Sovaran Singh Prajapati v. The State of Uttar Pradesh
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 225; [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1890
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sanjay Karol, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 4 Feb 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 259/2019
- Sections
- 313, 311, 302, 1, 201, 357, 209
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1890 : 2025 INSC 225 Sovaran Singh Prajapati v.
The State of Uttar Pradesh (Criminal Appeal No(s). 259-260 of 2019)
04 February 2025 [Vikram Nath, Sanjay Karol* and Sandeep Mehta, JJ.] Issue for Consideration a. Whether the Trial Court followed the basic requirements of a fairly conducted trial, in accordance with well-established prepositions of law, before imposing death sentence upon the Appellant/Accused?
b. Whether the High Court was correct in confirming the death sentence imposed by the Trial Court?
Headnotes† Constitutional of India – Art.21 – Fair Trial – Article 21 of the Constitution of India – To secure a fair trial is not solitary responsibility:
Held: Fair and impartial administration of justice is a treasured right protected by various enactments of law including, first and foremost, the Constitution, which under Article 21 guarantees the Right to Fair Trial – Fair and just investigation is the starting point of the fair trial process – The process is a triangulation of the rights of the accused, the victim, and the community – The process of investigation must be completed with promptitude – The Trial Court Judge must play an active role in the search for the truth, which a trial, undoubtedly must be – Bias of all nature must be eliminated – Fair trial is to be done to maintain public confidence and uphold the majesty of law – Unfair prolongation of trial is an affront to the ideal of fair trial – Fair trial is a basic human right – The main purpose of fair trial is to ensure that injustice is avoided as far as possible, but equally ‘fair trial’ is not leveraged to a point which would hinder the established procedure of CrPC – In other words, the command of the Code cannot be ignored at the behest of the prosecution or defence, in the name of fair trial – The responsibility to secure fair trial is not solitary, and lies upon the * Author [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1891Sovaran Singh Prajapati v. The State of Uttar Pradesh judge, the investigator, the investigating agency, and counsels for either side. [Paras 10, 11] Duty of the Trial Court – Not to be Mechanical –Court must actively seek out the truth:
Held: Trial Court should be an active participant to seek out the truth in a given set of circumstances to ensure that a balance is struck between the role and responsibility of prosecution as also the rights of the accused – The Court’s duty is not to merely record evidence by overlooking the object of the trial i.e. to extract the truth – The Trial Court ought to have observed and halted the proceedings, given the absence of the counsel for the defence at crucial stages of the trial; absence of adequate opportunity to examine and cross-examine the defence witnesses; and the improper, inadequate and incomplete examination of the accused under Section 313 CrPC – The course adopted by the Trial Court was mechanical and in complete ignorance of the rights of the accused and objective of the trial. [Paras 15, 15.2, 16] Appointment of Amicus Curiae – Standing of Amicus and role to be played by Amicus needs to be indicated by Trial Court in its Orders:
Held: Trial Court must indicate the standing of the person appointed as Amicus Curiae. Trial Court should also indicate the role played by the Amicus in the Trial — Whether the Amicus was appointed to assist the Court or was he appointed to aid the representation of the accused? Such indications enable the Appellate Court to gain a full view of the matter, including being able to ascertain compliance of essential aspects such as continuous and qualitative legal assistance of the accused. [Para 17] Duty of the Appellate Court – Capital Punishment Cases – Heightened Responsibility:
Held: An Appellate Court has to appreciate the evidence on record, after duly summoning the record of the Courts below, and then arrive at its own finding, irrespective of the order under challenge before it being of conviction or acquittal – In Capital Punishment cases, where a person’s life hangs in the balance, the High Court’s responsibility is heightened, and it must carefully examine all relevant and material circumstances before upholding the conviction and confirming the death sentence. [Paras 18, 19] 1892 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Duty of the Prosecutor – Examine all possible angles – Collect all relevant evidence:
Held: In a criminal trial, unless the law otherwise requires, the onus of proof never shifts, and always lies upon the Prosecution – The job of the prosecution is to drive home the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt, but at the same time, the prosecutor cannot forget that his first and foremost duty is that of an officer of the Court – The prosecuting agency has a responsibility to examine all possible angles, collect all relevant evidence and then produce the same before the Court for determination of guilt or lack thereof – The prosecutor in the present case seemed to have missed his duty as an officer of the Court by failing to bring to the notice of the Court that the circumstances of change of counsel; belated appointment of Amicus Curiae / defence counsel; closure of opportunity to cross-examine; recording of evidence in the absence of defence counsel contravened the principle of a fair trial. [Paras 20, 21] Purpose of Cross-Examination – Kartar Singh v. State of Punjab, (1994) 3 SCC 569 relied upon:
Held: In Kartar Singh v. State of Punjab, (1994) 3 SCC 569, the Supreme Court highlighted that the purpose of cross-examination is to: a) call into question the credibly the evidentiary value of the witness; b) bring out such facts that may favour the cross-examining lawyer’s client; and c) to establish the said witness is unworthy of belief and that his credit stands impeached. [Para 26] Section 311 CrPC – Applicability of – Explained:
