Ajay Madhusudan Patel & Ors. v. Jyotrindra S. Patel & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 710; [2024] 9 S.C.R. 894
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, Justice J.B. Pardiwala
- Decided
- 20 Sept 2024
- Case number
- ARBITRATION PETITION No. 19/2024
- Sections
- 11(6), 11, 7, 11(9), 2(1), 7(1), 11(8), 16, 8, 37, 7(4)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 9 S.C.R. 894 : 2024 INSC 710 Ajay Madhusudan Patel & Ors.
v.
Jyotrindra S. Patel & Ors.
(Arbitration Petition No. 19 of 2024)
20 September 2024 [Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, CJI, J.B. Pardiwala* and Manoj Misra, JJ.] Issue for Consideration What is the scope of jurisdiction of the referral court under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996; Whether in the instant case, on a prima facie view, the SRG Group being a non-signatory to the Family Arrangement Agreement (FAA), can be referred to arbitration.
Headnotes† Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 – s.11(6) – Appointment of arbitrators – Scope of jurisdiction of the referral Court: Held: SBP & Co. case expanded the scope of the Court’s power under Section 11 while empowering the referral courts to decide several preliminary issues – Boghara Polyfab case went to the extent of identifying three categories of preliminary issues that may arise for consideration in an application under Section 11 – However, the insertion of Section 11(6A) through the 2015 Amendment to the Act, 1996 stipulated that the Courts under Section 11 shall confine their examination to the ‘existence’ of an arbitration agreement – It legislatively overruled the decisions in SBP & Co. and Boghara Polyfab by virtue of its non-obstante clause – Duro Felguera case, in clear terms, clarified the effect of the change brought in by Section 11(6A) and stated that all that the Courts need to see is whether an arbitration agreement exists - nothing more, nothing less – Vidya Drolia case endorsed the prima facie test in examining the existence and validity of an arbitration agreement both under Sections 8 and 11 respectively – However, it was clarified that in cases of debatable and disputable facts and reasonably good arguable case, etc. the Court may refer the parties to arbitration since the arbitral tribunal has the * Author [2024] 9 S.C.R. 895Ajay Madhusudan Patel & Ors. v. Jyotrindra S. Patel & Ors. authority to decide disputes including the question of jurisdiction – It was further stated that jurisdictional issues concerning whether certain parties are bound by a particular arbitration under the group-company doctrine etc. in a multi-party arbitration raise complicated questions of fact which are best left to the tribunal to decide – In Re: Interplay Between Arbitration Agreements under Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 and Stamp Act, 1899, the position taken in Vidya Drolia case was clarified to state that the scope of examination under Section 11(6) should be confined to the “existence of the arbitration agreement” under Section 7 of the Act, 1996 and the “validity of an arbitration agreement” must be restricted to the requirement of formal validity such as the requirement that the agreement be in writing – Krish Spinning case cautioned that the Courts delving into the domain of the arbitral tribunal at the Section 11 stage run the risk of leaving the claimant remediless if the Section 11 application is rejected – The Cox and Kings case specifically dealt with the scope of inquiry under Section 11 when it comes to impleading the non-signatories in the arbitration proceedings – While saying that the referral court would be required to prima facie rule on the existence of the arbitration agreement and whether the non-signatory party is a veritable party to the arbitration agreement, it also said that in view of the complexity in such a determination, the arbitral tribunal would be the proper forum. [Para 65] Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 – Whether in the instant case, on a prima facie view, the SRG Group being a nonsignatory to the Family Arrangement Agreement (FAA), can be referred to arbitration:
Held: An important factor to be considered by the Courts and Tribunals is the participation of the non-signatory in the performance of the underlying contract – The intention of the parties to be bound by an arbitration agreement can be gauged from the circumstances that surround the participation of the nonsignatory party in the negotiation, performance, and termination of the underlying contract containing such an agreement – Further, when the conduct of the non-signatory is in harmony with the conduct of the others, it might lead the other party or parties to legitimately believe that the non-signatory was a veritable party to the contract containing the arbitration agreement – However, in order to infer consent of the non-signatory party, their involvement 896 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports in the negotiation or performance of the contract must be positive, direct and substantial and not be merely incidental – Thus, the conduct of the non-signatory party along with the other attending circumstances may lead the referral court to draw a legitimate inference that it is a veritable party to the arbitration agreement – In the instant case, the clauses of FAA such as clause 2.1.4 read with Schedule 7, clause 2.1.6 read with Schedule 8, clause 2.1.7, gives an impression, though prima facie, that the SRG Group may be connected to the FAA and forms part of the settlement contemplated therein – However, this aspect needs to be looked into more closely by the Arbitral Tribunal – On bare perusal of the email exchanges produced by the petitioner, it appears prima facie that several contested questions of fact need to be first resolved – A detailed examination of numerous disputed questions of fact are imperative in deciding whether the SRG Group participated in the negotiation and performance of the underlying contract and can be bound by the arbitration agreement – There is a limited jurisdiction afforded under Section 11(6) of the Act, 1996 – This Court cannot conduct a mini trial and delve into contested or disputed questions of fact – Therefore, considering the complexity involved in the determination of the question whether the SRG Group is a veritable party to the arbitration agreement or not, it would be appropriate for the arbitral tribunal to take a call on the question after taking into consideration the evidence that may be adduced by the parties before it and the application of the legal doctrine as elaborated in the decision in Cox and Kings case. [Paras 70, 71, 77, 78, 79, 80] Case Law Cited In Re: Interplay Between Arbitration Agreements under Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 and Stamp Act, 1899 [2023] 15 SCR 1081 : (2024) 6 SCC 1; Cox and Kings Ltd. v. SAP India Pvt. Ltd [2024] 9 SCR 199 : (2024) 4 SCC 1 – followed.
Duro Felguera S.A. v. Gangavaram Port Limited [2017] 10 SCR 285 : (2017) 9 SCC 729; Garware Wall Ropes Ltd. v. Coastal Marine Constructions & Engineering Ltd. [2019] 5 SCR 579 : (2019) 9 SCC 209; Vidya Drolia and Ors. v. Durga Trading Corporation [2020] 11 SCR 1001 : (2021) 2 SCC 1; SBI General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Krish Spinning [2024] 7 SCR 840 : (2024) SCC OnLine SC 1754 – relied on.
