Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation v. Mahadeo Krishna Naik
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 218; [2025] 3 S.C.R. 100
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Dipankar Datta, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 13 Feb 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 13834/2024
- Sections
- 166, 140, 114, 11, 106, 17
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 100 : 2025 INSC 218 Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation v.
Mahadeo Krishna Naik (Civil Appeal No. 13834 of 2024)
14 February 2025 [Dipankar Datta* and Sandeep Mehta, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the appellant-Corporation is guilty of suggestio falsi by not disclosing what it had pleaded before the MACT and suppresio veri by suppressing the award; whether the High Court was justified in exercising review jurisdiction; and whether the respondent is entitled to back wages for the period for which he remained out of service. Headnotes† Service law – Removal from service – Suggestio falsi and suppresio veri – Relevance of proceedings of the MACT in proceedings before the labour court – Respondent working as bus driver with the appellant-Corporation – Lorry coming from the opposite direction collided with a bus of the Corporation, driven by respondent, resulting in a fatal accident – Disciplinary action against respondent and was dismissed from service – Dismissal upheld by the Labour court – Writ petition by the respondent – Dismissed by the High Court – During pendency, proceedings for compensation initiated by victims of the accident before the MACT wherein Corporation took a contrary stand that the lorry driver was responsible for the accident and the tribunal awarded compensation – On basis thereof, the respondent applied for review before the High Court – Review proceeding allowed and directed payment of back wages to the respondent – Correctness:
Held: Corporation indulged in the misadventure of suggestio falsi and suppressio veri – Before the Labour Court, the Corporation established that inquiry conducted against the respondent, was fair, and the conclusion was arrived at upon due consideration of the materials on record – Having regard to the clear and specific stand * Author [2025] 3 S.C.R. 101Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation v. Mahadeo Krishna Naik taken before the MACT in its written statement, the Corporation did make a false representation before the Labour Court amounting to suggestio falsi – Having not disclosed before the Labour Court the outcome of the proceedings before the MACT, the Corporation also guilty of suppresio veri – Relevance of the MACT judgment and its probative value cannot be gainsaid – In industrial adjudication, principles of natural justice have to be complied with – Corporation has been far from fair in its dealings with the respondent – Corporation did not deliberately refer to the award of the MACT at two different tiers, and thereby actively suppressed relevant material from court of law – Contradictory nature of the stances taken by Corporation, reeks of the Corporation trying to approbate and reprobate on the same issue – Corporation’s non-disclosure is suppression of such high magnitude, akin to a clear fraud on court – Written statement of the Corporation and its award are documents of immense significance which were sufficient to tilt the balance in favour of the respondent – Objection of the Corporation to the Single Judge receiving such document as evidence in course of exercise of review jurisdiction without any substance and merits outright rejection – As regards payment of back wages, the respondent admitted that he was engaged on a daily wage basis, and because his service was terminated, he could not find a permanent employment elsewhere – No material on record to disbelieve him – Also clear that the Corporation succeeded in getting rid of the respondent by indulging in the misadventure of suppressio veri and suggestio falsi – Thus, in the interest of justice the order of the Single Judge awarding 100% back wages modified and respondent awarded 75% of the back wages from the date of his termination till the date of his superannuation – Also entitled to full terminal benefits, along with interest @ 6% p.a. [Paras 24-29, 30-33, 35, 36, 43-49] Service law – Termination of service – Payment of back wages, when:
Held: Ordering back wages to be paid to a dismissed employee, upon his dismissal being set aside by a court of law, is not an automatic relief – Grant of full or partial back wages has to be preceded by a fact-finding exercise by the industrial adjudicator/ court to ascertain whether in the interregnum the employee was gainfully employed – If the employee admits of any gainful employment and gives particulars of the employment together with 102 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports details of the emoluments received, or, if the employee asserts by pleading that he was not gainfully employed but the employer pleads and proves otherwise to the satisfaction of the court, the quantum of back wages ought to be awarded on reinstatement is really in the realm of discretion of the court – While grant of full back wages is the normal rule, an exceptional case with sufficient proof has to be set up by the employer to escape the burden of bearing back wages. [Paras 43, 44] Maxims – Suggestio falsi and suppresio veri – Meaning of: Held: Phrases suggestio falsi and suppresio veri embody concepts of unethical conduct of a party having serious consequences in various fields including law – Suggestio falsi is a false representation or a misleading suggestion while suppresio veri connotes suppression of the truth; an indirect lie, whether by words, conduct, or artifice – It is a type of fraud. [Paras 23, 24] Case Law Cited Associate Builders v. Delhi Development Authority [2014] 13 SCR 895 : 2015 (3) SCC 49; T.N. State Transport Corpn. (Coimbatore) Ltd. v. M. Chandrasekaran [2016] 4 SCR 266 : (2016) 16 SCC 16; Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation, Jaipur v. Phool Chand [2018] 11 SCR 448 : (2018) 18 SCC 229; Deepali Gundu Surwase v. Kranti Junior Adhyapak Mahavidyala [2013] 9 SCR 1: (2013) 10 SCC 324; State of M.P. v. Narmada Bachao Andolan [2011] 11 SCR 678 : (2011) 7 SCC 639; Union of India v. N. Murugesan [2021] 10 SCR 253 : (2022) 2 SCC 25; Hindustan Tin Works (P) Ltd. v. Employees [1979] 1 SCR 563 : (1979) 2 SCC 80; Surendra Kumar Verma v. Central Govt. Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court [1981] 1 SCR 789 : (1980) 4 SCC 443 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited Black’s Law Dictionary, 11th Edition – referred to.
List of Acts Constitution of India; Motor Vehicles Act, 1988; Evidence Act, 1872; Industrial Disputes Act, 1947; Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 103Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation v. Mahadeo Krishna Naik List of Keywords Removal from service; Back wages; Industrial dispute; Industrial adjudication; Suggestio falsi; Supressio veri; Dismissal due to gross negligence; Superannuation; Probative value; Fairness in procedure; Principles of natural justice; Suppression of evidence; Contradictory stances of a party; Fraud on court; Full terminal benefits; Lumpsum compensation to employee; Compensation; ‘He who asserts must prove’; Special knowledge; Reinstatement; Positive evidence of negative fact; Employment in the interregnum; Automatic relief of back wages; Review jurisdiction; Daily wage basis; 100% back wages; Award of 75% back wages; Full terminal benefits; Suggestio falsi and suppresio veri; Fraud.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 13834 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 30.11.2018 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in RP No. 18 of 2018 Appearances for Parties Ms. Mayuri Raghuvanshi, Vyom Raghuvanshi, Ms. Akanksha Rathore, Ms. Kinjal Sharma, Advs. for the Appellant.
Parvin Waman Satale, Rishabh Jain, S. K. Sarkar, Rajiv Shankar Dvivedi, Advs. for the Respondent.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Dipankar Datta J.
The A ppeAl
1. This appeal by the Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation, 1 by special leave, is directed against the judgment and order dated 30th November 2018 2 of Hon’ble S.C. Gupte, J.3 of the High Court 1 Corporation 2 impugned order 3 single judge 104 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports of Bombay 4 allowing a petition for review 5 of his earlier order dated 7 th February 2017 of dismissal of a writ petition6 instituted by the respondent. 7 The single judge not only set aside the order of dismissal of the writ petition passed by him but also set aside the award passed against Mahadeo by the 4 th Labour Court at Mumbai. 8 While so reviewing, the single judge also directed the Corporation to pay all benefits and emoluments including back wages to Mahadeo.
2. The Corporation has taken exception to the impugned order and contends that the High Court erred in interfering with the decisions of the Writ Court and the Labour Court in its review jurisdiction. FAcTuAl MATrix
3. The facts emerging from a perusal of the records would reflect that Mahadeo was appointed by the Corporation as a bus driver on 19 th April, 1988. The incident which formed the genesis of the present proceedings occurred on 10 th May 1996. A lorry coming from the opposite direction collided at about 22.45 hours with a bus of the Corporation, driven by Mahadeo, resulting in a fatal accident. Two passengers travelling on the bus succumbed to their injuries while several others (around ten) suffered injuries. The monetary loss to the Corporation arising from the accident was calculated at Rs. 45,000/.
