Dlf Ltd. (Formerly Known As Dlf Universal Ltd) and Anr. v. Koncar Generators and Motors Ltd.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 593; [2024] 8 S.C.R. 291
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, Justice Aravind Kumar
- Decided
- 8 Aug 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 7702/2019
- Sections
- 48, 17, 34, 37, 49, 45, 46, 44, 47, 75, 81, 50
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 8 S.C.R. 291 : 2024 INSC 593 DLF Ltd. (Formerly Known as DLF Universal Ltd) and Anr. v.
Koncar Generators and Motors Ltd.
(Civil Appeal No. 7702 of 2019)
08 August 2024 [Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha* and Aravind Kumar, JJ.] Issue for Consideration The issue arising in the present appeal relates to enforcement of an arbitral award expressed in foreign currency. In this context, two questions arise for consideration. First, what is the correct and appropriate date to determine the foreign exchange rate for converting the award amount expressed in foreign currency to Indian rupees. Second, what would be the date of such conversion, when the award debtor deposits some amount before the court during the pendency of proceedings challenging the award.
Headnotes† Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 – Arbitral Award – Enforcement of an arbitral award expressed in foreign currency – What is the correct and appropriate date to determine the foreign exchange rate for converting the award amount expressed in foreign currency to Indian rupees: Held: The statutory scheme of the Act makes a foreign arbitral award enforceable when the objections against it are finally decided – Therefore, as per the Act and the principle in Forasol case, the relevant date for determining the conversion rate of foreign award expressed in foreign currency is the date when the award becomes enforceable. [Para 20(i)] Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 – Arbitral Award – Enforcement of an arbitral award expressed in foreign currency – What would be the date of such conversion, when the award debtor deposits some amount before the court during the pendency of proceedings challenging the award:
Held: When the award debtor deposits an amount before the court during the pendency of objections and the award holder is permitted to withdraw the same, even if against the requirement of * Author 292 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports security, this deposited amount must be converted as on the date of the deposit – After the conversion of the deposited amount, the same must be adjusted against the remaining amount of principal and interest pending under the arbitral award – This remaining amount must be converted on the date when the arbitral award becomes enforceable, i.e., when the objections against it are finally decided. [Para 20(ii)(iii)] Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 – Appellants are Indian companies and the respondent is a Croatian company – Dispute arose between the parties – Matter referred to arbitration before the International Chamber of Commerce – Arbitral tribunal passed its award dated 12.05.2004 in favour of the respondent-claimant – Appellants then filed objections against the award u/s. 48 – The appellants deposited Rs. 7.5 crores with the Executing Court on 22.10.2010 – Trial Court dismissed the objections filed u/s. 48 – Appellants filed a revision, which the High Court admitted by order dated 03.06.2011 – The High Court stayed the operation of the Trial Court order dismissing objections, subject to the appellants depositing a further amount of Rs. 50 lakhs, in addition to Rs. 7.5 crores, with the Executing Court – The revision came to be dismissed by the High Court on 01.07.2014, by which the award attained finality as this order was not challenged any further – What would be relevant conversion date of the amount:
Held: The deposit of Rs. 7.5 crores was permitted for withdrawal by furnishing a bank guarantee – So, the first deposit of Rs. 7.5 crores must be converted as on the date of deposit being 22.10.2010 – The second deposit of Rs. 50 lakhs pursuant to the High Court order dated 03.06.2011 stands on a different footing from the first deposit – This order did not permit the respondent to withdraw this amount till the completion of the proceedings – Hence, the amount cannot be converted as on the date of deposit as the respondent could not have benefitted from the same – Here, the revision proceedings were complete on 01.07.2014 – Thus, the second deposit of Rs. 50 lakhs as well as the remaining amount due under the award must be converted when the objections proceedings attained finality on 01.07.2014 – The Executing Court, being the Additional District Judge cum Commercial Court, must determine the amount payable by taking into account the exchange rate as on 01.07.2014. [Paras 11.2, 18, 19, 21] [2024] 8 S.C.R. 293DLF Ltd. (Formerly Known as DLF Universal Ltd) and Anr. v. Koncar Generators and Motors Ltd.
