L. Muruganantham v. State of Tamil Nadu & Others
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 844; [2025] 7 S.C.R. 935
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 15 Jul 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 9487/2025
- Sections
- 2, 3, 45, 40, 3(5), 80, 61
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 935 : 2025 INSC 844 L. Muruganantham v.
State of Tamil Nadu & Others (Civil Appeal No. 9487 of 2025)
15 July 2025 [J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration (A) Whether the order of the High Court enhancing compensation to Rs.5,00,000/- for the alleged violations committed against the appellant, while dismissing the complaint against respondent no.3, and partly allowing the complaint against respondent no.2, calls for interference by this Court; and (B) Whether adequate and appropriate facilities are being made available to prisoners with disabilities during incarceration in the prisons of Tamil Nadu, in compliance with the provisions of the RPwD Act, 2016 and UNCPRD. Headnotes† Constitution of India – Arts.14 and 21 – Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 – United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, 2006 – Prisoners with disabilities – Appellant herein suffers from Becker Muscular Dystrophy, Autism Spectrum Disorder, and associated psychological conditions – An FIR was filed against him – Appellant was arrested – According to the appellant, during his incarceration, the prison authorities failed to provide him with appropriate food, medical care, and other necessary support considering his physical disability, which led to a deterioration in his health – Consequently, he lodged a complaint before the SHRC – The SHRC awarded Rs.1,00,000/- as compensation and directed initiation of disciplinary proceedings against erring police officer-respondent no.2 – The High Court enhanced the compensation to Rs.5,00,000/- and awarded costs of Rs.25,000/- to the appellant – The direction for disciplinary action against respondent no.2, was affirmed by the High Court and complaint against respondent no.3 (the prison authorities) was dismissed – Whether the order passed by the High Court require interference:
* Author 936 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Held: 1. The deficiencies in prison facilities may not be directly attributable to the respondent authorities in the present case – Accordingly, they cannot be held liable for the same – The direction issued by the High Court for initiation of departmental proceedings against respondent no.2, as well as the dismissal of the complaint against respondent no.3 (the prison authorities), appears to be well-reasoned and based on a careful appreciation of the facts and evidence on record – In contrast, no material was produced by the appellant to establish wilful negligence or deliberate omission on the part of the prison authorities to warrant a finding of human rights violation – There is no justification to disturb conclusions reached by the High Court. [Para 22]
2. While it is evident that the appellant did not receive certain medical and dietary facilities appropriate to his condition during incarceration, the records indicate that he remained in the prison hospital throughout and was provided with some special amenities recognising his disability – The absence of specific provisions, such as protein-rich food or specialised medical interventions appears to stem from institutional limitations within the prison system rather than from any deliberate neglect or malice on the part of the prison authorities – Mere non-supply of preferred or costly food items cannot ipso facto be treated as a violation of fundamental rights – Prisons are correctional institutions–not extensions of civil society’s comforts – The non-supply of non-essential or indulgent items does not amount to a constitutional or human rights violation unless it results in demonstrable harm to health or dignity – Considering the nature of the appellant’s disability (assessed at 80%), the progressive deterioration of his health during custody, the High Court was justified in enhancing the compensation from Rs.1,00,000/- to Rs.5,00,000/-. [Paras 21.1, 21.2, 21.3] Prison Reforms – Urgent need – Improvement of quality of life of inmates – Discussed.
Rights of Prisoners with disabilities – Obligation of the State: Held: The State has a constitutional and moral obligation to uphold the rights of prisoners with disabilities – This includes not only ensuring non-discriminatory treatment but also enabling their effective rehabilitation and reintegration into society – This Court emphasizes that reasonable accommodations are not optional, but integral to any humane and just carceral system – A systemic transformation is urgently required–one grounded in compassion, [2025] 7 S.C.R. 937L. Muruganantham v. State of Tamil Nadu & Others accountability, and a firm constitutional commitment to dignity and equality – The disabilities of incarcerated individuals must not become a basis for further deprivation or suffering; rather, the prison system must evolve to affirm their rights and provide the care necessary for rehabilitation. [Para 34] Constitution of India – Arts. 14 and 21 – Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 – United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, 2006 – Prisoners with disabilities – The following directions are issued for immediate and time-bound compliance:
Held: 1) All prison authorities shall promptly identify prisoners with disabilities at the time of admission – All rules, regulations, and essential information about prison life shall be provided to such prisoners in accessible and understandable formats (e.g., Braille, large print, sign language, or simplified language); 2) All prison premises shall be equipped with wheelchair-friendly spaces, accessible toilets, ramps, and sensory-safe environments to ensure universal accessibility; 3) All prisons shall designate and maintain dedicated spaces for physiotherapy, psychotherapy and other necessary therapeutic services; 4) A State-level access audit of all prisons in Tamil Nadu to be conducted by an expert committee; 5) The prison authorities shall ensure complete compliance with Sections 40 and 45 of the RPwD Act, 2016, Rule 15 of the 2017 Rules and the Harmonized Guidelines, 2021 in all prison infrastructure and services; 6) The State shall provide healthcare for prisoners with disabilities equivalent to that available in the community, including access to physiotherapy, speech therapy, psychiatric services, and assistive devices (such as wheelchairs, hearing aids, and crutches); 7) All prison medical officers shall be adequately trained and sensitized to address disabling conditions, ensuring provision of appropriate accommodations and treatment without discrimination or bias; 8) Every prisoner with a disability shall be provided a nutritious and medically appropriate diet, tailored to their specific health and dietary needs; 9) Lifesaving treatments, including regular and need-based physiotherapy and psychotherapy must be made available on-site or through linkage with government health facilities; 10) All prison staff shall undergo comprehensive training on the rights of persons with disabilities; 11) The State Prison Manual shall be reviewed and appropriately amended within six months to ensure conformity with the RPwD Act, 2016 and the UNCRPD; 12) The State shall undertake periodic consultations with civil society 938 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports organisations working in the disability sector to develop inclusive policies and identify accommodations based on real needs; 13) The State shall constitute a monitoring committee to conduct periodic inspections and submit compliance reports every three months; 14) The State shall maintain and update disaggregated data on the disability status of prisoners, including records on accessibility, reasonable accommodations, and medical requirements; 15) The Director General of Prisons shall file a comprehensive compliance report before the State Human Rights Commission within three months from the date of this judgment, detailing all steps taken in furtherance of these directions. [Para 35] Case Law Cited Shri Rama Murthy v. State of Karnataka (1997) 2 SCC 642 – relied on.
Vikash Kumar v. Union Public Service Commission [2021] 12 SCR 311; Jeeja Ghosh v. Union of India [2016] 4 SCR 638; Re: Inhuman Conditions in 1382 Prisons [2016] 1 SCR 1090; Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar [2014] 8 SCR 128 : (2008) 8 SCC 273 – referred to.
People’s Watch v. The Home Secretary, Home Department, Prison Secretariat and Others (2023) 2 MLJ 478 : CDJ 2023 MHC 025 – approved.
List of Websites http://www.oics.wa.gov.au/about-oics/independent-visitorservice/; Inspector of Custodial Services Act, 2003 available at: http://testweb.oics.wa.gov.au/wp-contempt/uploads/2013/11/ Insepctor-of-CustodialServices-Act-2003.pdf; Terms of Reference available at: https://s3-eu-west-2-amazonaws.com/ ppo-prod-storage-1g9rkhijkjmgw/uploads/2021/12/PPO-2021- Terms-of-Reference-with-cover.pdf; http://www/prisons.go.ke/ inspectionsComplainsMonitoringandevaluation.
List of Acts Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016; Constitution of India, 1950; United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, 2006; United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (Nelson Mandela Rules); Rights of Persons with Disabilities Rules, 2017; Tamil Nadu Prison Rules, 1983. [2025] 7 S.C.R. 939L. Muruganantham v. State of Tamil Nadu & Others List of Keywords Prisoners with disabilities; Article 14 of Constitution; Article 21 of Constitution; Prison Reforms; Becker Muscular Dystrophy; Autism Spectrum Disorder; Identification of prisoners with disabilities; Accessibility of prisoners with disabilities; Audit of prisons; Healthcare for prisoners with disabilities; Accommodation for prisoners with disabilities; Prison infrastructure and services; Dietary needs.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 9487 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 29.11.2022 of the High Court of Judicature at Madras in WP No. 22431 of 2021 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Respondents:
Amit Anand Tiwari, Sr. A.A.G., Sabarish Subramanian, Ms. Devyani Gupta, Vishnu Unnikrishnan, Ms. Saushriya Havelia, Ms. Tanvi Anand, Danish Saifi, Ms. M Karthiga.
Petitioner-in-person.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment R. Mahadevan, J.
Leave granted.
2. Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the final order dated 29.11.2022 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Madras1 in Writ Petition No. 22431 of 2021, the appellant has preferred the present appeal. For the sake of clarity and specificity, the operative portion of the impugned order is reproduced below:
“37. The very casual manner in which the officer replied to our query, as to whether, he had read the judgment in 1 Hereinafter referred to as “the High Court”
940 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Amesh Kumar v. State of Bihar and another shocks us. Such replies will reflect upon the entire Police force. We are constrained to point out that the compensation awarded by the State Human Rights Tribunal at Rs.1,00,000/- is wholly insufficient and we enhance to Rs.5,00,000/-. We further direct that the enhanced compensation of Rs.4,00,000/shall be borne by the State as we find that there has been several acts of commissions and omissions by the Police Department for which the 2nd respondent alone cannot be held liable. The other directions of the State Human Rights Commission relating to recovery of the penalty of Rs.1,00,000/- from the 2nd respondent and the direction to take disciplinary action against the second respondent in WP No.22431 of 2021 would stand.
38. In fine WP No.22431 of 2021 will stand partly allowed to the extent indicated above and WP. No.22527 of 2021 will stand dismissed. We also award cost of Rs.25,000/- to the petitioner payable by the State.
