Ashok v. State of Uttar Pradesh
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 919; [2024] 12 S.C.R. 335
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah, Justice Augustine George Masih
- Decided
- 2 Dec 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 771/2024
- Sections
- 313, 313(5), 351, 303, 304, 3(2), 366, 161, 27, 342
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 335 : 2024 INSC 919 Ashok v.
State of Uttar Pradesh (Criminal Appeal No. 771 of 2024)
02 December 2024 [Abhay S. Oka,* Ahsanuddin Amanullah and Augustine George Masih, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Matter pertains to the correctness of the order of conviction and sentence against the appellant, for the offences punishable u/ss.376, 302, 201 IPC as also SC and ST Act 1989; and as regards the role of the Public Prosecutor and appointment of legal aid lawyers. Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – ss.376, 302, 201 – Rape and murder – Prosecution case that appellant committed rape and murder of a ten year old girl – Victim’s cousin-witness to the incident, and narrated the same to the victim’s father – Dead body found hidden at the place of incident – Appellant fled from the spot when questioned by the victim’s father and thereafter, FIR was registered – Order of conviction and imposition of death sentence against the appellant, for the offences punishable u/ss.376, 302, 201 as also the 1989 Act – High Court upheld the conviction, however reduced the sentence to life imprisonment – Correctness:
Held: Evidence of victim’s cousin, the only eyewitness, cannot be held to be of sterling quality – It is unsafe to base conviction only on his testimony – At the most, it can be the evidence of the last seen together – As regards, the recovery of articles at instance of the appellant, the prosecution failed to prove that the recovery was from a particular place – Thus, evidence of recovery to be kept out of consideration – Appellant's guilt beyond reasonable doubt not established – As regards, the examination of the appellant u/s.313 Cr.P.C., material circumstances appearing in evidence against the appellant, version of the main prosecution witnesses not been put to him – Unless all material circumstances appearing against him * Author 336 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports in evidence are put to the accused, he cannot decide whether he wants to lead any defence evidence – Even the date and place of the crime allegedly committed by the appellant not put to the appellant – Thus, the appellant was prejudiced – Even assuming that failure to put material to the appellant in his examination was an irregularity, it cannot be cured by remanding the case to the trial court, since the incident is fifteen and a half years old and after such a long gap, it would be unjust to ask the appellant to explain the circumstances and material specifically appearing against him in the evidence – Moreover, the appellant had been incarcerated for about twelve years and nine months before he was released on bail – Even assuming that the evidence of eye witness can be believed, the appellant entitled to acquittal on the ground of the failure to put incriminating material to him in his examination u/s.313 CrPC – Both the trial court and High Court overlooked non-compliance with the requirements of s.313 CrPC – Shockingly, the trial court imposed the death penalty in a case which ought to have resulted in acquittal – Imposing capital punishment in such a case shocks the conscience of this Court – There was failure of the State to provide timely and quality of legal aid to the appellant – Thus, impugned judgments and orders set aside and the appellant is acquitted – Directions regarding the role of the Public Prosecutor and appointment of legal aid lawyers issued – Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989. [Paras 12, 13, 14-17, 19, 21-24] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.313(5) – Power to examine accused – Role of the public prosecutor:
Held: Under sub-Section (5) of s.313 (sub-Section (5) of s.351 of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023), the court is entitled to secure the assistance of the public prosecutor and the advocate representing the accused to prepare the questions to be put in the examination u/s.313 – Public Prosecutor has to play an active role in ensuring that every trial is conducted in a fair manner and in accordance with the law – It is the Public Prosecutor's duty to invite the Court's attention to the requirement of putting all incriminating material to the accused – Thus, the Public Prosecutor under an obligation to remain present when the examination of the accused is made to assist the Court – Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023. [Para 18] [2024] 12 S.C.R. 337Ashok v. State of Uttar Pradesh Constitution of India – Arts.21 and 39A – Equal justice and free legal aid – Failure to provide legal aid to the accused – Effect: Held: Right to get legal aid is a fundamental right of the accused, guaranteed by Art.21 – Even u/s.303 CrPC, every accused has a right to be defended by a pleader of his choice – Under s.304 CrPC, it is the duty of the Court to ensure that a legal aid lawyer is appointed to espouse the cause of the accused free of costs – When an accused has either not engaged an advocate or does not have sufficient means to engage an advocate, it is the trial court's duty to inform the accused of his right to obtain free legal aid, which is a right covered by Art.21 – ss.340 and 341 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 correspond to ss.303 and 304 CrPC – On facts, there was failure of the State to provide timely and quality of legal aid to the appellant – Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023. [Paras 19, 20] Criminal trial – Role of the Public Prosecutor and appointment of legal aid lawyers – Issuance of directions regarding the role of the Public Prosecutor and appointment of legal aid lawyers:
Held: (i) Duty of the Court to ensure that proper legal aid is provided to an accused;
(ii) Duty of Public Prosecutor to point out to the Court the requirement of providing accused free legal aid;
(iii) Public Prosecutor to request the Court not to proceed without offering to provide legal aid to the accused;
(iv) Duty of the Public Prosecutor to assist the trial court in recording the accused's statement u/s. 313 CrPC.
