Kaushik Premkumar Mishra & Anr. v. Kanji Ravaria @ Kanji & Anr.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 540; [2024] 7 S.C.R. 2295
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah
- Decided
- 19 Jul 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 1573/2023
- Sections
- 11, 85, 25, 114, 54, 17, 60, 32, 41, 32A
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 2295 : 2024 INSC 540 Kaushik Premkumar Mishra & Anr.
v.
Kanji Ravaria @ Kanji & Anr.
(Civil Appeal No. 1573 of 2023)
19 July 2024 [Vikram Nath* and Ahsanuddin Amanullah, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the sale deed dated 02.12.1985 was executed by Respondent No. 2; whether the sale consideration was paid with respect to sale deed dated 02.12.1985; whether the sale deed dated 02.12.1985 was presented for registration on 05.12.1985 or not; whether delayed registration of the sale deed dated 02.12.1985 would prove to be fatal; whether non-mutation would take away the right created by the sale deed in favor of the vendees; whether respondent no.2 had any right, title or interest left in the suit property after 02.12.1985; whether the sale deed dated 02.12.1985 was void as the vendees were alleged to be minors; whether the respondent no. 1 was a bona fide purchaser for value by way of a subsequent sale deed dated 03.12.2010.
Headnotes† Contract Act, 1872 – s.11 – Registration Act, 1908 – s.85 – A Land measuring 3.40 Hectares was sold by respondent no.2 to appellants and collaterals of the appellants – Half of the total land (suit land) was purchased by appellants and other half by the collaterals of appellants – Respondent no.2 herein executed a Sale Deed (suit land) in favour of appellant no.1 and his minor brother (since deceased) on 02.12.1985 with respect to suit land and another sale deed was also executed with the collateral of the appellants – The sale deed (suit land) in favour of the appellant no.1 and his minor brother could not be registered and remained pending for registration before the Sub-Registrar on account of deficiency in stamp duty – On 03.12.2010 respondent no.2 executed a Conveyance Deed with respect to the suit land in favour of respondent no.1 – It is the same land which was transferred in favour of the appellant no.1 and his brother in December, 1985 – The appellants then followed up registration of their sale deed, * Author 2296 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports which was registered on 14.06.2011 – Appellant filed suit for cancellation of sale deed 03.12.2010 and the same was dismissed by the Trial Court – First Appellate Court allowed the appeal filed by the appellants – However, the High Court set aside the decision of the First Appellate Court and upheld the decision of the Trial Court – Correctness:
Held: The Trial Court and the High Court had proceeded on the premise that the defendant No.1-the vendor (respondent no.2 herein) had denied the execution of the sale deed and had also denied that he had not received any consideration – This premise taken by both the Courts i.e. Trial Court and the High Court are contrary to the pleadings on record and the evidence led during the Trial – There is clear misreading of the evidence – In his written statement, defendant no.1 has not specifically denied anywhere that he had not executed the sale deed or that the signatures on the sale deed were not his signatures – Thus, the very premise on the basis of which the Trial Court and the High Court proceeded are perverse being contrary to the material on record – Both the said courts also failed to take into consideration that defendant no.1 the vendor (respondent no.2 herein) neither entered the witness box in support of his pleadings and to prove them, nor did lead any evidence, either oral or documentary, in support of his pleadings – There was no justification to treat a vague statement in the written statement of not recollecting about execution of sale deed, to be taken as a denial of the execution – The Trial Court and the High Court fell into the trap of clever drafting and a vague statement of defendant no.1 – The Trial Court and the High Court also committed a manifest error in recording that the defendant no.1- vendor (respondent no.2 herein) had denied having received any sale consideration with respect to the sale deed dated 02.12.1985 – In the written statement filed by the defendant no.1, there is no such statement made – Based upon the aforesaid two factual