Kunhimuhammed@kunheethu v. The State of Kerala
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 937; [2024] 12 S.C.R. 392
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Prasanna Bhalachandra Varale
- Decided
- 6 Dec 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 5097/2024
- Sections
- 304, 300, 326, 324, 34, 313, 302, 27
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 392 : 2024 INSC 937 Kunhimuhammed@Kunheethu v.
The State of Kerala (Criminal Appeal No. 5097 of 2024)
06 December 2024 [Vikram Nath* and Prasanna B. Varale, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether appellant had the intention to commit murder; whether the appellant’s act can be brought under section 304, IPC in light of the offence being committed in exercise of private defense and thereby exceeding the power given under the law, that is under exception 2 to section 300, IPC; whether appellant’s sentence should be reduced on the grounds of parity with his co-accused. Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – ss.302, 324 and 326/34 – The sympathizers of two political groups fought against each other – Appellant along with other accused committed murder of victim-S and injured CW-1 – Trial Court held appellant guilty u/ss.302, 324 and 326/34 of IPC and sentenced him to life imprisonment and the same was upheld by the High Court – Correctness: Held: The severity of the injuries inflicted on the deceased has been central to the Courts’ conclusion that the act qualifies as murder under Section 300 of the IPC – As per the post-mortem report, the deceased sustained both external and internal ante-mortem injuries that were identified as being inflicted by a sharp-edged knife – The prosecution established beyond doubt that these injuries were inflicted by the appellant-accused no. 1 using a knife, which was recovered during the investigation based on the appellant’s disclosure statement – Further, the doctor PW-6 has stated that these injuries were sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature – Cross-examination of these witnesses did not reveal any inconsistencies that could undermine the credibility of the evidence – Consequently, the courts have rightly concluded that the fatal injuries inflicted by the appellant were the direct cause of the deceased’s death – As far as intention of appellant to commit * Author [2024] 12 S.C.R. 393Kunhimuhammed@Kunheethu v. The State of Kerala murder is concerned, the injuries were concentrated on the vital parts of the deceased’s body, such as the chest and ribs, which house critical organs like the heart and lungs – The deliberate targeting of these areas indicates a clear intent to cause harm that could lead to death – There is also the testimony of the injured witnesses that accused used considerable force while stabbing – The other co-accused were reportedly armed with sticks, the appellant-accused no. 1 was in possession of a sharp knife, which was used to inflict severe injuries – The decision to carry and use such a weapon during the scuffle reflects a readiness to escalate violence beyond a mere physical altercation – The third clause of Section 300, IPC defines murder as the act of causing death by causing such bodily injury as is likely to result in death in the ordinary course of nature – In the instant case, the appellant’s actions satisfy these criteria – The appellant was armed with a knife, which he used to inflict multiple injuries on vital organs – The fatal nature of these injuries, as confirmed by medical evidence, and the circumstances of the attack clearly point to an intent to cause death or at least an intention to inflict injuries with the knowledge that they were likely to result in death – Even if it is presumed that the appellant-accused no. 1 did not have an intention to cause such bodily injury, the act of causing injuries with knife to vital parts is reflective of the knowledge that causing such injuries is likely to cause death in the ordinary course. [Paras 25.1, 25.7, 25.8, 25.16] Penal Code, 1860 – s.304 – Whether the appellant’s act can be brought under section 304, IPC in light of the offence being committed in exercise of private defense and thereby exceeding the power given under the law, that is under exception 2 to section 300, IPC:
Held: The courts below have made a categorical finding that the appellant-accused no.1 and his co-accused were the aggressors in the altercation – The attack was initiated by the accused group, who were armed with sticks and a knife, with the intent to intimidate or harm the victim and his companions – This fact is substantiated by the testimony of PW-1, an injured eyewitness, who described the sequence of events leading up to the stabbing – Even if it were assumed that the appellant-accused no. 1 acted in self-defense, the evidence overwhelmingly demonstrates that the force used was excessive and disproportionate – The act of stabbing the deceased 394 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports multiple times in vital organs such as the chest and heart goes far beyond what is permissible under the right of private defense – In the post-mortem report and corroborated by the testimony of PW-6 (the police surgeon), the injuries inflicted on the deceased were severe and intentional, including a fatal wound to the heart – In light of the above findings, the plea of exceeding the right of private defense under Exception 2 to Section 300, IPC, is not applicable to the appellant’s case. [Paras 26.5, 26.6, 26.7] Penal Code, 1860 – ss.302, 324 and 326/34 – Appellant- accused no.1 was convicted u/ss.302, 324 and 326/34 of IPC and sentenced to life imprisonment – Whereas, accused no.2 was found guilty of offences punishable u/s.326 and u/ss.324/34 of IPC and he was sentenced to six years imprisonment u/s.326 and two years rigorous imprisonment u/s.324 of IPC – The third accused was also awarded the same sentence as accused no.2 – The sentences were to run concurrently – All the three accused filed separate appeals before the High Court, which were dismissed – The second and third accused preferred a separate SLP, wherein this Court extended benefit of doubt to accused no.3 whereas accused no.2’s conviction was upheld, however, his sentence u/s.326 for six years was reduced to three years – Whether appellant’s sentence should be reduced on the grounds of parity with his co-accused:
Held: The doctrine of parity ensures fairness in sentencing when co-accused persons are similarly situated and share the same level of culpability – However, parity is not an automatic entitlement; the role, intent, and actions of each accused must be individually assessed to determine their degree of involvement in the crime – In the instant case, the courts have carefully evaluated the evidence against each accused and tailored their sentences accordingly – The appellant’s argument for parity fails to recognize the qualitative differences in their roles and the gravity of their actions – The appellant’s actions were not only more severe but also demonstrated a clear intent to cause death – The fatal injuries inflicted on the deceased, as detailed in the post-mortem report, leave no room for doubt about the appellant-accused no. 1’s culpability – The courts below have correctly observed that the appellant’s role in the crime is incomparable to that of his co-accused – The principle of parity does not apply in the present case, as the appellant’s [2024] 12 S.C.R. 395Kunhimuhammed@Kunheethu v. The State of Kerala actions were materially different from those of his co-accused. [Paras 27.2, 27.6, 27.7] Penal Code, 1860 – ss.302, 324 and 326/34 – Appellant convicted u/ss.302, 324 and 326/34 of IPC and sentenced to life imprisonment – Plea of old age and deteriorating health: Held: A murder committed with the intent to target vital organs, particularly in a group setting, reflects a level of intent and cruelty that demands an appropriate punitive response – To reduce the sentence in such a case would risk undermining the seriousness of the crime and the sanctity of life itself, principles that the judicial system is duty-bound to uphold – While the Court acknowledges the appellant’s advanced age and medical condition, these factors cannot outweigh the need for justice and the imperative to uphold the rule of law – When the minimum sentence itself is life imprisonment, then grounds like parity, leniency, old age, health concerns, etc. shall not be of any aid to the accused while seeking reduction of sentence – Therefore, the appellant herein has been granted the minimum sentence for committing the offence of murder. [Paras 28.4, 28.5, 29] Case Law Cited Manubhai Atabhai v. State of Gujarat [2007] 7 SCR 1115 : (2007) 10 SCC 358; Arun Nivalaji More v. State of Maharashtra [2006] Supp. 4 SCR 301 : (2006) 12 SCC 613; Nishan Singh v. State of Punjab [2008] 4 SCR 500 : (2008) 17 SCC 505; Vinod Kumar v. Amritpal [2021] 11 SCR 954 : (2021) 19 SCC 181; Balkar Singh v. State of Uttarakhand [2009] 5 SCR 242 : (2009) 15 SCC 366; Darshan Singh v. State of Punjab [2010] 1 SCR 642 : (2010) 2 SCC 333; V. Subramani v. State of Tamil Nadu [2005] 2 SCR 536 : (2005) 10 SCC 358; Sone Lal v. State of U.P. [1981] 3 SCR 352 : (1981) 2 SCC 531 – referred to.