If the Court omits any material circumstance against the accused, the Public Prosecutor must bring it to the Court's notice and assist in framing questions. It is the Public Prosecutor's duty to prevent trial infirmities that may prejudice the accused.;
(v) Accused entitled to free legal aid at all material stages, starting from remand, including bail petitions;
338 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
(vi) Accused to be made aware of his right to get free legal aid at all material stages;
(vii) For all the cases where there is a possibility of a life sentence or death sentence, appoint legal aid advocates with at least 10 years of criminal practice, and in other cases the accused entitled to a legal aid advocate who has good knowledge of the law and experience of conducting trials on the criminal side. Legal Services Authorities at all levels to give proper training to the newly appointed legal aid advocates;
(viii) Legal Services Authorities to monitor the work of the legal aid advocate and to ensure that they attend the court regularly and punctually when the cases entrusted to them are fixed;
(ix) It is necessary to ensure that the same legal aid advocate is continued throughout the trial unless there are compelling reasons to do so;
(x) In cases of serious nature and complicated legal and factual issues, the Court may appoint a senior member of the Bar who has a vast experience of conducting trials;
(xi) Accused is entitled to free trial and if effective legal aid is not made available to an accused it would amount to infringement of his fundamental rights guaranteed by Art. 21; and
(xii) Legal aid must be effective. Advocates appointed to espouse the cause of the accused must have good knowledge of criminal laws, law of evidence and procedural laws. If the legal aid advocate provided to an accused is not competent enough to conduct the trial efficiently, the rights of the accused will be violated. [Para 23] Case Law Cited Raj Kumar v. State (NCT of Delhi) [2023] 5 SCR 754 : 2023 SCC OnLine SC 609; Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v. State of Maharashtra [1974] 1 SCR 489 : (1973) 2 SCC 793; Hussainara Khatoon (IV) v. [2024] 12 S.C.R. 339Ashok v. State of Uttar Pradesh Home Secy., State of Bihar [1979] 3 SCR 1276 : (1980) 1 SCC 98; M.H. Hoskot v. State of Maharashtra [1979] 1 SCR 192 : (1978) 3 SCC 544; Anokhilal v. State of M.P. [2019] 18 SCR 1196 : (2019) 20 SCC 196 – referred to.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023.
List of Keywords Role of Public Prosecutor; Appointment of legal aid lawyers; Rape and murder; Imposition of death sentence; Eyewitness; Last seen together; Recovery of articles; Established beyond reasonable doubt; Examination u/s.313 Cr.P.C; Material circumstances appearing in evidence; Defence evidence; Irregularity; Incarceration; Failure to put incriminating material to accused in his examination u/s.313 CrPC; Death penalty; Capital punishment; Assistance of public prosecutor; Failure to provide legal aid to accused; Right to get legal aid; Right to be defended by a pleader of his choice; Espouse the cause of accused free of costs; State to provide timely and quality of legal aid to accused; Directions regarding role of Public Prosecutor and appointment of legal aid lawyers.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No. 771 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 28.11.2013 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in CC No. 170 of 2013 Appearances for Parties M. Shoeb Alam, Sr. Adv./Amicus Curiae, Talha Abdul Rahman, Amicus Curiae, M Shaz Khan, Sudhanshu Tewari, Faizan Ahmad, Advs. for the Appellant.
