Darshan Singh v. State of Punjab
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 19; [2024] 1 S.C.R. 248
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, Justice Aravind Kumar
- Decided
- 4 Jan 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 163/2010
- Sections
- 302, 34, 313, 161, 106
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
* Author [2024] 1 S.C.R. 248 : 2024 INSC 19 Case Details Darshan Singh v.
State of Punjab (Criminal Appeal No. 163 of 2010)
04 January 2024 [B. R. Gavai, Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Aravind Kumar*, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the prosecution had proved beyond reasonable doubt, the entire chain of circumstances, not leaving any link missing for the appellant to escape from the clutches of law.
Headnotes Penal Code, 1860 – s. 302 rw s. 34 – Murder – Prosecution case that the appellant along with the lady with whom he had illicit relations, administered poison to the appellant’s wife, with the motive to eliminate her and caused her death – Conviction u/s.302/34 and sentenced to life imprisonment – High Court upheld the order of conviction and sentence against the appellant while acquitted the lady – Correctness: Held: There was no eye-witness to the incident – Prosecution case rested on circumstantial evidence – Presence of the appellant and the lady in the appellant’s house in the intervening night not firmly and cogently established – Several omissions and improvements in the cross examination of the prosecution witnesses – There was a strong hypothesis that the deceased had committed suicide, which explanation was led by the appellant in his statement u/s.313 CrPC and is sufficient to create doubt – Furthermore, evidence of prosecution witnesses not sufficient to prove presence of the lady at the appellant’s house, as a natural corollary, such evidence cannot be relied on to conclude that the appellant was present in the house – Also the manner in which the High Court sought to distinguish the case of the appellant from the lady is perverse – When the conviction is to be based on circumstantial evidence solely, then there should not be any snap in the chain of circumstances – Failure [2024] 1 S.C.R. 249DARSHAN SINGH v. STATE OF PUNJAB to prove a single circumstance cogently can cause a snap in the chain of circumstances and make the accused entitled to benefit of doubt – In view thereof, the concurrent findings of conviction set aside – Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – Evidence. [Paras 25, 30, 33, 36-38] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s. 161 – Examination of witnesses by the police – Failure of the prosecution witnesses to mention in their statements u/s 161 about the involvement of an accused – However, their subsequent statement before court during trial regarding involvement of that particular accused – Reliance upon:
Held: It cannot be relied upon – Prosecution cannot seek to prove a fact during trial through a witness which such witness had not stated to police during investigation – Evidence of that witness regarding the said improved fact is of no significance. [Para 26] Evidence – Circumstantial evidence – Evidentiary value: Held: Circumstances from which an inference of guilt is sought to be drawn must be cogently and firmly established – Those circumstances should be of a definite tendency unerringly pointing towards the guilt of the accused – Circumstances taken cumulatively should form a chain so complete that there is no escape from the conclusion, that within all human probability, the crime was committed by the accused and they should be incapable of explanation on any hypothesis other than that of the guilt of the accused and inconsistent with his innocence. [Para 9] Evidence – Rustic/illiterate witness – Evidentiary value: Held: Appreciation of evidence led by such a witness has to be treated differently from other kinds of witnesses – It cannot be subjected to a hyper-technical inquiry – Evidence of a rustic/ illiterate witness must not be disregarded if there were to be certain minor contradictions or inconsistencies in the deposition – Witness. [Para 27] List of Citations and Other References Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra [1985] 1 SCR 88: (1984) 4 SCC 116; Rohtash Vs. State of Haryana [2012] 6 SCR 62: (2012) 6 SCC 589; Sunil 250 [2024] 1 S.C.R.DIGITAL SUPREME COURT REPORTS Kumar Shambhu Dayal Gupta Vs. State of Maharashtra 2011 (72) ACC 699 (SC); Rudrappa Ramappa Jainpur Vs. State of Karnataka (2004) 7 SCC 422; Vimal Suresh Kamble Vs. Chaluverapinake, (2003) 3 SCC 175;
Pramila vs State of Uttar Pradesh 2021 SCC OnLine SC 711; Periasami Vs. State of Tamil Nadu [1996] 6 Suppl. SCR 757: (1996) 6 SCC 457; Bhimsingh Vs.
State of Uttarakhand (2015) 4 SCC 281 – relied on.
