Navas @ Mulanavas v. State of Kerala
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 215; [2024] 3 S.C.R. 913
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice Sandeep Mehta, Justice K.V. Viswanathan
- Decided
- 18 Mar 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1215/2011
- Sections
- 302, 428, 106, 293, 293(4), 309, 449, 313, 432, 376, 366, 363
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:23 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
* Author [2024] 3 S.C.R. 913 : 2024 INSC 215 Navas @ Mulanavas v.
State of Kerala (Criminal Appeal No. 1215 of 2011)
18 March 2024 [B. R. Gavai, K.V. Viswanathan* and Sandeep Mehta, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Appellant-accused was held guilty for the offences punishable u/ ss.302, 449, 309, IPC and sentenced accordingly. For the offence punishable u/s.302, IPC, he was sentenced to death. High Court confirmed the conviction, however the sentence of death was modified and reduced to imprisonment for life with a direction that he shall not be released from prison for a period of 30 years including the period already undergone with set off u/s.428, Cr.P.C. alone. What should be the appropriate sentence and whether the High Court was justified in adopting the Swamy Shraddananda v. State of Karnataka [2008] 11 SCR 93 line of cases and whether the fixing of the quantum at 30 years without remission was the appropriate sentence, in the facts and circumstances of the case? Headnotes Sentence/Sentencing – Murder – Appropriate period of sentence to be imposed under the Swamy Shraddananda v.
State of Karnataka [2008] 11 SCR 93 principle wherein it was held that to avoid a death sentence, the courts can device a graver form of imprisonment for life beyond fourteen years – Aggravating and mitigating circumstances – Relevant factors for arriving at the number of years which the convict will have to undergo before which remission could be sought – Trial Court sentenced the accused to death for the offence punishable u/s.302, IPC – High Court confirmed the conviction, however modified the death sentence to imprisonment for 30 years without remission following the Swamy Shraddananda line of cases – Correctness:
Held: Circumstances of the present case were by themselves consistent with the sole hypothesis that the accused and the accused alone was the perpetrator of the murders – On the aggravating side, act committed by the accused was pre-planned/ 914 [2024] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports premeditated; he brutally murdered 4 unarmed and defenseless persons, one of whom was a child and the other an aged lady – By the act of the accused, three generations of single family lost their lives for no fault of theirs; nature of injuries inflicted on ‘L’ and two others highlights the brutality and cold-bloodedness of the act – On the mitigating side, the accused was quite young (28 years old) when he committed the act; the act committed was not for any gain or profit; he did not try to flee and in fact tried to commit suicide as he was overcome with emotions after the dastardly act; he had been in jail for 18 years and 4 months and the case was based on circumstantial evidence – Further, conduct report of the appellant indicated that no disciplinary actions were initiated against him in the prison and his conduct and behavior had been satisfactory so far – Judgment of the High Cout is upheld insofar as the conviction of the appellant u/ss.302, 449, 309 IPC is concerned – Sentence imposed for the offence u/ss.449, 309, IPC also not interfered with – High Court was justified on the facts of the case in following Swamy Shraddananda principle while imposing sentence for the offence u/s.302 IPC – However, the sentence u/s.302 imposed by the High Court is modified from a period of 30 years imprisonment without remission to that of a period of 25 years imprisonment without remission, including the period already undergone. [Paras 13, 58-60] Sentence/Sentencing – Murder – Remission – Commutation of death penalty to life imprisonment, however convict cannot be released on the expiry of 14 years (the normal benchmark for life imprisonment) – Aggravating and mitigating circumstances – Appropriate period of sentence to be imposed under the Swamy Shraddananda principle – Relevant factors for arriving at the number of years which the convict will have to undergo before which remission could be sought:
Held: Once the court decides that the death penalty is not to be imposed and also that the convict cannot be released on the expiry of 14 years, the guidelines set out in Swamy Shraddananda, V. Sriharan and the line of cases which applied these judgments will have to be considered and principles, if any, set out therein have to be applied – There can be no straitjacket formulae – Pegging the point up to which remission powers cannot be invoked is an exercise that has to be carefully undertaken and the discretion should be exercised on reasonable grounds – The principle in Swamy Shraddananda as affirmed in V. Sriharan was evolved as [2024] 3 S.C.R. 915Navas @ M u l a n a v a s v . State o f K e r a l a the normally accepted norm of 14 years was found to be grossly disproportionate on the lower side – At the same time, since