Ashok Saxena v. The State of Uttarakhand Etc.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 148; [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1454
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 30 Jan 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1704/2015
- Sections
- 301, 300, 304, 302, 34, 161, 209, 313, 307, 304A
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 1454 : 2025 INSC 148 Ashok Saxena v.
The State of Uttarakhand Etc.
(Criminal Appeal No(s). 1704-1705 of 2015)
30 January 2025 [J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the High Court committed any error in holding the appellant guilty of the offence of murder.
Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – s.301, exception 4 to s.300, s.304 Part-I – Murder – Culpable homicide by causing death of person other than person whose death was intended – Culpable homicide not murder if it is committed without premeditation in a sudden fight – When – On facts, altercation between the parties – Appellant armed with knife and co-accused with hockey stick trespassed into the house of the first informant with the intention to lay an assault on him – Informant’s wife intervened and in the process the appellant alleged to have inflicted knife blow in the abdomen of the wife, resulting in her death – Trial court acquitted the appellant, however, the High Court convicted him u/s.302 – Correctness:
Held: Even for the sake of argument, the appellant had no intention to cause death of the deceased, the doctrine of transfer of malice, as contemplated u/s.301 applicable to the instant case and the appellant would be guilty u/s.302 – Having regard to the genesis of the occurrence, the case falls within exception 4 to s.300 – Impugned judgment modified – Appellant to be convicted for the offence punishable u/s.304 Part-I and sentence reduced to the period already undergone since incident is of 1992 and that the appellant is aged 74 years. [Paras 36-46] Case Law Cited Gyanendra Kumar v. State of U.P., AIR 1972 SC 502; Hari Shankar Sharma v. State of Mysore, 1979 UJ 659 (SC); Jagpal Singh v. State of Punjab, AIR 1991 SC 982 : 1991 CrLJ 597; Abdul Ise Suleman v. State of Gujarat, 1995 CrLJ 464 – referred to. [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1455Ashok Saxena v. The State of Uttarakhand Etc. List of Acts Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Penal Code, 1860.
List of Keywords Murder; Culpable homicide by causing death of person other than person whose death was intended; Altercation between the parties; Intention to lay assault; Doctrine of transfer of malice. Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No(s). 1704-1705 of 2015 From the Judgment and Order dated 20.01.2015 of the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital in GA No. 82 of 2001 and CRLR No. 359 of 2001 Appearances for Parties Narender Hooda, Sr. Adv., Jasbir Singh Malik, Ms. Rhythm Bharadwaj, Ms. Suman Sharma, Ms. Niharika Singh, Varun Punia, Advs. for the Appellant.
Sudarshan Singh Rawat, Ms. Saakshi Singh Rawat, Sunny Sachin Rawat, Ajay Kumar Bahuguna, Advs. for the Respondents. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Order
1. These appeals arise from the judgment and order passed by the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital dated 20-01-2015 by which the appeal filed by the State of Uttar Pradesh came to be allowed and thereby the judgment and Order of acquittal passed by the Trial Court in Sessions Case No. 204 of 1994 came to be set aside.
2. Since, we intend to dispose of this appeal on a short ground we need not reproduce the facts or rather the case of the prosecution in details. We borrow the facts as stated by the High Court in its impugned judgment and order. We quote the relevant part of the High Court’s judgment:- “Present Govt. Appeal has been filed by the State being aggrieved against the judgment and order dated 06.11.1996 1456 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports passed by learned 2nd Addl. Sessions Judge, Nainital, whereby the respondents were acquitted of the charge(s) levelled against them. Respondent Ashok Saxena was exonerated of the charge levelled against him under Section 302 IPC and the respondent no. 2 Yashpal Singh was exonerated of the charge levelled against him under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC, giving them benefit of doubt. Respondent Yashpal Singh died during the pendency of the Govt. Appeal, on 24.01.2007, which fact is admitted to both the sides and therefore, this Court proceeds to discuss the appeal only against respondent no. 1 Ashok Saxena filed by the State.
2. Earlier, on a Govt. Appeal, being Govt. Appeal No. 82 of 2001 and Criminal Revision, being Criminal Revision No. 359 of 2001 filed by the revisionist, Division Bench of this Court held Ashok Saxena guilty of the offence punishable under Section 302 IPC and also held Yashpal Singh guilty of the offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC. They were accordingly convicted and sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life, as also to pay fine of Rs. 5,000/- each, vide order dated 14.07.2010.
