Mahanadi Coal Fields Ltd. & Anr. v. Mathias Oram & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 22; [2025] 1 S.C.R. 158
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bela M. Trivedi, Justice Satish Chandra Sharma
- Decided
- 2 Jan 2025
- Case number
- MISCELLANEOUS APPLICATION No. 2662/2023
- Sections
- 42
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 158 : 2025 INSC 22 Mahanadi Coal Fields Ltd. & Anr.
v.
Mathias Oram & Ors.
(Miscellaneous Application No. 2662/2023 In M.A. No. 231/2019 In Special Leave Petition (C) No. 6933 of 2007)
03 January 2025 [Bela M. Trivedi* and Satish Chandra Sharma, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose as regards the extension of the term of the Claims Commission, and determining the Rehabilitation and Resettlement benefits of the villages acquired by the appellant-MCL Headnotes† Coal Bearing Areas (Acquisition and Development) Act, 1957 – Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 – Compensation claim – Rehabilitation and Resettlement benefits – Determination, of land oustees of four acquired villages – Villages acquired by the appellant-MCL – Claims Commission appointed for determining the claim of compensation in respect of vast portions of lands acquired – Commission set up for carrying out the exercise for 14 villages – Report submitted by the Commission in relation to the village Gopalpur – Recommendations approved and made it an order of the Court – Following the Gopalpur model, the Commission submitted further reports which were approved – Several applications moved by the MCL and land owners seeking a range of directions – By order dated 03.11.2022, this Court held that the Gopalpur Model for determining the compensation was applied in respect of 10 villages which reports were approved by the courts, and the issues stood finalized and there could be no re-determination, and this Court * Author [2025] 1 S.C.R. 159Mahanadi Coal Fields Ltd. & Anr. v. Mathias Oram & Ors.
would not entertain Miscellaneous Application – In regard to four villages-Tumulia, Jhupuranga, Ratansara, and Kirpsara, no award approved on the said date – However, Miscellaneous Applications filed – Directions sought as regards extension of time to finalise the report of village Ratansara by the Nodal Officer, Claims Commissioner; directions to Commission to prepare the PAF/PDF list determining R&R benefits of any or all four remaining villages out of 14 villages acquired by the MCL; and directions to direct the Commission to decide their cases at the earliest:
Held: No further order for extension of the term of the Commission can be passed – Directions as prayed for by the Committee to direct the Commission to prepare PAF/PDF list determining the Rehabilitation and Resettlement benefits of the four villages cannot be issued – Commission entertained the cases filed by the land oustees of whose reports have already been finalized and approved by this Court – Commission also travelled beyond the directions given by this Court by entertaining the issues raised by the villagers and land oustees of four villages with regard to Rehabilitation and Resettlement benefits – Only additional exercise which the Commission had to carry out was the differential payable after the re-determination in respect of all the elements-market value, solatium, and further interest – This Court clearly earmarked the task of the Commission and of the other authorities and given final directions which had to be followed – Commission appears to have entertained the issues with regard to the suitability of resettlement sites for shifting of the eligible land oustees – Commission should not have entertained any of these issues, when all the issues alluded and dealt with thoroughly by this Court vide order dated 03.11.2022 – MCL already raised objections with regard to the method of calculation, the said issue was transferred to the High Court and is pending – High Court to decide the writ petition expeditiously – MCL to make payment towards the compensation immediately after the final judgment passed by the High Court. [Paras 15-26] List of Acts Coal Bearing Areas (Acquisition and Development) Act, 1957; Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013.
160 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports List of Keywords Compensation claim; Commission; Mahanadi Coalfields;
Compensation to land oustees; Rehabilitation and resettlement benefits; Gopalpur Model .