39. Before parting with this ease, considering the material that has been placed before us, we feel it is necessary to issue directions to the State Government to effectively implement the provisions of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016. There will be a direction to the Additional Chief Secretary to Government of Tamil Nadu, Home Department to ensure that the District wise Sensitization programmes are conducted for Police Officers including Constables regarding the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. Such programmes shall be so designed that they throw enough light on the provisions of the enactment and the intendment of the legislation. Guidelines should also be issued to the Police Officers as to how they should handle such physically disabled persons. Similar guidelines are also to be issued to the Government Doctors who come across such physically disabled persons who run into conflict with law and brought before them for medical examination. We remind the State that a statutory duty has been cast upon it by the provisions of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act 2016, to ensure that such persons live with dignity.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 941L. Muruganantham v. State of Tamil Nadu & Others … 42 We therefore direct the Director General of Police to take steps to have a periodical inspection of the CCTV Cameras in all Police Stations and ensure their functioning. In order to achieve this, the Director General of Police is required to make a District Level Officer in-charge of ensuring the functioning of CCTV cameras in certain number of Police Stations in the District and such Officers will be responsible for maintenance of the Cameras and if there is a failure on his part, he should be held accountable for such failure. This effort if taken, will go a long way in curing the malady of non-functioning CCTV Cameras. We hope that the above directions would be complied with in their letter and spirit in the interest of the Police Force itself. Consequently, the connected miscellaneous petition is closed.”
3. The appellant, who is an advocate, is a physically challenged person suffering from Becker Muscular Dystrophy, a progressively degenerative locomotive disability. He was assessed to have 70% disability in 2013, which increased to 80% in 2020. According to the appellant, he also suffers from autism and mental illness.
4. It is alleged by the appellant that due to a civil dispute, a false complaint was lodged against him and his aged mother by one Selvakumar, a henchman of the appellant’s paternal uncle, Dhandapani, and the same was registered as FIR in Crime No. 108 of 2020 for offences under Sections 294(b), 323 and 506(ii) of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 2 . Based on the said FIR, the appellant was arrested on 29.02.2020 by Respondent No. 2, who allegedly harassed and tortured him. He was thereafter, produced before the Judicial Magistrate, Udumalaipet, who remanded him to judicial custody.
5. The appellant further alleged that during his incarceration at the Central Prison, Coimbatore, Respondent No.3 failed to provide proper food, medical treatment, and care as required under the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 3 . The prison lacked infrastructure and facilities necessary for prisoners with disabilities, 2 For short, “IPC”
3 For short, “the RPwD Act, 2016”
942 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports and the officials were allegedly insensitive and ill-informed regarding the rights of persons with disabilities. The appellant was released on bail on 10.03.2020.
6. Subsequently, the appellant filed a complaint in SHRC No. 2745 of 2020 before the State Human Rights Commission 4 , seeking compensation of Rs. 50,00,000/- for the deprivation of life and liberty during incarceration. He also sought directions for the payment of Rs.2 crores to the Disability Rights Public Fund under the RPwD Act, 2016 for violations of his human, fundamental, and statutory rights, and for action against the erring officials.
7. After hearing all parties, the SHRC, by order dated 27.08.2021, disposed of the complaint filed by the appellant, with the following recommendations:
“(i) The Government of Tamil Nadu shall pay a compensation of Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees One Lakh only) to the Complainant. Thiru L. Muruganantham residing at No.1/16, Muthu Nagar, Kotapulipalayam Road, Dharapuram, Tiruppur District, within one month from the date of receipt of a copy of this Recommendation and the Government of Tamil Nadu may recover Rs.1,00,000/from the 1st Respondent. The complaint against the 2nd Respondent is dismissed.
(ii) This Commission also recommends to initiate disciplinary action against the 1st Respondent as per the Rules.
(iii) This Commission further recommends that the Government of Tamil Nadu to make all the prisons in the State accessible for persons with disabilities as per the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 and law declared by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Rajiv Raturi vs. Union of India and others on 15.12.2017 which affirmed that “Right to life under Article 21 has been held broad enough to incorporate the right to accessibility. All Government buildings providing any services to the public are to be made fully accessible by June, 2019 which has to be adhered to.”
4 For short, “the SHRC”
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 943L. Muruganantham v. State of Tamil Nadu & Others
8. Aggrieved by the aforesaid order of the SHRC, the appellant filed W.P.No.22431 of 2021 before the High Court, seeking a Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus to call for the records pertaining to SHRC Case No. 2745 of 2020 dated 27.08 2021, and to quash the same insofar as it dismissed the complaint against Respondent No.3, failed to consider the complaint against Respondent No.1, and partially allowed the complaint against Respondent No.2. The appellant also sought a direction to Respondent Nos.1 to 3 to pay compensation of Rs.50,00,000/- for the human rights violations committed against him, and for directions to Respondent No.1 to implement the RPwD Act, 2016, and the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, 2006 5 in relation to the Police and Prison Departments in Tamil Nadu.
