Maniklal Sahu v. State of Chhattisgarh
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1107; [2025] 10 S.C.R. 212
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 12 Sept 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 5578/2024
- Sections
- 307, 300, 302, 299, 100, 337, 304, 324
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 10 S.C.R. 212 : 2025 INSC 1107 Maniklal Sahu v.
State of Chhattisgarh (Criminal Appeal No. 5578 of 2024)
12 September 2025 [J.B. Pardiwala* and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the High Court committed any error in bringing the case within the ambit of “attempt to commit murder” punishable u/s.307 IPC on the ground that the deceased-R died after a period of nine months from the date of the incident.
Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – First limb of s.300 – Fatal injury – Intention to cause death – Death occurs after several days of complications – Principle that Courts must remember:
Held: If it is proved that the injury was fatal and the intention was to cause death, though the death occurred after several days of septicaemia or other complications having supervened, yet it is undoubtedly a murder as it falls within the first limb of s.300 of the IPC. [Para 69(a)] Penal Code, 1860 – Third limb of s.300 – Injuries sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature – Intended injuries – Death occurs after complications – Principle that Courts must remember:
Held: If it is proved that the injuries by themselves were sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature, and if it is established that those injuries were the intended injuries, though the death might have occurred after septicaemia or other complications had supervened, yet the act of the accused would squarely fall under the third limb of s.300 of the IPC and the accused is therefore liable to be punished u/s.302 of the IPC. [Para 69(b)] * Author [2025] 10 S.C.R. 213Maniklal Sahu v. State of Chhattisgarh Penal Code, 1860 – Fourth limb of s.300 – Injuries imminently dangerous to life – Death occurs after complications – Principle that Courts must remember:
Held: If it is proved that the injuries were imminently dangerous to life, though the death had occurred after septicaemia or other complications had supervened, yet the act of the accused would squarely fall under the fourth limb of s.300 of the IPC, provided, the other requirements like knowledge on the part of the accused, etc. are satisfied and so the accused would be liable to be punished u/s.302 of the IPC – Here also, the primary cause of the death is the injuries and septicaemia. [Para 66(c)] Penal Code, 1860 – s.300 – When injuries inflicted were sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death – Relevancy of skilful and efficient medical treatment:
Held: In judging whether the injuries inflicted were sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death, the possibility that skilful and efficient medical treatment might prevent the fatal result is wholly irrelevant. [Para 66(d)] Penal Code, 1860 – s.300 – When the supervening causes are attributable to the injuries caused – Whether the person inflicting the injuries is liable for causing death:
Held: If the supervening causes are attributable to the injuries caused, then the person inflicting the injuries is liable for causing death, even if death was not the direct result of the injuries. [Para 66(e)] Penal Code, 1860 – s.302 – The Courts to distinguish two types of cases i.e. first where the intervening cause of death, like peritonitis, is only a remote consequence of the injury and second where the complication which is the intervening cause of death is itself a practically inevitable sequence to the injury: Held: Broadly speaking, the courts would have to undertake the exercise to distinguish between two types of cases; first, where the intervening cause of death, like peritonitis, is only a remote and a rather improbable consequence of the injury; then it can be said that the injury is one which may, in particular circumstances, result in death, but which may not in ordinary course of nature be likely to lead to it – Secondly, where the complication which is the intervening cause of death is itself a practically inevitable 214 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports sequence to the injury – In that event, the probability is very high indeed, amounting to practical certainty i.e., death is a result in due course of natural events – A deep abdominal thrust with a knife followed by injury to the internal organs is practically certain to result in acute peritonitis causing death – It is clearly a case of murder u/s.302 and not merely of culpable homicide. [Para 66(f)] Penal Code, 1860 – s.300 – The Courts are to always look into the nature of the injuries found on the body of the deceased and infer whether assailants intended to cause death of the deceased, irrespective of the medical evidence:
Held: Even when the medical evidence does not say that any one of the injuries on the body of the deceased was sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature, yet it is open to the Court to look into the nature of the injuries found on the body of the deceased and infer from them that the assailants intended to cause death of the deceased – If none of the injuries alone were sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause the death of the deceased, cumulatively, they may be sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause his death. [Para 66(g)] Penal Code, 1860 – s.300 – What is significant is whether death was only a remote possibility, or is one which would have occurred in due course:
Held: What the courts must see is whether the injuries were sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death, or to cause such bodily injuries as the accused knew to be likely to cause death although death was ultimately due to supervention of some other cause – An intervening cause or complication is by itself not of such significance – What is significant is whether death was only a remote possibility, or is one which would have occurred in due course. [Para 66(h)] Penal Code, 1860 – s.300 – When the death is delayed due to later complications – The Courts must consider the nature of the injury, complications or the attending circumstances: Held: Where death is delayed due to later complications or developments, the courts should consider the nature of the injury, complications or the attending circumstances – If the complications or developments are the natural, or probable, or necessary consequence of the injury, and if it is reasonably contemplated as [2025] 10 S.C.R. 215Maniklal Sahu v. State of Chhattisgarh its result, the injury could be said to have caused death – If on the other hand, the chain of consequences is broken, or if there is unexpected complication causing new mischief, the relation of cause and effect is not established, or the causal connection is too remote then the injury cannot be said to have caused death – If the original injury itself is of a fatal nature, it makes no difference that death is actually caused by a complication naturally flowing from the injury and not the injury itself, since causal connection is proximate. [Para 66(i)] Penal Code, 1860 – s.302 and s.307 – Allegation that appellant along with the other co-accused threw victim-deceased from the terrace of the house and thereafter assaulted him with sticks and fisticuffs – Victim died after nine months from the date of incident on account of septicemia and pneumonia leading to cardiorespiratory arrest – In such circumstances, s.302 of IPC was added – Trial Court convicted appellant and the coaccused for the offence of murder and were sentenced to life imprisonment – However, the High Court altered the conviction of the appellant herein and the other co-accused from s.302 of the IPC to one u/s.307 of the IPC and sentenced them to undergo 7 years of rigorous imprisonment – Correctness: Held: In the present case, as per the oral testimony of the three doctors referred, the cause of death of deceased-R was cardiorespiratory failure – The injuries suffered by him at the time of assault lead to septic shock with bilateral pneumonia, post traumatic spinal cord injury with paraplegia and infected bedsore hepatic dysfunction – The injuries suffered by the deceased were sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death and would come under clause “Thirdly” of s.300 of the IPC – The deceased ultimately died having not recovered from the injuries – The presence of the supervening cause in the circumstances will not alter the culpability – In the case in hand, there had been no such considerable change of circumstances as to snap the chain of causation – The High Court erred in recording the finding that the deceased succumbed to the injuries suffered by him due to lack of proper treatment – There is absolutely no evidence in this regard – According to the High Court, since, the deceased died after about nine months from the date of the incident due to lack of proper treatment the case is not one of murder – This finding is erroneous – The High Court committed a serious error in bringing the case within the ambit of attempt to commit murder punishable u/s.307 of the IPC. [Paras 67, 68, 70] 216 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Penal Code, 1860 – s.307 – Ingredients to constitute the offence of attempt to commit murder:
Held: The most important ingredient to constitute the offence of attempt to commit murder punishable u/s.307 of the IPC is the intention or knowledge – To bring home guilt against an accused under this provision, it is necessary for the prosecution to establish that the intention of the accused was one of the three kinds mentioned in s.300 of the IPC – A person commits an offence u/s.307 of the IPC when he has the intention to commit murder and in pursuance of that intention, does an act towards its commission irrespective of the fact whether that act is the penultimate act or not – The provision requires that the act must be done with such intention, or knowledge, or in such circumstances that if death be caused by that act, the offence of murder will emerge. [Para 30] Case Law Cited Prasad Pradhan & Anr. v. State of Chhattisgarh [2023] 1 SCR 241 : (2023) 11 SCC 320; Patel Hiralal Joitaram v. State of Gujarat [2001] Supp. 4 SCR 378 : (2002) 1 SCC 22; State of Haryana v. Pala & Ors. [1996] 1 SCR 1022 : (1996) 8 SCC 51; Jagtar Singh & Anr. v. State of Punjab (1999) 2 SCC 174 – relied on. Sudershan Kumar v. State of Delhi [1975] 2 SCR 520 : (1975) 3 SCC 831 – referred to.
