Tusharbhai Rajnikantbhai Shah v. Kamal Dayani & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 588; [2024] 8 S.C.R. 235
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 7 Aug 2024
- Case number
- DIARYNO AND DIARYYR No. 1106/2024
- Sections
- 438, 482, 54, 12, 41A, 420, 447, 4R, 41, 437, 197, 323
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 8 S.C.R. 235 : 2024 INSC 588 Tusharbhai Rajnikantbhai Shah v.
Kamal Dayani & Ors.
Contempt Petition (C) D. No. 1106 of 2024 In (Special Leave Petition (Crl.) No. 14489 of 2023)
07 August 2024 [B.R. Gavai and Sandeep Mehta, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Accused-petitioner was granted absolute interim protection of anticipatory bail by Supreme Court, until modified or altered upon final disposal of the present SLP which was pending consideration before this Court. However, in gross violation of the said order, the petitioner was remanded to police custody during the currency of the aforesaid interim order. Present contempt petition filed by the petitioner against the respondents-police officials and the ACJM. Respondents, if committed contempt of this Court’s order. Headnotes† Contempt of Court – When – Accused-petitioner was remanded to police custody during the currency of the interim order passed by Supreme Court granting anticipatory bail to him – Contempt petition filed by the petitioner against the respondents (the police officials and the ACJM) for wilful disobedience and contempt of the Court’s order:
Held: There was no such stipulation in the order under contempt dtd. 08.12.2023 which was passed exercising jurisdiction u/Article 136 of the Constitution of India that the accused could be remanded to police custody – The portrayal made by the Investigating Officer (IO)-contemnor-respondent No. 4 in the remand application to claim that the petitioner was not cooperating in the investigation was totally cooked up – During subsistence of the order dtd. 08.12.2023, there was neither any authority with the IO to seek police custody remand of the accused nor was the prayer for remand justified in the backdrop of the fact that the FIR itself was lodged in relation to a civil dispute which arose from an oral agreement for sale of property – There was neither bona fide nor genuine need for grant of police custody of the petitioner – Thus, respondent No.4, acted 236 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports in flagrant defiance and gross contempt of the aforesaid order by applying for police custody remand of the petitioner – Further, the ACJM-contemnor-respondent No.7 also acted with bias and in a high-handed manner while granting police custody remand of the accused – The SLP filed on behalf of the petitioner had not been finally decided and was still pending adjudication, when the remand application was entertained and hence, there was no occasion for her to have proceeded to interpret this Court’s order in a fanciful manner and that too while acting on a tainted remand application filed by the IO – The reason offered by her that she was acting under a misconception owing to settled and prevailing practice in the State of Gujarat, is in disregard to the order passed by this Court – Order under contempt allowed only one interpretation i.e. the petitioner had to be released on bail in the event of arrest – The action of the respondent No.7 in granting police custody remand of the petitioner and in failing to release him upon completion of the said period is clearly in teeth of this Court’s order dtd. 08.12.2023 and tantamounts to contempt – Respondent No. 7’s contumacious actions also contributed to the illegal detention of the petitioner for almost 48 hours after the period of police remand had come to an end – Detention of the accused till 18.12.23 was unconstitutional and contrary to the letter and spirit of Articles 20 and 21 – Respondent Nos.4 and 7 guilty of committing contempt of this Court’s order dtd. 08.12.2023. [Paras 45-47, 59.3, 59.4, 60] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.438 – Bhartiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 – s.482 – Anticipatory bail – Investigating Officer (IO), if has the liberty to seek police custody remand of the accused after anticipatory bail has been granted by the competent Court – Plea of the Government of Gujarat and the High Court of Gujarat about such long-standing practice prevailing in the State of Gujarat:
Held: Power to grant anticipatory bail is to be exercised with a great degree of circumspection and not in a routine manner – Once, a Court exercises such power bearing in mind the strict parameters applicable to grant of anticipatory bail, then giving a handle to the IO to seek police custody remand of the accused, would virtually negate and frustrate the very purpose behind the order of anticipatory bail – Neither s.438, CrPC nor s. 482, BNSS, 2023 contemplate any such liberty to the IO – The practice prevalent in the State [2024] 8 S.C.R. 237Tusharbhai Rajnikantbhai Shah v. Kamal Dayani & Ors. of Gujarat that the Courts while dealing with the anticipatory bail application routinely impose the restrictive condition whereby, the IOs are granted blanket permission to seek police custody remand of the accused, in whose favour the order of anticipatory bail is passed, is in direct contravention to the ratio of the Constitution Bench judgment of this Court in the case of Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) reported as [2020] 2 SCR 1. [Paras 55, 58] Criminal jurisprudence – Power to grant police remand – Exercise of, not to be in a routine manner – FIR was filed against the accused-petitioner in a prima facie civil dispute pertaining to sale and purchase of property – He was remanded to police custody during the currency of the interim order passed by Supreme Court granting anticipatory bail to him – Impermissibility:
Held: Before exercising the power to grant police custody remand, the Courts must apply judicial mind to the facts of the case so as to arrive at a satisfaction as to whether the police custody remand of the accused is genuinely required – Mere assertion on the part of the State while opposing the plea for anticipatory bail that custodial investigation is required would not be sufficient – The State would have to show or indicate more than prima facie case as to why custodial investigation of the accused is required for the purpose of investigation – Courts are not messengers of the investigating agencies and the remand applications should not be allowed in a routine manner – In the present case, the FIR against the petitioner was pertaining to a dispute which prima facie appears to be of a civil nature and hence, the Magistrate ought not to have toed the line of the Investigating Officer while granting police custody remand of the petitioner – Application seeking police custody remand of the petitioner could not have been entertained without seeking permission of this Court as observed in Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) reported as [2020] 2 SCR 1. [Paras 48-50] Criminal Law – Investigation – On being interrogated, accused not obligated to confess to the crime:
Held: Non-cooperation by the accused is one matter and the accused refusing to confess to the crime is another – There would be no obligation upon the accused that on being interrogated, he must confess to the crime and only thereafter, would the Investigating Officer be satisfied that the accused has cooperated with the investigation. [Para 35] 238 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – ss.54, 200, 202 – Non-compliance – Complaint of custodial violence by the accused-petitioner– ACJM-contemnor-Respondent No.7 made a note on the complaint that after personally examining the feet of the accused, she did not find any injury thereupon: Held: When the accused makes a complaint of torture in police custody, it is incumbent upon the concerned Magistrate to have got the accused subjected to medical examination as per the mandate of s.54 – The formal complaint lodged by the petitioner on 16.12.2023 was proceeded with by 8 th Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate who took cognizance thereof on 22.12.2023 and directed that the complaint be posted for verification – After cognizance had been taken on a private complaint, the statements of the complainant and his witnesses ought to be recorded by taking recourse to the mandatory procedure prescribed u/ss.200 and 202 – However, in sheer disregard to the aforesaid order dated 22.12.2023, the respondent No.7 dismissed the complaint filed by the petitioner which order was rightly reversed by the High Court in the revision petition filed by the petitioner. [Para 54] Case Law Cited Sunilbhai Sudhirbhai Kothari v. State of Gujarat (2014) SCC OnLine Guj 14451 – overruled.
Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) [2020] 2 SCR 1 : (2020) 5 SCC 1 – followed.
Siddhram Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra [2010] 15 SCR 201 : (2011) 1 SCC 694; Paramvir Singh Saini v. Baljit Singh and Another [2020] 13 SCR 770 : (2021) 1 SCC 184; Sanuj Bansal v. The State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. (Petition for Special Leave to Appeal (Crl.) No. 10536/2023); Rekha v. State of T.N. [2011] 4 SCR 740 : (2011) 5 SCC 244; Ashok Kumar v. Union Territory of Chandigarh (2024) SCC OnLine SC 274; P. Chidambaram v. Directorate of Enforcement [2019] 14 SCR 450 : (2019) 9 SCC 24 – referred to.
List of Acts Contempt of Courts Act, 1971; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Bhartiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023; Constitution of India; Income Tax Act, 1961; Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002. [2024] 8 S.C.R. 239Tusharbhai Rajnikantbhai Shah v. Kamal Dayani & Ors. List of Keywords Anticipatory bail; Pre-arrest bail; Absolute interim protection; Interim order; SLP pending consideration; Remand application; Police custody; Police custody remand; Police custody remanded; During currency of the interim order; Contempt; Order under contempt; Contempt of the Court; Contempt petition; Wilful disobedience; Contempt of the Court’s order; IO and ACJM/ Magistrate guilty of contempt; Remand application; Civil dispute given criminal colour; Oral agreement for sale of property; Non-functioning CCTV cameras; Defiance; Gross contempt; Contemptuous; Contemnor; Contumacious actions; Custodial violence; Illegal detention; Illegal custody; Custodial investigation; Non-cooperation by the accused; Refusal to confess to the crime; Torture in police custody; Alleged custodial violence subject matter of departmental proceedings; Individual freedom; Right to liberty. Case Arising From INHERENT/CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Contempt Petition (Civil) Diary No. 1106 of 2024 In Special Leave Petition (Criminal) No. 14489 of 2023 From the Judgment and Order dated 05.10.2023 of the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad in CRLMA No.15242 of 2023 With Special Leave Petition (Crl.) No. 14489 of 2023 and Special Leave Petition(CRL.) Nos. 537 and 1116 of 2024 Appearances for Parties Iqbal Syed, Sr. Adv., Rajivkumar, Anurag Singh, J.K Mishra, Amaan Syed, Mohammad Aslam, Aniq Kadri, Vishrut Bhandari, Dipesh Dalal, Abid Ali Beerani, Advs. for the Petitioner.
S.V. Raju, Ms. Aishwarya Bhati, A.S.Gs., Ms. Archana Pathak Dave, Nikhil Goel, D.N. Ray, R Basant, Sr. Advs., Ms. Swati Ghildiyal, Prashant Bhagwati, Ms. Devyani Bhatt, Ms. Neha Singh, Ms. Devyanti Bhatt, K. Parameshwar, Ms. Ruchi Kohli, Ms. Srishti Mishra, Kushagra Pandey, Ms. Radha Gupta, Ashutosh Ghade, Shushil Shukla, Nimit Bhimjiyani, Purvish Jitendra Malkan, Ms. Neha Bhidey, Ms. Dharita Purvish Malkan, Ms. Deepa Gorasia, Alok Kumar, Kush Goel, Advs. for the Respondents.
240 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment By the Court Contempt Petition (Civil) No(s). ……….of 2024 (D.No. 1106 of 2024) in SLP(Crl.) No(s). 14489 of 2023
1. The instant petition under Section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 read with Article 129 of the Constitution of India has been filed by the petitioner alleging wilful disobedience by the respondentscontemnors of the order dated 8th December, 2023 passed by this Court in SLP(Crl.) No. 14489 of 2023.
Brief facts: -
2. The petitioner, along with other co-accused, was arraigned as an accused in FIR No. 11210068230266 dated 21 st July, 2023 filed by the contemnor-respondent No. 6 herein(the complainant), with an allegation that the petitioner had received a sum of Rs.1.65 crores in cash from the complainant towards the sale of 15 shops but the possession thereof was not handed over to the complainant despite the assurance given by the accused at the time of entering into an oral agreement.
3. The petitioner, apprehending his arrest in connection with the said FIR, sought anticipatory bail from the Sessions Court, which was denied whereafter, an application for anticipatory bail was filed before the High Court, which also came to be rejected. Being aggrieved, the petitioner approached this Court by filing SLP(Crl.) No. 14489 of 2023 seeking anticipatory bail.
4. This Court granted interim anticipatory bail to the petitioner vide order dated 8 th December, 2023(hereinafter being referred to as ‘the order under contempt’), which is reproduced hereinbelow:- "1. Perusal of the impugned order would reveal that the High Court has not even considered the case on merits.
