Hiralal Babulal Soni v. The State of Maharashtra & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 266; [2025] 2 S.C.R. 708
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra, Justice K.V. Viswanathan
- Decided
- 24 Feb 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 579/2012
- Sections
- 120B, 411, 114, 13, 13(1), 13(2), 403, 106, 313
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 708 : 2025 INSC 266 Hiralal Babulal Soni v.
The State of Maharashtra & Ors.
(Criminal Appeal No(s). 579-580 of 2012)
25 February 2025 [B.R. Gavai, Prashant Kumar Mishra,* and K.V. Viswanathan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose as regards the sustainability of the conviction of the accused u/s.120B and 411 IPC, when the seized gold bars are not the same gold bars linked to the fraudulent transactions. Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – ss.120B, 411 rw s.120B – Dishonestly receiving stolen property – Criminal conspiracy – Possession of stolen property – Commission of fraud by remittance through fake Telegraphic Transfers-TT and subsequent withdrawals amounting to Rs. 6.7 crores at the Bank – Bank account opened for a fictitious firm using forged documents – TTs made and said amount credited to the account of the firm and thereafter withdrawn by preparing demand drafts in favour of two companies – Amount involved in the demand drafts allegedly used against purchase of seized gold bars delivered to the appellant-accused no. 3 – Search at the shop of accused no. 3 leading to seizure of 205 gold bars and other documents – Trial court convicted two officers of the bank, however acquitted by the High Court – Accused no. 3 held guilty of the offence punishable u/ss.120B, 411 rw 120B, however directed that 205 gold bars be returned to the accused no. 3 – High Court upheld the conviction of accused no. 3, however quashed the direction to return the gold bars to accused no. 3 and the property stood confiscated – Challenge to:
Held: Once the courts below found that the seized gold bars are not the same gold bars linked to the fraudulent transactions, conviction u/ss.120B and 411 cannot be sustained – On consideration of the pre-requisite evidence to bring home the charge u/s.411, even if it is proved that the appellant was handed over the demand drafts and gold bars were purchased by the appellant from the company, * Author [2025] 2 S.C.R. 709Hiralal Babulal Soni v. The State of Maharashtra & Ors. still it was necessary for the prosecution to prove that the appellant either had knowledge or reason to believe that the demand drafts had been obtained through fraudulent process to make the gold bars as stolen property in the hands of the appellant or that the appellant was part of the conspiracy – Moreover, the appellant has been not charged and tried for the first part of the offence relating to criminal conspiracy vis-à-vis fraudulent TTs – Furthermore, the trial court held that the prosecution ought to have produced evidence to show that there was a stock of the same brand with the company and out of that stock some gold bars with the markings were sold to the so called fictitious firm – In the absence of this evidence and especially due to delay of four years in the recovery of the property the very basis of its identification is found shattered, and the possibility of mistaken identification cannot be ruled out – Invocation of s.114 of the 1872 Act not at all permissible since the prosecution failed to discharge its initial burden – Prosecution has to prove its case beyond all reasonable doubts by positively completing the chain of circumstances against the appellant, which the prosecution utterly failed – Thus, the conviction and sentence of the accused no.3 u/ss.120B and 411 set aside – Since the seized gold bars were recovered from the appellant, he is entitled to the possession thereof – Seized gold bars be handed over to the appellant – Since the identity of the seized property being the stolen property not established, the bank not entitled to the possession of the seized gold – Evidence Act, 1872. [Paras 30, 35, 37-39] Penal Code, 1860 – s.411 – Dishonestly receiving stolen property – Charge u/s.411 – Duty of the prosecution to prove: Held: Prosecution has to prove that the stolen property was in the possession of the accused; that some persons other than the accused had possession of the property before the accused got possession of it; and that the accused had knowledge that the property was stolen property. [Para 32] Case Law Cited Trimbak v. State of M.P, AIR 1954 SC 39; Nagendra Sah v. State of Bihar (2021) 10 SCC 725 – relied on.