errors, the Trial Court and the High Court wrongly shifted the burden on the plaintiff to prove execution of the sale deed and also payment of the sale consideration – The impugned judgment thus suffers from manifest error of law and facts both – It is not disputed by respondent No.2 that on 02.12.1985, he had executed another sale deed with respect to the remaining portion of the land in favour of the collaterals of the appellants – This sale deed in favour of the collateral was presented for registration on the same date as the sale deed of the appellant i.e. 05.12.1985 and was thereafter duly registered – The respondent No.2 has never challenged the [2024] 7 S.C.R. 2297Kaushik Premkumar Mishra & Anr. v. Kanji Ravaria @ Kanji & Anr. said sale deed in favour of the collaterals – It is thus apparent that the family members and collaterals of the appellants purchased the entire land measuring 3.40 Hectares from respondent No.2 in equal shares by two separate documents which were executed on the same date and presented for registration on the same day – There is no specific denial in the written statement filed by respondent No.2 about the sale deed in favour of collaterals – General denial has been made by placing strict proof of liability on the plaintiff – The respondent No.2 apparently wants to take advantage of certain minor aberrations and minor technicalities and is also taking up self-conflicting pleas – As far as the question of payment of sale consideration is concerned, assuming that no sale consideration was paid even though there was a registered sale deed, it would be at the instance of the vendor to challenge the said sale deed on the ground of no sale consideration being paid – In the present, case, there is no such challenge to the sale deed for being declared as void or being cancelled on such ground – Regarding delay of 26 years in registering the document, Non-registration of a document duly presented for registration could be for many reasons – But once it is registered, there is a presumption of correctness attached to it, that is to say that the document has been duly executed and registered in accordance to law – It was for the defendants (respondents) to come forward and to establish that the document was wrongly registered – They did not lead any evidence in this respect – Instead, they tried to put burden on the plaintiff-appellant by requiring him to call the Sub-Registrar as a witness, which the appellant rightly denied – It was always open for the respondents to have called for the records of the Sub-Registrar’s office and also the Sub-Registrar in order to find out any mandatory lacuna or illegality or lack of procedure not being followed with respect to the registration – They did nothing of this sort – In fact, respondent No.2 did not make any bone of contention with regard to the registration process and the registration of the documents after 26 years by challenging the same before the same authority or any superior authority or any Court of law – Registration of a document carries with it presumption of correctness until and unless the same was challenged by way of independent proceeding or a counter claim – In the absence of any such claim, the sale deed in favour of the appellants has to be treated as a valid document – The High Court recorded the findings that the fact that the purchasers were minors would not per se affect the validity of the sale deed for the reason that 2298 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports the second purchaser who was mentioned as a minor in the sale deed was represented through his natural guardian and mother – The respondent no.2 appears to be a dishonest person, which is apparent from his conduct not only during the trial but also acting in collusion with respondent no.1 to execute the sale deed for the same land which he had already transferred – Thus, the impugned judgement of the High Court is set aside and that of the first Appellate Court decreeing suit of the appellant is restored and maintained. [Paras 29, 30, 33.1,33.2, 33.6, 33.8, 33.9, 33.12, 33.13] Contract Act, 1872 – s.11 – Registration Act, 1908 – s.85 – Whether the sale deed dated 02.12.1985 was executed by Respondent No. 2:
Held: It is not disputed by respondent No.2 that on 02.12.1985, he had executed another sale deed with respect to the remaining portion of survey No.13/1 in favour of the collaterals of the appellants – This sale deed in favour of the collateral was presented for registration on the same date as the sale deed of the appellant i.e. 05.12.1985 and was thereafter duly registered – The respondent No.2 has never challenged the said sale deed in favour of the collaterals – It is thus apparent that the family members and collaterals of the appellants purchased the entire survey No. 13/1 measuring 3.40 Hectares from respondent No.2 in equal shares by two separate documents which were executed on the same date and presented for registration on the same day – There is no specific denial in the written statement filed by respondent No.2 about the sale deed in favour of collaterals – General denial has been made by placing strict proof of liability on the plaintiff. [Para 33.1] Registration Act, 1908 – Transfer of Property Act, 1882 – Registration of documents/sale deed – Payment of stamp duty – Deficiency of stamp duty – Deficiency of stamp duty cannot enure any benefit to the vendor:
Held: The issue of registration of a document is with the State, which requires compulsory registration of documents so that it is not deprived of revenue by way of stamp duty payable on such transfers of immovable property – If the purchaser has no means to pay stamp duty or exorbitant demand of stamp duty is made by the registering authority which the purchaser is unable to pay at that time but he remains satisfied with the fact that the vendor has fairly and duly executed the sale deed presented it for registration and put him in possession of the purchased property which he is [2024] 7 S.C.R. 2299Kaushik Premkumar Mishra & Anr. v. Kanji Ravaria @ Kanji & Anr. peacefully enjoying, he is always at liberty to pay the deficiency of stamp duty at any point of time – The document presented for registration will remain with the Registering Authority till such time, the deficiency is removed – However, this pendency of registration on account of deficiency cannot enure any benefit to the vendor, who has already eliminated all his rights by executing the sale deed after receiving the sale consideration – He cannot become the owner of the transferred land merely because the document of sale is pending for registration – It is the purchaser who cannot produce such document which is pending registration with respect to the immovable property in evidence before the Court of law as the same would be inadmissible in view of statutory provision contained in the TP Act as also the Act, 1908. [Para 33.13] Principles/Doctrines – Doctrine of bona fide purchaser – Applicability in case of subsequent purchaser:
Held: The doctrine of bona fide purchaser for value applies in situations where the seller appears to have some semblance of legitimate ownership rights – However, this principle does not protect a subsequent purchaser if the vendor had already transferred those rights through a prior sale deed – In a case where the vendor deceitfully executes a second sale deed 26 years after the initial transfer, without disclosing the earlier transaction and without any ongoing litigation regarding the property, the subsequent purchaser cannot claim the benefits of a bona fide purchaser – Essentially, if the vendor’s rights were already severed by the first sale, any later sale deed made without transparency and in bad faith is invalid – The subsequent purchaser, even if unaware of the prior sale, cannot be considered bona fide because the vendor no longer had the legal right to sell the property – Thus, the protection afforded by the bona fide purchaser doctrine is nullified by the vendor’s deceitful conduct and the pre-existing transfer of rights – This ensures that the original purchaser’s rights are upheld and prevents unjust enrichment through fraudulent transactions. [Para 35] Case Law Cited Raghunath & Ors. v. Kedar Nath [1969] 3 SCR 497 : (1969) 1 SCC 497; Bondar Singh & Ors. v. Nihal Singh & Ors. [2003] 2 SCR 564 : (2003) 4 SCC 161; Suraj Lamps and Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Haryana and Anr. [2009] 9 SCR 1048 : (2009) 7 2300 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports SCC 363; S. Kaladevi v. V.R. Somasundaram & Ors. [2010] 4 SCR 515 : (2010) 5 SCC 401; M/s Paul Rubber Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. Amit Chand Mitra & Anr. [2023] 14 SCR 28; Veena Singh (dead) Thr. Lrs. v. District Registrar/Additional Collector [2022] 3 SCR 736 : (2022) 7 SCC 1; Maya Devi v. Lalta Prasad [2014] 2 SCR 1129 : (2015) 3 SCC 588 – distinguished.
