Dr. Poornima Advani & Anr v. Government of NCT & Anr.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 262; [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1178
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 18 Feb 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2643/2025
- Sections
- 49, 52, 884, 6D, 11B, 27, 34
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1178 : 2025 INSC 262 Dr. Poornima Advani & Anr.
v.
Government of NCT & Anr.
(Civil Appeal No. 2643 of 2025)
18 February 2025 [J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, the Appellants would be entitled to claim interest on delayed stamp duty refund, in the absence of a provision in the statute to that effect. Headnotes† Constitution of India, 1950 – Article 226 – Refund of Stamp Duty – Interest to be paid along with the principal: Held: The Appellants approached the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution following their request for refund of the stamp duty as the e-stamp paper purchased by the Appellants was misplaced – The Single Judge of the High Court passed an order directing the Respondents to refund Rs. 28,10,000/- being the principal amount of the stamp duty – The Writ Petition was partly allowed as only the principal amount was ordered to be refunded whereas the interest on the same was declined – The Appellants herein being dissatisfied with non-grant of interest on the sum of Rs. 28,10,000/- preferred Letters Patent Appeal – The appeal Court dismissed the Letters Patent Appeal – The Civil Appeal allowed and the Respondents directed to pay an amount of Rs. 4,35,968/- (Rs. Four Lakh Thirty Five Thousand Nine Hundred Sixty Eight Only) towards interest within a period of two months from the date of the order without fail. [Paras 6, 7, 10, 31] Payment of Interest – Person deprived of money entitled to be compensated for deprivation:
Held: The subject General Mandamus is a salutary advancement of the law, calculated to insulate and protect a citizen from unfair treatment by the State – Referring to Authorised Officer Karnataka Bank v. M/s R.M.S. Granites Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. in Civil Appeal No. 12294 of 2024, held that when a person is deprived of the use of his money to which he is legitimately entitled, he has a right to be [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1179Dr. Poornima Advani & Anr. v. Government of NCT & Anr. compensated for the deprivation which may be called interest or compensation – Interest is paid for the deprivation of the use of money in general terms which has returned or compensation for the use or retention by a person of a sum of money belonging to other – Referring to Secretary, Irrigation Department, Government of Orissa v. G.C. Roy, (1992) 1 SCC 508, it was noted that a person deprived of use of money to which he is legitimately entitled has a right to be compensated for the deprivation, call it by any name – Reference being made to Riches v. Westminister Bank Ltd., 1947 (1) ALL ER 469 wherein it has been held that interest is a payment, which becomes due because the creditor has not had his money at the due date – It may be recorded either as representing the profit he might have made if he had had the use of the money, or, conversely, the loss he suffered because he had not that use. [Paras 15, 17, 20, 21] Doctrine of restitution – Interest necessary corollary of doctrine of restitution – Discussed:
Held: If doctrine of restitution is attracted, interest should follow – Restitution in its etymological sense means restoring to a party on the modification, variation or reversal of a decree or order what has been lost to him in execution of decree or order of the Court or in direct consequence of a decree or order – The term “restitution” is used in three senses, firstly, return or restoration of some specific thing to its rightful owner or status, secondly, the compensation for benefits derived from wrong done to another and, thirdly, compensation or reparation for the loss caused to another – Principles of restitution discussed in O.N.G.C. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Customs Mumbai, JT 2007 (10) SC 76 referred. [Paras 25, 27] Principle of compensation – When the collection is illegal, the amount so collected to be refunded with interest – Discussed: Held: Reference being made to Union of India through Director of Income Tax v. Tata Chemicals Ltd., (2014) 6 SCC 335, wherein it was held that when the collection is illegal, the Revenue is obliged to refund such amount with interest as money so deposited was retained and enjoyed by it – No discrimination can be shown between the assessee and Revenue in paying interest on the refund of tax – Money received and retained without right, carries with it the right to interest – Obligation to refund money received and retained without right implies and carries with in the right to interest. [Para 29] 1180 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports List of Acts Constitution of India.
List of Keywords Interest; Refund of interest; Compensation.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 2643 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 27.09.2019 of the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in LPA No. 288 of 2019 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Abhishek Puri, Sahil Grewal, Ms. Surbhi Gupta, Mrs. Reeta Dewan Puri, P. N. Puri.
Adv. for the Respondents:
Ms. Jyoti Mendiratta.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Order
1. IA No. 4291/2024 for substitution is allowed. Cause title be amended accordingly.
2. Leave granted.
3. This appeal arises from the judgment and order passed by the High Court of Delhi dated 27th September, 2019 in Letters Patent Appeal No. 288 of 2019 by which the appeal filed by the appellants herein against the judgment and order passed by the learned Single Judge of the High Court partly allowing the Writ Petition No. 9014 of 2017 filed by the appellants herein came to be dismissed.