K Parameshwar, Sr. A.A.G., Ms. Sakshi Kakkar, Advs. for the Respondent.
340 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Abhay S. Oka, J.
FACTUAL ASPECT
1. This is a very unfortunate case. The victim of the offence was ten years old at the time of the incident. On 27 th May 2009, around 9.00 a.m., she and her first cousin, PW-2, had gone to a pasture to graze her goats. The age of PW-2 was seven years at that time. As the victim was thirsty, she went near a tubewell cabin. The appellant-accused was working as an operator of the tubewell appointed by the owner of the tubewell. The victim requested the appellant to provide drinking water. The allegation of the prosecution is that, with evil intentions, the appellant took her inside the cabin. He committed rape on her and, after that, murdered her. According to the prosecution’s case, PW-2 saw the appellant forcibly taking the victim inside the cabin and raping her. By 11.00 a.m., PW-2 returned to PW-1, the victim’s father. PW-1 was the uncle of PW- 2. After PW-2 narrated the story to PW-1, he went to the tubewell cabin to find the victim and found the dead body of the victim hidden in a haystack in that cabin. On being questioned by PW-1, the appellant fled from the spot and thereafter, PW-1 registered the First Information Report.
2. The Trial Court, by judgment and order dated 24 th December 2012, convicted the appellant for the offences punishable under Sections 376, 302 and 201 of the Indian Penal Code (for short, ‘the IPC’). The Trial Court also convicted the appellant under the provisions of Section 3(2)(v) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 (for short, ‘the SCST Act’). The Trial Court imposed capital punishment.
3. The High Court heard the reference under Section 366 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short, ‘the CrPC’) with an appeal preferred by the appellant. Though the High Court confirmed the conviction, the death penalty was set aside and the appellant was sentenced to undergo life imprisonment for the remainder of his natural life subject to the exercise of powers of grant of remission or grant of clemency by the constitutional functionaries. [2024] 12 S.C.R. 341Ashok v. State of Uttar Pradesh
4. The present appeal is against the judgments mentioned above. By order dated 20 th May 2022, this Court granted bail to the appellant after noting that he had undergone actual incarceration for about 13 years. We may note here that earlier, learned counsel Shri M Shoeb Alam was appointed as amicus curiae to espouse the cause of the appellant. After his designation as a senior advocate, he continued to assist this Court. Shri Talha Abdul Rahman, Advocate-on-Record, was appointed amicus curiae to assist the learned senior counsel.
SUBMISSIONS
5. The learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant has taken us through the evidence of the prosecution witnesses. Inviting our attention to evidence of PW-1, Heera Lal, the father of the victim, he pointed out that the version of the witness in his examination-in-chief is based on what was reported to him by PW-2, the minor witness. But, if we compare the depositions of PW-2 with the examination-in-chief of PW-1, there is a significant variance between the version of PW-2 as stated by PW-1 and what PW-2 stated in his examination-in-chief. He pointed out that in the cross-examination, PW-1 has tried to improve upon his version by trying to depose consistently with the version of PW-2. Inviting our attention to the proceedings before the Trial Court, he submitted that when the examination-in-chief of the PW-1 was recorded, the appellant-accused was not represented by any advocate. Therefore, the cross-examination was adjourned to enable the appellant to engage an advocate. An advocate was appointed to espouse his cause after the examination-in-chief of PW-1 was recorded. The appellant was not represented by any advocate at the time of the framing of the charge.
