Dharmendra Kumar @ Dhamma v. State of Madhya Pradesh
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 480; [2024] 7 S.C.R. 218
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Surya Kant, Justice K.V. Viswanathan
- Decided
- 8 Jul 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 2806/2024
- Sections
- 161, 302, 154, 162(1), 145, 162, 32, 34, 27, 313, 32(1)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 218 : 2024 INSC 480 Dharmendra Kumar @ Dhamma v.
State of Madhya Pradesh (Criminal Appeal No. 2806 of 2024)
08 July 2024 [Surya Kant* and K. V. Viswanathan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration High Court if justified in upholding conviction and sentence of the appellant under ss. 302/34 IPC; the contradictions or discrepancies and the absence of blood group classification or inconclusive FSL results on the recovered weapon, if detrimental to the prosecution’s case; the Investigating Officer’s failure to obtain a fitness certificate from the medical officer, if would invalidate the consideration of the statement of the deceased recorded u/s. 161 CrPC before his death, as a ‘dying declaration; and disclosure statement made by the appellant leading to the discovery and subsequent seizure of the knife, if admissible in evidence.
Headnotes † Penal Code, 1860 – ss. 302/34 – Conviction and sentence under – On facts, dispute over construction of wall – Verbal abuses hurled at the complainant – Two persons who constructed the wall physically assaulted by the opposite party, the appellant inflicted knife blow to one, and later both of them succumbed to their injuries – Appellant convicted u/ss. 302, 147, 148, and 149 and sentenced to life imprisonment – High Court upheld the appellant’s conviction u/s. 302/34, however, acquitted him u/ss. 147 and 148 – Correctness:
Held: No contradictions or discrepancies in the prosecution case that would compel to take a view different than that of the courts below – When the testimonies of eyewitnesses are consistent, unimpeachable, and duly corroborated by medical evidence or the recovery of incriminating material like the weapon used, the deficiencies, if any, in the recording of FIR alone do not constitute a valid ground to overturn the conviction or undermine the prosecution case – Non-reading of contents of FIR to the complainant would not effect the prosecution case – Presence of appellant on the place * Author [2024] 7 S.C.R. 219Dharmendra Kumar @ Dhamma v. State of Madhya Pradesh of occurrence established – Disclosure statement by the appellant leading to the discovery and seizure of the knife admissible in evidence – Knife injury can be attributed to the appellant – Absence of blood group classification or inconclusive FSL results on the recovered weapon would not effect the prosecution case – Also, mere non-obtainment of a medical fitness certificate would not deter the court from considering a properly recorded statement u/s. 161 CrPC, to be a dying declaration – Thus, the order passed by the High Court upheld – Evidence.[Paras 44, 51, 58, 61, 69, 70] Evidence – Contradictions in the prosecution case – Omission on the part of the Investigating Officer in marking a spot where incident took place, on the site plan – Effect:
Held: Mere omission on the part of the Investigating Officer does not deflect the prosecution case – Site plan merely denotes the location of the incident without implying further details – In light of the fact that the persons who had seen that to which they have testified, due weightage must be given to their first-hand version – Their evidence cannot be jettisoned merely because the I.O. forgot to describe the room on the spot map – It is a case where eyewitnesses corroborated each other; their depositions are reinforced by deceased himself in his statement recorded u/s. 161 CrPC, and the location of the incident is depicted on the spot map as a `brick room’ – Thus, stands established that there was another Jhuggi where the deceased sought refuge and was eventually assaulted – So-called contradiction fails to invade the corpus delicti. [Paras 33, 34] First information report – Non-reading of contents of FIR to the complainant – Effect:
Held: Subject FIR fully satisfies all the ingredients of s. 154 CrPC – During the cross-examination, the complainant-informant claimed that the Police neither read out the FIR to her nor did it mention the contents of her statements which were recorded by the Police – Assuming it to be correct, such omission did not cause any prejudice to the appellant – Not a case where the appellant was not provided with a copy of the FIR or the charge sheet, which could have hindered his ability to effectively cross-examine the informant – Also no suggestion that he was not present at the scene, that he did not participate in the incident, or that he was falsely implicated for any reason – Appellant, thus, failed to demonstrate any prejudice resulting from