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Miscellaneous Application No. 2662 of 2023 In M.A. No. 231 of 2019 In Special Leave Petition (C) No. 6933 of 2007 From the Judgment and Order dated 03.11.2022 of the Supreme Court of India in MA No. 231 of 2019 And M.A. (D) No. 28318 of 2024 In M.A. No. 231 of 2019 In SLP(C) No. 6933 of 2007 With Interlocutory Application Nos. 137789 of 2024 & 137791 of 2024 And M.A. (D) No. 30630 of 2024 in SLP(C) No. 6933 of 2007 With Interlocutory Application Nos. 148429 & 148427 of 2024 Appearances for Parties K.M. Nataraj, A.S.G., Atmaram N.S. Nadkarni, Sr. Adv., Salvador Santosh Rebello, Raghav Sharma, Prateek Tanmay, Ms. Kritika, Jaskirat Pal Singh, Ms. Manisha Gupta, Ms. Arzu Paul, Ms. Deepti Arya, Rishikesh Haridas, Ms. Himanshi Nagpal, Ms. Pooja Gill, Anup Kumar, Amiya Kumar Behera, Ms. Pragya Choudhary, Ms. Shruti Singh, Mrs. Neha Jaiswal, Satyajit Mahanty, P Vamshi Rao, Abhishek Choudhury, Madhusudan Jena, Prashant Bhushan, Kamal Kishore, Ms. Kajal Giri, Tejaswi Kumar Pradhan, Manoranjan Paikaray, Ms. Anindita Pujari, Ms. Rohini Musa, Gurmeet Singh Makker, Ms. Priyanka Das, Abhishek Atrey, Sughosh Subramanyam, Pratyush Shrivastava, A. Venayagam Balan, Arvind Kumar Sharma, R. Chandrachud, Jogy Scaria, Shibashish Misra, Vishal Arun, [2025] 1 S.C.R. 161Mahanadi Coal Fields Ltd. & Anr. v. Mathias Oram & Ors.
Shankar Divate, Ashok Panigrahi, Ms. Geetanjali Das Krishnan, Mudit Sharma, Ms. Nandini Gidwaney, Satya Mitra, Rahul Shyam Bhandari, Ms. Neha Rathi, S. Verma, Aftab Ali Khan, S. K. Srivastava, Mansur Ali Khan, Gurjeet Singh, Rahat Ali Chaudhary, Ms. Mahetaba Asrar, Advs. for the appearing parties.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Bela M. Trivedi, J.
1. The captioned M.A. No. 2662 of 2023 in M.A. No. 231/2019 has been filed by the Secretary-cum-Administrative Nodal Officer, Claims Commission, Bhubaneswar seeking extension of time to finalise the report of village Ratansara.
2. The captioned M.A. (D) No.28318/2024 in M.A. No.231/2019 has been filed by the Applicant-Manikeswari Bisthapita Committee through its Secretary praying to direct the Commission to prepare the PAF/ PDF list determining R&R benefits of any or all four remaining Villages namely Tumulia, Jhupurunga, Kiripsira and Ratansara out of 14 villages acquired by the MCL in compliance of the order dated 03.11.2022 passed by this Court in M.A. No. 231 of 2019.
3. The captioned M.A. (D) No.30630/2024 has been filed by the eight applicants praying to direct the Commission to decide their cases at the earliest.
4. It may be noted that the Claims Commission had submitted the status report showing the progress of the proceedings before it as on 27.06.2024, pursuant to the order passed by this Court on 23.01.2024. Vide the said order dated 23.01.2024, this Court had extended the term of the Commission till 15.07.2024, after recording the statement of the Secretary of the Commission that the Commission shall finalise the claims in respect of Village Ratansara by June, 2024. This Court had also directed the Commission to submit the report with regard to the finalization of the claims in respect of the Village Ratansara on or before 01.07.2024. The Commission, therefore, has submitted the report dated 01.07.2024 updating the Court about the term of the Commission and the work pending with the Commission. 162 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
5. As per the Status Report submitted by the Claims Commission, the work pending before the Commission as on 27.06.2024 was as under: - “(i) To dispose of 2836 (2581 as on 31 st December, 2023 + 255 in 2024) Nos. of Civil Cases and 232 (228 + 4)
Nos. of Misc.
Cases filed by land oustees of 10 villages pursuant to orders of the Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 15.07.2013 and 10.07.2017.
(ii) To dispose of 24 (16+8) Nos. of cases pursuant to the direction of the High Court of Orissa issued in various Writ petitions.
(iii) To dispose of 194 (57+137) Nos. of cases filed by the villagers of Jhupurunga and Tumulia after finalization of the Report for substitution of legal heirs of awardees and correction of computer-generated mistakes.
(iv) To Certify suitability of Rehabilitation sites for shifting of eligible land oustees who are entitled to R&R benefits. Once the Rehabilitation site is ready, the Commission shall issue necessary certificate as directed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court vide order dated 10.7.2017.
(v) Determination of R&R benefits of land oustees of 4 acquired villages namely Jhupurunga, Tumulia, Kiripsira and Ratansara by the Commission subject to appropriate direction of the Hon’ble Supreme Court to that effect.”
