Smt. Naresh Kumari & Ors. v. Smt. Chameli & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 965; [2024] 12 S.C.R. 693
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia, Justice Prasanna Bhalachandra Varale
- Decided
- 11 Dec 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 8244/2009
- Sections
- 127, 126, 122, 123
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 693 : 2024 INSC 965 Smt. Naresh Kumari & Ors.
v.
Smt. Chameli & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 8244 of 2009)
11 December 2024 [Sudhanshu Dhulia* and Prasanna B. Varale, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose as regards the resumption of onerous gift to heirs of donor when conditions of gift are not fulfilled by heirs of the donee. Headnotes† Gift – Oral Gift – Resumption of onerous gift – Land gifted by donor to donee, duly executed and possession transferred – 45 years later, the plaintiffs-donor's heirs, filed suit for resumption of property claiming that gift was made in lieu of services to be rendered by donees and their heirs, to donors and their heirs lifelong, and since the defendants-donees stopped rendering these services, and original donees have died, suit land to revert to plaintiffs – Trial court decreed the suit holding that the subject matter of gift was only a life interest in suit land and since services had stopped the land was to be reverted in favour of plaintiffs – First Appellate Court upheld the same – High Court dismissed the suit, holding that it was not mentioned in the mutation that the donees had to serve the heirs of the donor as well and it could be presumed that proper services were rendered to donor during his lifetime, and the plaintiffs failed to disclose these services and when they were stopped – Interference:
Held: Not called for – In case of resumption of land where there has been long and uninterrupted possession of defendants, strong evidence is required by plaintiffs seeking a decree of possession – Plaintiffs case not backed by any plausible evidence – Gift was for past services but even if it is assumed that it was for some past and some future services, no occasion for the defendants to render the services as the plaintiffs-appellants had left the village and now, when defendants have been enjoying peaceful possession of land for long, resumption of land in favour of appellants will not * Author 694 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports be justified – There was only a vague and conclusory allegation that the defendants have discontinued to serve the successors of the donor-plaintiffs, without any evidence in support of the same – s.127 permits an onerous gift but a gift which is conditioned upon perpetual rendering of services without any remuneration would amount to a begar or forced labour, even slavery and thus, it is not just wrong or illegal but even unconstitutional, being violative of fundamental rights of the donees – This so-called rendering of services, was to be in perpetuity – Thus, the condition as is being read by the plaintiffs is nothing short of reading forced labour, as a condition – Meaningful and purposive interpretation is required – Thus, there was never such a condition of rendering continuous services in the gift deed and services here meant only the past services rendered by the donees to the donor, or at best it may include services to be rendered by the donees to the original donor, who passed away in the late 1950s – Gift had no condition of continuation of these services till perpetuity as the plaintiffs would like to read s.127 permitting onerous gifts was not in force as TPA not applicable in erstwhile Punjab – Nor can it be said that such condition being based on equity, justice and good conscience can be read into the gift deed as a valid condition – Stipulated condition of services and the continuation of the rendering of such services has to be read in the context when the deed was executed – Services shall be understood only as past services rendered, or at most, the services which had to be rendered by the original donees to the original donor during his lifetime – Transfer of Property Act, 1882 – ss.126 and 127. [Paras 10-18] Case Law Cited Shivshankara v. H.P. Vedvyasa Char [2023] 6 SCR 359 : 2023 SCC OnLine SC 358; Chander Bhan v. Mukhtiar Singh [2024] 5 SCR 1148 : 2024 SCC OnLine SC 761 – relied on.
Forbes v. Meer Mahomed Tuquee, 1870 SCC OnLine PC 21;
Partap Das v. Nand Singh, AIR 1924 Lah 729 (1); Captain Parmodh Singh v. Labh Singh, AIR 1955 P&H 49 – referred to.
List of Acts Transfer of Property Act, 1882; Punjab Security and Land Tenures Act, 1953; Punjab Act No. 12 of 1950; Punjab Act No. 5 of 1951. [2024] 12 S.C.R. 695Smt. Naresh Kumari & Ors. v. Smt. Chameli & Ors. List of Keywords English laws of equity; Onerous gift; Resumption of property; Conditions of service; Valid transfer of gift; Continued possession for a long time; Perpetual rendering of services; Begar; Forced labour; Violative of fundamental rights Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 8244 of 2009 From the Judgment and Order dated 20.08.2009 of the High Court of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh in RSA No. 934 of 2006 Appearances for Parties Anoop George Chaudhari, June George Chaudhari, Sr. Advs., Irshad Ahmad, Vivek Singh, Onkar Nath, Mrs. Anju Mirdha, Firasat Ali Siddiqi, Arvind Kumar, Ram Swarup Sharma, Advs. for the Appellants.