Held: The power of the Court under Section 311 CrPC is couched in the widest terms possible with no express limitation thereon – The Section is divided into two parts — The first part being directory and the second part mandatory – It is not only the prerogative but also the duty of the Court to summon and examine a witness who is absolutely necessary in the interest of justice – The power is to be exercised judiciously, both for the benefit of the prosecution and the defence, and could be exercised at any stage of the proceedings – This power under Section 311 is not to be exercised to fill up a lacuna in the case of the prosecution – If a witness so called gives evidence against the complainant, the latter should be given an opportunity to cross-examine, a right arising not [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1893Sovaran Singh Prajapati v. The State of Uttar Pradesh under Section 311, but under the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 – The order rejecting the application to recall witnesses records that the application under Section 311 was rejected and that defence evidence would be allowed only if the witness was produced on the next date – Such a summary rejection is unjustified, and the application should have been allowed. [Paras 30, 30.1, 32] Examination – Section 313 CrPC – Application of, explained – Raj Kumar v. State (NCT of Delhi), 2023 SCC OnLine SC 609 and Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v. State of Maharashtra (1973)
2 SCC 793:
Held: The principles governing Section 313 CrPC, as summarised in Raj Kumar v. State (NCT of Delhi), 2023 SCC OnLine SC 609 and in Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v. State of Maharashtra, (1973) 2 SCC 793, state that it is the duty of the Trial Court to put each material circumstance appearing in the evidence against the accused specifically, distinctively and separately – The object of examination under section 313 CrPC is to enable the accused to explain any circumstance appearing against him in the evidence – Failure to put material circumstances amounts to a serious irregularity and may vitiate the trial if it causes prejudice – Where such irregularity is curable, the appellate court can question the accused on the material circumstance not earlier put, or the case can be remanded to the Trial Court for recording a supplementary statement – While deciding if prejudice is caused, delay in raising the contention is only one of several factors to be considered – In the present case, factors summarised in Raj Kumar were not followed – All incriminating circumstances were not put to the accused and general, sweeping questions were employed, which were only denied – It is incumbent upon the prosecutor to aid the Court in preparing questions to be put to the accused – It has been held in Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade (supra) that prejudice can be caused if the statements are not properly recorded – There is adequate possibility that the appellant has been prejudiced. [Paras 32, 32.2] International Law – Fairness in criminal procedure: Held: The Universal Declaration of human Rights, 1948 records guarantee for fairness in criminal procedure in articles 10 and 11 – Article 14 of the International Covenant for Civil and Political Rights, 1996 which was ratified by India in 1979, guarantees equality 1894 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports to all persons before the law – The rights of the accused under article 67 of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court entitle the accused to basic protections under the law, even in the cases of gravest and most heinous crimes. [Paras 33, 33.1, 33.2] Case Law Cited Vinubhai Haribhai Malaviya v. State of Gujarat [2019] 15 SCR 936 : (2019) 17 SCC 1; Zahira Habibulla H. Sheikh v. State of Gujarat [2004] 3 SCR 1050 : (2004) 4 SCC 158; Sidhartha Vashisht v. State (NCT of Delhi) [2010] 4 SCR 103 : (2010) 6 SCC 1; J. Jayalalithaa v. State of Karnataka [2013] 17 SCR 759 : (2014) 2 SCC 401; Asha Ranjan v. State of Bihar [2017] 1 SCR 945 : (2017) 4 SCC 397; State of Haryana v. Ram Meher [2016] 5 SCR 172 : (2016) 8 SCC 762; Raj Kumar v. State (NCT of Delhi) [2023] 5 SCR 754 : 2023 SCC OnLine SC 609; Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v. State of Maharashtra [1974] 1 SCR 489 : (1973) 2 SCC 793; Jamatraj Kewalji Govani v. State of Maharashtra [1967] 3 SCR 415 : 1967 SCC OnLine SC 19; Rajendra Prasad v. Narcotic Cell [1999] 3 SCR 818 : (1999) 6 SCC 110; Vijay Kumar v. State of U.P. [2011] 11 SCR 893 : (2011) 8 SCC 136; Natasha Singh v. CBI [2013] 5 SCR 539 : (2013) 5 SCC 741; Rajaram Prasad Yadav v. State of Bihar [2013] 7 SCR 420 : (2013) 14 SCC 461; State v. N. Seenivasagan [2021] 2 SCR 529 : (2021) 14 SCC 1; Satbir Singh v. State of Haryana [2023] 11 SCR 723 : 2023 SCC OnLine 1086 – relied on. Pooja Pal v. Union of India [2016] 11 SCR 560 : (2016) 3 SCC 135; Bablu Kumar v. State of Bihar [2015] 8 SCR 512 : (2015) 8 SCC 787; Lalu Prasad v. State of Jharkhand [2013] 8 SCR 163 : (2013) 8 SCC 593; Wilayat Khan v. State of U.P. (1951) SCC 898; Atley v. State of U.P., AIR 1955 SC 807; Harijana Thirupala v. Public Prosecutor [2002] Supp. 1 SCR 379 : (2002) 6 SCC 470; Ravasaheb v. State of Karnataka [2023] 2 SCR 965 : (2023) 5 SCC 391; Masalti v. State of U.P. [1964] 8 SCR 133 : AIR 1965 SC 202; Charan Singh & Ors. v. State of Punjab [1975] 1 SCR 561 : (1975) 3 SCC 39; Arjun Marik & Ors. v. State of Bihar [1994] 2 SCR 265 : (1994) Supp. 2 SCC 372; Ashok v. State of Uttar Pradesh [2024] 12 SCR 335 : 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3580; Shiv Kumar v. Hukam Chand [1999] Supp. 2 SCR 81 : (1999) 7 SCC 467; Harendra Rai v. State of Bihar [2023] 11 SCR 403 : (2023) 13 SCC 563; Anees v. State (NCT of Delhi) [2024] 6 SCR 164 : 2024 SCC OnLine SC 757; State of Punjab v. Baldev Singh [1999] [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1895Sovaran Singh Prajapati v. The State of Uttar Pradesh 3 SCR 977 : (1999) 6 SCC 172; Chaluvegowda & Ors. v. State (2012) 13 SCC 538; Brijesh Kumar v. State of U.P. [2021] 2 SCR 995 : (2021) 19 SCC 177; M.H. Hoskot v. State of Maharashtra [1979] 1 SCR 192 : (1978) 3 SCC 544; Suk Das v. Union Territory of Arunachal Pradesh [1986] 1 SCR 590 : (1986) 2 SCC 401; Suhas Chakma v. Union of India [2024] 10 SCR 1769 : 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3031; Ramanand @ Nandlal Bharti v. State of U.P. [2022] 5 SCR 162 : 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1396; Shaik Mukhtar & Anr. v. The State of Andhra Pradesh now State of Telangana, Supreme Court decision in Criminal Appeal No. 1753 of 2019; Anokhilal v. State of M.P. [2019] 18 SCR 1196 : (2019) 20 SCC 196; Ekene Godwin v. State of T.N., 2024 SCC OnLine SC 337; Kartar Singh v. State of Punjab [1994] 2 SCR 375 : (1994) 3 SCC 569; Bashira v. State of U.P. [1969] 1 SCR 32 : 1968 SCC OnLine SC 84 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited American Jurisprudence 2nd Ed. 2007 – referred to.
