Union of India & Ors. v. Santosh Kumar Tiwari
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 392; [2024] 6 S.C.R. 429
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice Manoj Misra
- Decided
- 8 May 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 6135/2024
- Sections
- 11, 18, 8, 69, 116, 13, 3, 2, 9, 10, 11(1), 15
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
* Author [2024] 6 S.C.R. 429 : 2024 INSC 392 Union of India & Ors.
v.
Santosh Kumar Tiwari (Civil Appeal No. 6135 of 2024)
08 May 2024 [Dr. D. Y. Chandrachud, CJI, J. B. Pardiwala and Manoj Misra,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether Rule 27 of the Central Reserve Police Force Rules, 1955 to the extent it provides for punishments other than those specified in Section 11 of the Central Reserve Police Force Act, 1949, is ultra vires the CRPF Act and as such inoperable and void; whether the punishment of compulsory retirement from service could have been imposed upon the respondent (a Head Constable in CRPF) by relying upon the provisions of Rule 27 of the CRPF Rules; whether the punishment of compulsory retirement imposed suffers from any procedural infirmity and / or is shockingly disproportionate to the proven misconduct of the respondent.
Headnotes† Central Reserve Police Force Rules, 1955 – Rule 27 – Central Reserve Police Force Act, 1949 – Section 11 – Punishment of compulsory retirement prescribed in Rule 27, if ultra vires the CRPF Act:
Held: The rule-making power of the Central Government found in Section 18 is in broad terms – The Central Government is not only empowered to make rules for regulating the award of minor punishment under Section 11 but also to carry out the purposes of the Act which includes superintendence of, and control over, the Force as well as its administration – The delegate cannot override the Act either by exceeding the authority or by making provisions inconsistent with the Act however, when the enabling Act itself permits its modification by rules, the rules made prevail over the provision in the Act – While enacting the CRPF Act the legislative intent was not to declare that only those minor punishments could be imposed as are specified in Section 11 of the CRPF Act – Rather, it was left open for the Central Government to frame rules to carry out the purposes of the Act 430 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports and the punishments imposable were subject to the rules framed under the Act – Section 8 vests the superintendence and control over the Force in the Central Government – ‘Control’ is a word of wide amplitude and includes disciplinary control – Therefore, if the CRPF Act envisages vesting of control over the Force in the Central Government and the various punishments imposable under Section 11 are subject to the rules made under the Act, the Central Government in exercise of its general rule-making power, to ensure full and effective control over the Force, can prescribe punishments other than those specified in that section, including the punishment of compulsory retirement – To keep the Force efficient, weeding out undesirable elements therefrom is essential and is a facet of control over the Force, which the Central Government has over the Force by virtue of Section 8 of the CRPF Act – Thus, to ensure effective control over the Force, if rules are framed, in exercise of general rule-making power, prescribing the punishment of compulsory retirement, the same cannot be said to be ultra vires Section 11 of the CRPF Act, particularly when sub-section (1) of Section 11 clearly mentions that the power exercisable therein is subject to any rules made under the Act – The punishment of compulsory retirement prescribed by Rule 27 is intra vires the CRPF Act and is one of the punishments imposable – In the present case, respondent was part of a disciplined force and was found guilty of assaulting his colleague – Punishment awarded not shockingly disproportionate to the proven misconduct – Rather, considering his past service, already a sympathetic view was taken in the matter and no further latitude needs be shown – The punishment of compulsory retirement awarded to the respondent is affirmed – Impugned order of the High Court set aside. [Paras 17, 29, 30-32, 35, 36] Service Law – Service jurisprudence – Punishments – Compulsory retirement:
Held: Ordinarily a person in service cannot be visited with a punishment not specified in the contract of service or the law governing such service – Punishments may be specified either in the contract of service or in the Act or the rules governing such service – Compulsory retirement is a well-accepted method of removing dead wood from the cadre without affecting his entitlement for retirement benefits, if otherwise payable – It is another form of terminating the service without affecting retirement benefits – [2024] 6 S.C.R. 431Union of India & Ors. v. Santosh Kumar Tiwari Ordinarily, compulsory retirement is not considered a punishment – But if the service rules permit it to be imposed by way of a punishment, subject to an enquiry, so be it. [Paras 18, 33] Interpretation of Statutes – Central Reserve Police Force Act, 1949 – ss.11, 9, 10 – “subject to”:
Held: As regards Section 11 being exhaustive of the minor punishments which could be imposed, the intention of the legislature appears to the contrary – Section 11 expressly uses the phrase “subject to any rules made under this Act” before “award in lieu of, or in addition to, suspension or dismissal any one or more of the following punishments” – While prescribing punishment for “more heinous offences” and “less heinous offences” in Sections 9 and 10 respectively, the phrase “subject to any rules made under this Act” is not used – The expression “subject to” conveys the idea of a provision yielding place to another provision or other provisions subject to which it is made. [Para 28] Administrative Law – Delegate’s power to make rules:
Held: The intention of the legislature, as indicated in the enabling Act, must be the prime guide to the extent of delegate’s power to make rules – However, the delegate must not travel wider than the object of the legislature rather it must remain true to it. [Para 24] Words and Phrases – ‘control’ – Concept and import of – Discussed – Central Reserve Police Force Act, 1949.
Case Law Cited State of West Bengal v. Nripendra Nath Bagchi [1966] 1 SCR 771 : AIR 1966 SC 447 – followed.
State of Jammu and Kashmir v. Lakhwinder Kumar and Ors. [2013] 2 SCR 1070 : (2013) 6 SCC 333; St. Johns Teachers Training Institute v. Regional Director, National Council for Teacher Education and Anr. [2003] 1 SCR 975 : (2003) 3 SCC 321; Madan Mohan Choudhary v. State of Bihar & Ors. [1999] 1 SCR 596 : (1999) 3 SCC 396 – relied on.
Union of India & Ors. v. Ghulam Mohd. Bhat [2005] Supp. 4 SCR 367 : (2005) 13 SCC 228; Union of India & Ors. v. Diler Singh [2016] 4 SCR 473 : (2016)
432 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports 13 SCC 71; General Officer Commanding-in-Chief & Anr. v. Subash Chandra Yadav & Anr. [1988] 3 SCR 62 : (1988) 2 SCC 351; State Bank of India and Ors.
v. T.J. Paul [1999] 2 SCR 1060 : (1999) 4 SCC 759;
Rohtak & Hissar Districts Electric Supply Co. Ltd. v.
State of U.P. & Ors. [1966] 2 SCR 863 : AIR 1966 SC 1471; Dr. Mahachandra Prasad Singh v. Chairman, Bihar Legislative Council & Ors. [2004] Supp. 5 SCR 692 : (2004) 8 SCC 747; Southern Petrochemical Industries Co. Ltd. v. Electricity Inspector & ETIO [2007] 6 SCR 955 : (2007) 5 SCC 447; Prasar Bharti & Ors.
v. Amarjeet Singh & Ors. [2007] 2 SCR 160 : (2007) 9 SCC 539 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited “Principles of Statutory Interpretation” by G.P. Singh (13th Edition, Chapter 12 at page 1019, published by LexisNexis); P. Ramanatha Aiyer’s Advanced Law Lexicon 4th Edition Vol.4 at page 4640; Statutory Interpretation (Fifth Edition, page 262, Section 69) by Francis Bennion – referred to.
List of Acts Central Reserve Police Force Act, 1949; Central Reserve Police Force Rules, 1955.