List of Acts Evidence Act, 1872; Penal Code, 1860; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
List of Keywords Third clause of Section 300, IPC; Injuries were sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature; Exception 2 to section 300, IPC; Private defence; Doctrine of parity; Reduction of sentence; Old age of accused; Deteriorating health of accused.
396 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
5097 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 18.09.2018 of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in CRLA No. 1477 of 2012 Appearances for Parties Nikhil Goel, Sr. Adv., Haris Beeran, Azhar Assees, Anand B. Menon, Ms. Maneesha Sunilkumar, Radha Shyam Jena, Advs. for the Appellant.
P.V. Dinesh, Sr. Adv., Nishe Rajen Shonker, Mrs. Anu K Joy, Alim Anvar, Ms. Anna Oommen, Ms. Urvashi Chauhan, Advs. for the Respondent.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Vikram Nath, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. This appeal assails the correctness of the judgment and order dated 18.09.2018 whereby the appeal of the appellant-accused no.1, against his conviction under sections 302, 324 and 326/34 of Indian Penal Code, 1860 1 has been dismissed. The prosecution story in brief is:
2.1. On 10.04.2006, the sympathizers of United Democratic Front (UDF) and Left Democratic Front (LDF) fought against each other in connection with the dispute regarding the drawing of their election symbol at a place near a library in Kunnappalli, Pathaikkara Village. A criminal case with non-bailable offences was registered against the sympathisers of UDF in connection with the above incident.
2.2. On 11.04.2006, The appellant along with the other accused who are sympathisers of Indian Union Muslim League on
1 IPC
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 397Kunhimuhammed@Kunheethu v. The State of Kerala account of above enmity and with the intention to commit murder of deceased Subrahmannian and CW-1 Vasudevan Ramachandra, waited at Mukkilaplavu Junction for their arrival and at about 08:45 PM when the deceased along with Vasudevan Ramachandra reached at the above-mentioned place, the first accused attempted to beat the deceased with a tamarind stick, on his head. The deceased saved himself from the said attack and snatched the stick from the first accused and started assaulting the first accused on his forehead and back with the same stick. At this stage, the first accused took out a knife from his hip region and stabbed the deceased on the left side of chest, back of the head and the left shoulder. On seeing the above incident, CW-1 made an attempt to obstruct the first accused from assaulting the deceased, however, the first accused stabbed him on the left side of the buttock of CW-1 with the same knife. When CW-1 fell on the ground, the second accused caused a fracture on the right foot bone of CW-1 by beating him with another tamarind stick. Thereafter, the third accused assaulted CW-1 by beating on his right chest with a wooden stick.
2.3. After the said incident, the injured and the deceased were taken to the Maulana Hospital where Additional Sub-Inspector CW-32 reached and recorded the statement of CW-1 on the basis of which the First Information Report was registered as Crime No.260 of 2006 against the three accused under sections 302/324 read with section 34 IPC. The accused were thereafter arrested. The Investigating Officer prepared the inquest report, spot map, and recovered the knife under the seizure memo on the basis of the disclosure statement made by the first accused.
2.4. After completing the investigation, the charge sheet was submitted under sections 302/307 read with section 34 IPC. The Magistrate took cognizance and committed the case for trial to the Sessions Court. The Trial Court framed the charges under the aforesaid sections and read them over to the accused who denied the same and claimed trial.
3. The Prosecution examined 19 witnesses and filed 28 Exhibits and 18 material objects. The statements of the accused under section 313 398 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 2 were recorded wherein again they claimed that they were innocent and had nothing to do with the said incident. They claimed to have been falsely implicated on account of political rivalry at the instance of the leaders of Communist Party of India (Marxist) (CPI(M)).
