Jitender @ Kalla v. State (Govt of NCT of Delhi) & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 249; [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1969
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Jj]
- Decided
- 20 Feb 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 865/2025
- Sections
- 340, 16, 30, 302, 16(2)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1969 : 2025 INSC 249 Jitender @ Kalla v.
State (Govt of NCT of Delhi) & Ors.
(Criminal Appeal No. 865 of 2025)
20 February 2025 [Abhay S. Oka* and Augustine George Masih, JJ] Issue for Consideration I. Whether the Supreme Court decisions in Indira Jaising v. Supreme Court of India (I) and (II), which lay down the guidelines for the designation of senior advocates, require reconsideration.
II. Whether an advocate on record is guilty of misconduct by merely lending his name to petition without further participation in the proceedings of the case.
Headnotes† The appellant was convicted and sentenced to thirty years of rigorous imprisonment without the right to seek remission until the sentence was complete, a punishment restored by the Supreme Court in an earlier judgment – The present Special Leave Petition (SLP) was filed by the appellant challenging a High Court order passed in a separate and unconnected case concerning another convict – While filing the SLP, the appellant suppressed the material fact that his sentence was for a fixed term of thirty years without remission, leading the Court to initially proceed on the footing of a simple life sentence – Application was filed by the informant pointing out the suppression of material fact – Apex court sought explanation from Shri Jaydeep Pati, AOR and Shri Rishi Malhotra, Advocate (later designated as Senior Advocate) and refer the issue of designation of Senior Advocate to Hon’ble Chief Justice of India to consider. [Paras 1-9, 44, 45] The decisions of this Court in the case of Indira Jaising-I and Indira Jaising-II, which lay down the guidelines for designation of senior advocates by this Court and High Courts across the country under the 1961 Act, need reconsideration – Our views * Author 1970 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports need to be placed before the Hon’ble Chief Justice of India to enable him to consider whether the issues decided in the two decisions in the case of Indira Jaising need reconsideration by a larger Bench:
Held: In Indira Jaising-I, this Court dealt with the challenge in a petition under Article 32 of the Constitution of India, inter alia, to the system of designation of senior advocates followed by various High Courts, including the method of secret ballot – This Court considered the practices followed in various other nations and various High Courts in India – Thereafter, this Court proceeded to lay down mandatory guidelines which would cover the exercise of designation of senior advocates by this Court and all the High Courts – A direction was given to modify the norms/guidelines in existence so as to be in accord with the directions – In Indira Jaising-II, this Court reconsidered some of the directions issued in Indira Jaising-I – This Court considered the issues of voting by secret ballot, cut-off marks, and points assigned for publication – This Court also considered the aspect of personal interview and other general aspects – The mandatory guidelines have been laid down by this Court in the case of Indira Jaising-I in the exercise of powers under Article 142 of the Constitution of India – However, paragraph 74 of the decision indicates that this Court was of the view that the guidelines may require reconsideration in the light of the experience to be gained over a period of time – Even the decision in the case of Indira Jaising-II in paragraph 51 records that the process of improvement of the guidelines is a continuous one, as we learn from every experience – We are conscious of the fact that both the decisions in the case of Indira Jaising are by a Bench of three Hon’ble Judges and we are respectfully bound by the said decisions – Neither can we disagree with the two binding decisions nor can we take a contrary view – However, all that we are doing is expressing a few serious doubts and concerns – We propose to direct that this issue be placed before the Hon’ble Chief Justice of India to consider whether the issue needs to be reconsidered by a Bench of appropriate strength – This exercise will be within the four corners of what is held by the Constitution Bench in the case of the Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community and Anr. there is one more reason why we are undertaking this exercise – Both the decisions lay down that making such modifications and improvements will be a continuous exercise – For the reasons we have recorded hereafter, our views need to be placed before the [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1971Jitender @ Kalla v. State (Govt of NCT of Delhi) & Ors. Hon’ble Chief Justice of India to enable him to consider whether the issues decided in the two decisions in the case of Indira Jaising need reconsideration by a larger Bench. [Paras 30, 33, 34, 36, 40] An advocate-on-record of this Court is bound to maintain a much higher standard of professional conduct than any other advocate – It is only through an advocate-on-record that a litigant can seek justice from this Court unless he wants to appear in person – Therefore, the role of an advocate-onrecord is very crucial – Unless he maintains a high standard of conduct, he will be of no assistance to this Court – The standard of conduct of an advocate-on-record always ought to be higher than the conduct of any other advocate who is not an advocate on record – Every advocate-on-record must render effective service so that a common man can access remedies before this Court – In case any advocate-on-record commits misconduct or is guilty of conduct unbecoming of an advocate-on-record, an action against him as per Rule 10 of Order IV is warranted:
Held: When a petition/appeal/counter-affidavit is not drafted by the advocate-on-record, the advocate-on-record who files it is entirely and wholly responsible to this Court – Therefore, when an advocateon-record receives a draft of a petition/appeal/counter-affidavits from any other advocate, it is his duty to go through the case papers and, thereafter, to carefully go through the petition/appeal/ counter-affidavits to ascertain whether correct facts have been stated in the draft and whether all relevant documents are annexed to the petition/appeal/counter-affidavits – After reading the case papers, if he has any doubt, he must get the doubt clarified either by contacting the client or his local advocate – He is responsible for ensuring that he gets correct factual instructions so that there is no suppression of facts while filing petitions/appeals/counteraffidavits – An advocate-on-record is answerable to this Court since he has a unique position under the 2013 Rules – Therefore, when incorrect facts are stated in the petition/appeal/counter-affidavits or when material facts or documents are suppressed, the advocateon-record cannot shift the entire blame on either the client or his instructing advocates – Therefore, it is his duty to be cautious and careful – If advocates-on-record start merely lending their names to petitions/appeals/counter-affidavits drafted by somebody else, the very purpose of setting up the institution of advocates on-record 1972 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports will be frustrated – The duty of the advocate-on-record does not end after filing a case or a counter – Even if the counsel appointed by him is not present, he must be ready with the case on law and facts and effectively assist the Court – If advocates-on-record start behaving irresponsibly and start merely lending their names while filing petitions/appeals/counter-affidavits, it may have a direct impact on the quality of justice rendered by this Court – Therefore, in case any advocate-on-record commits misconduct or is guilty of conduct unbecoming of an advocate-on-record, an action against him as per Rule 10 of Order IV is warranted. [Paras 22-25, 44] Case Law Cited Indira Jaising v. Supreme Court of India (I) [2017] 10 SCR 478 : (2017) 9 SCC 766; Indira Jaising v. Supreme Court of India (II) [2023] 5 SCR 434 : (2023) 8 SCC 1 – distinguished.
Jitendra @ Kalia v. State of Govt. of NCT of Delhi [2018] 12 SCR 622 : (2019) 13 SCC 691; Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community and Anr. v. State of Maharastra and Anr. [2004] Supp. 6 SCR 1054 : (2005) 2 SCC 673 – relied on.
Amar Vivek Aggrawal v. High Court of Punjab & Haryana and Ors. (2022) 7 SCC 439; Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agrawal & Ors., 2024 INSC 856 : [2024] 11 SCR 1647 – referred to. List of Acts Advocates Act 1961; Constitution of India; Supreme Court Rules, 2013.
List of Keywords Advocate on Record; Senior Advocate; Advocate; Convict; Duty; Conduct.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
865 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 08.01.2024 of the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in WPCRL No. 72 of 2024 With Writ Petition (Crl.) No. 418 of 2024 [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1973Jitender @ Kalla v. State (Govt of NCT of Delhi) & Ors. Appearances for Parties Dr. S. Muralidhar, Amicus Curiae/Sr. Adv., Prateek K Chadha, Ms. Ninni Susan Thomas, Ma Karthik, Maitreya Subramaniam, Ms. Pallak Bhagat, Sreekar Aechuri, Ms. Surbhi Soni, Aniket Chauhaan Advs. for the Appellant:
Vinay Navare, Sr. Adv., L.N. Rao, Aryan Rajpal, Shivek Vyas, Shri Bhagwan, Vikash Kumar Goswami, Ashish Pandey, Prem Malhotra, Jaydip Pati.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General, Suryaprakash V Raju, Mrs. Aishwarya Bhati, A.S.Gs., Mohan V Katarki, Sr. Adv., Mukesh Kumar Maroria, Chitransh Sharma, Annam Venkatesh, Jagdish Chandra Solanki, Zoheb Hussain, Ms. Soumya Tandon, Vivek Gurnani, Chitvan Singhal, Mrs. Astha Singh, Ms. Shagun Thakur, Prashant Bhushan, Pranav Sachdeva, Jatin Bhardwaj, Abhay Nair, Rohit Ram, Paras Nath Singh, Shaileshwar Yadav, Rohit Kumar, Ms. Bhumika Choksey, Shailendra Singh, Ms. Radhika Mahopatra, Antariksh Singh, Anilendra Pandey, Varun Thakur, Hemant Kumar Chaturvedi, Rajeev Kumar Ranjan, Ms. Priya Kashyap, Vipin Nair, Mohd Aman Alam, Mrs. M.B.Ramya, Aditya Narendranath, Mrs. Madhavi Yadav, Ahanthem Henry, Ahanthem Rohen Singh, Mohan Singh, Aniket Rajput, Ms. Khoisnam Nirmala Devi, Kumar Mihir, Vipin Nair, President, SCAORA, Amit Sharma, Vice-President, SCAORA, Nikhil Jain, Secretary, SCAORA.