it is a matter concerning the liberty of the individual, courts should also guard against any disproportion in the imposition, on the higher side too – A delicate balance has to be struck – 27 previously decided cases applying the Swamy Shraddananda principle, surveyed – A journey through the cases shows that the fundamental underpinning is the principle of proportionality – The aggravating and mitigating circumstances which the Court considers while deciding commutation of penalty from death to life imprisonment, have a large bearing in deciding the number of years of compulsory imprisonment without remission, too – Some of the relevant factors that the courts bear in mind for arriving at the number of years which the convict will have to undergo before which the remission powers could be invoked are number of deceased who were victims of that crime, their age and gender; the nature of injuries including sexual assault if any; the motive for which the offence was committed; whether the offence was committed when the convict was on bail in another case; the premeditated nature of the offence; the relationship between the offender and the victim; the abuse of trust if any; the criminal antecedents; and whether the convict, if released, would be a menace to the society – Some of the positive factors are age of the convict; the probability of reformation of convict; the convict not being a professional killer; the socioeconomic condition of the accused; the composition of the family of the accused and conduct expressing remorse – Additionally, the Court would be justified in considering the conduct of the convict in jail; and the period already undergone – Aforesaid factors not exhaustive but illustrative and each case would depend on the facts and circumstances therein. [Paras 26, 27, 57] Evidence Act, 1872 – s.106 – According to the prosecution, appellant had illicit intimacy with ‘L’ however, after she tried to distance herself, the appellant was seriously aggrieved – Allegedly, on the fateful night he gained access into her house by making a hole in the eastern side wall of the house and murdered ‘L’ along with three others in the house – Appellant was the only other person inside the house, no cogent explanation came from him as to what transpired at the scene of occurrence:
Held: Evidence of the prosecution witnesses and even the version of the accused establishes his presence at the scene of 916 [2024] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports occurrence – Appellant was the only other person inside the house, with the other three being dead and one ‘KA’, who was injured and unconscious and who later died in that state itself – There was no cogent and plausible explanation forthcoming from the accused as to what transpired at the scene of occurrence – This coupled with the fact that his relationship with the deceased ‘L’ was strained clearly point to his guilt – s.106 states that when any fact is especially within the knowledge of any person, the burden of proving that fact is upon him – s.106 is not intended to relieve the prosecution of its duty – However, in exceptional cases where it could be impossible or at any rate disproportionately difficult for the prosecution to establish the facts which are especially within the knowledge of the accused, the burden will be on the accused since he could prove as to what transpired in such scenario, without difficulty or inconvenience – In this case, when an offence like multiple murders is committed inside a house in secrecy, the initial burden has to be discharged by the prosecution – Once the prosecution successfully discharged the burden cast upon it, the burden did shift upon the appellant being the only other person inside the four corners of the house to offer a cogent and plausible explanation as to how the offences came to be committed but he miserably failed on that score. [Para 12 (xiv)] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.293 – Prosecution case was that there were writings on the wall and on certain objects in the southern room of the ground floor where the accused was found – Specimen of these writings was taken and referred to the handwriting expert – Handwriting Expert produced P-42 report – Appellant contended that the handwriting expert had not been examined:
Held: The submission flies in the face of s.293 – Exhibit P-42 Report was prepared by Dr. KPJ, Joint Director (Research), Forensic Science Laboratory, Thiruvananthapuram – The report was duly marked and exhibited and proved as Exhibit P-42 – The Joint Director who occupies a position above the Deputy Director and Assistant Director, is encompassed in the phrase “Director” used in s.293(4)(e) – Hence, the report Ex. P-42 is admissible even without the examination of Dr. KPJ. [Para 12 (vii)] Criminal Law – Cases falling short of the rarest of the rare category – Sentencing – Principle laid down in Swamy Shraddananda v. State of Karnataka [2008] 11 SCR 93, discussed. [2024] 3 S.C.R. 917Navas @ Mulanavas v. State of Kerala Evidence – Case based on circumstantial evidence – Principles to be kept in mind while convicting an accused – Discussed. Case Law Cited Union of India v. V. Sriharan alias Murugan and Others [2015] 14 SCR 613 : (2016) 7 SCC 1 – followed.