SBP & Co. v. Patel Engg. Ltd. [2005] Supp. 4 SCR 688 : (2005) 8 SCC 618; National Insurance Company Limited v. Boghara Polyfab [2024] 9 S.C.R. 897Ajay Madhusudan Patel & O rs. v . J y otrindra S. Patel & O rs. Private Ltd [2008] 13 SCR 638 : (2009) 1 SCC 267; Sasan Power Ltd. v. North American Coal Corporation (India) Private Ltd [2016] 6 SCR 809 : (2016) 10 SCC 813 – referred to.
LF Ltd. v. PNB Housing Finance Ltd. (2024) SCC OnLine Del 2165; Moneywise Financial Services (P) Ltd. v. Dilip Jain (2024) SCC OnLine Del 1896; Cardinal Energy and Infra Structure Pvt. Ltd. v. Subramanya Construction & Development Co. Ltd. (2024) SCC OnLine Bom 964 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited 246th Report of the Law Commission of India.
List of Acts Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996; Contract Act, 1872. List of Keywords Section 11(6) of Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996; Appointment of arbitrators; Non-signatory to the Family Arrangement Agreement; Scope of Court’s power u/s.11 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996; 2015 Amendment to the Act, 1996; Existence of Arbitration agreement; Validity of Arbitration agreement; Veritable party; Non-signatory party; Disputed questions of fact; Legislatively overruled.
Case Arising From CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION: Arbitration Petition No. 19 of 2024 (Under Section 11(6) read with Section 11(9) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996)
Appearances for Parties Darius Khambhata, Sr. Adv., Keyur Gandhi, Shamik Shirishbhai Sanjanwala, Kunal Vyas, Anmolgandhi, Prabhakar Yadav, Ms. Shubhangi Agarwal, Abhishek Jamalpur, Advs. for the Petitioners.
Huzefa Ahmadi, Sr. Adv., Anuj K. Trivedi, Ms. Anushree Prashit Kapadia, Ms. Ekta Kundu, Ms. Ruby Singh Ahuja, Ms. Aakriti Vohra, Ms. Simran Jeet, Vasu Singh, Rohan Sharma, M/s. Karanjawala & Co., Advs. for the Respondents.
898 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment J.B. Pardiwala, J.
For the convenience of exposition, this judgment is divided in the following parts:
INDEX* A. FACTUAL MATRIX.......................................................... 3
B. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER
(AMP GROUP)............................................................... 25
C. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT
(JRS GROUP).................................................................. 31
D. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT
(SRG GROUP)................................................................ 32 E. ANALYSIS....................................................................... 38 i. Scope of jurisdiction of the referral court under Section 11(6) of the Act, 1996............................... 38 ii. Whether on a prima facie view, the SRG Group being a non-signatory to the FAA, can be referred to arbitration?........................................................ 55 F. CONCLUSION................................................................. 66
1. The present petition has been filed under Section 11(6) read with Section 11(9) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter, “the Act, 1996”) seeking appointment of a Sole Arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes between the Petitioners and the Respondents in terms of Clauses 7.2 and 7.3 respectively of the Family Arrangement Agreement dated 28.02.2020 (hereinafter, “the FAA”) read with the Amendment Agreement dated 15.05.2020 (hereinafter, “Amendment to the FAA”) entered into between the petitioner AMP Group and respondent JRS Group.
* Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
[2024] 9 S.C.R. 899Ajay Madhusudan Patel & O rs. v . J y otrindra S. Patel & O rs.
2. Since the Petitioner No. 13 i.e., Silvercity Management Ltd. is a company incorporated outside India having its office at 17, Bond Street, St. Helier, Jersey, JE2, 3NP, an island in the English Channel, northwest of France and the Petitioner No. 14 i.e., Hiral Ashit Patel is an individual, who is a citizen and resident of Canada, the dispute between the Parties falls within the definition of an international commercial arbitration under Section 2(1)(f) of the Act, 1996.
A. FACTUAL MATRIX
3. For convenience, the Parties involved in the present petition and the respective groups of which they form a part of are tabulated below: S.
NO.
NAME PETITIONER/
RESPONDENT
GROUP
1. Ajay Madhusudan Patel Petitioner No. 1 AMP
2. Apoorva Madhusudan Patel Petitioner No. 2 AMP
3. Meeta Ajay Patel Petitioner No. 3 AMP
4. Sonal Apoorva Patel Petitioner No. 4 AMP
5. Bhavik Ajay Patel Petitioner No. 5 AMP
6. Jinal Ajay Patel Petitioner No. 6 AMP
7. Kaushal Apoorva Patel Petitioner No. 7 AMP
8. Nishkal Apoorva Patel Petitioner No. 8 AMP
9. Apoorva M. Patel (HUF) Petitioner No. 9 AMP
10. Spectrum Ingredients Pvt. Ltd.
Rep. by its Director Petitioner No. 10 AMP
11. Sai Fragrances & Flavours Pvt. Ltd. Rep. by its Director Petitioner No. 11 AMP
12. Zest Aromas Pvt. Ltd.
Rep. by its Director Petitioner No. 12 AMP
13. Silvercity Management Ltd.
Rep. by its Chairman Petitioner No. 13 AMP
14. Hiral Ashit Patel Petitioner No. 14 AMP
15. Jyotrindra S. Patel Respondent No. 1 JRS
16. Rajesh C. Patel HUF Respondent No. 2 JRS
17. Sanjay S. Patel Respondent No. 3 JRS
18. Finhelp Investments and Consultants (Mumbai) Pvt. Ltd.
Rep. by its Director Respondent No. 4 JRS 900 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
19. Greenbiz Holdings and Consultants Pvt. Ltd. Rep. by its Director Respondent No. 5 JRS
20. Jyotrindra S. Patel and Sanjay S. Patel (Holding for and on behalf of J&S Associate – AOP) Rep. by its Member Respondent No. 6 JRS
21. Millenium Estates Pvt. Ltd.
Rep. by its Director Respondent No. 7 SRG
22. Deegee Software Pvt. Ltd.
Rep. by its Director Respondent No. 8 SRG
23. Samarjitsinh R. Gaekwad (Shareholder & Director of Millenium Estates Pvt. Ltd. and Deegee Software Pvt. Ltd.)
Respondent No. 9 SRG
24. Radhikaraje S. Gaekwad (Shareholder of Deegee Software Pvt. Ltd.)
Respondent No. 10 SRG
25. Subhanginiraje R. Gaekwad (Shareholder of Deegee Software Pvt. Ltd.)
Respondent No. 11 SRG
26. Gaekwad Services Ltd.
now known as Gaekwad Enterprise Pvt. Ltd. Rep.
by its Managing Director (Shareholder of Deegee Software Pvt. Ltd.)