Alka Bose v. Parmatma Devi and others [2008] 17 SCR 822 : (2009) 2 SCC 582; Anathula Sudhakar v. P. Buchi Reddy & Ors. [2008] 5 SCR 331 : (2008) 4 SCC 594; Raghwendra Sharan Singh v. Ram Prasanna Singh by LR [2019] 4 SCR 1069 :
(2020) 16 SCC 601; Mathai Mathai v. Joseph Mary & Ors. [2014] 5 SCR 621 : (2015) 5 SCC 622; Smriti Debbarma v. Prabha Ranjan Debbarma [2023] 1 SCR 355 : (2023) SCC On Line SC 9; Sukhwinder Singh v. Jagroop Singh and Anr. [2020] 1 SCR 512 : (2020) SCC Online SC 86; Seethakathi Trust Madras v. Krishnaveni [2022] 1 SCR 322 : (2022) 3 SCC 150; Hansa V. Gandhi v. Deep Shankar Roy (2013) 12 SCC 776; Hardev Singh v. Gurmail Singh [2007] 2 SCR 141 : (2007) 2 SCC 404; Krishnaveni v. M.A. Shagul Hameed and another (Civil Appeal No.2591 of 2024 @ SLP(Civil) No.23655 of 2019); Babasaheb Dhondiba Kure v. Radha Vithoba Barde (C.A. No.002458 of 2024); The Tehsildar, Urban Improvement Trust and Anr. v. Ganga Bai Menariya (dead) through Lrs. and others [2024] 2 SCR 650; Maya Devi v. Lalta Prasad [2014] 2 SCR 1129 : (2015) 3 SCC 588 – referred to.
Kunda wd/o Mahadeo Supare & Ors. v. Haribhau s/o Husan Supare (2014) 5 Mah. L.J.726 – referred to.
List of Acts Contract Act, 1872; Registration Act, 1908; Transfer of Property Act, 1882.
List of Keywords Section 11 of Contract Act, 1872; Section 85 of Registration Act, 1908; Execution of sale deed; Registration of sale deed; Payment of stamp duty; Deficiency of stamp duty; Deficiency of stamp duty cannot enure any benefit to the vendor; Doctrine of bona fide purchaser; Subsequent purchaser; Fraudulent transaction; Delay in registration of document; Pendency of registration of document; Payment of sale consideration.
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 2301Kaushik Premkumar Mishra & Anr. v. Kanji Ravaria @ Kanji & Anr. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 1573 of 2023 From the Judgment and Order dated 09.06.2022 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in SA No. 649 of 2019 Appearances for Parties Vinay Navare, Sr. Adv., Chinmay Deshpande, Sudhanshu Prakash, Anirudh Sanganeria, Advs. for the Appellants.
Huzefa Ahmadi, Ranjit Kumar, Sr. Advs., Mahesh Agarwal, Rishi Agrawala, Ankur Saigal, Devansh Srivastava, E. C. Agrawala, Tirathraj Pandya, Nirali Sarda, Kaushik Poddar, Advs. for the Respondents. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Vikram Nath, J.
1. “Law is the king of kings, nothing is mightier than law, by whose aid, even the weak may prevail over the strong.”
The power structures of our society are such that the weaker ones often find themselves exploited and oppressed by those who yield greater power. Land ownership is one such arena where we see the swords of powerplay being sharpened with continued fraud, deceit, and greed. While we shall deal with the facts of the present case in detail later, it is a classic example of continued suffering faced by the common man owing to mala fide intentions of the vendors who try to gain double-benefits, either by arm-twisting or through manipulation of the legal processes. Sometimes, the misery of the litigant is deepened when such travesty of justice is prolonged for decades. It is in cases like these, the law comes to the aid of the weak. While adjudicating such cases, it is not just the lives and the properties of the people that we are dealing with, but also their trust in the legal system. In cases like the one before us, it is not for us to just mechanically analyse the contentious transactions but to also ensure that injustice is remedied and nobody is benefitted by their own wrongs. Justice knows no bias and thus, through its aid, even the weak may prevail over the strong.
2302 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
2. This appeal by the plaintiff assails the correctness of the judgment and order dated 9th June, 2022 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Bombay, whereby the Second Appeal filed by the defendant no.2 (respondent no.1 herein) was allowed the judgment of the first Appellate Court was set aside and that of the Trial Court dismissing the suit of the appellant was maintained.
3. Respondent no.2 was the owner of Survey No.13 Hissa No.1 measuring 3.40 Hectares situate in village Shelwali, Tehsil Palghar, District Thane, Maharashtra. Half of the total area which would come to 1.70 Hectares on the western side is the suit land purchased by the appellants. Remaining half was purchased by collaterals of the appellants.