4. As a consequence of this accident, disciplinary action followed against Mahadeo. Consequent upon an inquiry, the Divisional Traffic Officer9 dismissed Mahadeo from service of the Corporation on 27th May, 1997. Aggrieved by his dismissal, Mahadeo preferred a departmental appeal which proved abortive. The Union of which Mahadeo was a member, thereafter, raised an industrial dispute. A reference was made by the Deputy Commissioner of Labour requiring the Labour Court The Labour Court, upon considering the evidence led and hearing the parties to the dispute, held that the inquiry conducted 4 High Court 5 Review Petition No. 18 of 2018 6 Writ Petition No. 154 of 2007 7 Mahadeo 8 Labour Court 9 disciplinary authority [2025] 3 S.C.R. 105Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation v. Mahadeo Krishna Naik was fair;10 the findings of the inquiry officer were not perverse; 11 and the punishment inflicted was in proportion to the misconduct proved; therefore Mahadeo was not entitled to reinstatement in service. Resting on these findings, the Labour Court answered the reference by holding that Mahadeo was not entitled to any relief.12
5. Crestfallen, Mahadeo invoked the writ jurisdiction of the High Court by applying under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. 13 The single judge dismissed the challenge observing that there was enough material before the Labour Court to support the findings of the Inquiry Officer and hence, no interference was warranted.
6. While the reference and then the writ petition was pending, proceedings for compensation had been initiated by the family members of the deceased and injured victims of the road accident under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 14 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal at Mumbai. 15 Mahadeo, after becoming aware of the proceedings before the MACT, more particularly the contrary stand taken by the Corporation where the entire blame for the fatal accident was laid on the feet of the lorry driver as well as the award of the MACT dated 9th July, 2004,16 applied for review before the High Court 17 . The review proceeding succeeded before the High Court, triggering this appeal.
iMpugned Order
7. The single judge, in review, noticed the stand taken by the Corporation before the MACT that the accident was entirely due to the negligence of the lorry driver, who was driving carelessly without observing traffic norms. It was stated before the MACT that the driver of the lorry drove it into the Corporation’s bus and that no fault could have at all been attributed to Mahadeo for the accident. Furthermore, in its defence, the Corporation led evidence before the MACT of the 10 vide preliminary award dated 26 th May, 2004 11 vide preliminary award dated 9 th December, 2005 12 vide final award dated 16 th May, 2006 13 W.P. 154 of 2007 14 the 1988 Act
15 MACT
16 the said award 17 Review Petition No.18 of 2018 106 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports conductor of the bus and a passenger who emphatically stated that the lorry driver was completely at fault for the accident. The single judge noticed the fact that the proceeding before the MACT culminated into an award for compensation in favour of the claimants therein, where the MACT recognising the fact that the lorry driver was at fault, did not affix any liability on the Corporation. Based on the pleadings and the evidence presented by the Corporation, the MACT categorically held that the accident took place because of the negligence of the lorry driver.
8. It became clear to the single judge that such relevant evidence was suppressed before the Labour Court. This material, in the opinion of the single judge, had a crucial and conclusive bearing on the case before the Labour Court.
9. The single judge relied on a decision of this Court reported in Associate Builders v. Delhi Development Authority,18 where it was held that disregard of a vital piece of evidence is one of the factors to be considered while examining whether an order is perverse. The single judge further held that if the material produced before the MACT had been produced before it, the Labour Court would have reached a diametrically opposite conclusion than the one it reached in the present case.
10. The Corporation contended that a conclusion reached by a claims tribunal under the 1988 Act is not binding on the Labour Court, with which the single judge agreed. However, the single judge held that the Corporation had admitted in a sworn pleading that the accident was not due to the negligence of Mahadeo. This newly produced material, which existed when the Labour Court made its award and the order dismissing the writ petition was made, could not be produced by Mahadeo, yet, it was of such a clinching nature that on the face of this material, no court could come to the conclusion that Mahadeo was rightly dismissed from service due to gross negligence on his part amounting to misconduct.
11. Mahadeo pleaded his inability to produce this material before as he only became aware of the proceedings before the MACT in June, 2017 and received the certified copies of the materials by 23 rd June 2017.
18 2015 (3) SCC 49
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 107Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation v. Mahadeo Krishna Naik This was neither challenged by the Corporation before the single judge nor was it shown that Mahadeo, despite being aware of the proceedings before the MACT, went into slumber.