Sreedharan v. State of Kerala, 1969 SCC OnLine Ker 46; Emperor v. Vasudeo Balwant Gogte, 1932 SCC OnLine Bom 1; In re, Maragatham (Madras High Court); In re, Periaswami C.A. 166 of 1961 (Mad); Nga Moe v. The King, AIR 1941 Rang 141; In re, Doraswami, 1943 SCC OnLine Mad 208 – referred to. Reg. v. Cassidy (1867) 4 Bom. H.C. (Cr. C.) 17; R. v. Whybrow, 1951-35-Crl. Appl. 141; R v. Grimwood 1962-(3)-AER. 285; Director of Public Prosecutions v. Smith, 1961-AC. 290; Brintons Ltd. v. Turvey, 1905 AC 230, 233, the Earl of Halsbury L.C.; R. v. Holland (1841) 2 M and Rob 351; (1904) 1 Cri LJ 909 – referred to. Books and Periodicals Taylor’s Principles and Practice of Medical Jurisprudence, 11th Edn. Vol. 1, at page 232; The Essentials of Modern Surgery by [2025] 10 S.C.R. 217Maniklal Sahu v. State of Chhattisgarh Handfield Jones and Pokitt, V Edn]; Mayne’s Criminal Law of India, 4th Edn., at p. 477; Male’s Pleas of the Crown, Volume I, page 28; Russel on Crime, 12th Edn., Vol. 1 at page 28 – referred to. List of Acts Penal Code, 1860.
List of Keywords Section 307 of IPC; Section 300 of IPC; Section 302 of IPC; First limb of s.300 of IPC; Thirs limb of s.300 of IPC; Fourth limb of s.300 of IPC; Fatal injury; Intention to cause death; Death occurring after several days; Septic shock with bilateral pneumonia; Post traumatic spinal cord injury with paraplegia and infected bedsore hepatic dysfunction; Medical treatment; Supervening causes; Injuries sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature. Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
5578 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 30.07.2024 of the High Court of Chhatisgarh at Bilaspur in CRA No. 607 of 2023 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Padmesh Mishra, Ms. Vastvikta Bhardwaj, Ms. Neelam Singh, Vijant.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Mrs. Prerna Dhall, Shivam Ganeshia, Ms. Akanksha Singh, Ambuj Swaroop, Kapil Katare, Prashant Singh, Ms. Rajnandani Kumari. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment J.B. Pardiwala, J.
For the convenience of exposition, this judgment is divided into the following parts:- 218 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports INDEX* A. FACTUAL MATRIX ..................................................................... 2
B. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT ............... 3
C. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE STATE 4
D. ANALYSIS .................................................................................. 5 i. When is an offence said to be made under Section 307 of the IPC ........................................................................ 12 ii. Application of Theory of Causation where death ensues after some delay ............................................................. 23 E. CONCLUSION ...................................................................... 39
1. This appeal is at the instance of a convict accused and is directed against the judgment and order passed by the High Court of Chhattisgarh dated 30.07.2024 in Criminal Appeal No. 607 of 2023 (hereinafter referred to as “Impugned Judgment”) by which the High Court partly allowed the Criminal Appeal filed by the appellant herein and altered the conviction of the appellant under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code (for short, “the IPC”) into one under Section 307 of the IPC.
2. It appears from the materials on record that four persons including the appellant herein were put to trial for the offence of murder of one Rekhchand Verma in the Sessions Case No. 21 of 2022 arising from the First Information Report bearing No. 0061 of 2022 dated 22.02.2022 registered with the Saja Police Station, District Bemetara, State of Chhattisgarh for the offence punishable under Sections 458, 294, 506(B) and 323 of the IPC respectively.
A. FACTUAL MATRIX
3. It is the case of the prosecution that on the fateful day of the incident the appellant herein along with three other co-accused trespassed * Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
[2025] 10 S.C.R. 219Maniklal Sahu v. State of Chhattisgarh into the house of the deceased and dragged him upto the terrace of the house and flung him down. After the deceased was thrown down from the terrace, the appellant and other co-accused assaulted him with sticks and fisticuffs. The injured was shifted to the hospital in a very critical condition. Dying declaration of the deceased was recorded vide Ex. P-22 in which he named the appellant herein and the other co-accused. The deceased also made oral dying declarations before the doctors who attended him medically in the hospital.
4. It appears that the injured Rekhchand Verma survived for about nine months from the date of the alleged incident. Ultimately, he died on 08.11.2022 on account of septicemia and pneumonia leading to cardiorespiratory arrest. In such circumstances, Section 302 of the IPC came to be added. The case was committed to the Court of Session. At the end of the trial, the appellant and the three coaccused came to be convicted of the offence of murder and were sentenced to life imprisonment.
5. The appellant herein along with co-accused, namely, Rupesh Kumar Sahu preferred Criminal Appeal No. 607 of 2023 in the High Court whereas the Criminal Appeal No. 866 of 2023 was preferred by Gulsan Sinha and Criminal Appeal No. 1151 of 2024 was preferred by one Chavendra Patel.
