Manish Sisodia v. Directorate of Enforcement
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 595; [2024] 8 S.C.R. 1061
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice K.V. Viswanathan
- Decided
- 9 Aug 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 3295/2024
- Sections
- 45, 439, 3, 207, 19, 436A, 482, 4
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 8 S.C.R. 1061 : 2024 INSC 595 Manish Sisodia v.
Directorate of Enforcement (Criminal Appeal No. 3295 of 2024)
09 August 2024 [B.R. Gavai* and K.V. Viswanathan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Appellant was incarcerated for around 17 months, trial yet to commence. Bail denied. Whether the trial court and the High Court correctly considered the observations made by this Court with regard to right to speedy trial and prolonged period of incarceration. The claim of the appellant was rejected applying the triple test contemplated under Section 45, Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002. Whether the right to bail in cases of delay coupled with incarceration for a long period should be read into Section 439, Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 and Section 45 of the PMLA. Whether the appellant was deprived of his right to speedy trial and if entitled to grant of bail.
Headnotes† Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 – s.45 – Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.439 – Delhi’s Excise Policy Cases, irregularities alleged in the framing and implementation – Cases by CBI and ED, appellant arrested – Previously two rounds of litigation, present is the third round – Incarceration for a long period – Delay in trial, bail rejected – Right to bail – Right to speedy trial – Right to bail in cases of delay coupled with incarceration for a long period, if should be read into Section 439 CrPC, 1973 and Section 45 of the PMLA:
Held: Yes – Right to bail in cases of delay coupled with incarceration for a long period, depending on the nature of the allegations, should be read into Section 439 Cr.P.C. and Section 45 of the PMLA – It is the basic right of the person charged of an offence and not convicted that he be ensured and given a speedy trial – When the trial is not proceeding for reasons not attributable to the accused, the court, unless there are good reasons would * Author 1062 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports exercise the power to grant bail – Provisions of Section 45 of the PMLA would not come in the way of consideration of the application of the appellant for grant of bail – On account of a long period of incarceration for around 17 months and the trial even not having been commenced, the appellant was deprived of his right to speedy trial – On facts, in view of the first order of this Court, the appellant was entitled to renew his request – 493 witnesses were named in the ED and the CBI matter – The case involves thousands of pages of documents and over a lakh pages of digitized documents – There is not even the remotest possibility of the trial being concluded in the near future – Appellant would be deprived of his fundamental right to liberty under Article 21 if kept behind the bars for an unlimited period of time in the hope of speedy completion of trial – Impugned judgment of the High Court quashed and set aside – Appellant granted bail in both ED and the CBI case on the conditions imposed. [Paras 37-39, 43, 49, 54, 58] Criminal Law – Right to fair trial – Right of the accused to inspect documents including “un-relied upon documents”:
Held: Accused has the right to fair trial, cannot be denied the right to have inspection of the documents including the “un-relied upon documents”. [Para 47] Bail – To be granted as a rule, jail is exception – Nonobservance by Courts, deprecated:
Held: Bail is not to be withheld as a punishment – Trial courts and High Courts play safe in matters of grant of bail and the principle that bail is a rule and refusal is an exception is, at times, followed in breach – It is high time that the trial courts and the High Courts should recognize the principle that “bail is rule and jail is exception”. [Para 53] Special Leave Petitions (SLPs) – Preliminary objection as regards the maintainability of the second set of SLPs – Delhi’s Excise Policy Cases, irregularities alleged in the framing and implementation – Cases by CBI and ED, appellant arrested – Previously two rounds of litigation, present is the third round before this Court – In earlier rounds of litigation, liberty was granted to the appellant to move a fresh application for bail in case of change in circumstances or in case the trial was [2024] 8 S.C.R. 1063Manish Sisodia v. Directorate of Enforcement protracted – Preliminary objection was raised as regards the maintainability of the present appeals on account of the second order of this Court, contending that the second set of SLPs cannot be filed to challenge the order of the High Court when the earlier SLPs arising out of the same order were disposed of:
Held: Rejected – This Court was concerned about the prolonged period of incarceration suffered by the appellant – Assurance was given by the prosecution that the trial shall be concluded by taking appropriate steps within next 6-8 months however, far from the trial being concluded within a period of 6-8 months, it is even yet to commence – Liberty was granted to the appellant to revive his prayer after filing of the chargesheet – Relegating the appellant to again approach the trial court and thereafter the High Court when they have already taken a view would be an empty formality – Right to speedy trial is a fundamental right within the broad scope of Article 21 – Liberty reserved by this Court vide its second order, to revive the request of the appellant was a liberty given by this Court to revive his prayer afresh after filing of the final complaint/charge-sheet – Undisputedly, the present appeals were filed after the final complaint/charge-sheet were filed by the respondents. [Paras 29, 32, 43] Case Law Cited Kunhayammed and Others v. State of Kerala and Others [2000] Supp. 1 SCR 538 : (2000) 6 SCC 359; P. Ponnusamy v. State of Tamil Nadu [2022] 15 SCR 265 : (2022) SCC OnLine SC 1543; Vijay Madanlal Choudhary and Others v. Union of India and Others [2022] 6 SCR 382 : (2022) SCC OnLine SC 929;
Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT of Delhi) [2024] 6 SCR 666 : (2024) SCC OnLine SC 934; Ramkripal Meena v. Directorate of Enforcement (SLP (Crl.) No. 3205 of 2024 dated 30.07.2024); Javed Gulam Nabi Shaikh v. State of Maharashtra and Another (2024) SCC OnLine SC 1693; Gudikanti Narasimhulu and Others v. Public Prosecutor, High Court of Andhra Pradesh [1978] 2 SCR 371 : (1978) 1 SCC 240; Shri Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia and Others v. State of Punjab [1980] 3 SCR 383 : (1980) 2 SCC 565; Hussainara Khatoon and Others (I) v. Home Secretary, State of Bihar [1979] 3 SCR 169 : (1980) 1 SCC 81; Union of India v. K.A. Najeeb [2021] 1064 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports 1 SCR 443 : (2021) 3 SCC 713; Satender Kumar Antil v. Central Bureau of Investigation and Another [2022] 10 SCR 351 : (2022) 10 SCC 51 – referred to.
List of Acts Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988; Penal Code, 1860.
List of Keywords Section 45 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002; Triple test under Section 45, Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002; Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Article 21 of the Constitution of India; Delhi’s Excise Policy Cases; Incarceration for a long period; Prolonged period of incarceration; Trial delayed; Delay in trial; Right to speedy trial; Bail rule, jail exception; Right to fair trial; Right to Life and Personal Liberty; Second set of Special Leave Petitions (SLPs); Preliminary objection; Inspection of documents; Un-relied upon documents.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No. 3295 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 21.05.2024 of the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in BA No. 1557 of 2024 With Criminal Appeal No. 3296 of 2024 Appearances for Parties Dr. Abhishek Manu Singhvi, Vikram Chaudhari, Sr. Advs., Vivek Jain, Mohd. Irshad, Amit Bhandari, Karan Sharma, Rajat Jain, Sadiq Noor, Mohit Siwach, Shailesh Chauhan, Advs. for the Appellant. Suryaprakash V. Raju, A.S.G., Mukesh Kumar Maroria, Zoheb Hussain, Annam Venkatesh, Vivek Gaurav, Hitarth Raja, Ms. Abhipriya, Ms. Sweta Desai, Vivek Gurnani, Ms. Aakriti Mishra, Arvind Kumar Sharma, Advs. for the Respondent.
[2024] 8 S.C.R. 1065Manish Sisodia v. Directorate of Enforcement Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment B.R. Gavai, J.