Ammini & Others v. State of Kerala [1997] 5 Suppl. SCR 181 : (1998) 2 SCC 301; Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra [1985] 1 SCR 88 : (1984) 4 SCC 116; Swamy Shraddananda v. State of Karnataka [2008] 11 SCR 93 : (2008) 13 SCC 767 – relied on.
Padum Kumar v. State of Uttar Pradesh [2020] 1 SCR 57 : (2020) 3 SCC 35; Bhupinder Singh v. State of Punjab [1988] 3 SCR 409 : (1988) 3 SCC 513; State of H.P. v. Mast Ram [2004] Suppl. 4 SCR 269 : (2004)
8 SCC 660; Shambhu Nath Mehra v. The State of Ajmer [1956] 1 SCR 199; Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980) 2 SCC 684; Machhi Singh v. State of Punjab [1983] 3 SCR 413 : (1983) 3 SCC 470; Haru Ghosh v. State of West Bengal [2009] 13 SCR 847 :
(2009) 15 SCC 551; Mulla & Another v. State of U.P.
[2010] 2 SCR 633 : (2010) 3 SCC 508; Ramraj v. State of Chhattisgarh [2009] 16 SCR 367 : (2010) 1 SCC 573; Ramnaresh and Others v. State of Chhattisgarh [2012] 3 SCR 630 : (2012) 4 SCC 257; Neel Kumar v. State of Haryana [2012] SCR 5 696 : (2012) 5 SCC 766; Sandeep v. State of Uttar Pradesh [2012] 5 SCR 952 : (2012) 6 SCC 107; Shankar Kisanrao Khade v.
State of Maharashtra [2013] 6 SCR 949 : (2013) 5 SCC 546; Sahib Hussain v. State of Rajasthan [2013] 2 SCR 1019 : (2013) 9 SCC 778; Gurvail Singh & Anr.
v. State of Punjab [2013] 1 SCR 783 : (2013) 2 SCC 713; Alber Oraon v. State of Jharkhand [2014] 9 SCR 330 : (2014) 12 SCC 306; Rajkumar v. State of Madhya Pradesh [2014] 3 SCR 212 : (2014) 5 SCC 353; Selvam v. State (2014) 12 SCC 274; Birju v. State of Madhya Pradesh [2014] 1 SCR 1047 : (2014) 3 SCC 421; Tattu Lodhi v. State of Madhya Pradesh [2016] 3 SCR 561 :
(2016) 9 SCC 675; Vijay Kumar v. State of Jammu & Kashmir (2019) 12 SCC 791; Parsuram v. State of 918 [2024] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Madhya Pradesh (2019) 8 SCC 382; Nand Kishore v.
State of Madhya Pradesh [2019] 1 SCR 260 : (2019) 16 SCC 278; Swapan Kumar Jha v. State of Jharkhand and Another (2019) 13 SCC 579; Raju Jagdish Paswan v.
State of Maharashtra (2019) 16 SCC 380; X v. State of Maharashtra [2019] 6 SCR 1 : (2019) 7 SCC 1; Irappa Siddappa Murgannavar v. State of Karnataka [2021] 11 SCR 51 : (2022) 2 SCC 801; Shiva Kumar v. State of Karnataka [2023] 4 SCR 669 : (2023) 9 SCC 817; Manoj and Others v. State of Madhya Pradesh [2022] 9 SCR 452 : (2023) 2 SCC 353; Madan v. State of U.P. 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1473; Sundar v. State by Inspector of Police [2023] 5 SCR 1016 : 2023 SCC OnLine SC 310; Ravinder Singh v. State Govt. of NCT of Delhi [2023] 4 SCR 480 : (2024) 2 SCC 323 – referred to.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Evidence Act, 1872; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
List of Keywords Sentence/Sentencing; Modification; Aggravating and mitigating circumstances; Remission; Remission powers; Commutation of penalty from death to life imprisonment; Principle of proportionality; Rarest of the rare category; Illicit intimacy; Handwriting expert. Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.1215 of 2011 From the Judgment and Order dated 09.02.2010 of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in CRLA No.1620 of 2007 Appearances for Parties Renjith B. Marar, Ms. Lakshmi N. Kaimal, Rajkumar Pavothil, Arun Poomulli, Vishnu Pazhanganat, Keshavraj Nair, Davesh Kumar Sharma, Ms. Ashu Jain, Jaleen Johnson, Harsh Vardhan Shah Shyam, Advs. for the Appellant.