List of Websites https://www.ohchr.org/en/instruments-mechanisms/instruments/ international-covenant-civil-and-political-rights; https://www.icc-cpi. int/about/the-court List of Acts Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Penal Code, 1860. List of Keywords Capital Punishment; Rights of the accused; Fair Trial; Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948; International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, 1966.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No(s). 259-260 of 2019 From the Judgment and Order dated 01.10.2018 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in CC No. 2611 of 2017 and REF No. 05 of 2017 1896 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Appearances for Parties Rajiv Shakdhar, Sr. Adv., Aditya Verma, Ms. Shreya Rastogi, Ms. Aathma Sudhir Kumar, Ms. Sakshi Jain, Karan Khetani, Jonathan Ivan Rajan, K Rigved Prasad, Samar Singh, Ms. Parkhi Rai, Mangesh Naik, Advs. for the Appellant.
Divyesh Pratap Singh, Shashank Shekhar Singh, Ajay Singh, Abhinav Singh, Harshvardhan Visen Mall, Advs. for the Respondent. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Order Sanjay Karol, J
1. These appeals arise out of judgment and order dated 1 st October 2018 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in Capital Case No.2611 of 2017 and Reference No.05 of 2017. The impugned judgment of the High Court confirmed the judgment of conviction dated 28 th February 2017, and the sentence of capital punishment imposed vide judgment dated 1st March 2017 upon the appellant by the Additional Sessions Judge, Mainpuri in Sessions Trial No.377/2014, titled State v. Sovaran Singh, under Sections 302 and 201 of Indian Penal Code 1860 1 .
FACTS AND PREVIOUS PROCEEDINGS
2. Brief Facts, as allegedly set out by the prosecution, are that in the intervening night of 29 th - 30 th of June 2014, the appellant returned home in an inebriated state, also carrying two bottles of liquor which he then consumed along with his father. Sometime later, a quarrel ensued between them which led to the appellant slapping his father, who was, as a result, injured in his ear. Thereafter, he demanded money from his wife Mamta to procure more liquor which she denied. As such he trashed, abused and eventually killed her. He also killed his daughter Sapna who was twelve years old. Resultantly, FIR No.128 of 2014 was registered under Section 302 IPC at P.S. 1 for short ‘IPC 1860’ [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1897Sovaran Singh Prajapati v. The State of Uttar Pradesh Karhal, District Mainpuri. With the completion of the investigation, challan was presented in the Trial Court and the appellant herein was put to trial.
3. Post-Mortem conducted by Dr. Rajesh Kumar Mishra (PW-3), found the following injuries on both the deceased persons, as recorded by the High Court in the impugned judgment:
“4. P.W. 3 Dr. Rajesh Kumar Mishra conducted post-mortem on dead body of Mamta on 30.6.2014 at 4.25 PM. On external examination, Doctor found her slim and weak with 146 cm height and 39.700 Kg in weight. Rigor mortis found present in lower segment of body; eyes were half closed, mouth open, nail in-tact and bleeding from nose and ear was noticed. P.W. 3 found following ante mortem injuries on her person:
"1. Abrasion 3 cm x 2 cm on right side forehead, 1 cm above eye brow, blackening present
2. Abrasion 3 cm x 4 cm just below right eye, blackening present.
3. Abrasion 5 cm x 4 cm on left side of left eye, blackening present. 4. Blood through nose and both ears.
5. Abrasion 6 cm x 3 cm on right side of neck, 1 cm below right mandible.
6. Abrasion 3 cm x 2 cm over anterior aspect of right shoulder, blackening present.
7. Abrasion 5 cm x 3 cm on right side of chest, 5 cm below left nipple.
8. Lacerated wound 5 cm x 3 cm on left side of vagina, exposing uterus and bladder.”
5. On internal examination, right eye was black; lips were swollen and black in colour; tongue inside mouth; ecchymosis present in neck muscles; hyoid left corner fractured; weight of right lung 340 gm (Pale) and left 320 gm; both chambers of heart empty; blood present in 1898 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports peritonial cavity; stomach contained about 150 gm semi digested food matter; small intestine contained semi digested food particles and large intestine contained faecal matter and gases; liver was lacerated 5 cm and pale; spleen weighed 150 gm and pale; kidneys-pale, right kidney weighed 150 gm and left 130 gm, urinary bladder and urethra were ruptured. In the opinion of Doctor, about one day has passed since the death. Cause of death was due to acute haemorrhagic shock as a result of ante mortem injuries, causing internal bleeding. Postmortem report prepared by P.W. 3 is Ex. Ka. 2.
6. The same Doctor, P.W. 3 examined dead body of deceased Sapna at about 04:40 PM on 30.06.2014.
According to him, deceased was aged about 12 years, 22.400 kg in weight. Rigor mortis was present; eyes and mouth closed and lips swollen. He found following ante mortem injuries on her person.
“1. Face and fore head swollen, right black eye.
2. Abrasion 6 cm x 4 cm on right side of face, 2 cm anterior to right ear.
3. Lips swollen and teeth mark laceration in inner side of lips.
4. Abrasion 5 cm x 3 cm on left side of face anterior to left eye.
5. Abrasion 1 cm x 1 cm on anterior aspect of left fore arm, 3 cm above wrist joint, bluish.
6. Abrasion 1 cm x 1 cm on posterior aspect of base of index finger (II Metacarpo-phallangeal joint), bluish.
7. Lateral fold of vagina wide open, mens (menstrual) and labia swollen, vagina congested and lacerated, particularly some sticky wheatish substance present, slide prepared.