Ms. Indira Jaising, Petitioner-in-person/Sr. Adv.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Order Abhay S. Oka, J.
CRIMINAL APPEAL @ S.L.P. (Crl) No.4299 of 2024
1. Leave granted.
2. Very important issues arise in the appeal. The first issue is about the conduct of the advocate-on-record who filed the Special Leave Petition (for short, ‘SLP’) out of which the present appeal arises. The second 1974 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports issue concerns the conduct of the advocate who appeared in this case as a counsel and was later designated as a senior advocate. Two consequential issues arise. The first consequential issue is about the need to formulate a code of conduct for the advocates-on-record. The second one is whether the decisions of this Court in the case of Indira Jaising v Supreme Court of India 1 (hereafter referred to as ‘Indira Jaising-I’) and Indira Singh v Supreme Court of India2 (hereafter referred as ‘Indira Jaising-II’) need reconsideration. The question of taking action against the appellant for making false statements will be considered in a separate IA on which a notice has been issued.
FACTUAL ASPECTS
3. First, we are setting out a few factual aspects. The trial court convicted the appellant for the offences punishable under Sections 302 and 307 of the Indian Penal Code (for short, ‘the IPC’) by the judgment dated 1st July 2013. He was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for life with a direction that his case for a grant of remission shall not be considered until he undergoes a sentence of thirty years. The appellant preferred an appeal before the High Court. While confirming the conviction, the High Court was of the view that the punishment imposed on the appellant was excessive and modified the same by removing the cap of thirty years. The appellant was let off on a sentence of 16 years, 10 months already undergone. By the judgment dated 25 th October 2018, in Jitendra @ Kalla v. State of Govt. of NCT of Delhi3 , this Court interfered with the view taken by the High Court and restored the order of sentence of the trial court. This Court held that the appellant’s sentence shall be thirty years of rigorous imprisonment and that the appellant shall have no right to seek remission till he completes the full sentence of thirty years.
4. The present appeal was filed to challenge the judgment dated 8th January 2024 passed by the Delhi High Court in a petition filed by one Rani, who was sentenced to undergo life imprisonment in an unconnected case. The petitioner therein applied for premature release. As the application was not considered, a prayer was made in
1 (2017) 9 SCC 766
2 (2023) 8 SCC 1
3 (2019) 13 SCC 691
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1975Jitender @ Kalla v. State (Govt of NCT of Delhi) & Ors. the Writ Petition before the High Court seeking a writ of mandamus, directing the 1 st respondent – State Government, to consider her case for premature release under the Government Policy dated 16 th July 2004. A copy of the order dated 30th June 2023 was placed on record by which the prayer of the petitioner in the said writ petition before the High Court was rejected by the State Government. The High Court, while setting aside the order dated 30th June 2023, directed reconsideration of the petitioner–Rani’s case and granted her time of two months to surrender.
5. Though the present appellant was not a party to the petition in which the impugned order was passed, strangely, he challenged the said order. It is an admitted position that while filing the SLP, which is the subject matter of this criminal appeal, the appellant did not disclose that he was directed to undergo imprisonment for thirty years without remission. Therefore, this Court proceeded on the footing that it was a case of a simple life sentence.