Case Law Cited Gurpreet Singh v. Union of India [2006] Supp. 7 SCR 422 : (2006) 8 SCC 457 – followed.
Forasol v. Oil and Natural Gas Commission [1984] 1 SCR 526 : (1984) Supp SCC 263 – relied on.
Renusagar Power Co Ltd v. General Electric Co [1993] Supp. 3 SCR 22 : (1994) Supp 1 SCC 644; P.S.L. Ramanathan Chettiar v. O.R.M.P.R.M [1968] 3 SCR 367; Fuerst Day Lawson v. Jindal Exports Limited [2001] 3 SCR 479 : (2001) 6 SCC 356; United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kantika Colour Lab [2010] 6 SCR 204 : (2010) 6 SCC 449; Meenakshi Saxena v. ECGC Limited [2018] 5 SCR 421 : (2018) 7 SCC 479; United India Insurance Co. Ltd v. Patricia Jean Mahajan [2002] 3 SCR 1176 : (2002) 6 SCC 281; Jiju Kuruvila v. Kunjujamma Mohan [2013] 7 SCR 276 : (2013) 9 SCC 166; Triveny Kodkany v. Air India Limited (2021) 19 SCC 214; KL Suneja v. Dr Manjeet Kaur Monga [2023] 1 SCR 1079 : (2023) 6 SCC 722; Nepa Limited v. Manoj Kumar Agrawal [2022] 14 SCR 446 : (2022) SCC OnLine SC 1736; Delhi Development Authority v. Bhai Sardar Singh and Sons (C.A. 3867 of 2010) – referred to.
Progetto Grano S.P.A. v. Shri Lal Mahal Limited (2014) SCC OnLine Del 3348; Fuerst Day Lawson v. Jindal Exports Ltd (2012) SCC OnLine Del 5647; Trammo AG v. MMTC Limited (2019)
SCC OnLine Del 7337; Voith Hydro v. NTPC Limited (2021) SCC OnLine Del 1325; Karamchand Thapar & Bros. (Coal Sales) Ltd. v. MMTC Ltd. (2022) SCC OnLine Del 949 – referred to.
Jugoslavenska Oseanska Plovidba v. Castle Investment Co. Inc. [1973] 3 All E.R. 498; In re United Railways of the Havana and Regia Warehouses, Ltd. [1959] 1 All E.R. 214 (CA); Schorsch Meier GmbH v. Hennin [1975] 1 All E.R. 152; Miliangos v. George Prank (Textiles) Ltd. 1976 AC 443 – referred to.
List of Acts Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996; Arbitration Act, 1940; Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973; Arbitration Act, 1950 (UK); Foreign Awards (Recognition and Enforcement) Act, 1961; Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
List of Keywords Arbitration; Arbitral award; Foreign arbitral award; Enforcement of an arbitral award expressed in foreign currency; Foreign Exchange; 294 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Foreign exchange rate for converting award; Date to determine the foreign exchange rate for converting the award; Enforcement of an arbitral award expressed in foreign currency; Relevant conversion date of amount; Section 48 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996; Section 17 of the Arbitration Act, 1940.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 7702 of 2019 From the Judgment and Order dated 26.02.2018 of the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh in CR No.1827 of 2017 Appearances for Parties Pinaki Misra, Sr. Adv., Pravin Bahadur, Ms. Ruby Singh Ahuja, Ms. Kritika Gomber, Ms. Akanksha Thapa, Vishnu Kant, Ms. Uzma Sheikh, M/s. Karanjawala & Co., Advs. for the Appellants.
Abhay Mahajan, Shivam Malhotra, Manoranjan Kumar, Advs. for the Respondent.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, J.