8. Abrasion 2 cm x 1 cm on anterior lateral aspect of right knee, bluish coloured.”
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1899Sovaran Singh Prajapati v. The State of Uttar Pradesh
7. On internal examination, brain was found congested with 1.100 kg in weight and haematoma was present;
bleeding found from nose and left ear; right lung weighed 300 gm and was congested and left lung weighed 250 gm; left side heart was empty and right side was full; stomach contained 200 gm semi solid food content, mucous normal, no foul smell; small intestine contained semi digested food material and large intestine had faecal matter and gases and liver was congested. In the opinion of doctor, death had occurred due to head injury/ante-mortem injuries. P.W. 3 had prepared post-mortem report Ex. Ka-3.”
4. The Trial Court considered the arguments of both the parties and eventually held that the prosecution had proved its case beyond reasonable doubt and as such, convicted the appellant of having committed a double murder. On the point of sentence, the matter was put up the following day, i.e., on 1st March 2017 and, having considered a host of judicial pronouncements, evaluating the aggravating and mitigating circumstances, the sentence of death by hanging was imposed qua Section 302 IPC and seven-year imprisonment for the offence punishable under Section 201 IPC.
5. On appeal, the High Court confirmed the sentence of death imposed by the Trial Court, accounting for all the attending aggravating and mitigating circumstances.
6. We have heard learned counsel for the parties, Mr. Rajiv Shakdher, learned Senior Counsel for the appellant and Mr. Divyesh Pratap Singh for the State. At the outset, it was clarified by the learned Senior counsel that under assail was the finding of conviction as also the sentence. In taking us through the record, numerous lapses have been pointed out, which go to the root of the matter, calling into question credibly, the justiciability of the conviction as well as the sentence imposed on the appellant.
Purpose of Trial
7. It is important to restate the purpose of trial. A trial, of course, is a fact-finding exercise wherein both parties, i.e., the prosecution and defence, after investigation by the competent authorities, present their versions of events and the role and duty of the Court to determine the truth. While undertaking such determination, the Court is not only 1900 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports to look at the evidence at hand but also ensure that all consideration balances the demand for justice and the rights of the accused. The American Jurisprudence 2 nd Ed. 2007, in the following terms, captures the purpose of a trial:
“The purpose of trial is to determine the validity of the allegations. The objective is to secure a fair and impartial administration of justice between the parties to the litigation and not the achievement of a hearing wholly free from errors. Once a civil action has been instituted and issue is joined upon the pleadings, there must be a trial on the issue before a judgment may be rendered. Trial is not a contest between lawyers but a presentation of facts to which the law may be applied to resolve the issues between the parties and to determine their rights. It is also not a sport; it is an inquiry into the truth, in which the general public has an interest.”
8. The statutory mechanism regarding a trial before a Court of Session is provided in the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 2 , under Chapter XVIII. The process and mode of taking and recording evidence have been provided for in Chapter XXIII. Chapter XXIV details the general provisions qua inquiries and trials. Herein, also provided is, the duty of the Court, in certain cases, to provide the person standing trial before it, with legal aid at the expense of the State. Also relevant here is Chapter XXVIII, which lays down the procedure for submission of a death sentence awarded by a Court of Session to the High Court for confirmation.
9. This case raises questions of compliance with various basic requirements of a fairly conducted trial, in accordance with wellestablished prepositions of law.
Fair Trial - A Guarantee under Article 21 of the Constitution of India
10. Fair and impartial administration of justice is a treasured right protected by various enactments of law including, first and foremost, the Constitution, which under Article 21 guarantees the Right to Fair 2 Abbreviated as Cr. P.C.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1901Sovaran Singh Prajapati v. The State of Uttar Pradesh Trial. In numerous pronouncements, this Court has underscored the same.
10.1 A Three-Judge Bench of this Court in Vinubhai Haribhai Malaviya v. State of Gujarat3, held as under:
“17. Article 21 of the Constitution of India makes it clear that the procedure in criminal trials must, after the seminal decision in Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India [Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India, (1978) 1 SCC 248] , be “right, just and fair and not arbitrary, fanciful or oppressive” (see para 7 therein). Equally, in Commr. of Police v. Delhi High Court [Commr.
of Police v. Delhi High Court, (1996) 6 SCC 323 :
1996 SCC (Cri) 1325] , it was stated that Article 21 enshrines and guarantees the precious right of life and personal liberty to a person which can only be deprived on following the procedure established by law in a fair trial which assures the safety of the accused. The assurance of a fair trial is stated to be the first imperative of the dispensation of justice (see para 16 therein).
18. It is clear that a fair trial must kick off only after an investigation is itself fair and just. The ultimate aim of all investigation and inquiry, whether by the police or by the Magistrate, is to ensure that those who have actually committed a crime are correctly booked, and those who have not are not arraigned to stand trial. That this is the minimal procedural requirement that is the fundamental requirement of Article 21 of the Constitution of India cannot be doubted. It is the hovering omnipresence of Article 21 over CrPC that must needs inform the interpretation of all the provisions of CrPC, so as to ensure that Article 21 is followed both in letter and in spirit.” (Emphasis supplied)
3 (2019) 17 SCC 1
1902 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 10.2 In the well-known ‘Best Bakery Case’ titled Zahira Habibulla H. Sheikh v. State of Gujarat4 , the Court, detailing various aspects of fair trial, observed as under:
“35. This Court has often emphasised that in a criminal case the fate of the proceedings cannot always be left entirely in the hands of the parties, crimes being public wrongs in breach and violation of public rights and duties, which affect the whole community as a community and are harmful to the society in general. The concept of fair trial entails familiar triangulation of interests of the accused, the victim and the society and it is the community that acts through the State and prosecuting agencies. Interests of society are not to be treated completely with disdain and as persona non grata. Courts have always been considered to have an overriding duty to maintain public confidence in the administration of justice — often referred to as the duty to vindicate and uphold the “majesty of the law”. Due administration of justice has always been viewed as a continuous process, not confined to determination of the particular case, protecting its ability to function as a court of law in the future as in the case before it. If a criminal court is to be an effective instrument in dispensing justice, the Presiding Judge must cease to be a spectator and a mere recording machine by becoming a participant in the trial evincing intelligence, active interest and elicit all relevant materials necessary for reaching the correct conclusion, to find out the truth, and administer justice with fairness and impartiality both to the parties and to the community it serves. Courts administering criminal justice cannot turn a blind eye to vexatious or oppressive conduct that has occurred in relation to proceedings, even if a fair trial is still possible, except at the risk of undermining the fair name and standing of the judges as impartial and independent adjudicators.