6. On 19 th March 2024, Shri Rishi Malhotra, advocate, and Shri Jaydip Pati, advocate-on-record, appeared. Along with the present appeal, other SLPs were listed. Therefore, there was a common order passed directing notice to be issued returnable on 19 th April 2024. In the meanwhile, since the present appellant was on furlough, an exemption was granted to the present appellant from surrendering. The order dated 19th March 2024 reads thus:
“Applications seeking exemption from filing a certified copy of the impugned order are allowed. Applications seeking permission to file the Special Leave Petitions are allowed. Issue notice, returnable on 19th April, 2024.
Liberty is granted to serve the Standing Counsel for the respondent-State, in addition.
To be heard along with SLP (Crl.) No.3497/2024 (@ Diary No.9321/2024).
In the meantime, as the petitioners are on furlough, we grant exemption to them from surrendering.”
7. We may note here that on 29 th April 2024, IA No.105306 of 2024 and IA No.104520 of 2024 were filed for intervention and recall of 1976 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the order dated 19 th March 2024, respectively. The applications were made by the 1 st informant in the case. In the application, it was pointed out that there was suppression of material facts about the fixed-term sentence of thirty years imposed on the appellant. Another fact pointed out was that the appellant had not approached the High Court and he had directly approached the Supreme Court by purportedly challenging the order passed in a writ petition filed by some other accused. After the said applications were served on the appellant, on 9 th May 2024, the advocate-on-record for the appellant mentioned the case at 10.30 a.m. and prayed for permission to withdraw the SLP. He had not intimated the advocate for the applicant that the matter would be mentioned for withdrawal. Therefore, while disposing of all the interim applications, this Court permitted the withdrawal of the SLP with liberty to the appellant to file appropriate proceedings before the High Court. Order dated 9 th May 2024 reads thus:
“SLP [CRL.] NO.4299/2024 Taken on Board. Heard learned counsel appearing for the petitioner.
The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner is not aware whether the application made by the petitioner for grant of permanent remission has been rejected. The remedy of the petitioner is to file appropriate proceedings before the High Court. Hence, we dispose of this Special Leave Petition by granting liberty to the petitioner to file appropriate proceedings before the High Court.
If the petitioner is already released on furlough and he has not yet surrendered, we grant time of three weeks to the petitioner to surrender, which will enable him to file appropriate proceedings before the High Court.
Applications for impleadment as well as for intervention are disposed of.
Pending applications stand disposed of accordingly.”
8. The fact that the application for intervention was pending was not brought to the notice of this Court. Therefore, the advocate for the applicant mentioned the matter on 17th May 2024 and pointed out [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1977Jitender @ Kalla v. State (Govt of NCT of Delhi) & Ors. that without notice to him or his client, Miscellaneous Application No. 986 of 2024 was mentioned in the morning session and that this Court permitted the petitioner to withdraw the SLP out of which the appeal arises. Therefore, notice was issued on the said application to the appellant. By order dated 17 th May 2024, the order permitting withdrawal of SLP was stayed.
9. On 11th July 2024, though this SLP was called out on two occasions, none appeared for the petitioner. This Court passed an order directing that the Registry shall issue an intimation to the advocate-on-record, calling upon the advocate-on-record to remain present on the next date. On 14th August 2024, Miscellaneous Application No.986 of 2024 seeking impleadment of the complainant as a party respondent was allowed. This Court allowed IA No.104520 of 2024 seeking recall of the order dated 19 th March 2024 to the extent of prayer in clause (a). This Court noted that the petitioner in the writ petition had already surrendered. Thereafter, an order was passed on 2 nd September 2024, which reads thus:
“We have perused the Special Leave Petition and the annexures to the Application for Intervention.
The Trial Court convicted the petitioner and sentenced him to undergo actual sentence of 30 years. The High Court interfered with the said order. Thereafter, this Court by a decision in Jitendra Alias Kalla vs. State (Government of NCT of Delhi) 1 restored the judgment of the Trial Court by specifically observing that the petitioner will undergo life sentence for 30 years without remission. These facts were suppressed while filing this Special Leave Petition.