Jaipal V. State of Haryana [2002] 2 Suppl. SCR 714:
(2003) 1 SCC 169; Trimukh Maroti Kirkan v. State of Maharashtra [2006] 7 Suppl. SCR 156: (2006) 10 SCC 681; State of U.P. Vs. Chhoteylal [2011] 1 SCR 406:
AIR 2011 SC 697; Dimple Gupta (minor) Vs. Rajiv Gupta [2007] 11 SCR 213: AIR 2008 SC 239; Sidhartha Vashisht Vs. State of NCT of Delhi [2010] 4 SCR 103:
AIR 2010 SC 2352 – referred to.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Keywords Murder; Acquittal; Imprisonment for life; Homicide; Suicide; Motive; Benefit of doubt; Circumstantial evidence; Onus of proof; Improved fact; Minor contradictions or inconsistencies; Omissions and improvements; Seen together; Rustic/illiterate witness; Reliable witness; Chance witness; Chemical examiner’s report; Plea of alibi. Other Case Details Including Impugned Order and Appearances CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.163 of 2010.
From the Judgment and Order dated 23.07.2009 of the High Court of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh in CRLA No.593-DB of 2000. Appearances:
Abhimanyu Tewari, Ms. Eliza Bar, Siddhant Saroha, Tushar Bathija, Praveer Singh, Parth Jain, Manav Bhalla, Advs. for the Appellant. Prateek Chadha, DAG, Sreekar Aechuri, Pragya Ganjoo, Ms. Muskan Singla, Ms. Rooh-e-hina Dua, Advs. for the Respondent. [2024] 1 S.C.R. 251DARSHAN SINGH v. STATE OF PUNJAB Judgment / Order of The Supreme Court Judgment Aravind Kumar, J.
1. This appeal by special leave arises out of judgment and order dated 23.07.2009 passed in Criminal Appeal No.593-DB of 2000 by the High Court of Punjab & Haryana. The High Court has upheld the order of conviction and sentence, as against Darshan Singh (the appellant) and has allowed the appeal of Rani Kaur (Accused No. 2), thereby acquitting her of all charges. The State of Punjab has not challenged the acquittal of Rani Kaur by filing any special leave petition. It is in this background that Darshan Singh had sought special leave to appeal before us and leave came to be granted by order dated 22.01.2010.
Case of the Prosecution:
2. The facts can be summed up in brief as follows:
The deceased, Amrik Kaur was married to Darshan Singh, the appellant, some time in 1988. The marriage was arranged through Melo Kaur (PW-3), the cousin sister of the deceased. The prosecution alleges that their marital relationship was strained owing largely to the fact that Darshan Singh had developed an illicit partnership with Rani Kaur (A2). Several relatives had prevailed on the appellant to put an end to his relationship with Rani Kaur, but to no avail. The illicit relationship between Darshan Singh and Rani Kaur is said to have lasted for at least three years before the fateful day. It is the case of the prosecution that on the intervening night of 18.05.1999 and 19.05.1999, Darshan Singh and Rani Kaur, with the motive of eliminating the deceased, administered poison and intentionally caused the death of Amrik Kaur.
3. On these allegations, Darshan Singh and Rani Kaur were prosecuted for charges under Section 302 r/w Section 34 IPC. The Trial Court convicted both the accused persons for the offence under Section 302 r/w Section 34 and sentenced them to undergo imprisonment for life. 252 [2024] 1 S.C.R.DIGITAL SUPREME COURT REPORTS Findings of the Trial Court and High Court:
4. The Trial Court has concluded that it was a case of homicide and not suicide. It has found that the appellant had a strong motive to commit the murder of his wife. It further held that the appellant and Rani Kaur were present in the house on the intervening night of 18.05.1999 and 19.05.1999 and therefore, the burden lay on them to explain as to ‘how the body of Amrik Kaur who was alive on the night of 18.05.1999 turned into a corpse’ the next morning. The Court has completely disbelieved the theory of suicide sought to be advanced on behalf of appellant. It was noted that merely because there were no injuries on the body of the deceased, that by itself would not obviate the possibility of forceful administration of the poisonous substance. On the basis of the above circumstances taken together, the Trial Court held that the prosecution has proved its case beyond reasonable doubt against the appellant and Rani Kaur.
5. In appeal, the High Court has agreed with the findings of the Trial Court in so far as the appellant is concerned and has acquitted Rani Kaur by extending her the benefit of doubt. It has found that there is no other evidence except the testimony of PW3 and PW4, to prove the presence of Rani Kaur on the intervening night of 18.05.1999 and 19.05.1999 at the appellant’s house.