3. Present respondent i.e. Ashok Saxena filed Criminal Appeal Nos. 963 -964 of 2011 before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and the Hon’ble Apex Court, among other things, was pleased to direct as under:
“In the above view of the matter, we are satisfied that the judgment/order dated 14.07.2010 rendered by the High Court in Government Appeal No. 82 of 2001 and Criminal Revision No. 359 of 2001, as against the appellant herein deserve to be set aside. The same are accordingly set aside and the matter is remanded back and restored on the file of the High Court. The High Court of Uttarakhand shall re-adjudicate the Government Appeal no. 82 of 2001 and Criminal Revision No. 359 of 2001 in accordance with law. The appellant shall enter appearance through counsel before the High Court of Uttarakhand on 19.11.2014. In case [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1457Ashok Saxena v. The State of Uttarakhand Etc. the appellant remains unrepresented, it will be open to the High Court to appoint an amicus curiae to assist it on behalf of the appellant”.
4. Thereafter, in the light of the directions of Hon’ble the Apex Court dated 15.10.2014, this Court proceeded to hear the Govt. Appeal as well as Criminal Revision afresh.
5. Whereas the State was represented by Mr. A.S. Gill, Deputy Advocate General with Mr. Milind Raj, Brief Holder for the State, the respondent Ashok Saxena by Mr. Lok Pal Singh, Advocate.
6. PW-1 Het Ram wrote a complaint (Ext. Ka-1) to SHO police station Kichha, District Nainital on 25.06.1992 enumerating the facts contained therein that the complainant is residing in Hydel Colony Kichcha; his son Joginder Singh used to go for learning typing and Surendra Singh S/o Yashpal Singh was also learning typing there. There was an altercation between Joginder Singh and Surender Singh at the typing centre; Joginder Singh narrated the incident of altercations at his home and his nephew-Man Singh made complaint to the father of Surender Singh. Thereafter, Surender Singh did marpeet with Joginder Singh and the complainant made complaint to his superior officers in this regard. On the day of incident, when nephew of complainant, accompanied with Joginder, had gone to typing centre, in the way, accused Ashok Saxena and Yashpal Singh met them and they threatened them with dire consequences. The son and nephew of the complainant reached home and narrated the entire story to the deceased. Accused persons Ashok Saxena and Yashpal also reached there and started hurling abuses at them. When the complainant came back from his duty, the entire story was narrated to him. On this, the complainant came outside his house and asked the accused persons not to hurl abusive languages, to which both the accused got annoyed. At that time, Ashok Saxena was having knife in his hand and Yashpal Singh was armed with hockey stick and they chased the complainant and entered into 1458 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports his house. In the meantime, when wife of the complainant came to his rescue, Ashok Saxena gave a knife blow in the stomach of his wife and Yashpal Singh caught hold of the hands of the victim. There was candlelight in the house. The incident took place at about 7:45 p.m. The complainant tried to catch hold of the accused persons, but they fled away. On receiving knife blow, wife of complainant fell down on the floor and she was taken to hospital in a rickshaw, where doctors declared her ‘brought dead’.”
3. Thus, it appears from the above that the nephew of the first informant along with Joginder were learning typewriting & for that they used to attend a typing institute.
4. While both were on their way to the typing centre, the appellant herein namely Ashok Saxena and the co-accused Yashpal Singh (since deceased) met them and threatened them with dire consequences. The two boys reached home and narrated the entire episode first before the deceased and then upon arrival of Hetram in the evening, the same was conveyed to him also.
5. The aforesaid was the starting point of all the trouble for both the families.
6. It appears that the appellant herein with a knife in his hand and Yashpal Singh (since deceased) with a hockey stick in his hand trespassed into the house of the first informant with the intention to lay an assault on him. The deceased i.e. the wife of Hetram, sensing trouble tried to intervene and in the process the appellant herein is alleged to have inflicted a knife blow in the abdomen of the deceased. Of-course there are allegations that at the relevant point of time the co-accused(deceased) had caught hold of the hands of the deceased.
7. The aforesaid incident took place at about 7.45 p.m. Hetram tried to catch hold of the accused persons but they managed to make good their escape.
8. The deceased having suffered a stab serious injury in her abdomen was put in a rikshaw for being taken to the hospital. However, she was declared dead on being brought to the hospital.