4 (2004) 4 SCC 158
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1903Sovaran Singh Prajapati v. The State of Uttar Pradesh
36. The principles of rule of law and due process are closely linked with human rights protection.
Such rights can be protected effectively when a citizen has recourse to the courts of law. It has to be unmistakably understood that a trial which is primarily aimed at ascertaining the truth has to be fair to all concerned. There can be no analytical, all-comprehensive or exhaustive definition of the concept of a fair trial, and it may have to be determined in seemingly infinite variety of actual situations with the ultimate object in mind viz.
whether something that was done or said either before or at the trial deprived the quality of fairness to a degree where a miscarriage of justice has resulted. It will not be correct to say that it is only the accused who must be fairly dealt with. That would be turning a Nelson’s eye to the needs of the society at large and the victims or their family members and relatives. Each one has an inbuilt right to be dealt with fairly in a criminal trial. Denial of a fair trial is as much injustice to the accused as is to the victim and the society. Fair trial obviously would mean a trial before an impartial judge, a fair prosecutor and atmosphere of judicial calm. Fair trial means a trial in which bias or prejudice for or against the accused, the witnesses, or the cause which is being tried is eliminated. If the witnesses get threatened or are forced to give false evidence that also would not result in a fair trial. The failure to hear material witnesses is certainly denial of fair trial. xxx
38. A criminal trial is a judicial examination of the issues in the case and its purpose is to arrive at a judgment on an issue as to a fact or relevant facts which may lead to the discovery of the fact issue and obtain proof of such facts at which the prosecution and the accused have arrived by their pleadings; the controlling question being the guilt 1904 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports or innocence of the accused. Since the object is to mete out justice and to convict the guilty and protect the innocent, the trial should be a search for the truth and not a bout over technicalities, and must be conducted under such rules as will protect the innocent, and punish the guilty. The proof of charge which has to be beyond reasonable doubt must depend upon judicial evaluation of the totality of the evidence, oral and circumstantial, and not by an isolated scrutiny.”
(Emphasis supplied)
10.3 In Sidhartha Vashisht v. State (NCT of Delhi)5 , this Court observed :
“197. In the Indian criminal jurisprudence, the accused is placed in a somewhat advantageous position than under different jurisprudence of some of the countries in the world. The criminal justice administration system in India places human rights and dignity for human life at a much higher pedestal. In our jurisprudence an accused is presumed to be innocent till proved guilty, the alleged accused is entitled to fairness and true investigation and fair trial and the prosecution is expected to play balanced role in the trial of a crime. The investigation should be judicious, fair, transparent and expeditious to ensure compliance with the basic rule of law.
These are the fundamental canons of our criminal jurisprudence and they are quite in conformity with the constitutional mandate contained in Articles 20 and 21 of the Constitution of India.”
(Emphasis supplied)
10.4 Observations in J. Jayalalithaa v. State of Karnataka6 , are important for our purposes. The relevant extracts are :
5 (2010) 6 SCC 1
6 (2014) 2 SCC 401
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1905Sovaran Singh Prajapati v. The State of Uttar Pradesh “28. Fair trial is the main object of criminal procedure and such fairness should not be hampered or threatened in any manner. Fair trial entails the interests of the accused, the victim and of the society. Thus, fair trial must be accorded to every accused in the spirit of the right to life and personal liberty and the accused must get a free and fair, just and reasonable trial on the charge imputed in a criminal case. Any breach or violation of public rights and duties adversely affects the community as a whole and it becomes harmful to the society in general. In all circumstances, the courts have a duty to maintain public confidence in the administration of justice and such duty is to vindicate and uphold the “majesty of the law” and the courts cannot turn a blind eye to vexatious or oppressive conduct that occurs in relation to criminal proceedings.
29. Denial of a fair trial is as much injustice to the accused as is to the victim and the society. It necessarily requires a trial before an impartial Judge, a fair prosecutor and an atmosphere of judicial calm. Since the object of the trial is to mete out justice and to convict the guilty and protect the innocent, the trial should be a search for the truth and not a bout over technicalities and must be conducted under such rules as will protect the innocent and punish the guilty. Justice should not only be done but should be seem to have been done. Therefore, free and fair trial is a sine qua non of Article 21 of the Constitution. Right to get a fair trial is not only a basic fundamental right but a human right also. Therefore, any hindrance in a fair trial could be violative of Article 14 of the Constitution. “No trial can be allowed to prolong indefinitely due to the lethargy of the prosecuting agency or the State machinery and that is the raison d’être in prescribing the time frame” for conclusion of the trial.