9. Respondent No.2, on the other hand, claiming that no human rights violation was committed against the appellant, and that the SHRC had erroneously held otherwise, filed W.P.No.22527 of 2021 seeking to quash the SHRC’s order.
10. The High Court, by the common order impugned herein, partly allowed the writ petition filed by the appellant and dismissed the writ petition filed by Respondent No.2. Aggrieved by the same, the appellant has preferred the present appeal before this Court.
11. During the course of hearing, the appellant, appearing as a partyin-person, made the following submissions:
11.1. That the appellant and his aged mother were falsely implicated in a criminal case lodged at the behest of his paternal uncle through one Selvakumar. Respondent No.2, acting in collusion with the said uncle, arrested the appellant illegally and obtained remand on the basis of false and misleading representations. The ulterior motive behind this was to coerce the appellant into transferring his valuable properties to his uncle. Though a charge sheet was filed, it was ultimately quashed by the High Court.
11.2. That the appellant suffers from Becker Muscular Dystrophy, Autism Spectrum Disorder, and associated psychological conditions. During incarceration, he was denied essential 5 For short, “the UNCRPD”
944 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports support such as physiotherapy, psychotherapy, protein-rich nutrition (e.g., eggs, chicken, nuts), accessible sanitation facilities, ramps, a low sensory environment for rest, and warm water for bathing. This lack of accommodation caused further deterioration of his physical and mental health, as evidenced by undisputed medical records showing his disability progressed from 70% in 2013 to 80% in 2020.
11.3. That the appellant repeatedly informed prison and medical authorities of his health condition, yet no physiotherapy or psychotherapy was provided. Protein-rich foods were denied, and milk was supplied on only 7 out of 10 days. The prison lacked accessible toilets and ramps, including in the dispensary. Loud announcements and continuous lighting aggravated his sensory distress. The hostile environment worsened his Avoidant / Restrictive Food Intake Disorder (ARFID), a condition recognized under DSM-5, leading to further mental and physical deterioration.
11.4. That both the SHRC and the High Court concurrently found that Respondent No.2, despite being aware of the appellant’s disability, acted in a callous and inhumane manner with ulterior motives. The High Court further observed that during incarceration, the appellant was denied proper medical care, food, and basic amenities, amounting to a violation of his statutory rights. Such deprivation, according to the appellant, constitutes a human rights violation under Section 2(d) of the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993, the RPwD Act, 2016, and Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India. However, the SHRC awarded a meagre sum of Rs.1,00,000/- towards compensation, which was slightly enhanced to Rs.5,00,000/by the High Court.
11.5. That compensation has been granted only for the human rights violations committed by the police, whereas no compensation has been granted for the progressive deterioration of the appellant’s disability caused by inhumane prison conditions. Such deterioration also constitutes a grave violation of his fundamental and human rights.
11.6. That as a result of the violations suffered, the appellant now experiences sleep deprivation, chronic pain, ulceration, and [2025] 7 S.C.R. 945L. Muruganantham v. State of Tamil Nadu & Others severe psychological trauma requiring long-term medication with significant side effects. His deteriorated health has also diminished his eligibility for advanced gene therapy – costing over Rs.16 crores – which should be considered while assessing compensation.
11.7. That Prisons are ill-equipped to provide reasonable accommodations to persons with disabilities. Despite statutory mandates under Sections 39 and 47(1)(a) of the RPwD Act, 2016, no sensitization or awareness programmes have been conducted for prison staff. RTI responses reveal that prison authorities maintain no data on accessibility, accommodations, or compliance. Further, there is a failure to publish disabilityrelated statistics, as mandated by Article 31 of the UNCRPD.
11.8. That the existing Prison Manual is non-compliant with the RPwD Act, 2016, and fails to address the needs of persons with varying disabilities. In Shri Rama Murthy v. State of Karnataka6, this Court noted that the outdated Prison Act, 1894, must be thoroughly overhauled. The appellant submits that systemic disregard for disability rights has led to irreversible harm to his health and dignity, and endangers similarly placed prisoners.
11.9. The appellant further relies on the following judicial precedents:
(i) Vikash Kumar v. Union Public Service Commission 7 , where this Court held that Section 3 of the RPwD Act, 2016, is a statutory embodiment of constitutional guarantees under Articles 14, 19, and 21, and that denial of reasonable accommodation constitutes discrimination;
(ii) Jeeja Ghosh v. Union of India 8, which emphasized adopting a human rights-based approach toward persons with disabilities;
(iii) Re: Inhuman Conditions in 1382 Prisons 9 , wherein this Court reiterated that the right to life under Article 21 includes the right to live with dignity, which applies equally to prisoners.