4. The facts giving rise to this appeal may be summarized as under:- The appellants herein were desirous of purchasing an immovable property in New Delhi. For that purpose, they purchased the e-stamp paper dated 06.07.2016 valued at Rs.28,10,000/- (Rupees Twenty Eight Lakh Ten Thousand Only). The money for that purpose was paid from the joint bank account of the appellants being husband and [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1181Dr. Poornima Advani & Anr. v. Government of NCT & Anr. wife respectively. The e-stamp paper which came to be purchased was dated 06.07.2016.
5. We borrow the other relevant facts from the judgment and order passed by the learned Single Judge dated 20 th August, 2018 more particularly, from paragraph 4.3 therein:- “4.3 Pertinently, the e-stamp paper dated 06.07.2016 purchased by the petitioners, sets down the following details:
(i) Particulars of the property, which was proposed to be purchased;(ii) the names of the parties, who intended to execute the sale deed;(iii) the consideration to be paid for consummating the sale transaction; and (iv) the value of e-stamp paper.
4.4 According to the petitioners, though initially, the intention was to execute the sale deed concerning subject property in July,2016, since, there was some delay in closing the loan transaction via which the transaction was to be funded, the execution of the sale deed was delayed.
4.5 This delay proved to be fatal, inasmuch as, on 4.8.2016, the petitioners were told by the broker, who had the custody of the e-stamp paper, that the e-stamp paper dated 6.7.2016 had been misplaced.
4.6 The petitioners realizing the enormity of the loss, filed a complaint with the Crime Branch, Delhi Police, on that very day i.e. 4.8.2016. As a follow up action, on 06.08.2016, the petitioners got public notices issued in two newspapers, namely, Asian Age (English edition) and Rashtriya Sahara (Hindi edition).
4.7 Since, the petitioners were desirous of taking the sale transaction in respect of subject property forward, they were left with no choice but to purchase a fresh e-stamp paper, which they did, on 6.8.2016.
4.8 This stamp paper bore the No.IN-DL80452882772240. The money for this was also paid out from the joint account of the petitioners, maintained with the State Bank of India. 4.9 Consequent thereto, on 8.8.2016, the petitioners and the vendor i.e., M/s. Scud Finlease Limited executed a sale deed.
1182 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
5. On 11.8.2016, the petitioners filed an application with the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Collector of Stamps, for refund of stamp duty amounting to Rs.28,10,000/- on account of loss of the e-stamp paper dated 6.7.2016.
5.1 The prayer made in the application was that the amount be refunded to the petitioners after deducting the usual cancellation charges, if any. The application was accompanied by an affidavit of petitioner No.2 that the e-stamp paper dated 6.7.2016 has been lost and was not traceable despite best efforts.
5.2 Furthermore, an indemnity bond was also executed by petitioner No.2, whereby he undertook to indemnify the respondents, if the stand taken by him that the e-stamp paper dated 6.7.2016 had been lost, proved to be incorrect and, as a result thereof, any loss/damage, etc. was suffered by them.
5.3 Since no action was taken on the petitioners’ application dated 11.8.2016, the petitioners addressed a letter dated 8.9.2016 to respondent No.2. In this letter, apart from anything else what was sought to be highlighted by the petitioners were two aspects: first, given the fact that every transaction is made in electronic form, it could be verified almost instantaneously; and second, the misplaced or lost e-stamp paper dated 6.7.2016 could not be used for any other purpose except that, which stood specified in the e-stamp paper. It was emphasized that given that fact that via a fresh e-stamp paper dated 6.8.2016, transaction qua the stamp paper dated 6.7.2016 had been consummated, the lost e-stamp paper had lost its legal efficacy and thus, could not be misused by anyone else.
5.4 As is evidence that both these assertions were made by the petitioners to allay the apprehensions of respondent No.2.
5.5 However, the petitioners’ plea for refund of stamp duty did not cut much ice with the respondents and, consequently, vide order dated 21.10.2018, the Collector of Stamps (HQ) rejected the petitioners’ application dated 11.8.2016 maintained for refund of stamp duty.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1183Dr. Poornima Advani & Anr. v. Government of NCT & Anr.
6. Aggrieved by the impugned order dated 21.10.2016, the petitioners have preferred by the instant writ petition.”
6. The learned Single Judge adjudicated the writ petition and ultimately thought fit to partly allow the same. The learned Single Judge issued a writ of mandamus to the respondents herein to refund a sum of Rs. 28,10,000/- within a period of two weeks from the date of pronouncement of the judgment.
