Abdul Wahid & Anr. v. State of Rajasthan
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 295; [2025] 2 S.C.R. 2101
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Pankaj Mithal, Justice * Jj]
- Decided
- 28 Feb 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 722/2012
- Sections
- 147, 302, 149, 27, 313
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 2101 : 2025 INSC 295 Abdul Wahid & Anr.
v.
State of Rajasthan (Criminal Appeal No. 722 of 2012)
28 February 2025 [Pankaj Mithal and Ujjal Bhuyan,* JJ] Issue for Consideration Whether it is for the prosecution to connect the accused to the alleged crime by producing credible and legally admissible evidence to punish.
Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – ss.302/149 – Murder – Accused persons assaulted the victim and the informant somehow managed to escape and lodged the first information that victim was lying at the place of occurrence in an injured condition – Incident was witnessed by brother-in-law of the victim and another – Allegations that due to previous enmity, the seven accused persons formed unlawful assembly whereafter they assaulted the victim with a murderous intent – FIR lodged and chargesheet filed u/s.147/148/149/302 against the appellants – Trial court convicted the appellants u/s.302/148 – High Court modified the conviction by holding the appellants guilty of offence punishable u/s. 302 with the aid of u/s.149 – Correctness: Held: Though prosecution witnesses stated about the recovery of the weapons on the basis of information given by the accused persons, the manner in which the recoveries were made and the circumstances surrounding the recoveries made the recoveries highly suspect – That apart, the alleged recoveries were made after several days of the incident and no bloodstains etc. were found on the weapons – Doctor who had conducted the postmortem examination, deposed in his evidence that the seized weapons were not shown to him – Knives were also not produced in court – Besides, all the seizure witnesses turned hostile – Thus, s.27 of the Evidence Act cannot come to the aid of the * Author 2102 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports prosecution – Moreover, the clothes of the accused were not seized and sent for forensic examination to find out whether there were any bloodstains – Such examination would have revealed whether there were any bloodstains on the clothes; whether those bloodstains were of human blood; and whether those matched the blood of the deceased – Material inconsistency in the evidence of prosecution witnesses – No doubt that the death of victim is homicidal – Medical evidence has also confirmed multiple stab injuries on his body leading to profuse bleeding and death – According to the prosecution, it is the accused who had committed murder of the victim – Thus, it is for the prosecution to connect the accused to the murder of the deceased by producing credible and legally admissible evidence – However, no credible evidence at all to connect the accused persons with the homicidal death of the victim – In such circumstances, the appellants entitled to the benefit of doubt – Evidence Act, 1872. [Paras 21, 24] Case Law Cited Anil Phukan v. State of Assam [1993] 2 SCR 389 : (1993) 3 SCC 282; Narendrasinh Keshubhai Zala v. State of Gujarat [2023] 2 SCR 746 : 2023 SCC Online 284 – referred to.
List of Acts Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Evidence Act, 1872; Penal Code, 1860.
List of Keywords Witness; Hostile; Life Imprisonment; Incised Wound; Murder; Place of incident; Investigation.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
722 of 2012 From the Judgment and Order dated 26.08.2011 of the High Court of Rajasthan at Jaipur in DBCRA No. 639 of 2003 With Criminal Appeal No. 1266 of 2012 [2025] 2 S.C.R. 2103Abdul Wahid & Anr. v. State of Rajasthan Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Ms. Gouri Karuna Das Mohanti, Snehasish Mukherjee, Ms. Anu Gupta, Sanjay Mani Tripathi, V. Elangovan, Ali Jethmalani, Pawan Kumar Sharma, Ms. Priya Rastogi.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Irshad Ahmad, Ms. Nidhi Jaswal, Milind Kumar.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Ujjal Bhuyan, J.
This judgment and order will dispose of Criminal Appeal Nos. 722 and 1266 of 2012.
