Alauddin & Ors. v. The State of Assam & Anr.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 376; [2024] 6 S.C.R. 20
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Ujjal Bhuyan
- Decided
- 3 May 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1637/2021
- Sections
- 145, 161, 164, 162, 141, 149, 302, 34, 32, 27, 155
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
* Author [2024] 6 S.C.R. 20 : 2024 INSC 376 Alauddin & Ors.
v.
The State of Assam & Anr.
(Criminal Appeal No. 1637 of 2021)
03 May 2024 [Abhay S. Oka* and Ujjal Bhuyan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Matter pertains to correctness of the order convicting the appellants for the offences punishable u/ss. 302/149 IPC when the statements in evidence full of omissions and contradictions and the evidence of last seen theory and motive not established.
Headnotes Penal Code, 1860 – ss. 302/149 – Murder and unlawful assembly – Conviction of the appellants for the offences punishable u/ ss. 302/149 for committing murder of the victim by the courts below – Correctness – Plea that statements in evidence of prosecution witness full of omissions and contradictions, and evidence of last seen theory and motive not established: Held: Trial court did not follow the correct procedure while recording the contradictions – Material omissions in the testimony of one of the prosecution witness affected the reliability of the witness – Material part of the testimony of the other prosecution witnesses was a significant omission which amounted to contradiction – No reliable evidence to show the involvement of the appellants in assaulting the deceased – Testimony of so-called eyewitnesses could not be relied upon – Theory of last seen together is helpful to the prosecution if the deceased was seen in the company of the accused in the proximity of the time at which the dead body is found – Evidence shows that after the deceased was seen in the company of the accused, he was in the company of others as well – Theory of last seen together not of any assistance to the prosecution since the involvement of other persons in the offence not ruled out – Theory of last seen together is rejected – Thus, the prosecution failed to bring home the charge against the appellants – Impugned judgments by the courts below set aside – Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – ss.161, 162 – Evidence Act, 1872 – s.145. [Paras 5, 12-18] [2024] 6 S.C.R. 21Alauddin & Ors. v. The State of Assam & Anr. Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – ss. 161, 162, 164 – Evidence Act, 1872 – s. 145 – Statements to police, use of, in evidence – Omission, when amounts to contradiction – Reliability of such statements:
Held: When witness makes a statement in his evidence before the Court which is inconsistent with what he has stated in his statement recorded by the Police, there is a contradiction – When a prosecution witness whose statement u/s.161 (1) or s.164 has been recorded states factual aspects before the Court which he has not stated in his prior statement recorded u/s.161 (1) or s.164, there is an omission – There would be an omission if the witness has omitted to state a fact in his statement recorded by the Police, which he states before the Court in his evidence – Explanation to s. 162 indicates that an omission may amount to a contradiction when it is significant and relevant – Thus, every omission is not a contradiction – It becomes a contradiction provided it satisfies the test laid down in the explanation u/s. 162 – When an omission becomes a contradiction, the procedure provided in the proviso to sub-Section (1) of s.162 must be followed for contradicting witnesses in the cross examination – As per proviso to sub-Section (1) of s.162, the witness has to be contradicted in the manner provided u/s. 145 of the Evidence Act – Object of this requirement of confronting the witness by showing him the relevant part of his prior statement is to give the witness a chance to explain the contradiction – This is a rule of fairness – Furthermore, every contradiction or omission is not a ground to discredit the witness or to disbelieve his/her testimony – Minor or trifle omission or contradiction not sufficient to disbelieve the witness’s version – Only when there is a material contradiction or omission can the Court disbelieve the witness’s version either fully or partially – Material contradiction or omission depends upon the facts of each case – Whether an omission is a contradiction also depends on the facts of each individual case. [Paras 7-9] Penal Code, 1860 – ss. 141, 149 – Unlawful assembly – When: Held: s. 141 defines unlawful assembly as an assembly of five or more persons – U/s. 149, every member of an unlawful assembly is guilty of the offences committed in the prosecution of the common object of the unlawful assembly – Thus, to apply s. 149, there has to be an unlawful assembly – On facts, five appellants 22 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports were convicted for the offence punishable u/s. 302 with the aid of s. 149 and ultimately, the High Court held that only four accused were guilty – High Court did not hold that apart from the present appellants whose conviction was confirmed, others formed part of the unlawful assembly – Hence, there was no unlawful assembly within the meaning of s.141 – Appellants could not have been convicted for the offence punishable u/s. 302 with the aid of s.
149. [Para 4] Case Law Cited Tahsildar Singh & Anr. v. State of U.P. [1959] Supp. 2 SCR 875 – relied on.
List of Acts Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Evidence Act, 1872; Penal Code, 1860.