2. In that view of the matter, issue notice, returnable in four weeks.
[2024] 8 S.C.R. 241Tusharbhai Rajnikantbhai Shah v. Kamal Dayani & Ors.
3. In addition to the usual mode, liberty is granted to the petitioner to serve notice through the Standing Counsel for the respondent/State.
4. By way of ad interim order, in the event of arrest petitioner be released on bail in connection with FIR being No.11210068230266 dated 21.07.2023 registered with Vesu Police Station, Surat City, subject to him executing personal bonds for a sum of Rs.25,000/- (Rupees Twenty Five Thousand only), with one or more sureties in the like amount.
5. However, the petitioner is directed to cooperate with the investigation and report to the Investigating Officer as and when directed to do so.”
5. The petitioner appeared at Vesu Police Station on 11th December, 2023 with a copy of the order under contempt dated 8th December, 2023 intending to join and cooperate with the investigation. Shri R.Y. Raval, Investigating Officer(contemnor-respondent No. 4) arrested the petitioner and thereafter, released him on bail upon execution of the requisite bail bonds in terms of order dated 8 th December, 2023. On the very same day, the petitioner was served with a notice under Section 41A of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter being referred to as ‘CrPC’) requiring him to remain present at the police station before the Investigating Officer for recording of further statement. When the petitioner appeared at the police station, another notice dated 12 th December, 2023 was served upon him requiring him to remain present before the Court of concerned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate for the purpose of seeking remand. The contents of the notice dated 12 th December, 2023 are relevant and shall have a material bearing on the outcome of the instant contempt petition and hence, the same are reproduced below for the sake of ready reference: - “ N O T I C E It is hereby given to you this notice in written form that, for the matter of offence committed u/s. 420, 120(b) of Indian Penal Code registered before Vesu Police Station vide Part-A-11210068230366/2023 Complainant Abhishek Vinodkumar Goswami aged: 28 years, occupation:
Business Real Estate Residing at C/405, Surya Palace, Ct 242 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Light, Surat City Mobile No 9879215044 filed a complaint against you and others for which you are remained present as per order passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the matter of Special Leave Application No.14489/2023 on 08/12/2023 and you were arrested on 11/12/2023 at 2100 hrs and thereafter, released on bail on basis of the order of the court. During course of investigation proceedings of the offence, you are hereby informed to remain in(sic) present by yourself or through your advocate on 13/12/2023 at 1500 hrs before 5 th Additional Senior Civil Judge and ACJM Surat Court No 608, New Court Building, Athwalines Surat for the matter of remand which please note seriously. Date 12/12/2023 R.Y. Raval Police Inspector Vesu Police Station Surat City To, Tushar Rajnikant Shah Residing at Flat No E/902, Florence Building, Opp Rajhans Cinema, VIP Road, Vesu, Surat City Mobile No 9825038475”
6. It is apposite to note that this notice makes a distinct reference to the order dated 8th December, 2023 passed by this Court. However, the notice is blissfully silent on the aspect that the petitioner had not cooperated with the investigation.
7. In compliance of the said notice, the petitioner appeared before learned 6 th Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Surat(‘contemnorrespondent No.7’) on 13 th December, 2023 on which date, the Investigating Officer, filed an application seeking his police custody remand for seven days. When the remand application was taken up, learned counsel representing the petitioner produced a copy of the order under contempt dated 8 th December, 2023 and made a fervent submission that the Supreme Court, while providing interim protection to the petitioner had not granted any liberty to the Investigating Officer to seek police custody remand and thus, the application seeking remand ought to be rejected. However, the 6 th ACJM, Ms. Deepaben Sanjaykumar Thakar, the contemnor-respondent No. 7 [2024] 8 S.C.R. 243Tusharbhai Rajnikantbhai Shah v. Kamal Dayani & Ors. in gross derision to the order dated 8 th December, 2023 passed by this Court granting interim protection to the petitioner, observed that the order of Supreme Court did not indicate that the Investigating Officer could not seek remand of the accused or that the Court cannot grant remand and accordingly, she proceeded to remand the petitioner to police custody till 16 th December, 2023. The order dated 13th December, 2023 which is the foundation of these contempt proceedings is reproduced hereinbelow: - “ORDER PASSED BELOW APPLICATION TO AVAIL
POLICE CUSTODY REMAND OF THE ACCUSED
TUSHAR RAJNIKANT SHAH IN THE MATTER OF VESU
POLICE STATION CRIMINAL BEARING REGISTER NO.
11210068230266/2023.
1. Application produced is taken into consideration similarly; the record of the matter is also taken into consideration. Heard arguments advanced by Learned APP Shri S.P.
Chauhan for Prosecution side and Learned Advocate Shri Dipesh Dalal for Accused Person.
2. It is the representation of Learned APP Shri Saurabhbhai Chauhan that, an offence against accused person for offence committed u/s. 420, 120[b] of Indian Penal code is registered for maximum sentence of seven years in which the main role played by the present accused and total of 15 shops were shown to be present along with Accused No. Sumit Goyenka and gave the information that he is the builder and accordingly the Complainant and witness obtained A sum of Rs. 1,65,00,000/- as consideration and also by way of cheque a sum of Rs.54,00,000/- also obtained and in that regard accused no.5, 6 and 7 given payment Diaries and then planned delinquency by the accused Conspirator committed the offense of cheating [deception] fraud. According to the ground for remand, they submit that the main accused has taken total of 9 cheques from the complainant which cheques are important for the present matter and same are required to be collected for the purpose of investigation proceedings. Recovery of Rs. 1,65,00,000/- is pending and in furtherance, addition of other offence of Umra Police Station First Criminal 244 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Register No 62/2019 for offence committed u/s. 447, 448, 451, 427, 114 of Indian Penal Code is registered and accordingly, accused person having criminal history and does not cooperate with police investigations The other co-accused are absconding, and hence, requested to allow police custody remand of Days-7.