Jayanth Muthraj, Sr. Adv., Nishe Rajen Shonker, Mrs. Anu K Joy, Alim Anvar, Abraham Mathew, Advs. for the Respondent.
[2024] 3 S.C.R. 919Navas @ M u l a n a v a s v . State o f K e r a l a Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment K.V. Viswanathan, J.
1. The present Appeal arises out of the judgment of a Division Bench of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in D.S.R. No. 4 of 2007 and Criminal Appeal No. 1620 of 2007 dated 09.02.2010. The Death Sentence Reference and the Criminal Appeal arose out of the judgment of the Court of the III Additional Sessions Judge (Adhoc), Fast Track Court No. 1, Thrissur in Sessions Case No. 491 of 2006.
2. The trial Court found the appellant (the sole accused) guilty for the offences punishable under Sections 302 and 449 IPC for having committed the murder of Latha (aged 39 years), Ramachandran (aged 45 years), Chitra (aged 11 years) and Karthiayani Amma (aged 80 years) after committing house-trespass. After committing the above said act, the accused attempted to commit suicide for which he was also found guilty under Section 309 IPC. The trial Court sentenced the accused to death for the offence punishable under Section 302 IPC. For the offence under Section 449 IPC, the accused was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for five years and to pay a fine of Rs.1,000/- and, in default, to undergo simple imprisonment for six months. The accused was also sentenced to undergo simple imprisonment for two months and to pay a fine of Rs.500/- for the offence under Section 309 IPC, and in default of the payment of fine to undergo simple imprisonment for one month.
3. When the matter went for confirmation before the High Court, the High Court, while confirming the conviction, modified the sentence. The sentence of death was modified and reduced to imprisonment for life with a further direction that the accused shall not be released from prison for a period of 30 (thirty) years including the period already undergone with set off under Section 428 Cr.P.C. alone. Aggrieved, the appellant is before us in the present appeal by way of special leave.
Brief Facts:
4. The prosecution story, in brief, is that in the household of the deceased Ramachandran, there were four people residing. Apart from Ramachandran, there was his wife Latha, their daughter Chitra 920 [2024] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports and Ramachandran’s mother Karthiayani Amma. The appellant, according to the prosecution, had, at an earlier point in time, illicit intimacy with Latha so much so that Latha even became pregnant, later leading to termination of pregnancy. It is the prosecution case that after Latha tried to distance herself, the appellant was seriously aggrieved, and they advert to an occurrence of 03.02.2005 when the appellant is supposed to have trespassed into the house where Latha lived and even tried to harm her. They rely on Ext. P-9 to Ext.P-11 complaints.
5. The macabre incident, out of which the present case arose, happened on the night intervening 03.11.2005 and 04.11.2005. It is alleged that the accused reached the house of the deceased late at night on 03.11.2005. Having reached the house, he made a hole in the eastern side wall of the house and gained access into the house. It is the prosecution case that, having gained access and being armed with 2 (two) knives and an iron rod, he caused the death of Ramachandran and Chitra with the iron rod in the upper floor room in the northern side of the house; that he caused serious injuries to Karthiayani Amma in the northern room on the ground floor (resulting in her death subsequently) and caused the death of Latha with multiple stab injuries in the hall near the stairs on the ground floor.
6. The prosecution case is that PW-1 Thankamani, the domestic help, who had seen the family hale and hearty the previous evening i.e., 03.11.2005, had come to sweep the house on the morning of 04.11.2005 at around 07:00 a.m. While sweeping the courtyard, she found that, unlike on normal days when the family would come out of the house in the morning, no one came out that day. While sweeping, she found that a hole had been dug on the eastern side wall of the house and to her horror also found that blood was dripping from a pipe adjoining the western side wall of the house. She raised an alarm resulting in the neighbours converging on the property.