Respondent No. 12 SRG
27. Samarjitsinh Gaekwad HUF (Shareholder of Deegee Software Pvt. Ltd.)
Respondent No. 13 SRG
28. Rajesh C. Patel (Shareholder of Deegee Software Pvt. Ltd.)
Respondent No. 14 JRS
29. Shilpa R. Patel (Shareholder of Deegee Software Pvt. Ltd.)
Respondent No. 15 JRS
30. Aditya Patel (Director of Deegee Software Pvt. Ltd.)
Respondent No. 16 SRG
31. Nitin Shripadbhai Pujari (Director of Deegee Software Pvt. Ltd.)
Respondent No. 17 SRG [2024] 9 S.C.R. 901Ajay Madhusudan Patel & O rs. v . J y otrindra S. Patel & O rs.
4. The Petitioners herein are collectively referred to as the “AMP Group”. The Petitioner Nos. 1 to 9 & 14 respectively are individuals and family members of Mr. Ashit Patel, who are a part of the AMP Group in the FAA. The Petitioner Nos. 10 to 13 respectively are companies described as a part of the AMP Group in the FAA. The Petitioner No. 13 is a company incorporated outside India and the Petitioner No. 14 is a resident of a foreign country.
5. The Respondents are divided into two groups i.e., “JRS Group” consisting of Respondents 1 to 6, 14 & 15 and “SRG Group” consisting of Respondents 7 to 13, 16 & 17. The Millenium Estates Pvt. Ltd. (hereinafter, “Millenium”) and Deegee Software Pvt. Ltd. (hereinafter, “Deegee”) are Respondent 7 and 8 companies respectively. The Respondents 9 to 17 are all either Directors or Shareholders of Respondent 7 and 8 companies. Therefore, the Respondents comprise of individuals, Companies and Shareholders and Directors of the respective companies dealt with under the FAA.
6. Apart from the Petitioners and Respondents aforementioned, a few other individuals find a repeated mention in the facts of the present petition. First, Mr. Ashit M. Patel who is the Power of Attorney Holder of Petitioner Nos. 1 to 9 and 14 of the AMP Group. He is the co-brother of Respondent No.1. Secondly, Mr. Kalpesh Parmar, a Chartered Accountant who represented the interests of the JRS Group during the negotiations leading up to the FAA, the implementation of the FAA and the first round of mediation. He is alleged to have also represented the interests of the SRG Group during the same. In the last, Mr. Pankaj Agarwal, an employee of Deegee.
7. Mr. Ashit Patel representing the AMP Group and Mr. Jyotrindra S. Patel (Respondent No.1) of the JRS Group are co-brothers and married in the same family. The two groups were jointly engaged in various businesses and co-owned several entities. Subsequently, the SRG Group had joined hands with the AMP Group and JRS Group in two entities i.e. Millenium and Deegee. SRG Group presently holds 40% equity shares in Millenium.
8. It is the case of the Petitioners that between 2013 & 2019, various disputes arose between the AMP Group on one side and the JRS and SRG Groups on the other which led to the filing of several proceedings before various forums including the National Company Law Tribunal (hereinafter, “NCLT”) at New Delhi, Mumbai and Ahmedabad by 902 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports the AMP Group. The same are still pending before the respective forums. It is pertinent to note that, of the aforesaid disputes, the respondent No.9 of the SRG Group is one of the respondents in CP/383/2017 pertaining to Deegee, filed by the AMP Group before the NCLT at Mumbai.
9. The Best Value Chem. Ltd. (hereinafter, “BVC”) is an entity involved in the business of manufacturing aroma chemicals co-owned by the AMP and JRS Groups. The Premji Group had initiated a proposal to buyout BVC and indicated that the deal could only go through if the litigations filed against BVC were withdrawn. Therefore, the parties thought it fit to resolve all the issues between them once and for all with the understanding that the AMP Group would completely takeover various entities and that the JRS and SRG Groups would co-own other entities.
10. During negotiations that preceded the execution of the FAA, the following events/communications took place;
• Vide emails dated 12.12.2019 and 02.01.2020, several internal documents required for the valuation of Millenium and Deegee were shared by Mr. Pankaj Agarwal with the AMP Group wherein a copy was marked to Mr. Kalpesh Parmar.
• Vide email dated 14.01.2020 sent to the AMP Group, Mr. Kalpesh Parmar confirmed that the matters pertaining to Millenium and Deegee even after its valuation may have to be discussed with Mr. Samarjitsinh (hereinafter, “Respondent No. 9”) of the SRG Group before finalisation. The said excerpt from the contents of the email are reproduced hereinbelow:
“…The pending details from Pankaj, if I correctly understand then it is related to documents of Millenium and Deegee, Even if we consider both of it to be treated separately, it can be done because even after valuation, the matter needs to be discussed out with Samarjitsinh before finalising. Therefore, in the binding agreement you can put necessary points covering both the properties and till it is not resolved we can work out some alternate solution so that both the groups are covered properly….”
(Emphasis supplied)
[2024] 9 S.C.R. 903Ajay Madhusudan Patel & O rs. v . J y otrindra S. Patel & O rs. • A joint meeting was arranged by Mr. Kalpesh Parmar and attended by Mr. Ashit Patel of the AMP Group and Respondent No.9 of the SRG Group.
• Vide email dated 25.01.2020 sent to the AMP Group, Mr. Kalpesh Parmar suggested that the valuation of Millenium be finalized in consultation with the Respondent No.9 of the SRG Group. The said excerpt from the contents of the email are reproduced hereinbelow:
“…In view of releasing above deadlock situation, I am suggesting that we include in FAA binding methodology to resolve it. For Chandan Sanjaybhai, Jagdishbhai & AMP can sit and decide the value within __ days from execution of FAA, Similarly for Millenium Sanjaybhai, Samarjitsinh & AMP can sit and close it along with issue of residential flats. This can also be done within __ days from execution of FAA. In the meantime, whatever valuation/s so far JRS has given on Chandan & Millenium will stand withdrawn, so nothing is there on table from JRS side on the value of Chandan & Millenium. Therefore, we can proceed to close on FAA & Escrow agreement on Monday. If you can flip this suggestion with AMP, I can try to convince Sanjaybhai too…”
(Emphasis supplied)
11. Subsequently, the FAA dated 28.02.2020 was entered into between the AMP Group and JRS Group. The terms of the FAA impose several obligations on the AMP and JRS Groups in pursuance of the settlement contemplated therein.