6. Coming to the depositions of PW-2, the learned senior counsel for the appellant urged that considering the difference between the version of PW-1 in his examination-in-chief and cross-examination, the possibility of PW-2 being tutored cannot be ruled out. He submitted that evidence of PW-2 was recorded two and half years after the incident, and on the date of the recording of evidence, his age was ten years. Possibly, he was tutored. He pointed out that the evidence of PW-2 was not of sterling quality and, therefore, cannot be the sole basis for the conviction, especially when evidence regarding recovery is doubtful.
342 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
7. The learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant as amicus curiae pointed out that the alleged recovery of the victim’s slippers and underwear, at the instance of the appellant, is highly doubtful as the place and time of recovery have not been mentioned in the recovery memo. The prosecution did not examine the two witnesses to the recovery memo. He pointed out that the prosecution made no attempt to prove that blood stains on the undergarments of the appellant were that of the blood of the victim. No analysis was made.
8. More importantly, he submitted that the incriminating circumstances brought on record in the evidence against the appellant were not put to him in his examination under Section 313 of the CrPC. Therefore, the appellant’s right of defence was seriously prejudiced. He relied upon a decision of this Court in the case of Raj Kumar v. State (NCT of Delhi).1
9. Shri K. Parameshwar, the learned senior counsel appearing for the State, supported the impugned judgments. However, he has assisted us on the issue of legal aid to the accused.
CONSIDERATION OF SUBMISSIONS
10. In the examination-in-chief, PW-1 stated that PW-2 witnessed the commission of rape and murder of the victim. According to the witness, PW-2 told him that as the door of the room was open while he was standing outside, he saw the act of commission of rape and murder. He deposed that after the PW-2 told him about the incident, he rushed along with two or three other persons to the spot. He found that the appellant was present there, and he questioned the appellant. Thereafter, the appellant fled. He tried to search for the victim. He found the dead body of the victim under the haystack in the room. It is pertinent to note that PW-2 had informed PW-1 that the appellant was the offender. Though two to three persons accompanied PW-1, he did not attempt to apprehend the accused and take him to the police. The conduct of PW-1 of not apprehending the appellant, though he was present, is unnatural.
11. Examination-in-chief of PW-1 was recorded by learned Trial Judge on 11th May 2011. At the end of the examination-in-chief, the learned Trial Judge recorded that the case was adjourned at the oral request 1 [2023] 5 SCR 754 : 2023 SCC OnLine SC 609 [2024] 12 S.C.R. 343Ashok v. State of Uttar Pradesh of the appellant to engage a counsel. Before the cross-examination was recorded on 2nd July 2011, an advocate was appointed to espouse the appellant’s cause. The cross-examination of PW-1 was recorded on 2 nd July 2011 and 24 th September 2011. The witness reiterated that he had narrated the facts stated to him by PW-2.
12. As far as PW-2 is concerned, he was 10 years old when his deposition was recorded. Many preliminary questions were put to the witness by the learned Trial Judge. After satisfying himself that the witness was able to understand the questions and give a reply to the same, an oath was administered to him. His version in the examination-in-chief is that the appellant gave drinking water to him and the victim. After drinking the water, when they tried to leave, the appellant caught the victim from behind, took off her undergarments, and the victim started screaming. He did not depose that he had seen the commission of rape and murder by the appellant. To this extent, the version of PW-2, as told to PW-1, is entirely different. PW-1 claims that PW-2 reported to him that he had seen the appellant committing rape and murder from outside the cabin. PW-8, the investigating officer, stated that he had recorded the Statement of PW-2 on 18 th June 2009. Thus, there was a delay of 21 days in recording his statement, though the FIR recorded that this witness had seen the appellant committing the crime. There is some dispute about whether the witness’s statement recorded under Section 161 of CrPC was produced with the charge sheet. The learned senior counsel appointed as amicus pointed out that it is not on the record of the Trial Court. In the list of witnesses mentioned in the charge sheet, the name of PW-2 has not been included. Therefore, for all the reasons discussed above, the evidence of PW-2, the only eyewitness, cannot be held to be of sterling quality. It is unsafe to base conviction only on his testimony. Even otherwise, taking his testimony as correct, the evidence of the PW-2 can, at the highest, be the evidence of the last seen together.
