Ram Singh v. The State of U.P.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 128; [2024] 2 S.C.R. 668
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Ujjal Bhuyan
- Decided
- 21 Feb 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 206/2024
- Sections
- 301, 307, 302, 304, 313
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:23 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
* Author [2024] 2 S.C.R. 668 : 2024 INSC 128 Ram Singh v.
The State of U.P.
(Criminal Appeal No. 206 of 2024)
21 February 2024 [Abhay S. Oka and Ujjal Bhuyan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration As per PW-1-informant (son of the deceased), on the fateful evening when he and his brother were sitting in the open space in front of the entrance door of his house, his mother was sitting close by on a cot and some neighbours were also sitting on another cot, the appellant came along with co-accused on whose instigation he fired on PW-1 but he slipped below the cot and the bullet hit his mother who died immediately. While the co-accused was acquitted on the same set of evidence, whether the conviction of the appellant u/s.301 r/w 302, u/s.307 IPC and his sentence were justified when there was no recovery of the weapon of crime, nonexamination of ballistic expert.
Headnotes Evidence – Non-recovery of the weapon of crime – Nonobtaining of ballistic opinion and non-examination of ballistic expert – When fatal:
Held: Non-recovery of the weapon of crime by itself would not be fatal to the prosecution case – When there is such non-recovery, there would be no question of linking the empty cartridges and pellets seized during investigation with the weapon allegedly used in the crime – Obtaining of ballistic report and examination of the ballistic expert is not an inflexible rule – When there is direct eye witness account which is found to be credible, omission to obtain ballistic report and non-examination of ballistic expert may not be fatal to the prosecution case but if the evidence tendered including that of eye witnesses do not inspire confidence or suffer from glaring inconsistencies coupled with omission to examine material witnesses, the omission to seek ballistic opinion and examination of the ballistic expert may be fatal – In the present case, the evidence of the eyewitnesses suffer from serious lacunae and cannot be said to be credible – That apart, material witnesses were not examined [2024] 2 S.C.R. 669Ram Singh v . T h e State o f U .P.
– Thus, the evidence tendered on behalf of the prosecution cannot be said to be full proof so much so that non-recovery of the main material evidence i.e., weapon of offence, non-obtaining of ballistic opinion and non-examination of ballistic expert would be immaterial – Prosecution did not prove the accusation against the appellant beyond all reasonable doubt – Also, on the same set of evidence, the trial court gave the benefit of doubt to the co-accused primarily on the ground that there was a grudge between the accused and PW-1 – Appellant given benefit of doubt – Conviction and sentence set aside – Order of the trial Court and the High Court quashed. [Paras 29, 30, 33 and 34] Evidence – Same set of evidence – Conviction of one accused and acquital of the other – Impermissibility:
Held: When there is similar or identical evidence of eyewitnesses against two accused by ascribing them the same or similar role, the court cannot convict one accused and acquit the other – Any lingering doubt about the involvement of an accused in the crime he is accused of committing, must weigh on the mind of the court and in such a situation, the benefit of doubt must be given to the accused – This is more so when the co-accused is acquitted by the trial court on the same set of evidence. [Paras 32, 33] Case Law Cited Javed Shaukat Ali Qureshi Vs. State of Gujarat, [2023] 12 SCR 220 : (2023) 9 SCC 164; Munna Lal Vs. State of U.P., [2023] 3 SCR 224 : (2023) SCC Online SC 80;
Gurucharan Singh Vs. State of Punjab, [1963] 3 SCR 585 : AIR 1963 SC 340; Sukhwant Singh Vs. State of Punjab, [1995] 2 SCR 1190 : (1995) 3 SCC 367; State of Punjab Vs. Jugraj Singh, [2002] 1 SCR 998 : (2002)
3 SCC 234; Gulab Vs. State of U.P., [2021] 9 SCR 678 :
(2022) 12 SCC 677; Pritinder Singh Vs. State of Punjab, [2023] 10 SCR 1033 : (2023) 7 SCC 727 – relied on.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860.