1. Leave granted. Appeals heard on merits.
2. The present appeals challenge the judgment and order dated 21 st May 2024 passed by the learned Single Judge of the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in Bail Application Nos. 1557 and 1559 of 2024, thereby rejecting the said applications filed by the present appellant for grant of bail. The aforesaid two applications were filed seeking bail in connection with ED Case No. HIU-II/14/2022 registered against the appellant by the Directorate of Enforcement (for short, ‘ED’) and First Information Report (FIR) No. RC0032022A0053 of 2022 registered against the appellant by the Central Bureau of Investigation (for short, ‘CBI’).
3. FIR No. RC0032022A0053 of 2022 came to be registered by the CBI on 17 th August 2022, and ED Case No. HIU-II/14/2022 came to be registered by the ED on 22nd August 2022.
4. Since both the cases arise out of similar facts, the latter being the predicate offence and the former being a case registered on the basis of the predicate offence, both these appeals are heard and decided together.
FACTS IN BRIEF:
5. The present case travelled two rounds before the trial court, the High Court and this Court. This is now the third round before this Court wherein the appellant is seeking bail in connection with the aforesaid two cases.
6. On the basis of a letter dated 20 th July 2022 addressed by Shri Vinai Kumar Saxena, the Lieutenant Governor of Delhi, alleging irregularities in the framing and implementation of Delhi’s Excise Policy for the year 2021-22, the Director, Ministry of Home Affairs had directed an enquiry into the said matter vide Office Memorandum dated 22nd July 2022. On 26 th February 2023, the appellant came to be arrested by the CBI. Subsequently, the appellant was arrested by the ED on 9th March 2023.
1066 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
7. After investigation, CBI filed charge-sheet on 25 th April 2023 for the offences punishable under Sections 7, 7A, 8 and 12 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (for short, ‘PC Act’) read with Sections 420, 201 and 120B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short, ‘IPC’). Upon completion of investigation, the ED filed a complaint under Section 3 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (for short, ‘PMLA’) on 4 th May 2023.
8. The first application for regular bail of the appellant in CBI matter came to be rejected by the High Court on 30 th May 2023. Subsequently, the first application for regular bail of the appellant in ED matter came to be rejected by the High Court on 3 rd July 2023. This Court, vide common order dated 30 th October 2023 (hereinafter referred to as “the first order of this Court”) rejected the regular bail applications of the appellant in the CBI matter and the ED matter, with certain observations which we will refer to in the subsequent paragraphs.
9. Subsequently, in view of the liberty granted by this Court, the appellant filed second bail application before the trial court on 27 th January 2024. In the said proceedings, the appellant was granted interim protection. However, by an order dated 30 th April 2024, the trial court rejected the said bail application on the ground that there was no change in the circumstances.
10. The appellant thereafter filed second bail application before the High Court on 2 nd May 2024. Vide impugned judgment and order dated 21st May 2024, the learned Single Judge of the High Court rejected the said bail application also.
11. Being aggrieved thereby, the appellant had approached this Court by filing Special Leave Petition (Criminal) Nos. 7795 and 7799 of 2024.
12. The matter was heard on 4 th June 2024. This Court, in the said order (hereinafter referred to as “the second order of this Court”) recorded the submissions of the learned Solicitor General that the investigation would be concluded and final complaint/charge-sheet would be filed expeditiously and at any rate on or before 3 rd July 2024 and immediately thereafter, the trial court would be free to proceed with the trial. This Court recorded the submissions made by the learned Solicitor General and observed that having regard to the fact that the period of “6-8 months” fixed by this Court by order dated 30 th October 2023 had not yet come to an end, disposed of the said [2024] 8 S.C.R. 1067Manish Sisodia v. Directorate of Enforcement petition with liberty to revive his prayer afresh after filing of the final complaint/charge-sheet.
13. Accordingly, after filing of the final complaint/charge-sheet, the appellant has approached this Court by way of the present appeals. This Court, vide order dated 16th July 2024 had issued notice. In response thereto, counter affidavit has been filed on behalf of the ED as well as the CBI opposing the present appeals.
SUBMISSIONS:
14. We have extensively heard Dr. Abhishek Manu Singhvi, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant and Shri Suryaprakash V. Raju, learned Additional Solicitor General (ASG) appearing on behalf of the respondents.