List of Keywords Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF); Head Constable in CRPF; Assaulting and abusing fellow colleague; Charges proved; Departmental enquiry; Suspension; Dismissal; Punishments; Minor punishments; Major punishments; More heinous offences; Less heinous offences; Punishment of imprisonment/fine; Disciplinary action; Dismissal from service; Removal from service; Delinquent employee; Award of punishment; Compulsory retirement;
Punishment of compulsory retirement from service; Non-gazetted officer; Departmental appeal; Misconduct; Proven misconduct; Rule making power of Central Government; Purpose of the Act; Intention of the legislature; Commandant; Competent authority; Delegate; Delegate’s power to make rules; Rules prevail over the provision in the Act; Control; Control over the Force; Disciplinary control; Central Government; ultra vires the CRPF Act; intra vires the CRPF Act. [2024] 6 S.C.R. 433Union of India & O r s . v . Santosh K u m a r T i w a r i Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No. 6135 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 10.12.2020 of the High Court of Orissa at Cuttack in WA No. 435 of 2020 Appearances for Parties Mrs. Aishwarya Bhati, A.S.G., R Bala, Sr. Adv., Navanjay Mahapatra, Ms. Seema Bengani, Ms. Shagun Thakur, Arvind Kumar Sharma, Advs. for the Appellants.
Anand Shankar, Arvind Wishwabandhu, Arun Kumar Arunchal, Advs. for the Respondent.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Manoj Misra, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. This appeal is against the judgment and order of the High Court of Orissa at Cuttack 1 dated 10.12.2020, whereby the Writ Appeal No. 435/2020, preferred by the appellants against the judgment and order of the learned Single Judge dated 14.01.2020, has been dismissed and the order of the learned Single Judge has been affirmed.
Factual Matrix
3. The respondent2 was a Head Constable in Central Reserve Police Force3. He was charge-sheeted on allegations of assaulting and abusing his fellow colleague. In the ensuing enquiry, the charges were found proved against the respondent. As a result thereof, the respondent was compulsorily retired from service vide order dated 16.02.2006. Aggrieved therewith, the respondent filed a departmental appeal, which was dismissed by the Deputy Inspector General (P), CRPF vide order dated 28.07.2006.
1 High Court 2 The original petitioner
3 CRPF
434 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
4. Assailing the order of compulsory retirement and dismissal of his appeal, the respondent filed a Writ Petition (C) No.17398/2006 before a Single Judge Bench of the High Court. The learned Single Judge vide order dated 14.01.2020 allowed the writ petition, inter alia, on the ground that the punishment of compulsory retirement was not one of the punishments specified in Section 11 (1) of the Central Reserve Police Force Act, 19494. The operative portion of the order of the learned Single Judge is extracted below:
“Thus, this court is of the opinion that the award of punishment by the order vide Annexure 5 not only remains bad, but in the circumstances, the consequential order vide Annexure 7 also becomes bad. In such view of the matter and as the Disciplinary Authority is to reconsider the question of punishment, this matter is relegated back to the Disciplinary Authority to hear the question of punishment, giving opportunity of hearing to the petitioner and pass the final order involving the disciplinary proceeding. For a remand of the matter to the Disciplinary Authority, this court observes, the Disciplinary Authority, while reconsidering the matter will also consider other grounds raised herein. For the setting aside of the order vide Annexure 5 and as the matter is relegated back to the authority, the position of the petitioner before passing of the final order shall be restored and for interference of this court with the order vide Annexures 5 and 7 release of the arrears, if any, involving the petitioner shall be dependent on the ultimate outcome involving fresh disposal of the proceeding by the Disciplinary Authority in terms of the directions of the apex court in paragraph 24 of the judgement in the case of Ranjit Singh versus Union of India as reported in (2006) 4 SCC 153.”
5. Aggrieved with the order of the learned Single Judge, the appellants preferred writ appeal (supra) before the Division Bench of the High Court, inter alia, on the following grounds:
(i) The charges against the respondent were found proved in the enquiry. They were of serious nature warranting penalty including that of dismissal or removal from service. Compulsory retirement 4 CRPF Act [2024] 6 S.C.R. 435Union of India & Ors. v. Santosh Kumar Tiwari is nothing but a species of removal from service and, therefore, being a lesser penalty than dismissal or removal from service, was an imposable punishment.
