Thakore Umedsing Nathusing v. State of Gujarat
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 198; [2024] 2 S.C.R. 1178
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 22 Feb 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 250/2016
- Sections
- 378(1), 392, 302, 34, 25, 313, 396, 306, 27
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:23 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
* Author [2024] 2 S.C.R. 1178 : 2024 INSC 198 Thakore Umedsing Nathusing v.
State of Gujarat (Criminal Appeal No. 250 of 2016)
22 February 2024 [B.R. Gavai and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Scope of interference by High Court in an appeal challenging acquittal of the accused by the trial Court; standard of proof required to bring home charges in a case based purely on circumstantial evidence.
Headnotes Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.378(1)(b) – Appeal in case of acquittal – Interference by High Court – Scope – Prosecution’s case that the accused persons took the jeep of the victim-deceased on hire and thereafter they murdered the victim and looted the jeep – Appellants-accused were convicted and sentenced for offence punishable u/s.392, IPC however, were acquitted u/s.302 r/w s.34 and ss.396 and 397, IPC – High Court reversed the acquittal and convicted them for offences punishable u/ss.302, 396, IPC and sentenced accordingly – Correctness:
Held: No direct evidence was led to bring home the charges against the accused and the entire case of prosecution was based on circumstantial evidence – Prosecution miserably failed to lead reliable, tangible and convincing links forming a complete chain of incriminating circumstances so as to bring home the guilt of the accused for the charge of murder punishable u/s.302 – Further, while reversing the acquittal of the accused recorded by the trial Court for the charges u/s.302 r/w s.34 and ss.396, 397, the High Court did not record any such finding that the view taken by the trial Court based on appreciation of evidence was either perverse or it was not one of the permissible views favouring the acquittal of the accused – Thus, the impugned judgment falls short of the satisfaction mandatorily required to be recorded for reversing a judgment of acquittal and converting it to one of conviction – [2024] 2 S.C.R. 1179Thakore Umedsing Nathusing v . State o f G u j a r a t Judgment of the High Court is based on conjectures and surmises rather than on any substantive or reliable circumstantial evidence pointing exclusively to the guilt of the accused – Judgment of the trial Court, convicting and sentencing the accused for offence u/s.392 is also based on the same set of inadmissible and unreliable links of circumstantial evidence, and the impugned judgment of the High Court are quashed and set aside – Appellants acquitted. [Paras 22, 37, 38-41] Evidence – Circumstantial evidence – Standard of proof – Prosecution case that the accused persons had taken the jeep of the victim-deceased on hire and thereafter they murdered the victim and looted the jeep – Case of prosecution based entirely on circumstantial evidence:
Held: Prosecution relied upon the circumstantial evidence comprising of disclosures, recoveries and discoveries for bringing home the guilt of the accused – The most important recovery was allegedly of the jeep – The said recovery was attributed to A1, who was allegedly apprehended by PSI (PW-22) – He forwarded a report/communication (Exhibit-96) to the officer in-charge of the Sardarnagar Police Station wherein, the confession made by A1 implicating himself and the other accused was recorded – So called disclosure statement made by A1 (Exhibit-96) on which the prosecution banked upon and the High Court relied upon by treating it to be an incriminating circumstance against the accused persons was inadmissible, unworthy of reliance and doubtful and cannot be read in evidence against the other accused i.e. A2, A3 and A5 – Exhibit-96 being hit by s.25, Evidence Act cannot be read in evidence for any purpose whatsoever – The prosecution pinned the identity of A2, A3, and A5 as the assailants on the basis of the disclosure statement (Exhibit -96) of A1 – They were primarily convicted on the basis of the recoveries of knives and clothes – These so called incriminating articles allegedly recovered at the instance of the accused were never sent to the Serology expert for comparison of the blood groups existing thereupon with the blood group of the deceased – Evidence of the concerned police officials associated with the recoveries and their testimonies were highly doubtful – The knife which was recovered at the instance of A3 was found from a nala which is a place open and accessible to all – The knife attributed to A4 cannot be linked to him – Recoveries were highly doubtful and tainted – These 1180 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports recoveries in no manner can be treated to be incriminating in nature – Even if it is assumed that such recoveries were effected, the same did not lead to any conclusive circumstance in form of Serological report establishing the presence of the same blood group as that of the deceased and hence they do not further the cause of prosecution – Prosecution failed to lead the link evidence mandatorily required to establish the factum of safe keeping of the muddamal articles and hence, the recoveries became irrelevant. [Paras 26-28, 30, 34-36] Evidence – Confession of one co-accused against the other – Evidentiary value – Such statement not a substantive piece of evidence. [Para 36] Case Law Cited Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra, [1985] 1 SCR 88 : (1984) 4 SCC 116; H.D. Sundara and Others v. State of Karnataka, [2023] 14 SCR 47 :
(2023) 9 SCC 581; Mustkeem alias Sirajudeen v. State of Rajasthan, [2011] 9 SCR 101 : (2011) 11 SCC 724;
Haricharan Kurmi v. State of Bihar, [1964] 6 SCR 623 :
AIR 1964 SC 1184 – relied on.
