G.M. Shahul Hameed v. Jayanthi R. Hegde
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 493; [2024] 7 S.C.R. 316
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Dipankar Datta, Justice Pankaj Mithal
- Decided
- 9 Jul 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 1188/2015
- Sections
- 151, 35, 58, 33, 34, 114, 41, 42, 36
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 316 : 2024 INSC 493 G.M. Shahul Hameed v.
Jayanthi R. Hegde (Civil Appeal No. 1188 of 2015)
09 July 2024 [Dipankar Datta* and Pankaj Mithal, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether upon admission of an instrument in evidence and its marking as an exhibit by a court (despite the instrument being chargeable to duty but is insufficiently stamped), such a process can be recalled by the court in exercise of inherent powers saved by Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 for the ends of justice or to prevent abuse of the process of the court. Headnotes† Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – s.151 – Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957 – ss.33-35, 58 – GPA insufficiently stamped, admitted in evidence and marked as exhibit – No objection from the appellant – Trial Court if can recall such process of admission and marking of the instrument in exercise of its inherent power saved by s.151 or the remedy available under the 1957 Act was required to be pursued by the appellant to fasten the respondent with the liability to pay the deficit duty and penalty: Held: The presiding officer of a court being authorised in law to receive an instrument in evidence, is bound to give effect to the mandate of ss.33 and 34 and retains the authority to impound an instrument even in the absence of any objection from any party to the proceedings – Irrespective of whether objection is raised or not regarding admissibility of an instrument, owing to its insufficient stamping, the question of admissibility has to be decided according to law – The presiding officer of a court when confronted with the question of admitting an instrument chargeable with duty but which is either not stamped or is insufficiently stamped ought to judicially determine it – Application of judicial mind is a sine qua non having regard to the express language of ss.33 and 34 – However, once a decision on the objection is rendered- right or wrong, s.35 would kick in to bar any question * Author [2024] 7 S.C.R. 317G.M. Shahul Hameed v. Jayanthi R. Hegde being raised as to admissibility of the instrument on the ground that it is not duly stamped at any stage of the proceedings and the party aggrieved by alleged improper admission has to work out its remedy as provided by s.58 of the 1957 Act – On the date the GPA was admitted in evidence and marked as an exhibit, the Trial Court did not deliberate on its admissibility, much less applied its judicial mind, resulting in an absence of judicial determination – Trial Court not having ‘decided’ whether the GPA was sufficiently stamped, s.35 of the 1957 Act cannot be called in aid by the respondent – For s.35 to come into operation, the instrument must have been “admitted in evidence” upon a judicial determination – The words “judicial determination” have to be read into s.35 – Once there is such a determination, whether the determination is right or wrong cannot be examined except in the manner ordained by s.35 – However, in a case of “no judicial determination”, s.35 is not attracted – No error in the order dated 19.10.2010 passed by the Trial Court in exercise of its inherent power saved by s.151, CPC to do justice as well as to prevent abuse of the process of court and allowing the interlocutory applications filed by the appellant and directing the respondent to pay the deficit stamp duty with penalty – Impugned order of the High Court set aside. [Paras 14, 18, 4, 22] Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957 – s.35 – When not attracted – Discussed.
Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957 – s.33 – Examination and impounding of instruments – Duty of the court:
Held: s.33 has been inserted in the statute with a definite purpose – The revenue would stand the risk of suffering huge loss if the courts fail to discharge the duty placed on it per provisions like s.33 – The legislature has reposed responsibility on the courts and trusted them to ensure that requisite stamp duty, along with penalty, is duly paid if an unstamped or insufficiently stamped instrument is placed before it for admission in support of the case of a party – It is incumbent upon the courts to uphold the sanctity of the legal framework governing stamp duty, as the same are crucial for the authenticity and enforceability of instruments – Allowing an instrument with insufficient stamp duty to pass unchallenged, merely due to technicalities, would undermine the legislative intent and the fiscal interests of the State – The courts ought to ensure that compliance with all substantive and procedural requirements 318 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports of a statute akin to the 1957 Act are adhered to by the interested parties – This duty of the court is paramount, and any deviation would set a detrimental precedent, eroding the integrity of the legal system. [Para 21] Case Law Cited Javer Chand and Others v. Pukhraj Surana [1962] 2 SCR 333; Ram Rattan v. Bajrang Lal [1978] 3 SCR 963 : (1978) 3 SCC 236 – referred to.