the alleged non-reading of the contents of the FIR 220 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports to the informant – Reading over of the information after it is written down, the signing of the said information by the informant, and the entry of its substance in the prescribed manner not obligatory, but procedural in nature, and the omission of any of them does not impact the legal consequences resulting from the information provided – Furthermore, when testimonies of eyewitnesses are consistent, unimpeachable, and duly corroborated by medical evidence or recovery of weapon used, the deficiencies, if any, in recording of FIR alone do not constitute a valid ground to overturn the conviction or undermine the prosecution case. [Paras 40-44] Evidence – Presence of appellant on the place of occurrence, if doubtful:
Held: No reason to doubt that the appellant was not only present at the scene of crime, but he actively participated in the occurrence and gave one of the fatal blows to deceased – Submission of poor visibility owing to darkness at the spot of occurrence not tenable – Place of occurrence, was adjacent to that of the complainant making it easier for the witnesses to observe and identify the accused persons – Each accused, particularly the appellant, was familiar to the eyewitnesses – Considering that the incident occurred on a summer night, there would have been minimal obstruction to visibility for the witnesses – Appellant, in his 313 CrPC statement, nowhere took the plea of alibi also did not pursue this defence during the cross-examination of witnesses either, as also did not adduce any evidence in support thereof – Furthermore, not a case where the complainant or prosecution witness held grudges against the appellant and fabricated a story to implicate him after the incident – Rather, the name of the appellant surfaced in the very first version, duly recorded, within less than two hours of the occurrence – Also no motive to falsely implicate the appellant indicated.[Paras 48, 49, 51] Evidence – Disclosure statement by the appellant leading to the discovery and seizure of the knife-weapon of offence – Admissibility in evidence – Knife injury, if can be attributed to the appellant:
Held: Disclosure statement of the appellant to the extent it led to the recovery of a knife correctly admitted in evidence – Prosecution version was accepted by the courts below – It cannot be ignored that both eyewitnesses, are illiterate labourers, and their testimonies were recorded after a considerable length of time had passed since [2024] 7 S.C.R. 221Dharmendra Kumar @ Dhamma v. State of Madhya Pradesh the occurrence – Both the witnesses emphatically denied that they were tutored by Police or anyone else – Unfiltered testimony of a rustic witness, even if marred with some minor inconsistencies or discrepancies, cannot debilitate its perseverance – Evidence of such witnesses has to be evaluated comprehensively and carefully, especially when the cross-examination discreetly suggests that the accused persons did make a bid to win them over by exerting some extraneous pressure – Thus, the statements of the prosecution witness does not suffer from the discrepancy of such a nature that they should be discarded – Even the testimony of the Investigating Officer is devoid of any ulterior motive or attempt to fabricate evidence or falsely implicate the appellant and his co-accused – It would be too unfair and unreasonable to expect a witness, unless parroted, to recall every minute detail of the occurrence and present it with a totally accumulative narrative – Appellant’s submission that knife injury was not caused by him, bereft of any merit. [Paras 56-58] Evidence – Absence of blood group classification – Inconclusive FSL results on the recovered weapon – Effect on the prosecution case:
Held: Upon a thorough examination of the FSL report, its confirmed that the blood group classification test conducted on the recovered knife yielded inconclusive results – However, the human blood was detected on the knife recovered at the instance of the appellant – Various weapons, including lathis and even the knife attributed to accused underwent an FSL examination, yet, no traces of human blood were found on them – Notably, human blood was solely found on the knife used by the appellant – Furthermore, non-explanation of human blood on the weapon of crime constitutes a circumstance against the accused – It is incumbent upon the accused to provide an explanation regarding the presence of human blood on the weapon – Appellant failed to do so – While it may not be a decisive factor to determine the guilt, but conspicuous silence does lend support to prosecution case. [Para 61] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s. 161 – Statement made by deceased to a police officer u/s. 161, regarding cause of death – Admissibility as dying declaration:
Held: s.161 empowers the Police to examine orally any person who is acquainted with the facts and circumstances of the case 222 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports under investigation – Police may reduce such statement into writing also – s. 162(1), nonetheless, mandates that no statement made by any person to a Police Officer, if reduced to writing, be signed by the person making it, nor shall such statement be used in evidence except to contradict a witness in the manner provided by s. 145 of the Evidence Act – However, Sub-Section (2) of s. 162 carves out an exception to Sub-Section (1) that nothing in s. 162 shall be deemed to apply to any statement falling within the ambit of clause (1) of s. 32 of the Evidence Act – Statement made by a person who is dead, as to the cause of his death or to the circumstances of the transaction which resulted in his death, to a Police Officer and which has been recorded u/s. 161, shall be relevant and admissible, notwithstanding the express bar against use of such statement in evidence contained therein – In such eventuality, the statement recorded u/s. 161 assumes the character of a dying declaration – Since extraordinary credence has been given to such dying declaration, the court ought to be extremely careful and cautious in placing reliance thereupon. [Para 64] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s. 161 – Consideration of the statement of one of the deceased recorded u/s. 161 before his death, as a dying declaration – Non-obtainment of a medical fitness certificate by the investigating officer from the medical officer – Effect:
Held: As regard to the assessment of mental fitness of the person making a dying declaration, it is indubitably the responsibility of the court to ensure that the declarant was in a sound state of mind – This is because there are no rigid procedures mandated for recording a dying declaration – If an eyewitness asserts that the deceased was conscious and capable of making the declaration, the medical opinion cannot override such affirmation, nor can the dying declaration be disregarded solely for want of a doctor’s fitness certification – Requirement for a dying declaration to be recorded in the presence of a doctor, following certification of the declarant’s mental fitness, is merely a matter of prudence – On facts, investigating officer recorded the statement instantly, a day after the incident, categorically stating that the medical report did not mention that the condition of the declarant, was serious in nature – On perusal of the statement, it is clear that the declarant was in a fit condition as not only did he properly explain the incident but has also markedly specified the role of the appellant – That [2024] 7 S.C.R. 223Dharmendra Kumar @ Dhamma v. State of Madhya Pradesh apart, the injuries found during the post-mortem examination conducted by the doctor have duly corroborated the statement of deceased – Mere non-obtainment of a medical fitness certificate would not deter the Court from considering a properly recorded statement u/s. 161 to be a dying declaration. [Para 70] First information report – Object of:
Held: FIR is not a substantive piece of evidence, and it can be used only to corroborate or contradict the version of an informant – Also written complaint to register the FIR not necessary – Even an oral communication to the Police disclosing the commission of a cognizable offence is sufficient to register the FIR – Object of the FIR is to inform the jurisdictional Magistrate and the Police Administration of the offence reported to the Police Station; to acquaint the Judicial Officer before whom the case is ultimately tried as to what are the actual facts stated immediately after the occurrence and on what materials the investigation commenced; and most importantly, to safeguard the accused against subsequent variations, exaggerations or additions. [Paras 38, 39] Case Law Cited Shivanna v. State of Hunsur Town Police [2010] 10 SCR 410 : (2010) 15 SCC 91; State v. N.S. Gnaneswaran (2013) 3 SCC 594; State (NCT of Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu [2005] Supp. 2 SCR 79 : (2005) 11 SCC 600; Heera v. State of Rajasthan [2007] 7 SCR 1065 (2007) : 10 SCC 175; Nathuni Yadav v. State of Bihar [1996] Supp. 10 SCR 905 : (1998) 9 SCC 238; Pulukuri Kottaya v. Emperor (1946) SCC OnLine PC 47; Raja @ Rajinder v. State of Haryana [2015] 3 SCR 947 : (2015) 11 SCC 43; John Pandian v. State [2010] 15 SCR 1012 : (2010) 14 SCC 129; Mukeshbhai Gopalbhai Barot v. State of Gujarat [2010] 9 SCR 632 : (2010) 12 SCC 224; Sri Bhagwan v. State of U.P. [2012] 12 SCR 774 : (2013) 12 SCC 137; Pradeep Bisoi v. State of Odisha [2018] 12 SCR 947 : (2019) 11 SCC 500; Koli Chunilal Savji v. State of Gujarat [1999] Supp. 3 SCR 284 : (1999) 9 SCC 562; Laxman v. State of Maharashtra [2002] Supp. 1 SCR 697 : (2002) 6 SCC 710 – referred to.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Evidence Act, 1872.