12. It is pertinent to observe that the present petition relates primarily to the dispute arising from specific clauses wherein the SRG Group is also required to undertake certain steps and actions specified viz,
(a) Clause 2.1.4 read with Schedule 7 on Millenium Exit (presently AMP Group holds 36% while SRG Group holds 40%) where AMP Group is required to exit and SRG Group is required to purchase additional shares; (b) Clause 2.1.5 requiring Amendment of Lease Deed executed between Millenium, the Lessor and Aurosagar Estates Pvt. Ltd. (hereinafter, “Aurosagar”), the Lessee and; 904 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
(c) Clause 2.1.6 read with Schedule 8 on Deegee Exit where JRS and SRG Groups are required to completely exit and AMP Group would purchase the shares. The relevant clauses of the FAA are reproduced hereinbelow:
“2.1.4 Exit of AMP Group from Millenium
(a) Within 30 (thirty) days from the Trigger Date(“Millenium Transfer Date”), Parties shall execute duly stamped agreement(s) with SRG to record and finalize their understanding with respect to exit of AMP Group from Millenium by way of transfer/ buy back of all Class A equity shares in Millenium (“Millenium Exit”) in the manner set out in Schedule 7. The Parties agree that the valuation of Millenium for the purposes of the Millenium Exit shall be INR 130,00,00,000 (Rupees One Hundred Thirty Crores). It is hereby clarified that AMP Group will continue to hold Class B equity shares in Millenium in accordance with the provisions set out in the articles of association of Millenium.
(b) Notwithstanding anything contained herein, Parties shall endeavour to simultaneously undertake the Millenium Exit and Deegee Exit on the same day in accordance with Clause 2.1.4 and Clause 2.1.6, respectively.
(c) Parties shall co-operate with each other for any actions required to be undertaken or documents required to be executed in order to give effect to the actions contemplated under this Clause, including but not limited to passing exercising their voting rights to provide necessary board or shareholders’ approval, execution and stamping of share transfer forms, endorsement of share certificates, filing forms with the registrar of companies, making entries in statutory registers, providing all necessary information and documents necessary for preparing necessary documents, etc required to be complied by Millenium under Applicable Law.
[2024] 9 S.C.R. 905Ajay Madhusudan Patel & Ors. v. Jyotrindra S. Patel & Ors. 2.1.5 Amendment of Aurosagar Lease Deed
(a) On the Millenium Transfer Date, Aurosagar and Millenium shall execute a duly stamped amendment deed to the Aurosagar Lease Deed in the format set out in Annexure 1.
(b) Parties shall co-operate with each other for any and all such actions required to be undertaken and execute all such documents as may be necessary in order to give effect to this Clause (Including registration of the amendment deed), including but not limited to exercising their voting rights to provide necessary board or shareholders’ approval, attending office of registrar of assurance for admitting the amendment deed, providing all necessary information and documents necessary for preparing necessary documents, etc.
(c) All costs and expenses for amendment of the Aurosagar Lease Deed in accordance herewith, including without limitation, fee charged by attorneys and other advisors/consultants, stamp duty and registration charges shall be borne by AMP Group.
2.1.6 Exit of JRS Group and SRG from Deegee Software (a)Within 30 (thirty) days from the Trigger Date (“Deegee Transfer Date”), Parties shall and shall ensure that SRG executes duly stamped agreement(s) to record their understanding with regards to exit of JRS Group and SRG from Deegee Software, including (i) transfer of all shares held by JRS Group and SRG in Deegee Software (“AMP Deegee Transfer”); (ii) resignation of directors appointed by JRS Group/SRG from the board of directors of Deegee Software; and (iii) repayment of loan by Deegee Software to its lenders including the interest accrued thereon in the manner set out in Schedule 8 ((i), (ii) and (iii) are collectively referred as “Deegee Exit”)
906 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
(b) AMP Group shall complete due diligence of Deegee Software within 20 (twenty) Business Days from the Execution Date, in the event, there are any findings requiring indemnity by AMP Group from JRS Group and/or SRG the same will be mutually agreed between the parties.
(c) Parties shall co-operate with each other for any actions required to be undertaken or documents required to be executed for giving effect to the actions contemplated under this Clause, including but not limited to exercising their voting rights to provide necessary board or shareholders’ approval, execution and stamping of share transfer forms, endorsement of share certificates, filing forms with the registrar of companies and the Reserve Bank of India, making entries in statutory registers, providing all necessary information and documents necessary for preparing necessary documents, etc required to be complied by Deegee Software under Applicable law. AMP Group shall be responsible for all compliances/filings under foreign exchange laws of India in relation to the AMP Deegee Transfer.
xxx xxx xxx
SCHEDULE 7
MILLENIUM EXIT
In connection with Millenium Exit, the Parties have agreed the following:
1. AMP Group will exit from Millenium. The total value of Millenium has been fixed at INR 130,00,00,000 and AMP Group’s share of 36% out of total value of Millenium will be INR 46,80,00,000.
2. Phase–1 - SRG will purchase approx. 11% shares of AMP Group post receipt of Balance JRS Purchase Price in the JRS Designated Bank Account. JRS Group proposes to provide necessary funding to SRG for purchasing shares held by AMP Group in Millenium.
[2024] 9 S.C.R. 907Ajay Madhusudan Patel & O rs. v . J y otrindra S. Patel & O rs.
3. Phase 2 - Millenium will buy back the balance shares of AMP Group i.e., approx. 25% from the funds to be received from Deegee Software. Any tax in relation to such buyback to be borne by AMP Group.
4. Phase 3 - within 12 months from execution of relevant documents in respect of Millenium Exit, Millenium will separate out the Class “B” shares being residential flat owners in a separate co-operative society.
5. Until co-operative society is not formed, Millenium will provide no objection letter to AMP Group for transfer of their flats.
SCHEDULE 8
DEEGEE EXIT
In connection with Deegee Exit, the Parties have agreed the following:
1. JRS Group and SRG will exit from Deegee Software. AMP Group will discuss with Jabalpur Group and finalise on their exit. The total value of the property owned by Deegee Software is fixed at INR 141,00,00,000, which shall be used to pay off loans with proportionate interest to all lenders of Deegee Software.