7. It appears that the petition was partly allowed as only the principal amount was ordered to be refunded whereas the interest on the same was declined. We take notice of few relevant observations made by the learned Single Judge while ordering refund of the principal amount referred to above:- “19. Therefore, the question before me is: should the Court, in such circumstances, fold its hands and deny a person, who has lost the stamp paper, relief only because the draftsman has omitted the use of such expression explicitly in the Statute. As noticed above, it is not unknown to law that when Courts have encountered such creases in the Statute they have proceeded to iron them out without destroying the fabric which forms the core of the Statute. The expression obliterate appearing in Section 49(a) of the Act should, in my opinion, include cases where the Stamp paper is lost by an applicant seeking refund of stamp duty. This would be a reasonable ‘and practical’ interpretation of Section 49(a) of the Act, as any other interpretation could lead to a situation where it may fall foul of Article 14 of the Constitution.
20. There is another way of looking at the matter, which is, the scheme of Chapter V of the Act. If the scheme, as discussed above, is kept in mind, respondents ought to refund stamp duty even in cases where an applicant claims refund of stamp duty on account of loss of e-stamp paper; subject to an enquiry establishing factum of loss and adequate safeguards being put in. To my mind, if the contrary view was sustained, it would result in the State retaining money without the authority of law, as admittedly, the taxing event had not occurred in the facts and circumstances of this case.
1184 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
21. In the instant case, the petitioners have provided a photocopy of e-stamp paper dated 6.7.2016, which at the moment, is the best secondary evidence available with it, which, shows that the e-stamp paper was not engrossed. 21.1 Given the foregoing discussion, clearly, the amount retained by the respondents cannot be in the nature of tax as the taxing event has not occurred in the instant case. It cannot be also in the nature of fee as there was no quid pro quo.
21.2 In any event, the stand of the respondents is that the stamp duty is in the nature of tax. If that be the position, could the respondents retain money in anticipation of the taxing event occurring? Article 265 of the Constitution provides that no tax shall be levied or collected except by authority of law. Therefore, emphasis is not only on no tax being levied without the authority of law, but is also on collection of tax without authority of law.
22. Therefore, in my view, the continued retention of amount paid towards anticipated stamp duty in the hands of the respondents is illegal. The apprehension expressed by the respondents that there was a possibility of the lost e-stamp paper being mis-utilized seems to be tenuous for the following reasons:
(i) First, the particulars of the transaction, parties and the consideration have already been incorporated in the lost e-stamp paper.
(ii) Second, with the technological innovation in place, the said information would be available and anyone trying to use the lost e-stamp paper can easily be found out. In any event, the fact the lost e-stamp paper dated 06.07.2016 adverts to the same property qua which sale transaction stands effected via the new stamp paper dated 06.08.2016, the possibility of misuse of the old e-stamp paper dated 06.07.2016, to my mind, does not arise.
(iii) The lost e-stamp paper dated 06.07.2016 having been locked and cancelled, there is, to my mind, given the technology in place, no possibility of the [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1185Dr. Poornima Advani & Anr. v. Government of NCT & Anr. lost e-stamp paper being mis-utilized. The Collector of Stamps invariably checks the website of Stock Holding Corporation Ltd. to ascertain whether or not the stamp paper is genuine. The order dated 11.03.2015, passed by the Divisional Commissioner, clearly casts such an obligation on the Collector of Stamps.
(iv) Lastly, in any case, the petitioners have furnished an indemnity bond, and therefore, loss or damages, if any, suffered by the respondents can always be recovered.
23. Before I proceed further, I need to touch upon the argument raised by Mr. Ramesh Singh that the view held by a Single Judge of this Court in Piyush Aggarwal’s case requires reconsideration. This was a case where the petitioners had sought refund of stamp duty on account of the fact that before the instrument on which the stamp duty was leviable, was executed, by virtue of a notification issued by the State, the stamp duty and transfer duty on conveyance had been substantially reduced. Since, the petitioners had paid excess stamp duty and transfer duty, they sought refund of the same.
23.1 The facts, as gleaned from the judgment, would show that the conveyance i.e. the instrument, in that case, was executed on 30.06.2003, whereas the notification, reducing the stamp duty and transfer duty, was issued on 19.05.2003. 23.2 The Court was, thus, called upon to adjudicate two aspects: First, as to when, did the chargeable event occur? Second, whether in the given circumstances, the petitioners claim for refund of excess stamp duty and transfer duty was sustainable?
