Puja Ferro Alloys P Ltd. v. State of Goa and Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 217; [2025] 3 S.C.R. 138
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Dipankar Datta, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 13 Feb 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2027/2012
- Sections
- 3, 23, 51, 21, 11, 78
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 138 : 2025 INSC 217 Puja Ferro Alloys P Ltd.
v.
State of Goa and Ors.
(Civil Appeal Nos. 2027-2028 of 2012)
14 February 2025 [Dipankar Datta* and Sandeep Mehta, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the appellant-companies are covered by the notification issued by the State dated 30.09.1991 for the purpose of availing 25% rebate on the tariff chargeable for availing power supply. Headnotes† Electricity Act, 1910 – ss.23, 51-A – Goa (Prohibition of Further Payments and Recovery of Rebate Benefits) Act, 2002 – s.3 – Electricity tariff – Relief of rebate of 25% on electricity tariff in terms of notification dated 30.09.1991 to the appelant companies – By notification dated 30.09.1991 the industrial units which applied for availing power supply for bona fide industrial activities entitled to rebate of 25% on the tariff chargeable to electricity bills for five years from the date electricity supply made available – Supply of electricity to appellant-companies – 25% rebate given only from 01.01.1997 – By Notification dated 31.03.1995, previous notification dated 30.09.1991 was rescinded – Notifications of 1996 amended notification dated 30.09.1991 to include another consumer category and to extend the benefit of rebate to all the industrial units who apply or avail extra high-tension power supply – Thereafter, by Circular dated 31.03.1998, the State suspended the rebate entitlement, however, the said circular did not mention whether the suspension of the rebate given under the notification dated 30.09.1991 or the amending notifications of 15.05.1996 and 01.08.1996 and on 24.07.1998, the notification dated 01.08.1996 was rescinded – Writ petitions – High Court in GR Ispat’s case held that rescission of the notification dated 30.09.1991 would only mean that the benefit was given up from * Author [2025] 3 S.C.R. 139Puja Ferro Alloys P Ltd. v. State of Goa and Ors. 01.04.1995 and the new industrial units could not apply after 01.04.1995 to obtain the benefit of rebate; that the amendment of the notification after its rescission indicates that the notification dated 30.09.1991 was in existence and operation for those industrial units who had already become entitled to get the benefit of rebate under it, thus, the suspension of the release of rebate was invalid and inoperative; notification dated 24.07.1998 is legal, valid and operative and that the petitioning companies were entitled to 25% rebate in power tariff till 24.07.1998 – GR Ispat’s case upheld by this Court – Thereafter, 2002 Act was passed which specified that those who had already availed benefits of notifications dated 1996 would be liable to refund the amount – Respondents sought recovery from the appellants under the 2002 Act – Challenge to – Division Bench dismissed the petitions upholding the demand notices – Review applications also dismissed – Correctness:
Held: High Court rightly held that the appellant-companies are not entitled to the rebate and the impugned demand notices does not suffer from any vice including that of illegality – High Court in GR Ispat’s case held that the challenge against the rescission on the grounds of promissory estoppel against the State is unsustainable as it must yield to the principle of public equity – Thus, the Government has a justifiable ground of supervening public interest to withdraw the grant of rebate in power tariff which was promised in the notifications dated 30.09.1991 and 01.08.1996 – Judgment of GR Ispat attained finality – Supply of electricity was effected to all the appellant-companies, except one, on varying dates beyond 31.03.1995; however, the notification dated 30.09.1991 had life till 31.03.1995 whereafter it stood rescinded – Declaration in Manohar Parrikar’s case that the Notifications dated 15.05.1996 and 01.08.1996 were non-est and void ab initio – Appellant-companies were seeking benefit of these subsequent notifications before the High Court in GR Ispat’s case which was not accepted by the High Court – Considering the ruling by the High Court that they are covered under the notification dated 30.09.1991, they now seek to protect their benefits under the guise of this notification which, in any event, stood rescinded with effect from 01.04.1995 whereas the supply was effected therafter – Division Bench rightly held that 140 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports the challenge is without any legal basis as the question is squarely covered by the decision in GR Ispat’s case – Principle of res judicata applies even to petitions arising for decision in the writ jurisdiction u/Art.226 – Writ petitions before the High Court hit by res judicata in view of its previous decision in GR Ispat’s case which, when challenged before this Court, was upheld – Appellant-companies bound by the decision in GR Ispat’s case – Having failed up to this Court, the appellant-companies could not have adopted a stand different from the one taken in the first round of litigation – Public interest change the things against the appellant-companies – High Court accepted that the policy of rebate was unviable resulting from financial crunch and was overriding public interest, and would apply as res judicata against the appellant-companies – Also no appeal lies against order of rejection of petition for review – Constitution of India – Art.226. [Paras 19-21, 24, 25, 27-30] Case Law Cited GR Ispat Ltd. v. Chief Electrical Engineer, 1999 (1) Goa L.T. 218; Manohar Parrikar v. State of Goa, 2001 SCC OnLine Bom 350; MRF Limited v. Manohar Parrikar & Ors. [2010] 5 SCR 1081 : (2010) 11 SCC 374; Goa Glass Fibre Limited v. State of Goa & Anr. [2010] 5 SCR 970 : (2010) 6 SCC 499; Pawan Alloys & Casting (P) Ltd. v. UP SEB [1997] Supp. 3 SCR 266 : (1997) 7 SCC 251; Inderchand Jain v. Motilal [2009] 11 SCR 252 : (2009) 14 SCC 663; Satyadhyan Ghosal v. Deorajin Debi [1960] 3 SCR 590 : [1960] 3 SCR 590; Hope Plantations Ltd. v. Taluk Land Board [1998] Supp. 2 SCR 514 : (1999) 5 SCC 590; T.P. Moideen Koya v. State of Kerala [2004] Supp. 4 SCR 904 : (2004) 8 SCC 106 – referred to.