6. All the three criminal appeals referred to above were heard by the High Court and those were partly allowed vide the Impugned Judgment and order passed by the High Court. As stated above, the High Court altered the conviction of the appellant herein and the other co-accused from Section 302 of the IPC to one under Section 307 of the IPC and sentenced them to undergo 7 years of rigorous imprisonment and fine of Rs. 1,000/-.
7. In such circumstances referred to above, the appellant Maniklal Sahu is here before us with the present appeal.
B. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT
8. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant vehemently submitted that the High Court ought to have acquitted the appellant herein of all charges rather than altering the conviction from one under Section 302 IPC to Section 307 IPC. The principal contention canvassed on behalf of the appellant herein is that the cause of death has no nexus with the injuries suffered by the deceased at the time 220 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports of the alleged assault on him. In other words, the learned counsel laid much stress on the fact that the injured died after about nine months from the date of the incident. Second argument canvassed on behalf of the appellant is, that the eyewitnesses are not reliable witnesses. They are interested witnesses being PW-1 Satish Verma, brother of the deceased; PW-11 Vikas Verma, another brother of the deceased; and PW-12 Gautahiri Bai Verma, mother of the deceased. It was argued that they had no occasion to witness the alleged assault.
9. In such circumstances referred to above, the learned counsel appearing for the appellant would submit that there being merit in his appeal, the same may be allowed and the appellant may be acquitted of all the charges.
C. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE STATE
10. On the other hand, the learned counsel appearing for the State, while vehemently opposing this appeal, submitted that the High Court committed a serious error in altering the conviction under Section 302 of the IPC into one of attempt to commit murder punishable under Section 307 of the IPC.
11. However, the learned counsel fairly submitted that the State has not preferred any acquittal appeal in this regard. In such circumstances, he submitted that let the conviction of the appellant herein for the offence punishable under Section 307 of the IPC be maintained.
D. ANALYSIS
12. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and having gone through the materials on record, the only question that falls for our consideration is whether the High Court committed any error in passing the Impugned Judgment and order?
13. We do not propose to reappreciate the entire oral evidence on record. We have looked into the oral testimonies of PW-1 Satish Verma, brother of the deceased; PW-11 Vikas Verma, another brother of the deceased; and PW-12 Gautahiri Bai Verma, mother of the deceased respectively. They are all eyewitnesses to the incident. There is no good reason for us to disbelieve or discard their evidence.
14. We only propose to examine in the present appeal whether the High Court committed any error in bringing the case within the ambit of [2025] 10 S.C.R. 221Maniklal Sahu v. State of Chhattisgarh “attempt to commit murder” punishable under Section 307 IPC on the ground that the deceased Rekhchand Verma died after a period of nine months from the date of the incident. Unfortunately, the exercise which we propose to undertake is ultimately going to be academic as there is no acquittal appeal filed at the instance of the State. However, we should not ignore or overlook the gross error committed by the High Court. We must explain, why the High Court is wrong in its view.
15. We must start with the medical evidence on record. The prosecution examined PW-9 Dr. Sheetal Kaushal. Dr. Sheetal Kaushal in his examination-in-chief has deposed under:- 01- “I was posted as Medical Officer at Community Health Centre Saja from 22.06.2020 to 16.06.2022.
02- On 22.02.2022 at 11.14 pm, the injured Rekhachand Verma, son of Radheshyam Verma, age 19 years, resident of Boratra, Police Station Saja, was brought to me for examination by constable Indraman Nishad number 274 of Police Station Saja at Community Health Center Saja, in which, during his examination, I found that:
1. The said injured person said that he was pushed down from the roof and beaten up and the condition of the said injured person was serious and his blood pressure was very low. The said injured person was in a semiconscious state and the smell of alcohol was coming from his mouth.
2. The above injured person had a lacerated wound measuring 8 cm x 0.5 cm x 1 cm in the temporal parietal region of his head, which was bleeding profusely.
3. The above patient was having pain in his throat and was having difficulty in moving his throat. I had advised him to get an X-ray done and also advised him to get his head checked by a neurosurgeon.
4. The injury was very serious so the correct opinion about the nature of the injury could have been given only after examination by a neurosurgeon and a radiologist. The condition of the patient was so serious that I advised him to be immediately taken to a higher centre.