4. The Trial Court after appreciating the evidence led by the parties held that the appellantwas found guilty of offences punishable under sections 302, 324 and 326/34 IPC and accordingly sentenced him to life imprisonment with a fine of Rs.1 Lakh under section 302, IPC, six years rigorous imprisonment with a fine of Rs.25,000/- under section 326, IPC, and two years imprisonment under section 324, IPC. Accused no.2 was found guilty of offences punishable under section 326 and under sections 324/34 IPC and he was sentenced to six years imprisonment under section 326, IPC with a fine of Rs.25,000/- and two years rigorous imprisonment under section 324 IPC. The third accused was also awarded the same sentence as accused no.2. The sentences were to run concurrently.
5. Three appeals were preferred before the High Court by the three accused separately. The High Court by the impugned order dismissed all the three appeals. The second accused and the third accused had preferred a separate SLP registered as SLP(Crl.) No.2822 of 2019. In the said SLP, leave was granted, and it was partly allowed vide judgment and order dated 29.07.2019. This Court extended benefit of doubt to accused no.3 whereas accused no.2’s conviction was upheld, however, his sentence under section 326 for six years was reduced to three years.
6. We have heard Shri Nikhil Goel, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant and Shri P.V. Dinesh, learned senior counsel appearing for the State of Kerala and perused the material on record. The submissions of Shri Goel are limited to the extent that this was not a case of premeditated pre planned murder. There was no mens rea for committing culpable homicide amounting to murder. The intention was only of assaulting with the stick but later on during the fight as the deceased overpowered the appellant and started assaulting him with the same stick after snatching it from the appellant, the appellant pulled out the knife from his back and stabbed the deceased and 2 CrPC [2024] 12 S.C.R. 399Kunhimuhammed@Kunheethu v. The State of Kerala also the injured to save him. He has drawn attention to the evidence on record as also to the judgment of the Trial Court wherein specific finding was recorded to that extent by the Trial Court but despite the same, the Trial Court proceeded to record conviction under section 302 IPC and not section 304 IPC.
7. He also submitted that the appellant is aged 67 years and is suffering from multiple ailments and that having undergone almost twelve and half years of actual sentence, this Court may consider reducing the sentence by converting the conviction to under section 304 IPC Part II.
8. On the other hand, Mr. P.V. Dinesh, learned senior counsel appearing for the respondent-State submitted that the Trial Court and the High Court have both dealt with this aspect of the matter and have concurrently found that this was a case of culpable homicide amounting to murder. The fact that the appellant was carrying a knife and the number of assaults made by him on the deceased as also the injury would clearly show that the intention was to commit murder.
9. Having heard the learned counsels for the parties, we find it imperative to look into the evidence, witness testimonies, and injury reports to better understand and analyse the incident to see whether the culpable homicide in the present case amounts to murder or not. A meticulous analysis of the evidence on record is necessary to check whether the appellant had the intention to kill the deceased or if he can be given the benefit of reduction of sentence on the grounds pleaded in the appeal. To understand the evidence and their probative value in establishing the offence, it is necessary to look at the categorical findings of both the courts below.
FINDINGS OF THE TRIAL COURT
10. The Trial Court found appellant guilty of offences under Sections 302, 326, and 324, IPC. The Trial Court’s findings were primarily based on the direct testimony of PW1, an eyewitness who was also injured in the incident, and corroborative evidence from medical and forensic reports.
11. The evidence of PW1 was crucial to the prosecution’s case. The Trial Court carefully analyzed his testimony and found it credible, reliable, and consistent with the injuries sustained by the deceased and PW1, as recorded in the medical reports. Although the defense argued 400 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports that PW1 was an interested witness and highlighted omissions and contradictions in his testimony, the Trial Court concluded that these discrepancies were minor and did not affect the core narrative. The Trial Court also noted that PW1’s statements were corroborated by PW2, who arrived at the scene shortly after the incident and observed the accused fleeing. PW2’s account was deemed trustworthy and supported the prosecution’s version.
