Ramesh A. Naika v. The Registrar General, High Court of Karnataka Etc.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 303; [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1721
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sanjay Karol, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 13 Feb 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 877-878/2020
- Sections
- 302, 366(1), 313, 300, 65, 235(2), 506, 195A, 507
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1721 : 2025 INSC 303 Ramesh A. Naika v.
The Registrar General, High Court of Karnataka Etc.
(Criminal Appeal No(s). 877-878 of 2020)
13 February 2025 [Vikram Nath, Sanjay Karol* and Sandeep Mehta, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Appellant-R, a bank manager, was convicted of murdering his two minor children, along with his sister-in-law and mother-inlaw, in June 2010. His motive stemmed from disapproval of his sister-in-law’s relationship, which his wife and her family supported. On 16.06.2010, he allegedly killed his sister-in-law and mother-inlaw at his house in Tumkur and disposed of their bodies in a sump tank. The next day, he took his children to a water tank in Mangalore and drowned them. He later sent messages to his wife, suggesting she end her life. His wife reported the matter, leading to his arrest. The Trial Court sentenced him to death. It was held by the Trial Court that the circumstances did indeed point to the guilt of the appellant and that the defence could not point to any alternative hypothesis to establish his innocence. He was in the company of the deceased children and none else, hence the application of the last seen theory - he had to explain that since they were with him, and a short time later they were found to be deceased, it was incumbent upon him to furnish an explanation. Since none is forthcoming, all circumstances considered, the chain is completed. The conviction by the Trial Court and the sentence of death penalty imposed on the accused was upheld by the Karnataka High Court.
Whether, in the facts and circumstances of the case, the sentence of death penalty imposed on the Appellant by the Trial Court confirmed by the High Court can be interfered with.
Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – Section 302 – Murder of two minor children – Conviction under Section 302 confirmed, whereas death penalty commuted to life sentence – Case of circumstantial evidence: * Author 1722 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Held: It is clearly a case of circumstantial evidence – The principles to be applied in consideration of the evidence have been christened the ‘Panchsheel Principles’ detailed in the Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra (1984) 4 SCC 116 judgment – Both the Courts below have found the circumstances to be established against the appellant-convict – Held that there is no error in the findings recorded by both the Courts qua the guilt of the Appellant and the judgment on conviction. [Para 6] Criminal Procedure Code – Sentencing – Mitigating circumstances relied upon to commute death penalty to life sentence till remainder of life without remission: Held: To enable parties to adequately prepare, it is desirable that there be some gap between the pronouncement of judgment, and the hearing on sentencing – It has, however, been held that the point of focus in a sentencing hearing is quality and reliability of assistance and closeness of time, itself would not render the sentence handed down, susceptible to doubt – The mitigating circumstances considered including Appellant’s lack of prior criminal record, his good relations with the deceased individuals before the crime, and his initial act of securing a job for his sister-in-law, which indicated positive intentions toward the family – The absence of criminal intent as a mitigating circumstance was negated by the Court.
The rule only is that the circumstantial evidence ought to be unimpeachable, and the matter at hand be an exceptional case, or the evidence be so convincing that the option of imposition of any other penalty stands foreclosed in the judicial mind – Therefore, non-consideration of this ground cannot be said to be damaging to the sanctity of the sentencing order – On the basis of mitigating circumstances, the death penalty commuted to life sentence till the remainder of life without remission. [Paras 7, 10, 13] List of Websites https://home.nps.gov/liho/learn/historyculture/alincolnbio.htm; http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/antecedent List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1723Ramesh A. Naika v.
The Registrar General, High Court of Karnataka Etc.
List of Keywords Death Penalty; Murder; Panchsheel Principles.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No(s). 877-878 of 2020 From the Judgment and Order dated 22.09.2017 of the High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru in CRLRC No. 2 of 2014 and CRLA No. 196 of 2014 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Dr. Yug Mohit Choudhary, Ms. Payoshi Roy, K. Paari Vendhan, Siddhartha, Ms. Ragini Ahuja, S. Prabu Ramasubramanian, G. Sriram, Bharathimohan M.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Prateek K. Chadha, A.A.G., V. N. Raghupathy, Sreekar Aechuri, Ms. Mythili S, Ms. Surbhi Soni, Aniket Chauhaan.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Order Sanjay Karol, J.