224 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports List of Keywords Contradictions or discrepancies; Absence of blood group classification; Inconclusive FSL; Medical fitness certificate; Statement of the declarant recorded u/s. 161 CrPC before his death; Dying declaration; Disclosure statement; Admissible in evidence; Testimonies of eyewitnesses; First information report; Plea of alibi; Onus to prove; Test Identification tests. Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.2806 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 19.12.2017 of the High Court of M.P. Principal Seat at Jabalpur in CRA No.193 of 2006 Appearances for Parties Dushyant Dave, Sr. Adv., Kuldip Singh, Mrs. Ayushi Gaur, Gaurav Yadava, Advs. for the Appellant.
Ms. Mrinal Gopal Elker, Saurabh Singh, Ashish Rawat, Advs. for the Respondent.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Surya Kant, J.
Leave granted.
2. This appeal is directed against the judgment dated 19.12.2017, passed by the High Court of Madhya Pradesh at Jabalpur (hereinafter, ‘High Court’), dismissing the Criminal Appeal filed by the Appellant against his conviction and sentence under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter, ‘IPC’) awarded by the Learned Additional Sessions Judge, Bhopal (hereinafter, ‘Trial Court’) vide judgment and order dated 10.11.2005.
FACTS :
3. At this juncture, it is imperative to delve into the factual matrix to set out the context of the present proceedings.
4. FIR No. 268 dated 20.06.2004 was registered at Police Station Kamla Nagar, Bhopal under Sections 307, 147, 148, and 149 of IPC on the [2024] 7 S.C.R. 225Dharmendra Kumar @ Dhamma v. State of Madhya Pradesh statement of Usha Bai (P.W.10). The said Complainant stated that on the night of 20.06.2004, at around 9:30 pm, she was overseeing the construction of the wall of her Jhuggi (hut) by Devi Singh @ Tillu, and Tularam. At that moment, accused persons, Ahmad and his wife, Kanija Bi, arrived and objected to the construction. Tillu asserted that it was their Jhuggi and they had the right to build the wall. Meanwhile, other accused persons, including Vijay, Dharmendra @ Dhamma (Appellant), Katchu @ Ramswaroop, Ballu, Ravi, and Asgar, arrived and began verbally abusing the Complainant, Tillu, and Tularam. The situation intensified as all the accused, including the Appellant, rushed to physically assault Tillu. In defence, Tillu sought refuge inside a nearby unoccupied Jhuggi belonging to one Bhairav Shastri, locking the door from inside. However, the accused forcibly entered Bhairav Shastri’s Jhuggi by breaking open the door. Once inside, they surrounded Tillu, with the Appellant delivering a knife blow to Tillu in his abdomen, while Asgar inflicted another blow slightly lower on his stomach. Following this, the other accused persons also physically assaulted Tillu using their fists and sticks. Meanwhile, Tularam attempted to intervene, but he too was subjected to blows from Katchu and Ahmad, resulting in injuries to his head and hands. Upon hearing the commotion, residents from the locality arrived at the scene, prompting the accused to flee. The Complainant further stated that she attempted to intervene but was threatened with dire consequences if she did not leave the area.
5. After the incident, Tillu and Tularam, both injured, were taken to Katju Hospital for medical aid. The Emergency Medical Officer, Dr. R.S. Vijayvargiya (P.W.4), noted Tillu’s lack of pulse, as well as two stab wounds in his chest and three stab wounds in his abdomen, indicating a critical condition. Upon examining Tularam, Dr. Vijayvargiya observed severe injuries to the occipital and temporal regions of his head. Subsequently, both injured persons were referred to Hamidia Hospital for further treatment.
6. Tillu unfortunately succumbed to his injuries and was declared dead, while Tularam was still alive and was admitted to Hamidia Hospital.
7. Dr. C.S. Jain (P.W. 13) conducted the post-mortem examination on Tillu, determining that the cause of death was shock and haemorrhage resulting from multiple stab wounds across the body and head injuries. The wounds were inflicted by a sharp, penetrating weapon, causing the stab injuries, while the head injuries were inflicted by a hard and 226 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports blunt object. The combined injuries to the head and abdomen were deemed sufficient to cause death.