6. The Original Writ Petitioner i.e., Mahanadi Coalfields Limited (MCL) has filed a detailed reply to the Part-I report for Village Ratansara dated 27.06.2024 and to the progress status report dated 27.06.2024. Raising objections against the report of Village Ratansara dated 27.06.2024 submitted by the Claims Commission, the MCL has stated that the Claims Commission had completely erred in its methodology of calculating the compensation for Village Ratansara and has also ignored the express directions of this Court given vide judgment dated 03.11.2022 passed in M.A. No. 231 of 2019 in SLP (C) No. 6933 of 2007. According to the MCL, since the MCL had objected to the Commission’s methodology of calculation, this Court vide the order dated 10.10.2023 had transferred the issue to the High Court of Orissa. The W.P. (C) No. 39185 of 2023 preferred before the High Court in this regard is pending. It is further stated by the MCL [2025] 1 S.C.R. 163Mahanadi Coal Fields Ltd. & Anr. v. Mathias Oram & Ors.
that so far as the payment of compensation for the structures was concerned, the MCL has already made payment without prejudice to rights and contentions as regards the calculation method.
7. As regards the other pending work shown by the Commission in its status report dated 27.06.2024, the petitioner MCL has raised strong objections by preparing following tabular chart:
S.
No Purported pending works mentioned by Claims Commission Ground of MCL for closure of the Commission 01 To dispose of 2836 Nos. of Civil Cases and 232 Nos. of Misc. Cases filed by land oustees of 10 villages.
At para 68.iii.c of order dated 03.11.2022, this Hon’ble Court had directed that, “ This court is of the opinion that the Commission could not reopen determinations based upon change of policies of the State given that the benefits adjudicated by it based on factual determinations has crystallised.
In many cases, MCL has actually provided employment to several individuals. Consequently, it is held that all cases that have been adjudicated and were approved by this court cannot be reopened”. Since the PAF list of the 10 villages have been approved by the Hon’ble Court, the Claims Commission cannot re-open those cases.
Subsequently Hon’ble Court in its order dated 10.10.2023 had directed that, “ in case of any grievance by any party with respect to any order or report of the Claims Commission, the grievance should be first articulated before the High Court, in appropriate proceedings.” The Commission cannot hear all of such cases as is sought to be heard, as the same pertain to the villages whose reports have already been finalised, and have been approved by this Hon’ble Court and this Hon’ble Court has thereafter in express directions given vide Judgement dated 03.11.2022 stated that there shall not be any re-opening in so far as the 10 villages are concerned. Thus, the act of the Claims Commission would amount to re-opening of cases which have already attained finality and the same cannot be permitted. In view of the above, the Claims Commission cannot re-open the cases of 10 villages.
164 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports 02 In 24 Nos. of writ petitions Hon’ble High Court has directed the Claims Commission to dispose these cases.
The Claims Commission is hearing cases in so far as the 10 villages which issues have already attained finality. The said issues were kept pending by the Claims Commission and not decided in order to prolong the work of the Claims Commission instead of completing the main task assigned by this Hon’ble Court. This Hon’ble Court has vide its Order dated 03.11.2022 passed in M.A No. 231 of 2019 expressly directed that all the issues which have attained finality in so far as the 10 villages the same shall not be re-opened, and therefore, the question of hearing or deciding any of such cases by the Claims Commission does not arise.
03 To dispose of 194 Nos. of cases filed by the villagers of Jhupurunga and Tumulia.
The villages acquired under CBA by MCL, apart from the villages in Sundargarh District, R&R Policy of Govt. of Odisha, 2006 is applicable and District Collector is the competent authority to redress the grievances, pertaining to R&R benefits, of the project affected families.
As per para 68.iii.a of the judgement dated 3.11.2022 of this Hon’bie Court the R&R Policy 2006 as amended by the 2013 policy more specifically Clause 20, clearly provides that there shall be a District and Directorate Level grievance redressal mechanism for project affected persons. The same has been set up and can hear all of such grievances if any.
Hence, the Collector, Sundargarh can also hear the grievance related to R&R benefits of these 04 villages as is similarly done in other areas. In case of any grievance regarding amount of compensation or apportionment of compensation, CBA Tribunal is constituted w/s 17 of CBA Act, 1957 to hear the grievances of the project affected families (land losers). A Statutory Tribunal set up under the CBA Act is functioning in Jharsuguda District Odisha. As there is well settled mechanism in the Odisha R&R Policy and in CBA Act to redress the grievance of the affected families (land losers), the same can be dealt with appropriately.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 165Mahanadi Coal Fields Ltd. & Anr. v. Mathias Oram & Ors.