(ii) Section 11 of the CRPF Act provides that, subject to the rules made under the Act, the Commandant or any other authority or officer, as may be prescribed, award in lieu of, or in addition to, suspension or dismissal, anyone or more of the punishments specified therein to any member of the Force whom he considers to be guilty of disobedience, neglect of duty or remissness in the discharge of any duty or of other misconduct in his capacity as a member of the Force. Sub-section (1) of Section 18 empowers the Central Government to notify rules for carrying out the purposes of the CRPF Act. Sub-section (2) of Section 18 provides that without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing power, rules may provide for all or any of the matters specified therein, which includes regulating the award of minor punishment under Section 11, and providing for appeals from, or the revision of, orders under that section, or remission of fines imposed under that section. Rule 27 of the Central Reserve Police Force Rules, 1955 5 , specifies the procedure for the award of punishments. Clause (a) of Rule 27 enumerates in a tabular form the punishments which could be imposed and the authority competent to impose such punishments. At serial no.4, under column no.2, in the table, the punishment of compulsory retirement is mentioned as being one of the punishments that may be imposed by the Commandant after a formal departmental enquiry. Thus, in light of the provisions of Section 11 of the CRPF Act read with Rule 27 of the CRPF Rules, and by taking into consideration that charges were duly proved in the enquiry, the punishment of compulsory retirement was fully justified.
6. The Division Bench of the High Court, however, found no merit in the writ appeal and dismissed the same accordingly.
7. In these circumstances, the appellants are before this Court questioning the impugned judgment and order of the High Court. 5 CRPF Rules 436 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
8. We have heard Ms. Aishwarya Bhati, learned Additional Solicitor General, appearing for the appellants, and Mr. Anand Shankar, learned counsel, appearing for the respondent.
Submissions on behalf of the appellants
9. Ms. Bhati, learned counsel for the appellants, inter alia, submitted:
(i) The only ground pressed by the original petitioner was that the punishment of compulsory retirement is not imposable as it is not provided for in Section 11 of the CRPF Act, which is nothing but misconceived;
(ii) The High Court while accepting the above ground failed to consider:
(a) Section 116 of the CRPF Act is expressly made subject to any rules made under the Act. Section 18 7 of the 6 11. Minor punishments—
(1) The Commandant or any other authority or officer as may be prescribed, may, subject to any rules made under this Act, award in lieu of, or in addition to, suspension or dismissal any one or more of the following punishments to any member of the Force whom he considers to be guilty of disobedience, neglect of duty, or remissness in the discharge of any duty or of other misconduct in his capacity as a member of the Force, that is to say,—
(a) reduction in rank;
(b) fine of any amount not exceeding one month’s pay and allowances;
(c) confinement to quarters, lines or camp for a term not exceeding one month;
(d) confinement in the quarter-guard for not more than twenty-eight days, with or without punishment drill or extra guard, fatigue or other duty; and
(e) removal from any office of distinction or special emolument in the Force.
(2) Any punishment specified in clause (c) or clause (d) of sub-section (1) may be awarded by any gazetted officer when in command of any detachment of the Force away from headquarters, provided he is specially authorised in this behalf by the commandant.
(3) The Assistant Commandant, a company officer or a subordinate officer, not being below the rank of subedar or inspector, commanding a separate detachment or an outpost, or in temporary command at the headquarters of the Force, may, without a formal trial, award to any member of the Force who is for the time being subject to his authority any one or more of the following punishment for the commission of any petty offence against discipline which is not otherwise provided for in this Act, or which is not of a sufficiently serious nature to require prosecution before a criminal court, that is to say,—
(a) confinement for not more than seven days in the quarter-guard or such other place as may be considered suitable, with forfeiture of all pay and allowances during its continuance;
(b) punishment drill, or extra guard, fatigue or other duty, for not more than thirty days with or without confinement to quarters, lines or camp;
(c) censure or severe censure:
Provided that this punishment may be awarded to a subordinate officer only by the Commandant.