Kamal v. State (NCT of Delhi), 2023 INSC 678 : [2023] 11 SCR 49; Mohan Lal v. State of Maharashtra (1979) 4 SCC 751; Shiv Kumar v. State of M.P [2022] 7 SCR 493 : (2022) 9 SCC 676 – referred to.
710 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports List of Acts Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988; Penal Code, 1860; Evidence Act, 1872.
List of Keywords Dishonestly receiving stolen property; Criminal conspiracy; Commission of fraud by remittance through fake Telegraphic Transfers; Fictitious firm; Forged documents; Demand drafts; Seizure of 205 gold bars; Return of 205 gold bars; Confiscation; Suspicion; Proof beyond reasonable doubt; Demand drafts obtained through fraudulent process; Mistaken identification; Prosecution failed to discharge initial burden; Chain of circumstances; Duty of the prosecution to prove charge u/s. 411 IPC.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No(s). 579-580 of 2012 From the Judgment and Order dated 16.07.2009 of the High Court of Bombay in CRLA No. 363 of 2009 and CRLA No. 638 of 2006 With Criminal Appeal No(s). 581-583 and 584 of 2012 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Uday Gupta, Sr. Hiren Dasan, Chand Qureshi, Mrs. Shivani Lal, Mujahid Ahmad, Harish Dasan, Rajive Ranjan, Raj Kumar Yadav, Dhirendar Kumar Verma, Mrs. Arpana Soni, Chand Qureshi, Mrs. Shivani Lal, Mujahid Ahmad, Harish Dasan, Rajive Ranjan, Raj Kumar Yadav, Dhirendar Kumar Verma, Mrs. Arpana Soni, A. P. Singh, Naman Saraswat, Tavinder Sidhu, M/S. M. V. Kini & Associates. Advs. for the Respondents:
Upmanyu Tewari, Mrs. V. D. Khanna, Mahesh Kumar, Akshay Kumar Sharma, Ms. Devika Khanna, Ms. Suhasini Sen, Mukesh Kumar Maroria, Sachin Sharma, Chinmayee Chandra, Siddhant Kohli, Vinayak Sharma, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Shrirang B. Varma, Bharat Bagla, Sourav Singh, Aditya Krishna, Ms. Preet S. Phanse, Adarsh Dubey, Uday Gupta, Sr. Hiren Dasan, Chand Qureshi.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 711Hiralal Babulal Soni v. The State of Maharashtra & Ors. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Prashant Kumar Mishra, J.
1. These criminal appeals are disposed of by this common order as they are directed against the common judgment and order dated 16.07.2009 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay whereunder the High Court dismissed the appeal of the appellant/Hiralal Babulal Soni (Criminal Appeal Nos. 579-580/2012) and the appeal of the appellant/ accused No. 3 namely, Nandkumar Babulal Soni, (Criminal Appeal No. 581-583/2012) whereas the appeals of Mr. S.K. Sheenappa Rai (accused no.1), Devdas Shetty (accused no.2) and Vijaya Bank were allowed. We shall later notice the conviction and sentence awarded by the courts below.
2. The offence pertains to commission of fraud by remittance through fake Telegraphic Transfers 1 and subsequent withdrawals to the tune of Rs. 6,70,00,000/- at Vijaya Bank, Nasik Branch, Maharashtra.
2.1. On 30.01.1997, one person disclosing as a representative of M/s. Globe International, a proprietary concern, approached the bank for opening an account which was not immediately accepted by the accused no. 1 (S.K. Sheenappa Rai), Branch Manager as he wanted to verify the documents as there was difference in signatures. However, since one Surendera Bhandary, Assistant General Manager, Vijaya Bank, Fort Branch, Bombay confirmed the letter of introduction issued by him, the personal presence of the proposed account holder was dispensed with, and the account was opened.