8. Girish Bohre, the Investigating Officer (P.W.14), commenced the investigation by preparing a spot map (Ex.P.2) and also seized the blood-stained pieces of the floor from the place of occurrence (Ex.P.31).
9. As Tularam was alive though critically injured, the Investigating Officer (P.W. 14) documented his statement (Ex.P.40) under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter, ‘CrPC’) wherein Tularam recounted the events during the subject incident. Tularam mentioned that he and Tillu were constructing the wall of Usha Bai’s Jhuggi at Navgrah Mandir. Around 9:15 pm, Ahmad and his wife, Kanija Bi, approached and opposed the construction. Despite Tillu’s assertion that it was their wall, Ahmad persisted in preventing them. Shortly after, Vijay, Dharmendra @ Dhamma (Appellant), Katchu @ Ramaswaroop, Ballu, Ravi, and Asgar arrived, initiating verbal abuse. The accused then assaulted Tillu, who sought refuge inside Bhairav Shastri’s nearby Jhuggi, locking himself inside. The assailants forcibly entered and surrounding Tillu, Dhamma (Appellant) inflicted a knife blow to Tillu’s abdomen, while Asgar also stabbed him near the navel. Additionally, the other accused engaged in physical assault using sticks, lathis, and fists. When Tularam attempted to intervene, Katchu and Ahmad struck him with sticks, inflicting injuries to his head, hands, and body. Tularam noted that Lallu (P.W.11) and one Ramesh were eyewitnesses to the incident.
10. Tularam too passed away approximately five days after undergoing surgery in Hamidia Hospital. Dr. Neelam Srivastava (P.W.15) conducted his post-mortem examination, concluding that the cause of death was cardio-respiratory failure resulting from a head injury. Moreover, the severity of the injury was such that it could have led to death under normal circumstances. This injury, deemed homicidal, was inflicted by hard, blunt, and heavy objects.
11. During the course of investigation, the Investigating Officer (P.W. 14), following a disclosure statement (Ex.P.14) made by the Appellant, recovered a knife, which the Appellant had concealed in Barrack No. 2 of Police Line Nehru Nagar. Lallu Vishwakarma (P.W.11) was a witness to this recovery. The knife was then submitted for forensic examination (Ex.P.39), where the human blood on the knife was detected but the blood group classification was inconclusive. [2024] 7 S.C.R. 227Dharmendra Kumar @ Dhamma v. State of Madhya Pradesh
12. After the investigation, all the accused persons, including the Appellant, were charged under Sections 147, 148, 302/149, 307/149 of IPC.
13. In the trial, the prosecution examined as many as 15 witnesses to bring the guilt home, including Usha Bai, P.W.10 (Complainant) and Lallu Vishwakarma, P.W.11, both eyewitnesses. The prosecution case is largely based upon the version of these two eyewitnesses, who claimed that the fatal blows were caused to the victims in front of them.
14. The Trial Court, having found the version of the two eyewitnesses (P.W.10 and P.W.11) to be trustworthy, which was duly corroborated by the testimony of the Investigating Officer (P.W.14), the medical evidence and the recovery of the weapon, held the Appellant guilty of offences under Sections 302, 147, 148, and 149 of IPC and sentenced him to undergo life imprisonment.
15. The High Court, vide the impugned judgment, upheld the Appellant’s conviction under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the IPC, though it has acquitted him under Sections 147 and 148 of the IPC. The High Court has held that: (i) The presence of the Appellant stood established through the testimony of Lallu Vishwakarma (P.W.11), and his cross-examination further confirms that there was no motive for falsely incriminating the Appellant; (ii) The allegations against the Appellant, as detailed by eyewitnesses Usha Bai (P.W.10) and Lallu Vishwakarma (P.W.11), were duly corroborated by the medical opinions of Dr. C.S. Jain (P.W.13) and Dr. Neelam Shrivastava (P.W.15); (iii) The statement given by deceased Tularam, as recorded by P.W.14, aligns with other evidence relied upon for conviction; (iv) The weapon (knife) was seized based on the disclosure statement of the Appellant, making the recovery admissible under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (hereinafter, ‘IEA’); and (v) the testimony of Investigating Officer, P.W.14, also corroborated the weapon’s seizure.