1. A child’s parents are their reason for existence and form an indispensable part of their lives, even more so, in the early years of life. Parents are expected to be loving, nurturing and sometimes disciplining guides in life. Abraham Lincoln is said to have said that “love is the chain whereby to bind a child to its parents1 ”. In the classical traditions of India, however, parents are placed on a higher pedestal, at an exalted position, as their word equals the word of God. While it is true that in modern times, we refrain from making such comparisons, nonetheless, it cannot be said that the irreplaceability, essentiality, importance, and desirousness of the love, affection, and stewardship of parents, has been watered down in any way. One 1 https://home.nps.gov/liho/learn/historyculture/alincolnbio.htm 1724 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports is forced to wonder, in the facts of this case, how these cherished ideals could have been entirely absent.
THE APPEALS
2. These appeals challenge judgment dated 22 nd September 2017, passed by the High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru in Criminal Referred Case No.2 of 2014 and Criminal Appeal No.196 of 2014 confirming the conviction and death sentence awarded to the appellant under Section 366(1), Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 2 . Also, by the accused seeking setting aside the conviction under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 3 and sentence of death, respectively imposed by judgment and order dated 26th November 2013 and 3 rd December 2013 by the V Additional District and Sessions Judge, Dakshin Kannada, Mangaluru sitting at Puttur4 in Sessions Case No.28 of 2011.
FACTS
3. The facts, as can be understood from the record are that : The appellant-convict was a respectable member of society working as a Manager at the Solapur Branch of the Punjab National Bank. He was married to Smt. Sundari (PW-2) who was herself an employee of the State Bank of Mysore, Mangalore Branch. They had two children – 10-year-old Bhuvanraj and 3½-year-old Krithika 5 . It is alleged that the appellant-convict was dissatisfied with the behaviour and life choices of his sister-in-law, Ms. Savitha whom he had gotten a job at the Provident Fund office, who fell in love with her co-worker Mr. P. Mohan (PW-19) and wanted to pursue matrimonial life with him. Further, the appellant-accused first tried to get his wife to dissuade Ms. Savitha from going down her chosen path but was persuaded to refrain from interfering therein. Subsequently, while visiting Tumkur (residence of Ms. Savitha, and Mrs. Saraswathi, mother-in-law, and ancestral village of the appellant-accused) and Mangalore (where Smt. Sundari resided with the deceased children), from Solapur where he was posted, when this issue again came up, he once 2 Hereafter ‘Cr.P.C.’ 3 Hereafter ‘I.P.C.’ 4 Hereafter ‘Trial Court’ 5 Hereafter ‘deceased children’ [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1725Ramesh A. Naika v.
The Registrar General, High Court of Karnataka Etc.
again found Smt. Sundari not to be supporting his stand. As such, to teach her and his sister-in-law a lesson, he decided to end the lives of the latter, his own children, Smt. Saraswathi, and then to get his wife to commit suicide.
In furtherance of this design, he killed, it is alleged by the prosecution, Ms. Savitha and Ms. Saraswathi at Tumkur Village, by dumping their bodies in the sump tank of his house there on 16 th June 2010 and then came to Mangalore the next day. Here, having gotten in touch with PW-3, his nephew, he secured the locker keys from his wife, met PW-1, her brother, and gave him Rs.17,00,000/-. He then returned home and then, on the pretext of showing them around the city, took his children in the cab of PW-9, Firoze, to the gardens situated on the property of PW-7, Mr. Sathyanarayana Prasad, where he was seen arriving by Mr. Mahalinga Naika PW-4 and there drowned them in the tank. Having done so, he sent a message to his wife, informing her that the said persons were no longer in the land of the living, and she too should follow suit by ending her life in a well. Concerned by this, she informed her relatives, who advised approaching the authorities.
Eventually, with the assistance of various persons, the bodies of the deceased children were found in the water tank in the gardens of PW-7. PW-1 set the law in motion by registering the FIR in Crime No.56/2010 on 17 th June, 2010. The appellant-convict was apprehended at Rama Lodge in Puttur. Chargesheet was filed on 20 th August, 2010. Here only it is clarified that the present appeals deals only with the murder of the two children and, in relation to the other deceased, the accused already stands tried separately.
PREVIOUS PROCEEDINGS
4. The prosecution examined 19 witnesses and exhibited 19 documents and 10 material objects in evidence. On behalf of the defence, no other evidence apart from the exhibition of one document, during the course of the cross-examination of PW-16, was led. The Trial Court framed five issues which are extracted hereinunder:
“1. Whether the prosecution is able to prove the homicidal death of the children of the accused Bhuvanraj and Krithika?
1726 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
2. Whether the prosecution is able to prove the motive against the accused?
3. Whether the prosecution is able to prove that, on 16-06-2010 in he afternoon the accused picked his children Bhuvanraj and Krithika from his house at Mangalore with a soleintention of committing their murder, brough them to Ardamoole of Panaje Village of Puttur Taluk drowned them in water tank situated in the areca garden of PW7 Mr. SatyanarayanaPrasad, resulting their death?
