Proposed Vaibhav Cooperative Housing Society Limited v. State of Maharashtra & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 971; [2024] 12 S.C.R. 732
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia, Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah
- Decided
- 12 Dec 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 5193/2024
- Sections
- 40
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 732 : 2024 INSC 971 Proposed Vaibhav Cooperative Housing Society Limited v.
State of Maharashtra & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 5193 of 2024)
12 December 2024 [Sudhanshu Dhulia* and Ahsanuddin Amanullah, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the allotment of the plot in favour of Medinova Regal Co-operative Housing Society (MRHS) was proper or violative of the procedure as well as eligibility criteria.
Headnotes† Allotment of land – Co-operative Housing Society – The Division Bench of the High Court has dismissed the appellant’s writ petition and declined to interfere in the allotment of land by the Respondent-State to MRHS:
Held: The entire history of how the plot came to be allotted to MRCHS shows nepotism and favouritism for a society which was not even eligible in the first place for this allotment – A perusal of the records shows that not a single member of the society, is a doctor at Tata Memorial Hospital – Leave aside a doctor, not one member is an employee of Tata Memorial Hospital which was the projection earlier and for which the plot was sought to be allotted – The composition of this society has also now completely changed from its original composition – If land is allotted under the discretionary powers of the government, then it is necessary to give reasons in writing as to why such allotment is made in favour of a particular society – Since there has to be transparency in matters of allotment of land by the government, adherence to the rules and regulations becomes important in the cases of allotment, but unfortunately, all this is completely missing in the present case where allotment was made in favour of MRCHS in total violation of the prescribed procedure – Also, MRCHS had applied for a different plot than what they were ultimately allotted – Nothing has been brought to notice of this * Author [2024] 12 S.C.R. 733Proposed Vaibhav Cooperative Housing Society Limited v. State of Maharashtra & Ors.
Court which would even remotely indicate that the plot actually allotted to MRCHS was ever sought by them – This by itself vitiates the entire allotment – Similarly, a perusal of the Letter of Intent as well as the Letter of Allotment does not disclose any reasons why MRCHS was allotted land under the discretionary quota – Non-disclosure of reasons shows that such an allotment is arbitrary – Thus, the allotment of the plot in favour of MRCHS is not proper, as it is violative of the procedure as well as eligibility criteria. [Paras 6, 7, 8, 12] Case Law Cited Angarki Coop. Housing Society Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra (1997) 9 SCC 713; S.V. Asgaonkar v. MMRDA [2018] 3 SCR 410 : (2018) 17 SCC 467 – referred to.
List of Acts Land Revenue (Disposal of Government Land) Rules, Maharashtra, 1971 read with Government Regulations dated 09.07.1999. List of Keywords Allotment of land; Co-operative Housing Society; Violation of procedure; Change of composition; Discretionary powers of Government.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 5193 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 24.02.2012 of the High Court of Bombay in WP No. 928 of 2010 Appearances for Parties Vinay Navare, Sr. Adv., Prashant Shrikant Kenjale, Harish Nirbhavane, Advs. for the Appellant.
Sanjay Kharde, Shyam Divan, Sr. Advs., Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Bharat Bagla, Sourav Singh, Aditya Krishna, Ms. Preet S. Phanse, Adarsh Dubey, Sandeep Sudhakar Deshmukh, Nishant Sharma, Patil Avi Vilas, Advs. for the Respondents.
734 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Sudhanshu Dhulia, J.
1. The appellant has filed this appeal challenging judgement dated 24.02.2012, whereby a Division Bench of the High Court of Bombay has dismissed the appellant’s writ petition and declined to interfere in the allotment of land by the Respondent-State to Medinova Regal Co-operative Housing Society (hereinafter for brevity “MRCHS” or “Respondent No. 5”)
2. MRCHS is a proposed housing society and had applied, through its Chief Promoter Dr. C.N. Shenoy, to the Chief Minister of the State of Maharashtra for allotment of a plot bearing CTS No.629 Part D, E, F at Bandra on 11.10.2000. It was mentioned in their application that the members of applicant society work in Tata Memorial Centre, a leading hospital and research institute for cancer, and these members do not own any house, despite living in Maharashtra for the last twenty years or so. Further, they had said that they have been residing at places which are at quite a distance from their workplace and thus find travelling difficult and time consuming, although as doctors they have to reach their hospital in time in order to respond to emergencies. On these grounds a request was made for allotment of land.
Three years later on 16.01.2003, the Revenue & Forest Department issued a Letter of Intent (“LoI”) in favour of MRCHS for sanction of one plot of land, out of two plots of equal area which will be created after subdividing the plot bearing C.S. No. 341 C.T.S. No. 608/1 and 608/2 at Bandra (“subject plot”). It is important to note that this plot is different from the plot for which the MRCHS had applied.