3. On 05/10/2023, Learned Advocate Shri Dipesh Dalal on behalf of accused person produced copy of order of R/Criminal Misc. Appln [For Anticipatory Bail] No 15242/2023 and order passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Special Leave to Appeal [Cri] No 14489/2023 dated 05/12/2023 submitted and it was submitted that there is an order to release the bail if the accused is detained and there is no mention of remand. In furtherance, they submit that the petitioner has cooperated with the police investigation and will continue to cooperate in the future as well so there is no need for remand.
In furtherance, they submit that the provision of maximum punishment in the present matter is seven years, therefore, in the matter of Satender Antil versus CBI of the Hon’ble Supreme Court A remand application cannot be granted mechanically as held in the judgment of the further submit that the accused has been present in the police station frequently and has cooperated fully in the investigation, hence the said application is proposed to be rejected.
4. Heard, on 21/7/2023 for the present matter, the complainant filed u/s 420, 120[b] of Indian Penal Code against a total 7 accused in Vesu Police Station. A complaint under section 4R0, 120(b) is lodged which provides for a maximum sentence of seven years. In the present matter, the co-accused is yet to be arrested, if we take the matter diary regarding the behavior of the accused Tushar Rajinikanth Shah mentioned in the remand petition. they will be called on 8/12/2023 for the matter of Special Leave to Appeal No 14486/2023 is not present at the police station for investigation till the order of “releasing the applicant from bail due to arrest” is passed. The facts of the matter diary become significant. The police have visited the house of the main accused, issued notices and reminders under [2024] 8 S.C.R. 245Tusharbhai Rajnikantbhai Shah v. Kamal Dayani & Ors. section 41(A) but the accused himself was not found present at the house, his wife or his mother was present and replied that he was there for the last two months. Not present means the accused person did not cooperate with the police investigation proceedings. Taking into consideration the matter diary dated 11/12/2023, appeared after the order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court and wrote his answer which answer taking into account the facts of the main complaint, it is prima facie evident on the record that the present accused has been dealt with other coaccused, the prime of the present matter. Accused Sumit Goenka is yet to be arrested, other accused are yet to be arrested, police investigation is pending in that direction. In the present matter it is pending investigation as to which accused took the paid compensation of the project property; the main accused has admitted in his statement that the diary was written by him. So, it becomes clear that their criminal role is there and if we note the extreme importance, in the present matter the prosecution has made serious allegations of pre-planned and criminal conspiracy, then a thorough investigation is pending in that regard. In the present matter it becomes necessary to bring the modus operandi of the accused on record. At this stage, it is to be noted that in the present time, the amount of offence related to property like land and houses has increased, in which most of the builder level people are also involved, while in the present matter, there is a deal of 15 shops, so the compensation amount is Rs. 1,65,00,000/- paid, thorough investigation of the offence becomes necessary so the reasons stated in the remand application are true. The present application is eligible to be granted if the coaccused is investigated properly and the modus operandi of the offence is placed on record. In furtherance at this stage there is truth in the reasons stated. The present application is eligible to be granted if the co- accused is investigated properly and the modus operandi of the crime is placed on record. In furtherance, it is to be noted at this stage that Learned Advocate Shri Dipesh Dalal has emphasized on the order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court but in that order no order has been made that 246 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports the investigating officer cannot ask for remand or the court here cannot grant remand so the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Satender Antil versus CBI All the principles laid down in the judgment have been followed by this Court. In the present matter Remand application not automatically but taking into consideration the circumstances of the matter, diary and conduct of the accused, I consider the following order to be appropriate just and appropriate in the interest of justice.
(emphasis supplied)
// ORDER // Remand application is partly allowed.
Police custody remand of Accused Tushar Rajnikant Shah is granted till 16/12/2023 at 1500 hrs.
Signature of accused person and Investigation Officer shall be obtained below order passed.
Investigation Officer shall strictly adhere [follow] the guideline of Hon’ble Supreme Court and send a copy of this order to Chief Judicial Magistrate.
Pronounced this order on 13/12/2023 in the open court. 13/12/2023 Surat Deepaben Sanjaykumar Thakar 6 th Addl. Chief Judicial city Surat [GJ00943] Seen Sign Illegible Seen Sign Illegible Accused is taken into custody And remand order copy is received.
Sign Illegible Today explanation of remand order is received, Sign Illegible”
8. The petitioner has alleged that during the period of police custody remand, he was tortured by the Deputy Commissioner of Police(contemnor- [2024] 8 S.C.R. 247Tusharbhai Rajnikantbhai Shah v. Kamal Dayani & Ors. respondent No. 3) and the Police Inspector(contemnor-respondent No. 4). It is further alleged that upon completion of the period of remand, the petitioner was compelled by the 6th ACJM, i.e., contemnorrespondent No. 7 to move a regular bail application under Section 437 CrPC which was objected to by the learned Assistant Public Prosecutor(in short ‘APP’). The 6 th ACJM(contemnor-respondent No. 7) proceeded to allow the application for bail vide order dated 16 th December, 2023.
9. On 16th December, 2023, when the petitioner was presented before the 6 th ACJM(contemnor-respondent No. 7) at the end of the remand period, he made a complaint regarding torture in police custody which fact was noted by the 6 th ACJM(contemnor-respondent No. 7) in the order sheet dated 16 th December, 2023. The 6th ACJM(contemnorrespondent No. 7) proceeded to record the statement of the petitioner virtually as if he was being cross-examined. She also undertook an exercise of self-observation of the legs of the accused-petitioner and made a remark in the proceeding sheet that no signs of beating were visible thereupon. These proceedings are relevant to the issue at hand in a limited sphere and thus, the same are reproduced hereinbelow for the sake of ready reference:- “My name is Tushar Rajnikant Shah, I am 43 years old. I want to say many things, but my mental condition is not proper so that I can properly dictate everything.
Question: What is your complaint against police?
Answer: Yes, I am beaten a lot, tortured also.
Question: On which part of body beaten?