6 (1997) 2 SCC 642
7 [2021] 12 SCR 311 8 [2016] 4 SCR 638 9 [2016] 1 SCR 1090 946 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
11.10. In light of the above facts, documentary evidence, and legal principles, the appellant prays for compensation and systemic reforms. The directions sought by the appellant are as follows:
(a) To direct the jail authorities to pay compensation for the violation of the appellant’s rights during his incarceration;
(b) To ensure provision of physiotherapy, psychotherapy, and all necessary life-saving medical treatments for prisoners with disabilities;
(c) To mandate the supply of a proper and nutritious diet to prisoners with disabilities, tailored to their individual health needs;
(d) To direct an access audit of all prisons in Tamil Nadu, in accordance with the Harmonized Guidelines and Standards for Universal Accessibility in India – 2021;
(e) To mandate full accessibility of prisons in Tamil Nadu as required under Section 45 read with Section 40 of the RPwD Act, 2016, Rule 15 of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Rules, 2017, and the above Guidelines;
(f) To ensure provision of reasonable accommodations under Section 3(5) read with Section 2(h) of the RPwD Act, 2016, and the principles laid down in Vikash Kumar (supra);
(g) To conduct sensitization and training programs for prison authorities, including medical staff, regarding the rights and needs of prisoners with disabilities, as mandated under Sections 39 and 47(1)(a) of the RPwD Act, 2016;
(h) To initiate review and amendment of the Prison Manual under Section 80 of the RPwD Act, 2016, in order to address and safeguard the rights of prisoners with disabilities;
(i) To ensure compliance with Article 31 of the UNCRPD by maintaining and disseminating disaggregating statistical data regarding accessibility and accommodations for prisoners with disabilities on official websites, thereby ensuring transparency and accountability.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 947L. Muruganantham v. State of Tamil Nadu & Others
12. Denying the submissions made by the appellant, the learned counsel for the respondents submitted as follows:
12.1. In connection with Crime No. 108/2020 registered at Dharapuram Police Station for offences under Sections 294 (b), 323 and 506(ii) IPC, the appellant was remanded by the Judicial Magistrate on 29.02.2020 and admitted to Central Prison, Coimbatore on the same day. He was released on bail on 10.03.2020. Notably, from the date of admission until his release, the appellant remained an inpatient in the Prison Hospital throughout.
12.2. Subsequent to his release, the appellant lodged a complaint before the SHRC which was registered as Case No.
2475/2020/C2. In this complaint, he alleged custodial torture by Respondent No.2 during arrest and failure on the part of Respondent No.3 (prison authorities) to provide basic facilities and adequate medical treatment, taking into account his physical disability.
12.3. Upon consideration of the matter, the SHRC awarded compensation of Rs.1,00,000/- and directed disciplinary action against the erring police officer (Respondent No.2). However, it dismissed the complaint against Respondent No.3. Aggrieved by the limited relief, the appellant filed Writ Petition No. 22431/21 before the High Court seeking enhanced compensation of Rs.50,00,000/- and action against the prison authorities.
12.4. By its order dated 29.11.2022, the High Court partly allowed the writ petition, observing that while the arrest and initial treatment of the appellant could amount to a human rights violation, there was no evidence of any violation by the jail authorities. The relevant portion of the order is extracted below: “34…It is seen from the jail records that had been produced, the petitioner was always in the jail dispensary and certain special amenities were provided to him as a physically disabled person.
Special diet which includes milk was supplied to him. Mere non provision of certain amenities which would amount to a statutory violation may not strictly amount of Human Rights violation. While arrest 948 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports and incarceration of the petitioner could be said to be a Human Rights Violation, the non-provision of certain amenities or treatment during a short period of incarceration, in our opinion, will not amount to a serious Human Rights violation.”
12.5. Nonetheless, the High Court enhanced the compensation awarded by the SHRC from Rs.1,00,000/- to Rs.5,00,000/ , of which Rs.4,00,000/- was to be paid by the State and Rs.1,00,000/- recovered from Respondent No.2. Additionally, Rs.25,000/- was awarded as costs to the appellant, payable by the State. In compliance, the Government issued G.O.(D) No.270, Home (Police-HR) Department Dated 07.03.2023, sanctioning Rs.5,25,000/- towards payment of compensation. Thus, according to the respondents, the order of the High court has already been complied with.
12.6. It is relevant to note here that the appellant was continuously housed as an inpatient in the Prison Hospital from 29.02.2020 to 10.03.2020. This, according to the respondents, indicates that the prison authorities took necessary steps to address the appellant’s specific needs, including providing a cot with a mattress, a special medical diet (milk and egg), psychiatric counselling, and assistance from medical staff and coprisoners for daily routines.
12.7. As per the medical history recorded on 01.03.2020 by the Prison Doctor, the appellant was a known case of Becker’s Muscular dystrophy since the age of 27 and had a history of psychiatric illness, for which he was on anti-depressants. However, no supporting medical records were produced by the appellant or his family members at the time of admission. Based on clinical examination, the Medical Officer recommended inpatient care, continued physiotherapy, psychiatric counselling, and a special medical diet.