1. The issue arising in the present appeal relates to enforcement of an arbitral award expressed in foreign currency. In this context, two questions arise for consideration. First, what is the correct and appropriate date to determine the foreign exchange rate for converting the award amount expressed in foreign currency to Indian rupees. Second, what would be the date of such conversion, when the award debtor deposits some amount before the court during the pendency of proceedings challenging the award. Two uncertainties have a direct bearing on the question to be answered, the time lapse between the date of the award and its enforceability- a local factor, and the ever-fluctuating exchange rates- a global factor.
1.1 Taking into account these two factors and the statutory provisions, coupled with the decisions of this Court, we have formulated twin principles: First, following the principle in Forasol v. Oil and Natural Gas Commission,1 the date when the arbitral 1 [1984] 1 SCR 526 : 1984 Supp SCC 263 [2024] 8 S.C.R. 295DLF Ltd. (Formerly Known as DLF Universal Ltd) and Anr. v. Koncar Generators and Motors Ltd.
award becomes enforceable shall be the date for conversion. Under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 2 this date is when the objections against the award are dismissed, and award attains finality. Second, in the event that the award amount or part of it is deposited in court pending objections, enabling withdrawal by the decree holder, that date of such deposit shall be the relevant date for conversion as per the principle in Renusagar Power Co Ltd v. General Electric Co. 3 Before we consider the submissions of the counsels representing the parties, followed by our reasons and decision, we will refer to the relevant facts of the case.
2. Facts: The relevant facts are that the appellants are Indian companies and the respondent is a Croatian company. The parties entered a contract for the design, engineering, manufacturing, and supply of two generators by the respondent. Certain disputes arose between them that were referred to arbitration before the International Chamber of Commerce, 4 Paris. The three-member arbitral tribunal passed its award dated 12.05.2004 in favour of the respondent-claimant and held the appellants to be jointly and severally liable to pay Euros 10,93,989, along with interest, as follows:
i. Euros 9,60,308.41 with interest of 5% p.a. starting on 31.10.1999 until final repayment;
ii. Euros 18,411.40 for the storage and maintenance of the goods with interest of 5% p.a. starting from the date of the award;
iii. Euros 5,545.40 relating to lawyer expenses of the claimant, euros 99,482.70 relating to arbitration fees paid to the ICC, euros 3,389.57 as guaranty expenses relating to the repayment of the appellants’ arbitration fee to the ICC, euros 6,852 relating to the arbitration costs in Paris, all these amounts with interest of 5% p.a. from the date of the award.
2 Hereinafter ‘the Act’.
3 [1993] Supp. 3 SCR 22 : 1994 Supp (1) SCC 644 4 Hereinafter “ICC”.
296 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports 2.1 The respondent filed for execution of the award in 2004, while the appellants filed a petition under Section 34 of the Act, which was dismissed on 28.04.2010. In 2010, the appellants then filed objections against the award under Section 48 of the Act and also filed a Section 37 appeal against the Section 34 order. The High Court dismissed the appeal by its order dated 15.10.2010, the terms of which are important for our purpose and are hence extracted:
“After arguing for some time learned counsel have reached a consensus on the present appeal. It has been agreed by learned counsel for the appellants that the appeal as well as the application under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 would be dismissed as withdrawn. It has been further agreed that the appellants would deposit an amount of Rs.7.5 Crores before the Executing Court on or before 08.11.2010.
It has been agreed by learned counsel for the respondent that the application under Section 48 which has been filed by the appellants would be decided on its own merits without being influenced by any findings or observations in the order on the application under Section 34 dated 28.04.2010. It has further been agreed by learned counsel for the respondent that the amount of Rs. 7.5 Crores which would be deposited by the appellants would be released to it only consequent to furnishing a bank guarantee of a scheduled bank of India in the amount of Rs. 7.5 Crores in favour of the Executing Court and the said bank guarantee would be kept alive during the proceedings under Section 48 and for a period of 60 days thereafter. The final order thereon would obviously be passed by the Executing Court after the conclusion of the proceedings under Section 48.”