12. Hence, recording satisfaction that a case for review had been set up, the single judge proceeded to observe that no useful purpose would be served by remanding the matter to the Labour Court as the materials spoke for themselves and no case of negligence could be made out against Mahadeo by the Corporation. Consequently, the Corporation suffered an order for payment of all benefits and emoluments including back wages on the basis of continuous service of Mahadeo from the date of his wrongful termination till his superannuation. Since Mahadeo had attained the age of superannuation, reinstatement was denied.
13. The writ petition, thus, stood allowed on review of the earlier order of dismissal.
cOnTenTiOns OF The pArTies
14. On behalf of the Corporation, exception is taken to the impugned order on the following grounds:
(i) Mahadeo was a trained driver who was responsible for the safety of the passengers travelling in the bus. It is a fact that there was extensive damage to the bus and its passengers by the lorry and even though Mahadeo might have swerved to avoid the collision, there was a massive impact on account of the high speed of the bus. To bolster this submission, the Corporation relied on a decision of this Court in T.N. State Transport Corpn. (Coimbatore) Ltd. v. M. Chandrasekaran19 where it was held that the injuries caused to the passengers and the nature of impact raises an inference that the bus was being driven negligently by the bus driver.
(ii) The proceedings before the MACT and the disciplinary proceedings stand on completely different footing. The disciplinary proceedings were aimed at examining the role of Mahadeo in the collision, whereas the MACT proceedings aimed to determine the negligence of the drivers involved in the collision.
19 (2016) 16 SCC 16
108 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
(iii) Judicial review is limited to analysis of the decision-making process and the High Court could not have ventured into the correctness of the decision itself. Once it has been established that no ground for review was made out on the aspects of fairness and propriety of the inquiry, the High Court should not have interfered with the decision of the Labour Court.
(iv) The single judge has substituted its view in the place of the competent authority and erred in not remanding the matter to the Labour Court.
(v) Full back wages have been awarded to Mahadeo without any evidence that he was not gainfully employed during the period from his termination to his superannuation. The single judge erred in ignoring the fact that Mahadeo had a blemished service record, and several punishments had been meted out to him during his short service period. Reliance has been placed on the decision Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation, Jaipur v. Phool Chand 20 to contend that it is settled law that back wages are not automatic even if termination is set aside; hence, the single judge erred in not supplying reasons for award of full backwages.
15. Mahadeo, supporting the impugned order, advanced the following arguments:
(i) The Corporation has indulged in committing fraud on the Court, by not disclosing the fate of the judicial proceedings before the MACT and the pleadings filed therein, to obtain favourable orders.
(ii) Mahadeo has been fighting this legal battle since 1997 and due to dismissal from service, he has been unable to find any other permanent employment as a driver. He has been victimised by the Corporation and has suffered irreparable financial loss due to its condemnable actions.
(iii) The impugned order of the single judge granting relief is justified having regard to the decision of this Court in Deepali Gundu
20 (2018) 18 SCC 229
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 109Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation v. Mahadeo Krishna Naik Surwase v. Kranti Junior Adhyapak Mahavidyala,21 where this Court has held that if an employee is terminated on the basis on frivolous allegations in violation of natural justice, that in itself will be ample justification to award full backwages. Issues
16. To our mind, the present controversy tasks us to address four issues. The first is whether, the Corporation is guilty of suggestio falsi by not disclosing what it had pleaded before the MACT and suppresio veri by suppressing the said award. Depending on an affirmative answer to the first issue, the second issue would be whether, on facts and in the circumstances, the single judge was justified in exercising review jurisdiction. Again, an affirmative answer to the second issue would require serious consideration as to whether any interference with the direction for payment of full back wages is called for or not. Fourthly and finally, subject to our answers to all the three issues, what would be the appropriate relief for Mahadeo needs to be considered.
WriTTen sTATeMenT OF The cOrpOrATiOn beFOre The MAcT
17. To answer the above issues, we need to appreciate what was the nature of claim before the MACT, what precisely was the defence raised by the Corporation to avoid liability for payment of compensation, and what was the outcome of such proceedings.