15. A preliminary objection has been raised on behalf of the learned ASG that the appellant cannot be permitted to file second set of SLPs to challenge the order of the High Court dated 21 st May 2024 when the earlier SLPs arising out of the same order were disposed of. He submitted that the liberty granted by this Court vide order dated 4th June 2024 has to be construed as a liberty to apply to the trial court afresh. It is submitted that, only after the appellant approaches the trial court and in the event he does not succeed before the trial court, thereafter he approaches the High Court and in the event he also does not succeed before the High Court, then only he would be entitled to approach this Court. He therefore submitted that the present appeals deserve to be rejected thereby relegating the appellant to approach the trial court afresh. To buttress his submission, Shri Raju relied on the judgment of this Court in the case of Kunhayammed and Others v. State of Kerala and Others. 1
16. The said preliminary objection has been opposed by Dr. Singhvi, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant contending that this Court had specifically, vide its first order dated 30 th October 2023, granted liberty to the appellant to move a fresh application for bail in case the trial does not conclude within next 6-8 months and also in case the trial is protracted and proceeds at 1 [2000] Supp. 1 SCR 538 : (2000) 6 SCC 359 : 2000 INSC 339 1068 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports a snail’s pace in next three months. He submitted that, admittedly, the trial has not been concluded within a period of 6-8 months from the date of the first order of this Court. He further submitted that the record would show that the trial was protracted and proceeded at a snail’s pace in the period of three months after the first order of this Court was passed. He submitted that the second order of this Court clearly reserves the right of the appellant to revive the request afresh after filing of the final complaint/charge-sheet as assured by the learned Solicitor General. Dr. Singhvi therefore prays for rejection of the preliminary objection.
17. On merits, Dr. Singhvi submitted that this Court, vide its first order dated 30 th October 2023, has given various findings in favour of the appellant. It is submitted that, a perusal of the same would clearly reveal that at number of places, this Court has given findings which would show that the respondents have not been in a position to make out a prima facie case. Dr. Singhvi further submitted that a perusal of the record would reveal that even the investigation in the case is not complete. He therefore submitted that unless the investigation is complete, the trial cannot proceed. He submitted that three more supplementary complaints have been filed on 10 th May 2024, 17th May 2024 and 20th June 2024 in the ED matter and as on 27 th July 2024, there were 40 persons who have been arrayed as accused in the proceedings with more than 8 complaints. He further submitted that, in the ED matter, the ED has cited 224 witnesses and produced 32,000 pages of documents. He further submitted that, in the CBI matter, the CBI has cited 269 witnesses and produced around 37,000 pages of documents. It is therefore submitted that in all there are 493 witnesses, excluding the ones in the 4 th Supplementary Charge-sheet filed by the CBI, who will have to be examined and that in total the documents are running into around 69,000 pages.
18. Dr. Singhvi submitted that the ED has deliberately concealed the documents it acquired during investigation by putting documents exculpating the accused persons in the category of “un-relied upon documents”. It is submitted that, as such, it was necessary for the appellant to inspect such “un-relied upon documents”. He further submitted that there was an inordinate delay on the part of the ED and the CBI in producing the list of “un-relied upon documents”. [2024] 8 S.C.R. 1069Manish Sisodia v. Directorate of Enforcement
19. Dr. Singhvi submitted that, taking into consideration the voluminous number of witnesses and documents, there is no possibility of the trial seeing the light of the day and therefore the appeals filed by the appellant deserve to be allowed.
20. Shri Raju vehemently opposed the present appeals. He submitted that this Court, in its first order, after enumerating various factors on merits of the matter in paragraph 25 has held that the Court was not inclined to accept the prayer for grant of bail. It is therefore submitted that the appeals of the present appellant on merits were specifically rejected.