Answer: Allowing me to sit and on the bottom of the leg beaten and beaten with belt written as Satyashodahk Yantra.
Question: Who has beaten?
Answer: Three officers were there, (1) ACP Gurjar Saheb, IPS and other two I can identify if I see them and they were in simple dress and name plate was not there.
I have not given food since I went there.
Complainant Abhishek or Akhilesh on whose face black spot is there was doing torturing arriving there.
248 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Question: What torturing was done?
Answer: To give money, do settlement, this all belongs to my father and will not spare you.
Question: Except this what is your complaint?
Answer: Now I will state after taking lunch peacefully. Question: You are standing on your legs?
Answer: Yes Question: Do you have any problem in standing?
Answer: In left leg I feel more problem.
Question: Do you came walking on your leg in the court? Answer: Yes Question: Any other thing you want to say against police now?
Answer: Nothing now Above statement is read by me and thereafter I put my signature.
After taking said statement of the accused on bottom portion of the leg of the accused I have done self-observation wherein no sign of beating is found.
Before me Sd/- Illegible 16/12/23 (Kum. D.S. Thaker)
Today, the accused who is present after completion of remand, made a complaint against the police stating that they have ill-treated him which has been registered as per the said statement of the accused. However, after a detailed checking from the bottom of the legs of the accused, no signs are found, as alleged. It is the complaint of the accused that he is beaten by “Satyashodhak Yantra written belt”, however, it is to be noted that the clothes the accused was wearing on the day when remand was granted to the accused are different from the clothes he is wearing today after three days of remand, it could be seen that the same is clean and proper. Even looking at [2024] 8 S.C.R. 249Tusharbhai Rajnikantbhai Shah v. Kamal Dayani & Ors. the physical condition of the accused, it could be concluded that he was kept in good condition and he was provided with clean clothes by his family which was handed over to the accused by the police. It is the submission of the accused that he had not been provided with food on the day when he went on remand. Even if the statement of the accused is to be noted and believed to be correct, it could not be possible that after beaten with the belt, as alleged, the accused could stand properly on his leg today. Therefore, the statement made by him that he has not been provided with food cannot be believed. The accused in the beginning had stated that, he has a lot of things to say but due his mental condition, he has not been able to express everything clearly. However, it is peculiar to note that during the aforesaid statement made by the accused, he was frequently looking at his Ld. Advocate while giving reply due to which the accused was asked that, “why are you looking at your Advocate and giving reply, ill-treatment is done with you then you must be aware what has happened and it is you who have to give your statement.” Thereafter, he has given his statement. The accused has not complained that he is mentally tortured. At this stage, it is notable to mention that the accused is working as a builder having a reputation in society and in such condition and circumstances, remaining in police custody for interrogation, could have been uncomfortable to him. Taking into consideration the mental state of the accused, the serious allegations made by him against the police could not be found reasonable and justifiable in view of the present case and circumstances. All the aforesaid observations and evaluations made today is noted by directly observing the accused.
Sd/-Illegible 16/12/23 6 th Add. Sr. Civil Judge & A.C.J.M., Surat.”
10. It is noteworthy that pursuant to the order dated 16th December, 2023 granting regular bail, the petitioner was compelled to file fresh bail 250 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports bonds and was ultimately released from custody on 18th December, 2023. Apparently thus, the petitioner was kept in confinement for a period of nearly 48 hours even after the period of police custody remand had come to an end. Immediately after being released from custody, the petitioner filed a complaint(Annexure P-10) to the Commissioner of Police alleging torture by the Deputy Commissioner of Police(contemnor-respondent No. 3), Police Inspector(contemnorrespondent No. 4), Police Constable(contemnor-respondent No. 5) and other police officials of Vesu Police Station. A prayer was made in said complaint to call for and preserve the CCTV footage of the police station, lest the police officials of Vesu Police Station tamper with the evidence in form of the recording and thereby, cause grave prejudice to the petitioner’s complaint case. The Commissioner of Police, however, did not take any cognizance of the said complaint of the petitioner whereupon, the petitioner filed a private complaint against contemnor-respondent Nos. 3, 4 and 5 as well as the complainant i.e. contemnor-respondent No. 6. The petitioner categorically alleged in the complaint that he was tortured in Vesu police station, where the complainant of the case was also present, and was pressurised to make payment to the complainant and compromise the matter.
11. Since the 6 th ACJM(contemnor-respondent No. 7) was on leave, the learned Magistrate on duty (8 th Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate) took cognizance of the said complaint vide order dated 21st December, 2023, with a clear finding that the acts complained of were not committed by the concerned police officials while discharging official duties and therefore, sanction to prosecute was not required under Section 197 CrPC. The complaint was kept for verification on 3rd January, 2024.
12. Later, the 6 th ACJM(contemnor-respondent No.7) took up the complaint and proceeded to reject the same vide order dated 6th January, 2024 without recording the statements of the complainant and his witnesses as mandated by Sections 200 and 202 CrPC. The contents of this order are also considered germane for the purpose of adjudication of the instant contempt petition since the same has a direct bearing upon the conduct of contemnor-respondent No. 7 and hence, the same are being reproduced hereinbelow for the sake of ready reference: - “Criminal Inquiry No. 280/2023 [2024] 8 S.C.R. 251Tusharbhai Rajnikantbhai Shah v. Kamal Dayani & Ors.