2.2 In accordance with the above, the appellants deposited Rs. 7.5 crores with the Executing Court on 22.10.2010. 2.3 The Trial Court dismissed the objections filed under Section 48 by order dated 02.04.2011. The appellants filed [2024] 8 S.C.R. 297DLF Ltd. (Formerly Known as DLF Universal Ltd) and Anr. v. Koncar Generators and Motors Ltd.
a revision, which the High Court admitted by order dated 03.06.2011. By this order, the High Court also stayed the operation of the Trial Court order dismissing objections, subject to the appellants depositing a further amount of Rs. 50 lakhs, in addition to Rs. 7.5 crores, with the Executing Court. The Court directed that the amount shall be disbursed to the successful party on the final adjudication of this lis. It also rejected the respondent’s prayer for deposit of the amount in euros. Pursuant to this order, the appellants deposited Rs. 50 lakhs on 15.07.2011. Subsequently, the revision came to be dismissed by the High Court on 01.07.2014, by which the award attained finality as this order was not challenged any further. 2.4 In the execution proceedings, the Trial Court by order dated 24.08.2016 permitted the respondent to withdraw the entire deposit of Rs. 8 crores as per the direction of the High Court. On 10.10.2016, the respondent received Rs. 11,60,12,100, including the interest that had accrued on the deposited amount. 2.5 The execution petition was allowed by the Trial Court by its order dated 03.02.2017, wherein it was held that the relevant date to convert the award amount expressed in euros to Indian rupees (the foreign exchange rate) is 01.07.2014, i.e., the date on which all the objections against the award were finally decided as it is only on such date that the award is deemed to be a decree. The Trial Court accepted the calculation as submitted by the respondent.
2.6 The appellants filed a revision petition against this order, which was dismissed by the High Court by order dated 26.02.2018, 5 which is impugned herein. The High Court rejected the appellant’s reliance on this Court’s decision in Forasol (supra) to submit that the date of decree shall be deemed as the relevant date for conversion and since the award dated 12.05.2004 is a deemed decree under the Act, the exchange rate as on the date of the award should be applied. The Court reasoned that this Court’s judgment in Forasol (supra) was passed under the Arbitration Act, 1940 and hence, does not apply in the present case. Instead, the High Court referred to the Delhi High Court’s 5 In CR No. 1827 of 2017 (O&M), Punjab and Haryana High Court (hereinafter “impugned judgment”). 298 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports decision in Progetto Grano S.P.A. v. Shri Lal Mahal Limited, 6 against which this Court dismissed the SLP, 7 where it was held that the relevant date for conversion is when the objections filed under Section 48 are finally decided. Further, the Court referred to Section 49 of the Act8 that provides that the foreign arbitral award shall be deemed to be a decree of the court when it is satisfied that it is enforceable under Part II, Chapter I of the Act. It reasoned that such satisfaction required under Section 49 is complete only when the objections filed under Section 48 are finally decided, which was on 01.07.2014 in the present case (when the High Court dismissed the revision). It also observed that the appellants delayed execution of the award by initially filing under Section 34, despite such application not being maintainable and then filing an appeal against this order and subsequently withdrawing it. The appellants cannot be permitted to benefit from the fluctuation in exchange rates when the delay is attributable to them. Therefore, the relevant date for conversion is 01.07.2014.
2.7 While issuing notice on the special leave petition filed by the appellant on 10.09.2018, 9 this Court confined the issue to determining whether the foreign exchange rate as on 15.10.2010 would apply to the deposit of Rs. 8 crores.