222 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
5. The above injuries sustained by the above victim can be caused by falling from the roof and hitting the head with a hard or blunt object and the nature of the said injury can be determined only after treatment by the NCCT head and neurosurgeon and radiologist. In this regard, the medical examination report prepared by me is Ex.P. 06, part of which is signed by me.
03- On 25.02.2022, I was informed by the police station in-charge Saja by sending a memorandum that the injured Rekhachand Verma was referred to a higher center for advanced treatment and NCCT Head, Neurosurgery, Cervical X-ray was advised, who was admitted to Mekahara Raipur on 23.02.2022, then to DKS Hospital Raipur and on 24.02.2022 he was admitted from DKS Hospital to MMI Hospital Raipur, where the victim is admitted in ICU. Whose MRI scan has been done, the part below the waist of the injured has become numb, due to which there is a possibility of spinal cord fracture, so give opinion on the following two points-
1. What is the nature of the injury suffered by the victim?
2. Was it possible for the injured person to die due to the injury?
I had written in reply to the above questions that, 1) “The nature of injury can only be determined by a Radiologist and Neurophysician and Neurosurgeon.” and 2) “Yes, it was possible.” The Curie report prepared by me in this regard is Ex.P. 07, which bears my signatures on parts A to A. 04- On 24,03,2022, the police station in-charge Saja sent a sealed stick along with a memorandum for testing and asked-
1. Could the injury sustained by Rekhachand Verma have been caused by the confiscated stick?
2. Are there blood stains on the said stick?
3. Any other opinions?
I had examined the sealed stick along with the above mentioned memorandum sent by the police station [2025] 10 S.C.R. 223Maniklal Sahu v. State of Chhattisgarh in-charge Saja, whose length and size I have mentioned by drawing its picture and after examining the said stick, my opinion is that 1) “Such injuries can be inflicted on the injured Rekhachand with this type of stick.” and 2) “I did not find any blood stains on the stick.” In this regard, the query report prepared by me is Ex.P. 08, which bears my signatures on parts A to A.”
There is practically no cross examination of Dr. Sheetal Kaushal.
16. We now look into the evidence of Dr. Twinkle Chandrakar, PW-24. Dr. Chandrakar in her examination-in-chief has deposed as under:- “01- I am posted as Assistant Professor in Sri Sankaracharya Institute of Medical Science, Junwani Bhilai, District-Durg (CO) for the last two years.
02- On 21.10.2022 at 10:35 P.M. the injured/deceased Rekhchand Lodhi father Radheshyam Verma age 22 years resident Boratara Tehsil Saja District Bemetara was brought to me for treatment at Shankaracharya Institute of Medical Science, Junwani Bhilai Hospital. On examining him I found that-
01. The condition of the said injured was very serious and he had no movement and sensation in both his legs due to which he was unable to walk and he had trouble breathing and his blood pressure was very low, he was not urinating and he was suffering from vomiting and diarrhea and he also had fever.
The said injured had movement in both his hands.
02. There was a wound in the hip of the injured person which was filled with pus.
03. The injured person had weakness in both his hands and legs. The injured person had anaemia and there was swelling in his body.
04. The said injured person was being given oxygen with the help of a ventilator and medicines were being given to maintain blood pressure and due to blood loss, blood was transfused and antibiotics were given and the wound on his hip was being treated.
224 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
05. The patient’s condition was not satisfactory and the patient was becoming unstable.
03- I had admitted the said injured/ deceased on 22.10.2022 in Shankaracharya Hospital Junwani, who died during treatment on 08.11.2022 due to Septic shock with bilateral pneumonia with post traumatic spinal cord injury with paraplegia with infected bedsore with hepatic dysfunction. The entire treatment of the said deceased Rekhachand was done by the medicine unit of the hospital under my guidance and his discharge summary has been prepared by Junior Doctor Richa Sharma, which is , Ex.P. 28, on which my signature is on part A and my seal and seal are on parts B to B. Along with the said discharge certificate, the photocopy of the entire bedhead ticket related to the treatment of the said deceased in our hospital is of total 137 pages and a death certificate was issued by our hospital in relation to the death of the above deceased, the death certificate is Ex.P. 29, on which my signature is on part A to A and my seal and seal are on parts B to B. 04- On 29.11.2022, the police station in-charge of police station Saja sent letter no. / Th.Pr. / Saja / 702-A / 2022 regarding providing opinion by curating the discharge certificate and bedhead ticket of deceased Rekhachand Lodhi. In crime number 61/2022 of police station Saja and asked the following question-
1. On the night of 22.02.2022 at about 8 o’clock, the accused beat up Rekhachand Verma with sticks and fists and threw him from the roof onto the CC road with the intention of killing him, due to which his spine was fractured. The deceased died during treatment at Shankaracharya Hospital on 08.11.2022. Did the deceased die due to fracture in his spine?