(4) A jemadar or sub-inspector who is temporarily in command of a detachment or an outpost may, in like manner and for the commission of any like offence, award to any member of the Force for the time being subject to his authority any of the punishments specified in clause (b) of sub-section (3) for not more than fifteen days.
7 18. Power to make rules: - 1) The Central Government may by notification in the official Gazette, make rules for carrying out the purposes of this Act.
[2024] 6 S.C.R. 437Union of India & Ors. v. Santosh Kumar Tiwari CRPF Act empowered the Central Government to make rules for carrying out the purposes of the Act and without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing power, rules could be made regulating the award of punishment under Section 11. CRPF Rules, 1955 were notified by the Central Government. Rule 278 specifically provided for compulsory retirement as one of the punishments imposable on a nongazetted officer, like the respondent. Thus, the impugned order of the High Court is in ignorance of the relevant provisions of the Act as well as the rules.
(b) Section 11 empowers the Commandant or any other competent authority to award in lieu of, or in addition to, suspension or dismissal anyone or more of the specified punishments. The specified punishments include removal from any office of distinction or special emolument in the Force. Dismissal is the highest of those punishments.
Removal is a lesser punishment. Section 11 uses the word removal as an expression of wide amplitude so as to include any punishment that has the effect of terminating the service. As compulsory retirement also entails in
(2) In particular and without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing power, such rules may provide for all or any of the following matters, namely:-
(a) regulating the classes and grades of, and the pay, pension and other remuneration of, member of the force, and their conditions of service in the force;
(b) regulating the powers and duties of officers authorized to exercise any function by or under this Act;
(c) fixing the period of service for members of the force;
(d) regulating the award of minor punishment under section 11, and providing for appeals from, or the revision of, orders under that section, or the remission of fines imposed under that section, and the remission of deductions made under section 13;
(e) regulating the several or collective liability of member of the force in the case of the loss or theft of weapons and ammunition;
(f) for the disposal of criminal cases arising under this Act and for specifying the prison in which a person convicted in any such case may be confined.
(3) Every rule made under this Act shall be laid, as soon as may be after it is made, before each House of Parliament, while it is in session, for a total period of thirty days which may be comprised in one session or in two or more successive sessions, and if, before the expiry of the session immediately following the session or the successive sessions aforesaid, both Houses agree in making any modification in the rule, or both Houses agree that the rule should not be made, the rule shall thereafter have effect only in such modified form or be of no effect, as the cases may be; so, however, that any such modification or annulment shall be without prejudice to the validity of anything previously done under that rule.
8 27. Procedure for the award of punishments —
(a) [The punishments shown as items 1 to 11 in column 2 of the table] below may be inflicted on non-- Gazetted Officers and men of the various ranks shown in each of the headings of columns 3 to 6, by the authorities named below such headings under the conditions mentioned in column 7. [TABLE 438 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports SI.
No.
Punishment Subedar (inspector)
Sub Inspector Others except Const. & enrolled followers Consts.
& enrolled followers Remarks 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
1. Dismissal or removal from the Force DIGP DIGP Comdt. Comdt.
To be inflicted after formal departmental enquiry
2. Reduction to a lower timescale of pay or service DIGP DIGP Comdt. Comdt.
3. Reduction to a lower stage in the time-scale of pay for a specified period DIGP DIGP Comdt. Comdt.
4. Compulsory retirement DIGP DIGP Comdt. Comdt.
5. Fine of any amount not exceeding one month’s pay and allowances DIGP DIGP Comdt. Comdt.
6. Confinement in the Quarter Guard exceeding seven days but not more than twenty eight days with or without punishment drill or extra guard fatigue or other duty - - - Comdt.