2. Criminal Appeal No. 722 of 2012 arises out of SLP(Crl.) No. 1764 of 2012 filed by Abdul Wahid and Babu (appellants herein). In this appeal, challenge has been made to the judgment and order dated 26.08.2011 passed by the High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan at Jaipur Bench (for short ‘High Court’ hereinafter) in D.B. Criminal Appeal No. 639 of 2003 whereby the High Court has upheld the judgment and order dated 10.03.2003 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge No. 4, Kota (‘trial court’ for short) in Sessions Case No. 13/1996 convicting the appellants under Sections 302/148 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC). However, the High Court modified the conviction by holding the accused guilty of the offence punishable under Section 302 with the aid of Section 149 IPC while maintaining the sentence of life imprisonment.
2.1. Criminal Appeal No. 1266 of 2012 has been filed by Abdul Shakur (appellant herein) against the aforesaid judgment and order of the High Court dated 26.08.2011 affirming the judgment and order of the trial court and convicting the appellant under Sections 302/149 IPC and sentencing him to undergo imprisonment for life.
2.2. So the 3 appellants are Abdul Wahid, Babu and Abdul Shakur.
3. Since Criminal Appeal No. 722 of 2012 was argued as the lead appeal, facts narrated therein are referred to hereunder, though both 2104 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the appeals arise out of the same incident and the same judgment of the High Court.
4. Faeem Ahmed lodged first information before the Maqbara police station, Kota, Rajasthan on 25.06.1988 at about 12:35 AM. He stated therein that Ahsan Ali and himself were on way to the residence of the in-laws of Ahsan Ali in Nayapura around 10:40 PM. While Ahsan Ali was talking to his relatives in the shop of his brother-inlaw, he was seen by accused Abdul Sattar and Abdul Wahid. This was noticed by Faeem Ahmed who knew them and also about the strained relationship between Ahsan Ali on the one hand and Abdul Sattar and Abdul Wahid on the other hand. He suggested to Ahsan Ali that while returning home, they should change the route. However, Ahsan Ali insisted on going through the same route by which they had come. While returning, when they reached the place called Ghantaghar at around 12 midnight, suddenly accused Babu, Abdul Wahid, Abdul Sattar, Aziz @ Patti, Abdul Shakur, Bundu and Latur Ali accosted them and attacked Ahsan Ali and himself with knives etc. The first knife injury was inflicted by Babu on the stomach of Ahsan Ali whereafter he fell down from the motorcycle; the second injury was inflicted by Abdul Wahid on the chest of Ahsan Ali, also by knife; Abdul Sattar inflicted injury by a katar (sword) on the backside of Ahsan Ali. Abdul Shakur and Aziz @ Patti who were also trying to inflict injuries on Ahsan Ali, chased the informant Faeem Ahmed. He ran into the Gauri Hotel lane. When the said two accused persons did not find Faeem Ahmed, they returned back and started assaulting Ahsan Ali.
4.1. Informant somehow managed to escape and went to the police station to lodge the first information. He stated that Ahsan Ali was lying at the place of occurrence in an injured condition. The incident was witnessed by Wahid (brother-in-law of Ahsan Ali) and Jameel. He alleged that due to previous enmity, the above named 7 accused persons i.e. Babu, Abdul Sattar, Abdul Wahid, Abdul Shakur, Aziz @ Patti, Bundu and Latur Ali alongwith Jaffar Mohammad formed an unlawful assembly whereafter they assaulted Ahsan Ali with a murderous intent.
4.2. On the basis of the first information, FIR No. 48/1988 was registered on 25.06.1988 under Sections 147/148/149/307 IPC. Injured Ahsan Ali was taken to the hospital for treatment [2025] 2 S.C.R. 2105Abdul Wahid & Anr. v. State of Rajasthan but he succumbed to his injuries whereafter Section 302 IPC was added to the FIR.