List of Acts Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Evidence Act, 1872; Penal Code, 1860.
List of Keywords Appeal against acquittal; Circumstantial evidence; Disclosure statement; Confession of co-accused; Confession of an accused in custody; Recoveries doubtful; Recoveries not incriminating. Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.250 of 2016 With Criminal Appeal Nos. 218-219 of 2016 and Criminal Appeal No. 1102 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 11.12.2015 of the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad in CRLA No. 1012 of 1993 [2024] 2 S.C.R. 1181Thakore Umedsing Nathusing v . State o f G u j a r a t Appearances for Parties Rauf Rahim, Sr. Adv., Nachiketa Joshi, Mohd. Asad Khan, Ms. Sucheta Joshi, Himadri Haksar, Narayan Dev Parashar, Ali Asghar Rahim, Shekhar Kumar, Advs. for the Appellant.
Ms. Archana Pathak Dave, Sr. Adv., Ms. Swati Ghildiyal, Ms. Devyani Bhatt, Advs. for the Respondent.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
1. These appeals take exception to the common judgment dated 11 th December, 2015 passed by the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad in Criminal Appeal Nos. 949 of 1994 and 1012 of 1993.
2. The appellants being the original accused Nos. 1, 2, 3 and 5 namely Thakore Laxmansing Halsing (hereinafter being referred to as A1), Thakore Pravinsing Rajsing(hereinafter being referred to as A2), Thakore Umedsing Nathusing (hereinafter being referred to as A3), Thakore Khemsing Halsing(hereinafter being referred to as A5) alongwith original accused No.4, namely, Thakore Prabhatsing Kapursing(hereinafter being referred to as A4), were tried in Sessions Case Nos. 107 and 143 of 1990 respectively by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, District Banaskantha at Palanpur (hereinafter being referred to as ‘trial Court’). The accused appellants were convicted by the trial Court for the offence punishable under Section 392 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short ‘IPC’) and were sentenced to undergo 10 years’ rigorous imprisonment with fine of Rs. 5,000/and in default, to undergo further three months simple imprisonment. The learned trial Court acquitted accused appellants of the charges under Sections 302 read with Section 34 and Sections 396 and 397 IPC vide the judgment and final order dated 21 st August, 1993. The original accused No.4 was acquitted of all the charges.
3. Being aggrieved, the accused appellants preferred Criminal Appeal No. 1012 of 1993 against the judgment and order dated 21 st August, 1993 and craving acquittal whereas, the State preferred Criminal Appeal No. 949 of 1994 seeking to assail the acquittal of the accused appellants for the charged offences, i.e. Sections 302 read with Section 34 and Sections 396 and 397 of IPC.
1182 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Brief Case of Prosecution:-
4. One Vithalbhai Kachrabhai Barot PW-1 lodged a complaint dated 1 st March, 1990 [Exhibit-21] at Gadh Police Station, Taluka Palanpur, Gujarat alleging inter alia that his son Bharatbhai (deceased) who used to drive a Jeep bearing registration No.GJ-08-114 had been murdered and his dead body was found lying in the field of one Nizamkhan at village Dangiya on Dantiwada Road. Based on the said complaint, Criminal Case (FIR) No. 2914 of 1990 came to be registered at Gadh Police Station, Taluka Palanpur, Gujarat and the investigation was commenced.