7. It is PW-2 (Shyama Sundaran), a neighbour, who called the police after witnessing the commotion outside the house. PW-30 (KT Kumaran) the ASI rushed to the spot with his police party and reached at 08:25 AM. He also found a hole in the wall on the eastern side of the house and also that telephone cable was cut. He instructed PW-6 (Balan) & PW-23 (Rajan) to break open the door on the western side of the house first. PW-6 & PW-23 broke open the outer door but found that the inner door was also locked and it could not be opened. It [2024] 3 S.C.R. 921Navas @ M u l a n a v a s v . State o f K e r a l a was then decided to break open the door on the front side of the house. PW-4 (Sandeep) removed the tile portion above the porch and entered the porch. He then broke open the door using a pestle and entered the poomukham (veranda). PW-4 then broke the glass ventilator above the main door and inserted his hand to open the door latch. As they entered, they found Latha’s dead body in the passage near the stairs. The body of Ramachandran and Chitra were found dead in the upper floor room on the northern side of the house. Karthiyani Amma was found in the northern room on the ground floor unconscious. PW-6 & PW-23 took Karthiyani Amma to hospital. It was PW-32 (Ajaya Kumar), the Investigating Officer of the case, who reached the spot at 09:15 AM and saw blood droplets starting from the northern room on the ground floor to the room on the south. When he opened the door, he found the accused lying on the floor with a cut injury on his left wrist.
8. PW-30, ASI registered the suo motu FIR and PW-32, conducted the investigation. The appellant was sent up for trial. In all, the prosecution examined 32 witnesses (PWs 1-32) and proved Exhibits P1 to P45 series. Material Objects [M.Os.] 1-122 were also marked by the prosecution. The accused did not examine any defence witnesses; but proved Exhibits D1-D5. The accused also gave a statement while being examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C. At the Section 313 stage, he advanced a version to the effect that there was a pact between him and Latha to commit suicide; that he had come to the house of Latha on 03.11.2005 with the intention that both of them shall commit suicide; that Latha had kept the door open as usual and he gained entry into the house through such door; that after he entered the house, he found Latha and others were all lying dead/injured; that on account of grief, he had cut his left wrist in an attempt to commit suicide and that he was found available in the house in an unconscious state. The appellant was clearly implying that somebody else had gained access into the house and caused the death of all victims. It is then that he proceeded to commit suicide.
9. The case entirely rests on circumstantial evidence. Both the trial Court and the High Court have closely marshalled the circumstantial evidence in the case to arrive at the conclusion that the accused alone is responsible for the death of the four deceased. Additionally, it also relied on the fact that the accused having been found present in the house had offered no plausible and cogent explanation about 922 [2024] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports the sequence of events that had transpired inside, leading to the sole and irresistible conclusion that the accused has perpetrated the heinous crime.
Contentions:
10. We have heard Mr. Renjith B. Marar, learned counsel for the appellant, who advanced elaborate arguments, covering the entire spectrum by making available a chart setting out the summary of the deposition of the prosecution witnesses, the relevant exhibits marked and the argument of the defence in separate columns. He mainly contended that the case made out by the prosecution falls short of the proof needed in a case which is based entirely on circumstantial evidence. Learned counsel contended that with the available evidence it would be unsafe to sustain the conviction and pleaded for outright acquittal. The specific contentions of the learned counsel challenging certain individual circumstances have been dealt with hereinbelow while tabulating the circumstances. Alternatively, learned counsel pleaded that the sentence of 30 years without remission is excessive and prayed that the sentence may be appropriately tailored to meet the ends of justice.
11. Shri Jayanth Muth Raj, learned senior counsel, for the State vehemently rebutted the arguments of the counsel for the appellant and contended that the trial Court and the High Court have correctly arrived at the conclusion of guilt. Learned senior counsel contended that the case actually warranted death penalty but the High Court has modified it to a sentence of imprisonment for 30 years without remission for the offence under Section 302. According to the learned senior counsel, the sentence did not deserve any further modification. Discussion:
12. We have carefully considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the respective parties and have perused the material on record, including the relevant original trial Court records. The circumstances that unerringly point to the guilt of the appellant as it emerges from the deposition of the witnesses and the duly proved exhibits can be summarized as under:
(i) There was the incident on 03.02.2005 when the accused allegedly trespassed into the house and had thrown a koduval (curved sword) at deceased Latha. This highlights the friction [2024] 3 S.C.R. 923Navas @ M u l a n a v a s v . State o f K e r a l a between the accused and deceased Latha. Ext. P9 - P11 complaint of 03.02.2005 has been marked by the prosecution. It also forms an important piece of evidence to establish motive. ii) PW-3, Raman, an auto driver, deposed that on the night of 03.11.2005, the accused engaged his services to go to Orumanayur. The accused asked him to stop at a place called Muthenmavu (which is the place where the house of the deceased was situated) and he paid him Rs.70/-. We have seen the original deposition and it clearly records that it was at 10.30 PM on the night of 03.11.2005 that the accused engaged the services of PW-3 at Guruvayur auto stand to reach the area where the house of the deceased was located. Mr. Renjith B. Marar, learned counsel, has challenged the evidence of PW-3 on the ground that no test identification parade was held and the identification was for the first time at the police station. This submission need not detain the court as nothing much turns on it. The presence of the accused even otherwise, at the scene of occurrence has been spoken to by PW-1, PW- 2, PW-4, PW-6, PW-23, PW-30 and PW-32, as has been discussed hereinbelow.