4. Relevant facts for appropriate adjudication of this appeal are as follows:
(a) Respondent no.2 herein executed a Sale Deed in favour of appellant no.1 and his minor brother Ambrish Mishra (since deceased) on 02.12.1985 with respect to suit land and the appellant no.1, along with his brother, was put into possession of the same.
(b) On the same date another Sale Deed was executed by the respondent no.2 in favour of one Param Umakant Mishra and Sohardha Jagdish Mishra (collaterals of the appellants) for the remaining half portion.
(c) On 05.12.1985 both the aforementioned Sale Deeds were presented for registration before the Sub-Registrar, Palghar.
(d) The Sale Deed in favour of Param Mishra and Sohardha Mishra was registered and later on their names were mutated in the revenue records. However, on account of deficiency in stamp duty, the Sale Deed in favour of the appellant no.1 and his minor brother could not be registered and remained pending for registration before the Sub-Registrar. As such their names could not be incorporated in the revenue records and the name of the respondent no.2 continued to be recorded.
(e) It would be relevant to mention that in the Sale Deed it was mentioned that the appellant no.1 is aged 18 years whereas [2024] 7 S.C.R. 2303Kaushik Premkumar Mishra & Anr. v. Kanji Ravaria @ Kanji & Anr. his brother Ambrish, was a minor and was represented through his natural guardian-mother (Smt. Malti).
(f) On 8 th October, 1999, brother of the appellant Ambrish passed away issueless and later on his widow re-married, as such, his parents became the successors and legal heirs of the estate of Ambrish.
(g) On 3rd December, 2010 respondent no.2 executed a Conveyance Deed with respect to the suit land in favour of respondent no.1. It is the same land which was transferred in favour of the appellant no.1 and his brother in December, 1985.
(h) On 8th June, 2011 the appellants came to know about inspection of the suit land by some strangers, so they went to the spot. They found that respondent no.1, along with some musclemen, was trying to take possession of the suit land but on account of suit land being protected by fencing, they could not enter. It was at that time the appellant no.1 came to know about a conveyance deed in favour of respondent no.1 on the basis of which he was trying to take possession.
(i) The appellants thereafter made inquiries in the office of the Sub-Registrar and came to know that there was a sale deed dated 3rd December, 2010 in favour of respondent no.1
(j) After obtaining a certified copy of the said Deed, which was received on 14th June 2011, the picture became clear to the appellant. The fraud played on them by respondent no.2 of transferring the same property (suit land) in favour of respondent no.1, which had been earlier transferred in their favour, became apparent.
(k) The appellants then followed up registration of their sale deed. After removing the deficiency in stamp duty, the sale deed executed on 02.12.1985 and presented for registration on 05.12.1985 before the Sub-Registrar came to be registered on 14th June, 2011. The above incident of interference in possession by the respondent no.1 gave rise to filing of the suit.
5. The appellants along with Premkumar, father of appellant no.1, instituted a suit for cancellation of sale deed dated 03.12.2010 and 2304 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports for perpetual injunction on 27 th June, 2011 which was registered as Special Civil Suit No.46 of 2011. The vendor was impleaded as defendant No.1 (respondent no.2 herein) and the subsequent purchaser as defendant No.2 (respondent no.1 herein). The facts as stated in paragraph 4 above are pleaded in the plaint as such are not being repeated.
6. Both the defendants filed separate written statements. The written statement filed by the defendant no.1 averred that the plaintiff was not entitled to any of the reliefs; the suit was barred by limitation; the land in suit was owned by him; that he did not recollect having executed any such sale deed in favour of the appellant no.1 and his brother; that the plaintiff purchasers were minors, as such, the sale deed in their favour was void; it was also denied that defendant no.2 had tried to trespass the property and take forcible possession with the help of musclemen.