5. In the early hours of 2 nd March, 1990, PSI J.N. Chaudhary (PW-22) of Sardarnagar Police Station saw a jeep being rapidly driven near Charannagar, Ahmedabad. The PSI tried to stop the jeep which was being driven away at a high speed and the same was stopped at some distance. Four persons alighted from the jeep and tried to run away. One of these persons was chased down and was apprehended and he divulged his name to be Laxmansing(A1).
6. It is alleged that A1, upon interrogation by the police disclosed the names of four co-accused (A2, A3, A4 and A5) and stated that they were the ones who were travelling with him in the jeep.
7. During interrogation, A1 also confessed to the murder of the owner of the jeep and also that the vehicle was looted in the course of the said transaction. He also stated that the persons who had escaped from the spot were also privy to the murder. Since the jeep bore blood stains, it was seized and A1 was taken into custody.
8. The usual investigation was conducted; panchnama was prepared; the remaining four accused were apprehended. At the instance of A2, a blood stained knife was recovered which was alleged to be the weapon of offence. This recovery was alleged to be from a nala. A3 and A4 were arrested. Blood stained clothes of A3 were recovered. A4 was arrested on 4 th April, 1990 and a knife was produced on his information by one Shobhnaben wife of Kanji Chhara. The Investigating Officer concluded that the accused persons had taken the jeep taxi of Bharatbhai (deceased) on hire and thereafter they murdered the victim and looted the jeep.
[2024] 2 S.C.R. 1183Thakore Umedsing Nathusing v. State of Gujarat
9. Two separate charge-sheets came to be filed against the accused in the Court of Judicial Magistrate Ist Class (JMFC) concerned for the offences punishable under Sections 302 read with Section 34 and Sections 396 and 397 of the IPC. The offences being exclusively triable by the Court of Sessions, both sets of charge-sheeted accused were committed to the Sessions Court, Banaskantha, at Palanpur from where the cases were made over to the Court of Additional Sessions Judge, Banaskantha at Palanpur for trial. Charges were framed against A1, A2, A3 and A4 in Sessions Case No. 107 of 1990 for the offences punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the IPC and Sections 396 and 397 of the IPC. Identical charges came to be framed against A5 in Sessions Case No. 143 of 1990. The accused pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried. Though charges were framed separately, the trial of both sets of accused was conducted jointly.
10. Twenty five (25) witnesses were examined and twenty three(23) documents were exhibited by the prosecution in order to prove its case. Upon being questioned under Section 313 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter being referred to as ‘CrPC’) and when confronted with the circumstances portrayed by the prosecution against the accused, they denied the same and claimed to be innocent.
11. After hearing the arguments advanced by the learned Public Prosecutor and the defence counsel and upon appreciating the evidence available on record, the learned trial Court, proceeded to acquit accused No. 4 in entirety. While recording acquittal of A1, A2, A3 and A5 from the charges for the offences punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 and Sections 396 and 397 of the IPC, they were held guilty and convicted for the offence punishable under Section 392 of the IPC and were sentenced to undergo 10 years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 5,000/-, in default to further undergo 3 months simple imprisonment. Being aggrieved by their conviction, the accused A1, A2, A3 and A5 preferred Criminal Appeal No. 1012 of 1993 whereas the State preferred Criminal Appeal No. 949 of 1994 for assailing acquittal of A1, A2, A3 and A5 before the Gujarat High Court.
12. The appeal preferred by the State being Criminal Appeal No. 949 of 1994 was allowed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Gujarat vide judgment dated 11th December, 2015 whereas the appeal 1184 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports preferred by the accused appellants was dismissed. The High Court reversed the acquittal of the accused and convicted them for the offences punishable under Sections 302 and 396 IPC and sentenced them to undergo life imprisonment and the fine and default sentence imposed by learned trial Court was maintained.