2. If deceased Rekhachand died due to some other reason, please give your clear opinion?
05- In order to answer the said query, after examining the discharge certificate of deceased Rekhachand and the bed head ticket related to his treatment, I have given this statement that, 1) In the history of the said injured, on [2025] 10 S.C.R. 225Maniklal Sahu v. State of Chhattisgarh 22.02.2022, due to spinal cord injury, there was paraplegia and the said deceased had weakness in both hands and legs due to which the patient became bedridden and there was infection in the wound of his hip, due to which it is possible that the death of patient Rekhachand was due to spinal cord injury. 2) While answering the query question number 02 of the police station incharge, I have written such an opinion in my query report Ex. P. 30 which is the memorandum of the police station in-charge dated 29.11.2022 on the page that, A-Septic shock with Bilateral Pneumonia. B-Post traumatic Spinal Cord injury with Paraplegia infected bedsore hepatic dysfunction. That is, the patient Rekhachand died due to the same reason which I have mentioned in the answer to query question no. 01. My signature is on parts A to A of the query report Ex. P. 30.”
Once again, there is practically no cross examination of Dr. Twinkle Chandrakar.
17. In the last, we should look into the oral evidence of Dr. Abhishek Shrivastava, PW-28. Dr. Abhishek Shrivastava in his examinationin-chief has deposed as under:- “01- I am posted as Senior Medical Officer In Government Hospital, Supela Bhilai, District Durg from 01.01.2021 till date.
02- On 09.11.2022 at 12:30 PM, deceased Rekhchand Radheshyam Lodhi, age 22 years, resident of Boratara, District Bemetara, was presented from Shankaracharya Hospital, father late Junwani, District Durg, for postmortem by constable number 484 Evan Baghel of Police Outpost Smriti Nagar Police Station Supela, to Government Hospital, Supela Bhilai, District Durg. The said body was identified by Satish Lodhi, Rajendra Yadu and constable Evan Baghel.
03- The postmortem of the said dead body was started by me on 09.11.2022 at 12:30 P.M. The said dead body was of a male, which was wrapped in a white cloth and was lying straight on the postmortem table. The body of the said deceased was stiff and cold. There was injury 226 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports on the entire back portion of both the thighs of the said deceased and there was injury on his left ankle as well. There was bedsore on the entire lower back of the said deceased, the size of which was 4 x 3 cm.
04- The deceased was of normal height and his skull, cranium, vertebrae, brain and spinal cord were congested. There was fluid present in the right and left lungs of the deceased. There was a clot in the heart of the deceased. The diaphragm, intestine, mouth and esophagus and pharynx of the deceased were normal and his spleen, kidney were pale and urinary bladder was empty and genitals were normal. There was half-digested food in the stomach of the deceased and half-digested food and stool was also present in his small intestine and large intestine. 05- On the basis of the results and experience obtained from the postmortem of the said deceased Rekhachand, it is my opinion that the said deceased died of cardiorespiratory attack due to septic shock, which was caused by infection of the injuries in the body of the deceased. The time of death of the said deceased was between 18 to 36 hours and the injuries found on the body of the said deceased were before his death (antemortem). In this regard, the postmortem report prepared by me is Ex.P. 34, which bears my signatures on parts A to A, B to B and C to C.
Cross-examination by Shri Balram Sahu, Advocate for accused Gulshan and Chavendra:- 06- On being asked whether septic shock can occur in the absence of treatment) the witness said that it is possible if necessary antibiotics are not given during treatment.” (Emphasis supplied)
There is practically no cross examination of Dr. Abhishek Shrivastava.
18. Thus, the injured was brought to the hospital on 22.02.2022 in a very critical condition. According to Dr. Kaushal (PW-9), the injured was in a semi-conscious state. He was bleeding profusely due to a very serious head injury.