23.3 Insofar as the first aspect was concerned, the Court ruled that the chargeable event, for levy of stamp duty, would occur on the date of execution of the instrument and not on the date of adjudication or the date of presentation, which, in that case were events which occurred prior to the date of the notification, whereby the stamp duty and transfer duty charges were reduced by the State.
23.4 Insofar as the second issue was concerned, the Court held that Section 52 which allows, inter alia, for refund 1186 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports of stamp duty in cases where a person, inadvertently, uses on an instrument chargeable with duty, a stamp of a description other than that prescribed for such an instrument — was available to the petitioners for refund of stamp duty. According to the Court, if the date of execution of the instrument is taken as the date which would determine as to what would be the admissible stamp duty that had to be levied on the instrument (i.e. the conveyance) then, the petitioner‘s case would fall within the ambit of the provisions of Section 52 of the Act, as excess duty had been, inadvertently, paid by the petitioners since the notification reducing the rate of stamp duty and transfer duly stood published prior to the execution of the instrument in that case.
23.5 This apart, the Court observed that even if it is assumed that Section 52 of the Act was not applicable, the petitioners would be entitled to refund of stamp duty as the State could not retain the stamp duty in view of the provision of Article 265 of the Constitution. The relevant observations made by the Court are as follow:
“….11. Even as regards applicability of Section 52 of the Act, the matter can be looked at in another perspective. The “chargeable event”
being the date of execution of the document and if on that date higher than the admissible stamp duty is levied or collected, it would fall within the ambit of excess payment being “inadvertently”
collected on the said date from the petitioner.
Thus, it could even be urged that Section 52 of the Act was applicable. Further as noticed earlier dehors the applicability of Section 52 of the Act, stamp duty collected without authority of law cannot be retained in terms of Article 265 of the Constitution of India in the absence of any statutory provision requiring refund application to be submitted within a specified period or prohibiting the refund unless made within the specified period. In the instant case, it may be noted, that application for refund had been made [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1187Dr. Poornima Advani & Anr. v. Government of NCT & Anr. within the stipulated period of six months under Section 52 of the Act…..”
(Emphasis is mine)
23.6 Having regard to the facts which obtained in Piyush Aggarwal’s case and enunciation of law by the Court, I am not persuaded to hold that the judgment requires reconsideration, as was contended by Mr. Ramesh Singh. To my mind, the ambit and scope of Article 265 of the Constitution is not restricted only to cases where the Court finds that the levy imposed by the State is illegal or unconstitutional. As adverted to above, Article 265 of the Constitution, not only imposes a bar on imposition of tax without the authority of law, it also imposes a prohibition on collection of tax without the authority of law. 23.7 In my opinion, the other contention of Mr. Ramesh Singh that the Court in Piyush Aggarwal’s case failed to notice the legal regime of the Act, is also not correct in view of the fact that the Court did notice the relevant provisions, which were necessary for adjudication of the matter at hand.
23.8 The other submission of Mr. Ramesh Singh, that the Act is a complete code by itself and that refund could only be ordered in respect of instances provided in the Act, has been answered by me hereinabove. The rationale employed by me is that the scheme of Chapter V of Act which adverts to allowances and refunds is required to be interpreted in a manner that the Statute does not fall foul of the Constitution.
23.9 Therefore, in that sense, the other argument of Mr. Ramesh Singh that the Collector of Stamps is a creature of the Statute and can, therefore, only operate within its periphery, has to be answered, in my opinion, in the same vein. While one cannot quibble with the proposition that the statutory authority has to necessarily act within the ambit of the statute which forms the basis of its nativity, the extent and amplitude of its power will, however, be governed by the provision of the Constitution. There being 1188 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports no prohibition in the Act for grant of refund for lost stamp paper, surely the Collector of Stamps cannot collect or retain what lawfully does not belong to the State.
24. Interestingly, our neighbouring country i.e. Pakistan, which has a somewhat similar Statute, dealing with the levy collection and refund of stamp duty, is beset with difficulties which are akin those faced by applicant(s), in our country, seeking refund of stamp duty on account of loss of stamp paper. This aspect, I came across upon a judgment dated 23.02.2016, delivered by the Lahore High Court, in Writ Petition No.27935 of 2012, titled: Aziz Ullah Khan Vs. Government of the Punjab etc., being brought to my notice.
24.1 The Court in that case was faced with a question as to whether refund of stamp duty ought to be ordered in a case where the petitioners had misplaced i.e. lost the stamp papers.
24.2 The Additional Advocate General resisted the writ petition, broadly, on the ground that there was no provision for grant of refund of stamp paper, in cases where it was lost and that if such a relief was granted, it would result in loss to the national exchequer.