30. Article 12 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights provides for the right to a fair trial what is enshrined in Article 21 of our Constitution. Therefore, 1906 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports fair trial is the heart of criminal jurisprudence and, in a way, an important facet of a democratic polity and is governed by the rule of law. Denial of fair trial is crucifixion of human rights…”
(Emphasis supplied)
10.5 This Court in Asha Ranjan v. State of Bihar7 , written by Dipak Misra J., (as his Lordship then was) referring to State of Haryana v. Ram Meher8 , summarized the conclusions drawn in the latter, as under :
“51. … Simultaneously, the concept of fair trial cannot be allowed to such an extent so that the systemic order of conducting a trial in accordance with Criminal Procedure Code or other enactments get mortgaged to the whims and fancies of the defence or the prosecution. The command of the Code cannot be thrown to the winds. In such situation, as has been laid down in many an authority, the courts have significantly an eminent role. A plea of fair trial cannot be acquiesced to create an organic disorder in the system. It cannot be acceded to manure a fertile mind to usher in the nemesis of the concept of trial as such. The Court further observed that there should not be any inference that the fair trial should not be kept on its own pedestal as it ought to remain but as far as its applicability is concerned, the party invoking it has to establish with the support of established principles. The process of the court cannot be abused in the name of fair trial at the drop of a hat, as that would lead to miscarriage of justice.” (Emphasis supplied)
10.6 From a studied analysis of the above decisions, the following principles as to the meaning and import of fair trial, can be illustratively deduced :
7 (2017) 4 SCC 397
8 (2016) 8 SCC 762
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1907Sovaran Singh Prajapati v. The State of Uttar Pradesh
(1) Fair and Just investigation is the starting point of the fair trial process.
(2) This process is a triangulation of the rights of the accused, the victim and the community that acts through the state and prosecuting agencies.
(3) Process of investigation and trial must be completed with promptitude.
(4) The trial Judge has to play an active role in the search for truth, which a trial, undoubtedly has to be.
(5) Bias of all nature, against the accused, the victim, the witnesses; or the cause of/at trial, has to be eliminated.
(6) The process of fair trial is to be done to maintain public confidence & uphold the majesty of law.
(7) The atmosphere in which a trial is to be conducted in a fair manner has to be in an atmosphere of ‘judicial calm’.
(8) Unfair prolongation of trial is an affront to the ideal of fair trial.
(9) The ideal of fair trial has protection in the Constitution and in the international legal framework, as a basic human right.
(10) The centripodal purpose of fair trial is to ensure that injustice is avoided as far as possible, but equally ‘fair trial’ is not leveraged to a point which would hinder the established procedure of Cr.P.C. In other words, the command of the Code cannot be ignored at the behest of the prosecution or defence, in the name of fair trial.
11. As is evident from the principles enunciated above, to secure a fair trial, is not a solitary responsibility. The Judge; the investigator; the investigating agency; and the counsel for either side, each have their own responsibility.
12. An inspection of the records of this case, reveals that on many points each of the constituents responsible for a fair trial have in 1908 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports some way or another abdicated their responsibility. Some of the points that we noticed:
(a) At the time of examination of the star witness of the prosecution (PW-2), counsel of the defence was absent.
(b) The statement of the accused under Section 313 of Cr.P.C. was improperly recorded without all scenarios and circumstances being put to him.
(c) The initial charge under Section 302 IPC against the appellant was framed on 22 nd December 2014 and then, an additional charge was framed under Section 201 IPC on 27th August 2016. The delay of a year and a half in adding a charge against the appellant is entirely unexplained.
(d) The Legal Aid Counsel provided to the appellant was not only appointed at a belated stage but also changed more than once during the course of trial.
(e) The application under Section 311 Cr.P.C., while true, is a power which has to be exercised judiciously, was rejected summarily and without assigning any reason.
(f) On 21 st February 2017, the defence counsel was changed and, yet, on the same day, the defence evidence was closed on account of non-production of witness.
(g) The accused being a person of considerably less means, did not have access to an independent counsel/counsel of his own choice. As such, he was entirely dependent on the counsel appointed for him by the Court. The assistance given by such counsel on account of being not present and changes/ substitutions is rendered doubtful.
13. At this juncture, we deem it appropriate to refer to certain orders, recorded by the Trial Court in its daily status report, are as under: Order dated 1st September 2015 reads as under:
“01.09.2015- Case called out. Accused Sobran Singh present from jail in judiciary custody. Statement of PW-1 Rajnesh Kumar recorded. But Accused Counsil not appeared for cross examination. The opportunity of cross examinations is closed at 3.35 [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1909Sovaran Singh Prajapati v. The State of Uttar Pradesh P.M. fix 17.09.2015 for remaining evidence. Summon witnesses.
(A.S.J./F.T.C.)”
(Emphasis supplied)
Order dated 8th June 2016 is extracted below :
“08.06.2016- Case called out. Accused Sobran Singh present from jail in judicial custody. Evidence of Pw-2 Km. Poonam recorded. But Accused counsil not appeared for cross examination. Accused filed 18-B application for providing Government Counsel and Sri Veer Pal Singh Rathor appointed as Amicus Curie in this case as per list in the office. He be informed accordingly. Fixed 24.06.2016 for cross examination on PW-2. Advocate be informed accordingly.
(A.S.J./F.T.C.)”
(Emphasis supplied)
Order dated 10 th June 2016 is extracted below :
“10.06.2016- Put up today. Accused counsel filled application 19-B for strucking off the name from the list of Amicus Curie and to appoint any other Advocate. According to the order passed on the application ‘File taken up today on application of Ld. Amicus Curie appointed on 08.06.2016. As he has shown his in avaiablety to conduct the case, Sri Naresh Chand Dixit is appointed as Amicus Curie as per list. He be informed accordingly.
(A.S.J./F.T.C.)”
Order dated 25 th July 2016 is extracted below :
“25.7.2016- Case called out. Accused Sobran Singh present from jail in judicial custody. A.D.G.C. (Criminal) moved application No. 25 A for framing charge under Section 201 I.P.C agaisnt the accused. Fixed 29.07.2016 for hearing of 25-A.
(A.S.J./F.T.C.)”
1910 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Order dated 27 th August 2016 is extracted below :
“27.8.2016- Case called out. Accused Sobran Singh present from jail in judicial custody. charge framed against the accused Under Section 201 I.P.C. Charge Read over and explationed before the accused.
Accused denied the charge and claimed for trial.
Fixed 03.09.2016 for remaining evidence. summon witnesses.