2.2. It is the case of the prosecution that the documents submitted at the time of account opening were forged and the person representing the firm namely, Surendra Jain or the firm Globe International were fictitious. The account was eventually opened on 06.02.1997. On 25.04.1997, Nasik Branch received TT of Rs. 10,00,000/- in the account of Globe International and thereafter till 28.07.1997, 11 TTs were sent from Delhi issued by 1 “TT”
712 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Vijaya Bank, Ansari Road Branch, New Delhi. On 06.08.1997, Vijaya Bank, Nasik Branch received TT of Rs. 4,00,000/- which was credited to the account of Globe International. Thus, total amount of Rs. 6,70,00,000/- was credited in this account. Simultaneously, with the credit of TT amount, the same was withdrawn and subsequently, the TTs were found to be bogus and forged and the entire fraud was committed not only by accused nos. 1 and 2 but was done with the help of absconding and unknown persons like Mukesh Shah @ Mayur Desai or Ashok Agarwal @ Surender Jain and so on. On 12.08.1997, it was found that no payment of the said TTs was ever made at Vijaya Bank, Ansari Road Branch, Delhi. On this date, accused no. 1 informed Vijaya Bank, Fort Branch, Bombay about the fraud and the payments against 19 demand drafts for a total amount of Rs.1,61,44,000/- were stopped.
3. During the investigation, the Investigating Officer recorded the statements of the owner of Jewellary firms i.e. M/s. Chenaji Narsinghji2 and M/s. V.P. Jewellers and thereafter filed the chargesheet against accused nos. 1 and 2 by mentioning that further investigation is going on. Later, Central Bureau of Investigation 3 found that most of the DDs were issued in favour of M/s. CN against the purchase of gold bars and the delivery of those gold bars were given to accused no. 3 or through him to Mayur Desai @ Mukesh Shah. CBI found link between absconding accused Mukesh Shah and accused no. 3 to whom gold bars were delivered from M/s. CN. On 01.06.2001, a search was carried out at the shop of accused no. 3 effecting seizure of 205 gold bars and other documents. Thus, chargesheet was filed against accused no. 1 (S.K.Sheenappa Rai), accused no. 2 (M. Devdas Shetty), accused no. 3 (Nandkumar Babulal Soni) whereas accused no. 4 (Mayur Desai @ Mukesh Shah @ M.P. Jain @ Mukesh Jain) could not be traced and declared proclaimed offender by the Trial Court on 12.02.2002.
4. The Trial Court framed charges against the accused persons for offences under Section 120B read with Sections 403, 409, 411, 420, 2 ‘M/s. CN’ 3 ‘CBI’ [2025] 2 S.C.R. 713Hiralal Babulal Soni v. The State of Maharashtra & Ors. 471, 477A and 109 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 4 read with Section 13 (2) read with Section 13 (1) (d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. While the accused nos. 1 and 2 submitted that they are innocent; the account was opened as per the banking procedure; they have been given a clean chit in the departmental inquiry conducted by the Vijaya Bank. The accused no. 3 set up a defence that he has no connection with either M/s.CN or with Mukesh Shah @ Mayur Desai and, thus, he is falsely implicated without there being any evidence against him. He claimed that the seized gold bars are his property, legally acquired by him. At the end of trial, accused nos. 1 and 2 were convicted for the offences under Sections 120B, 467, 409, 471, 477A, 403 of the IPC as also under Section 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. Accused No. 1 was also held guilty of the offence punishable under Sections 403 and 465 read with Section 120B of the IPC and accused no. 2 was held guilty under Section 403 of the IPC. The accused no. 3 was held guilty of the offence punishable under Section 120B of the IPC as well as under Section 411 read with Section 120B of the IPC. The Trial Court directed that the muddemal articles consisting of 205 gold bars be returned to the accused no. 3.
5. While the accused persons preferred separate appeals challenging their conviction and sentence, the CBI preferred Criminal Appeal No. 638 of 2006 for challenging that part of the judgment of the Trial Court by which the gold bars were returned to accused no. 3. Criminal Appeal No. 363 of 2009 has been preferred by Hiralal Babulal Soni challenging the order regarding return of gold bars to accused no. 3.