4. Whether the prosecution is able to prove the offence U/Sec.302 of IPC against the accused?
5. What Order or relief?”
On the first issue, reliance is placed on the testimonies of PW1-Mr. P. Aithappa Naika, PW2-Smt. Sundari, PW3-Mr. Dayananda, PW4- Mr. Mahalinga Naika, PW5-Panch witness, PW6-Mr. Kripashankar, PW7-Mr. A.R. Sathyanarayana Prasad, PW8-Mr. Keshava Moorthy, PW9-Mr. P.S. Firoze, PW10-Mr. Ramesh K., PW11-Dr. Geethalaxmi, PW12-Dr. Deepak Rai. It is recorded that, while searching for the deceased children, PWs 1 to 3 and 9 arrived at Ardamole. They got in touch with PW-4 and, ultimately, along with PW-7, found the bodies floating in water.
PW-12, Dr. Deepak Rai, concluded that the death of the children was due to drowning in water. Such a conclusion was supported by the evidence of PW-11 Dr Geethalaxmi. It was further established by the evidence of PW-4 that the appellant-convict was originally a resident of Ardamole. These circumstances along with the consideration of his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C., the homicidal death was proved.
4.1. The next question was that of motive. In determining the same, reference is made to the statements of Smt. Sundari (PW-2), Mr. P. Mohan (PW-19). The conclusion of the Trial Court is as below: - “39. Now the totality of the evidence did not point out that for the reason of Ms. Savitha fell in love with PW19 which was not acceptable to the accused, [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1727Ramesh A. Naika v.
The Registrar General, High Court of Karnataka Etc.
who expected Ms.Savitha to respect him properly by obliging his words and in doing so she was compelled with disassociate with PW19 by braking her relationship with him – and to take brake her proposal to marry PW19. When he has expected the assistance of his wife PW2 to mend the ways of Ms. Savitha which did not give any positive result as the accused was padfied and he was asked to keep quite from the affairs of Ms. Savitha, the accused himself intervened with the affairs of Ms. Savitha in the indirect manner by calling PW19 expressing dissatisfaction about their marriage proposal and accused made attempts to see that the relationship between Ms. Savitha and PW19 breaks away by means of transfer of PW19. The accused though successful in getting transfer of PW19 from one section to another Section, as Ms. Savitha and PW19 decided to go ahead with their proposed marriage, as a last resort the accused meddle with PW2 compelled her to convince Ms. Savitha to take brake from the proposed marriage as PW2 did advise her husband that the parents and brothers of Ms, Savitha will take care of her affairs and asking him to keep quite, accused used the life of the children and himself as weapon of offence against PW2 and for this background leading to death of the children explained clear version of the prosecution. There are no other hypothesis which can be possible to take out from the evidence as well the defence from the ocular evidence on record. Hence the motive for the incident has been explained by the prosecution is in the manner proposed. In the result point No.2 is answered in the Affirmative.”
4.2. The question next to be considered was whether, when the appellant-convict picked up the deceased children from his house in Mangalore, the sole intention was of committing their murders. It was noted that the case rests on circumstantial evidence. The circumstances, listed by the prosecution as pointing cumulatively to the guilt of the appellant-convict, are - 1728 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports “78. Now the prosecution has proposed several chains of circumstances which are
1. Arrival of the accused to Mangalore on 16-06-2010;
2) Accused moving with the children from Mangaldore to Ardamoole in a taxi belongs to PW9;
3) The accused was seen together with the children at Ardamoole and he was seen alone at Ardamoole moving towards Puttur;
4) The accused sending SMS messages to PW2 indicating the fate of himself as well as the children and directing her to do certain act as her fate, 5) PW2 meeting PW9, who taking them to Ardamoole where with the assistance of PW4, 6, 7 the dead bodies of the children was found in the pond of PW7, 6) thereafter the accused was found stayed at Hotel Rama at Puttur and he has been apprehended on 17-06-2010, 7) homicidal death of the children, 8) motive for the incident and 9) failure on the part of the accused to offer explanation for the incriminating evidence appeared against him:”
4.3. It was held that the circumstances did indeed point to the guilt of the appellant and that the defence could not point to any alternative hypothesis to establish his innocence. He was in the company of the deceased children and none else, hence the application of the last seen theory - he had to explain that since they were with him, and a short time later they were found to be deceased, it was incumbent upon him to furnish an explanation. Since none is forthcoming, all circumstances considered, the chain is completed.
4.4. Qua the fourth question it is held that none of the exceptions mentioned in Section 300 I.P.C. are attracted in this case, and as such, essential ingredients of Section 302 I.P.C. were met, warranting his conviction thereunder.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1729Ramesh A. Naika v.