2. The sale proceeds received by AMP Group from sale of shares as per Phase 1 of Millenium Exit, will be brought in Deegee Software by AMP Group.
3. AMP Group will bring further funds in Deegee Software to pay off entire loan provided by Millenium to Deegee Software along with interest at the rate of 14.50% p.a. compounded annually.
4. Simultaneously, with repayment of loans to Millenium as per paragraph 3 above, (i) Deegee Software to pay off entire loan provided by JRS Group and SRG along with interest at the rate of 14.50% p.a. compounded annually; and (ii) shares 908 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports of Deegee Software held by JRS Group and SRG shall also be transferred to AMP Group.
5. The above exercise to be completed within 12 months from the execution of relevant documents in this regard.”
(Emphasis supplied)
13. Post the execution of the FAA and in pursuance of the implementation thereof, the following communications were exchanged:
• Vide emails dated 12.03.2020 and 13.03.2020 sent to the AMP Group, Mr. Pankaj Agarwal shared documents required for the due diligence of Deegee which were marked to Mr. Kalpesh Parmar and the latter email was additionally marked to the respondent No.9 of SRG Group.
• Vide emails dated 24.04.2020 and 04.05.2020 sent to the AMP Group, the JRS Group lawyers shared the FAA Closing Tracker reflecting the status of implementation of the FAA which included the pending transfer of Deegee and Millenium. The same were marked to Mr. Kalpesh Parmar.
• Vide email dated 08.05.2020 sent to a shareholder of BVC, Mr. Kalpesh Parmar acted as the representative of the SRG Group on discussions pertaining to the amendment of the Aurosagar lease deed. The said excerpt from the contents of the email are reproduced hereinbelow:
“….On Aurosagar point, this email I am sending to put forward views of Samarjitsinh (SRG) and not JRS. SRG is clear that Millenium can give POA to AMP and his immediate family and as agreed in FAA draft, PL can work on language without disturbing the construct / concept. SRG is not going to honour any POA which is beyond what is stated in the draft of POA shared with him even though you find any logical point in AMP’s arguments. As per him AMP is neither trustworthy nor a reliable person, so he is not interested in dealing any further with him. He already had a very bad experience of similar nature when he had sealed a deal with TATAs, that time also [2024] 9 S.C.R. 909Ajay Madhusudan Patel & O rs. v . J y otrindra S. Patel & O rs. after signing the minutes, AMP took extreme U-turn just for SRG to become a laughing stock not only in front of all partners and HDFC Realty but also in front of TATAs. That’s enough for him.
Please appreciate, though SRG is not a signatory to FAA, he is ready to honour what was agreed with him over phone call but on other side there is a person though has signed a document is now not ready to stick to it. Real mockery.
I would suggest that seriously you should take this with Sanjaybhai & Shaju before approaching PI. My hands are tied on this since I have to safeguard interest of SRG….”
(Emphasis supplied)
• Vide email dated 11.05.2020 sent to the AMP Group on discussions pertaining to the Aurosagar Lease deed, Mr. Kalpesh Parmar indicated that Respondent No.9 is the only decision maker in Millenium and JRS is at best the facilitator if needed. The said excerpt from the contents of the email are reproduced hereinbelow:
“…..The newly inserted points mentioned in the lease deed vide clause nos. 2.8, 2.9 (including 2.9.1 to 2.9.4), 2.10 and 2.11 cannot be considered as part of the draft of lease deed for following reasons:…..
…4. While your newly inserted points suggest that they are having a futuristic impact so this can very well be taken up in due course with Millenium when Samarjitsinh is the only decision maker and JRS is at best the facilitator if needed…”
(Emphasis supplied)
14. An Amendment to the FAA was executed between the AMP Group and JRS Group on 15.05.2020. The clauses relevant to the present dispute are reproduced hereinbelow:
“5. Clause 2.1.5(a) stands deleted in its entirety and is substituted with the following:
910 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports On the Millenium Transfer Date, Aurosagar and Millenium shall simultaneously execute the following:
(i) duly stamped amendment deed to the Aurosagar Lease Deed in the format set out in Annexure 1; (ii)
duly stamped irrevocable special power of attorney in favour of Aurosagar in the format set out in Annexure 1A; and (iii) duly stamped deed of indemnity in the format set out in Annexure 1B.
6. Clause 2.1.6(b) stands deleted in its entirety and is substituted with the following:
AMP Group shall complete due diligence of Deegee Software on or before June 30, 2020. In the event, there are any findings requiring indemnity by AMP Group from JRS Group and/or SRG the same will be mutually agreed between the parties in writing.
xxx xxx xxx
12. Paragraph 27 in Schedule 4 stands deleted in its entirety and is substituted with the following:
“Transaction Documents” means this Agreement, the Settlement Escrow Agreement and any and every document executed in connection with the transaction contemplated under or in connection with this Agreement.”
(Emphasis supplied)
15. In continuation of the implementation of the FAA, the following communications were exchanged;
• Emails dated 01.07.2020, 10.04.2021 and 15.04.2021 were exchanged between the AMP Group and Mr. Kalpesh Parmar pertaining to the due diligence of Deegee.
• Vide email dated 09.10.2020 sent to the AMP Group, the JRS lawyers shared drafts of the Share Purchase Agreements (hereinafter, “SPAs”) pertaining to Millenium and Deegee and a copy was marked to Mr. Kalpesh Parmar.
• Vide email dated 27.11.2020 and a reminder email dated 03.04.2021, Mr. Kalpesh Parmar sent the drafts of these SPAs [2024] 9 S.C.R. 911Ajay Madhusudan Patel & O rs. v . J y otrindra S. Patel & O rs. (with AMP Group comments) to the SRG lawyers with a copy marked to Respondent No.9 in order to seek their comments. • Vide email dated 26.03.2021 sent to the AMP Group with a copy marked to the Respondent No.9, Mr. Kalpesh Parmar clarified that though the SPAs related to Deegee was stuck up with a non-JRS Group, yet the JRS Group was ready to hand over the affairs of Deegee w.e.f. 01.04.2021 and requested the AMP Group to withdraw all litigations before the concerned forums. • Vide email dated 03.04.2021 sent to the JRS Group with a copy marked to the Respondent No.9, the AMP Group requested the JRS Group to undertake steps for restoring the original shareholding of the AMP Group in Deegee.