6. The High Court under the impugned judgment has allowed the Criminal Appeal preferred by accused nos. 1 and 2 and their conviction and sentence has been set aside. The Criminal Appeal No. 428 of 2006 preferred by accused no. 3 (Nandkumar Babulal Soni) was dismissed. The Criminal Appeal No. 363 of 2009 (converted from Criminal Application No. 463 of 2007) preferred by Hiralal Babulal Soni was also dismissed. The Criminal Appeal No. 638 of 2006 preferred by CBI challenging the Trial Court’s direction to return 205 gold bars to the accused no. 3 (Nandkumar Babulal Soni) has been allowed and the direction is quashed and set aside by the High 4 ‘IPC’ 714 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Court. The property stood confiscated and placed at the disposal of the State Government.
7. Aggrieved by the High Court’s judgment, accused no. 3 (Nandkumar Babulal Soni) has preferred Criminal Appeal Nos. 581-583 of 2012 challenging his conviction as also seeking return of 205 gold bars whereas Criminal Appeal No. 579-580 of 2012 has been preferred by Hiralal Babulal Soni and Criminal Appeal No. 584 of 2012 has been preferred by Vijaya Bank, both seeking return of gold bars. Submissions:
8. Mr. Uday Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant(s) has vehemently argued that the appellant is wrongly convicted for the offence under Section 411 of the IPC without there being any evidence against him. It is put forth by him that incomplete chain of circumstantial evidence has been relied upon for appellant’s conviction which is legally unsustainable, and the appellant has been convicted only on the basis of suspicion. According to him, the yawning gap between the charge for the offence under Section 411 of the IPC and the evidence adduced by the prosecution. Learned counsel referred to the judgment in the matter of ‘Kamal vs. State (NCT of Delhi).5
9. Mr. A.P. Singh, learned counsel appearing for the Vijaya Bank/ appellant has argued that since the gold bars have been acquired by using forged TTs/DDs by defrauding the bank, the gold bars should be returned to the bank. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant/Hiralal Babulal Soni has also prayed that on the basis of evidence on record, appellant/Hiralal Babulal Soni is entitled for return of the gold bars.
10. Per Contra, Ms. Suhasini Sen, learned counsel for the respondent (CBI) has argued that there is independent evidence on record to link the appellant (Accused No. 3) with Mukesh Shah @ Mayur Desai and the fraudulent transactions. She has also referred to the statements of PW-22 (Dhiraj Ganeshmal Jain), PW-26 (Prakash Kumar Deoraj Jain), PW-32 (Ashok Kumar Bhavarlal Jain) and PW-33 (Chandramohan A. Shetty) (IO). She would also refer to the evidence regarding the identification of the gold bars. Learned counsel
5 2023 INSC 678
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 715Hiralal Babulal Soni v. The State of Maharashtra & Ors. would sum up the arguments with submission that the conviction of Accused No. 3 as well as the order of the High Court regarding the custody of the gold bars be upheld.
The nature of fraud – “Telegraphic Transfer”
11. At the relevant time, Vijaya Bank offered a service facility to all its customers whereby money could be remitted through the means of “Telegraphic Transfer” (TT). If a customer desired to remit funds urgently from one place to another, he could deposit cash and request the remitting branch to send the amount to the credit of a particular account. Upon receipt of money, the remitter branch would generate a code which was then sent via telegram to the concerned branch in which account of the beneficiary was operational. Upon decoding, the receiving branch would then credit the amount to the account of the beneficiary and send “Bank adjustment Requisition Form” (BARF) to the remitting branch which upon receiving the BARF would send a credit advice to the receiving branch.
Role of different persons including the accused:
12. One unknown person representing M/s. Globe International with its sole Proprietor being one Surender Kanti Lal Jain approached the bank for opening an account. Despite several irregularities in the process of opening of account, Accused No. 1 (S.K. Sheenappa Rai – acquitted), the Branch Manager, Vijaya Bank, Nasik Branch allowed the opening of the account. All the documents presented at the time of opening of the account were found bogus during the investigation. It was also found that the firm M/s. Globe International and its Proprietor Mr. Surender Kanti Lal Jain are fictitious. Mr. Surender Kanti Lal Jain was never identified or traced nor has been arrayed as an accused.