Moreover, the petitioner was not a party to the petition before the Delhi High Court on which the impugned order was passed. In the synopsis, there is a specific reference to an order of conviction. However, it is not disclosed that the order of sentence was for a fixed term of 30 years. Therefore, this is a very serious and gross case of material misrepresentation made while filing the Special Leave Petition. The Advocateon-Record for the petitioner, who filed this Special Leave Petition, owes an explanation to this Court.
Therefore, the Registry to issue notice to Shri Jaydip 1978 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Pati, Advocate-on-Record, which is made returnable on 30th September, 2024.
A copy of this order shall accompany the notice.
Shri Jaydip Pati, Advocate-on-Record, will explain his conduct by filing an affidavit.”
(emphasis added)
10. Pursuant to the order, Shri Jaydip Pati, advocate-on-record, filed an affidavit dated 9th September 2024. After considering the said affidavit on 30 th September 2024, this Court passed the following order: “Mr. Jaydip Pati, Advocate-on-Record has filed an affidavit pursuant to order passed by this Court. To say the least, the contents are shocking. We will elaborately deal with the stand taken by him at an appropriate stage. In view of what is stated in the affidavit, we issue notice to Shri Rishi Malhotra, learned Senior Advocate to appear before this Court for explaining what is stated in the affidavit filed by Mr. Jaydip Pati, Advocate-on-Record.
Registry to forward copies of all orders passed in the SLP/M.A. along with a copy of affidavit filed by Mr. Jaydip Pati, Advocate-on-Record to Mr. Rishi Malhotra, learned Senior Advocate. Notice made returnable on 21st October, 2024.
Considering what is stated in the affidavit by Mr. Jaydip Pati, Advocate-on-Record and considering the fact that in recent past, this Court has noticed that at least in half a dozen cases blatant false statements were being made in the writ petitions and Special Leave Petitions filed seeking relief of premature release, we will require assistance of the President of the Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association (SCAORA). We request the President, SCAORA to appear and assist the Court on the next date of hearing. Copies of all the orders passed by this Court and a copy of affidavit of Mr. Jaydip Pati, Advocate-on-Record be forwarded to the President of SCAORA.”
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1979Jitender @ Kalla v. State (Govt of NCT of Delhi) & Ors.
11. In terms of the said order, Shri Rishi Malhotra, advocate (who was designated as a senior advocate on 14 th August 2024), filed an affidavit dated 18 th October 2024. The order dated 21 st October 2024 reads thus:
“We have perused the affidavit of Mr. Rishi Malhotra, the learned senior counsel. Ms. Meenakshi Arora, the learned senior counsel representing him states that a better affidavit will be filed.
We permit Mr. Rishi Malhotra, the learned senior counsel to withdraw his affidavit and to file a better affidavit. This case raises issues of great concern, insofar as the responsibility of Advocates-on Record of this Court is concerned. Apart from the dispute between a senior and his junior, as is reflected from the affidavits filed on record, the issue of concern is of the conduct of the Advocate-on- Record, especially in the light of explanation (a) to Rule 10 of Order IV of the Supreme Court Rules, 2013. A very important role has been assigned to Advocates-on-Record, as no litigant can seek redressal of his grievance before this Court without engaging an Advocate-on-Record. It is, therefore, necessary to consider of framing guidelines for the conduct of the Advocates-on-Record.
The learned President of the Supreme Court Advocateson-Record Association and the other Office Bearers are present and they have agreed to assist the Court on this aspect.
For assisting the Court for framing the guidelines, we appoint Dr. S. Murlidhar, senior advocate as Amicus Curiae. It will be open for him to appoint an Advocate-on-Record of his choice to assist him.
Copies of the entire proceedings including the affidavits on record shall be forwarded to the learned Amicus Curiae. It will be appropriate if the Office Bearers of the Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association interact with the learned Amicus Curiae so that they will be able to come out with agreed guidelines.
List on 11th November, 2024.”
1980 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Thereafter, another affidavit dated 30 th November 2024 was filed by Shri Rishi Malhotra tendering an unconditional apology.
12. Orders passed from time to time by this Court will show that the following aspects need consideration:
a) The role played by Shri Jaydip Pati, advocate-on-record; b) The role played by Shri Rishi Malhotra, senior advocate; and, c) The role of the appellant.
