Janardan Das & Ors. v. Durga Prasad Agarwalla & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 778; [2024] 9 S.C.R. 947
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Pankaj Mithal, Justice Prasanna Bhalachandra Varale
- Decided
- 26 Sept 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 613/2017
- Sections
- 16, 20
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 9 S.C.R. 947 : 2024 INSC 778 Janardan Das & Ors.
v.
Durga Prasad Agarwalla & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 613 of 2017)
26 September 2024 [Vikram Nath, Pankaj Mithal and Prasanna B. Varale, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose as to whether the plaintiffs proved their continuous readiness and willingness to perform their part of the contract as mandated u/s.16(c) of the Specific Relief Act, 1963; whether the agreement to sell was valid and enforceable against three co-owners-sisters, considering that defendant no. 1-co-owner lacked the authority to act on their behalf without a valid and subsisting General Power of Attorney; and whether the relief of specific performance, being discretionary, having been denied by the trial court was rightly granted by the High Court.
Headnotes† Specific Relief Act, 1963 – s.16(c) – Specific performance of contract – Enforcement – Readiness and willingness of the plaintiffs to perform the contract – Devolution of suit property among five heirs-two brothers and three sisters equally – Plaintiffs operating a petrol pump on the suit land allegedly entered into an agreement to sell with defendant No. 1 and his brother for the purchase of the suit property for consideration – Agreement stipulated that the sisters-co-owners would execute the sale deed within three months as they had not joined the agreement – Plaintiffs filed suit for specific performance of the agreement – Said agreement was executed solely by the brothers-two co-owners without any signatures, written consent, or explicit authorization from the sisters-three co-owners – Meanwhile, all the co-owners of the property transferred the suit property in favour of the appellants by virtue of a sale deed for consideration – Suit dismissed by the trial court, however, the High Court decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiffs – Correctness:
Held: Plaintiffs’ failure to comply with the essential terms of the agreement and to take necessary steps within the stipulated time 948 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports demonstrates a lack of readiness and willingness to perform their part of the contract as mandated u/s.16(c), which is fatal to their claim for specific performance – High Court erred in overlooking the plaintiffs’ inaction and lack of diligence – Further, defendant No. 1-co-owner lacked the authority to bind other three co-ownerssisters in the agreement to sell – General Power of Attorney did not confer upon him the power to sell the property on behalf of his sisters at the time of the agreement, having been impliedly revoked by the partition deed – Plaintiffs’ knowledge of the necessity of obtaining the sisters’ consent, coupled with their failure to secure such consent, renders the agreement ineffective against the sisters, and cannot be specifically enforced against them, and the plaintiffs cannot claim any right over their shares in the property based on the said agreement – Appellants are the bona fide purchasers in good faith of the suit property for valuable consideration – Once they have acquired the rights in the property way back, no justification to disturb the said sale deed by decreeing the suit for specific performance of the agreement – Thus, considering the discretionary nature of the relief and the principles governing its exercise, granting specific performance would be neither just nor equitable – Plaintiffs’ failure to fulfil essential contractual terms, coupled with the lack of authority to bind all co-owners, renders the grant of specific performance inappropriate – Equitable remedy sought by the plaintiffs cannot be granted in light of their conduct and the circumstances of the case – Given the incomplete and unenforceable nature of the agreement, it is neither just nor equitable to grant the relief sought by the plaintiffs – Thus, the judgment and decree passed by the High Court set aside and that of the trial court dismissing the suit for specific performance restored. [Paras 9-25] Specific Relief Act, 1963 – s.16(c) – Specific performance of contract – Enforcement – Readiness and willingness of the plaintiffs to perform the contract:
Held: s.16(c) mandates that a plaintiff seeking specific performance of a contract must aver and prove that they have performed or have always been ready and willing to perform the essential terms of the contract which are to be performed by them – This requirement is a condition precedent and must be established by the plaintiff throughout the proceedings – Readiness and willingness of the plaintiff are to be determined from their conduct prior to and subsequent to the filing of the suit, as well as from the terms [2024] 9 S.C.R. 949Janardan Das & Ors. v. Durga Prasad Agarwalla & Ors. of the agreement and surrounding circumstances – Rationale behind this provision is to ensure that a party seeking equitable relief has acted equitably themselves – Specific performance is a discretionary relief, and the plaintiff must come to the court with clean hands, demonstrating sincerity and earnestness in fulfilling their contractual obligations – Any laxity, indifference, or failure to perform their part of the contract can be a ground to deny such relief. [Para 8] Power of Attorney – General Power of Attorney – When can agent bind the principals to contract of sale:
Held: In contracts involving multiple owners of property, it is imperative that all co-owners either personally execute the agreement to sell or duly authorize an agent to act on their behalf through a valid and subsisting power of attorney – Agent’s authority must be clear and unambiguous, and any limitations or revocations of such authority must be duly considered – Without proper authority, an agent cannot bind the principals to a contract of sale. [Para 14] Specific Relief Act, 1963 – s.20 – Relief of specific performance under – Nature of:
Held: Relief of specific performance is discretionary in nature – s.20 explicitly states that the court is not bound to grant such relief merely because it is lawful to do so – But the discretion of the court has to be on sound and reasonable principles – Discretion must be exercised judiciously and based on sound principles, ensuring that granting specific performance is just and equitable in the circumstances of the case. [Paras 19, 21] Case Law Cited U.N. Krishnamurthy v. A.M. Krishnamurthy [2022] 13 SCR 250 : (2023) 1 SCC 775 – referred to.
List of Acts Specific Relief Act, 1963.
List of Keywords Continuous readiness and willingness to perform part of contract; Agreement to sell; General Power of Attorney; Specific performance; 950 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Sale deed; Consideration; Multiple parties; Distinct interests; Bona fide purchasers in good faith; Equitable relief; Contractual obligations; Contracts; Agent binding principals to contract of sale; Judicious exercise of discretion; Grant of specific performance. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 613 of 2017 From the Judgment and Order dated 25.10.2013 of the High Court of Orissa at Cuttack in FA No. 185 of 1997.
Appearances for Parties Umakant Misra, Mrs. Prabhati Nayak, Niranjan Sahu, Monomoy Basu, Ms. Apoorva Sharma, Advs. for the Appellants.
S.R. Singh, A.C. Pradhan, Sr. Advs., Saurabh Mishra, Shrimay Mishra, Abhinav Pandey, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Order
1. The present appeal arises from the judgment and order dated 25.10.2013 passed by the High Court of Orissa at Cuttack in First Appeal No. 185 of 1997, wherein the High Court reversed the judgment of the Civil Judge (Senior Division), Baripada, dated 17.05.1997 in T.S. No. 103 of 1994. The High Court decreed the suit for specific performance filed by the plaintiffs (Respondent Nos. 1 & 2 herein), directing the defendants, including the present appellants (Defendant Nos. 9 to 11), to execute a sale deed in favour of the plaintiffs. Aggrieved by this decision, the defendant nos. 9 to 11 have approached this Court by way of the present appeal.
2. The relevant facts giving rise to the original suit are as follows: 2.1 Late Surendranath Banerjee was the original owner of the suit property situated in Baripada, Odisha. Upon his demise on 03.07.1980, the property devolved equally among his five heirs: two sons—Defendant No. 1 (Binayendra Banerjee) and late Soumendra Nath Banerjee—and three daughters—Defendant Nos. 6 to 8 (Smt. Rekha Mukherjee, Smt. Sikha Das, and Smt. Monila Pal).
[2024] 9 S.C.R. 951Janardan Das & Ors. v. Durga Prasad Agarwalla & Ors. 2.2 On 14.04.1993, an oral agreement was entered into between all the co-owners (Defendant Nos. 1 to 8) and the appellants (Defendant Nos. 9 to 11), wherein the co-owners collectively agreed to sell the suit property to the appellants for a total consideration of ₹4,20,000. This agreement was the culmination of mutual discussions and a longstanding understanding between the parties, reflecting the genuine intent of all co-owners to transfer the property to the appellants.