List of Acts Code of Civil Procedure, 1908; Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957; Indian Stamp Act, 1899; Constitution of India.
List of Keywords Inherent powers; Inherent powers saved by Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908; Stamp duty; Instrument chargeable with duty; Instrument not stamped/insufficiently stamped; Admission of instrument in evidence; Objection to the instrument’s insufficient stamping; Objection regarding admissibility of instrument owing to its insufficient stamping; Question of admitting instrument chargeable with duty but not stamped/insufficiently stamped; General Power of Attorney; GPA; GPA insufficiently stamped; GPA admitted in evidence and marked as exhibit; Instrument marked as exhibit; Recall of process of admission of instrument in evidence and marking of the instrument; Impounding of instruments; Liability to pay the deficit duty and penalty; Application of judicial mind; Judicial determination; Prevent abuse of the process of the court. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 1188 of 2015 From the Judgment and Order dated 26.09.2011 of the High Court of Karnataka at Bangalore in WP No. 11653 of 2011 Appearances for Parties D.P. Chaturvedi, Tarun Kumar Thakur, Ms. Parvati Bhat, Vivek Ram, Abhay Choudhary M, Ms. Anuradha Mutatkar, Advs. for the Appellant. Mrs. Rekha Pandey, Suyash Mohan Guru, Ms. Sharmistha Choudhury, Raghav Pandey, Ms. Gauri Pandey, Advs. for the Respondent. [2024] 7 S.C.R. 319G.M. Shahul Hameed v. Jayanthi R. Hegde Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Dipankar Datta, J.
1. The substantial question arising for decision in this civil appeal is whether upon admission of an instrument in evidence and its marking as an exhibit by a court (despite the instrument being chargeable to duty but is insufficiently stamped), such a process can be recalled by the court in exercise of inherent powers saved by section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure 1 for the ends of justice or to prevent abuse of the process of the court.
2. Assail in this civil appeal is to the judgment and order dated 26 th September, 2011 2 passed by a learned Single Judge of the High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru 3 whereby His Lordship set aside the order dated 19th October, 2010 passed by the Court of Additional Senior Judge-III, Mangalore 4 and allowed the petition 5 preferred by the respondent under Article 227 of the Constitution.
3. The facts, relevant for the disposal of the present appeal, are adverted to in brief hereunder:
a. First Sale Agreement and Sale Deed: On 3rd October, 2003, a Sale Deed was executed regarding the suit property by one B. Ramesh Hegde in favour of his wife, who is the respondent here. This Sale Deed was executed on the strength of a General Power of Attorney 6 dated 16 th September, 2003, which was allegedly executed by one Praveen Shetty in favour of B. Ramesh Hegde in respect of the suit property, authorizing him with power to sell the suit property.
b. Second Sale Agreement and Sale Deed: An agreement to sell the suit property was executed between the appellant and Praveen Shetty on 11th September, 2003. The appellant paid the 1 CPC, hereafter 2 impugned order, hereafter 3 High Court, hereafter 4 Trial Court, hereafter 5 Writ Petition No. 11653 of 2011 (GM-CPC)
6 GPA, hereafter 320 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports consideration, and a Sale Deed was executed on 8th October, 2003 between the appellant and Praveen Shetty.