As far as the role of the appellant is concerned, we may note here that IA No.259649 of 2024 has been filed by an intervener for initiating proceedings under Section 340 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short, ‘CrPC’) on which notice has been issued on 20th January 2025 and the said application has been de-tagged. Therefore, the issue of the conduct of the appellant will be examined when we consider the said application.
13. The conduct of the advocate-on-record gives rise to the issue regarding the duties and obligations of advocates-on-record and guidelines for their conduct. On this aspect, we have heard Dr S Murlidhar, learned senior counsel appearing as amicus curiae, Shri Vipin Nair, President of the Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association (for short, ‘SCAORA’) and Vice-President and Secretary Shri Amit Sharma and Shri Nikhil Jain respectively. We have also heard Shri Tushar Mehta, learned Solicitor General of India and lastly, Shri Vinay Navare, senior advocate representing Shri Rishi Malhotra, senior advocate.
14. The second aspect about the conduct of Shri Rishi Malhotra, senior advocate, gives rise to a contention raised by Shri Tushar Mehta, learned Solicitor General of India, appearing for Union of India, for reconsideration of earlier decisions of this Court in Indira Jaising-I1 and Indira Jaisingh-II2 and another decision in the case of Amar Vivek Aggarwal v. High Court of Punjab & Haryana and Ors.4 On these issues raised by the learned Solicitor General of India, we have also heard Ms. Indira Jaising, a senior advocate who has intervened.
4 (2022) 7 SCC 439
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1981Jitender @ Kalla v. State (Govt of NCT of Delhi) & Ors.
CONDUCT OF THE ADVOCATE ON RECORD AND HIS SENIOR
15. Firstly, we will deal with the issue of the conduct of the advocate-onrecord for the appellant and the consequential question of issuing guidelines on the conduct of advocates-on-record. Before we do that, we must consider the stand taken by Shri Jaydip Pati, advocate-onrecord, in his affidavit dated 9th September 2024, filed in compliance with the order of this Court dated 2nd September 2024. The stand taken in the affidavit by Shri Jaydip Pati can be summarised as follows: a) Shri Rishi Malhotra, the then advocate-on-record drafted eight SLPs including the present SLP, and he asked Shri Jaydip Pati to sign on those petitions as an advocate-on-record;
b) Shri Jaydip Pati never doubted the bona fides of Shri Rishi Malhotra. As he was working with Shri Rishi Malhotra as his junior, he could not refuse to sign the petitions and vakalatnama as an advocate-on-record;
c) Only after this Court issued a notice he learnt that the chamber of Shri Rishi Malhotra, while drafting the present petition, concealed the fact that this Court, in the case of Jitendra @ Kalla 3, had restored the fixed-term sentence of the appellant herein, for thirty years; and, d) He never imagined that Shri Rishi Malhotra, in his capacity as a chamber senior, would exploit the situation by filing cases through him while concealing material facts.
Thus, Shri Jaydip Pati stated that he filed the SLP drafted by Shri Rishi Malhotra as an advocate-on-record without even bothering to read the same.
16. Shri Rishi Malhotra filed an affidavit dated 18 th October 2024, raising the following contentions:
a) This Court appointed him as an amicus curiae in two cases in which the issue of permanent remission of convicts was involved; b) He must have filed cases on behalf of more than two hundred convicts seeking their premature release;
c) Due to increased workload and paucity of time, he shared his workload with different chamber juniors, including Shri Jaydip Pati and Shri Utkarsh Singh;
1982 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports d) He gave certain cases to Shri Jaydip Pati to file for the purpose of giving him financial benefit, and accordingly, he must have drafted at least nine cases which were filed before this Court; e) There is no complaint made by Shri Jaydip Pati regarding other cases which were given to him and he has not stated that he signed those petitions without checking the contents;
f) Shri Jaydip Pati filed the cases given to him as per client’s instructions, and the drafts of the SLPs made by Shri Pati were neither shown to him, nor discussed with him;
g) Coming to know about other cases filed by him where convicts had not fulfilled the eligibility criteria for premature release, he himself filed applications seeking withdrawal of such applications with an unconditional apology as an assurance that he would be extra careful in future matters; and, h) The recent turn of events has affected his mental health and has brought a lot of humiliation and embarrassment to him; therefore, he has stopped taking any new remission cases.