ARGUMENTS OF MR. ABHIMANYU TEWARI, COUNSEL
APPEARING FOR APPELLANT:
6. PW3, Melo Kaur, is not a reliable witness. The presence of the appellant, Darshan Singh, at the house on the intervening night of 18.05.1999 and 19.05.1999 is sought to be established based on her testimony. She has made several improvements in her version, and her testimony suffers from several contradictions, and therefore, it is not safe to rely on such a witnesses’ uncorroborated testimony. It would be prejudicial to the appellant to rely on only a part of her testimony and exclude the rest. If her testimony is ignored in toto, there is no other evidence to establish the key circumstance of appellant’s presence at the spot of crime. 6.1 That aluminium phosphide is rather impossible to administer in a deceitful manner owing to its pungent smell and odour. [2024] 1 S.C.R. 253DARSHAN SINGH v. STATE OF PUNJAB No injury marks have been found on the deceased, which further establishes that there could not have been any forceful administration of the poison. Therefore, it is submitted that it is nothing but a case of suicide, the driving force for which, was the confrontation with Melo Kaur. It is the appellants’ case that Amrik Kaur was having an illicit affair with Melo Kaur’s husband, Gurmel Singh PW4, and embarrassed with her sister finding out, she self-administered the poisonous substance and committed suicide. Counsel has submitted judgments to support the proposition that aluminium phosphide has a pungent smell similar to garlic.
6.2 Reliance has been placed on Jaipal V. State of Haryana – (2003) 1 SCC 169 wherein the Apex Court discussed the nature of aluminium phosphide. The relevant paragraphs have been extracted below for reference:
“16. According to Modi, symptoms and signs of poisoning by aluminium phosphide are similar to poisoning by zinc phosphide (p. 197, ibid.). The chief symptoms after the administration of zinc phosphide are a vacant look, frequent vomiting with retching, tremors and drowsiness followed by respiratory distress at death. Zinc phosphide acts as a slow poison and is decomposed by hydrochloric acid in the stomach with the liberation of phosphine which acts as a respiratory poison. Being a very fine powder zinc phosphide adheres firmly to the crypts in the mucous membrane of the stomach, and a very small quantity only in the stomach even after vomiting is sufficient to cause death by slow absorption.
17. Phosphine released from zinc phosphide (rat poison) and from aluminium phosphide, is mainly used as a fumigant to control insects and rodents in foodgrains and fields. Liberated from the metal phosphides by the action of water or acids, gaseous phosphine exerts more potent pesticidal action, for it penetrates to all areas otherwise inaccessible for pesticide application. Pathological findings from phosphine inhalation are 254 [2024] 1 S.C.R.DIGITAL SUPREME COURT REPORTS pulmonary hyperaemia and oedema. It causes both fatty degeneration and necrosis of liver (p. 174, ibid.).
18. Our attention was invited, as was done in the High Court and the trial court, to a paper entitled “Toxicology — Acute Aluminium Phosphide Poisoning in Northern India” written by Dr Mitra Basu and Prof. S.B. Siwach, Head, Department of Medicine, Postgraduate Institute of Medical Sciences, Rohtak and published in Current Medical Journal, Vol. I, No. 5, July 1995. The authenticity of this article has not been doubted by the High Court nor questioned either in the High Court or in this Court. The learned authors have noticed the aluminium phosphide having emerged as a major health problem in northern India when these cases first started coming in 1984 and hardly any literature being available earlier on this malady. In Postgraduate Institute of Medical Sciences, Rohtak about 2000 cases were reported which were all suicidal.
19. We may briefly sum up the opinion of the learned authors from their published paper. Phosphine gas (active ingredient of ALP) causes sudden cardiovascular collapse; most patients die of shock, cardiac arrhythmia, acidosis and adult respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS). Aluminium phosphide is available in the form of chalky-white tablets. When these tablets are taken out of the sealed container, they come in contact with atmospheric moisture and the chemical reaction takes place liberating Phosphine gas (PH3) which is the active ingredient of ALP. This gas is highly toxic and effectively kills all insects and thus preserves the stored grains. When these tablets are swallowed, the chemical reaction is accelerated by the presence of hydrochloric acid in the stomach and within minutes phosphine gas dissipates and spreads into the whole body. The gas is highly toxic and damages almost every organ but maximal damage is caused to heart and lungs. Sudden cardiovascular collapse is the hallmark of acute poisoning. Patients [2024] 1 S.C.R. 255DARSHAN SINGH v. STATE OF PUNJAB come with fast, thready or impalpable arterial pulses, unrecordable or low blood pressure and icy-cold skin. Somehow these patients remain conscious till the end and continue to pass urine despite unrecordable blood pressure. Vomiting is a prominent feature associated with epigastric burning sensation. The patients will be smelling foul (garlic-like) from their breath and vomitus. Many of them will die within a few hours. Those who survive for some time will show elevated jugular venous pressure, may develop tender hepatomegaly and still later adult respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS), renal shutdown and in a very few cases, toxic hepatic jaundice. The active ingredient of ALP is phosphine gas which causes extensive tissue damage. A spot clinical diagnosis is possible in majority of cases of ALP poisoning. However, ALP on account of its very pungent smell (which can drive out all inmates from the house if left open) cannot be taken accidentally.”