iii) PW-1 Thankamani has clearly spoken about the fact that, on 03.11.2005, when she left the house after her work at 7.30 p.m. all the deceased were hale and hearty. On the morning of 04.11.2005, it was she who detected the dripping of the blood from the pipe adjoining the western wall, and a hole being made in the eastern side wall of the house.
iv) The evidence of PW-1, 2, 4, 6, 23, 30 and 32 speaks about the appellant lying in the southern room of the house and being taken to the hospital from there. PWs 1,2,4,6,23 & 30 also speak about the hole that has been made on the eastern wall of the house. The seizure of M.O. 29,30,31,32,33 & 34 items i.e., 2 (two) knives, 2 (two) knife sheaths, iron rod and bag recovered also contributes as a link in the chain.
v) On 4.11.2005, M.O. 29 & 30 (Knives found in the southern room on the ground floor where the accused was found) were seized and taken into custody under Ext. P-12 (Scene Mahazar). M.O. 33 (Iron rod) was also seized and taken from the northern room in the upper floor, vide the same Ext. P-12.
924 [2024] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports vi) Another important circumstance is the report of the Finger Print Expert (Ext.P-22). The Finger Print Expert has opined that the chance finger print on the water bottle found at the scene of the crime (marked as C-9 by the Expert) was identified as the left thumb impression of the appellant in the slip made available with the Expert for verification (marked as “S” by the expert). The Expert concluded in P-22 that since the identical ridge characteristics are present in their nature and relative possessions, the finger impressions “C9” and “S” are identical i.e. that they are the impressions of the same finger of the person. The Expert concluded that, in his opinion, that the chance print marked as C-9 and developed by him from the scene of crime on 04.11.2005 is made by the left thumb of the appellant.
vii) The prosecution case is also that there were writings on the wall and on certain objects in the southern room of the ground floor where the accused was found. The writings indicate that these were parting messages of the accused (as the High Court labels them) since he had decided to commit suicide. The writings were in the following words “Do not enter here”; “Shyaman, you are a O, you should not desire the ruppam of a woman, money will make people traitors, you are O, you should not destroy the local area”; The mirror had the writing with pen on it reading ‘Latha, I love you’ and same was underlined and below that it was written ‘Salim, I love you’ and ‘Yahio I lo” and below that ‘Shabna I lo”; The aforesaid wall had one wall clock with the label ‘Samaya Quartz’ inside. On it, it was written with marker pen ‘Latha, I love you’; On the wall, below the clock, it was written “My name is Nawas, reason for my death is Latha, so myself and Latha decided to die together.....Confirm by Navaz P.M.”; “Yahayikka knows that now I shall not be there, wherever, no harm should happen to Yahayikka. I may be an idiot”; “For Salim to know, even if I am not there, you shall always be in my eyes”. Near to that it was written “night =12 O’clock, I am at the house of Latha” in two lines. Below that it was written “6 to 7= Finishing”; “I have no role in the looting of 6 lakhs. I was present in the said vehicle. This is true” and near to that it was written “for police to know where I was for all these days, no child knows”.