c. Civil Suit by the appellant: The appellant instituted a civil suit 7 against the respondent, B. Ramesh Hegde, and Praveen Shetty, seeking a declaration that the Sale Deed dated 3rd October, 2003 was null and void, and not binding on the appellant. d. Civil Suit by the respondent: Conversely, the respondent also instituted a civil suit 8 against the appellant and Praveen Shetty, seeking a declaration that the Sale Deed dated 8 th October, 2003 was null and void, and not binding on the respondent. e. Filing of GPA before the Trial Court: In the suit instituted by the respondent, witness action commenced. B. Ramesh Hegde, in whose favour the GPA was executed by the respondent, on 6th June, 2010 tendered the GPA in course of his examinationin-chief. The appellant’s counsel was engaged in another court; hence, he was unable to appear. The junior counsel did not object that the GPA was insufficiently stamped and, thus, inadmissible in evidence. The Trial Court, in the absence of objection, admitted the GPA in evidence and marked it as an exhibit whereafter the matter stood adjourned for cross-examination.
f. Interlocutory Applications: On the next hearing date, 25 th June, 2010 to be precise, the appellant filed two interlocutory applications 9 in the suit filed by the respondent. In I.A. No. IX, the appellant sought a review of the order dated 6th June, 2010, and in I.A. No. X, it was prayed that the GPA be impounded on the ground that it has been insufficiently stamped. The appellant contended that since the GPA was executed in favour of a third party with power to sell the property, article 41 of the Schedule to the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957 10 was applicable, necessitating payment of requisite stamp duty based on the market value of the property. The GPA was prepared only on a stamp paper worth Rs.100, rendering it insufficiently stamped and in accordance with section 34 of the 1957 Act, 7 O.S. No. 301 of 2003 8 O.S. No. 134 of 2005 9 I.A.s, hereafter 10 1957 Act, hereafter [2024] 7 S.C.R. 321G.M. Shahul Hameed v. Jayanthi R. Hegde an insufficiently stamped document had to be impounded and a penalty of ten times the duty value paid.
g. The respondent objected to the I.A.s asserting that the appellant had to avail his remedy under section 58 of the 1957 Act and that being available, the appellant could not seek a review. Further, it was claimed that no proof had been furnished that the appellant’s counsel was otherwise engaged at that time. Lastly, it was contended that once a document had been admitted in evidence, the stamp duty could not subsequently be questioned on the ground that it has been insufficiently stamped, as per section 35 of the 1957 Act.
4. Vide order dated 19 th October, 2010, the Trial Court allowed the I.A.s and directed the respondent to pay the deficit stamp duty, along with the penalty, as required for a power of attorney under article 41(eb) of the Schedule to the 1957 Act.
5. Dissatisfied with the aforesaid order of the Trial Court, the respondent approached the High Court whereupon the petition was allowed by the impugned order, inter alia, recording that:
“2. It is evident from the material that the document has been marked and admitted in evidence and exhibited. It is the contention of the respondent under order 13 rule 4 there should be a specific statement to the effect that the document has been so admitted and endorsement shall be signed and initialed by the Judge. In the absence of the said requirement, marking of document does not mean admission of document in evidence. The argument of the counsel for the respondent is untenable. In the normal procedure when the document is produced, it is marked and exhibit number has assigned and beneath the said exhibit Judge puts his initial. This procedure fully complies with the requirement under Order 13 Rule 4 of the Act. Therefore, the contention that the document has not been properly marked and it should be rejected in evidence on the ground of insufficiently stamped is untenable. The trial court will have no jurisdiction to reconsider the issue. The remedy available for the respondent is only under section 58 of the Stamp Act. Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed.”
322 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
6. It is the legality of the impugned order that we are tasked to examine while answering the question formulated at the beginning of this judgment.