04 Certify the suitability of Resettlement sites for shifting of eligible land oustees, as directed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court vide order dated 10.07.2017 At para 68.iv.a of order 03.11.2022, this Hon’ble Court had directed that:
“On the point of housing plots, it is hereby declared and directed that the State and MCL are under an obligation to ensure that the land acquired by it in those areas which are to be developed, have to be developed. The State Government shall ensure that at least three nodal officers from the departments concerned are deployed for facilitating this task of coordinating with allagencies and ensuring that the development of the plots duly takes place to enable the Collector to make the necessary allotments within the time indicated”.
Hence, the commission has no role to play in Resettlement sites for either allotment of plots or shifting of the project displaced families.
05 Determining R&R benefits of land oustees of 4 acquired villages, namely Tumulia, Kiripsira, Jhupurunga, and Ratansara, the Commission subject to the appropriate direction of the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
The Petitioner MCL, the Land oustees, and District Administration after holding a meeting, addressed a letter dated 25.01.2024 (at page 59 of the Vol-Il documents of Claims Commission dated 27.06.2024), to the Claims Commission to prepare the PAF list. However, the Claims Commission vide its Letter dated 12.02.2024 (at page 71 of the Vol-II documents of Claims Commission dated 27.06.2024) refused to do the same, stating that there is no direction from this Hon’ble Court to prepare the PAF list. In order to obviate any further delays, the Petitioner MCL herein itself preparing and finalising the PAF list for village Jhupurunga as per the principle set by this Hon’ble Court in M.A. 231 of 2019 in SLP(C) No. 6933 of 2007 dated 03.11.2022, in consultation with the 03 nodal officers appointed by State Government. After preparation of PAF lists it will be sent to Collector, Sundargarh for approval. On approval of the PAF list by Collector, Rehabilitation & Resettlement benefits will be provided to the villagers according to the approved list. The same procedure is being followed in other districts coming under the coalfield area of MCL in the state of Odisha. Similarly, the PAF list for Tumulia, would be prepared by the Petitioner MCL. In so far as village Kiripsira and Ratansara 166 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports is concerned, the same does not fall within the Coal Block of MCL, and this Hon’ble Court vide its Order dated 15.07.2013 passed in SLP (C) No. 6933 of 2007, stated that since village Ratanrasa and Kiripsara was transferred by the Union of India to other companies, only payment of compensation is the liability of MCL and it may recover the said amount from the successor company. The Petitioner states that it is also pertinent to note that the in practice, and otherwise in all acquisitions the modality adopted is that the Petitioner MCL carries out the survey and preparation of the Project Affected Persons (PAF) list and thereafter the same is submitted to the District Administration which verifies the same and consequent to such verification the District Collector approves the PAF list. Once such PAF list receives the approval from the District Collector, the Petitioner MCL extends the R&R benefits to the persons as figuring in the approved PAF List. Hence, the commission has no role either in preparation of PAF list or in extending employment & Monetary Compensation.
8. We had heard the concerned learned counsels for the parties on 06.08.2024 permitting them to file brief note of submissions, which they have filed.
9. Though the case has a chequered history, to put it in nutshell, the Claims Commission was appointed by this Court vide the order dated 19.07.2010 passed in SLP(C) No. 6933 of 2007, for determining the claim of compensation in respect of vast portions of lands acquired by the Central Government in Village Gopalpur and others of the District Sundergarh, Orissa. The said Commission was set up for carrying out the exercise for the following villages.
(i) Sardega
(ii) Jhupurunga
(iii) Ratansara
(iv) Tikilipara
(v) Siarmal
(vi) Tumulia [2025] 1 S.C.R. 167Mahanadi Coal Fields Ltd. & Anr. v. Mathias Oram & Ors.
(vii) Karlikachhar
(viii) Kulda
(ix) Bankibahal
(x) Balinga
(xi) Garjanbahal
(xii) Bangurkela
(xiii) Kiripsira
(xiv) Lalma R.F.
10. Out of the afore stated villages, part payment was already made at the relevant time in case of villages Sardega and Tikilipara and full payment was made in case of villages Bankibahal and Balinga, however the possession was not fully taken.
11. Based on the Report submitted by the Claims Commission in relation to the village Gopalpur, this Court had passed an order dated 19.04.2012 approving the recommendations contained therein and made it an order of the Court.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.