16. Several items under the FAA were pending implementation including the finalisation and execution of SPAs for Millenium and Deegee at the end of the SRG Group. Therefore, vide email dated 20.12.2021 sent to the JRS Group, the AMP Group nominated Mr. Upen Shah as the AMP Group’s representative in compliance with clause 7.1.2 of the FAA for amicable resolution of the issues arising out of the FAA between the AMP and JRS Groups. Vide reply email dated 26.12.2021, the JRS Group named Mr. Sanket Jain and/or Mr. Kalpesh Parmar as their representative. Clause 7.1.2 is reproduced hereinbelow:
“7.1.1 The Parties agree to use all reasonable efforts to resolve any dispute, controversy, claim or disagreement of any kind whatsoever between or amongst any of the Parties in connection with or arising out of this Agreement or the Transaction Document/s executed in connection with the transaction contemplated under or in connection with this Agreement, including any question regarding its existence, validity or termination (“Dispute”), expediently and amicably to achieve timely and full performance of the terms of this Agreement or the Transaction Document/s. 7.1.2 Any Party which claims that a Dispute has arisen must give notice thereof to the other Parties as soon as practicable after the occurrence of the event, matter or thing which is the subject of such Dispute and in such notice, such Party shall provide particulars of the 912 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports circumstances and nature of such Dispute and of its claim(s) in relation thereto and shall designate a Person as its representative for negotiations relating to the Dispute, which Person shall have authority to settle the Dispute. The other Parties shall, within 7 (seven) days of such notice, each specify in writing its position in relation to the Dispute and designate as their representative in negotiations relating to the Dispute, a Person with similar authority.”
17. The first round of mediation was held between the representatives of the AMP and JRS Groups on 19.01.2022. However, the discussions on the issues did not lead to any conclusion. While the minutes of the same were shared with Mr. Kalpesh Parmar, he denied its contents and stated that the draft minutes do not correctly record the events which occurred at the meeting.
18. For the purpose of initiating the second round of mediation, an email dated 06.05.2022 was sent by the JRS Group to the AMP Group invoking Clause 7.1.2 and they nominated Mr. Anuj Trivedi or Mr. Kalpesh Parmar to act as their representatives. In response to the same, on 23.05.2022, the AMP Group nominated Mr. Keyur Gandhi and/or Mr. Upen Shah and/or Mr. Nihar Mehta as their representatives. The first mediation meeting was convened on 13.06.2022. The second mediation meeting was convened on 23.07.2022 wherein it was stated by the petitioners that the AMP and JRS Groups were agreeable to hold a joint meeting with SRG for the purpose of resolving the major issues pertaining to Millenium and Deegee.
19. In the midst of mediation, on 17.10.2022, the JRS Group sent a WhatsApp message to the AMP Group stating that (a) the JRS Group had a meeting with the SRG Group, (b) SRG and Millenium were ready to purchase the stake of AMP Group in Millenium at the price agreed in the FAA, (c) SRG would exit from Deegee subject to a payment of Rs. 25 crore as compensation considering its contribution to the growth of Deegee. The contents of the message are reproduced hereinbelow:
“Dear Keyurbhai.
My clients had a meeting with SRG and the following points have been suggested by SRG:
[2024] 9 S.C.R. 913Ajay Madhusudan Patel & O rs. v . J y otrindra S. Patel & O rs.
(1) Millennium:
(a) SRG and Millennium would be ready to purchase the stake of AMP in Millennium at the price already agreed AMP and JRS.
(b) The said purchase would be made from the compensation that SRG receives from AMP for handling, taking care of and making Deegee prosperous over the last 20 years. The said compensation would be used for purchasing 11% of the 36% stake of AMP in Millennium.
(c) The balance 25% would be “buy back” by Millennium of AMP shares. This would be subject to the receipt of loan and interest by Millennium & SRG from Degee
(2) Amendment to AoA: Millennium and SRG are of the opinion that AoA does not need to be amended
(3) Aurosagar Lease Deed: the lease of Millennium and Aurosagar is as per the plans sanctioned by the Municipal Corporation. The draft lease deed provided is in contradiction to the said sanctioned plans.
(4) Aurosagar Special Power of Attorney: Millennium and SRG are of the opinion that there is no required of a Special Power of Attorney.
(5) Deegee
(a) SRG will exit from Deegee, however, the same has been formed and promoted by SRG, SRG has also given its name in order to avoid the conflict of interest of AMP with Firmenich. SRG has taken care of the company for the last 20 years and has provided services without any renumeration. In view thereof, for exiting Deegee, SRG is expecting compensation of Rs.25 crores
(b) Millennium and SRG are also expecting interest 14.50% till repayment of the amount lent to AMP JRS Group has suggested that we may have another meeting and try to take it forward”.
(Emphasis supplied)
914 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
20. Further on 21.11.2022, the JRS Group sent another WhatsApp message to the AMP Group stating that it had spoken to the SRG Group and that if the AMP Group was not ready to recognise SRG’s contribution in the growth of Deegee, it would be difficult for them to agree with the AMP Group on any point. The contents of the message are reproduced hereinbelow:
“Talked with SRG and here is the response- As he understands from me that AMP group is looking forward for meeting with SRG to discuss the points forwarded by SRG, however AMP Grp would not like to give any compensation for Deegee to SRG. As per SRG, if AMP Grp is not even ready to recognize his contribution in growth of Deegee, then it would be difficult for him to meet AMP Grp for any point and thereby the points sent by SRG shall be considered as non existent and should not be referred any time in future.”
(Emphasis supplied)
21. Vide email dated 16.05.2023 sent to the AMP Group, Mr. Kalpesh Parmar conveyed that he would discuss with SRG and try to resolve all matters pertaining to Deegee and would also intimate the outcome of his discussion. It was also conveyed that Millenium can be simultaneously worked out once Deegee is settled. The contents of the email are reproduced hereinbelow:
“Dear Nihar, Based on my discussions with JRSG, following are the comments:
[…]
4. All Deegee points we will discuss and try to resolve with SRG and Jabalpur Group. The outcome, we will update you. However, we expect to complete other companies/ entities as per excel chart, which is concerning only JRSG & AMPG, subject to the comments herein without putting any deadlines for Deegee.
5. About Millenium, once Deegee is settled. Millenium can be simultaneously worked out.
[2024] 9 S.C.R. 915Ajay Madhusudan Patel & Ors. v. Jyotrindra S. Patel & Ors.