12.8. In accordance with Rules 196, 197, 198(iii), and 845 of the Tamil Nadu Prison Rules, 1983, every new prisoner is examined by a Medical Officer and may be placed under quarantine or admitted to the Prison Hospital, if required. These procedures were duly followed in the appellant’s case. Furthermore, Rule 405 of the Tamil Nadu Prison Manual [2025] 7 S.C.R. 949L. Muruganantham v. State of Tamil Nadu & Others Volume II provides that the medical diet of hospitalized prisoners is under the full control of the Medical Officer. Accordingly, the appellant was provided with appropriate medical attention and dietary support during his period of incarceration.
12.9. The respondents submitted that Central and Special Prisons in Tamil Nadu are equipped with wheelchairs, disabled-friendly toilets, and trained personnel to attend to the needs of elderly, sick, and disabled inmates. All such facilities were available to the appellant. The Medical Officer recorded all relevant details in the prescribed proforma as per the guidelines issued by the National Human Rights Commission.
12.10. Ultimately, it was submitted that the prison authorities extended all possible medical care and basic amenities to the appellant, and hence, the claim of human rights violations during his incarceration is unfounded.
12.11. Therefore, the learned counsel submitted that the appeal is devoid of merit and is liable to be dismissed.
13. In reply, the appellant submitted that the prison records and the counter affidavit filed by the respondents reveal inconsistencies and false claims regarding the provision of treatment and accommodations. For instance, while certain records assert that eggs were supplied, the prison food logs indicate otherwise. Similarly, psychological counselling was only recommended, but never actually administered, contrary to the claims made by the respondents. Thus, according to the appellant, the respondents failed to comply with the provisions of the RPwD Act, 2016 and other applicable laws.
14. We have considered the submissions made by the appellant as partyin-person and the learned counsel appearing for the respondents and carefully perused the materials available on record.
15. The two broad issues that arise for our consideration are as follows: (A) Whether the order of the High Court enhancing compensation to Rs.5,00,000/- for the alleged violations committed against the appellant, while dismissing the complaint against Respondent No.3, and partly allowing the complaint against Respondent No.2, calls for interference by this Court; and 950 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports (B) Whether adequate and appropriate facilities are being made available to prisoners with disabilities during incarceration in the prisons of Tamil Nadu, in compliance with the provisions of the RPwD Act, 2016 and UNCPRD.
Order of the High Court
16. It is not in dispute that the appellant was falsely implicated in a criminal case at the behest of his paternal uncle, resulting in his illegal arrest and subsequent harassment by Respondent No.2. Though an FIR was registered and a charge sheet was filed pursuant thereto, the same was eventually quashed by the High Court. However, by that time, the appellant had already undergone incarceration from 29.02.2020 to 10.03.2020.
17. According to the appellant, during his incarceration, the prison authorities failed to provide him with appropriate food, medical care, and other necessary support considering his physical disability, which led to a deterioration in his health. Consequently, he lodged a complaint before the SHRC seeking compensation and initiation of actions against the erring officials for the alleged violations committed against him. The respondents, however, contended that the appellant was housed in the prison hospital throughout his custody, and was provided with food, treatment, and care suited to his needs, and therefore, no human rights violation could be attributable to the prison authorities.
18. Upon a detailed examination of the records, the SHRC concluded that the appellant’s arrest was in clear violation of the guidelines laid down by this Court in Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar 10. However, it held that during the period of incarceration, the appellant had been admitted to the prison hospital and was provided necessary medical treatment. Consequently, the SHRC found no specific human rights violation attributable to the prison authorities during the appellant’s custody. Accordingly, in the complaint filed by the appellant, the SHRC recommended the payment of compensation of Rs. 1,00,000/- to the appellant, to be paid by Respondent No.1 and recoverable from Respondent No.2. It also recommended initiation of departmental disciplinary proceedings against Respondent No.2.
10 (2014) 8 SCC 273
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 951L. Muruganantham v. State of Tamil Nadu & Others
19. A similar view was taken by the High Court in the writ petition filed by the appellant. However, pointing out that the compensation awarded by the SHRC was inadequate given the nature and circumstances of the case, the High Court enhanced the compensation to Rs.5,00,000/ , directing that Rs.4,00,000/- be paid by the Government. The other directions of the SHRC including the imposition of penalty of Rs.1,00,000/- on Respondent No.2 and the recommendation for disciplinary action against him, were affirmed by the High Court. Additionally, the High Court awarded costs of Rs.25,000/- to the appellant payable by the State. At this juncture, it is relevant to note that the respondents have complied with the directions of the High Court and have paid the entire amount of Rs.5,25,000/- to the appellant.
20. Both the SHRC and the High Court unequivocally held that the FIR, arrest, and incarceration of the appellant were carried out at the behest of his paternal uncle with the ulterior motive of usurping his property. The arrest was illegal and did not comply with the safeguards prescribed by this Court. Importantly, the authorities failed to consider the appellant’s disability status. These findings are supported by documentary evidence, and we find no reason to depart from them.
21. The next issue to be determined is whether the compensation of Rs.1,00,000/- awarded by the SHRC, and later enhanced to Rs.5,00,000/- by the High Court, merits further enhancement by this Court.