17. Shri Rishi Malhotra then filed an application, which was affirmed on 30th November 2024, seeking permission to withdraw his earlier affidavit dated 14th November 2024. In this application, he has made a turnaround and has entirely changed his earlier stand. After he was permitted to withdraw the affidavit dated 14 th November 2024, Shri Rishi Malhotra filed a fresh affidavit dated 30 th November 2024. In the said affidavit, Shri Rishi Malhotra has claimed that he is a fourth-generation lawyer. What he stated in the affidavit can be summarised as follows:
a) He tendered an unconditional apology to this Court by accepting that he should have verified the SLP drafted by his chamber colleague to ensure that there were no incorrect statements. It was his moral and professional duty to oversee the work of his chamber juniors, and he was negligent in that behalf;
b) Wherever he had made wrong statements regarding the eligibility of the convicts to get a premature release, he has withdrawn all those petitions by tendering an apology;
c) He claimed that such misrepresentation by some of the Delhi convicts has occurred for the first time in his entire legal career for which he expressed regret and tendered an apology; and, [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1983Jitender @ Kalla v. State (Govt of NCT of Delhi) & Ors. d) He stated that he had tendered an unconditional apology for stating incorrect facts in the petitions. He assured the Court that such incidents would not be repeated in the future.
18. Shri Rishi Malhotra has accepted that he should have verified the facts stated in the SLP filed by Shri Jaydip Pati. He has accepted that he was not diligent and has tendered an apology. He admitted that he has made factually incorrect statements in the petitions filed by him concerning the grant of remission, and after realising it, he has withdrawn the petitions.
DUTY OF AN ADVOCATE-ON-RECORD
19. It is necessary to examine the legal provisions. Firstly, we will deal with the provisions of the Advocates Act, 1961 (for short, ‘the 1961 Act’). Under Section 16, there are two classes of advocates, namely, senior advocates and other advocates. Sections 29 and 30 are also important, which read thus:
“29. Advocates to be the only recognised class of persons entitled to practise law.—Subject to the provisions of this Act and any rules made thereunder, there shall, as from the appointed day, be only one class of persons entitled to practise the profession of law, namely, advocates.
30. Right of advocates to practise.—Subject to the provisions of this Act, every advocate whose name is entered in the [State roll] shall be entitled as of right to practise throughout the territories to which this Act extends,—
(i) in all courts including the Supreme Court;
(ii) before any tribunal or person legally authorised to take evidence; and
(iii) before any other authority or person before whom such advocate is by or under any law for the time being in force entitled to practise.”
Thus, every advocate within the meaning of the 1961 Act is entitled to practice in all courts throughout the territories to which the 1961 Act extends, including this Court. An exception has been carved 1984 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports out to Section 30 under the Supreme Court Rules, 2013 (for short, ‘the 2013 Rules’), framed by this Court in the exercise of powers under Article 145 of the Constitution of India, with the approval of the President of India. Order IV thereof deals with advocates. Rule 1 of Order IV carves out an exception. Rule 1 reads thus: “1. (a) Subject to the provisions of these rules an advocate whose name is entered on the roll of any State Bar Council maintained under the Advocates Act, 1961 (25 of 1961)
as amended shall be entitled to appear before the Court: Provided that an advocate whose name is entered on the roll of any State Bar Council maintained under the Advocates Act, 1961 (25 of 1961), for less than one year, shall be entitled to mention matters in Court for the limited purpose of asking for time, date, adjournment and similar such orders, but shall not be entitled to address the Court for the purpose of any effective hearing:
Provided further that the Court may, if it thinks desirable to do so for any reason, permit any person to appear and address the Court in a particular case.
(b) No advocate other than the Advocate-on-record for a party shall appear, plead and address the Court in a matter unless he is instructed by the advocateon-record or permitted by the Court.