18. The road accident taking the lives of two young children and causing injury to several others had given rise to a First Information Report.22 Mahadeo was not named as an accused therein. The driver of the lorry, involved in such accident, was the sole accused in the FIR. This fact was known to the Corporation from day one of the accident. The parents of Nitin Vardekar, 23 a deceased passenger aged 17 years, had approached the MACT with a claim for compensation 24 under section 166 of the 1988 Act, impleading the Corporation, 25 the
21 (2013) 10 SCC 324
22 FIR
23 claimants 24 Application No. 2901/1996 25 OP - 1 110 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports owner of the lorry 26 and the insurer of the lorry 27 as opposite parties.
19. To contest the claim of the claimants, the Divisional Controller of the Mumbai Division of the Corporation, Kurla, Mumbai filed the written statement, on solemn affirmation, for consideration of the MACT. Relevant passages from the said written statement read as follows: “4. …..It is true that when the said S.T. Bus reached at Pen Phata on Mumbai Goa Highway at Nagothane at about 22:45 hrs on 10.05.1996 at that time one M/Lorry bearing Registration no. MRL 8226 came from the opposite direction in a very fast speed and in rash and negligent manner and gave heavy dash to the driver side of the S.T. Bus. It is also true that due to the said impact, the right side of the S.T. was cut off and the deceased who was sitting on the right side in the said S.T. Bus sustained injuries.
5. With reference to para 22(ii) of the application, this and by the correct side of the road (sic). The said S.T. Bus was fully under the control of the Bus Driver of this Opp. Party. When the said S.T. Bus came near Pen Phata, at Nagothane, at that time one M/Lorry bearing registration no. MRL8226 which was being driven by the driver of the Opp. Party No. 2, at a fast speed, rashly, negligently and without any care, caution and proper lookout from the opposite direction of the S.T. Bus, could not control his vehicle, came on the wrong side of the road and dashed against the bus very heavily. The impact was so heavy that the right portion of the S.T. Bus from the driver’s side was tore and the passenger i.e. the deceased sustained injuries. The S.T. Bus driver, on seeing the M/Lorry coming towards the bus, tried to save his vehicle to his left side to avoid the accident. However, as the driver of the Opp. Party No.2 came abruptly in front of the bus in a rash and negligent manner, it came in contact of the right side of the S.T. sustained injuries and was removed to the hospital. It will this be observed that there was no negligence whatsoever on the part of the S.T. Bus driver, but it was 26 OP - 2 27 OP - 3 [2025] 3 S.C.R. 111Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation v. Mahadeo Krishna Naik sheer negligence on the part of the driver of the Opp. Party No. 2 who drove his M/lorry rashly, carelessly and Opp. Party denies that the accident is of such a nature that it would not have taken place but for the gross negligence and rashness of the driver of this Opp. Party and puts the applicants to the strict proof thereof. This Opp. Party further denies that the driver of the S.T. Bus was rash and negligent while driving the same in as much as he drove the said vehicle at a high, excessive and improper speed or that he drove the said S.T. Bus without taking precautions and/or keeping proper lookout or watch for the traffic and puts the applicant to the strict proof thereof. This opp. Party further denies that the driver of the S.T. Bus failed and neglected to apply the breaks and/or failed to apply the breaks efficiently and/or in sufficient time to avoid the accident or neglected to manoeuvre the vehicle so as to avoid the accident and puts the applicant to the strict proof thereof.”
(emphasis supplied)
AWArd OF The MAcT
20. MACT, Mumbai, considering the claim raised by the claimants and the defence of the Corporation recorded the evidence of, inter alia, a passenger named Anant Chindarkar28 and the conductor of the Corporation’s bus named Chandrakant Lokhe, 29 respectively. On the basis of appreciation of the materials on record, the MACT proceeded to deliver the said award. We consider it appropriate to extract relevant passages from the said award hereinbelow: “2. …Applicant Nos.1 and 2 are father and mother respectively of the deceased Nitin. On 10.5.1996 the deceased was travelling by S.T. Bus No.MH-12-Q-8712.
It was going along Mumbai Goa Highway. At about 10.45 p.m., it reached at Nagothane. At that time, one Motor Lorry No.MRL-8226 came from the front side in very fast 28 P.W. 2 29 D.W. 1 112 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports speed and gave dash to the said S.T. Bus at its’s driver’s side. Therefore, right side of S.T. Bus was cut off. The deceased was seriously injured and died on the spot.