(ASJ 1 st )”
Order dated 1 st February 2017 is extracted below : “01.02.2017- Case called out. Accused Sobran Singh present from jail in judicial custody. Statement of witness S.I. Sri Om Veer Singh has been recorded as PW-6. Cross Examination of witness has been done by Defence counsel. Application No. 32-B filled by the defence counsel for summoning PW-1 and PW-2 for cross examination. Objected by A.D.G.C.
And endorsed that no prosecution evidences to be recorded. Strongly opposed by defence counsel.
Fixed 04.02.2017 for statement Under Section 313 Cr.P.C. And hearing of 32-B application.
(A.S.J. 1st )”
Order dated 4 th February 2017 is extracted below : “04.02.2017- Case called out. Accused Sobran Singh present from jail in judicial custody. Statement of accused Sobran Singh has been recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C. Fixed on 08.02.2017 for defence argument.
(A.S.J. 1st )”
Order dated 18 th February 2017 is extracted below : “18.02.2017- Case called out accused present in J.C. But not present. Counsel present heared on application 32-B brief order is passed on the [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1911Sovaran Singh Prajapati v. The State of Uttar Pradesh application. After lunch at 02:30 P.M. an application for time to adduce defence witness 35-B moved by defence counsel. Order passed on the application as “Vide order of even date today, application u/s 311 moved by Ld. counsel has been rejected. He sought time to adduce arguments which was granted. After which, he has moved application for providing defence evidence. if the Ld. Counsel produce the witness on the date fixed he will be examined failing which matter will be posted for Judgment after hearing the argument of prosecution.”
(A.S.J. 1st )”
Order dated 21 st February 2017 is extracted below: “21.02.2017- Case called out. Accused person is present in Judicial Custody. An application 36-B moved by the Ld. counsel for accused as per order passed on the application “Application is rejected. As apportunity has already been given”
At 12:00 P.M. present Sri Dalveer Yadav newly appoint counsel for the accused. He states that no witness no present. D.E. Closed as on last date it was ordered that if Ld. producees the witness on the date fixed he will be examined failing which argument will be recorded.
Argument of prosecution recorded. Part argument of defence also recorded. Put up after lunch for remaining argument of Ld. defence counsel.
03:00 P.M. Present Ld. Counsel for defence.
Arguments concluded. Put up for Judgment on 28.02.2017 for judgment.”
Order dated 28 th February 2017 is extracted below : “28.02.2018 9 - Case called out. Accused in presented in Judicial Custody from the evidence on record, 9 It should be 2017 but is mentioned as 2018 in the Convenience Compilation 1912 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports I found that the prosecution has proved the case against the accused beyond reasonable doubt both u/s 302 IPC and 201 IPC.
Accused has guilty and putup on 01.03.2017 for the point of sentence.
(A.S.J. 1st )”
Order dated 1 st March 2017 is extracted below :
“01.03.2017- Case called out. Accused person present in Judicial custody order passed on separate sheet 37-A.
Order Convict Sobran Singh sentence to death for offence punishable u/s 302 IPC accordingly the convict be hanged by neck till he is death. Fine of Rs. 20,000/- to the convict is also imposed in default of payment of fine, the convict shall undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of two months.
Convict Sobran Singh is further sentenced to seven years rigorous imprisonment and fine of Rs. 5,000/u/s 201 IPC in default of payment of fine rigorous imprisonment for two month to the convict. Out of the realized Rs. 20,000/- will be paid to the family of the deceased.
A copy of this order be sent to the Secretary, Legal Service Authority, Mainpuri for deciding the quantum of compensation to be awarded under the scheme refereed to in sub-section 1 of section 357-A Cr.P.C. (A.S.J. 1st )”
14. In this context, it is essential to delve into the responsibilities cast on each unit.
(a) Duty of the Trial Court
15. On numerous occasions, this Court has highlighted the duty of a Trial Court to be an active participant to seek out the truth in a given set [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1913Sovaran Singh Prajapati v. The State of Uttar Pradesh of circumstances ensuring that a balance is struck between the role and responsibility of prosecution as also the rights of the accused. It would be helpful to refer to certain pronouncements: 15.1 This Court in Pooja Pal v. Union of India10 , observed : “54…It was remarked as well that due administration of justice is always viewed as a continuous process, not confined to the determination of a particular case so much so that a court must cease to be a mute spectator and a mere recording machine but become a participant in the trial evincing intelligence and active interest and elicit all relevant materials necessary for reaching the correct conclusion, to find out the truth and administer justice with fairness and impartiality both to the parties and to the community…”
15.2 Reference may once again be made to the Best Bakery Case (supra), where in regard to the role of a Court, it was held : “55. The courts, at the expense of repetition we may state, exist for doing justice to the persons who are affected. The trial/first appellate courts cannot get swayed by abstract technicalities and close their eyes to factors which need to be positively probed and noticed. The court is not merely to act as a tape recorder recording evidence, overlooking the object of trial i.e. to get at the truth. It cannot be oblivious to the active role to be played for which there is not only ample scope, but sufficient powers conferred under the Code. It has a greater duty and responsibility i.e. to render justice, in a case where the role of the prosecuting agency itself is put in issue and is said to be hand in glove with the accused, parading a mock fight and making a mockery of the criminal justice administration itself.” (Emphasis supplied)
10 (2016) 3 SCC 135
1914 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 15.3 In Bablu Kumar v. State of Bihar11 , this Court observed : “22. Keeping in view the concept of fair trial, the obligation of the prosecution, the interest of the community and the duty of the court, it can irrefragably be stated that the court cannot be a silent spectator or a mute observer when it presides over a trial. It is the duty of the court to see that neither the prosecution nor the accused play truancy with the criminal trial or corrode the sanctity of the proceeding. They cannot expropriate or hijack the community interest by conducting themselves in such a manner as a consequence of which the trial becomes a farcical one. The law does not countenance a “mock trial”. It is a serious concern of society. Every member of the collective has an inherent interest in such a trial. No one can be allowed to create a dent in the same. The court is duty-bound to see that neither the prosecution nor the defence takes unnecessary adjournments and take the trial under their control. The court is under the legal obligation to see that the witnesses who have been cited by the prosecution are produced by it or if summons are issued, they are actually served on the witnesses. If the court is of the opinion that the material witnesses have not been examined, it should not allow the prosecution to close the evidence. There can be no doubt that the prosecution may not examine all the material witnesses but that does not necessarily mean that the prosecution can choose not to examine any witness and convey to the court that it does not intend to cite the witnesses.”