4.3. Police carried out the investigation and on completion of the same, filed chargesheet against the 8 accused persons under Sections 147/148/149/302 IPC. Since it was sessions triable, the case was committed to the Court of Sessions whereafter charges were framed against the accused persons to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
4.4. Prosecution examined as many as 22 witnesses. On completion of the prosecution evidence, the accused persons were examined under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Cr.P.C.) who denied the charge and alleged false implication. The defence also examined 3 witnesses. It may be mentioned that trial against 4 accused persons viz. Abdul Sattar, Bundu, Latur Ali and Aziz @ Patti abetted on account of their death. On conclusion of the trial, trial court vide the judgment and order dated 10.03.2003 acquitted accused Jaffar Mohammed of all the charges. The present 3 appellants Abdul Wahid, Babu and Abdul Shakur were convicted for the offence under Sections 302/148 IPC and sentenced accordingly.
5. Aggrieved by the aforesaid conviction and sentence, the 3 appellants preferred appeal before the High Court. The High Court vide the judgment and order dated 26.08.2011 (impugned judgment) affirmed the judgment and order dated 10.03.2003 of the trial court with the modification that the conviction was under Sections 302/149 IPC. The sentence of life imprisonment imposed upon the appellants was maintained. The appeal was accordingly dismissed.
6. In the first appeal, notice was issued by this Court in the related SLP on 24.02.2012. Leave was granted on 30.04.2012 and the 2 appellants, Abdul Wahid and Babu, were granted bail. In so far the second appeal is concerned, leave was granted on 16.08.2012 and vide order dated 07.12.2012, the appellant Abdul Shakur was granted bail.
7. Learned counsel for the appellants submits that the courts below were not justified in convicting the appellants on the testimony of the sole eyewitness PW-1. After disbelieving the evidence of other witnesses presented as eyewitnesses by the prosecution, evidence 2106 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports of PW-1 has to be taken with a pinch of salt as he was a relative and an employee of the deceased. He is an interested witness and his testimony is not corroborated by any independent witness.
7.1. Learned counsel further submits that PW-1 is not a reliable and trustworthy witness in as much as in his cross-examination, he has admitted that he is a stock witness; police had produced him as a witness in the Babar Mushtaq case to depose falsely. Further, in his cross-examination he admitted that there are 3/4 criminal cases pending against him. Thus, he has got criminal antecedents. It is evident that PW-1 was being used by the police to nail the accused and, therefore, a great deal of suspicion hovers over his testimony. As such, it would be wholly unsafe to rely on the testimony of PW-1 to convict the appellants without any independent corroboration. In this connection, he has placed reliance on the decision of this Court in Anil Phukan Vs. State of Assam1.
7.2. Learned counsel for the appellant has also cast aspersions on the FIR contending that though the same was registered on 25.06.1988 around midnight (12:30 PM), it was forwarded to the concerned magistrate only two days thereafter on 27.06.1988.
7.3. Referring to the testimony of the investigating officer PW-17, learned counsel submits that the said witness admitted in his cross-examination that the motorcycle on which the deceased was travelling alongwith PW-1 when he was allegedly attacked by the accused persons was never seized; the blood soil sample from the place of incident was not collected by the investigating officer and, therefore, could not be subjected to forensic examination. He also submits that the knives and katar allegedly used by the appellants to assault the deceased and recovered pursuant to confessional statements of the accused persons were never produced in court. As a matter of fact, all the witnesses to the alleged recovery of weapons turned hostile stating that they had put their signature on being forced by the police.
1 (1993) 3 SCC 282
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 2107Abdul Wahid & Anr. v. State of Rajasthan
7.4. Learned counsel also submits that PW-1 in his evidence stated that appellant No. 2 had inflicted a stab wound on the stomach of the deceased. But in the postmortem report, no such injury was found either on the stomach or in the abdominal region. PW-15, the doctor who had conducted the postmortem examination, deposed in his cross-examination that the weapons used in the offence i.e. knives and katar were not shown to him. Further PW-15 stated in his cross-examination that all the injuries from injury No. 1 to injury No. 8 could well be inflicted by only one weapon as the injuries were of the same nature. In this connection, reliance has been placed on the decision of this Court in Narendrasinh Keshubhai Zala Vs. State of Gujarat2.
