State of Jharkhand v. Dr. Nishkant Dubey & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 94; [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1909
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Manmohan
- Decided
- 21 Jan 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 5475/2024
- Sections
- 366, 336, 441, 447, 448, 12B, 4, 5, 10, 5(2), 19, 15(1)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 1909 : 2025 INSC 94 State of Jharkhand v.
Dr. Nishkant Dubey & Ors.
(Criminal Appeal No. 5475 of 2024)
21 January 2025 [Abhay S. Oka and Manmohan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration What are the essential conditions that must be satisfied to attract the provisions of Section 366 of the IPC?
What are the essentials to constitute a trespass as criminal trespass?
Whether the procedure provided under the general law will be attracted if the special law provides for a special procedure? Headnotes† Respondents boarded a chartered plane to travel from Deoghar Airport – Air Traffic Controller denied the permission for take-off – Pilot along with other respondents barged into the room of ATC and exerted pressure – ATC clearance was given and Chartered flight took off at 18:17 hours – F.I.R was lodged against respondents – High court quashed the F.I.R being abuse of process of law – Appellant filed appeals challenging the Judgement – Supreme Court dismissed appeals with liberty to appellant. [Paras 1, 2 and 42] Penal Code, 1860 – Section 336 – To attract the provision, it must be alleged that the accused has done the act in question rashly and negligently and it was such as to endanger the life and liberty or personal safety of the others:
Held: Section 336 IPC seeks to punish a person who does an act rashly or negligently and endangers human life or personal safety of others – To attract Section 336 IPC, the prosecution must allege that the accused did the act in question; that it was done rashly or negligently and that it was such as to endanger the life * Author 1910 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports or personal safety of others – In the facts of the present case, the Respondents-accused persons were only asking the ATC to grant permission for take-off – This Court is of the view that the action of the pilot and the passengers talking to ATC officials in the present case cannot be construed as creating undue or illegal pressure on ATC officials – Moreover, as the aircraft carrying the Respondents-accused persons had taken off after obtaining ATC permission, it cannot be said that the Respondents-accused persons acted rashly or negligently so as to endanger human lives – Consequently, Section 336 IPC is not attracted to the present case. [Paras 33 and 34] Penal Code, 1860 – Sections 441, 447 and 448 – Every trespass is not itself criminal – To constitute an offence of criminal trespass prosecution has to allege that the trespass was committed with one of the intents enumerated in Section 441 IPC – No allegation of forcible entry or intimidation or insult or annoyance has been made by any official of ATC:
Held: It is settled law that every trespass by itself is not criminal – To constitute criminal trespass, the prosecution has to allege that the trespass was committed with one of the intents enumerated in Section 441 IPC – Accordingly, the prosecution has to prove that the complainant had possession of the property in question and that the accused entered into or upon the property; or after having lawfully entered unlawfully remained there with the intention
(a) to commit an offence; or (b) to intimidate, insult, or annoy the person in possession – In the absence of any such allegation, the offence under Section 441/447 IPC cannot be sustained. [Para 35] In the present case, no allegation of forcible entry or intimidation or insult or annoyance has been made by any official of ATC – On the contrary, the Director of Deogarh Airport has been arrayed as an accused in the FIR – Consequently, Section 447 IPC is not attracted to the present case – Also, as the ATC office is not a place used as a human dwelling or a place of worship or a place for the custody of goods, the ingredients of Section 448 IPC are not attracted to the present case. [Paras 36, 37] The Aircraft Act, 1934 – Any special law having special jurisdiction, power or procedure shall prevail over general law – The Aircraft Act, 1934 and the rules framed thereunder [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1911State of Jharkhand v. Dr. Nishkant Dubey & Ors. constitute a complete code and its Section 12B is in the nature of a pre-condition for taking cognizance by a court, the local police can only forward the material collected by it to such authorised officer:
Held: The Aircraft Act, 1934 as well as the Rules framed thereunder [including Rule 14(ix) of Airport (Security) Rules, 2011] are a complete Code which deals with safety and security of civil aviation and aerodrome – The Aircraft Act, 1934 also prescribes a special procedure for taking cognizance of any offence punishable under the Aircraft Act, 1934, i.e., the complaint must be made by or with the prior sanction of the Aviation authorities – Section 12B is in the nature of a pre-condition for taking cognizance by a Court – Clause (2) of Section 4 and Section 5 of the Code provide that special form of procedure would prevail – Consequently, as a complaint can be made/filed by an authorised officer alone under the Special Act, i.e. the Aircrafts Act, 1934, before the concerned Court, the local police can only forward the material collected by it during the investigation to such authorised officer. [Paras 39-41] Case Law Cited Navi Mumbai Environment Preservation Society and Anr. v. Ministry of Environment, Division Bench of Bombay High Court, PIL No.218/2013 dated 22nd December, 2016; State (NCT) of Delhi v. Sanjay [2014] 9 SCR 1063 : (2014) 9 SCC 772; Jayant & Ors. v. State of Madhya Pradesh [2020] 11 SCR 665 : (2021) 2 SCC 670 – referred to.