7. Defendant no.2 in his written statement averred that the valuation of the suit was not proper; that no cause of action arose to file the suit; that the plaintiffs had supressed material facts and documents and, as such, the suit was liable to be dismissed; that the plaintiff no.1 and his brother Ambrish were minors and, as such incompetent to contract; that as per section 11 of the Indian Contract Act, 18721 the transaction with minor was void and as such unenforceable in law; that guardian of minor Ambrish was shown as his mother whereas actually it should have been his father and therefore also the sale deed was bad; that there was no signature of plaintiff no.2 in the sale deed; that the widow of brother Ambrish was not made a party, as such, the suit was bad for non-joinder of the necessary party; that the sale deed was not duly registered as per provisions of law; that before registration no notice was issued to the vendor i.e. defendant no.1; no explanation or details were given with regard to the delay of 26 years in getting the registration; that under section 85 of the Registration Act, 1908, 2 the documents pending for two years were liable to be destroyed, as such, the sale deed was not legal and proper; that there was interpolation in the documents of sale; that he was bona fide purchaser for value and had done so after verification 1 The Act, 1872 2 The Act, 1908 [2024] 7 S.C.R. 2305Kaushik Premkumar Mishra & Anr. v. Kanji Ravaria @ Kanji & Anr. of the title from the revenue records as also having searched the records of the Sub-Registrar; lastly, it was prayed that the suit be dismissed.
8. In the written statement of the respondent no.2 (defendant no.1) there was no specific denial of the execution of the Sale Deed on 02.12.1985 in favour of the appellant no.1 and his brother. There was also no specific or even general denial of not receiving the sale consideration. No suit for cancellation of the said Sale Deed has ever been filed nor any counter claim was filed by the defendants to the suit filed by the appellants assailing the sale deed dated 02.12.1985.
9. On the basis of the pleadings, the Trial Court framed the following issues:
"(i) Do plaintiffs prove that they are in possession and occupation of the suit land?
(ii) Do plaintiffs prove that they are owners of the suit land by virtue of registered Sale Deed dated 02/12/1985?
(iii) Do plaintiffs prove that the defendants were trying to take possession of the suit land forcibly and unauthorizedly?
(iv) Do plaintiffs prove that the Deed of Conveyance dated 03/12/2010 registered at serial No.9176 is void-ab-initio?
(v) Do plaintiffs prove that they are entitle for relief of permanent injunction against the defendants as prayed in the suit?
(vi) Do plaintiffs prove that they are entitled for any other relief?
(vii) Does defendant No.1 prove that the alleged Agreement to Sale dated 02/12/1985 is void-ab-initio?
(viii) Does defendant No.1 prove that the plaintiffs’ suit is barred by limitation?
(ix) Does defendant No.2 prove that the Sale Deed dated 02/12/1985 was not enforceable by law?
(x) Does defendant No.2 prove that he is bona fide purchaser and the possessor of suit land?
(xi) What order and decree?”
10. The parties to the suit led evidence, both oral and documentary. On behalf of the plaintiffs Kaushik Premkumar Mishra examined himself 2306 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports as PW-1 and further examined Shri Mohan Joshi, Advocate as PW-2 and Prashant Mishra as PW-3. They also filed documentary evidence which included amongst others (i) sale deed dated 02.12.1985,
(ii) certified copy of 7/12 extract of suit property, (iii) mutation entry no.668, (iv) Form No.1 of Register of Marriages for the year 2007 and (v) Conveyance deed dated 03.12.2010.
11. Defendant no.1 the vendor did not lead any evidence, either oral or documentary. He failed to appear and enter the witness box even to support his pleadings made in the written statements. There was also no cross-examination of PW-1 on his behalf.
12. Defendant no.2, the subsequent purchaser examined himself as DW-1, and further examined Ranjeet Patil as DW-2, Parvez Patel as DW-3, Sunit Patil as DW-4, Govind Rawaria as DW-5. He also filed voluminous documents relating to revenue records, mutation entries, search reports, copy of notices and various other documents relating to his possession.