****
3. Opposite party No.1 M.S.R.T.C. filed written statement Exhibit-8. It’s case is that: The said Motor lorry came on wrong side of the road and dashed the S.T. Bus heavily. The accident occurred due to sole negligence of the driver of the said lorry.
****
ISSUES FINDINGS
1) Whether the Applicants prove that the accident took place due to rash and negligent driving of vehicle No.MRL-8226?
Yes 2) Whether the Applicants prove that the deceased died in the said accident?
Yes Whether the Applicants prove that they are entitled to compensation as alleged?
Yes, Rs.1,40,000/- ****
8. Applicants examined one Anant Chindarkar as P.W.2 as an eye witness. P.W.2 stated that: On 10.5.1996 he was accompanying the deceased in the said S.T. Bus.
Deceased was sitting on seat No.25. Near Pen fatta, one lorry came from front side and gave dash to the S.T. Bus. That lorry was in great speed. It hit S.T. Bus as it’s middle portion of the right side. Therefore right side of the S.T. Bus was torn. The deceased got injuries on his head and chest. He became unconscious. Police came on the spot after about 15 to 20 minutes and removed the deceased to Nagothane Rural Hospital by one private car. P.W.2 and his friends also went to that hospital. Doctor examined the deceased and declared him dead. Number of that S.T.
Bus is MH-12-Q-8712. Number of that lorry is MRL-8226.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 113Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation v. Mahadeo Krishna Naik ****
10. Opposite party No.1 M.S.R.T.C. examined one Chandrakant Lokhe as D.W.1. He stated that on 10.5.1996 he was conductor of the said S.T. Bus. Accident happened near Nagothane Fatta at about 10.45 p.m. Speed of S.T.
Bus was about 30 K.M.P.H. There was vehicular traffic on the road. The S.T. Bus was on the left side of the road. The said lorry came from front side in great speed and gave dash to middle portion of right side of S.T. Bus. The accident happened because lorry came to wrong side of the road. Body of S.T. Bus was torn. The lorry went further ahead and then overturned. The S.T. Bus was stopped immediately after the accident. Lorry driver was responsible for the accident.
****
13. …Spot panchnama Exhibit-23 further shows that: The said truck No. MRL 8226 after giving dash to the S.T. Bus went towards western side of the road. Then it hit and uprooted six stones on the kacha road. Thereafter, it went below the road and dashed one tree. It was standing there facing towards the road. Trucks body is of iron. Upper side of truck’s cabin was broken and was lying near it. It stopped about 115 feet away from the place of accident. Driver’s side body of the truck was seen damaged.
****
16. P.W.2 Anant Chindarkar was one of the passengers in the said S.T. Bus. That fact is not disputed by the other side. D.W.1 Chandrakant Lokhe was the conductor of the said S.T. Bus. It is also not disputed. P.W.2 and D.W.1 were, therefore, supposed to have personal knowledge and experience of the circumstances in which the accident occurred. Both of them blamed driver of the said lorry for the occurrence.
****
20. For the aforesaid reasons I find that the accident took place because of rash and negligent driving of the said 114 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports truck No.MRL-8226. Issue No.1 is, therefore, answered affirmatively.
****
25. Consequently, the applicants are entitled to get total compensation of Rs.1,40,000/- (Rs.1,30,000 + Rs.10,000). Admittedly: Deceased died in the accident in question. The said motor lorry was involved in it. It was insured with the New India Assurance Co. Ltd., on the date of the accident. The Opposite party No.2, Ramesh Suryawanshi is owner of the said lorry. Therefore, I find that Opposite Party No.2 and Insurer are liable to pay aforesaid compensation of Rs.1,40,000/- to the applicants. Issue No.3 is answered accordingly.
****
27. Hence, the following order:
ORDER
Application is partly allowed with proportionate costs. Opposite party No.2 Ramesh Suryawanshi and the Insurer the New India Assurance Co. Ltd. Both are ordered to pay jointly and severally Rs.1,40,000 (Rupees One Lakh Forty Thousand Only) to the applicants alongwith interest at the rate of 6% p.a. From the date of the filing of the application i.e. 27.8.1996 till payment.
It is inclusive of payment under sec.140 of Motor Vehicles Act by way of No-Fault Liability.
The case against Opposite party No.1, M.S.R.T.C. is dismissed.”
(emphasis supplied)
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.