State of Haryana & Ors. v. Bhajan Lal & Ors. [1990] Supp. 3 SCR 259 : (1992) Supp. 1 SCC 335 – followed.
List of Acts Penal Code,1860; Aircraft Act, 1934; Constitution of India, 1950; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Aircraft Rules, 1937; Airport (Security) Rules, 2011.
List of Keywords Quashing of FIR; Air Traffic Control; First Information Report; Special Law, Local Law; Trespass, Civil Aviation; Aerodrome; Investigation; Cognizance; Complaint.
1912 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
5475 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 13.03.2023 of the High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi in WPCRL No. 448 of 2022 With Criminal Appeal No(s). 5476 and 5477 of 2024 Appearances for Parties Arunabh Chowdhury, Sr. Adv., Ms. Pragya Baghel, Jayant Mohan, Karma Dorjee, Dechen Wangadi Lachungpa, Ms. Adya Shree Dutta, Advs. for the Appellant.
Maninder Singh, Siddharth Bhatnagar, Sr. Advs., Ankit Yadav, Ms. Shaoni Das, Rishi K Awasthi, Mahesh Agarwala, Anshuman Srivastava, Victor Das, Shashwat Singh, Shivani Agrawal, Punit Yadav, Piyush Vatsa, Amit Vikram Awasthi, Abhinav Sharma, Punit Vinay, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Manmohan, J.
1. Present appeals have been filed challenging the judgment and order dated 13 th March, 2023 passed by the High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi allowing the writ petitions filed by the Respondents herein and quashing the First Information Report (‘FIR’) being Deoghar Kunda P.S. Case No.169 of 2022 registered against the Respondentsaccused persons for commission of alleged offences under Sections 336, 447 and 448 of Indian Penal Code, 1860 (‘IPC’) and Sections 10 and 11A of the Aircraft Act, 1934 holding that the FIR is vitiated by mala fides and allowing the proceedings to continue would amount to abuse of law. The High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi while quashing the FIR has held as under:- “26. In view of the above facts, reasons and analysis and considering that Aircraft took off after permission of the ATC, Aircraft Act, 1934 is itself complete code and there are [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1913State of Jharkhand v. Dr. Nishkant Dubey & Ors. procedure prescribed therein to lodge the complaint and of the enquiry, in view of the Act, the competent authority has not complained anything, even Airport Director has been made accused and even the two sons of the petitioner no. 1 has not been spared and considering that when the Special Act is there, Sections of Indian Penal Code are not attracted, petitioner no.1 and 4 in W.P.(Cr.) No. 448 of 2022 are Member of Parliament and petitioner no.1 is Chairman of the Airport Advisory Committee of Deoghar Airport and petitioner no.4 is also a member of the Standing Committee, Civil Aviation, further considering the materials on record which suggests that several cases have been lodged against the petitioner no.1 in W.P.(Cr.) No. 448 of 2022 which have been quashed by this Court and some judgments are affirmed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, it transpires that F.I.R. has been lodged malafidely and allowing to continue the proceeding will amount the abuse of process of law, accordingly, the F.I.R. bearing Deoghar Kunda P.S. Case No. 169 of 2022 including the entire criminal proceeding registered under sections 336, 447 and 448 of the Indian Penal Code and section 10 and 11A of the Airport Act, 1934, pending in the Court of learned Sub Divisional Magistrate, Dumka, is hereby quashed.”
FACTS
2. The facts, as mentioned in the FIR, are that on 31 st August, 2022 at 17:25 hours, the Respondents-accused persons boarded a chartered plane to travel from Deoghar Airport. After some time, the door of the plane opened and the pilot came down and moved towards the Air Traffic Control (‘ATC’) room as the Air Traffic Controller had denied permission for take-off. Learned counsel for Appellant-State of Jharkhand stated that the first informant who was Security-incharge in Deoghar Airport followed the pilot and when he entered the ATC room, he saw that the pilot was creating pressure for giving Respondents-accused persons clearance for take-off at the earliest. Thereafter, the other Respondents-accused persons also barged into the ATC room and created pressure for the clearance to be given to them. According to the learned counsel for the Appellant-State of Jharkhand, pursuant to the pressure exerted by the Respondents- 1914 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports accused persons, the ATC clearance was given and the chartered flight took-off at 18:17 hours even when the sunset time on that day was 18:03 hours.