13. The Trial Court, after considering the evidence led by the parties, dismissed the suit, vide judgment dated 24.02.2016. The Trial Court recorded the following findings:
13.1 Issues Nos.1,2,4,5 and 6 were decided in negative, whereas Issues nos. 7, 8, 9 and 10 in the affirmative, mainly for the reason that the appellant no.1 as also his brother were minors at the time of the execution of the Sale Deed on 02.12.1985, as such could not have entered into a contract being a minor and, therefore, the Sale Deed was void.
14. The appellants preferred appeal before the District Judge which was registered as Civil Appeal No.28 of 2016. The District Judge, vide judgment dated 7th March, 2019 allowed the appeal, set aside the judgment of the Trial Court and decreed the suit. The first Appellate Court framed the following points for determination in paragraph 14 of the judgment and in the said table, it also recorded the outcome of the said findings. The said table is reproduced below: “14. Heard the Ld. Advocates for both the parties. Perused the record and the proceedings. Following points arise for my determination on which I have recorded my findings for the reasons to follow:
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 2307Kaushik Premkumar Mishra & Anr. v. Kanji Ravaria @ Kanji & Anr. S.No. Points Findings
1. Whether plaintiffs prove that they are in possession and occupation of the suit property?
…In the affirmative.
2. Whether plaintiffs prove that they are owners of the suit land by virtue of registered sale deed dated 02.12.1985?
…In the affirmative.
3. Whether plaintiffs prove that the defendants were trying to take forcible possession of suit property unauthorizedly?
…In the affirmative.
4. Whether plaintiffs prove that the deed of conveyance dated 03.12.2010 registered at sr. no.9176 is void-abinitio?
…In the affirmative.
5. Whether plaintiffs prove that they are entitled for relief of permanent injunction?
…In the affirmative.
6. Whether plaintiffs prove that they are entitled for other reliefs?
…In the affirmative.
7. Whether defendant no.1 proves that the alleged agreement to sale dated 02.12.1985 is void ab-initio?
…In the negative.
8. Whether defendants prove that the suit is barred by Law of Limitation?
…In the negative.
9. Whether defendant no.2 proves that sale deed dated 02.12.1985 was not enforceable by law?
…In the negative.
10. Whether defendant no.2 proves that he is bona fide purchaser and in possession of the suit property?
…In the negative.
11. Whether judgment and decree in Spl. Civil Suit No.46 of 2011 requires interference and is liable to be set aside?
…In the affirmative.
12. What order? As per final order.
2308 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
15. In the analysis, the First Appellate Court recorded the following findings also:
15.1. It held that the title of the property relates back to the date of execution of the sale deed and not the date of the registration.
15.2. It held that during the lifetime of the father, mother can act as the natural guardian of the minor.
15.3. The defendants having failed to seek a declaration of the sale deed dated 02.12.1985 being declared void ab-initio or for its cancellation, once the document is duly registered by the Sub-Registrar, it is only the competent Civil Court which would have the jurisdiction to declare it as cancelled or void ab-initio.
15.4. Merely because the challenge to the procedure has been made with respect to the registration, the submission of the defendants with respect to the delayed registration etc. gets washed out.
16. The said judgment was assailed by way of Second Appeal by the respondent no.1, the subsequent purchaser (defendant no.2) only. No appeal was filed by the respondent no.2 (defendant no.1), vendor of the appellant. This appeal was registered as Second Appeal No.649 of 2019.
17. By the impugned judgment dated 09.06.2022, the High Court has allowed the same and after setting aside the judgment of the first Appellate Court, restored that of the Trial Court and dismissed the suit. It is this judgment of the High Court, which is under challenge in the present appeal. The High Court framed the following substantial questions of law in paragraph 12 of the judgment which are reproduced hereunder: - “12. The substantial questions of law raised in the appeal are:
i) Whether execution of the sale deed dated 02.12.1985 at Exhibit 54 has been duly proved;
ii) Whether the sale deed at Exhibit 54 conveys title in favour of plaintiffs;
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 2309Kaushik Premkumar Mishra & Anr. v. Kanji Ravaria @ Kanji & Anr. iii) Whether the findings of the first Appellate court on the issue of execution and validity of sale deed dated 02.12.1985 are not based on evidence on record and are perverse.”