3. Submissions: Learned senior counsel Mr. Pinaki Mishra appeared on behalf of the appellants. Initially, he submitted that 01.07.2014 would not be the relevant date for conversion for the entire amount and argued for using the exchange rate on 02.04.2011, when the Trial Court dismissed objections under Section 48. However, he later restricted his submissions to the exchange rate that applies when the amount of Rs. 8 crores was deposited by the appellants on 22.10.2010 as per the order dated 15.10.2010. The crux of his argument is that the deposited amount stands converted as on the 6 2014 SCC OnLine Del 3348 7 SLP No. 27041/2014, order dated 21.11.2014.
8 Section 49 of the Act reads:
“49. Enforcement of foreign awards.—Where the Court is satisfied that the foreign award is enforceable under this Chapter, the award shall be deemed to be a decree of that Court.” 9 By order 10.09.2018, this Court ordered: “Issue notice, returnable within four weeks, limited to the conversion rate that would be applicable on 15.10.2010 insofar as the deposit of Rs. 7.5 Crores is concerned. The same will apply to the further deposit of Rs. 50,00,000/-.” [2024] 8 S.C.R. 299DLF Ltd. (Formerly Known as DLF Universal Ltd) and Anr. v. Koncar Generators and Motors Ltd.
date of its deposit, and this amount then cannot be converted again as per the exchange rate prevailing on 01.07.2014. He has submitted that the High Court passed an order dated 15.10.2010 directing the appellants to deposit Rs. 7.5 crores on the consent of both parties, and also permitted the respondent to withdraw this amount on furnishing a bank guarantee in Indian rupee for the entire amount, to which the respondent had agreed at the time. He further submitted that the appellants cannot be faulted for the respondent not withdrawing the amount when it was deposited. In response to the respondent’s contention regarding their inability to furnish a bank guarantee of a scheduled Indian bank, he submitted that the respondent had agreed to this condition when the order was passed, and in any case, it could have applied for a modification but did not do so. Since the respondent consented to the deposit of Rs. 7.5 crores and it was also permitted to withdraw the same, the amount stood converted as on the date of its deposit on 22.10.2010. The exchange rate on this date was 1 euro = Rs. 59.17. While the arbitral award along with interest was euros 16,73,469.07, the deposited amount of Rs. 7.5 crores gets converted to euros 12,67,534.22 at that exchange rate, and the balance of the award would be euros 4,05,934.85 that remained pending as on this date. Subsequently, pursuant to the High Court’s interim order dated 03.06.2011 in revision against the Trial Court dismissing the objections petition, the appellant deposited an additional amount of Rs. 50 lakhs on 15.07.2011. As on this date, the amount of arbitral award including interest pending payment was euros 4,17,278.78, i.e., after converting and adjusting the earlier deposit against the award. Using the prevailing exchange rate of 1 euro = Rs. 62.89 as on 15.07.2011, the appellant’s deposit amounts to euros 79,503.90. Therefore, a balance of euros 3,37,774.88, along with interest, remains pending for which the exchange rate as on 01.07.2014 would apply.
3.1 Mr. Mishra concluded by submitting that the appellants would be required to pay only Rs. 3.19 crores if their calculation is accepted. On the other hand, if the impugned judgment is upheld, they would be required to be pay more than double the amount, i.e., Rs. 6.48 crores.