13. Therefore, it is necessary to consider the other circumstantial evidence. In this case, the recovery of the victim’s slipper and underwear is alleged at the appellant’s instance. We have perused the recovery memo signed by the circle officer and two independent witnesses. The prosecution did not examine the two independent witnesses. Though the date of recovery is mentioned in the memo, the time and, most importantly, the place of recovery are not mentioned. Therefore, it 344 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports cannot be said that pursuant to the statement made by the appellant, in accordance with Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1972 (for short, ‘the Evidence Act’), the articles were found at the place stated by the appellant. Hence, the prosecution failed to prove that the recovery was from a particular place. Thus, evidence of recovery will have to be kept out of consideration. The recovery of the articles at the instance of the appellant is a very important circumstance in the chain of circumstances. It is not proved. Hence, the appellant’s guilt beyond reasonable doubt has not been established.
EXAMINATION OF THE APPELLANT UNDER SECTION 313
OF CR.P.C
14. Now, we come to the appellant’s statement, recorded per Section 313 of the CrPC. Only three questions were put to the appellant. In the first question, the names of ten prosecution witnesses were incorporated, and the only question asked to the appellant was what he had to say about the testimony of ten prosecution witnesses. In the second question, all the documents produced by the prosecution were referred, and a question was asked, what the appellant has to say about the documents. In the third question, it was put to the appellant that knowing the fact that the victim belongs to a scheduled caste, he caused her death after raping her and concealed her dead body, and he was asked for his reaction to the same. What PW-1 and PW-2 deposed against the appellant was not put to the appellant. The contents of the incriminating documents were not put to the appellant.
15. In the case of Raj Kumar,1 in paragraph 17, this Court has summarised the law laid down by this Court from time to time on Section 313 of the CrPC. Paragraph 17 reads thus:
“17. The law consistently laid down by this Court can be summarized as under:
(i) It is the duty of the Trial Court to put each material circumstance appearing in the evidence against the accused specifically, distinctively and separately. The material circumstance means the circumstance or the material on the basis of which the prosecution is seeking his conviction;
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 345Ashok v. State of Uttar Pradesh
(ii) The object of examination of the accused under Section 313 is to enable the accused to explain any circumstance appearing against him in the evidence;
(iii) The Court must ordinarily eschew material circumstances not put to the accused from consideration while dealing with the case of the particular accused;
(iv) The failure to put material circumstances to the accused amounts to a serious irregularity. It will vitiate the trial if it is shown to have prejudiced the accused;
(v) If any irregularity in putting the material circumstance to the accused does not result in failure of justice, it becomes a curable defect.
However, while deciding whether the defect can be cured, one of the considerations will be the passage of time from the date of the incident;
(vi) In case such irregularity is curable, even the appellate court can question the accused on the material circumstance which is not put to him; and
(vii) In a given case, the case can be remanded to the Trial Court from the stage of recording the supplementary statement of the concerned accused under Section 313 of CrPC.
(viii) While deciding the question whether prejudice has been caused to the accused because of the omission, the delay in raising the contention is only one of the several factors to be considered.”
This Court based its decision on several decisions, including the decision in the case of Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v. State of Maharashtra.2 This Court relied upon what was held in paragraph 16 of the said case. Paragraph 16 of the said case reads thus: 2 [1974] 1 SCR 489 : (1973) 2 SCC 793 346 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports “16. ……………. It is trite law, nevertheless fundamental, that the prisoner’s attention should be drawn to every inculpatory material so as to enable him to explain it. This is the basic fairness of a criminal trial and failures in this area may gravely imperil the validity of the trial itself, if consequential miscarriage of justice has flowed. However, where such an omission has occurred it does not ipso facto vitiate the proceedings and prejudice occasioned by such defect must be established by the accused. In the event of evidentiary material not being put to the accused, the court must ordinarily eschew such material from consideration.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.