12. The recovery of the murder weapon (a knife, marked as MO1) at the instance of appellant was a significant factor in the Trial Court’s findings. The knife was recovered under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 based on information provided by appellant during his custodial interrogation. Forensic examination confirmed that the knife bore human blood matching the deceased’s blood group. This finding provided compelling corroboration of PW1’s testimony regarding the role of Accused No. 1 in the fatal assault. Additional physical evidence, such as blood-stained sticks recovered from the crime scene, further substantiated the prosecution’s case.
13. Medical evidence also played a vital role. The postmortem report of the deceased, prepared by PW-6 (a police surgeon), confirmed that the cause of death was multiple stab injuries inflicted with a sharp-edged weapon like MO1. PW6 identified specific fatal injuries to the heart and lungs, which were consistent with the prosecution’s narrative of the assault. Similarly, the wound certificate of PW1 corroborated his account of the injuries he sustained during the attack. The Trial Court observed that the injuries detailed in the medical reports aligned with the testimonies of PW1 and PW2, reinforcing the prosecution’s case.
14. The defense attempted to argue that the incident occurred in the exercise of private defense, claiming that the accused were attacked by CPI(M) workers, including the deceased and PW1. However, the Trial Court rejected this claim, finding it unsubstantiated and improbable. The injuries on appellant, documented in the wound certificate, were deemed minor and inconsistent with the defense’s narrative of a large-scale attack. The Court concluded that the accused were the aggressors and were not entitled to claim the right of private defense.
15. Ultimately, the Trial Court held that the prosecution had proved beyond reasonable doubt that appellant intentionally caused the death of [2024] 12 S.C.R. 401Kunhimuhammed@Kunheethu v. The State of Kerala Subrahmannian and grievously injured PW1. The recovery of the murder weapon, corroborative forensic and medical evidence, and the reliable testimony of PW1 and PW2 were central to this conclusion. Accordingly, appellant was convicted under Sections 302, 326, and 324 IPC and sentenced to life imprisonment for the murder charge, along with additional terms for the other offenses.
FINDINGS OF THE HIGH COURT
16. The High Court of Kerala meticulously analyzed the roles and culpability of each accused based on the evidence presented during the trial. The findings highlight the distinct involvement of each accused in the crime, with a particular focus on the actions of appellant. This comprehensive assessment ensures that the degree of liability is proportionate to their individual actions and intentions as discerned from the evidence on record.
17. The High Court affirmed the findings of the Trial Court that Accused No. 1 played a pivotal role in the murder. The evidence of PW-1, an injured eyewitness, was central to establishing the sequence of events. PW-1 testified that appellant first beat the deceased with a wooden stick, causing injuries to his left shoulder. When the deceased tried to flee, appellant – accused no. 1 drew the knife and inflicted a stab wound to his back. As PW-1 intervened to protect the deceased, appellant–turned on him, stabbing him in the buttock. This act of aggression was corroborated by medical evidence, which indicated that PW-1 sustained injuries consistent with the use of the weapon recovered during the investigation. Despite PW-1’s injuries, appellant resumed his attack on the deceased, stabbing him multiple times in the chest and other vital areas.
18. The High Court emphasized the significance of the post-mortem report, which revealed eight incised wounds on the deceased, including fatal injuries to the chest, heart, and lungs. PW-6, the police surgeon, testified that these injuries were consistent with the knife recovered and that the fatal wounds were sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death. The chemical analysis linking the knife to appellant was further corroborated by the presence of human blood matching the deceased’s blood group on the weapon. The recovery of the knife, facilitated by a disclosure statement from appellant, lent further credence to the prosecution’s case. 402 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
19. The High Court also addressed the appellant’s argument that the testimony of PW-1 was unreliable due to alleged embellishments regarding the number of stab injuries. The Court rejected this contention, noting that minor omissions in the First Information Statement (FIS) could not undermine the credibility of PW-1’s account, especially given the traumatic circumstances under which the FIS was recorded. The court reasoned that PW-1, having sustained a stab injury himself, may not have been able to provide exhaustive details at the time but consistently identified appellant – accused no. 1 as the primary assailant. The testimony of PW-2, an independent eyewitness, corroborated PW-1’s account, further strengthening the prosecution’s case against appellant.