16. Discontented with his conviction, the Appellant is in appeal before us. Contentions Of Parties :
17. Mr. Dushyant Dave, learned Senior Counsel for the Appellant, argued that the High Court erred in upholding the Appellant’s conviction under Section 302/34 IPC. Substantiating this, he made the following submissions:
a) The prosecution’s case presented inherent contradictions. On the one hand, the two eyewitnesses (P.W.10 and P.W.11), 228 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports relied upon by the courts below, testified that the entire incident unfolded inside Bhairav Shastri’s Jhuggi, situated near that of the Complainant, (P.W.10). On the other hand, the Investigating Officer (P.W.14), during his cross-examination, stated that no quarrel took place near P.W.10’s Jhuggi, and that there was no ‘Bhairon Baba Temple’ or residence near the site of occurrence. It was argued that since the incident admittedly occurred inside a Jhuggi, it is unbelievable that the eyewitnesses could have seen it.
b) It was contended that the presence of the Appellant at the place of incident is stoutly disputed, and such an inference can be well drawn from the statement of the Complainant herself. The incident took place around 9:30 pm, posing visibility challenges for the witnesses. Usha Bai (the Complainant, P.W.10) has deposed that she was familiar with accused Ahamd, Asghar Ali, Ravi, and Kanija Bi but was aware of the other accused by name only. This clearly indicates that P.W.10 was not acquainted with the Appellant. Barring the eyewitness account, there is no other credible evidence to suggest that the Appellant was present or participated in the occurrence.
c) Further, the knife injury could not be attributed to the Appellant, as testified by Lallu Vishwakarma (P.W.11), who explicitly stated that he couldn’t discern who assaulted whom.
d) That apart, it was urged that the weapon confiscated from the Appellant underwent a Forensic Science Laboratory (hereinafter, ‘FSL’) examination, producing inconclusive results, which bolsters the Appellant’s case that he was falsely implicated. e) Finally, it was canvassed that the statement of the deceased Tularam, recorded by Investigating Officer Girish Bohre (P.W.14) under Section 161 CrPC, could not have been considered a ‘dying declaration’ due to the absence of certification from the doctor regarding Tularam’s mental fitness.
f) Even otherwise, a dying declaration made before the Investigating Officer/ Police is always shrouded by suspicious circumstances and no reliance thereupon can be made.
18. Per Contra, Ms. Mrinal Gopal Elker, learned counsel on behalf of the State, argued that the impugned judgment dated 19.12.2017 does not warrant any interference by this Court. She submitted as follows: [2024] 7 S.C.R. 229Dharmendra Kumar @ Dhamma v. State of Madhya Pradesh a) The Courts below have expressly affirmed the presence of the Appellant at the site of incident and his involvement in the occurrence, based on the testimony of Lallu Vishwakarma (P.W.11). She argued that Vishwakarma’s cross-examination provides no reason to doubt his version qua the Appellant. b) There is a specific accusation against the Appellant of inflicting the knife blow on the deceased Tillu’s abdomen, which is supported by the Medical Legal Certificate (MLC) conducted by Dr. R.S. Vijayvargiya (P.W.4), who confirmed the presence of a stab wound on the abdomen with profuse bleeding.
c) After he was apprehended, the Appellant voluntarily disclosed the location of the concealed knife to the Investigating Officer in the presence of witnesses. Such a recovery is admissible in evidence as an incriminating material against the Appellant. d) Finally, Ms. Elker highlighted that the courts below have rightly considered the statement of deceased Tularam recorded under Section 161 of CrPC as a ‘dying declaration’, corroborating the prosecution’s case against the Appellant beyond any doubt.
ANALYSIS :
19. Having heard learned Senior Counsel/Counsel for the parties at a considerable length and on perusal of the statements of eyewitnesses along with other relevant material on record, we find that the following three questions fall for our consideration in the present appeal: A. Have the Courts below erred in not appreciating the contradictions or discrepancies which would dislodge the prosecution’s case? B. Is the absence of blood group classification or inconclusive FSL results on the recovered weapon detrimental to the prosecution’s case?