[2024] 3 S.C.R. 925Navas @ M u l a n a v a s v . State o f K e r a l a Specimen of these writings was taken and referred to the handwriting expert. The Handwriting Expert produced P-42 report. PW-32, the Investigating Officer spoke about the seizure of a mirror, a samaya quartz clock and the November-December, 2005 page of Guruvayur Cooperative Urban Bank Calendar. All these items had writings on them at the scene of the crime. Twenty black and white photographs of the handwritings were taken. These were termed ‘question’ writings and marked by the Handwriting Expert in the report for his reference as Q1, Q2, Q3, Q4, Q5, Q5A, Q6, Q6A to Q6P. The Expert was also furnished with the ‘standard’ writings by Appellant marked by the Expert for his reference as S1 to S49. In Ext. P-42, the Handwriting Expert concludes that, on comparison, the ‘question’ and ‘standard’ writings are by the same person. He concluded that they agree in general writing characteristics such as skill, speed, spacing, relative size and proportionate spelling errors. The Expert opined that similarities found between the question and standard writings are significant and numerous and there did not exist any material differences. Only with regard to the signature stamp in Q6(q), the expert concluded that it was not possible to arrive at any definite conclusion regarding the authorship for want of sufficient data on that score. With regard to all others, it was concluded that the person who wrote the blue enclosed writings stamped and marked as ‘standard’ writings also wrote the red enclosed ‘question’ writings. The High Court has found that this aspect of handwriting was not even seriously challenged by the accused. Mr. Renjith B. Marar, learned counsel, contended that the handwriting expert had not been examined. In support thereof, he relies on the judgment of this Court in Padum Kumar v. State of Uttar Pradesh, (2020) 3 SCC 35. The submission flies in the face of Section 293 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Exhibit P-42 Report is prepared by Dr. K.P. Jayakumar, Joint Director (Research), Forensic Science Laboratory, Thiruvananthapuram. The report is duly marked and exhibited and proved as Exhibit P-42. The Joint Director who occupies a position above the Deputy Director and Assistant Director, is encompassed in the phrase “Director” used in Section 293(4)(e). This position is expressly settled by the judgment of this Court in Ammini & Others v. State of Kerala, (1998) 2 SCC 301. The relevant para of which is extracted hereinbelow:
“11. …..The trial court was also wrong in holding that the report given by the Forensic Science Laboratory with 926 [2024] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports respect to the contents of MO 44 was not admissible in evidence as it was signed by its Joint Director and not by the Director. On a true construction of Section 293(4) CrPC it has to be held that Joint Director is comprehended by the expression “Director”. The amendment made in clause
(e) of Section 293(4) now indicates that clearly. If the Joint Director was not comprehended within the expression Director then the legislature would have certainly named him while amending the clause and providing that Section 293 applies to the Deputy Director or Assistant Director of a Central Forensic Science Laboratory or a State Forensic Science Laboratory. A Joint Director is a higher officer than a Deputy Director or an Assistant Director and, therefore, it would be unreasonable to hold that a report signed by Joint Director is not admissible in evidence though a report signed by the Deputy Director or Assistant Director is now admissible. In our opinion the High Court was right in holding that the report made by the Joint Director was admissible in evidence and that it deserved to be relied upon.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
Hence, the report Ex. P-42 is admissible even without the examination of Dr. K. P. Jayakumar. (See also Bhupinder Singh v. State of Punjab, (1988) 3 SCC 513 & State of H.P. v. Mast Ram, (2004)
8 SCC 660)
viii) The evidence of the doctors PWs-10 & 19, who conducted the post-mortem of Latha & Chitra respectively, fixed the timing of death between 6-18 hours prior to 6.25 PM on 04.11.2005. Evidence of PW-25, Doctor who conducted post-mortem of Ramachandran stated that the death occurred 12-18 hours prior to 6:25PM. This synchronizes with the time that the accused made entry into the house.
ix) The hair strands found on the body of Chitra were found to be similar and identical to the hair of the accused. In Ext.P41(b), which is the report of Dr. R. Sreekumar, Assistant Director (Biology) in the forensic laboratory, it is opined that the hairs in Item 45 (hairs from the belly of Chitra) are human scalp hairs which are similar to the sample scalp hairs in Item 58 (a tuft [2024] 3 S.C.R. 927Navas @ Mulanavas v. State of Kerala of black hairs) which is the combed hair and cut hair of the appellant. Challenging the circumstances, Mr. Renjith B. Marar, learned counsel, contends that PW-27 Annamma John does not speak about the hair being seized and that there was no seizure memo spoken to in her 161 statement. This submission has no merit since Exhibit P-26 is the seizure mahazar of the objects collected by PW-27 on 04.11.2005, the day the sordid incident was unravelled. In the Inquest Report also PW-14 mentions about the collection of hair from the body of the deceased Chitra by PW-27.