3. Around a month later, one Mr. Dilip D. Gijare informed the Collector that he has now become the Chief Promoter of MRCHS. Further, out of the 11 persons shown as members of MRCHS at the time of issuance of the Letter of Intent, 5 are ineligible and have been substituted by inclusion of 8 new persons. Thus, the composition of the proposed MRCHS changes for the first time.
Meanwhile on 29.08.2003, the present appellant also applies for allotment of the subject plot in its favour.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 735Proposed Vaibhav Cooperative Housing Society Limited v. State of Maharashtra & Ors.
Subsequently, the Joint Secy., Forest & Revenue Department prepares an Office Note dated 14.07.2004 detailing the Collector’s findings that out of the original 15 members, 2 have not submitted their details, 5 have resigned and 4 are ineligible due to income limit. Further, out of the newly included 8 members, 5 are ineligible due to income limit as well. Thus, the Joint. Secy. opined that the LoI in MRCHS’ favour should be cancelled. The Chief Minister remarked “please resubmit the file with the latest position”.
4. Thereafter, the Joint Secy. again recommended cancellation of the LoI vide Office Note dated 21.09.2004. It was noted that even the new Chief Promoter of MRCHS, Mr. Dilip D. Gijare, has submitted his resignation and of the original 11 members, who were shown as members of MRCHS at time of issuance of LoI, none are eligible for membership. Thus, it was observed that the main object of sanctioning the plot in favour of MRCHS is not getting satisfied. This is what was said:
“that out of 11 members alongwith Letter of Intent provided to [MRCHS], 5 members have given resignations and details two members have not been received. Remaining 4 members are not eligible because of income limit and out of 9 members who have been admitted fresh, 4 members from Tata Memorial Centre and 1 Private Surgeon and thus total 5 members are also not eligible as per income limit… Similarly resignation of Dr. Dilip D. Gihare, newly appointed Chief Promoter of the society has been submitted. It is being observed from the details submitted in this case by the Collector that total 5 members out of total 11 members of the list enclosed with [LoI] of Intent dated 16/1/2003 provided to [MRCHS] have given resignation and 2 members have not submitted their details… In this manner out of total 11 members whose names have been mentioned in list alongwith Letter of Intent of the Government dated 16/1/2003 provided to the society, not a single member can be considered to be eligible in the present circumstances for membership. Similarly earlier 9 members who have been recommended by the society and 9 members who have been proposed in connection with T.D.R. and names of such total 19 members have not been included in the list of Letter of Intent of Government dated 736 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 16/1/2003 provided to the society. From these details main object of the government of sanctioning plot of land under the subject to the society is not getting satisfied. Taking this fact into consideration as most of the members of Tata Memorial Centre is not being eligible for Membership, letter of Intent of the Government dated 16/1/2003 issued… for the allotment to [MRCHS] should be cancelled. However, submitted for orders.”
The Chief Minister again intervened and directed scrutiny of the second proposal by MRCHS. The composition of the proposed MRCHS has changed thrice already, yet they are afforded another opportunity by the Chief Minister.
This time, the Principal Secy. (Revenue) vide Office Note dated 17.05.2005 recommends cancellation of the LoI. He notes that after scrutiny of all 29 members, i.e., original and additional members, only 8 of them can be considered prima facie eligible while the condition of admitting 20% of MRCHS’ members from the backward classes has still not been complied with. The reason that 8 members were only prima facie eligible is because they were in the private service (not working with Tata Memorial Centre) and could be considered only after submission of their income certificate, as provided by the Competent Authority.
On 03.04.2006, the Chief Minister sent the file back with the remarks “Last opportunity be provided to the society and concerned Collector should complete the action.” This direction sounds more like a command given by the Chief Minister.
5. Once this direction was given by the Chief Minister, things started moving smoothly for MRCHS as the Joint Secy. found 13 members out of their 29 members to be eligible for granting final membership. Consequently, Letter of Allotment was issued in favour of MRCHS on 10.04.2008.
6. The entire history of how the plot came to be allotted to MRCHS shows nepotism and favouritism for a society which was not even eligible in the first place for this allotment. A perusal of the records shows that not a single member of the society, is a doctor at Tata Memorial Hospital. Leave aside a doctor, not one member is an employee of Tata Memorial Hospital which was the projection earlier [2024] 12 S.C.R. 737Proposed Vaibhav Cooperative Housing Society Limited v. State of Maharashtra & Ors.
and for which the plot was sought to be allotted. The composition of this society has also now completely changed from its original composition.
Further, the appellant has taken us through the office noting of MRCHS’ file which clearly suggests that the concerned authorities were not favourably inclined to allot the plot to MRCHS and the matter kept lingering since the year 2000, on one pretext or the other and thereafter as late as in 2006 one last opportunity was given to MRCHS and after 8 years and countless changes in the membership of the society the land was allotted to them, that too a different plot than the one they applied for!
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.