List of Acts Electricity Act, 1910; General Clauses Act, 1897; Goa (Prohibition of Further Payments and Recovery of Rebate Benefits) Act, 2002. List of Keywords Rebate on the tariff chargeable for availing power supply; Electricity tariff; Suspension of rebate; Rescission; Industrial units; GR Ispat’s case; Promissory estoppel against the State; Principle of public equity; Manohar Parrikar’s case; Principle of res judicata; First [2025] 3 S.C.R. 141Puja Ferro Alloys P Ltd. v. State of Goa and Ors. round of litigation; Public interest; Policy of rebate; Financial crunch; Overriding public interest; Res judicata; Petition for review; Tariff applicable to electricity bills; Rebate; High-tension or low-tension power; Extra High-tension power; Rescission of notification by State; Power tariff; Rules of business; Non-est; Void ab initio; Judgment in personam; Principle of estoppel; Res judicata on writ jurisdiction; Appeal on review petition.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal Nos. 2027-2028 of 2012 From the Judgment and Order dated 08.07.2011 and 21.10.2011 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay at Goa in Writ Petition No. 160 of 2011 and CRA No. 26 of 2011 in W.P. No. 160 of 2011 respectively Appearances for Parties Santosh Paul, Sr. Adv., A. Raghunath, Sriharsh Nahush Bundela, Amaan Khan, Advs. for the Appellant.
Ms. A. Subhashini, Abhay Anil Anturkar, Dhruv Tank, Aniruddha Awalgaonkar, Sarthak Mehrotra, Ms. Surbhi Kapoor, T. Mahipal, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Dipankar Datta J.
The A ppeAl
1. In all but one of the civil appeals under consideration, the appellantcompanies call in question the common impugned judgment and order dated 08.07.2011 of the High Court1 in a batch of writ petitions2 and a common order dated 21.10.2011 on a batch of civil review applications. By the impugned judgment and order, the High Court 1 High Court of Bombay, at Goa 2 W.P. Nos. 157-160/2011 142 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports declined to grant the relief of rebate of 25% on the electricity tariff in terms of the notification dated 30.09.1991 to the appellants. The subsequent order dismissed the review applications.
2. Civil Appeal No. 4556/2012 [M/s Karthik Alloys Ltd. v. The State of Goa and Another] is a connected appeal, which challenges the judgment and order dated 08.07.2011 of the High Court dismissing the writ petition 3 filed by M/s Karthik Alloys Ltd. on similar grounds. R esume of fAcTs
3. This is the third round of litigation before this Court regarding the issue of grant of relief of rebate, but not between the same parties.
4. Civil Appeal No. 2027-28 of 2012 [Puja Ferro Alloys P Ltd. v. The State of Goa and Another] is the lead appeal. Considering the commonality of the issues of facts and law in all the connected appeals, we proceed to note the facts of the lead appeal to the extent the same are relevant for a decision on these appeals.
i. Vide Notification dated 27.06.1988, the first respondent-State of Goa 4 determined tariff applicable to electricity bills issued from 01.07.1988.
ii. Vide Notification dated 30.09.1991 issued under Section 23 read with Section 51-A of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910, 5 the SoG determined tariff whereby industrial units which applied for availing High-Tension or Low-Tension power supply for bona fide industrial activities were held entitled to a rebate of 25% on the tariff chargeable under the notification dated 27.06.1988 for a period of five years from the date on which the electricity supply was made available.
iii. The appellant-companies then applied for power from the SoG and entered into respective power supply agreements. The details are tabulated hereunder 6 :
3 WP No. 179/2011 4 SoG 5 1910 Act 6 Data taken from GR Ispat Ltd. v. Chief Electrical Engineer, 1999 (1) Goa L.T. 218 [2025] 3 S.C.R. 143Puja Ferro Alloys P Ltd. v. State of Goa and Ors. Appellant- Company Application for Power Power Supply Agreement Date of Power Connection Puja Ferro Alloys Pvt. Ltd.