List of Keywords Non-recovery of weapon of crime; Non-examination of ballistic expert; Ballistic opinion; Non-obtaining of ballistic opinion; 670 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Gunshot injury; Not proved beyond reasonable doubt; Glaring inconsistencies; Evidence of eyewitnesses not credible; Material witnesses; Same set of evidence; Benefit of doubt.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No. 206 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 05.02.2018 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in CRLA No. 1611 of 1983 Appearances for Parties Pradeep Kumar Mathur, Chiranjeev Johri, Chandra Nand Jha, M.K. Tiwari, Sitesh Kumar, Arvind Kumar, Advs. for the Appellant. Rana Mukherjee, Sr. Adv., Samarth Mohanty, Ankit Goel, Advs. for the Respondent.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Ujjal Bhuyan, J.
This appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 05.02.2018 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in Criminal Appeal No. 1611 of 1983, confirming the conviction and sentence imposed on the appellant by the Additional Sessions Judge, Non-metropolitan Area, Kanpur in Sessions Trial No. 297 of 1982.
2. In the sessions trial, appellant Ram Singh was convicted under Section 301 read with Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC). He was also convicted under Section 307 IPC. For the offence under Section 301/302 IPC, appellant was sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life and for the offence under Section 307 IPC, appellant was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for five years, both the sentences to run concurrently.
2.1. As noticed above, the appeal filed by the appellant before the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad (‘High Court’ for short) was dismissed. Consequently, the conviction and sentence of the appellant imposed by the Sessions Court was confirmed by the High Court.
[2024] 2 S.C.R. 671Ram Singh v. The State of U.P.
Prosecution case
3. PW-1 Shri Radhey Lal lodged a first information before the Bhognipur Police Station in the District of Kanpur (U.P.) on 19.08.1982 at midnight stating that he and his brother Desh Raj were sitting in the open space in front of the entrance door of his house during the evening hours. His mother Dulli was sitting close by on a cot. On another cot, neighbours Lala Ram i.e. PW-3 and Man Singh i.e. PW-2 were sitting. They were chatting under a glowing lantern hanging on the roof-side of his residence. According to the informant, at about 08:00 PM, appellant Ram Singh accompanied by one Lala Ram came to his residence. He stated that both of them were residents of his village. Ram Singh was holding a country made pistol in his right hand. As per version in the first information, Lala Ram had instigated Ram Singh by loudly saying that these people were creating disturbances; so kill them. Ram Singh fired on the informant but he slipped below the cot. The bullet hit the left breast of his mother Dulli who cried aloud saying that she was dead. According to the informant, they also cried. Ram Singh and Lala Ram ran away towards the north. Mother died immediately due to the gunshot wound. Informant stated that the incident was seen by his brother Desh Raj and by his neighbours Lala Ram and Man Singh in the light of the lantern. On hearing the firing, many people living nearby came. They had seen the accused running. The mother was lying dead on bed. The informant further stated that about one and a half months back, there was a scuffle betfween his son Baan Singh and the appellant Ram Singh which matter was duly reported to the local police station. Lala Ram and Ram Singh belongs to the same party. Because of this, they came to the door of his residence when on the instigation of Lala Ram, Ram Singh fired a shot due to which his mother Dulli died.
3.1. The first information as dictated by the informant, was reduced to writing by the scribe Sunder Lal, another brother of PW-1. The said first information was registered as FIR bearing No. 252/1982.
4. Police investigated the crime and on completion of the investigation submitted chargesheet charging appellant Ram Singh of having committed offence under Sections 301 and 302 of the IPC as well as under Section 307/34 IPC. On the other hand, the co-accused 672 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Lala Ram was charged of having committed offence under Section 307/34 IPC.
4.1. To prove its case, prosecution examined six witnesses. After considering the evidence and materials on record, the Sessions Court convicted the appellant under Section 301 read with Section 302 IPC and also under Section 307 IPC. However, the other accused Lala Ram was given the benefit of doubt and accordingly was acquitted.