20. The High Court concluded that the actions of appellant demonstrated clear intent to cause death. The deliberate targeting of vital organs with a sharp weapon indicated premeditation or, at the very least, the formation of intent during the incident. The court observed that while the altercation may have initially involved the use of sticks, appellant’s decision to escalate the violence by drawing and using a knife was an intentional and unilateral act. This conduct set him apart from the other accused, whose actions were limited to assaulting the victims with sticks.
21. In contrast, accused nos. 2 and 3 were found guilty of lesser offenses under Section 326 IPC for causing grievous hurt to PW-1. The evidence established that they used sticks to beat PW-1, resulting in non-fatal injuries, including a fracture to his leg. The High Court concurred with the Trial Court’s finding that there was insufficient evidence to prove that Accused Nos. 2 and 3 shared a common intention with appellant to commit murder. The court noted that there was no evidence to suggest that they were aware of the knife concealed by appellant or his intent to use it. This lack of knowledge precluded the application of Section 34, IPC to hold them vicariously liable for the murder.
22. The High Court underscored the principle that liability must be determined based on the specific actions and intentions of each accused. While accused nos. 2 and 3 were complicit in the assault, their participation did not extend to the homicidal attack perpetrated by accused no. 1. The court further noted that the initial assault with sticks did not indicate a pre-arranged plan to kill the deceased. Had [2024] 12 S.C.R. 403Kunhimuhammed@Kunheethu v. The State of Kerala there been such an intention, the attack would have begun with the use of the knife rather than sticks.
23. The High court also dismissed the appellant’s plea for leniency based on parity with the co-accused. It emphasized that the role of appellant was materially different and far more culpable than that of accused Nos. 2 and 3. The fatal injuries inflicted by appellant on the deceased were deliberate, targeted, and intended to cause death, whereas the actions of the co-accused were confined to non-fatal assaults on PW-1. The principle of parity, therefore, did not apply in this case.
24. The High Court upheld the conviction of appellant under Section 302 IPC for the murder of Subrahmannian. The court noted that the evidence against him was overwhelming, including eyewitness testimonies, medical reports, and forensic findings. The sentences imposed on Accused Nos. 2 and 3 under Section 326 IPC were also affirmed, as they appropriately reflected their limited roles in the incident.
FINDINGS ON THE GROUNDS FOR REDUCTION OF SENTENCE
25. SCUFFLE AND LACK OF INTENT: The appellant’s counsel has argued that the incident arose out of a scuffle between two rival factions, during which the act of stabbing and killing the deceased was not premeditated but rather occurred spontaneously in the heat of the moment. According to the appellant, there was no deliberate intent to commit murder, and the unfortunate event resulted from a confrontation that escalated during the altercation. However, this submission has been closely examined and dismissed by both the Trial Court and the High Court, based on substantial evidence presented during the proceedings.
A. Fatal Injuries:
25.1 The severity of the injuries inflicted on the deceased has been central to the Courts’ conclusion that the act qualifies as murder under Section 300 of the IPC. As per the post-mortem report, the deceased sustained both external and internal ante-mortem injuries that were identified as being inflicted by a sharp-edged knife. These injuries, detailed in the Trial Court’s order, include multiple incised penetration wounds to vital regions such as the chest, rib cage, lungs, and heart.
404 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports 25.2 The evidence of PW-6, the police surgeon who conducted the post-mortem examination, was instrumental in establishing the fatal nature of the injuries. He testified that the death resulted from multiple injuries, including several incised wounds caused by the knife recovered during the investigation. The injuries sustained by the deceased, as per the report, were as follows:
External Antemortem Injuries:
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.