ARGUMENTS ON BEHALF OF APPELLANT-STATE OF JHARKHAND
3. Learned counsel for the Appellant-State of Jharkhand stated that the ATC room is a restricted area and the Respondents-accused persons forcefully trespassed and entered the ATC room which was a serious security breach and the Respondents-accused persons threatened the ATC officers and coerced them to give permission for take-off. He stated that the ATC had denied clearance/permission to chartered flight to take-off from Deoghar Airport due to low visibility and bad weather conditions. He pointed out that the Deoghar Airport does not have the facility of night operation. He stated that by forcefully obtaining the ATC clearance by threatening and creating pressure on the ATC officers, the chartered flight with the Respondents-accused persons on board, took-off at 18:17 hours i.e., after sunset.
4. He submitted that there was a clear violation of Rule 14(ix) of Airport (Security) Rules, 2011 which empowers the Security Officer to supervise the movement of persons in the restricted areas. He contended that the said Rules of 2011 have been promulgated in exercise of powers under Section 4 read with Section 5 of the Aircraft Act, 1934. Section 5(2)(gc) of the Aircraft Act, 1934 permits the Central Government to make rules to provide for “the measures to safeguard civil aviation against acts of unlawful interference”.
5. He submitted that the High Court of Jharkhand failed to appreciate that the bar under Section 12B of the Aircraft Act, 1934 will get triggered and come into play only after the investigation is complete and the result of investigation in the form of the Final Report/Chargesheet is filed before the competent Court. According to him, Section 12B does not bar the police from registering an FIR and consequently conducting investigation arising out of the FIR.
6. He pointed out that in the context of prosecution under the Environment Protection Act, 1986 which, by virtue of Section 19, mandates that no Court shall take cognizance of an offence under this Act except on complaint made by the officers specified therein, the Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in Navi Mumbai Environment Preservation Society and Anr. vs. Ministry of [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1915State of Jharkhand v. Dr. Nishkant Dubey & Ors. Environment (PIL No.218/2013) dated 22 nd December, 2016 has after considering the judgment of this Court in State (NCT) of Delhi vs. Sanjay, (2014) 9 SCC 772 held that the offence under Section 15(1) of the Environment Protection Act, 1986 is a cognizable offence and therefore, the police can register the FIR under Section 154(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short ‘Code’). The Division Bench of the Bombay High Court (speaking through one of us Hon’ble Mr. Justice A.S. Oka as his Lordship then was) held, “Therefore, if FIR is registered by the Police for the offence punishable under Section 15 of the Act of 1956, the registration of offence and investigation carried out by the police is not per se vitiated. A complaint can be made/filed by authorized officer under Clause (a) of Section 19 before the concerned Court. While filing a complaint, the authorized officer can always rely upon the material collected by the police during the investigation. The Complaint can include the material collected by the police during the investigation carried out on the basis of the FIR.” He pointed out that the High Court of Bombay in the said case, inter alia, issued the following interim direction at para 15(iii):- “(III) We clarify that registration of offences by the Police under Sub-Section (1) of Section 15 of the said Act of 1986 and the investigation carried out thereon is not per se illegal. The officers authorized under clause (a) of Section 19 can always file complaints in accordance with the said Code by relying upon the material collected during the investigation and material forming part of the charge sheet prepared by the Police.”
7. He further submitted that the finding of the High Court of Jharkhand in the impugned judgment that the Aircraft Act, 1934 is a Special Act and a complete Code in itself and therefore, IPC offences are not attracted, is erroneous and is in the teeth of the law laid down by this Court in State (NCT of Delhi) Vs. Sanjay (supra) and in Jayant & Ors. Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh, (2021) 2 SCC 670. The relevant portion of the judgment relied upon in State (NCT of Delhi) Vs. Sanjay (supra) is reproduced herein below:- “69. Considering the principles of interpretation and the wordings used in Section 22, in our considered opinion, the provision is not a complete and absolute bar for taking 1916 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports action by the police for illegal and dishonestly committing theft of minerals including sand from the riverbed….
xxx xxx xxx xxx
72. From a close reading of the provisions of the MMDR Act and the offence defined under Section 378 IPC, it is manifest that the ingredients constituting the offence are different. The contravention of terms and conditions of mining lease or doing mining activity in violation of Section 4 of the Act is an offence punishable under Section 21 of the MMDR Act, whereas dishonestly removing sand, gravel and other minerals from the river, which is the property of the State, out of the State’s possession without the consent, constitute an offence of theft. Hence, merely because initiation of proceeding for commission of an offence under the MMDR Act on the basis of complaint cannot and shall not debar the police from taking action against persons for committing theft of sand and minerals in the manner mentioned above by exercising power under the Code of Criminal Procedure and submit a report before the Magistrate for taking cognizance against such persons. In other words, in a case where there is a theft of sand and gravel from the government land, the police can register a case, investigate the same and submit a final report under Section 173 CrPC before a Magistrate having jurisdiction for the purpose of taking cognizance as provided in Section 190(1)(d) of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
73. After giving our thoughtful consideration in the matter, in the light of the relevant provisions of the Act vis-à-vis the Code of Criminal Procedure and the Penal Code, we are of the definite opinion that the ingredients constituting the offence under the MMDR Act and the ingredients of dishonestly removing sand and gravel from the riverbeds without consent, which is the property of the State, is a distinct offence under IPC. Hence, for the commission of offence under Section 378 IPC, on receipt of the police report, the Magistrate having jurisdiction can take cognizance of the said offence without awaiting the receipt [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1917State of Jharkhand v. Dr. Nishkant Dubey & Ors. of complaint that may be filed by the authorised officer for taking cognizance in respect of violation of various provisions of the MMDR Act. Consequently, the contrary view taken by the different High Courts cannot be sustained in law and, therefore, overruled. Consequently, these criminal appeals are disposed of with a direction to the Magistrates concerned to proceed accordingly.”