21.1. While it is evident that the appellant did not receive certain medical and dietary facilities appropriate to his condition during incarceration, the records indicate that he remained in the prison hospital throughout and was provided with some special amenities recognising his disability. The absence of specific provisions, such as protein-rich food or specialised medical interventions appears to stem from institutional limitations within the prison system rather than from any deliberate neglect or malice on the part of the prison authorities. Hence, these shortcomings do not amount, per se, to a violation of human rights attributable to the jail authorities.
21.2. The appellant specifically contended that he was not provided with adequate protein-rich food, such as eggs, chicken and nuts, on a daily basis. While persons with disabilities constitute 952 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports a particularly vulnerable class and are entitled to reasonable accommodations under domestic law and international conventions, the mere non-supply of preferred or costly food items cannot ipso facto be treated as a violation of fundamental rights. The right to life under Article 21 of the Constitution undoubtedly extends to all prisoners, including those with disabilities. However, this does not confer a right to demand personalised or luxurious food choices. The State’s obligation is to ensure that every inmate, including those with disabilities, receives adequate, nutritious, and medically appropriate food, subject to medical certification.
21.3. Prisons are correctional institutions – not extensions of civil society’s comforts. The non-supply of non-essential or indulgent items does not amount to a constitutional or human rights violation unless it results in demonstrable harm to health or dignity. Considering the nature of the appellant’s disability (assessed at 80%), the progressive deterioration of his health during custody, and the ongoing treatment, he requires, the High Court was justified in enhancing the compensation from Rs.1,00,000/- to Rs.5,00,000/-. We find this amount to be fair, just, and reasonable in the facts and circumstances of the case, and therefore, see no reason to interfere with the same.
22. As already indicated, the deficiencies in prison facilities may not be directly attributable to the respondent authorities in the present case. Accordingly, they cannot be held liable for the same. The direction issued by the High Court for initiation of departmental proceedings against Respondent No.2, as well as the dismissal of the complaint against Respondent No.3 (the prison authorities), appears to be well-reasoned and based on a careful appreciation of the facts and evidence on record. In contrast, no material was produced by the appellant to establish wilful negligence or deliberate omission on the part of the prison authorities to warrant a finding of human rights violation. Therefore, we find no justification to disturb these conclusions reached by the High Court.
Adequate and Appropriate facilities for prisoners with disabilities
23. Prisons are often regarded as the “tail-end” of the criminal justice system – historically designed for rigid discipline, harsh conditions, [2025] 7 S.C.R. 953L. Muruganantham v. State of Tamil Nadu & Others and minimal liberties. While modern penological principles advocate rehabilitation over retribution, the current prison infrastructure and operational systems in India remain grossly inadequate – especially when it comes to meeting the needs of prisoners with disabilities.
24. In the present case, though the deficiencies in prison facilities may not be directly attributable to the respondent authorities, they highlight the urgent need for prison reforms, particularly the implementation of disability-sensitive infrastructure and protocols. This Court is conscious of the systemic neglect in prison infrastructure, especially in relation to the needs of prisoners with disabilities. In Rama Murthy (supra), this Court referred to the Mulla Committee Report and emphasised the dire conditions in Indian prisons, including inadequate hygiene, insufficient medical care, and lack of accountability. The relevant paragraphs of the said decision are usefully extracted below: “35. The Mulla Committee has dealt with this aspect in Chapter 6 and 7 of its Report, a perusal of which shows the pathetic position in which most of the jails are placed insofar as hygienic conditions are concerned. Most of them also lack proper facilities for treatment of prisoners. The recommendations of the Committee in this regard are to be found in Chapter 29. We have nothing useful to add except pointing out that society has an obligation towards prisoners’ health for two reasons. First, the prisoners do not enjoy the access to medical expertise that free citizens have. Their incarceration places limitations on such access; no physician of choice, no second opinions, and few if any specialists. Secondly, because of the conditions of their incarceration, inmates are exposed to more health hazards than free citizens. Prisoners therefore, suffer from a double handicap.
36. In `American Prison System’ (supra) there is a discussion at pages 411-13 as to whether a prisoner can seek any relief from the Court because of neglect of medical treatment on the ground of violation of their constitutional right. Policy makers may bear this also in mind while deciding about the recommendations of the Mulla Committee Report, which they would so do within six months from today. Insubstantial food and inadequate clothing.
954 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
37. There is not much to doubt that the rules contained in concerned Jail Manual dealing with food and clothing etc. to be given to prisoners are not fully complied with always. All that can usefully he said on this aspect is the persons who are entitled to inspect jails should do so after giving shortest notice so that the reality becomes known on inspection. The system of complaint box introduced in Tihar Jail during some period needs to be adopted in other jails also. The complaint received must be fairly inquired and appropriate actions against the delinquent must be taken. On top of all, prisoners must receive full assurance that whoever would lodge a complaint would not suffer any evil consequence for lodging the same.”