C. Does the Investigating Officer’s failure to obtain a fitness certificate from the medical officer invalidate the consideration of the statement of Tularam recorded under Section 161 CrPC before his death, as a ‘dying declaration’?
A. CONTRADICTIONS IN THE PROSECUCTION’S CASE:
20. Since the prosecution case against the Appellant predominantly hinges upon the testimonies of Usha Bai (P.W.10), Lallu Vishwakarma 230 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports (P.W.11), Dr. C.S. Jain (P.W.13), Dr. Neelam Shrivastava (P.W.15) and Girish Bohre (P.W.14), we deem it appropriate to briefly summarise their testimonies hereunder:
21. Usha Bai (P.W.10) swore that on 20.06.2004, around 9.00 p.m., she was overseeing the construction of wall of her Jhuggi by Devi Singh alias Tillu and Tularam. Ahmad and Kanija Bi, two of the accused, arrived and ordered them to halt construction. Following this, Ahmad struck Tularam on the head with a lathi. Subsequently, Asgar, Ahmad’s son, incited the other accused to attack, prompting all the accused to rush in and assault Tillu, Tularam, and Lalaram with various weapons like sticks, rods, and pipes. When P.W.10 attempted to intervene by grabbing Ahmad’s lathi, she was verbally abused and told to step aside. Consequently, she retreated to the sidelines. The accused continued to beat Tillu and Tularam until they were incapacitated. Tillu succumbed to his injuries at the scene, while Tularam was barely breathing. Immediately after the incident, Tillu, Tularam, and Lalaram were rushed to Hamidia Hospital for treatment by the Kamla Nagar Police Station. Tillu passed away en route to the hospital. P.W.10 lodged a First Information Report (FIR) (Ex.P.7) detailing the incident.
22. Lallu Vishwakarma (P.W.11) recounted that the incident occurred near a wall owned by Usha Bai (P.W.10). Around 8-9:30 pm, Ahmad arrived wielding a lathi at the place of construction of Usha Bai’s wall, where P.W.11 and Tillu were sharing a meal. Ahmad confronted them, objecting to the wall’s construction. In response, Tillu urged them to allow the construction to proceed. Subsequently, all the other accused arrived and assaulted Tillu and another individual, although P.W.11 couldn’t discern the specific assailants. The accused wielded various weapons such as lathis, knives, sticks, rods, and pipes during the attack. Tillu was found injured inside Bhairon Baba’s room, while Tularam lay injured at the construction site. P.W.11 then arranged for the injured to be transported in an auto. He noted that Tillu’s intestines were protruding, which he wrapped in cloth and placed in the auto. Additionally, Tularam had suffered traumatic and haemorrhagic shock due to multiple injuries. The injured were then taken to Hamidia Hospital. The Police subsequently confiscated the knife and sticks from the Appellant (Ex.P.14) and prepared a memorandum, which P.W.11 signed.
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 231Dharmendra Kumar @ Dhamma v. State of Madhya Pradesh
23. In addition to the two eyewitnesses, the prosecution so as to lend corroboration to the ocular evidence, called upon medical experts, namely Dr. C.S. Jain (P.W.13) and Dr. Neelam Shrivastava (P.W.15), who conducted the post-mortem examinations of Tillu and Tularam, respectively.
24. Dr. C.S. Jain, P.W.13, reported that Tillu’s body was brought in for post-mortem examination on 21.06.2004, revealing four stab wounds on the front side of the abdomen, along with a laceration on the head and three abrasions. He concluded that the stab wounds were inflicted by a hard, sharp, and penetrating weapon, while the head injuries were caused by a hard and blunt object. The combined injuries to the head and abdomen were deemed sufficient to cause death.
25. Dr. Neelam Shrivastava, P.W.15, testified that Tularam’s body was brought for post-mortem examination on 24.06.2004, revealing multiple radial fractures, subdural subarachnoid haemorrhage, and various wounds. She concluded that Tularam’s death resulted from respiratory failure due to a head injury and its associated complications. The severity of the injury was sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature, and it was determined to be homicidal, inflicted by a hard, blunt, and heavy weapon. During cross-examination, she clarified that Tularam did not sustain any injuries from knives or swords on his body.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.