the case.
24. Pursuant to this Court’s order dated 13th August, 2018, the Writ Appeal No. 14 of 2017 (in the High Court of Meghalaya) was renumbered as Writ Appeal No. 266 of 2018 (in the High Court of Gauhati) and was taken up for consideration by the Division Bench of the Gauhati High Court, which disposed of the same vide order dated 5 th November, 2019, quashing the order dated 16 th July, 2015 passed in Writ Petition(C) No. 177 of 2014 on the ground that the learned Single Judge of the High Court of Meghalaya had not recorded the contentions of the appellants herein. The Division Bench of the Gauhati High Court remanded the matter to the learned Single Judge of the High Court of Meghalaya for fresh adjudication on merits, observing that the interim order passed by this Court would continue.
25. Aggrieved by the remand order, the appellants filed Civil Appeal No. 3310 of 2020 15 before this Court. This Court vide order dated 28 th September, 2020, allowed the appeal and set aside the remand order, while transferring the writ appeal from the Division Bench of the Gauhati High Court back to the Division Bench of the High Court of Meghalaya for fresh consideration and disposal on merits.
26. Writ Appeal No. 14 of 2017 was allowed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Meghalaya vide judgment and order dated 6 th May, 2021 and the matter was remanded back to the learned Single Judge to take appropriate decision regarding the validity of the order dissolving the CMJ University on merits preferably within a period of six months. The said judgment dated 6th May, 2021 is assailed in the present appeal i.e., Civil Appeal No. 9694 of 2024, filed by the appellants.
15 Arising out of SLP(C) No. 10941 of 2020.
1036 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
27. Subsequently, the State Government also filed an appeal i.e., Civil Appeal No. 9695 of 2024, challenging the Division Bench judgment dated 6 th May, 2021, only to the limited extent of the matter being remanded to the learned Single Judge for fresh adjudication.
28. Vide order dated 1 st June, 2021, this Court directed the parties to maintain status quo, as it existed on that date. Leave was granted on 20th August, 2024.
B. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANTS
29. Learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the appellants advanced the following pertinent submissions for assailing the impugned order: -
(a) That the University came into existence pursuant to the enactment of the CMJ University Act, 2009 by the Meghalaya Legislative Assembly, with an emphasis on providing high-quality and industry-relevant education in various fields. A huge amount of money has been invested in creating infrastructure spanning more than 1.5 lakh square feet built-up area, state-of-the-art laboratory, a library and modern classrooms at the main campus of the University for imparting quality education to the students.
(b) That the CMJ University was granted UGC recognition vide letter dated 25th November, 2010 as a State Private University and was empowered to award degrees as specified by the UGC under Section 22 of the UGC Act, through its main campus.
(c) That under Section 14(1) of the Act, the Sponsor is entitled to appoint a suitable person as the Chancellor of the University subject to the approval of the Visitor. Therefore, on a bare reading of this sub-section, it is clear that prior approval is not required for the appointment of a Chancellor. He further urged that an appointment subject to approval is valid so long it is not disapproved. In this regard, he placed reliance upon the decisions of this Court in (i) U.P. Avas Evam Vikas Parishad & Anr v. Friends Coop. Housing Society Ltd. & Anr16; (ii) High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan v. P.P. Singh & Anr 17 , 16 1995 Supp (3) SCC 456.
17 (2003) 4 SCC 239.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1037CMJ Foundation and Others v. State of Meghalaya and Others and (iii) Ashok Kumar Das & Ors v. University of Burdwan & Ors18.
(d) The trustees of CMJ Foundation as early as on 29 th July, 2009 had adopted a valid resolution appointing Shri Chander Mohan Jha as the Chancellor of the CMJ University in terms of Section 14(1) of the Act. Various representations dated 29 th July, 2009, 3 rd August, 2009 and 6 th October, 2009 were addressed to the Visitor, seeking approval of the appointment of the Chancellor of the CMJ University. Thereafter, two reminders dated 17 th November, 2009 and 9 th December, 2009 were also sent to the Visitor seeking approval. However, none of these communications received any response whatsoever from the Visitor.
(e) That the appellants sent a letter dated 1st April, 2010, to the State Government which clearly specified that ‘if the Visitor (Governor of Meghalaya) failed to accord his approval, it would be assumed as a ‘deemed approval’ for the functioning of the University and the appointment of the Chancellor of the University.’ He submitted that in view of this letter and other correspondences shared with the State Government, the CMJ University rightfully assumed ‘deemed approval’ to the appointment of the Chancellor. Consequently, admissions were given to the students, and the courses concerned commenced. Students who had completed their respective courses commencing from the academic year 2010-2011 and other students who continued to study in the CMJ University were granted degrees in accordance with the mandate of the Act and the UGC recommendations.
(f) That Section 26 of the Act clearly stipulates that no act or proceeding of any authority of the University shall be deemed invalid merely on the reason of the existence of any vacancy of post or defect in the constitution of the authority.
(g) That the respondents did not comply with the directions given by this Court vide order dated 13th September, 2013 passed in Special Leave Petition, 19 whereby, the State Government was
18 (2010) 3 SCC 616.
19 SLP(C) No. 19617 of 2013.
1038 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports required to proceed strictly in accordance with the Act, after complying with the mandate of Section 48 of the Act and not mere paper compliance. To buttress this submission, learned senior counsel drew our attention to the following observations made by this Court in the order dated 13th September, 2013:- “In view of the above, we feel that ends of justice will be served by directing the State Government to take appropriate action under Section 48 of the 2009 Act after giving notice and reasonable opportunity of hearing to the petitioners.
The special leave petitions are accordingly disposed of with direction that within three months from today the State Government shall, after giving an opportunity to the petitioners to show cause against the action proposed to be taken, pass a speaking order under Section 48 of the 2009 Act.”
(h) As per learned senior counsel, the State Government failed to comply with the mandatory requirements as provided under Sub-sections (2) and (3) of Section 48 of the Act, which deal with the procedure of dissolution of the University. He urged that as per Section 48(2) of the Act, it was mandatory that the State Government on identification of mismanagement, maladministration, indiscipline, failure in accomplishment of the objectives of the CMJ University and economic hardships in the management systems of the CMJ University, should have issued directions to the management system of the University for rectification thereof. Only in the event that the directions were not complied with within such time as may be prescribed, could the power to wind up the University have been exercised by the State Government.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.