[2025] 10 S.C.R. 227Maniklal Sahu v. State of Chhattisgarh
19. What is discernable from the medical evidence on record, in the form of oral testimonies of the three doctors referred to above, and the documentary evidence in the form of postmortem report and the injury certificate Exhibit P-34 is that the deceased died due to complications from paraplegia following spinal cord injury which resulted in systemic infection and multi-organ failure. Exhibits P-28, P-29 and P-34 respectively make it clear. It is ultimately the septic shock resulting from infected pressure sores which in turn arose from the spinal injury sustained in the incident that proved to be fatal.
20. The deceased also suffered from pneumonia. According to the medical experts, this pneumonia was the direct result of the long drawn medical treatment which was given to the deceased over a period of nine months.
21. All the three medical experts examined by the prosecution are clear in their oral testimony that the deceased died during treatment on 08.11.2022 due to septic shock with bilateral pneumonia, post traumatic spinal cord injury with paraplegia and infected bedsores leading to hepatic dysfunction. The ocular version of the eyewitnesses corroborates with medical evidence on record.
22. Keeping the aforesaid in mind, we now proceed to consider the understanding of the High Court while altering the conviction. i. When is an offence said to be made under Section 307 of the IPC
23. The High Court while altering the conviction under Section 302 to one under Section 307 of the IPC recorded the following findings as contained in paragraph 35 of the Impugned Judgment. Para 35 reads thus:- “35. No doubt, the injuries caused by the appellants to the deceased were grievous in nature. He died due to septic shock with bilateral pneumonia with post traumatic spinal cord injury with paraplegia with infected bedsore with hepatic dysfunction. Due to spinal cord injury, there was paraplegia and the deceased had weakness in both hands and legs, due to which the deceased became bedridden and there was infection in the wound of his hip. Due to which, it is probable that the death of deceased Rekhchand Verma was due to his spinal 228 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports cord injury. Rekhchand Verma was firstly referred to the Community Health Center, Saja, the doctor there referred him to Mekahara Hospital, Raipur and from there he was shifted to DKS Hospital and thereafter he was again shifted to MMI Narayan Hospital, Raipur and finally he was shifted to Shankaracharya Hospital, Durg where he died. As such, due to lack of proper treatment, he died after about 9 months of the incident. Therefore, the case of the appellants falls within the purview of Section 307 of the IPC and not under Section 302 of the IPC.
Even otherwise, the trial Court has already convicted the appellants for offence under Section 307/34 of the IPC for the same offence, therefore, there is no necessity to convict them also for offence under Section 302/34 of the IPC.”
24. We have noticed over a period of time that the courts get confused while determining the exact nature of offence, more particularly, when there is a long interval between the date the victim suffered injuries and the date of his death.
25. We must first look into the relevant provisions of the IPC. Sections 299, 300 and 302 of the IPC respectively read as under:- “Section 299. Culpable homicide.—Whoever causes death by doing an act with the intention of causing death, or with the intention of causing such bodily injury as is likely to cause death, or with the knowledge that he is likely by such act to cause death, commits the offence of culpable homicide.
xxx “Explanation 2.—Where death is caused by bodily injury, the person who causes such bodily injury shall be deemed to have caused the death, although by resorting to proper remedies and skillful treatment the death might have been prevented.”
Section 300. Murder.—Except in the cases hereinafter excepted, culpable homicide is murder, if the act by which the death is caused is done with the intention of causing death, or— [2025] 10 S.C.R. 229Maniklal Sahu v. State of Chhattisgarh 2ndly.—If it is done with the intention of causing such bodily injury as the offender knows to be likely to cause the death of the person to whom the harm is caused, or— 3rdly.—If it is done with the intention of causing bodily injury to any person and the bodily injury intended to be inflicted is sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death, or— 4thly.—If the person committing the act knows that it is so imminently dangerous that it must, in all probability, cause death, or such bodily injury as is likely to cause death, and commits such act without any excuse for incurring the risk of causing death or such injury as aforesaid.
xxx Section 302. Punishment for murder.—Whoever commits murder shall be punished with death, or imprisonment for life, and shall also be liable to fine.”
26. To come within the definition of Section 299 IPC, the act of the accused should cause death and it must be (a) with the intention of causing death, or (b) with the intention of causing such bodily injuries as is likely to cause death, or (c) with the knowledge that he is likely by such act to cause death. The question when a person could be said to have caused death by his act needs to be answered taking into consideration the Explanations 1 and 2 respectively to Section 299 of the IPC.