6. Escrow should be released along with the signing of consent terms of Aurosagar.
7. As informed earlier Aurosagar’s SPOA & Lease Deed points can be directly dealt with SRG.
You may consider above comments and discuss. You may thereafter make necessary changes in your comments in the excel file and resend it”.
(Emphasis supplied)
22. Since mediation between the parties yielded no result, the JRS Group sent an Arbitration Notice dated 11.12.2023 to the AMP Group invoking Clauses 7.2 and 7.3 respectively contained in the FAA dated 28.02.2020 read with the Amendment to the FAA dated 15.05.2020. The JRS Group, in the said notice, alleged, inter alia, that while the JRS Group had fulfilled its obligations under the FAA, the AMP Group had failed to discharge and take appropriate steps in compliance of its obligations. On account of such failure, the JRS Group was unable to fulfil its corresponding obligations and hence, disputes had arisen between the parties. They nominated Justice Kalpesh S. Jhaveri (Former Chief Justice, High Court of Orissa) to act as the sole arbitrator to resolve and adjudicate the disputes only between the AMP Group and JRS Group, in accordance with the FAA. The arbitration clause contained in the FAA is reproduced hereinbelow:
“7.2 Any Dispute, if not resolved in accordance with Clause 7.1, shall be referred to and finally resolved by arbitration in accordance with the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 read with the rules framed thereunder (“Arbitration Act”). Subject to any interim reliefs/orders granted, this Agreement and the rights and obligations of the Parties contained in this Agreement shall remain in full force and effect pending issuance of the award in such arbitration proceedings, which award, if appropriate, shall determine whether and when any termination shall become effective. 7.3 The arbitral tribunal shall consist of a sole arbitrator mutually agreed upon and appointed by the Parties. Failing such agreement, either Party shall be at liberty to seek appointment of a sole arbitrator by preferring an appropriate application in accordance with the Arbitration Act before 916 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports the jurisdictional Court or arbitral institution, as the case may be, at Ahmedabad.”
23. On 12.01.2024, the AMP Group gave its reply to the aforesaid notice and sent it to both the JRS and SRG Groups. The AMP Group, while denying the contents of the Arbitration Notice, alleged, inter alia, that, it is the JRS Group that had failed to perform their part of the obligations under various pretext despite the AMP Group pursuing the same. It stated that the assertion on the part of the JRS Group that SRG Group was not bound by the terms of the FAA since it is not a signatory to the said document was completely contrary to what had been represented to AMP during the negotiations and at the time of execution of the FAA and further the same was made only for the purpose of raising an extra monetary demand of Rs. 25 crore which was never contemplated under the FAA. It was further stated that Mr. Kalpesh Parmar and the JRS Group had represented the SRG Group at all stages including the mediation process. The appointment of Justice Akil Kureshi (Former Chief Justice, High Court of Rajasthan) was suggested as an arbitrator for adjudication of all disputes arising under the FAA between the AMP, JRS and SRG Groups.
24. On 09.02.2024 and 10.02.2024 respectively, the JRS Group and SRG Group responded to the reply to the Arbitration Notice sent by the AMP Group.
25. Upon failure to reach an agreement on the appointment of the Sole Arbitrator within 30 days, the Petitioner AMP Group has filed the present Arbitration Petition No. 19 of 2024 before this Court.
B. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER (AMP
GROUP)
26. Mr. Darius Khambata, the learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners submitted that although the SRG Group is not a signatory to the FAA dated 28.02.2020 which contains the arbitration clause, yet it is a veritable party to the arbitration agreement since they participated in the negotiations leading up to the FAA and continued to talk with the parties on the issues pertaining to the implementation of the FAA.
27. It was submitted that the successful implementation of the FAA was contingent on the involvement and action of the SRG Group and it [2024] 9 S.C.R. 917Ajay Madhusudan Patel & O rs. v . J y otrindra S. Patel & O rs. was the intention and understanding of all the parties, including the SRG Group, that they would adhere to, and act on the terms of the FAA. The same was submitted to be evident through the following: • The email dated 14.01.2020 by which Mr. Kalpesh Parmar stated that the valuation of Respondent Nos. 7 and 8 respectively can be finalized only in consultation with the SRG Group;
• A joint meeting that took place between Mr. Kalpesh Parmar, Mr. Ashit Patel and Respondent No.9 during which Respondent No.9 represented that Mr. Kalpesh Parmar was also representing the interest of the SRG Group in the negotiations and that SRG would be bound by the final terms agreed with Mr. Kalpesh Parmar and JRS Group;
• The email dated 08.05.2020 by which Mr. Kalpesh Parmar asserts that SRG is ready to honour what was agreed in the FAA and that he has to safeguard the interest of SRG in the implementation of the FAA.
• Even after the execution of the FAA, important emails dated 13.03.2020, 27.11.2020, 26.03.2021 and 03.04.2021 respectively were sent by the JRS Group/Kalpesh Parmar wherein SRG (Respondent No.9) was marked and has not objected to the contents thereof or raised any grievance.
• During the mediation process, the SRG Group had communicated through a JRS Group representative that it is ready and willing to perform its obligations under the FAA if its demand for an additional consideration of Rs. 25 Crore for exit from Respondent No. 8 company is accepted by the AMP Group.
28. The Counsel submitted that the execution of the terms of the FAA required the involvement and action of the SRG Group while also benefitting them. It was submitted that a perusal of the following clauses and schedules of the FAA would indicate that the transaction was one of separation of shareholding and businesses of the three groups viz AMP, JRS and SRG:
• Clause 2.1.4 read with Schedule 7 provides that AMP Group would exit from Respondent No. 7 Company i.e. Millenium (where the SRG Group already holds 40%) and that out of the 36% shares held by the AMP Group, 11% will be purchased 918 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports by the SRG Group and the remaining 25% will be bought back by Respondent No. 7 Company. The valuation of Respondent No. 7 Company is provided as Rs. 130 crore.
• Clause 2.1.6 read with Schedule 8 provides that the JRS and SRG Groups shall exit the Respondent No. 8 Company i.e. Deegee by selling their shares to the AMP Group. Sale proceeds received by the AMP Group on its exit from the Respondent No. 7 company will be brought into the Respondent No. 8 Company. The valuation of Respondent No. 8 Company is provided as Rs. 141 Crore.
• Clause 2.1.7 read with Item 10 of Schedule 3 provides that the AMP Group shall withdraw CP 383/2017 filed against the Respondent No. 8 Company where Respondent No.9 is also a party.