7. Mr. Chaturvedi, learned counsel for the appellant, while laying a challenge to the impugned order argued that admission of an insufficiently stamped instrument in a casual manner by mechanically marking it as an exhibit, without any application of judicial mind, should not preclude the court seized of the proceedings from reconsidering whether such document is sufficiently stamped and could have at all been admitted in evidence. Various provisions of the 1957 Act were referred to by him for persuading us to hold that the view taken by the High Court was grossly erroneous. Accordingly, it was prayed by him that the impugned order be set aside and the civil appeal be allowed with liberty to the respondent to take steps in accordance with the order of the Trial Court.
8. Mr. Guru, learned counsel for the respondent, defended the impugned order by asserting that it is correct both in law as well as on facts. It was argued that setting aside of the Trial Court’s order by the impugned order was indeed justified since the GPA having been admitted in evidence, such admission could not have been reviewed by the same court under any circumstance. Emphasis was placed on the need for an objection to the document’s admissibility being raised when it was first tendered for being admitted and then marked as an exhibit. Citing section 35 of the 1957 Act, it was contended that once an instrument is admitted in evidence, the admission cannot be questioned by the trial court or any appellate or revisional court; and that the only remedy that the 1957 Act provides is a revision under section 58 thereof in the manner as provided. Thus, he submitted that the civil appeal being devoid of any merit deserved outright dismissal.
9. A short but interesting question has engaged our consideration. There is no doubt that the GPA is insufficiently stamped. What we need to consider on facts and in the circumstances is, which of the two conflicting views taken by the Trial Court and the High Court is right.
10. Despite the GPA having been admitted in evidence and marked as an exhibit without objection from the side of the appellant, we propose to hold for the reasons to follow that the Trial Court did have the authority to revisit and recall the process of admission and marking of the instrument, not in the sense of exercising a power of review [2024] 7 S.C.R. 323G.M. Shahul Hameed v. Jayanthi R. Hegde under section 114 read with Order XLVII, CPC but in exercise of its inherent power saved by section 151 thereof, and that the other remedy made available by the 1957 Act was not required to be pursued by the appellant to fasten the respondent with the liability to pay the deficit duty and penalty.
11. We may refer to the statutory framework of the 1957 Act. Sections 33, 34, 35 and 58, to the extent relevant for a decision on this appeal, read as follows:
“33. Examination and impounding of instruments.-
(1) Every person having by law or consent of parties authority to receive evidence, and every person in charge of a public office, except an officer of police, before whom any instrument, chargeable in his opinion, with duty, is produced or comes in the performance of his functions, shall, if it appears to him that such instrument is not duly stamped, impound the same.
(2) For that purpose every such person shall examine every instrument so chargeable and so produced or coming before him, in order to ascertain whether it is stamped with a stamp of the value and description required by the law in force in the State of Karnataka when such instrument was executed or first executed:
Provided that,—
(a) ***
(b) ***
(3) For the purposes of this section, in cases of doubt, the Government may determine,—
(a) what offices shall be deemed to be public offices; and
(b) who shall be deemed to be persons in charge of public offices.
34. Instruments not duly stamped inadmissible in evidence, etc.- No instrument chargeable with duty shall be admitted in evidence for any purpose by any person having by law or consent of parties authority to receive evidence, or shall be acted upon, registered or 324 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports authenticated by any such person or by any public officer, unless such instrument is duly stamped:
Provided that,—
(a) ***
(b) ***
(c) ***
(d) ***
35. Admission of instrument where not to be questioned. – Where an instrument has been admitted in evidence such admission shall not, except as provided in section 58, be called in question at any stage of the same suit or proceeding on the ground that the instrument has not been duly stamped.
58. Revision of certain decisions of Courts regarding the sufficiency of stamps. –
(1) When any Court in the exercise of its Civil or Revenue jurisdiction or any Criminal Court in any proceeding under Chapter XII or Chapter XXXVI of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898, makes any order admitting any instrument in evidence as duly stamped or as not requiring a stamp, or upon payment of duty and a penalty under Section 34, the Court to which appeals lie from, or references are made by, such first mentioned Court may, of its own motion or on the application of the Deputy Commissioner, take such order into consideration.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.