7.5. High Court had rightly rejected the evidence of PW-2, PW-3, PW-4, PW-5 and PW-8 as their depositions did not inspire the confidence of the court. The aforesaid witnesses displayed unnatural conduct by not taking the deceased to the hospital when he was in an injured condition even after the assailants had left the place of occurrence. They did not rush to the police station either, though it was so nearby. Such conduct raises grave doubts about the presence of the aforesaid witnesses at the time of the incident.
8. Per Contra, learned counsel representing the respondent State submits that both the trial court as well as the High Court had carefully analysed the entire evidence on record and thereafter convicted the appellants under Sections 302/149 IPC. The impugned conviction and sentence do not suffer from any legal infirmity to warrant interference under Article 136 of the Constitution of India.
8.1. Learned counsel submits that PW-1 Faeem is an eyewitness to the incident. It is he who had lodged the FIR where he named the appellants as accused. FIR was lodged very promptly without the slightest delay.
8.2. There is complete consistency between the ocular evidence of PW-1 and the medical evidence. The ocular evidence of PW-1 clearly states that the appellants had given knife blows in the chest and in other parts of the body which were also indicated 2 2023 SCC OnLine SC 284 2108 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports in the postmortem report. Such sharp injuries caused the death of the deceased. The ocular evidence of PW-1 could not be shaken. He clearly pointed out the role played by the appellants in the murder of Ahsan Ali.
8.3. PW-15, the doctor who had conducted the postmortem examination, stated that the postmortem was conducted promptly. 8 incised wounds were found on the person of the deceased. The first 3 injuries were found on the abdomen, chest and lungs of the deceased. It has come on record that the said injuries were caused by sharp edged weapons.
8.4. In the circumstances, learned counsel for the State submits that there is no merit in the appeals and accordingly those are liable to be dismissed.
9. Submissions made by learned counsel for the parties have received the due consideration of the Court.
10. At the outset, it would be apposite to advert to the depositions of the material prosecution witnesses.
11. PW-1 is Faeem Ahmed. In his evidence in chief, he stated that on 25.06.1988 (sic), he and Ahsan had left Bhatghat at about 10:45 PM and reached the residence of the in-laws of Ahsan at Nayapura by motorcycle. There Ahsan talked with his brother-in-law Wahid. Ahsan had parked his motorcycle in front of the shop of his brotherin-law and was chatting with his friends who had come over there to meet him. At that time, the motorcycle of Sattar came there from the direction of the hospital. He knew the two persons who were sitting on it. They were Sattar and Wahid who were known to him. The two persons saw Ahsan and went away in the motorcycle. At that stage, PW-1 told Ahsan that they should go home now by a different route. However, Ahsan brushed aside such suggestion and went back through the same route. When they reached Ghantaghar at about 12:30 AM, Babu, Wahid, Sattar, Shakur, Aziz @ Patti, Bundu and Latur confronted them. They were armed with knives and katar. They attacked Ahsan. First blow by knife was given by Babu in the abdomen of Ahsan; second blow by knife was inflicted on the left side chest of Ahsan by Wahid; the third blow was given by Sattar with his katar hitting the back of Ahsan. Aziz and Shakur chased PW-1 with a knife. PW-1 ran into the street of Gauri Hotel. After sometime, Aziz [2025] 2 S.C.R. 2109Abdul Wahid & Anr. v. State of Rajasthan and Shakur stopped looking for PW-1 and went back to the place of incident where Ahsan was being assaulted.
11.1. According to PW-1, he came running to the police station and submitted a written report. He knew all the accused persons and identified them in court.
11.2. In his cross-examination, he stated that he was the brotherin-law of Ahsan’s elder brother. PW-1 also stated that he used to work as jeep driver of Ahsan. Besides, he used to manage all the labour employed by Ahsan in his contract works since Ahsan was a contractor. PW-1 and Ahsan had stayed in Ahsan’s in-laws’ place for about 20-25 minutes. He denied the suggestion that the motorcycle in which he and the deceased were travelling had lost balance and after colliding with a roadside pole, Ahsan fell down as a result of which they sustained injuries.