8. He also submitted that in the impugned judgment, the High Court of Jharkhand erroneously adjudicated upon disputed questions of facts even when the investigation was at a nascent stage.
9. He lastly submitted that the High Court of Jharkhand had conducted a mini trial while deciding the writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
ARGUMENTS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS-ACCUSED
10. Per contra, learned senior counsel for the Respondents-accused persons stated that the Respondent No.1 is a sitting and threetime Member of Parliament and Chairman of the Airport Advisory Committee, Deoghar Airport. He stated that Respondent No.1 was accompanied amongst others by Respondent No.4 (also a sitting Member of Parliament and a Member of Standing Committee, Civil Aviation) when his flight landed from New Delhi at Deoghar Airport. He stated that in his capacity as Chairman of the Airport Advisory Committee, Respondent No.1 disembarked from the aircraft, met the Director of the Deoghar Airport and reviewed the functioning of the airport and operational issues like night landing.
11. He contended that this routine meeting has been falsely represented by the Appellant-State of Jharkhand as a forcible trespass of the ATC room at the Deoghar Airport. He further contended that the FIR was premised on completely incorrect facts, was illegal and mala fide for the following reasons:
S.NO. REASON PARTICULARS
1. Alleged offence governed by the provisions of S e c t i o n 1 2 B o f t h e Aircraft Act.
Procedure under Section 12B of the Aircraft Act, 1934 – Precondition of complaint to be made by/with sanction of the relevant Aviation Authorities has been completely bypassed.
1918 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
2. FIR premised on an incorrect legal basis.
The basis of the FIR was that the Aircraft could be operated only till 17:30 hrs. This position is legally flawed and completely incorrect.
Rule 4 of the Aircraft Rules, 1937 clearly defines flight by night as, inter alia, a flight performed between the period of half an hour after sunset. As per FIR, on the day of alleged incident, i.e., 31 st August, 2022, the sunset was at 18:03 hours.
As per the Petitioner’s own affidavit before the High Court (para 6 at page 128 of SLP), the flight took off at 18:17 hours after the clearance from Kolkata
ATC.
Therefore, the flight take-off, being within the period of half an hour after sunset, was legal and proper.
3. Allegation in FIR of forcible entry into the ATC Room, Deoghar Airport and pressure exerted to obtain ATC clearance.
The clearance for take-off was given by the ATC, Kolkata. The ATC at Deoghar Airport neither had the authority nor the control to grant take-off clearance.
There is no allegation that the answering Respondent tried to influence take-off clearance from the ATC-Kolkata.
12. Learned senior counsel for the Respondents-accused persons submitted that the provisions of the Aircraft Act, 1934 being special law shall prevail over the Code being the general law. He pointed out that Entry 29 of the List I of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India states as follows:- “29. Airways; aircraft and air navigation; provision of aerodromes; regulation and organization of air traffic and aerodromes; provision for aeronautical education and training and regulation of such education and training provided by States and other agencies.”
13. He pointed out that Section 4A of the Aircraft Act, 1934 prescribes for the constitution of a body to be known as the “Directorate General of Civil Aviation”. Under sub-Section (2) thereof, it is provided that: [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1919State of Jharkhand v. Dr. Nishkant Dubey & Ors. “(2) The Directorate General of Civil Aviation shall be responsible for carrying out the safety oversight of regulatory functions in respect of matters specified in this Act or the rules made thereunder.”
14. Similarly, under Section 4B of the Aircraft Act, 1934 a “Bureau of Civil Aviation Security” has been constituted. Under sub-section (2) thereof, it is stated that:
“(2) The Bureau of Civil Aviation Security shall be responsible for carrying out the regulatory and oversight functions in respect of matter relating to civil aviation security specified in this Act or the rules made thereunder.”
15. He stated that under Section 4C of the Aircraft Act, 1934, a provision has been made for constituting a body named as “Aircraft Accidents Investigation Bureau”. Under sub-Section (2) thereof, it is provided that:
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.