9. The First Information Report (FIR) was lodged by Hetram at the Kichan Police Station, Nainital on 25.6.1992, which reads thus:- [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1459Ashok Saxena v. The State of Uttarakhand Etc. “To
SHO
Police Station Kichan, Nainital Sir, It is submitted that I am living with my family in the Hydril Colony, Kichan. My son Joginder Singh goes to learn typing in Kichan since last 4-5 days and at the same shop, Yashpal Singh’s son Surinder Singh also learns typing. Day before yesterday, my son Joginder had a heated arguments with Yashpal’s son Surinder at the typing shop. When my son came home and told about this, my nephew Man Singh went and lodged complaint about this to Surinder’s father at his house. On this, Surinder beat my son Joginder in the evening in the colony. I complained about this to my officers. Earlier also, I have made several similar complaints to my officers. To avoid a quarrel, in the evening my nephew went to pick up Joginder from the typing shop. On the way, they meet Ashok Saxena and Yashpal Singh both on the scooter and said that you keep complaining for no reason at all and today we shall see you. At that time, my nephew and son escaped and came home and told everything to his mother and following them Yashpal also came to his house and sat at his door and started abusing when electricity went off. I finished my duty and came home and with me, my acquaintance Chandra Shekhar Mohalla Kishanpur had also come. Then I was told the whole thing. I went out and stopped Yashpal and Ashok Saxena from abusing then both peoples stood up in anger and Ashok Saxena with a knife in his hand and Yashpal Singh with a hockey in hand ran after me. I ran inside my house. As soon as both these persons entered my house, my wife came forward to save me. Ashok Saxena stabbed my wife with a knife from the front and Yashpal, while abusing held both hands of my wife. Candles were lighted in the house. This incident took place at about quarter to 7.45 pm. I immediately tried to catch them both but could not get hold of them and they ran off. After being stabbed with knife my wife fell down on the floor. I immediately put her in a rickshaw and took her to the hospital where 1460 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the doctors declared my wife as dead. Dead body of my wife is kept in the Kichan Hospital. Please oblige me by writing my report and taking necessary action.”
10. On the FIR being registered the investigation started. The inquest Panchnama of the dead body of the deceased was drawn in the presence of two independent Panch witnesses. The body of the deceased was sent to the hospital for post mortem.
11. The post mortem revealed the following two injuries:- “1. Cut wound 3cm x Yi cm deep till the cavity on the stomach towards the left 10 cm above the mid claride line and diagonal. On opening the wound muscles of stomach, walls, fragments, and left lobe of the liver was found to be cut.
2. On internal examination right portion of the heart was full of blood and left was empty. Around 11/2 liters blood was present in the stomach cavity. Some undigested food was present in the intestine.”
12. The clothes and other articles of the deceased as well those of the accused persons were collected and sent to the Forensic Science Laboratory for chemical analysis. Statements of various witnesses were recorded by the police under Section 161 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 (for short the “Cr.P.C.”)
13. Upon completion of the investigation chargesheet was filed for the offence of murder.
14. The case came to be committed to the Court of Sessions under the provisions of Section 209 of the Cr.P.C. Upon committal, the case came to be registered in the Court of Additional Sessions Judge II, Nainital as Sessions Case No. 204 of 1994.
15. The Trial Court framed charge to which both the accused persons pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
16. The prosecution examined the following witnesses:- “PW 1 Hetram (Informant)
PW 2 Joginder Singh (Son of deceased)
PW 3 Surinder Singh (S.I. & I.O.)
PW 4 Dr. Anil Kumar Tiwari (conducted post mortem)”
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 1461Ashok Saxena v. The State of Uttarakhand Etc.
17. The prosecution also led few pieces of documentary evidence.
18. Upon closure of the recording of the oral evidence the further statements of the appellant herein and the co-accused were recorded under Section 313 of the Cr.P.C., to which both claimed to be innocent and said that they were falsely implicated.
19. The Trial Court upon appreciation of the oral as well as documentary evidence on record came to the conclusion that the prosecution had failed to establish its case beyond reasonable doubt and accordingly acquitted both the accused.
20. The State went in appeal before the High Court. The High Court allowed the appeal. Against the order passed by the High Court allowing the appeal filed by the State and holding the appellant herein guilty of the alleged offence, the appellant came before this Court by filing Criminal Appeal Nos. 963-964 of 2011 respectively. This Court vide a order dated 15.10.2014 disposed of both the appeals in the following terms:- “Heard learned counsel for the parties.
It is not a matter of dispute that the appellant herein was prosecuted in furtherance of FIR S.T.No.204 of 1994 dated 25.06.1992 lodged at police station Kichan, Nainital. The Trial Court, namely, the Additional Sessions Judge-II, Nainital while proceeding against the appellant in Sessions Case No.204 of 1994 acquitted the appellant, as also, his co-accused Yashpal Singh vide judgment/order dated 06.11.1996.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.