3.2 Mr. Abhay Mahajan, learned counsel, appearing for the respondent submitted that the exchange rate on 01.07.2014 would apply to the entire award amount. He submitted that the respondent had not consented to the deposit of Rs. 7.5 300 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports crores and that the High Court did not convert the amount but only directed deposit of a lump sum amount. He relied on this Court’s decision in P.S.L. Ramanathan Chettiar v. O.R.M.P.R.M. Ramanathan Chettiar10 where it was held that the judgment debtor depositing a sum in court during the pendency of the appeal does not pass the title and vest the money with the decree-holder. The decree-holder may withdraw the amount only on furnishing security, which means that the payment is not in satisfaction of the decree. Further, the judgment debtor can proceed against the security in case he succeeds in the appeal. Rather, the purpose of the deposit is to obtain a stay of execution and to put the money beyond the reach of the parties pending the disposal of the appeal. On this basis, Mr. Mahajan submitted that the deposit of Rs. 8 crores during the pendency of the objections under Section 48 does not pass the title of this amount to the respondent and such deposit was not under the arbitral award as the award can be deemed to be a decree only on 01.07.2014 when all the objections to the award stood dismissed. Hence, this is the relevant date for conversion. 3.3 As per the calculation sheet submitted by the respondent, the exchange rate as on this date is 1 euro = Rs. 82.21 and this rate must be used for converting the entire arbitral award and interest. The amount of Rs. 11.6 crores withdrawn by the respondent on 10.10.2016 must first be appropriated towards interest and then towards the principal sum. After adjusting this amount and after accounting for interest, the respondent submits that it is entitled to Rs. 6,57,62,057 from the appellants.
4. Analysis – Statutory Scheme: It is important to first set out the statutory scheme for the enforcement of foreign arbitral awards in India. Under the Act, Part II deals with the enforcement of certain foreign arbitral awards. Chapter I deals with awards under the New York Convention. Section 45 provides for the power of a court to refer parties to arbitration.11 Section 46 provides that a foreign award 10 [1968] 3 SCR 367 11 Section 45 reads:
“45. Power of judicial authority to refer parties to arbitration.—Notwithstanding anything contained in Part I or in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908), a judicial authority, when seized of an action in a matter in respect of which the parties have made an agreement referred to in section 44, shall, at the request of one of the parties or any person claiming through or under him, refer the parties to arbitration, [2024] 8 S.C.R. 301DLF Ltd. (Formerly Known as DLF Universal Ltd) and Anr. v. Koncar Generators and Motors Ltd.
which is enforceable under this Chapter shall be treated as binding for all purposes on the persons between whom it is made.12 Section 47 provides for the evidentiary requirements for enforcement of a foreign award.13 Section 48 sets out various grounds on which the court may refuse the enforcement of a foreign award. 14 Section 49 [unless it prima facie finds] that the said agreement is null and void, inoperative or incapable of being performed.”
12 Section 46 reads:
“46. When foreign award binding.—Any foreign award which would be enforceable under this Chapter shall be treated as binding for all purposes on the persons as between whom it was made, and may accordingly be relied on by any of those persons by way of defence, set off or otherwise in any legal proceedings in India and any references in this Chapter to enforcing a foreign award shall be construed as including references to relying on an award.”
13 Section 47 reads:
“47. Evidence.—(1) The party applying for the enforcement of a foreign award shall, at the time of the application, produce before the court—
(a) the original award or a copy thereof, duly authenticated in the manner required by the law of the country in which it was made;
(b) the original agreement for arbitration or a duly certified copy thereof; and
(c) such evidence as may be necessary to prove that the award is a foreign award.
(2) If the award or agreement to be produced under sub-section (1) is in a foreign language, the party seeking to enforce the award shall produce a translation into English certified as correct by a diplomatic or consular agent of the country to which that party belongs or certified as correct in such other manner as may be sufficient according to the law in force in India. [Explanation.—In this section and in the sections following in this Chapter, “Court” means the High Court having original jurisdiction to decide the questions forming the subject-matter of the arbitral award if the same had been the subject-matter of a suit on its original civil jurisdiction and in other cases, in the High Court having jurisdiction to hear appeals from decrees of courts subordinate to such High Court.]” 14 Section 48 reads:
“48. Conditions for enforcement of foreign awards.—(1) Enforcement of a foreign award may be refused, at the request of the party against whom it is invoked, only if that party furnishes to the court proof that—
(a) the parties to the agreement referred to in section 44 were, under the law applicable to them, under some incapacity, or the said agreement is not valid under the law to which the parties have subjected it or, failing any indication thereon, under the law of the country where the award was made; or
(b) the party against whom the award is invoked was not given proper notice of the appointment of the arbitrator or of the arbitral proceedings or was otherwise unable to present his case; or
(c) the award deals with a difference not contemplated by or not falling within the terms of the submission to arbitration, or it contains decisions on matters beyond the scope of the submission to arbitration: Provided that, if the decisions on matters submitted to arbitration can be separated from those not so submitted, that part of the award which contains decisions on matters submitted to arbitration may be enforced; or
(d) the composition of the arbitral authority or the arbitral procedure was not in accordance with the agreement of the parties, or, failing such agreement, was not in accordance with the law of the country where the arbitration took place; or
(e) the award has not yet become binding on the parties, or has been set aside or suspended by a competent authority of the country in which, or under the law of which, that award was made.