7. Stoppage of increment DIGP DIGP Comdt. Comdt.
8.. Removal from any office of distinction or special emolument in the Force DIGP DIGP Comdt. Comdt. May be inflicted without a formal departmental enquiry
9. Censure Comdt. Comdt. Asstt.
Comdt.
or Coy Comdr.
A.
Comdt.
or Coy Comdr.
10. Confinement to quarter Guard for not more than seven days with or without punishment or extra guard fatigue or other duty - - - Comdt.
11. Confinement to quarters lines, camp, punishment, drill, fatigue duties, etc., for a term not exceeding one month - - - Comdt.
Note— 1. When the post of Deputy Inspector General remains unfilled for a period of over one month at a time the Commandant shall exercise the powers of punishing the Subedars (Inspectors) and Sub- Inspectors except the powers of ordering dismissal or removal from the Force. [2024] 6 S.C.R. 439Union of India & O r s . v . Santosh K u m a r T i w a r i termination of service, it is nothing but a species of removal, which is permissible under the CRPF Rules. Therefore, once an enquiry is held, charge of gross indiscipline is found proved, bearing in mind that the original petitioner was a member of a disciplined force, the punishment awarded, being one of the punishments imposable, was not liable to be interfered with by the High Court.
10. In support of her submissions, Ms. Bhati relied on two decisions of this Court, namely, (a) Union of India & Ors. v. Ghulam Mohd. Bhat9; and (b) Union of India & Ors. v. Diler Singh10.
Submissions on behalf of the respondent
11. Mr. Anand Shankar, learned counsel for the respondent, defending the impugned order submitted:
(i) Punishment of compulsory retirement as specified in Rule 27 of the CRPF Rules is ultra vires the provisions of Section 11 of the CRPF Act, which is exhaustive, and no punishment beyond what is specified therein can be imposed;
(ii) Decision of this Court in Ghulam Mohd. Bhat (supra) is of no help to the appellants as it relates to the punishment of removal from service and not compulsory retirement from service;
(iii) Rule 27 was framed in exercise of power delegated to the Central Government under clause (d) of sub-section (2) of Section 18 of the CRPF Act, which is only to regulate the award of minor punishment not to introduce any other species / kind of punishment. Therefore, a punishment which is not contemplated under the statute cannot be introduced by way of a rule, particularly in absence of specific delegation of power in this regard. Dismissal and compulsory retirement are two different kinds of punishment and cannot be treated as interchangeable. Thus, in absence of any delegation of power Note— 2. When the post of Commandant remains unfilled for a period of over one month at a time consequent on the incumbent proceeding on leave or otherwise, the Assistant Commandant shall exercise the powers of punishment vested in the Commandant, except the powers of ordering dismissal or removal from the Force.
9 [2005] Supp. 4 SCR 367 : (2005) 13 SCC 228
10 (2016) 13 SCC 71
440 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports to frame rules introducing a new punishment, Rule 27, to the extent it introduces the punishment of compulsory retirement, is ultra vires the CRPF Act;
(iv) The charge levelled on the original petitioner was not established, as no eye-witness was presented to prove it. Otherwise also, Hawaldar M. Devnath, who was allegedly assaulted by the original petitioner, was inimical to the original petitioner and made a false complaint. The Disciplinary Authority and the Appellate Authority acted in a mechanical manner.
12. In support of his submissions, Mr. Anand Shankar relied on a decision of this Court in General Officer Commanding-in-Chief & Anr. v. Subash Chandra Yadav & Anr11 .
Issues
13. Having taken note of the rival submissions, the issues that arise for our consideration in this appeal are as follows:
(i) Whether the punishment of compulsory retirement from service could have been imposed upon the respondent by relying upon the provisions of Rule 27 of the CRPF Rules?
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.