2.3 Meanwhile, on 06.06.1993, the plaintiffs (Respondent Nos. 1 & 2), who are dealers operating a petrol pump on the suit land under a dealership agreement with Defendant No. 12 (Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited), allegedly entered into an agreement to sell with Defendant No. 1 and late Soumendra for the purchase of the suit property for a total consideration of ₹5,70,000 paying ₹70,000 as earnest money. The agreement stipulated that the sisters (Defendant Nos. 6 to 8) would come to Baripada within three months to execute the sale deed, as they were unable to do so at the time of the agreement. As per the terms of the agreement, the sale deed was to be executed before 30.09.1993.
2.4 It is pertinent to note that the agreement dated 06.06.1993 was executed solely by Defendant No. 1 and late Soumendra, without any signatures, written consent, or explicit authorization from Defendant Nos. 6 to 8, who collectively held a significant 3/5th share in the property. The plaintiffs were aware that without the participation and consent of the sisters, a valid and enforceable sale could not be completed.
2.5 The alleged authority of Defendant No. 1 to act on behalf of his sisters was based on an unregistered General Power of Attorney (GPA) dated 30.12.1982. However, this GPA was limited in scope, primarily authorizing Defendant No. 1 to manage certain aspects of the property, such as collecting rent. Moreover, the GPA was effectively revoked by a registered partition deed dated 17.02.1988, wherein the co-owners partitioned the property and specifically limited Defendant No. 1’s authority to collection of rent, with no mention of any power to sell the property on behalf of the sisters.
952 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports 2.6 In fulfilment of the prior oral agreement dated 14.04.1993, and after ensuring the participation and consent of all co-owners, Defendant No. 1, late Soumendra, and Defendant Nos. 6 to 8 executed a registered sale deed on 27.09.1993 in favor of the appellants (Defendant Nos. 9 to 11) for a consideration of ₹4,20,000. The appellants who are bona fide purchasers, acted in good faith and completed the transaction with all the five rightful owners, and accordingly acquired valid title to the property.
2.7 The plaintiffs (Respondent Nos. 1 & 2), despite being aware of the necessity of obtaining consent from Defendant Nos. 6 to 8 and the limitations of Defendant No. 1’s authority, filed T.S. No. 103 of 1994 before the Civil Judge (Senior Division), Baripada. They sought specific performance of the alleged agreement dated 06.06.1993 or, in the alternative, specific performance to the extent of the shares of Defendant No. 1 and late Soumendra. The plaintiffs, as dealers operating on the suit land, aimed to secure ownership of the property to further their commercial interests.
3. Before the Trial Court, the plaintiffs contended that they had entered into a valid and enforceable agreement to purchase the suit property from Defendant No. 1 and late Soumendra on 06.06.1993 for a total consideration of ₹5,70,000, paying ₹70,000 as earnest money. They asserted that Defendant No. 1 was authorized to act on behalf of Defendant Nos. 6 to 8 by virtue of the General Power of Attorney dated 30.12.1982 (Ext.1), which empowered him to sell the property. The plaintiffs emphasized that the agreement stipulated the sisters (Defendant Nos. 6 to 8) would come to Baripada within three months to execute the sale deed, and they were assured by Defendant No. 1 and late Soumendra that the sisters had consented to the sale. They maintained that they were always ready and willing to perform their part of the contract, including paying the balance consideration and completing the sale. Furthermore, they argued that the subsequent sale deed executed on 27.09.1993 in favour of Defendant Nos. 9 to 11 was invalid and not binding on them, as it was executed with full knowledge of the prior agreement with the plaintiffs.