ORDER BELOW EX-1
1. The said private complaint is filed by complainant Tushar Rajnikant Shah against police officers u/s 323, 342, 344, 363, 384, 504, 506(2), 120(b) of IPC. It is submitted in complainants application that against him in Vesu Police Station A-part CR No.11210068230266/23 is filed u/s 420, 120(b) on date 21.7.2023 wherein he was mentioned as accused no. 4. Investigation officer has taken his statement. The complainant has filed in the Hon’ble Court of Principal District and Sessions Judge at Surat Anticipatory bail application no. 5922/2023 on date 27.7.2023 which was rejected on date 1.8.2023. Thereafter he has filled in the Hon’ble Gujarat High Court CRMA No. 15242/2023 and made order partly allowing the same, being aggrieved by it the complainant filed SLP in Hon’ble Supreme Court on date 5.10.2023 bearing No. 14489/2023 and order was passed allowing his anticipatory bail application. Pursuance to the said order complainant has given his statement on date 11.12.2023 in Vesu Police Station as an accused no. 4 and given bail bond and surety. Thereafter I.O, has Issued notice on date 12.12.2023 to remain present and therefore on date 12.12.2023 remained present at 1/00 and till night up to 10/00 given his reply. Thereafter, on date 13.12.2023 LO. has demanded 7 days remand for him and Hon’ble Lower Court made order allowing 3 days remand. It is submitted by him that during police remand custody with Satyashodhak Yantra belt beating 35 to 40 belt and to do compromise made, him physically uneasy have done unbearable coercion and therefore he became mentally unwell and family members gave courage and he filed present complaint. The complainant has prayed to do legal Inquiry against accused.
2.As per complaint of the complainant on date 3.1.2024 verification is taken and in the said verification he has not stated facts as per his complaint. He has not stated fact about which police officer has beaten him. Compare to complaint application in his verification different facts are coming out like “one person was standing on leg and beat me in bottom of the leg.” As this one person which 252 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports police officer was there no such facts are stated. Asking about who used to come to give clothes, no one has come from his home, his friend Rajendranbhai Rawal came, such facts he has stated but no such friend’s name is mentioned by him as his witness or such witness affidavit as a documentary evidence list is produced along with original complaint. The said complainant has not made satisfactory clarification about any person coming from his family to give clothes. Thereafter he was clearly asked that on completion of remand prior to bringing him in this Court he was taken to medical checkup and its reply is given by him in affirmative. At this stage it is notable that in said original case i.e. Vesu Police Station A-part CR No. 11210068230266/23 medical checkup produced it is clearly mentioned that on body portion of the said accused no apparent injury is there. Further it is notable that he during checkup ha not submitted to the Doctor that he has been assaulted. And in reference to the question he has stated that, “ I am not allowed to speak such”, but at that time the said complaint accused paikee which accused did not allow him to speak such, no such facts are stated. Thereafter he was clearly asked that on completion of remand and on producing in this Court he has stated his facts willingly as per his desire which is replied by him in affirmative. Thereafter he was asked that this Court has at the same time ask him to sit down and checked his bottom of the legs but no signs of beating was found such is stated and he gave his reply in affirmative. Thus, said verification considering entirely with the complaint in Vesu Police Station A-part CR No.11210068230266/23, the accused has filed ill-treatment complaint and therefore in the present separately given complaint nothing remains to be done. Main notable facts is such that in medical certificate of the accused no signs of assault are seen and this Court has personally done observation but no such signs are seen. Further, this Court has on the same day after observing the accused personally in details of observation and evaluation noted and considering it the complainant’s private complaint is not maintainable.
The accused naturally remained in police custody and [2024] 8 S.C.R. 253Tusharbhai Rajnikantbhai Shah v. Kamal Dayani & Ors. in police lock up, have dissatisfaction against police employees which is very casual and natural reaction.
No person would like to remain in police custody and therefore the said complaint is prima facie is filed keeping grudge against the police with a feeling of revenge is made self-clear. As per the said complaint no facts are recorded by accused after completion of remand immediately is not stated in his ill-treatment and therefore the said complaint is not valid and tenable and therefore following order I understand is reasonable and justified.
(emphasis supplied)
ORDER
1. The order is made to cancel the said complaint u/s. 203 of Cr. P.C.
Order declared today on date 06.01.2023 in open Court. Date: 06.01.2024 Surat.
Seen Sd/- Illegible Sd/- Illegible 6.1.24 (Kum. Deepaben Sanjaykumar Thaker)
6th Add. Chief. Judi. Magistrate Surat (GJ00943)
13. A perusal of the order reveals that the 6th ACJM(contemnor-respondent No.7) proceeded to deal with the complaint in a pre-determined manner and rejected the same without recording the statements of the petitioner(complainant) and his witnesses as per the mandate of Sections 200 and 202 CrPC. Acting purely on her own whims and fancies, the contemnor-Respondent No.7 concluded that ex facie the complaint was filed keeping grudge against the police and with the feeling of seeking revenge. The order dated 6th January, 2024 passed by 6th ACJM(contemnor-respondent No.7) has been set aside by the High Court of Gujarat and rightly so, in our opinion, vide order dated 22 nd February, 2024 while accepting the revision petition filed by the petitioner, being R/Criminal Revision Application 254 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports No. 273 of 2024. Relevant observations made by the High Court are reproduced hereinbelow:- “11. As per Section 203 of the Code, the learned Magistrate ought to have recorded the statement on oath of the complainant and of the witnesses and when in-charge Magistrate has directed the complainant to remain present with his witnesses and the witnesses were present before the learned Magistrate, learned Magistrate without giving any reasons for not recording the statements of the witnesses has dismissed the complaint which is illegal and improper. That if the statements of the witnesses were recorded, learned Magistrate could have applied her mind and form the judgment whether there is sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused or not. That learned Magistrate has acted erroneously and has passed the impugned order which is illegal and improper and hence, the same is required to be set aside.
12. On perusal of the impugned order, it appears that the complainant was directed to remain present with his witnesses and as per the submission of the learned senior advocate for the applicant, witnesses were present before the learned Magistrate, but their statements have not been recorded. No reasons have been given by the learned Magistrate for non-recording of the statements of the witnesses and hence, the applicant original complainant has not been given full opportunity for putting up his case before the learned Magistrate. That the impugned order is improper and perverse and is required to be set aside. Learned(sic)
13. Under the circumstances, the application is allowed. The impugned order dated 6.1.2024 passed below Exh.1 in Criminal Inquiry No.280 of 2023 is quashed and set aside. The learned Magistrate is directed to record the statements of the witnesses and then after applying judicial mind to the material placed before the Court, form the judgment whether or not, there is sufficient ground to proceed.”