x) It is also important to note that the 2 (two) strands of hair found on one of the knives, was found to be Latha’s as per FSL Report (Ex. P. 41(b)).
xi) The testimonies of the Doctors PWs, 10, 19, 25 and 26, clearly bring out that the injuries sustained by the deceased could be caused by means of M.O. 29, 30 and 33. This is an additional circumstance.
xii) Ext.P41(c), which is the report of the Scientific Assistant (Chemistry), FSL, Thiruvananthapuram, clearly establishes that the black coloured ink in Item 66 (the marker pen with trade brand label as Kolor Pik permanent XL marker) and 67 (1 black coloured plastic cap) is similar to the ink used in the black coloured writings in Item 63 (wooden frame) item 64 (wall clock) with trade label samay and item 65 (calendar of Guruvayur Cooperative Urban Bank). Item numbers referred to here are the ones given for reference by the Scientific Assistant in her report. The Marker pen (part of M.O. 95) was recovered from the southern room where the Appellant was found, and rightly an inference has been drawn that the writings on M.O. 43 (Wall Clock) M.O. 90 (Mirror) and M.O. 94 (2005 Calendar) are the writings of the accused by using M.O 95 (marker pen) xiii) At the site where the hole was drilled, soil/powder was available. It is found in the forensic report that the soil/powder on M.O. 34 bag (found in the room where the accused was found) and seized as per Ext.P-12 scene mahazar, was apparently similar to the soil/powder seized near the hole. Equally so, in the M.O. 71 shirt belonging to the accused, apparently similar soil/ powder was found. These are established by the FSL report 928 [2024] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports (Exh. 41(a)). Further, the nail clippings of the accused taken by PW-31 dated 14.11.2005 revealed apparently similar soil/ powder to the soil/powder found at the site of the hole as per FSL report (Exh. 41(a)). This is a circumstance relied upon by the prosecution to establish that the accused gained access through the hole that he dug. The argument of the accused that the nail clippings were taken on 14.11.2005 and no importance could be attached has rightly been rejected by the High Court saying that it is not even the case of the accused that the soil/ powder detected from the hole at the scene of occurrence was planted on his nail. Mr. Renjith B. Marar, learned counsel for the appellant contended that Exhibit P-41(a) report was not put in the Section 313 questioning in the context of the soil particles on the wall tallying with the soil particles in the nail clippings and on the shirt and the bag found in the room where the accused was present. We have called for the original record and examined the Section 313 statement and had the Malayalam version read over to us. We have also seen the translated version of Section
313. Exhibit P-41(a) was put in question no. 52 but it was in the context of item 68 cable and as to how it could be cut with the knives (item 22 and 23). To that extent, Mr. Renjith B. Marar is right that the report was not put in this context. The report was put to the accused albeit in the context of the cable and knives. However, viewed in the conspectus of the other circumstances even if this circumstance is eschewed, it will not make any difference to the ultimate conclusion. The further argument that there was no seizure memo for the nail clippings is clearly incorrect. PW-31 Dr. Hitesh Shankar has clearly deposed that he had collected the nail clippings and hair samples and the blood of the accused-appellant and after sealing and labeling them handed it over to the police constable-4628. Exhibit P-45(i) marked by PW-32 Ajay Kumar, Investigating Officer as part of the property list, mentions about the collection of nail clippings, hair sample and sodium fluoride tube. Hence, the contention that the chain of custody is not established cannot be countenanced. There is no reason to disbelieve PW-31 Dr. Hitesh Shankar and the documents in support of the same.
xiv) The evidence of the prosecution witnesses and even the version of the accused establishes his presence at the scene of [2024] 3 S.C.R. 929Navas @ M u l a n a v a s v . State o f K e r a l a occurrence. His explanation that deceased Latha would always leave the door open for him to enter and that when he entered, he found them already dead and lying on the floor wounded has been found to be false. If the appellant’s own case is that he entered the house that night, no cogent explanation has been given as to who opened the door. However, we have not gone by his version. His presence at the scene of crime is established by the evidence of PW-1, PW-2, PW-4, PW-6, PW-23, PW-30 and PW-32.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.