List of Keywords Evidence; Omissions and contradictions; Last seen theory and motive; Material omissions; Reliability of the witness; Offence of murder; Statements to the police; Unlawful assembly; ss. 161, 162, 164 of CrPC; s. 145 of the Evidence Act; ss. 141 and
149 IPC.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.1637 of 2021 From the Judgment and Order dated 13.09.2021 of the Gauhati High Court in CRLA No. 205 of 2019 Appearances for Parties Siddhartha Dave, Sr. Adv., Farrukh Rasheed, Ms. Jamtiben Ao, Md. Ekhlakh Alam, Seraj Ahmad, Ms. Reshma Bai Bhukya, Mahesh Kumar, Advs. for the Appellants.
Nalin Kohli, Sr. A.A.G., Anshul Malik, Sarthak Sharma, Shuvodeep Roy, Pravir Choudhary, Ms. Malini Poduval, Ms. Babita Sant, Ms. Niharika Dwivedi, Vaibhav Tiwari, Reepak Kansal, Surender Tyagi, Mrs. Annwesha Deb, Mrs. Sneha Rani, Prince Arora, Pankaj Kumar Sharma, Advs. for the Respondents.
[2024] 6 S.C.R. 23Alauddin & Ors. v . T h e State o f A s s a m & A n r . Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Abhay S. Oka, J.
FACTUAL ASPECT
1. The appellants are accused nos. 3, 1, 6 and 7 respectively. The appellants have been convicted for the offences punishable under Section 302, read with Section 149 of the Indian Penal Code (for short, ‘IPC’). The allegation against the appellants is of committing culpable homicide amounting to the murder of one Sahabuddin Choudhury. The incident is of 3rd February 2013. There were eight accused who were tried for the offence. Out of the eight accused, the Trial Court convicted five. One died during the pendency of the trial. An appeal against conviction was preferred before the High Court. By the impugned judgment, the High Court confirmed the appellants’ conviction. However, the High Court set aside the conviction of accused no. 5. The case of the prosecution is that accused no. 1 (Md. Abdul Kadir) picked up the victim of the offence from his residence at 4 pm on the date of the incident and took him to Bhojkhowa Chapori Bazar. The accused killed the victim behind L.P. School by assaulting him with a sharp weapon.
SUBMISSIONS
2. Learned senior counsel appearing for the appellants has taken us through the notes of evidence of the material prosecution witnesses. He pointed out that in paragraph 42 of its judgment, the Trial Court held that the claim of PW-1 (Md. Akhtar Hussain Choudhury) that he was an eyewitness was fallacious. He pointed out that even evidence of PW-3 (Md. Afazuddin Chaudhury) needs to be discarded, as his evidence is full of omissions and contradictions. Moreover, he cannot be termed an eyewitness. As far as evidence of PW-4 (Md. Saidur Ali) is concerned, he again submitted that the evidence is not worthy of acceptance, as it is wholly unreliable. He pointed out that evidence of PW-6 (Mustt Hasen Banu, wife of the deceased) shows that there was a prior enmity between her husband and the accused. He pointed out that PW-6 admitted that her husband had lodged a police complaint against the accused on the allegation that the accused had dispossessed him from his land. He submitted that evidence 24 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports of last seen together in the form of testimony of PW-7 (Md. Sultan Ali) cannot be relied upon. He submitted that the same is true with evidence of PW-9 (Md. Abdul Haque). He pointed out that evidence of PW-10 (Md. Anisul Haque) does not help the prosecution at all. He also invited our attention to the evidence of PW-11 (Sri Bidyut Bikash Baruah, Investigating Officer). He submitted that while recording the cross-examination of the prosecution witnesses, the contradictions had not been properly recorded in accordance with the law.
3. Learned senior counsel appearing for the State submitted that the evidence of prosecution witnesses shows that the deceased was last seen together with the accused. He submitted that coupled with the evidence of last seen together, the motive for the commission of offence had been established. Even otherwise, there is convincing evidence against the appellants. He, therefore, submitted that no fault can be found with the view taken by the High Court.
CONSIDERATION OF SUBMISSIONS
4. There is one aspect that was not brought to the notice of this Court, which goes to the root of the matter. As can be seen from paragraph 108 of the judgment of the Trial Court, the appellants have been convicted for the offence punishable under Section 302 with the aid of Section 149 of IPC. We may note here that ultimately, the High Court held that only four accused were guilty. Under Section 149 of IPC, every member of an unlawful assembly is guilty of the offences committed in the prosecution of the common object of the unlawful assembly. Therefore, to apply Section 149 of IPC, there has to be an unlawful assembly. Section 141 of IPC defines unlawful assembly as an assembly of five or more persons. The High Court has not held that apart from the present appellants whose conviction was confirmed, others formed part of the unlawful assembly. Hence, there was no unlawful assembly within the meaning of Section 141 of IPC. Therefore, the appellants could not have been convicted for the offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC with the aid of Section 149. The High Court has not modified the charge from Section 302, read with Section 149 of IPC, to Section 302, read with Section 34 of IPC.