6.3 It was also argued that the courts below have failed to give sufficient weight to the evidence led on behalf of the defence, in particular, the testimony of DW3 and DW4.
6.4 Lastly, it was argued that Rani Kaur (A2) having been extended benefit of doubt, it was rather anomalous to exclude such benefit to A1- the appellant, when the case of the prosecution was that both of them were present at the scene of crime.
Arguments of Mr. Prateek Chaddha, learned counsel on behalf of State of Punjab:
7. Melo Kaur was an illiterate person who cannot be expected to be aware of the intricacies of law and cross examination and therefore, it was rather natural for minor inconsistencies to creep into the testimony of such a witness. The Trial Court has rightly appreciated her testimony by excluding the uncorroborated parts from the corroborated parts of her testimony. In that sense, the Trial Court has separated the chaff from the grain, as is expected to be done when it has to appreciate the evidence of a partly 256 [2024] 1 S.C.R.DIGITAL SUPREME COURT REPORTS reliable and partly unreliable witness. Moreover, the accused himself has never denied his presence at the scene of crime. In his statement recorded under Section 313 of Cr.P.C., he has admitted his presence. This, coupled with the testimony of PW3, 4 and 5, is sufficient to prove the presence of the accused at the spot of crime.
7.1 The case rests on circumstantial evidence, the prosecution has proved the circumstances from which an inference of guilt is sought to be drawn, cogently and convincingly. The circumstances relied on include -– (1) Motive; (2) Presence of the appellant at the scene of crime; (3) Cause of Death: By Poisoning (4) Opportunity to administer poison; (5) Conduct
(6) False explanation in 313 Statement.
7.2 He has further relied on the principle laid down in Trimukh Maroti Kirkan v. State of Maharashtra1 to contend that the degree of evidence needed to prove the case resting on circumstantial evidence in the given facts cannot be as high as is normally the case. In view of Section 106 of the Evidence Act, the appellant was under a burden to explain the circumstances leading to the death of the deceased. Merely remaining quiet or offering a false explanation would provide an additional link in the chain of circumstances to make it complete. Remaining quiet, or offering a false explanation would therefore provide an additional link in the chain of circumstances to make it complete. He has also sought to distinguish the cases relied on behalf of the appellant.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS:
8. We have heard the learned Counsel for the appellant and respondent and perused the materials on record.
9. There is no eye-witness to the incident. The case of the prosecution rests on circumstantial evidence. The normal approach in a case based on circumstantial evidence is that the circumstances from which an inference of guilt is sought to be drawn must be cogently
1 (2006) 10 SCC 681
[2024] 1 S.C.R. 257DARSHAN SINGH v. STATE OF PUNJAB and firmly established; that those circumstances should be of a definite tendency unerringly pointing towards the guilt of the accused; that the circumstances taken cumulatively should form a chain so complete that there is no escape from the conclusion, that within all human probability, the crime was committed by the accused and they should be incapable of explanation on any hypothesis other than that of the guilt of the accused and inconsistent with his innocence. [See Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra2 ]
10. Let us, therefore, examine whether the prosecution had proved beyond reasonable doubt, the entire chain of circumstances, not leaving any link missing for the appellant to escape from the clutches of law. The circumstances which are said to have been proved on behalf of the prosecution is as follows:
1. Motive
2. Presence at the spot
3. False explanation in 313 statement
4. Death by Poisoning – Doctor’s opinion on cause of death
5. Conduct of the Appellant
6. Opportunity to administer poison.
11. According to the case of the prosecution, the illicit relationship that existed between Darshan Singh and Rani Kaur served as the key motive for them to jointly eliminate the deceased. The fact that they were in an illicit relationship has been sufficiently proved from the testimony of PW 2, PW 3 and PW 4. This circumstance, therefore, has been cogently established.
12. The most important circumstance, among all, must be the circumstance of the appellant and Rani Kaur having been present in the appellant’s house on the intervening night of 18.05.99 and 19.05.99 and they having been seen leaving the house in the early hours of the day. For, the proof of presence has the effect of triggering into operation,
2 (1984) 4 SCC 116
258 [2024] 1 S.C.R.DIGITAL SUPREME COURT REPORTS Section 106 of the Evidence Act and the principle laid down in the case of Trimukh Maroti Kirkan v. State of Maharashtra. Even the circumstance that the appellant had the ‘opportunity’ to administer poison was strongly linked to aspect of proving the presence of the appellant and Rani Kaur in the appellants house.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.