14. It is in the aforesaid backdrop, that the petitioner has approached this Court by way of the instant contempt petition with a prayer seeking [2024] 8 S.C.R. 255Tusharbhai Rajnikantbhai Shah v. Kamal Dayani & Ors. prosecution of the respondents and to convict and sentence them for wilful disobedience and gross contempt of this Court’s order dated 8 th December, 2023.
15. Notice of the contempt proceedings was issued to the respondents on 10th January, 2024.
16. The High Court of Gujarat was subsequently impleaded in the matter vide order dated 29 th January, 2024.
17. Reply affidavits in response to the notice for contempt, have been filed on behalf of the respondents arraigned in the contempt petition. The petitioner has also filed separate rejoinder affidavits. Submissions on behalf of the petitioner: -
18. Mr. Iqbal Syed, learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner advanced the following pertinent submissions: - 18.1 That the order dated 8th December, 2023 passed by this Court was explicit to the effect that the petitioner was to be released on bail in event of his arrest. No liberty was ever granted by this Court to the Investigating Officer to seek police custody remand of the petitioner while he was under the protective umbrella of the interim anticipatory bail order passed by this Court. 18.2 That the SLP seeking anticipatory bail filed by the petitioner was still pending consideration before this Court and thus, if at all, the Investigating Officer desired to seek police custody remand of the petitioner on the alleged ground of non-cooperation in investigation, then the appropriate procedure would have been to move an application before this Court to seek such liberty. 18.3 That the Investigating Officer had already accepted the bail bonds of the petitioner on 11th December, 2023 and hence, there could not have been any occasion for grant of police custody remand of the petitioner because such course of action resulted into fresh arrest of the petitioner which is clearly in teeth of the order passed by this Court.
18.4 That a pertinent objection was raised before the 6 th ACJM(contemnor-respondent No. 7) that there was no scope for granting police custody remand of the petitioner in view of this Court’s order, but the 6 th ACJM No. 6(contemnor- 256 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports respondent No. 7) totally glossed over the interim order passed by this Court and granted 3 days’ police custody remand of the petitioner by assigning a totally flimsy justification that this Court had not precluded the Investigating Officer from seeking police custody remand of the petitioner nor was the Magistrate prohibited from exercising such power. In support of the submission that there was no scope to remand the petitioner to police custody, learned senior counsel for the petitioner placed reliance on the judgment passed by this Court in the case of Siddhram Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra.1 18.5 He urged that in spite of the interim order of anticipatory bail granted by this Court being in currency, the petitioner was not released from custody even at the end of the police remand period, and rather, he was compelled to file a regular bail application under Section 437 CrPC to which the learned Assistant Public Prosecutor(APP) objected. However, the application was allowed, and the bail bonds of the petitioner were accepted, and he was released from custody on 18 th December, 2023 which aggravates the contemptuous acts of the contemnor-respondent No. 7 because the petitioner was kept in illegal custody for more than 48 hours.
As per learned senior counsel, it is a clear case of the petitioner being kept in illegal custody for a period of 6 days in teeth of the interim order granted by this Court and that too, during pendency of the special leave petition.
18.6 He urged that the biased, pre-determined and prejudiced bent of mind of the 6 th ACJM(contemnor-respondent No.7) is fortified from the fact that when the petitioner made a complaint regarding torture in police custody on being produced before the Court at the end of the remand period, the 6 th ACJM(contemnor-respondent No. 7) proceeded to record a calculated finding that the accused-petitioner was not having signs of injury by even going to the extent of personally examining the feet of the petitioner which procedure was purely within the domain of a Medical Expert.
1 [2010] 15 SCR 201 : (2011) 1 SCC 694 [2024] 8 S.C.R. 257Tusharbhai Rajnikantbhai Shah v. Kamal Dayani & Ors. 18.7 Over and above this, the private complaint filed by the petitioner alleging torture in police custody was rejected in an arbitrary and high-handed fashion even without recording the statements of the complainant (petitioner herein) and the witnesses under Sections 200 and 202 CrPC which is the mandate of law.
The High Court of Gujarat, vide order dated 22nd February, 2024 while reversing the order passed by the 6th ACJM (contemnorrespondent No.7) rejecting the complaint has taken note of the fact that learned Magistrate committed grave legal error in ignoring the provisions of CrPC while rejecting the complaint filed by the petitioner.
18.8 That the petitioner after being released from custody lodged a prompt complaint to the Commissioner of Police, Surat (contemnor-respondent No.2) on 20 th December, 2023 with a pertinent prayer to preserve the CCTV footage of Vesu Police Station. However, no action was forthcoming on the said complaint, and it is only after this Court took cognizance of the contempt proceedings and issued notice that an inquiry was initiated in this regard.
18.9 That the Commissioner of Police, Surat (contemnorrespondent No. 2) has admitted in his affidavit that CCTV cameras installed at Vesu Police Station by a private agency were not functional and this fact was brought to notice of Mr. R.Y. Raval, Police Inspector (contemnor-respondent No. 4) by the PSO in charge on 21st December, 2023. He contended that the clear omission and negligence on part of the concerned police officials in not ensuring the functioning of the CCTV cameras is in sheer disobedience of the mandate of this Court’s judgment in the case of Paramvir Singh Saini v. Baljit Singh and Another.2 18.10 That as per the reply affidavit filed by the Commissioner of Police, Surat(contemnor-respondent No. 2), the FSL examination carried out on the internal storage(hard disk) and the DVR reveals that the CCTV footage of Vesu Police 2 [2020] 13 SCR 770 : (2021) 1 SCC 184 258 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Station from 13 th December, 2023 to 16 th December, 2023 was not found in hard disk which clearly establishes that the police officials had tampered with the DVR and deleted the data saved between 13th December, 2023 to 16 th December, 2023, in order to destroy the evidence of custodial violence committed upon the petitioner.