29. The counsel submitted that the Share Purchase Agreements (SPAs) were to be executed to facilitate the implementation of Clauses 2.1.4 and 2.1.6 respectively of the FAA and the SRG Group would have been a party to the SPAs. This is evident from the draft SPAs and the same were forwarded specifically to the respondent No.9 vide email dated 27.11.2020. That according to the dispute resolution clause contained in Clauses 7.1 and 7.2 respectively, disputes between or amongst any of the parties in connection with or arising out of the Transaction Documents can be amicably resolved and upon its failure, be resolved by arbitration. The term “Transaction Documents” is defined as “means this Agreement, the Escrow Agreement and any and every document executed in connection with the transaction contemplated under or in connection with this Agreement” and also includes the SPAs to be executed inter alia the SRG Group, the drafts of which were forwarded to the SRG Group on 27.11.2020.
30. It was submitted that the AMP Group has conducted the due diligence of the Respondent No.8 Company i.e., Deegee as contemplated in Clause 2.1.6(b) of the FAA with the full knowledge and consent of the SRG Group. The same is evident vide emails dated 01.07.2020, 23.10.2020, 10.04.2021 and 15.04.2021 respectively. This demonstrated that the FAA had also been partly implemented qua the SRG Group which is in management of the said company. [2024] 9 S.C.R. 919Ajay Madhusudan Patel & O rs. v . J y otrindra S. Patel & O rs.
31. One another submission made by the counsel was that the nomenclature of the agreement i.e., “Family Arrangement Agreement” is irrelevant. In addition to that, the description and obligation of the parties under the FAA is also irrelevant since most cases of nonsignatory parties will involve agreements, the terms of which do not expressly include the non-signatory. In support of the aforesaid, the counsel placed reliance on the decision of this Court in Sasan Power Ltd. v. North American Coal Corporation (India) Private Ltd. reported in (2016) 10 SCC 813 where it was settled that the nomenclature of an agreement is not determinative of its character.
32. The counsel submitted that while on many occasions the representatives of JRS Group were there to take care of the interests, suggestions and comments of the SRG Group, it was understood by all the parties that the SRG Group although not a signatory to the FAA yet would be a part of the execution of and compliance of the terms and conditions thereof. Therefore, there was commonality of subject matter and composite transactions, in view of which SRG is a veritable party liable to be referred to arbitration.
33. By placing a strong reliance on the decision of this Court in Cox and Kings Ltd. v. SAP India Pvt. Ltd. reported in (2024) 4 SCC 1, the counsel submitted that the settled position is that the referral court should leave it for the Arbitral Tribunal to decide whether the nonsignatory party is indeed a party to the arbitration agreement on the basis of factual evidence and application of legal doctrine. He submitted that the Delhi and Bombay High Courts have consistently taken a view to refer the parties, including the non-signatories to arbitration in DLF Ltd. v. PNB Housing Finance Ltd. reported in (2024) SCC OnLine Del 2165, Moneywise Financial Services (P) Ltd. v. Dilip Jain reported in (2024) SCC OnLine Del 1896 and Cardinal Energy and Infra Structure Pvt. Ltd. v. Subramanya Construction & Development Co. Ltd. reported in (2024) SCC OnLine Bom 964 by relying on this Court’s decision in Cox and Kings (supra).
34. The counsel finally submitted that it is critical to refer even the nonsignatory to arbitration since otherwise there is a risk that the nonsignatory may not appear before the Arbitral Tribunal and disregard its award as beyond jurisdiction. In any event, the arbitrability of disputes qua the SRG Group can always be considered by the Arbitral Tribunal.
920 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
C. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT (JRS
GROUP)
35. Ms. Anushree Prashit Kapadia the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Respondent JRS Group submitted that while the JRS Group has no objection to the adjudication of disputes with the AMP Group by arbitral proceedings presided by the Sole arbitrator nominated by the AMP Group, the SRG Group cannot be a part of the arbitration proceedings as they are not party to the FAA. It was also submitted that the FAA contained the definition of “Parties” and the SRG Group is not defined in the FAA. The AMP Group and JRS Group are family members, whereas, the SRG Group is not part of the family.
36. The counsel submitted that the various clauses of the FAA indicate that the FAA binds only the AMP and JRS Groups. Clauses 2.1.4 and 2.1.6 respectively wherein the SRG Group is mentioned do not cast any obligations on the SRG Group since it merely states that “Parties shall execute…” & “Parties shall ensure...”. There is also no exchange of consideration with the SRG Group in the FAA.
37. The counsel submitted that neither the JRS Group nor the chartered accountant, Mr. Kalpesh Parmar have ever represented the SRG Group, acted on their behalf or received any authority or power from the SRG Group. There is no evidence on record or otherwise to the contrary.
38. The counsel submitted that Clause 8.1 of the FAA on “Entire Agreement” categorically states that the FAA superseded any and all prior oral and written agreements. Therefore, the case of the AMP Group that SRG Group was effectively a part of the negotiations and is privy to the transactions is inconsequential.
39. The counsel finally submitted that the AMP Group and JRS Group have fulfilled part of their respective obligations under the FAA and are in a position to fully execute the FAA without the presence or role of the SRG Group. Clause 8.7 dealing with Partial Validity empowers the severance of invalid or unenforceable provisions of the FAA.
D. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT (SRG
GROUP)
40. Mr. Huzefa Ahmadi, the learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the Respondent SRG Group submitted that the present petition [2024] 9 S.C.R. 921Ajay Madhusudan Patel & O rs. v . J y otrindra S. Patel & O rs. is merely a device to embroil strangers into an agreement entered into between two groups of the same family since the SRG Group is admittedly neither a party nor signatory or confirming party to the FAA or the alleged arbitration agreement contained therein. The AMP and JRS Groups who are signatories thereto are ad idem about the terms of the FAA, including their mutual intention to refer the disputes arising from it to arbitration. Had the SRG Group been involved in the negotiations leading to the signing of the FAA, or participated therein, or expressed its inclination to be bound by the arbitration agreement, the same would have been recorded in the FAA.
41. The counsel submitted that the fact that the FAA had always been intended to operate inter se the AMP and JRS Groups is borne from a bare perusal of the clauses of the FAA itself which only confers rights or fastens obligations upon the said Groups.
• Recital F specifically records that the AMP and JRS Groups “after mutual discussions and negotiations have agreed to settle all disputes/issues that have arisen amongst the parties over last several years …. on the terms and conditions as mutually agreed to”.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.