11.3. Elaborating further, he stated that the attack on him and the deceased started near the shops of Bisayeeti and Hindu Band, east of Garib Nawaj Hotel. The motorcycle did not fall over Ahsan because Ahsan was pulled down by the accused persons. PW-1 stated that he also fell down from the motorcycle and as he got up, he saw the accused assaulting Ahsan. When two of the accused persons charged towards him, he ran away. He saw Ahsan lying on the thade of Shakuntala Chemicals shop.
11.4. PW-1 denied in his cross-examination that he had any previous enmity with the accused persons. He went to the site of the assault with the Assistant Sub Inspector (ASI) who took the injured Ahsan to the hospital in an auto rikshaw while asking PW-1 to take the motorcycle to the police station.
11.5. PW-1 stated that he did not raise any alarm while the accused persons were assaulting Ahsan because they had warned that if anybody raised their voice, they would be killed. On further cross-examination, PW-1 stated that he knew Ahsan since his childhood days. He also knew the accused persons for about 8 to 10 years. The accused persons were having dispute with Ahsan since 7 days prior to the incident. In fact, Ahsan had told him that there could be a fight between the accused persons 2110 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports and him. Therefore, when he saw Wahid on a motorcycle, he apprehended about the possibility of assault and accordingly had warned Ahsan. However, he admitted that neither he nor Ahsan informed the police station about such a threat.
11.6. On further cross-examination, PW-1 stated that when the accused persons started assaulting Ahsan, there were about 100 persons in and around the place. They were accosted all of a sudden by the accused persons as a result of which their motorcycle fell down. No one from amongst the crowd came to rescue them. He defended his fleeing from the scene by stating that if he had tried to rescue Ahsan, he could also have been assaulted. He asserted that the first knife blow was given by accused Babu; the second one by accused Wahid on the chest; and the third blow by way of katar was given by Sattar. He stated that he had seen the accused persons assaulting Ahsan but he did not see which parts of the body of Ahsan had suffered injuries but the three injuries he referred to were inflicted by Babu, Wahid and Sattar immediately after Ahsan fell down from the motorcycle. He denied the suggestion that the public had brought Ahsan to the police station in a thela. He stated that Ahsan was taken to the hospital in an injured condition by the ASI. He admitted that he was presented as a witness in a case against Aziz @ Patti where he deposed in favour of the informant Babar Mushtaq. He denied the suggestion that police used to present him as a false witness in criminal cases. He admitted that there were 3/4 cases pending against him.
11.7. PW-1 reiterated that Babu had injured Ahsan first by knife injury which was followed by Wahid. Babu had stabbed Ahsan in his abdomen due to which Ahsan fell on the ground from the motorcycle.
12. PW-4 is Wahid who described himself as the brother-in-law of Ahsan. In his evidence-in-chief, he stated that Ahsan alongwith Faeem had come to his house in the night at about 11:00 to 11:15 PM. He talked with his jijajee (Ahsan) whereafter he (Ahsan) went back. Thereafter, he and his brother Jameel went to Ghantaghar by a motorcycle to have tea and paan masala. While at Ghantaghar, they heard the sound of an approaching motorcycle which was being driven by [2025] 2 S.C.R. 2111Abdul Wahid & Anr. v. State of Rajasthan Ahsan with Faeem sitting behind. It was about 12:00 to 12:15 hours. All of a sudden, he heard the voice of 8 to 9 persons shouting gher lo. He mentioned their names as Babu, Wahid, Sattar, Jaffar, Latur, Bundu and Aziz @ Patti. He also stated that there was one more person whom he identified in court as Shakur. According to him, first knife blow was given on the chest of Ahsan by Babu; second one on the chest by Wahid; Sattar gave blow of katar on the back of Ahsan whereafter they charged towards Faeem, who ran towards the street of Gauri Hotel. After sometime, they abandoned the chase, came back and started assaulting Ahsan again. They shouted that if ‘anybody comes forward, he will be killed’. PW-4 stated that it was for this reason, he hid himself. Thereafter, he came home to inform other relatives. From there, he came to the hospital but in the meanwhile, Ahsan had died.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.