18.11 That the very fact, that the police officials registered the FIR on the basis of complaint filed by complainant(contemnorrespondent No. 6), being FIR No. 11210068230266 for allegations which ex facie disclose a civil dispute plain and simple, reflects their mala fide and biased approach.
On these grounds, the learned senior counsel implored the Court to prosecute and suitably punish the respondents while holding them guilty of wilful disobedience/gross contempt of this Court’s order dated 8th December, 2023. He also prayed that the interim protection granted to the petitioner vide order dated 8 th December, 2023 passed in SLP(Crl.) No. 14489 of 2023 may be made absolute.
Submissions on behalf of the respondents: -
19. Shri R. Basant, learned senior counsel appearing for the freshly impleaded respondent, the High Court of Gujarat (respondent No. 8) advanced the following submissions: - 19.1 The contention of learned counsel for the petitioner that the Investigating Officer could not have sought remand of the petitioner is misplaced since, the judgment relied upon by the petitioner i.e. Siddhram Satlingappa Mhetre (supra) wherein, it was held that tenure of anticipatory bail order cannot be limited has been explicitly overruled by a larger Bench of this Court in the case of Sushila Aggarwal v. State(NCT of Delhi).3 He placed reliance on the following paras from the above judgment in support of this contention:- “92.6- An order of anticipatory bail should not be “blanket” in the sense that it should not enable the accused to commit further offences and claim relief of indefinite protection from arrest. It should be confined to the offence or incident, for which apprehension of 3 [2020] 2 SCR 1 : (2020) 5 SCC 1 [2024] 8 S.C.R. 259Tusharbhai Rajnikantbhai Shah v. Kamal Dayani & Ors. arrest is sought, in relation to a specific incident. It cannot operate in respect of a future incident that involves commission of an offence.
92.7- An order of anticipatory bail does not in any manner limit or restrict the rights or duties of the police or investigating agency, to investigate into the charges against the person who seeks and is granted pre-arrest bail.”
19.2 He submitted that the Courts in Gujarat based on the view taken by the Division Bench of High Court of Gujarat in the case of Sunilbhai Sudhirbhai Kothari v. State of Gujarat,4 have been following a consistent practice of incorporating a condition in the orders granting anticipatory bail that the Investigating Officer would be entitled to seek police custody remand of the accused as and when required. In Sunilbhai Sudhirbhai Kothari(surpa), the reference was made to the Division Bench to answer the following question of law: - “Whether the Investigating Agency has power to get police custody under Section 167 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, when an accused is already granted bail under the provision of Section 438 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.”
The Division Bench answered the reference in affirmative and thus, there was no impediment for the Investigating Officer to have sought police custody remand of the petitioner and that the learned Magistrate was also acting well within the jurisdiction conferred upon her by CrPC while granting police remand of the petitioner.
20. The learned counsel representing the contemnor-respondent Nos. 2 to 7 submitted in cohesion that all the contemnors have tendered unconditional apology in their reply affidavits for the alleged contumacious acts. They urged that the contemnors had no intention whatsoever to disobey or disregard this Court’s order dated 8 th December, 2023 and the infraction, if any, in this regard is purely unintentional and thus, a lenient view may be taken and the contempt notices may be discharged.
4 2014 SCC OnLine Guj 14451 260 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
21. Mr. S.V. Raju, learned ASG appearing on behalf of Commissioner of Police, Surat(contemnor-respondent No. 2) advanced the following submissions: - 21.1 That respondent No. 2 has no direct role in the contempt proceedings and thus the contempt notice issued to him may be discharged.
21.2 That Commissioner of Police(contemnor-respondent No. 2) has tendered an unconditional apology for any of the alleged action/omission which may have resulted in contempt of this Court’s order dated 8th December, 2023.
21.3 That Vesu Police Station was a newly established police station and thus, CCTV cameras installed in the police station were not properly functional.
21.4 That the DVR and hard disks of the CCTV cameras installed in the police station were forwarded for analysis to the FSL, from where a report has been received that there was some technical defect in the DVR and that the video footage from 13 th December, 2023 to 16th December, 2023 could not be preserved therein. The fact regarding the technical defect in the DVR was not brought to the knowledge of the Commissioner of Police (contemnor-respondent No.2) and hence, he cannot be held guilty of wilful negligence in discharge of duties. 21.5 That Commissioner of Police (contemnor-respondent No. 2) has already initiated departmental proceedings against the erring police officials. The Police Inspector/Investigating Officer (contemnor-respondent No. 4) and Police Constable (contemnor-respondent No. 5) have been placed under suspension.
He thus implored the Court to discharge the contempt notice issued to the Commissioner of Police, Surat(contemnor-respondent No.2).
22. Ms. Aishwarya Bhati, learned ASG, appearing on behalf of Deputy Commissioner of Police, Surat(contemnor-respondent No. 3) advanced the following submissions: - 22.1 That the said contemnor has tendered an unconditional apology for any act or omission which may have contributed to the non-compliance/contempt of this Court’s order dated 8 th [2024] 8 S.C.R. 261Tusharbhai Rajnikantbhai Shah v. Kamal Dayani & Ors. December, 2003. Learned ASG reiterated the averments made in the reply affidavit filed on behalf of the officer and urged that he was, in no manner, connected with the investigation of the subject FIR and thus he cannot be held responsible for the contumacious acts. She fervently contended that the contemnor-respondent No. 3 had no role to play either in the investigation of the case or the custodial torture allegedly meted out to the petitioner during the period of police custody. She also urged that no injuries were found on the person of the petitioner as per the medical report.
22.2 Regarding the issue of the non-functioning of the CCTV cameras in the Vesu Police Station, she submitted that the CCTV cameras had been installed some time back and were functional but there was some problem with the DVR storage not just during the 3 days of custodial period of the petitioner but was persisting since November, 2023. On these grounds, Ms. Bhati, learned ASG implored the Court to accept the unconditional apology filed on behalf of contemnor-respondent No.3 and discharge the contempt notice issued to him.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.