15.09.1992 05.08.1993 16.05.1995 Karthik Alloys Ltd.
26.11.1992 - 17.11.1993 Karthik Inductions Ltd.
- - 28.07.1995 Global Ispat Pvt. Ltd.
21.02.1994 10.02.1995 29.04.1995 Sunrise Electromelt Ltd.
01.02.1994 08.02.1995 10.02.1995 iv. Vide Notification dated 31.03.1995, issued under Section 23 read with Section 51-A of the 1910 Act as well as Section 21 of the General Clauses Act, 1897, the previous notification dated 30.09.1991 was rescinded w.e.f. 01.04.1995. In terms thereof, the scheme of rebate was stopped and any new industrial unit applying for power after 31.03.1995 would not get the benefit of the notification dated 30.09.1991.
v. On 15.05.1996, the notification dated 30.09.1991 was amended to include another consumer category of “Extra High-Tension”. vi. The notification dated 30.09.1991 was once again amended on 01.08.1996 so as to extend the benefit of rebate to all the industrial units who apply or avail extra high-tension power supply. The rebate of 25% was given on the prevailing tariff in force.
vii. Power began to be supplied to the appellant-companies as mentioned in the table above. However, the 25% rebate was given only from 01.01.1997. The accumulated arrears of rebate were sought to be disbursed in 60 equated monthly instalments. viii. Vide Circular dated 31.03.1998, the SoG suspended the rebate entitlement. However, the said circular does not mention whether the suspension of the rebate was of the rebate given under the notification dated 30.09.1991 or the amending notifications of 15.05.1996 and 01.08.1996.
144 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports ix. On 24.07.1998, the amending notification dated 01.08.1996 was rescinded.
x. A batch of writ petitions challenging the circular dated 31.03.1998 and the notification dated 24.07.1998 came to be presented before the High Court.
xi. The High Court vide judgment and order dated 21.01.1999 in W.P. No. 239 of 1998 [GR Ispat Ltd. v. Chief Electrical Engineer7 ] held that rescission of the notification dated 30.09.1991 by the notification dated 31.03.1995 would only mean that the scheme providing rebate was given up from 01.04.1995 and that the new industrial units could not apply after 01.04.1995 to obtain the benefit of rebate. The High Court also held that the amendment of the notification after its rescission clearly indicates that the notification dated 30.09.1991 was in existence and operation for those industrial units who had already become entitled to get the benefit of rebate under it. Therefore, the suspension of the release of rebate was invalid and inoperative. The High Court concluded that the notification dated 24.07.1998 is legal, valid and operative and that the petitioning companies therein were entitled to 25% rebate in power tariff till 24.07.1998. xii. When the decision was challenged in this Court in CA No. 3206-3217/1999, interference was declined vide order dated 13.02.2001 as the High Court had taken a balanced view in the matter.
xiii. A writ petition also came to be filed in the High Court challenging the notifications dated 15.05.1996 and 01.08.1996 wherein prayer was made to declare the same as null and void. The High Court allowed the said writ petition [Manohar Parrikar v. State of Goa8 ] owing to brazen non-compliance with the Rules of Business framed under Article 166(3) of the Constitution. The impugned notifications were held to be non-est and void ab initio and the consequential acts based on such notifications were also to be considered null and void.
7 1999 (1) Goa L.T. 218 8 2001 SCC OnLine Bom 350 [2025] 3 S.C.R. 145Puja Ferro Alloys P Ltd. v. State of Goa and Ors. xiv. Meanwhile in 2002, the SoG enacted the Goa (Prohibition of Further Payments and Recovery of Rebate Benefits) Act, 2002. 9 Section 3 of 2002 Act specified that any person or industrial consumer in the SoG who has already availed of the benefits of 25% rebate in pursuance of the Government notifications dated 15.05.1996 and 01.08.1996 would be liable to refund the amount to the third respondent herein – the Chief Electrical Engineer, Electricity Department, Government of Goa.
xv. A batch of civil appeals challenging the judgment and order in Manohar Parrikar (supra) was dismissed by this Court in MRF Limited v. Manohar Parrikar & Ors.10 xvi. Moreover, this Court in Goa Glass Fibre Limited v. State of Goa & Anr.11 categorically held that the object of the 2002 Act is not to undo or reverse the judgments of the Supreme Court or the High Court but it merely seeks to recover and extinguish all liabilities of the SoG that accrue or arise from the notifications dated 15.05.1996 and 01.08.1996.