The Registrar General, High Court of Karnataka Etc.
4.5. As such, it was held that the prosecution had proved its case beyond reasonable doubt. Thereafter, vide order of sentencing dated 3 rd December 2013, the Court balanced the aggravating and mitigating circumstances, to conclude that the act of the appellant-convict did indeed fall into the rarest category, deserving the harshest penalty known to the criminal justice system, i.e., the penalty of death.
5. As per the requirement of law, the matter traveled to the High Court in confirmation proceedings. The appellant-convict also filed an appeal. The High Court, having heard the parties, held that his arrival at Mangalore, taking his kids around the city and eventually to the gardens of PW-7, and the short time gap between when the children and the appellant-convict were seen together and the discovery of the deceased children’s bodies, i.e., three circumstances taken together are sufficient to drive home the guilt of the accused. In doing so, the testimonies of PW-1, PW-2, PW-3, PW-4, PW-7 and PW-9 have been relied upon. Having observed thus, the Court then went on to make certain observations regarding the messages and call records produced. An objection to the effect that the same are inadmissible in Court, and the Trial Court ought not to have considered the same in the absence of a certificate under Section 65-B of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, was raised, however, the same was cast aside, holding that their production was not as a piece of substantive evidence, and instead, was used to corroborate the evidence of PW-1 and PW-2, and also to establish the movements of the appellant-convict. It was held as under – “31. With regard to the contents of SMS are concerned, we fully approve the procedure adopted by the learned Sessions Judge in bringing on record the contents of these SMS. We have perused the lower court records.
It is seen that the learned Sessions Judge has passed a detailed order on the applications made by the prosecution under Sections 3, 62 and 65B of the Evidence Act and Sections 230 and 311 Cr.P.C. on 19.4.2013. Further, the proceedings dated 22.10.2013 reveal that M.Os 1 and 4 viz., the mobiles which were seized by the Investigating agency, were opened in the open court. These mobile phones were charged and SMS therein were transcribed by the court in the open court. These transcriptions were 1730 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports very much available to the accused at the time of crossexamination of the witnesses. Therefore, it does not like in the mouth of the accused now to contend that reliance on this material is illegal or contrary to the procedure prescribed under the Evidence Act. Even otherwise the law is well settled that objection regarding the proof of documents if not taken at the time when the document is produced before the court, the party cannot be permitted to raise the said objection at the appeal stage. In SONU@ AMAR vs. STATE OF HARYANA (2017 SCC ONLINE SC 765), the Hon’ble Supreme Court had an occasion to consider such an issue…”
“32. The accused had full and ample opportunity to explain the circumstance of SMS sent by him. The accused having not offered any explanation, the trial court was justified in placing reliance on the contents of these messages. The Trial Court has reproduced the contents of these messages in the impugned judgment in verbatim and we do not find it necessary to burden the record of reproducing them over again. Suffice it to note that the author of these SMS and call records have been proved and these SMS lend suitable corroboration to the testimony of PW-2 that accused sent a false message through the Mobile (M.O.6) of deceased Savitha, after her death misleading PW-2 that she was admitted in Manipal Hospital and further that after drowning the children in the tank, he sent her the message through his mobile M.O.4 that he had already sent his mother-inlaw, sister-in-law and children to heaven.”
On motive, it was observed that the differences stemmed from the opposing stands taken by PW-2 and other members of her family regarding Ms. Savitha’s relationship with Mr. P. Mohan (PW-19). The appellant-convict was of the view that the said relationship should be disapproved of, and as a result broken off, but this position did not get any support from others and as such, he resolved to eliminate the members of PW-2’s family and his own children.
As such, it was concluded as under :
“Thus, on ultimate analysis of all of the above facts and circumstances, the gravity and the magnitude of the [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1731Ramesh A. Naika v.
The Registrar General, High Court of Karnataka Etc.
offences, committed by the accused, the depraved manner in which he committed four murders including that of his minor children, the utter lack of remorse on part of the accused , his determination to annihilate almost all members of the immediate family of PW.2 and the threats issued to her and the surviving members of her family and also in the larger interest of the society, the Trial Court was justified in awarding death sentence to the accused. We do not find any good reason to commute the death sentence to life imprisonment with or without remission. We do not find any mitigating circumstance warranting commutation or to take any lenient view in the matter. On thorough and careful consideration of the entirematerial on record and on appraisal of all the attending facts and circumstances as discussed above, we are of the firm view that in the fact situation of the present case, death penalty is the only just and appropriate punishment that requires to be imposed on the accused. The reference made by the Trial Court deserves to be accepted.”
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.