21. Shri Raju further submitted that, though the Court granted liberty to file a fresh application in the circumstances enumerated in paragraph 29, it was held that the same would be considered by the trial court on merits without being influenced by the dismissal of the earlier bail applications including the said first order. It is therefore submitted that the trial court as well as the High Court were required to take into consideration the merits of the matter. However, the present appellant opposed the consideration of the application on merits and insisted on consideration of the application only on the ground of delay in trial. It is therefore submitted that both the courts have rightly considered the merits of the matter and after considering the merits, found that the appellant was not entitled to grant of bail. He submitted that no interference would be warranted.
22. Shri Raju submitted that the trial court and the High Court have specifically come to a finding that the appellant has delayed the pre-charge proceedings by taking recourse to the provisions of Section 207 of Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 (for short, ‘Cr.P.C.’). He submitted that more than hundred applications have been filed out of which many are under Section 207 Cr.P.C. These applications have been filed only for the purpose of delaying the trial. It is submitted that though in view of the law laid down by this Court in the case of P. Ponnusamy v. State of Tamil Nadu,2 such applications could have been filed only after framing of the charges, the same have been intentionally filed at a pre-charge stage of the trial, so as to delay the framing of the charges. He submitted that though the appellant 2 [2022] 15 SCR 265 : 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1543 : 2022 INSC 1175 1070 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports is entitled to file an application for discharge, the same has not been filed only in order to protract the trial. He submitted that the totality of the circumstances would reveal that it is the appellant who has been protracting the trial. It is submitted that as the appellant himself is responsible for protracting the trial, he cannot be permitted to take the benefit of the same.
23. The learned ASG submitted that unless the triple conditions as stipulated under Section 45 of the PMLA are satisfied, no person accused of an offence shall be released on bail. It is submitted that, in the present case, this Court itself by the first order has found that the appellant was not entitled for bail on merits and as such, the second condition stipulated under Section 45 of the PMLA that there are reasonable grounds for believing that he is not guilty of such offence, would not be satisfied in the present case.
24. The learned ASG further submitted that the appellant is a very influential person having occupied the office of Deputy Chief Minister of Delhi when the crime was committed. He submitted that if the appellant is released on bail, there is every possibility of him influencing the witnesses or tampering with the evidence.
25. Dr. Singhvi, in rejoinder, has submitted that the contention that the trial is being delayed due to the applications being filed by the appellant under Section 207 Cr.P.C. is totally incorrect. He submitted that the said applications were required to be filed since the prosecution had not placed on record the documents exculpating the accused persons by placing the same in the category of “un-relied upon documents”. He submitted that in order to avail the right of a fair trial and in adherence to the principles of natural justice as encapsulated in Section 207 Cr.P.C., the appellant was forced to file such applications. However, each of these applications were vehemently opposed by the prosecution. It is submitted that the said material ought to have been placed on record by the prosecution themselves, however, for the reasons best known to the prosecution, they have not done so. He submitted that the appellant has filed only 14 applications in ED case and 13 applications in CBI case and that all these applications have been allowed by the learned trial judge. He lastly submitted that even as per the prosecution, if the entire “un-relied upon documents” are to be supplied in digital form, it will take a long time. To support his submission, Dr. Singhvi places reliance on the compliance report [2024] 8 S.C.R. 1071Manish Sisodia v. Directorate of Enforcement dated 7th May 2024 filed by the Assistant Director of ED which would fortify this position.
CONSIDERATION OF PRELIMINARY OBJECTION:
26. We will first deal with the preliminary objection of the learned ASG with regard to the filing of the second set of appeals before this Court challenging the order of the High Court dated 21st May 2024 i.e., on the point of maintainability.