27. The simpler case is where death results directly and immediately from the act itself. Equally, when death ensues as a natural or necessary consequence flowing from that act, there can be no hesitation in holding that the act caused the death. For “Thirdly” of Section 300 to apply the requirement is, that the injury inflicted should be found sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death, a high degree of probability, in the ordinary way of nature, that death would ensue on the injuries. The difficulty arises when there are recognisable contributory causes leading to death, and the Court is called upon to consider in such case the relative effect and strength of the different causes in bringing about the effect i.e., the death, and then to ascertain whether the responsibility of the death could be assigned to a particular act which is not as proximate, or immediate.
230 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
28. Section 307 of the IPC reads as under:- “Section 307. Attempt to murder.—Whoever does any act with such intention or knowledge, and under such circumstances that, if he by that act caused death, he would be guilty of murder, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine; and if hurt is caused to any person by such act, the offender shall be liable either to imprisonment for life, or to such punishment as is hereinbefore mentioned.”
29. An offence under Section 307 IPC has the following essential ingredients:-
(i) The death of a human was attempted;
(ii) That the death was attempted to be caused, or caused in the consequence of the act of the accused; and
(iii) That the act was done with the intention of causing death; or that it was done with the intention of causing such bodily injury as: a. the accused knew to be likely to cause death; or b. was sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death, or that the accused attempted to cause death by doing an act known to him to be so dangerous that it must in all probability cause:
i. death, or ii. such bodily injury as is likely to cause death.
30. Thus, from the above, the most important ingredient to constitute the offence of attempt to commit murder punishable under Section 307 of the IPC is the intention or knowledge. To bring home guilt against an accused under this provision, it is necessary for the prosecution to establish that the intention of the accused was one of the three kinds mentioned in Section 300 of the IPC. A person commits an offence under Section 307 of the IPC when he has the intention to commit murder and in pursuance of that intention, does an act towards its commission irrespective of the fact whether that act is the penultimate act or not. The provision requires that the act must be done with such intention, or knowledge, or in such [2025] 10 S.C.R. 231Maniklal Sahu v. State of Chhattisgarh circumstances that if death be caused by that act, the offence of murder will emerge.
31. It is clear as noonday that causing an injury that would endanger life is not an essential condition for the applicability of Section 307 of the IPC. Even if the injuries inflicted are simple in nature, that by itself cannot be a ground for acquittal, if the offence otherwise falls under Section 307 of the IPC.
32. The word “intent” means design, or determination with which a person acts. It presupposes knowledge. It is the purpose to use particular means to effect certain result. The “act” referred in Section 307 of the IPC attempted to must be with the “intention” of killing a human. Intention is a state of mind which cannot be proved by direct evidence as a fact; it can only ordinarily be inferred from proved facts. It may be proved by res gestae, by acts or events previous or subsequent to the incident or occurrence, or on admission. We say so because it shows the presence of will in the act which consummates a crime. The relevant circumstances from which the intention can be gathered. We have supplied a suggestive, and not exhaustive list:-
1. the nature of the weapon used;
2. the manner in which the weapon was used;
3. the part of the body where the injuries were inflicted;
4. the nature of the injuries caused;
5. the opportunity available which the accused gets.
33. We may quote with profit one very erudite decision of the High Court of in the case of Sreedharan v. State of Kerala, reported in 1969 SCC OnLine Ker 46, wherein the Court illustrated the metrics by which intention and knowledge can be inferred. It was held that intention can be inferred from the circumstantial evidence of the case, such as the motive, the preparations made, the declarations of the offender, the weapon used, the persistent of the assault, and the nature of the injuries inflicted, and its position. In the IPC, the word “intention” is understood in the context of the consequences of an act, and not in relation to the act. The Court lucidly elaborates that the presence of intention is gathered when an act is done deliberately or purposely, it is not contingent on the resultant effect. Most importantly, the 232 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports inference lies in reading of the consequences from the eyes of a reasonable man. The relevant observations read thus:- “16. Intention and knowledge are a man’s state of mind; direct evidence thereof except through his own confession cannot be had; and apart from a confession they can be proved only by circumstantial evidence. In other words, they are matters for inference from all the circumstances of the case such as the motive, the preparations made, the declarations of the offender, and, in the case of homicide, the weapon used, the persistence of the assault, and the nature of the injuries actually inflicted as also their location. In the case of what are generally described as unpremediated offences or as offences committed on the spur of the moment, intention may be contemporaneous with the physical act, at best of just an instant before, and is generally to be gathered from the nature and consequences of the act and the attendant circumstances. It is here that the much criticised maxim that every man is presumed to intend the natural and probable consequences of his act comes into play.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.