24.3 I must confess that, though, in that case, the Court noticed the existence of Rule 5 of the Punjab Non Judicial Stamp Refund, Renewal and Disposal Rules, 1954 which provided for refund of stamp duty in case of its loss, albeit, in specified circumstances i.e., where stamp paper was stolen or lost in transit by Government officials. The Court, after noting that there was a discrimination, inasmuch as, Rule 5 permitted write off where stamp papers were lost by public functionaries, whereas, a similar facility was not given to private person, went on to deal with the other arguments, that is, whether it could order refund in exercise of its constitutional powers in the absence of specific provision for refund, the possibility of loss to the national exchequer, as also misuse of stamp paper, in the following manner:
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1189Dr. Poornima Advani & Anr. v. Government of NCT & Anr. “…..It is very strange to note that the public functionaries, in the event of loss of Stamp Papers in transit, have been bestowed with a remedy to seek write off whereas the private persons have not been provided with such facility. This fact alone renders it crystal clear that a discriminatory treatment is being given by the public functionaries to their own brethren in the event of loss of stamp papers whereas the request of a member of society is not being entertained merely for the reason that the original are not available. Such approach, being in conflict with the clear cut mandate given under Article 25 of the Constitution of Islamic Republic of Pakistan, 1973, cannot be encouraged rather deserves to be discouraged.
10. Learned Additional Advocate General has adopted the plea that when the statute has not allowed any refund in case of loss of Stamp Papers the same cannot be permitted by this Court in exercise of Constitutional jurisdiction vested under Article 199 of the Constitution of Islamic Republic of Pakistan, 1973. In this respect I am of the view that according to the golden principle of interpretation of a statute, a beneficial approach should be followed. As far as the case in hand is concerned, when a via media has been provided in the event of loss of Stamp Papers during transit by the public functionaries, how the petitioner can be deprived of such facility. It is not the case of the respondents that the case of the petitioner is not covered under Rule 32 of the Rules, 1954. The apex Court of the country, in H.R.C. No.40927-S of 2012 Application by Abdul Rehman Farooq Pirzada (PLD 2013 SC 829) while highlighting the principles of interpretation of statutes by the superior Courts has inter-alia held as under:- “The interpretation cannot be narrow and pedantic but the Courts’ efforts should be to construe the same broadly, so that it may be able to meet the requirements of an ever changing society. The general words cannot be construed 1190 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports in isolation but the same are to be construed in the context in which they are employed. In other words, their colour and contents are derived from the context.”
Further, a Full Bench of this Court in the case of Rub Nawaz Dhadwana Advocate etc. v. Rana Muhammad Akram Advocate etc. (W.P. No.16793 of 2014) while dealing with the powers of the superior Courts to abridge the distance between the legislator and the public-at-large has inter-alia observed as under:
“The judge must reflect these fundamental values in the interpretation of legislation. The judge should not narrow interpretation to the exclusive search for subjective legislative intent. He must also consider the “intention” of the legal system, for the statute is always wiser than the legislature. By doing so the judge gives the statute a dynamic meaning and thus bridges the gap between law and society.”
If refusal on the part of the respondents to issue refund in favour of the petitioner is adjudged on the touchstone of aforequoted cases, I am of the humble opinion that the same is not tenable for the reason that when the legislator has framed rules for refund of spoiled/unused/lost Stamp Papers, how the respondents can interpret said rules according to their own whims just to damage the case of the claimants.
xxx xxx xxx In this scenario, the objection raised by the learned Additional Advocate General that the refund is not permissible without production of original Stamp Papers is of no worth at all. The bonafide of the petitioner is apparent from the fact that after loss of original Misplaced Stamp Papers he not only reported matter to the Police with promptitude but also got published proclamation in daily “Smaj” and having done so he, with a view to avoid further delay towards execution of sale deed, got issued fresh Stamp Papers to complete [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1191Dr. Poornima Advani & Anr. v. Government of NCT & Anr. the sale transaction. A copy of the sale deed provided by the above named deed writer shows that the Misplaced Stamp Papers were used for the said purpose but due to their loss during journey sale deed could not be registered. The logic behind issuance of refund against the spoiled, destroyed or unused Stamp Papers is to accommodate a person who has not used those Stamp Papers for the purpose for which the same were issued. In the case in hand after admission by the respondents that neither the Misplaced Stamp Papers were used for any other purpose nor anybody else has claimed refund in that regard, the request of the petitioner cannot be turned down merely on the ground that he could not produce the original Misplaced Stamp Papers before the competent authority. If the original Stamp Papers were available with the petitioner there was no necessity for him to incur another sum of more than one million rupees for the same purpose.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.