(2) Enforcement of an arbitral award may also be refused if the Court finds that—
(a) the subject-matter of the difference is not capable of settlement by arbitration under the law of India; or
(b) the enforcement of the award would be contrary to the public policy of India. [Explanation 1.—For the avoidance of any doubt, it is clarified that an award is in conflict with the public policy of India, only if,—
(i) the making of the award was induced or affected by fraud or corruption or was in violation of section 75 or section 81; or 302 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports provides that where the court is satisfied that a foreign award is enforceable under this Chapter, it shall be deemed to be a decree of that court. Section 50 provides for appeal against certain orders, i.e., orders refusing to refer parties to arbitration under Section 45 and orders refusing to enforce a foreign award under Section 48. 15 Finally, Section 5116 is a savings clause and Section 52 17 provides that Chapter II of Part II shall not apply to awards governed under this Chapter.
4.1 From the statutory scheme, it is clear that a foreign arbitral award is binding between the parties when it is enforceable under Part II, Chapter I of the Act (Section 46). The enforceability of the award can be challenged under Section 48, and the order passed on such an application can be appealed under Section 50 only if it is allowed and the court refuses enforcement of the award. Therefore, a foreign award can be enforced when the objections against it are finally decided and dismissed. At this point, the award is deemed to be a decree of the court as per Section 49.18 Unlike under the Arbitration Act, 1940, there is no requirement for a separate decree by a court for making the award a rule of the court.19
(ii) it is in contravention with the fundamental policy of Indian law; or
(iii) it is in conflict with the most basic notions of morality or justice. ] [Explanation 2.—For the avoidance of doubt, the test as to whether there is a contravention with the fundamental policy of Indian law shall not entail a review on the merits of the dispute.]
(3) If an application for the setting aside or suspension of the award has been made to a competent authority referred to in clause (e) of sub-section (1) the Court may, if it considers it proper, adjourn the decision on the enforcement of the award and may also, on the application of the party claiming enforcement of the award, order the other party to give suitable security.” 15 Section 50 reads:
“50. Appealable orders.—(1) [Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force, an appeal] shall lie from the order refusing to—
(a) refer the parties to arbitration under section 45;
(b) enforce a foreign award under section 48, to the court authorised by law to hear appeals from such order.
(2) No second appeal shall lie from an order passed in appeal under this section, but nothing in this section shall affect or take away any right to appeal to the Supreme Court.” 16 Section 51 reads:
“51. Saving.—Nothing in this Chapter shall prejudice any rights which any person would have had of enforcing in India of any award or of availing himself in India of any award if this Chapter had not been enacted.”
17 Section 52 reads:
“52. Chapter II not to apply.—Chapter II of this Part shall not apply in relation to foreign awards to which this Chapter applies.”
18 See Fuerst Day Lawson v. Jindal Exports Limited (2001) 6 SCC 356, paras 30 and 31. 19 ibid.
[2024] 8 S.C.R. 303DLF Ltd. (Formerly Known as DLF Universal Ltd) and Anr. v. Koncar Generators and Motors Ltd.