Despite clear directions, no comprehensive legal framework has yet been developed to secure enforceable rights for disabled prisoners facing systemic neglect.
25. This Court expresses deep concern over the plight of incarcerated individuals with disabilities, who are among the most marginalized and vulnerable groups, within the justice system. The social and structural barriers they face in society are only magnified within the prison environment. Unlike the minimal safeguards afforded to women prisoners, there is currently no specific legal or policy framework that guarantees dignity, accessibility, and protection for persons with disabilities or for members of the transgender community in prisons. From the stage of arrest through trial and incarceration, persons with disabilities face systemic disadvantage due to the lack of training and sensitivity among police and prison personnel.
26. Most prison facilities are structurally inaccessible to individuals with mobility, sensory, or cognitive impairments. Institutional routines and infrastructure are not designed to accommodate diverse needs, making it difficult – or at times impossible – for such prisoners to use toilets, dining areas, libraries, or health clinics. Additionally, due to the absence of trained caregivers or appropriate custodial policies, persons with disabilities are often denied help with essential daily activities such as bathing, dressing, or eating. This neglect results in indignity, mental distress, and, at times, serious physical harm.
27. Such inaccessibility and denial of basic care are not mere administrative lapses; they amount to violations of fundamental rights [2025] 7 S.C.R. 955L. Muruganantham v. State of Tamil Nadu & Others enshrined under Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India. They also breach provisions of the RPwD Act, 2016 – specifically Sections 6, 25, and 38 – which mandate the State to ensure healthcare and non-discriminatory treatment for persons with disabilities, including those in custody. Furthermore, under Article 15 of the UNCRPD, to which India is a signatory, any cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment of disabled persons in detention is strictly prohibited.
28. Persons with disabilities must be provided healthcare equivalent to that available in the general community. This includes access to physiotherapy, speech therapy, psychiatric care, and assistive devices, such as wheelchairs, hearing aids, or crutches. Prison authorities are under a duty to coordinate with public healthcare systems to ensure uninterrupted care. Logistical or financial limitations cannot be cited to justify a withdrawal of this obligation.
29. International legal standards reaffirm these responsibilities. The United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (Nelson Mandela Rules) prescribe prompt, adequate healthcare and specific attention to the needs of prisoners with disabilities. Under Rule 2, the principle of non-discrimination requires prison systems to proactively accommodate the unique vulnerabilities of such individuals. Rule 5(2) mandates that reasonable accommodations must be made so that persons with disabilities have full and effective access to prison life on an equal basis with others.
30. Lawful incarceration does not suspend the right to human dignity. The punishment lies only in the restriction of liberty – not in the denial of humane treatment or reasonable accommodations. Failure to meet these obligations inflicts disproportionate suffering on disabled prisoners and betrays the constitutional role of the State as a custodian – not a tormentor – of those it detains.
31. Despite clear constitutional and statutory mandates, the lack of disaggregated data on disability continues to hinder targeted policy intervention. In response to a Parliamentary query in 2016,the Government acknowledged that it does not maintain any data regarding disabled prisoners. The National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) – despite providing detailed information on caste, gender, and religion – fails to record disability status. Its 2022 report, for instance, only references 137 pending cases under the Mental Health Act, offering no insight into the wider population of prisoners with disabilities. 956 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
32. This data gap has far-reaching implications throughout the criminal justice process. The unavailability of interpreters, accessible communication formats, or assistive technologies during investigation and trial hinders the right to a fair hearing. This results in miscommunication, delays, and the denial of justice. These systemic omissions constitute indirect discrimination and disproportionately burden persons with disabilities – entrenching their social exclusion.
33. Most State prison manuals remain outdated and uninformed by developments in disability law and rights-based discourse. They frequently conflate sensory or physical disabilities with mental illness or cognitive decline, thereby eroding the distinct legal right to reasonable accommodation. This conflation promotes harmful stereotypes and obstructs disabled inmates from claiming their lawful entitlements.
33.1. At this juncture, we also note with approval the judgment in People’s Watch v. The Home Secretary, Home Department, Prison Secretariat and others11 which incidentally also arose from the Madras High Court. The said judgment elaborates on the urgent need for prison reforms and outlines concrete modalities for improving the quality of life of inmates. The following paragraphs from the judgment are extracted hereunder for reference. The directives issued therein are hereby re-emphasized, as their effective implementation would significantly advance the objective of comprehensive prison reforms, aligned with the constitutional vision of a welfare state that is attentive to the principles of inclusivity, equality, and non-discrimination.
“15. The Model Prison Manual, 2016 came into existence, after multiple judicial interventions. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has repeatedly recommended an overhaul of prison administration by suggesting reforms in treatment of prisoners and management of prisons. The dehumanized existence of prisoners was reprimanded by Justice Krishna Iyer in Sunil Batra v. Delhi Administration [1980 AIR 1579] and he called for an overhaul of Prison Manuals in
11 (2023) 2 MLJ 478 : CDJ 2023 MHC 025
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.