4.2. At this stage, we may mention that there are two Lala Ram in this case. One is Lala Ram, son of Prahalad Singh who is PW-3 and the other is Lala Ram, son of Dhanna Ram Yadav who was named as accused number 2 and acquitted by the trial court.
5. As noticed above, the trial court convicted the appellant under the aforesaid provisions of IPC and sentenced him accordingly. The coaccused Lala Ram, son of Dhanna Ram Yadav, was acquitted. The appeal filed by the appellant before the High Court was dismissed. Consequently, his conviction and sentence were confirmed. Submissions
6. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that there are gross contradictions in the testimony of the prosecution witnesses. The so called eyewitnesses were no eyewitnesses at all. Rather, they were interested witnesses having previous political enmity with the appellant. It is because of such political rivalry that appellant was falsely implicated in the case.
6.1. He further submits that not only there are glaring inconsistencies in the version of the prosecution witnesses; crucial and material witnesses have not been examined. Even the country made pistol allegedly used by the appellant was not recovered. The pellets found at the site and also extricated from the body of the deceased were not sent for ballistic examination. In the absence of any ballistic report linking the pellets to the pistol allegedly used by the appellant, he could not have been convicted. Both the trial court and the High Court therefore fell in error in convicting the appellant.
6.2. Learned counsel submits that it is true that on 16.07.2018, this Court had issued notice only on the question of converting the [2024] 2 S.C.R. 673Ram Singh v. The State of U.P.
conviction from under Section 302 IPC to Section 304 IPC and also on the prayer for grant of bail, nonetheless, he had submitted before this Court on 31.10.2023 that he would argue for acquittal as well.
6.3. He further submits that the trial court had committed a fundamental error in convicting the appellant on the one hand and acquitting the co-accused Lala Ram on the other hand. Evidence against both were the same. When on the same set of evidence the co-accused was acquitted, the trial court ought to have acquitted the appellant as well. This aspect was overlooked by the High Court. In support of his submission, learned counsel has placed reliance on a decision of this Court in Javed Shaukat Ali Qureshi Vs. State of Gujarat, (2023) 9
SCC 164.
6.4. Contention of learned counsel for the appellant is that there are no materials on record to conclusively prove the guilt of the appellant. Rather, it is a case of no evidence. Therefore, appellant is entitled to be acquitted. Orders of the trial court as well as of the High Court should be set aside.
7. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent-State argues that in view of the incriminating evidence against the appellant, both the Sessions Court as well as the High Court had rightly convicted the appellant. The ocular evidence clearly points to the positive act of the appellant firing the gunshot which killed the mother of PW-1, Dulli. Considering the gruesome nature of the murder and the testimony of the prosecution witnesses, conviction of the appellant is fully justified. High Court had rightly dismissed the criminal appeal of the appellant. No case for interference is made out.
8. Submissions made by learned counsel for the parties have received the due consideration of the Court.
Evidence: appreciation and analysis
9. PW-1, who is the first informant and son of the deceased, stated in his evidence that they are the three brothers: Desh Raj, Sunder Lal and himself, he being the youngest. He lived with his mother at his village where his mother had property. In the same village, his maternal uncle used to reside. Both the accused were residents of his village and belonged to the same community. He deposed that he 674 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports had a rivalry with accused Ram Singh in connection with the election of village Pradhan. In that election, wife of the accused Ram Singh was one of the candidate. Ram Singh was also related to accused Lala Ram. PW-1 stated that he had voted for the candidate who stood against the wife of Ram Singh. In that election, Ram Singh’s wife lost and in this connection, a fight had broken out between the son of PW-1 i.e. Baan Singh and accused Ram Singh in respect of which FIR and cross FIR were lodged. The cases were going on. Accused Lala Ram was deposing as a witness in Ram Singh’s case. This incident had happened about a month and a half prior to the present incident. According to him, it was around 08:00PM in the evening when he was sitting at his door. His mother Dulli was sitting on the cot. The place was lit up by the hanging lantern which was hung on the roof. The two accused came from the north. Accused Lala Ram challenged PW-1 by saying that the latter was creating a lot of mischief and, therefore, he should be killed. Ram Singh fired from his country made pistol which he was carrying. Instead of hitting PW-1, the bullet hit his mother leading to her death. Thereafter, the two accused fled away. After this incident, PW-1 alongwith PW-2 Man Singh went to Bhognipur Police Station and on the way informed his brother Sunder Lal, the scribe, who wrote the first information which PW-1 carried to the police station.