4. The defendants, in their respective written statements, refuted the plaintiffs’ claims. They contended that Defendant No. 1 did not have [2024] 9 S.C.R. 953Janardan Das & Ors. v. Durga Prasad Agarwalla & Ors. the authority to sell the property on behalf of Defendant Nos. 6 to 8. They argued that the General Power of Attorney (Ext.1) was limited in scope and effectively revoked by the partition deed dated 17.02.1988 (Ext.6/a), which allocated specific shares to each co-owner and only authorized Defendant No. 1 to collect rent, not to sell the property. The defendants maintained that the agreement dated 06.06.1993 was incomplete and unenforceable, as it was contingent upon obtaining the consent and participation of Defendant Nos. 6 to 8, which was never secured. They further asserted that the plaintiffs failed to fulfil the terms of the agreement, particularly in not ensuring the presence and consent of the sisters within the stipulated time, indicating lack of readiness and willingness to perform their obligations. The defendants highlighted that the sale deed executed on 27.09.1993 in favour of Defendant Nos. 9 to 11 was valid, having been executed with the full consent and participation of all co-owners, including Defendant Nos. 6 to 8. They asserted that the appellants were bona fide purchasers for value without notice of any enforceable prior agreement, rendering the plaintiffs’ claims untenable.
5. The Trial Court, after framing issues and examining the evidence, dismissed the suit of the plaintiffs for specific performance. The key findings of the Trial Court were as follows:
5.1 The Court found that the agreement dated 06.06.1993 was executed only by Defendant No. 1 and late Soumendra, without any signatures or explicit consent from Defendant Nos. 6 to 8. The agreement itself acknowledged that the sisters were not present and their willingness needed to be secured, stating that they would come to Baripada within three months to execute the sale deed.
5.2 The Trial Court examined the General Power of Attorney and concluded that it did not explicitly authorize Defendant No. 1 to sell the property on behalf of the sisters. Moreover, the GPA was impliedly revoked by the subsequent partition deed (Ext.6/a), which allocated specific shares to each co-owner and only authorized Defendant No. 1 to collect rent, not to sell the property.
5.3 The agreement was deemed incomplete and unenforceable against Defendant Nos. 6 to 8, as their consent and participation were essential for a valid sale. The agreement’s reliance on 954 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports future consent rendered it a contingent contract that did not materialize within the stipulated time.
5.4 The Court observed that the plaintiffs failed to demonstrate continuous readiness and willingness to perform their part of the contract. They did not take effective steps to secure the consent and presence of the sisters within the three-month period specified in the agreement. Their inaction and reliance solely on Defendant No. 1 and late Soumendra indicated a lack of diligence and commitment to fulfilling the contractual obligations.
5.5 The Court considered whether specific performance could be granted for the 2/5th share belonging to Defendant No. 1 and late Soumendra. It concluded that such partial enforcement was impractical and inequitable, given the nature of the property and its existing lease to Defendant No. 12. Splitting ownership would complicate the tenancy and could not be reasonably executed. 5.6 The Court held that the sale deed dated 27.09.1993 executed in favour of Defendant Nos. 9 to 11 was valid and binding. The appellants were bona fide purchasers who had completed the transaction with all rightful owners, including Defendant Nos. 6 to 8. The plaintiffs’ prior agreement did not create any interest in the property that could invalidate the appellants’ title. Recognizing that the plaintiffs had paid ₹70,000 as earnest money, the Court ordered that they were entitled to a refund of this amount with pendente lite and future interest at 6% per annum from Defendant Nos. 1 to 5 (the legal heirs of late Soumendra included).
6. Aggrieved by the Trial Court’s judgment, the plaintiffs filed a first appeal before the High Court of Orissa. On appeal, the High Court reversed the Trial Court’s judgment and decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiffs. It held that the General Power of Attorney dated 30.12.1982 was valid and conferred authority upon Defendant No. 1 to act on behalf of Defendant Nos. 6 to 8, rejecting the notion that it was impliedly revoked by the partition deed dated 17.02.1988. The High Court found that the alleged revocation of the GPA was forged and not genuine. It concluded that the agreement dated 06.06.1993 was valid and enforceable against all defendants, including the sisters, and that the plaintiffs were always ready and [2024] 9 S.C.R. 955Janardan Das & Ors. v. Durga Prasad Agarwalla & Ors. willing to perform their part of the contract. Consequently, the High Court granted specific performance of the contract, directing all defendants, including Defendant Nos. 9 to 11 (appellants herein), to execute the sale deed in favour of the plaintiffs upon payment of the balance consideration.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.