13. The aforesaid judgment dated 11 th December, 2015 is assailed in these appeals preferred on behalf of the accused appellants. Submissions on behalf of accused appellants:-
14. Learned counsel for the accused appellants contended that the prosecution did not prove any document whatsoever to establish that the jeep bearing registration No.GJ-08-114 was owned by or was in possession of the deceased. The incriminating articles allegedly recovered at the instance of the accused were never got examined through the Forensic Sciences Laboratories (FSL). Only the blood samples of two accused were sent to the FSL for serological examination.
15. The prosecution miserably failed to prove the fact that A1 was found present in the Jeep bearing registration No.GJ-08-114, when the same was stopped by the PSI J.N. Chaudhary (PW-22) of the Kubernagar Police Station. In this regard, attention of the Court was drawn to the communication i.e. Exhibit-96 forwarded by PSI J.N. Chaudhary (PW-22) to the officer in-charge of the Sardarnagar Police Station wherein the registration number of the jeep is not mentioned. Learned counsel urged that this omission is fatal to the prosecution case.
16. It was thus urged that there is no reliable and tangible evidence establishing guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt so as to justify conviction of the accused-appellants as directed by the Division Bench of the Gujarat High Court while reversing the findings of acquittal recorded by the trial Court.
17. It was further contended that A2, A3 and A5 have been convicted solely on the basis of the confessional statement of A1 recorded by the Police Inspector PW-22. Learned counsel submitted that the said disclosure being in the form of a confession recorded by the Police Officer, is totally inadmissible in evidence as being hit by Sections 25 and 26 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872(hereinafter being referred to as ‘Evidence Act’).
[2024] 2 S.C.R. 1185Thakore Umedsing Nathusing v. State of Gujarat
18. It was further submitted that the High Court, while reversing the acquittal of the accused as recorded by the trial Court, has not recorded any such finding that the view taken by the trial Court was perverse or two views i.e. one favouring the accused and the other favouring the prosecution were not possible from the evidence as available on record. It was contended that the findings recorded by the High Court in the impugned judgments are not based on any tangible evidence and are drawn sheerly on conjectures and surmises. They, therefore, submitted that the accused are entitled to an acquittal and the impugned judgment deserves to be set aside. Submissions on behalf of Respondent-State:-
19. Per contra, Ms. Archana Pathak Dave, learned senior counsel appearing for the respondent-State vehemently opposed the submissions advanced by the learned counsel representing the accused-appellants. She submitted that the High Court, after thorough and apropos appreciation of the substantial and convincing circumstantial evidence led by the prosecution has recorded unimpeachable findings holding the accused guilty of the offences. She thus implored the Court to dismiss the appeals and affirm the judgment of the High Court.
Discussion:-
20. We have given our thoughtful consideration to the submissions advanced at bar and thoroughly perused the impugned judgment minutely and the evidence available on record.
21. Two fundamental issues are presented for adjudication in these appeals:-
(i) The scope of interference by High Court in an appeal challenging acquittal of the accused by the trial Court;
(ii) The standard of proof required to bring home charges in a case based purely on circumstantial evidence.
22. It is not in dispute that the prosecution did not lead any direct evidence so as to bring home the charges against the accused and the entire case of prosecution is based on circumstantial evidence. 1186 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
23. The principles required to bring home the charges in a case based purely on circumstantial evidence have been crystalized by this Court in the case of Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra, (1984) 4 SCC 116. The following five golden rules were laid down in the above judgment: - “(1) the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is to be drawn must or should be and not merely “may be”, fully established.
(2) the facts so established should be consistent only with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to say, they should not be explainable on any other hypothesis except that the accused is guilty,
(3) the circumstances should be of a conclusive nature and tendency,
(4) they should exclude every possible hypothesis except the one to be proved, and
(5) there must be a chain of evidence so complete as not to leave any reasonable ground for the conclusion consistent with the innocence of the accused and must show that in all human probability the act must have been done by the accused.”
24. The principles that govern the scope of interference by the High Court in exercise of appellate jurisdiction while dealing with an appeal against acquittal under Section 378(1)(b) CrPC were reiterated by this Court recently in the case of H.D. Sundara and Others v. State of Karnataka, (2023) 9 SCC 581 as follows:
“(a) The acquittal of the accused further strengthens the presumption of innocence;
(b) The appellate Court, while hearing an appeal against acquittal, is entitled to re-appreciate the oral and documentary evidence;
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.