9.1. In his cross-examination, he stated that accused Lala Ram was a witness in the case against his son. He explained that there was a pile of bricks about 3-4 steps north of the courtyard where the deceased was sitting. The deceased was sitting on the northern side of the cot whereas PW-1 and his brother Desh Raj were sitting at the other end of the cot. He added that when Ram Singh fired at him, he bent below the cot, so also his brother. He could not see as to whether PW-2 and PW-3 had bent or not. As per the version of PW-1, the first gunshot did not hit him. Second shot was not fired at him or his brother because his mother had died in the first gunshot itself. Accused Ram Singh was at a distance of three steps from his mother’s cot. On hearing their screaming, several villagers came to the place of occurrence. At this, the two accused ran away. However, he stated that he could not say as to whether any villager had seen the accused running away or not as no villager had told him.
[2024] 2 S.C.R. 675Ram Singh v. The State of U.P.
9.2. In the cross-examination, it further revealed that deceased Dulli used to live with the brother of PW-1 i.e. Desh Raj whose house was behind the house of PW-1. The other brother’s house was also nearby. On that fateful evening, though dinner had been taken, the deceased had not eaten food. As they were conversing in the courtyard, his mother was sitting quiet on the cot and did not participate. This time, he stated that he and his brother were sitting on the floor at the time of gunshot. Though he had bent down when the shot was fired, nobody got under the cot. On receiving the gunshot, the mother had collapsed on the cot. He had cried while sitting but had not hugged his mother. He had gone to his brother Sunder Lal’s hotel where the first information was written but his brother Sunder Lal did not accompany him to the police station.
9.3. He denied the suggestion that it was a false case because of personal enmity; that Desh Raj and others who were sitting on the cot with the deceased in Desh Raj’s house and that while examining a country made pistol, a bullet was fired accidentally.
10. PW-2 Man Singh stated that the deceased was sitting on a cot in the courtyard. Desh Raj and PW-1 were sitting on the floor near the cot. Accused Lala Ram had instigated accused Ram Singh by saying that PW-1 was being mischievous and that he should be killed. At this, accused Ram Singh walked 2-3 steps and fired from his country made pistol but instead of hitting PW-1, his mother was hit and she died.
10.1. In his cross-examination, PW-2 stated that the deceased was sitting on a cot while PW-1 and his brother Desh Raj were sitting on the floor on the west side of the cot. He saw the accused in the lantern light. Though Lala Ram had instigated Ram Singh, he did not get up from the cot and kept sitting. When shot was fired, Desh Raj and Radhey Lal (PW-1) stood up. He did not run to see the deceased after being shot. She was shot from a distance of 2-3 steps.
11. PW-3 Lala Ram, son of Prahalad Singh, stated that at the relevant time on the date of incident, he and Man Singh PW-2 were sitting on the same cot. Dulli was sitting on bed. Desh Raj and Radhey Lal were sitting on the floor at a distance of one and a half hems away. The two accused came from the northern side. Accused Lala 676 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Ram instigated accused Ram Singh to kill PW-1 saying that he was doing a lot of mischief. Ram Singh instantly fired from his country made pistol. The bullet did not hit Radhey Lal PW-1 but hit the left breast of his mother who was killed.
11.1. In his cross-examination, he stated that he had seen accused Ram Singh before accused Lala Ram started challenging PW-
1. He did not see what Ram Singh was carrying and did not see any country made pistol in his hand. It would be wrong to say that he had seen country made pistol in the hands of Ram Singh. Sub-Inspector of Police had not questioned him. While he was examined in court, he admitted that there were party politics between the Pradhan of the village who got elected and the accused. He also denied the suggestion that he had not seen any such incident and that no such incident had happened.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.