(Emphasis supplied)
16. In the present facts, the Court ought to have been the first one to observe and halt proceedings, given that counsel for the defence was absent on crucial occasions such as the examination-in-chief and crossexamination of PW-1; statement of PW-2 also was recorded in the absence of counsel for the accused; no adequate opportunity was given
11 (2015) 8 SCC 787
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1915Sovaran Singh Prajapati v. The State of Uttar Pradesh to produce and examine defence witnesses; and the examination of the accused under Section 313 was improper, inadequate and incomplete. The course of action adopted by the Court was mechanical and in complete ignorance of the rights of the accused and the overarching purpose of a trial. It is true that the Court had provided an opportunity for the defence to produce a witness but at the same time a condition was put that if on the said date the witness is not produced, the opportunity would be closed. This approach is in ignorance of the ground realities of production of a witness, and to the detriment of the accused. The Court cannot be said to have done its part.
17. We must also observe that in this case, the daily status of the Trial Court extracted supra, reveals that that the Court appointed both an Amicus Curiae and a legal aid counsel for the accused. There is no quarrel on that point. The same is permissible. [See: Lalu Prasad v. State of Jharkhand12 and Shaik Mukhtar & Anr. v. The State of Andhra Pradesh now State of Telangana13 ] However, we are constrained to record that the appointment of the Amicus Curiae in a manner of this magnitude is in ignorance thereof for the case papers are silent as to the standing of the said person appointed to such a position. What was the role played by him? Was he appointed to assist the Court or was he appointed to aid the representation of the accused? Such matters should be clearly indicated to enable the Appellate Court to gain a full view of the matter including being able to ascertain compliance of essential aspects such as continuous and qualitative legal assistance to the accused.
(b) Duty of the Appellate Court
18. In the context of the duty of the Court, we must also look to the role played by the Court when sitting in appellate and/or confirmation jurisdiction. It has long been held that a Court in first appellate jurisdiction, has to appreciate the evidence on record, after duly summoning the record of the Courts below, and then arrive at its own finding, irrespective of the order under challenge before it being of conviction or acquittal. [See: Wilayat Khan v. State of U.P. 14 ;
12 (2013) 8 SCC 593
13 Criminal Appeal No. 1753 of 2019
14 (1951) SCC 898
1916 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Atley v. State of U.P15 ; Harijana Thirupala v. Public Prosecutor16 ; and Ravasaheb v. State of Karnataka17 ]
19. When particularly concerned with cases of Capital Punishment, naturally, since a person’s life hangs in the balance, the High Court’s responsibility is accordingly enhanced/heightened. It “must carefully examine all relevant and material circumstances before upholding the conviction and confirming the sentence of death.” [See: Masalti v. State of U.P.18 ; Charan Singh & Ors. v. State of Punjab19 ; and Arjun Marik & Ors. v. State of Bihar20 ]
(b) Duty of Prosecutor
20. In a criminal trial, unless the law otherwise requires, the onus of proof never shifts. It is always on the prosecution. The job of the prosecution is to drive home the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt, but at the same time, the prosecutor cannot forget that his first and foremost duty is, that of an officer of the Court. The prosecuting agency carries the role, primarily, till the time the matter enters the Court. They have a responsibility to examine all possible angles, collect all relevant evidence and then produce the same before the Court for determination of guilt or lack thereof. The following extracts of judgments underscore the indispensable role of the prosecutor. 20.1 In Bablu Kumar (supra), it was held that :
“The Public Prosecutor who conducts the trial has a statutory duty to perform. He cannot afford to take things in a light manner. The court also is not expected to accept the version of the prosecution as if it is sacred. It has to apply its mind on every occasion. Non-application of mind by the trial court has the potentiality to lead to the paralysis of the conception of fair trial.”
(Emphasis supplied)
15 AIR 1955 SC 807
16 (2002) 6 SCC 470
17 (2023) 5 SCC 391
18 AIR 1965 SC 202
19 (1975) 3 SCC 39
20 (1994) Supp. 2 SCC 372 [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1917Sovaran Singh Prajapati v. The State of Uttar Pradesh 20.2 Recently, a Three-Judge Bench of this Court in Ashok v. State of Uttar Pradesh21 issued directions regarding the role of public prosecutors and appointments of counsel through legal aid processes, this Court held :
“23. Our conclusions and directions regarding the role of the Public Prosecutor and appointment of legal aid lawyers are as follows:
a. It is the duty of the Court to ensure that proper legal aid is provided to an accused;
b. When an accused is not represented by an advocate, it is the duty of every Public Prosecutor to point out to the Court the requirement of providing him free legal aid. The reason is that it is the duty of the Public Prosecutor to ensure that the trial is conducted fairly and lawfully;
c. Even if the Court is inclined to frame charges or record examination-in-chief of the prosecution witnesses in a case where the accused has not engaged any advocate, it is incumbent upon the Public Prosecutor to request the Court not to proceed without offering legal aid to the accused;
c. It is the duty of the Public Prosecutor to assist the Trial Court in recording the statement of the accused under Section 313 of the CrPC. If the Court omits to put any material circumstance brought on record against the accused, the Public Prosecutor must bring it to the notice of the Court while the examination of the accused is being recorded. He must assist the Court in framing the questions to be put to the accused. As it is the duty of the Public Prosecutor to ensure that those who are guilty of the commission of offence must be punished, it is also his duty to ensure that there are no infirmities in the conduct of the trial which will cause prejudice to the accused;
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.