13. Accused No. 1 (S.K. Sheenappa Rai) and Accused No. 2 (M. Devadas Shetty) both officers of the bank allegedly credited the amount to the account of M/s. Globe International and also allowed withdrawal of the amount in conspiracy with Mr. Surender Kanti Lal Jain and Mayurkumar Manubhai Desai @ M.J. Shah @ M.P. Jain @ Mukesh Jain @ Mukesh Shah.
14. Mayurkumar Manubhai Desai @ M.J. Shah @ M.P. Jain @ Mukesh Jain @ Mukesh Shah was involved in cash withdrawals of Rs. 98,00,000/- at Vijaya Bank, Nasik Branch.
716 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
15. A sum of Rs. 2,59,78,504/- was withdrawn by preparing demand drafts in favour of M/s. CN and M/s. V.B. Jewellers by Mayurkumar Manubhai Desai @ M.J. Shah @ M.P. Jain @ Mukesh Jain @ Mukesh Shah. These demand drafts were honoured by Vijaya Bank, Fort Branch, Mumbai and Tamil Nadu Mercantile Bank, Mandvi Branch upon withdrawal of the said amount from the account of M/s. Globe International. The amount involved in these demand drafts were allegedly used against purchase of seized gold bars.
Discovery of fraud and investigation:
16. The accused no. 1 became suspicious of the transactions taking place in the account of M/s. Globe International. On 12.08.1997, he informed Vijaya Bank, Fort Branch, Mumbai about the fraud and the resultant payment against 19 demand drafts amounting to Rs. 1,61,44,000/- was stopped. On this date, there was a balance of Rs. 1,53,27,178/- in the account of M/s. Globe International, as against the total credit amount through 12 TTs amounting to Rs. 6,70,00,000/-. The bank initiated departmental proceedings against the accused nos. 1 and 2. However, subsequently, both of them were exonerated of all the charges.
17. On 04.09.1997, a formal complaint was lodged by Vijaya Bank and on 09.09.1997, the CBI registered the crime against the accused Nos. 1, 2 and Surender Kantilal Jain (not traced) as Proprietor of M/s. Globe International and against unknown private persons. The appellant/accused no. 3 was summoned by the CBI after 1½ years i.e. on 03.02.1999. However, he denied his involvement in the alleged crime. After nearly 4 years i.e. 24.05.2001, the CBI conducted a search in the shop of appellant/Accused No. 3 on 28.05.2001. However, in the absence of appellant/Accused No. 3, the shop was sealed. On 30.05.2001, appellant/Accused No. 3 requested the Investigating Officer for removing the seal mentioning in his communication the details of cash, gold (in stock). The 205 gold bars mentioned in appellant/Accused No. 3’s communication dated 30.05.2001 were later on seized by the CBI on 01.06.2001. The details of 205 gold bars were as under:
(i) 110 T.T. bars of ARY make;
(ii) 30 T.T. bars of HARMONY make;
(iii) 57 T.T. bars of Johnson Mathew make;
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 717Hiralal Babulal Soni v. The State of Maharashtra & Ors.
(iv) 06 T.T. bars of Credit Suisse make;
(v) 02 T.T. bars of PAMP Suisse make;
18. The CBI filed the chargesheet on 31.05.2002 whereupon the charges were framed, trial was conducted, and all the three accused were convicted by the Trial Court as mentioned infra. However, the High Court acquitted the Accused Nos. 1 and 2 but convicted the appellant/Accused No. 3 in Criminal Appeal Nos. 581-583 of 2012 for offence under Section 120B IPC and Section 411 IPC read with Section 120B IPC.
ANALYSIS:
19. There being no appeal by the CBI challenging the acquittal of the Accused Nos. 1 and 2 by the High Court, our discussion would confine to the case against appellant/Accused No. 3 only.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.