Pallav Sisodia, Rajive Bhalla, Sr. Advs., Sandeep S. Tiwari, Manjul Kumar Tiwary, Ms. Rekha S. Tiwari, Rameshwar Prasad Goyal, Shubham Bhalla, Yajur Bhalla, Ms. Anchita Nayyar, Ms. Akansha Gulati, Ms. Ragini Sharma, Mrs. Gauri Bedi, Ms. Ruksana Khan, Rohit Pandey, Alex Noel Dass, Sumeir Ahuja, Varun Puri, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Sudhanshu Dhulia, J.
1. The appellants/plaintiffs are before this Court against the judgement of the Punjab & Haryana High Court dated 20.08.2009, whereby the second appeal of the respondents/defendants was allowed and the concurrent decisions of the courts below, which had decreed the suit, were set aside.
The facts are as follows:
2. Land measuring 38 Bighas 8 Biswas (hereinafter “suit land”) was gifted by one Rai Bahadur Randhir Singh (“donor”) to Sanwalia, Ratiram and Sheochand, all sons of one Chhailu (“donees”) in 1953. The 696 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports oral gift was duly executed and mutation was carried out in favour of the donees on 13.12.1953. The possession of this land was also given to the donees on 13.12.1953.
Things remained peaceful, for 45 long years, then a suit was filed in the year 1998 for declaration and for possession, or more precisely for resumption of this property. The case of the plaintiffs was that they are the heirs of the erstwhile donor and that the suit land was gifted in lieu of the services, which had to be rendered by the donees and their heirs to the donor and his heirs lifelong. It was then asserted that since the defendants have stopped rendering these services and since the original donees have died anyway, the suit land should revert to the plaintiffs in terms of the gift condition. These plaint averments were countered in an extremely dull even unimaginative manner in the written statements of the defendants. Nevertheless, the defendants opposed the plaint averments, contending that though the gift was for services rendered, there was no condition for the gift to revert to the donor upon the death of the donees. Even otherwise, they contended that the plaintiffs have no cause of action as the terms of the gift are being complied with and the defendants have been rendering “all kind of services”, to the plaintiffs! It was also asserted that records relating to possession and ownership of the suit land have been mutated in their favour since 1953 and that the suit is hopelessly barred by limitation.
3. The Trial Court, after hearing the parties, concluded that what was crucial was that the subject matter of the gift was only a life interest in suit land and since the services have been stopped, the land was liable to be reverted in favour of the plaintiffs. Consequently, the suit was held to be within time and as the plaintiffs’ title was proved, the suit was decreed. The First Appellate Court agreed with these findings and dismissed the defendant’s appeal!
The High Court though allowed the defendant’s second appeal and dismissed the suit, largely on the ground of limitation, though it was, inter alia, also observed that nowhere in the mutation dated 13.12.1953 is it mentioned that the donees had to serve the heirs of the donor as well and it could be presumed that proper services were rendered to the donor during his lifetime. Further, the plaintiffs failed to disclose what these “services” were and when exactly they were stopped.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 697Smt. Naresh Kumari & Ors. v. Smt. Chameli & Ors. Apart from making a bald statement in the plaint that the defendants have stopped rendering services, there is no worthwhile evidence placed by the plaintiffs before the Trial Court. On the contrary, evidence has been placed by the defendants in form of DW-1 who has stated that after the death of the donor-Randhir Singh, his children had left the village and nobody from the family of the donor remained in the village and therefore there was no one who could be served. This evidence, however, has not been considered either by the Trial Court or by the First Appellate Court and no reason has been assigned as to why this was done.
4. At the centre of this dispute lies the oral gift, which came to be recorded in the mutation order dated 13.12.1953. The same, as translated to English, is reproduced below:
In a general meeting Rai Bahadur Randhir Singh donor along with identifier Neki Ram Lambardar who appeared and made a statement that he has gifted the land measuring 38 Bigha 8 Biswas in lieu of services till life to Sanwalia etc. and delivered the possession to them.
if donees refused to render the services in that case the land shall revert to the donor or to his heirs. Sanwalia, Rati Ram and Sheo Chand donees are also present who admit the above statement as correct. As such with the consent of the parties the land comprised in Khewat No.64, Khasra Nos. 1169[13-18], 1171[6-11], 1173[7-0], 1174 [10-19] total 38 Bigha 8 Biswas on behalf of Rai Bahadur Randhir Singh donor in favour of donees Sanwalia, Rati Ram, Sheo Chand in equal share. Mutation is sanctioned in favour of donees.
5. Unfortunately, the courts have lost sight of an important aspect here which has a crucial bearing on the case, which is the background of the transfer of land made in the year 1953.