27. Undisputedly, the appellant had earlier challenged the same order dated 21 st May 2024 vide SLP (Criminal) Nos. 7795 and 7799 of 2024. On doing so, a Division Bench of this Court passed the order dated 4 th June 2024. It will be apposite to refer to the observations made by this Court in the said order, which read thus:
“Though, elaborate arguments have been made, we do not propose to go into the said arguments or dwell upon it and then record our reasons for the simple reason that Co-ordinate Bench while dismissing the appeals vide order dated 30.10.2023, as noticed hereinabove has granted liberty to the appellant, i.e., the petitioner herein to move a fresh application for bail by placing reliance on the assurance given on behalf of the prosecution that they would conclude the trial by taking appropriate steps within next 6-8 months and as such the liberty was extended to the petitioner herein to move a fresh application in case of change in circumstances, or in case the trial is protracted and proceeds at a snail’s pace in next three months. It was also observed that if such an application is filed in the aforesaid circumstances, the same would be considered by the trial court on merits without being influenced by the dismissal of the earlier bail application including the judgment of this Court.
Shri Tushar Mehta, learned Solicitor General on instructions would submit that the investigation would be concluded and final complaint/charge sheet would be filed expeditiously and at any rate on or before 03.07.2024 and immediately thereafter, the trial court will be free to proceed with trial. In the light of the said submissions made and having regard to the fact that the period of “6-8 months” fixed by 1072 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports this Court by Order dated 30.10.2023 having not come to an end, it would suffice to dispose of these petitions with liberty to the petitioner to revive his prayer afresh after filing of the final complaint/Charge-sheet as assured by learned Solicitor General. Needless to state that in the event of such an application being filed, the same would be considered on its own merits as already observed by this Court vide paragraph 29 (supra). Contentions of both parties kept open.
Accordingly, these petitions stand disposed of. All pending applications consigned to record.”
28. Before considering the submissions of the learned ASG with regard to maintainability of the present appeals on account of the second order of this Court, it will be apposite to refer to certain observations made by this Court in its first order, which read thus:
“26. However, we are also concerned about the prolonged period of incarceration suffered by the appellant – Manish Sisodia. In P. Chidambaram v. Directorate of Enforcement (2020) 13 SCC 791, the appellant therein was granted bail after being kept in custody for around 49 days [P. Chidambaram v. Central Bureau of Investigation (2020) 13 SCC 337], relying on the Constitution Bench in Shri Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia and Others v. State of Punjab (1980) 2 SCC 565, and Sanjay Chandra v. Central Bureau of Investigation (2012) 1 SCC 40, that even if the allegation is one of grave economic offence, it is not a rule that bail should be denied in every case. Ultimately, the consideration has to be made on a case to case basis, on the facts.
The primary object is to secure the presence of the accused to stand trial. The argument that the appellant therein was a flight risk or that there was a possibility of tampering with the evidence or influencing the witnesses, was rejected by the Court. Again, in Satender Kumar Antil v. Central Bureau of Investigation and Another (2022) 10 SCC 51, this Court referred to Surinder Singh Alias Shingara Singh v. State of Punjab (2005) 7 SCC 387 and Kashmira Singh v. State of Punjab [2024] 8 S.C.R. 1073Manish Sisodia v. Directorate of Enforcement (1977) 4 SCC 291, to emphasise that the right to speedy trial is a fundamental right within the broad scope of Article 21 of the Constitution. In Vijay Madanlal Choudhary (supra), this Court while highlighting the evil of economic offences like money laundering, and its adverse impact on the society and citizens, observed that arrest infringes the fundamental right to life. This Court referred to Section 19 of the PML Act, for the in-built safeguards to be adhered to by the authorised officers to ensure fairness, objectivity and accountability. [See also Pankaj Bansal v. Union of India and Ors. 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1244] Vijay Madanlal Choudhary (supra), also held that Section 436A of the Code can apply to offences under the PML Act, as it effectuates the right to speedy trial, a facet of the right to life, except for a valid ground such as where the trial is delayed at the instance of the accused himself. In our opinion, Section 436A should not be construed as a mandate that an accused should not be granted bail under the PML Act till he has suffered incarceration for the specified period. This Court, in Arnab Manoranjan Goswami v. State of Maharashtra and Others (2021) 2 SCC 427, held that while ensuring proper enforcement of criminal law on one hand, the court must be conscious that liberty across human eras is as tenacious as tenacious can be.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.