CONTRADICTIONS AND OMMISSIONS
5. Before we deal with the merits, something must be stated about how the trial court recorded the prosecution witnesses’ cross-examination [2024] 6 S.C.R. 25Alauddin & Ors. v. The State of Assam & Anr. in this case, especially when they were confronted with their prior statements. The Trial Court did not follow the correct procedure while recording the contradictions.
6. Under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short, ‘CrPC’), the police have the power to record statements of the witnesses during the investigation. Section 162 of CrPC deals with the use of such statements in evidence. Section 162 reads thus: “162. Statements to police not to be signed: Use of statements in evidence.—(1) No statement made by any person to a police officer in the course of an investigation under this Chapter, shall, if reduced to writing, be signed by the person making it; nor shall any such statement or any record thereof, whether in a police diary or otherwise, or any part of such statement or record, be used for any purpose, save as hereinafter provided, at any inquiry or trial in respect of any offence under investigation at the time when such statement was made:
Provided that when any witness is called for the prosecution in such inquiry or trial whose statement has been reduced into writing as aforesaid, any part of his statement, if duly proved, may be used by the accused, and with the permission of the Court, by the prosecution, to contradict such witness in the manner provided by Section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (1 of 1872); and when any part of such statement is so used, any part thereof may also be used in the re-examination of such witness, but for the purpose only of explaining any matter referred to in his cross-examination.
(2) Nothing in this section shall be deemed to apply to any statement falling within the provisions of clause (1) of Section 32 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (1 of 1872), or to affect the provisions of Section 27 of that Act.
Explanation.—An omission to state a fact or circumstance in the statement referred to in sub-section (1) may amount to contradiction if the same appears to be significant and otherwise relevant having regard to the context in which such omission occurs and whether any omission 26 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports amounts to a contradiction in the particular context shall be a question of fact.”
The basic principle incorporated in sub-Section (1) of Section 162 is that any statement made by a person to a police officer in the course of investigation, which is reduced in writing, cannot be used for any purpose except as provided in Section 162. The first exception incorporated in sub-Section (2) is of the statements covered by clause (1) of Section 32 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (for short, ‘Evidence Act’). Thus, what is provided in sub-Section (1) of Section 162 does not apply to a dying declaration. The second exception to the general rule provided in sub-Section (1) of Section 162 is that the accused can use the statement to contradict the witness in the manner provided by Section 145 of the Evidence Act. Even the prosecution can use the statement to contradict a witness in the manner provided in Section 145 of the Evidence Act with the prior permission of the Court. The prosecution normally takes recourse to this provision when its witness does not support the prosecution case. There is one important condition for using the prior statement for contradiction. The condition is that the part of the statement used for contradiction must be duly proved.
7. When the two statements cannot stand together, they become contradictory statements. When a witness makes a statement in his evidence before the Court which is inconsistent with what he has stated in his statement recorded by the Police, there is a contradiction. When a prosecution witness whose statement under Section 161 (1) or Section 164 of CrPC has been recorded states factual aspects before the Court which he has not stated in his prior statement recorded under Section 161 (1) or Section 164 of CrPC, it is said that there is an omission. There will be an omission if the witness has omitted to state a fact in his statement recorded by the Police, which he states before the Court in his evidence. The explanation to Section 162 CrPC indicates that an omission may amount to a contradiction when it is significant and relevant. Thus, every omission is not a contradiction. It becomes a contradiction provided it satisfies the test laid down in the explanation under Section 162. Therefore, when an omission becomes a contradiction, the procedure provided in the proviso to sub-Section (1) of Section 162 must be followed for contradicting witnesses in the crossexamination.
[2024] 6 S.C.R. 27Alauddin & Ors. v . T h e State o f A s s a m & A n r .
8. As stated in the proviso to sub-Section (1) of section 162, the witness has to be contradicted in the manner provided under Section 145 of the Evidence Act. Section 145 reads thus:
“145. Cross-examination as to previous statements in writing.—A witness may be cross-examined as to previous statements made by him in writing or reduced into writing, and relevant to matters in question, without such writing being shown to him, or being proved; but, if it is intended to contradict him by the writing, his attention must, before the writing can be proved, be called to those parts of it which are to be used for the purpose of contradicting him.”
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.