The transaction which is the subject matter of the dispute admittedly occurred in December, 1953. This was the period immediately after our independence where each State in the country had already framed or was in the process of framing legislations on land reforms with a focus on redistribution of land. Since land was in the State list (List II of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India), such legislation was being brought by almost every State in the country. 698 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Punjab was no exception. The land reforms were for acquisition of land from big landlords and zamindars after placing a limit on land holding and then to redistribute it to the landless and the marginal agriculturist. This was being done as this was the pledge given during our freedom movement by the leaders to the nation and immediately after our independence, this was the first task sought to be achieved everywhere in the country.
The reference in our case would be to the Punjab Security and Land Tenures Act, 1953 (hereinafter “1953 Act”), which had become effective on 15th April, 1953. Even prior to this, attempts were made to reform land ownership such as the Punjab Act No.12 of 1950 and the Punjab Act No.5 of 1951, which were repealed by the 1953 Act. The big zamindars and big land owners were fully conscious that they would not be able to retain land beyond the ceiling fixed by the Statute, which had an outer limit of 30 standard Acres for a family. The surplus land (beyond 30 acres) was to vest with the State. The land owners, therefore, either were gifting their land to their helpers, agricultural workers, even to priests or to temples, or in any other manner where they thought their best interest would lie. One thing was clear that technically they would not be able to keep land beyond the surplus limit.
During this period, gifting, donation or transfer of land in any possible manner permitted by law was common place, not only in Punjab but in all parts of the country. We have to examine the present transfer of land which took place in December, 1953 with this context and background in our mind. It is true again, that what we have here is a pure civil matter and considerations as we have just referred above are outside the scope of pure civil litigation. The answer to this would be that civil matters will undoubtedly be decided on facts and law as they exist and as they are applicable, but again in order to appreciate the facts we have to keep the context in mind. Context is always very important. The above reference was only with that aspect in mind.
6. Another factor which has an extremely important bearing in this case and which has again not been satisfactorily dealt with by the Trial Court and the First Appellate Court is the long delay by the plaintiffs in seeking resumption of their so-called property. It is a settled position of law that in cases of resumption of land or immovable property where there has been long and uninterrupted possession of the [2024] 12 S.C.R. 699Smt. Naresh Kumari & Ors. v. Smt. Chameli & Ors. defendants, strong evidence is required to be placed by the plaintiffs to set up a claim, when the plaintiff is seeking a decree of possession. In this case, the nature of pleadings have already been referred to in the preceding paragraphs. The entire case of the plaintiffs rests on the proposition that their predecessors-in-interest have gifted this land to the forefathers of the defendants with the condition that the land is being given to them so that they continue to provide lifelong services to the donor as well as to their descendants, and since they have discontinued these services, the land is liable to revert to the descendants/legal heirs of the original donor. This assertion, however, is not backed by any plausible evidence. Moreover, this proposition has legal implications which may go against the plaintiffs.
7. This suit is based on the aforesaid extremely thin proposition of law and on top of it there is no worthwhile evidence placed by the plaintiffs in their case, except for their reliance on words and phrases in the gift deed, to which unfortunately the defendants have also fallen prey. It is the case of none other but the plaintiffs that the agricultural land, which was the subject matter of the suit, was given in gift to the predecessors-in-interest of the defendants, but it was not an unconditional gift. It was an onerous gift with a condition and since the respondents have violated the conditions of the gift, the land is liable to be reverted to the plaintiffs. Even if we look at this case as a land given as a gift to the defendants or their predecessorsin-interest, the nature of the gift, the context in which it has been given and the entire accumulating circumstances including the fact that the possession of land was handed over the same day goes to show that it was actually an absolute transfer of property with transfer of interest in favour of the donees and their descendants, the only exception being that the donees were not given right over the “common land” of the village, known as “shamlat land”.
8. Now the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (for short “TPA”) was not in force in erstwhile Punjab when the gift was executed in 1953,1 yet such provisions in TPA which are based on principles of justice, equity and good conscience have always been enforced by Courts.2 1 Parts of Transfer of Property Act, 1882 came to be enforced in erstwhile Punjab vide Gazette Notification No. 1605-R(CH)-55/589 dated March 26, 1955.
2 Partap Das v. Nand Singh, AIR 1924 Lah 729 (1); Captain Parmodh Singh v. Labh Singh, AIR 1955 P&H 49.
700 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports In any case, before the enforcement of Transfer of Property Act, 1882, the transfer of immovable property in India was governed by the principles of English laws of equity.
Sections 126 and 127 of the TPA where provisions regarding the suspension or revocation of gifts and onerous gifts is defined respectively are quoted below:
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.