18. The High Court recorded the following findings:
18.1. The sale deed in question dated 02.12.1985 could not be held to be invalid for the sole reason that the deed was signed only by the vendor and not by the vendees (in favour of plaintiffs).
18.2. The fact that the purchasers were minors would not per se affect the validity of the sale deed (in favour of plaintiffs).
18.3. It criticizes the findings of the first Appellate Court regarding the sale deed dated 02.12.1985 having been validly proved by the plaintiffs to be not based on consideration of material facts on record as discussed and considered by the Trial Court while holding that the sale deed was not validly proved.
18.4. It considered in great detail the provisions of the Registration Act to hold that the sale deed dated 02.12.1985 was not validly registered, as such, could not have been relied upon by the plaintiffs for any of the reliefs claimed by them or to maintain the suit.
19. We have heard Shri Vinay Navare, learned senior counsel for the appellants, Shri Ranjit Kumar, learned senior counsel appearing for respondent No.2 and Shri Huzefa Ahmadi, learned senior counsel representing respondent No.1.
20. The submissions of Shri Navare for the appellant may be summarized as under:
20.1. Respondent No.2 did not specifically deny execution of the sale deed in favour of appellant no.1 and his brother. He has only stated in the written statement that he does not recollect to have executed any such document.
20.2. Respondent No.2 did not cross-examine the appellant No.1 who had entered the witness box. The appellant No.1 had specifically stated, not only in the plaint but also in his deposition, that respondent No.2 had executed the sale deed on 02.12.1985 after receiving the sale consideration.
2310 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
20.3. Respondent No.2, although filed a written statement making vague assertions but chose not to appear in the witness box apparently to avoid being cross-examined.
20.4. The first Appellate Court had decreed the suit of the appellant but no appeal was filed against the same by the respondent No.2. The only appeal filed before the High Court was by respondent No.1.
20.5. The objection as to the registration or the procedure adopted while registering the sale deed was essentially available to respondent No.2 but he did not raise it in the written statement. Further respondent no.2 neither cross-examined appellant No.1 nor did he enter the witness box nor did he assail the judgment of the first Appellate Court decreeing the suit.
20.6. The only manner in which respondent No.2 could have challenged the sale deed in favour of the appellants was by way of either a counter-claim or by way of an independent suit praying for cancellation of the sale deed by impleading the registering authority, which he chose not to do.
20.7. As there was no counter-claim filed by the defendant, in particular, respondent No.2, the question of validity of execution and registration of the Sale Deed dated 02.12.1985 in favour of the appellant no.1 and his brother, could not be tested.
20.8. The Trial Court did not frame any issue with respect to the validity of the registration process or the registration of the sale deed by the registering authorities, after such a long gap of 26 years. Without framing such an issue, the Trial Court committed serious error and a patent illegality in recording a finding with regard to the registration process and commenting on the registering authorities. Even the High Court committed the same illegality.
20.9. There is no limitation provided under the law for a sale deed which had been executed and duly presented before the Registrar for registration, for such document to be registered within a particular time. Even if there was a gap of 26 years from the date of presentation till the date of registration, it would not make any difference and the sale deed would relate back to the date of execution once registered.
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 2311Kaushik Premkumar Mishra & Anr. v. Kanji Ravaria @ Kanji & Anr.
20.10. The fact that the sale deed was duly executed on 02.12.1985 and thereafter presented for registration on 05.12.1985 is apparent from the fact that respondent No.2 on the same date i.e. 02.12.1985 had executed the sale deed for the remaining half portion of Survey No.13/1 in favour of collaterals of the appellant and further, the said sale deed in favour of the collaterals was also presented for registration on 05.12.1985 i.e. the same day on which the appellant presented the sale deed for registration. The sale deed of the collaterals was later on registered. However, the sale deed of the appellant no.1 remained pending for registration due to deficiency in stamp duty and was finally registered in 2011 after the deficiency was removed.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.