5. Case-law on Relevant Date for Conversion: Now, we will discuss the case-law on the relevant date of conversion, both in the context of arbitral awards and judgments where the decretal amount is expressed in a foreign currency. The seminal case that first decided this question was Forasol v. ONGC (supra). Forasol was a French company that was awarded a tender for structural drilling of oil for exploration by ONGC. Pursuant to certain disputes that arose between the parties, the matter was referred to arbitration and on 21.12.1974, an arbitral award was passed in Forasol’s favour where the amount was expressed in French francs. This award was made under the Arbitration Act, 1940. The Court held that the award can be enforced either in foreign currency or in Indian rupee. The principles for determining conversion to Indian rupee are as follows: 5.1 Where the contract provides for a rate of exchange, the same must be used to convert the amount in accordance with the wording of the contractual clause. In this case, article IX-3.1 of the contract provided for the exchange rate of FF 1.033 = Re. 1.000, which the Court held as applying to only 20% of the fees and charges computed in French francs based on contractual interpretation. 20 Further, the arbitral award provided for an enhanced rate of conversion of FF 1.000 = Rs. 1.5178 as applicable to payments in Indian rupee on or after 30.11.1966 as the Indian rupee was depreciated at this time. The Court interpreted the arbitral award and held this exchange rate to apply in place of what was provided in article IX-3.1 to the extent of payments made in Indian rupee on and after 30.11.1966.21 5.2 For the remaining amount that still required to be converted to Indian rupee for which no exchange rate was provided in the contract or the arbitral award, the Court considered six possible dates as the proper date for fixing the rate of exchange22 : i. the date when the amount became due and payable;
ii. the date of the commencement of the action;
iii. the date of the decree;
20 Forasol (supra), para 16.
21 ibid, paras 17-22.
22 ibid, paras 24-2 5.
304 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports iv. the date when the court orders execution to issue; v. the date when the decretal amount is paid or realised; vi. and in cases where a decree is passed by the court in terms of an arbitral award in foreign currency, the date of the award.
5.3 After an extensive discussion of English jurisprudence on the point, the Court noted the position of law in England at the time. 23 Briefly stated, the position is as follows: Both courts and arbitrators in England have the jurisdiction to make a judgment/ award in foreign currency in certain circumstances. In the Jugoslavenska case, 24 the Court of Appeal held that in cases of arbitral awards, the date of award is the relevant date for determining the exchange rate. This was a departure from the ‘breach date rule’, i.e., the conversion must be as per the exchange rate on the date when the debt was payable, which principle was laid down by the House of Lords in the Havana case. 25 Subsequently, in the Schorsch Meier case 26 (this was not a case of arbitration but a claim for payment of price of goods in a foreign currency filed before English courts), the Court of Appeal held that the date of conversion should be the date of payment, i.e., the date on which the court authorises enforcement of the judgment in terms of sterling. Finally, in the Miliangos case,27 the House of Lords also held that the date of conversion should be the date when the court authorises enforcement of the judgment in terms of sterling pound. While Jugoslavenska (supra) was not expressly overruled by the House of Lords, its correctness was doubted.
5.4 The Court held that there is no bar on courts in India to pass a decree for a sum expressed in foreign currency. However, for the purpose of payment of such amount, the limitations and restrictions under the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973 (that was in force at the time) must be considered. If permission 23 ibid, para 39.
24 Jugoslavenska Oseanska Plovidba v. Castle Investment Co. Inc., [1973] 3 All E.R. 498. 25 In re United Railways of the Havana and Regia Warehouses, Ltd.,[1959] 1 All E.R. 214 (CA). 26 Schorsch Meier GmbH v. Hennin, [1975] 1 All E.R. 152 27 Miliangos v. George Prank (Textiles) Ltd., 1976 AC 443. [2024] 8 S.C.R. 305DLF Ltd. (Formerly Known as DLF Universal Ltd) and Anr. v. Koncar Generators and Motors Ltd.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.