(c) In petitions/appeals received from jail or a matter filed by a party-in-person or where a party-in-person as respondent is not represented by an Advocate-on-Record, the Secretary General/Registrar may require the Supreme Court Legal Services Committee to assign an Advocate, who may assist the Court on behalf of such person:
Provided that whenever a party wants to appear and argue the case in person, he/she shall first file an application along with the petition seeking permission to appear and argue in person. The application shall indicate reasons as to why he/she cannot engage an Advocate and wants to appear and argue in person, and if he is willing to accept an Advocate, who can be appointed for him by [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1985Jitender @ Kalla v. State (Govt of NCT of Delhi) & Ors. the Court. Such application shall, in the first instance, be placed before the concerned Registrar to interact with the party-in-person and give opinion by way of office report whether the party-in-person will be able to give necessary assistance to the Court for proper disposal of the matter or an Advocate may be appointed as Amicus Curiae:
Provided further that whenever an advocate whose name is entered on the rolls of any State Bar Council maintained under the Advocates Act, 1961 (25 of 1961) wants to appear and argue the case in person, he shall be exempted from the requirement of interaction by the concerned Registrar. If the application is allowed by the Court then only the party-in-person will be permitted to appear and argue the case in person.”
(emphasis added)
Therefore, as far as this Court is concerned, an advocate other than an advocate-on-record for a party is entitled to appear, plead or address a case only if he is instructed by an advocate-on-record. Rule 5 of Order IV lays down the qualifications of an advocate to be registered as an advocate-on-record. Rules 7 and 10 of Order IV are again relevant, which read thus:
“7. (a) An advocate-on-record shall, on his filing a memorandum of appearance on behalf of a party accompanied by a vakalatnama duly executed by the party, be entitled—
(i) to act as well as to plead for the party in the matter and to conduct and prosecute before the Court all proceedings that may be taken in respect of the said matter or any application connected with the same or any decree or order passed therein including proceedings in taxation and applications for review; and
(ii) to deposit and receive money on behalf of the said party. (b)(i) Where the vakalatnama is executed in the presence of the Advocate-on-Record, he shall certify that it was executed in his presence.
1986 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(ii) Where the Advocate-on-Record merely accepts the vakalatnama which is already duly executed in the presence of a Notary or an advocate, he shall make an endorsement thereon that he has satisfied himself about the due execution of the vakalatnama.
(c) No advocate other than an advocate-on-record shall be entitled to file an appearance or act for a party in the Court.
(d) Every advocate-on-record shall keep such books of account as may be necessary to show and distinguish in connection with his practice as an advocate-on-record—
(i) moneys received from or on account of and the moneys paid to or on account of each of his clients; and
(ii) the moneys received and the moneys paid on his own account.
(e) Every advocate-on-record shall, before taxation of the Bill of Costs, file with the Taxing Officer a certificate showing the amount of fee paid to him or agreed to be paid to him by his client.
10. When, on the complaint of any person or otherwise, the Court is of the opinion that an advocate-onrecord has been guilty of misconduct or of conduct unbecoming of an advocate-on-record, the Court may make an order removing his name from the register of advocates on record either permanently or for such period as the Court may think fit and the Registrar shall thereupon report the said fact to the Bar Council of India and to State Bar Council concerned:
Provided that the Court shall, before making such order, issue to such advocate-on-record a summons returnable before the Court or before a Special Bench to be constituted by the Chief Justice, requiring the advocate-on-record to show cause against the matters alleged in the summons, and the summons shall, if practicable, be served personally upon him with copies of any affidavit or statement before the Court at the time of the issue of the summons.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1987Jitender @ Kalla v. State (Govt of NCT of Delhi) & Ors. Explanation.—For the purpose of these rules, misconduct or conduct unbecoming of an advocateon-record shall include—
(a) mere name lending by an advocate-on-record without any further participation in the proceedings of the case;
(b) absence of the advocate-on-record from the Court without any justifiable cause when the case is taken up for hearing; and
(c) failure to submit appearance slip duly signed by the advocate-on-record of actual appearances in the Court.” (emphasis added)
20. An occasion for an advocate-on-record to file a memorandum of appearance accompanied by a vakalatnama, arises when he files a case in this Court or when he appears for a respondent or opponent in any case. If a vakalatnama is not duly executed before the advocate-on-record but executed in the presence of a notary or another advocate, the advocate-on-record must, before filing the vakalatnama, make an endorsement thereon that he has satisfied himself about the due execution of the vakalatnama. Therefore, if someone else hands over the vakalatnama to an advocate-on-record, the requirement of making an endorsement, as provided in clause (a)(ii) of Rule 7, is mandatory. This endorsement cannot be made blindly but must be based on due verification and confirmation. This responsibility is put on the advocates-on-record to uphold the integrity of the process.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.