xvii. Vide demand notice dated 21.02.2011, the respondents sought recovery from Puja Ferro [the lead appellant-company], under Section 3 of the 2002 Act, an amount of Rs. 1,36,30,072/-. Aggrieved by the impugned demand notice, the appellantcompany preferred a writ petition12 before the High Court. Similar demand notices were served on the other appellant-companies leading them too to file their respective writ petitions before the High Court.
xviii. By the common impugned judgment and order, referred to at the beginning of this judgment, the Division Bench of the High Court dismissed the batch of writ petitions filed by the appellant-companies and thereby, upheld the demand notices. Review applications filed against the impugned judgment and order were also dismissed by the High Court holding that no error apparent on the face of the record was shown to exist. 9 2002 Act
10 (2010) 11 SCC 374
11 (2010) 6 SCC 499
12 W.P. No.160/2011 146 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Impugned J udgmenTs
5. Before the High Court, the appellant-companies assailed the demand notices on the ground that the rebate was offered for the purpose of increasing investment and industries in the SoG. Based on the promise that incentives in the form of rebate would be given, the appellant-companies set up industries in the SoG, obtaining loans from banks and financial institutions as well as on plots of land on lease from the Industrial Development Corporation. They urged that the SoG was bound to provide the rebate as per the notifications providing such rebate and the subsequent power supply agreement entered into by and between the appellant-companies and the authorities. Moreover, the High Court had previously decided that the amendment of the rescinded notification would imply that the rebate entitlement was still available to existing consumers and that only new consumers were not eligible for the 25% rebate. This was carried up to this Court which upheld the said order of the Division Bench of the High Court. They further contended that the decision of the High Court in Manohar Parrikar (supra) does not affect the claim of the appellant-companies as it was a judgment in personam. It was also urged that the SoG under the guise of recovery of rebate was actually recovering the rebate benefit granted under the notification dated 30.09.1991.
6. The respondents defended the impugned demand notices before the High Court on the ground that the appellant-companies had claimed that they availed the benefits of 25% rebate on the power tariff pursuant to the notification dated 30.09.1991; however, their case cannot be accepted because the notification dated 30.09.1991 was rescinded with effect from 01.04.1995 vide notification date 31.03.1995. It was further urged that the previous order of the High Court in Manohar Parrikar (supra), which was subsequently challenged before this Court, binds the appellant-companies as it has clearly held that the rebate benefit will not be available to the appellant-companies after the unexpired period of five years.
7. The High Court concluded that the appellant-companies are not those who are claiming benefit of rebate under the notification dated 30.09.1991, as this notification was rescinded by the notification dated 31.03.1995. The High Court, based on the reply affidavit filed by the respondents, proceeded on the basis that the appellant- [2025] 3 S.C.R. 147Puja Ferro Alloys P Ltd. v. State of Goa and Ors. companies have availed the power supply only after 31.03.1995. The High Court held that the previous decisions have clarified that the 2002 Act is valid and constitutional and that the demand notices had been issued under Section 3 of the 2002 Act. Moreover, it was held that the appellant-companies cannot rest their claims on the basis of the notifications dated 15.05.1996 and 01.08.1996 as these decisions were held not to be Government decisions, and the notification dated 30.09.1991 was rescinded on 31.03.1995 with effect from 01.04.1995.
8. The High Court observed that the appellant-companies have been supplied power only from 10.05.1995, 29.04.1995, 28.07.1995 and 16.05.1995 and, therefore, none of the appellants before the High Court could lay a valid claim to be covered by the notification dated 30.09.1991. Consequently, all the writ petitions came to be dismissed.
9. Aggrieved by the said judgment and order of the High Court, various civil review applications were filed seeking a review thereof. The Division Bench dismissed the same holding that there was no error apparent on the face of the record that would necessitate any review of the judgment and order under review.
conTenTIons
10. Mr. Santosh Paul, learned senior advocate for the appellantcompanies, orally as well as through the written notes of arguments assailed the impugned judgment and order by contending that: i. The appellant-companies are covered by the notification dated 30.09.1991 and not by the notification dated 01.08.1996. ii. The High Court has not appreciated that the rights of the appellant-companies crystallized upon making the application for power while the notification dated 30.09.1991 was in force and hence, irrespective of when the power was actually supplied, the appellant-companies are entitled to the benefit of rebate. iii. Referring to the decision in Pawan Alloys & Casting (P) Ltd. v. UP SEB,13 it was urged that the new industries were attracted to the region relying upon the promise of the SoG to grant rebate
13 (1997) 7 SCC 251
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.